To the Bone but the original plays on the left while the remastered is played on the right

I actually examined both audio files and there are actually changes to the instrument timings and more effects on the vocals
*is that another sans next to me?
*heh, this is a weird timeline
original:
• Sans and Papyrus Song ...
remastered:
• Sans and Papyrus Song ...

[@T_Dude]

I genuinely cannot tell why I prefer the old animations. The new ones are objectively better, and the new version is even funnier. Nostalgia, maybe?

[@weirdguy8058]

i prefer the old one since they got papyrus' arm, spine and leg bones the correct color

[@Maniac-oj6wn]

new neck for papyrus is as floppy as a spaghetti noodle maybe? i dunno

[@yourehallucination4366]

​@@weirdguy8058nope new one got it correct

[@moonlight._.69]

​@@weirdguy8058old one is wrong actually, papyrus has black sleeves

[@Suzukari]

​@@weirdguy8058no they got it wrong

[@t-mag3004]

When I watched the remastered animation, it made me realise how underrated empty-eyed Sans is among the fandom, he's waaay scarier/intimidating with empty eyes than with the blue left eye which isn't that special anymore since it's way overused in all fan works, not to mention the AU characters that always has that eye 'active' so to speak. So yeah, I'd like more empty-eyed Sans in my suggested Undertale artwork thanks.

[@jaxsterminator8634]

THANK YOU! Besides, he only ever uses his left eye for attacks, he never uses it when talking anyway.

[@randomlyannoying]

@@jaxsterminator8634 Pretty sure he never even uses it for attacks. Doesn't he only use it at the end to teleport you back to the centre of the square?

[@jaxsterminator8634]

@@randomlyannoying Yeah, you’re right. He also uses his blue and yellow eye to throw you around before his special attack.

[@ELGIEstickanimation]

I draw empty eye sockets sans' cuz its way more easier

[@Tobiazinth]

His yellow/blue eye is only used while sans uses magic attacks (gaster blasters and telekinesis) , and besides the empty eyes are intimidating as *FUCK* ingame

[@tartarusempress1583]

The new one just captures the essence of undertale so much better to me, plus the mixed media with the sprites adds alot

[@just_an_internet_explorer8038]

Ikr? Especially this bit 3:59 to 4:12

[@albireothestarthebacklight2990]

Though I prefer old’s proportions for Pap for some reason.

[@tartarusempress1583]

@@albireothestarthebacklight2990 it might be that were more used to paps being like 5x sans' height??? I wanna add to my original comment too that old feels like its trying to be hyperrealistic which just isnt undertale

[@PhantomOfficial07]

@@albireothestarthebacklight2990 thats fair. The old papyrus model had charm imo. the new one is silly and more accurate tho so i like it more

[@Palest_being]

I like the new animation more overall but I prefer the older human design

[@Gunanter]

I like how scarcely the new one used sans' bad time eye, because it's only really seen once in game, and every other time that people would normally use the bad time eye, they used the often underutilized empty eyed look of sans, and, honestly the new animation makes it seem to fit more with undertale as a game, compared to the often darker fandom that portrays it

[@azubuikeware241]

Also in the original the bad time eye just looked like a slightly blue unnaturally big eye

[@StupidYTDude]

everything looks spot on to the game sprites except frisk's head size

[@MarthaVsHumanity]

I totally agree with this. Sans’ glowing eye is only seen three times on the Genocide run (during his opening attack, his final attack, and if you try pushing the box before he falls asleep), whereas his eyeless sprite is used way more (including twice on the Pacifist route, during the MTT Resort conversation and before the Asriel sprite), so this just makes sense.

[@DankFirewolf]

@@MarthaVsHumanity holy sh you're so right literally just replayed the sans fight to confirm this and it is true

[@Rike680]

“Bad time eye”..

[@Shy_Man111]

A mix of both would be really good. There's some parts like the undyne cameo and the first part where first walks through all the locations in the old version would be better then the updated alternatives

[@point0947]

Really wish Undyne was in the new version tbh

[@co10urs_72]

Fr

[@skratte]

Fr

[@secretman796]

Exactly what I wanted.

[@Aurorakitzune]

As much as I love the original, I like the remastered version better, the part where Papyrus's head becomes an actual human skull made me laugh so hard

[@alexakluttz8768]

IKR

[@ririlub]

3:51

[@roscannon]

the red in the remaster is good

[@Officially_Unofficial-1]

Bro said 💀 literally

[@jadengriffith6831]

Sans is ugly in new version

[@Couchiestpotato]

I just kinda wish that the new version muffled the drums when sans said, “You’re only still alive because i made a promise” like they did in the old version but its fine, both are good in their own ways, personally i like the new version better

[@Orio435]

oh, THAT’S why it didn’t hit the same now i want someone to upload the new version with the og audio

[@nathanpierce7681]

ehhh, i think the fact that the new one only slightly muffles the instrumentals fits better, especially with the animation. in the old one, it's a full stop, literally giving us flashes of sans in the judgement hall. in the new one, it's just us looking up from the call with papyrus to sans who is sitting right beside us, so that wouldn't warrant a sudden change in the instrumental also i like that the new one doesn't give much attention to it in the music. it's just a blink and you'll miss it moment, which would fit since a lot of people would probably breeze through the line without paying much attention and since sans is always in the background. fitting that even his threat doesn't get much focus until the end of the song, where he makes good on it and dunks frisk during the genocide route.

[@wittyshenanigans1302]

Literally had to edit it where I only kept that part of the og and meshed it with the remastered

[@em-diamond9769]

gonna be honest left papyrus looks better but right sans looks better. the amount right paps moves his neck is unsettling

[@yourfathersinferioritycomplex]

I think so too, the new animation is insanely good but too energetic and bouncy, even for someone like paps

[@TheOffspringy]

well right shows more of his personality and gives him more character and quality so i think right is better.

[@pixlv6384]

The way left papyrus moves his jaw is weird looking. In the game it basically just goes up and down

[@TheXMASMouse]

In my opinion, both look good to me.

[@ARandomEliatrope]

@@pixlv6384 Thats mostly a problem with the rig though, they couldn't exactly change it because it was a pre-made model.

[@chickengaming4344]

I think the remastered has the better animation objectively, but the characters feels off. I think it's the facial expressions, Frisk just always having a blank stare just added to the og music video.

[@TheOffspringy]

yeah but would be odd if frisk just didnt react at ALL like it looks off in the og too i like that they added more character to frisk in the new one instead of just a still face. just shows more effort

[@checkerhat327]

@@TheOffspringy I think part of the charm in Undertale *was* the constant monotone face of Frisk when surrounded by the utter chaos that is the monsters, but that's just me honestly.

[@mauro27279]

​@@checkerhat327same

[@shadowstar8619]

I noticed that Frisk and Sans have some pretty strange leg movements in the walking parts, too, with the way their legs/feet sweep or curl upward after each step.

[@stitchthelilo]

@@checkerhat327 nope, not just you at all, frisks poker face is one of the many reasons why i love undertale so much

[@Galagas1011]

I can't tell which one I like better. I'd probably have to say the new one, because the animation is so clean and smooth. However the older one is a classic, so you can't really dislike it.

[@alexanderthegreat-mx5zu]

The old one has also smooth animation and better/fitting models for the vibe it's trying to give.

[@wynseas]

@@alexanderthegreat-mx5zu I think I have to respectfully disagree! the way papyrus' mouth moves in the old one feels.. unnerving, to me. I totally get what you're saying, and I understand your opinion, but to me the newer one is leagues above! Not trying to diss on the original, but I think the overall vibe, animation, and style for the newer one works better :] Again though I definitely get why people would think otherwise, especially with nostalgia

[@BedrRedstone]

​@@alexanderthegreat-mx5zuBetter fitting models??? Bro the sans model doesn't even look correct

[@alexanderthegreat-mx5zu]

@@wynseas you have to also take into account the fact that the original is ten years old and despite that, it holds really well.

[@alexanderthegreat-mx5zu]

@@BedrRedstone I swear to fcking god,if you are gonna complain about the slippers being white just because they were pink in the concept art.

[@opera_ghost8504]

I really like the new version's animation actually! some people have said they like the old papyrus model better, but I actually like how cartoony and bouncy the new one is, at least compared to how stiff the old one was. and of course, we finally have the optimal sans model, that's him right there. sans.

[@wynseas]

i feel the same about it! i dont really understand how people like the old papyrus model better. personally, i think the old papyrus model looked a bit strange while he was talking, and i love the cartoony vibe overall with the new one

[@PakistaniGoatMilker94]

@@wynseasI like the new papyrus but I do kinda miss the old one in how much bigger and more realistic he was One of the things I wished carried over the most was the scene at the beginning when papyrus is just dragging frisk welcoming them to the underground

[@wynseas]

@@PakistaniGoatMilker94 i get that! it was a fun scene i agree

[@CapitanJorge24]

​@@PakistaniGoatMilker94yea thats one of the few things i prefer over the original the new one's intro scene felt like we were playing an undertale VR game or smth the old one was funnier in that regard too

[@seabeebug]

Straight up yeah that's sans. That's him right there

[@chiifgui3413]

i dont know what the others are saying but the new one is honestly much better, way more creative and expressive, a quarter of the old video was just undertale gameplay with the song over it, i think people are saying the old one is better due to nostalgia.

[@Creeper_Duck]

I agree, but something about the new Papyrus model looks off.

[@michaelfranklin6340]

@@Creeper_Ducki think it’s the neck

[@Creeper_Duck]

​​@@michaelfranklin6340hmm maybe. But it might also be the lack of lines on his teeth. Edit: nvm he does have lines, but you cant see them very well. I think that might be the problem but I'm still not sure.

[@ARandomEliatrope]

@@Creeper_Duck I think it's just the fact his head is absolutely huge in comparison to the rest of his body.

[@Creeper_Duck]

@@ARandomEliatrope maybe, but isn't that just how papyrus looks in-game? Maybe I'm too use to seeing Papyrus less cartoony.

[@BansheeBooVT]

For me, I really like the new one better. The old one captures more of the entire Undertale cast like a Neutral route, while the new one shows the closeness to Sans and Papyrus, but also tells the story of the Genocide Route. Plus giving Papyrus the eyeballs like he has in his icons fits super well and is very comical, but also making Sans' empty eyes really makes him more terrifying than the one yellow eye.

[@masontheyt0126]

4:02 The remastered part really had me 😂

[@nathanpierce7681]

new one has a better instrumental ngl, the old one just seems to loop a lot while the new one tries to vary throughout the song for different lyrics same goes for five long nights

[@CharaTR]

Nah, the feeling and rhythm and everything else is better than before. in animation. It reflects UT's canon and originality very well, but the new one is just too.. animatik.

[@Tello-Vision]

Wait the lyrics are the exactly the same tho

[@nathanpierce7681]

@@Tello-Vision i didnt say the lyrics were changed, i said the instrumental tries to change for every verse that needs it

[@AsterWi]

Wait the music actually changed??

[@nathanpierce7681]

@@AsterWi yeah? you didnt notice? it's most prominent during the "you're only still alive because i made a promise" part, because instead of the music being completely muffled and being dramatic, it just quiets down a little it's also noticeable in the part leading up to "hey, papyrus mind your manners!" verse, because in the old one the instrumental is a simple loop while in the new one it actually changes a bit after sans talks to paps

[@Harrison0728]

I'm really glad they got Coda to make this for them! It looks so good!!!

[@Leaked_Footage_79]

3:59 - 4:11 the remake made this funny af

[@EsmeraldaTGG]

It's the goofy-ass expression Sans pulls when he says "but ain't two skulls better than one?" that just _does me in_

[@ARandomEliatrope]

@@EsmeraldaTGG It's the realistic-ass skull on Papyrus for me lmao

[@fransiscayulianita68]

​@@ARandomEliatrope 💀

[@Leaked_Footage_79]

@@ARandomEliatrope its the "LEAVE ME ALONE" face Papyrus makes for me

[@ZOMBiFOX13]

​@@ARandomEliatropesame , for me it's also the fact that papyrus moves like a store brought skeleton prop too lol

[@yggdrasilsaltar]

i personally think the vocals match the newer models more? especially papyrus’s bouncer movement expresses his goofyness alot better, sans’s is also really good too. especially since his eyes emote for him and the mouth gets bigger and smaller and he isnt just making the same single expression the entire time

[@uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhidk]

yea, the one on the right looks like the original and the one on the left looks like an amateur animator reanimated it to practice

[@Miszuq]

i love how at 4:08 papyrus's head is turned into a realistic skull

[@KSAM428]

Yeah!

[@cute_protogen]

Because he was so mad

[@hyper_blade1477]

Combining both versions of the song actually sounds hella good.

[@heckinconcernedkitten61]

3:14 this is probably my favorite part

[@johna6169]

I noticed this cool detail. The left side consists of the pacifist route, and a little genocide route appears whenever sans solo sings. While the right side only has genocide and neutral route vibes, genocide appearing without sans going solo, the end shows that paps died and sans fights you, meaning that yes, it is the genocide route that frisk(player) choose. Edit: 7 months later and i will ad some details I found on both left and right. I will say it in the replies.

[@isaacskinner5565]

I saw the remastered version as going through 3 separate timelines; pacifist, neutral, genocide, in that order.

[@johna6169]

⁠@@isaacskinner5565nah, the asgore 1:18 part of the remaster is the neutral asgore fight OR the beginning of the asreil fight(pacifist), sans’s date 2:44 in pacifist, and sans fight 4:28 in genocide respectively. Meaning that it’s mixed up, not in a proper order

[@johna6169]

@@isaacskinner5565 if fact, the sans date and asgore is the only part that is pacifist, the rest like ”Trough all you travels your sins will follow 1:24 ” is genocide/neutral themed

[@johna6169]

@@isaacskinner5565it just keeps on switching from neutral to genocide until the end, where genocide seems to be the route that the PLAYER chose

[@isaacskinner5565]

wow, you really paid a lot more attention to everything than i did. Ye i think you're right.

[@pinkius]

New one is just much better. Everything is just way more skillful compared to old one. A lot of creative ideas, a lot of camera work and amazing effects, especially the derpy Paps and Sans faces, they're just peices of art on their own. Also NO undertale gameplay which means that everything was animated. It's just that much better.

[@BananaMan-wc8ru]

I perfer the undertale gameplay compared to those goofy-ass walking animations 💀

[@PakistaniGoatMilker94]

Theirs more to it than just looking good the old one had many iconic moments like papyrus dragging frisk and papyrus just generally being way bigger than everybody and the “your only still alive” line hits way harder in the old one Although I thought the new one had some cool moments as well like when papyrus gets mad at the creepy pasta joke visual gag and the end of the new one with the sans fight was also cool I don’t think one is better than the other they both have their strengths

[@yggdrasilsaltar]

@@BananaMan-wc8ruthats just the way the characters walk lmao

[@BananaMan-wc8ru]

@@yggdrasilsaltar they could've been a little less goofy though lmao

[@Aigle662frileux]

@@BananaMan-wc8ru I love the gofiness in this its better than edgy trash fanon versions of the character

[@PossumsAreNice]

I like the remake’s animation more, but I like the original version of the song more. I think it’s because the OG has a sort of “edge” in the music and vocals that fits the vibe, which remake doesn’t have

[@TheIT221]

I think the couple of extra instruments, like in the Toriel scene, or the first sans/papyrus snow interaction sounds better, but the left side would otherwise remain my undisputed favorite If only someone could add those instruments into a copy of the old video lol

[@azubuikeware241]

Until the parts after frisk kills papyrus

[@MrEggBoi]

I love the few references to the older animation, like 3:33

[@IrisThatOneGothMf]

i overall prefer the original animation, it may not be as polished as the new one, but i think it was perfect as it is other than that in my honest opinion, has nothing to do with my nostalgia for it. i preferred the original art style and how each scene played out in the original, but it doesn't hurt to make remakes of animations and songs, the new one is great too.

[@_Flame9029]

Exactly my opinion. No nostalgia bias or anything, straight up the animations and models fit better with the song.

[@user-rm3wj3cy5m]

I really like the remaster, it has so many interesting angles and movements. Despite the fact that Sans smiles all the time in this remake, his facial expressions are more expressive than in the old video.

[@MrFell.]

Sans physically never changes his mouth expression-

[@pacifistichuman82649]

sans didn't even move his mouth a pixel in the original

[@ahmed4363]

he also only uses his blue/yellow eye just 1 time in the animation and mostly uses his empty eyes. In the game the blue eye appears like 3 times in the genocide route only

[@adsonmachado5805]

"Excuse me balls" Sans - 2024

[@zapadap1328]

The new models really make you realize how unsettling and uncanny the old ones were

[@teamok1025]

The new one is more expressive and more smoother than the old one. The old one have a old charm and an nostalgia and an archive of the community back then.

[@shceinor]

i love the soup store comic reference in the new one

[@Chaotic_Overlord]

Same, even if it's kinda random.

[@KaburKab]

I learned two things from this video. 1. Nostalgia catches up to you fast. 2. Animation has came a very long way.

[@ARandomEliatrope]

I really like how the left one ends more than the right one, the stab on the two *BLUE* bones looks really awkward and Sans' smile just looks super off.

[@almas4663]

Considering Frisk is falling during that scene, aka - Is in a state of motion, it makes sense why blue bones affect them

[@ARandomEliatrope]

@@almas4663 Sans is using his telekinesis, the "Moving" part only effects you if its YOU moving yourself, not outside forces moving you.

[@sansgaster5284]

@@ARandomEliatrope if i remember right if you jumped and let go of the keys in undertale when coming across a blue bone, you'd still get nicked damage

[@moon4236]

Tbh I don't think the ending with the sans fight fits at all, it doesn't really go with the lyrics like sans is just warning you while also making puns in the song meanwhile him and Frisk are fighting to the death lmao.

[@almas4663]

@@moon4236 I think it firs perfectly - He fights you while also reflecting on the times he was just goofing around with his bro

[@Nightcaat]

The new one is simply better for the most part. I never liked how the OG uses in-game footage in several places; it felt like they gave up on animating the whole thing (which I fully understand but it was still worse off for it). It’s cool that they remastered it when it could’ve been left alone just fine

[@wandering_nobody]

Listening to these side-by-side confirms to me that they only remastered the instrumental and SFX. Which means they couldn't improve upon the perfection that is the original vocals.

[@lerdeldrinboiYT]

Honestly, I kinda prefer the original. Don't get me wrong, the remaster is also really good. Like, the animation is really smooth and objectively better than the old one's and also has better visual comedy. And the music of the new one definitely adds a small bit more. Though there are some gripes I have with the remaster. For example, the animation can get a bit too floaty and bouncy for it's own good at times. While the old animation was stiff and dated, it definitely fit with the music and it's movement limits actually helped a bit. I also think the old music is better despite what the new ones add. The best example is two of Sans's solo parts. The "You're only still alive because I made a promise" and his solo part in the final chorus part actuall got quite downgraded in the remaster. San's solos got a new demonic ish voice and sound less menacing as a result. While the original had his voice stay the same but sound more serious than usual, while also muffling the instruments to add to the ominous effect. No hate to the remaster. Coda did an amazing job in animating and has talent, and I could see what JT was going for, but the overall product unfortunately ended up a tad bit weaker than the original. Still like it a ton though.

[@flamenarezki]

4:37 new mega cool

[@JackSmith-yj4sz]

I love the old animation, but I feel like the new one just has so much more personality. Also I like the scarce use of sans' blue eye, it's so overused an I think the no pupils fave is scarier anyway.

[@Overwatch2010]

0:21 In the old one papyrus is dragging Frisk but in the new one he’s talking to them instead

[@flyingfirebear7270]

4:07 I don’t know if the one on the right was supposed to be a reference to that one comic where he gets the realistic skull for the last frame but either way it’s funny

[@rachelisverycoo]

3:14 THE NEW ONE DOES SANS SO WELL WTF

[@retrowave69]

personally enjoy the older animation better, it directs the camera to focus on the one actually singing more than the new one, and since Sans never actually moves his lips, it helps.

[@leglessdumbass]

what lips

[@Mr_questionman]

​@@leglessdumbass exactly what lips

[@-Monkii]

I personally love how animated the right one is

[@Whitty1218]

3:04 bro the birch Wood lol

[@IronicR]

Lol didn’t even see that at first

[@FunzeeTime]

i love the remastered one, it adds so much more life to it.

[@ZKDiamondS]

2:23 Bro the way Sans looks in the newer one is priceless

[@DingoDongo09]

I love the comparison cuz it makes me realize that both are good but some parts could be swapped out to be better

[@azubuikeware241]

4:30 this part and the rest of the song were peak but for the part where Frisk attacks Sans I would’ve liked gaster blasters because of the way the bass feels

[@ARCtrooper65]

The old SFM one will always have a place in my heart, but the new one is objectively better

[@pearl830]

sans and frisk looked so weird back then im glad they made a remastered one its SO MUCH better.

[@CartoonyDoesVids]

Old version: a bit funny and kinda realistic New version: funny and fancy

[@ivanlol7153]

Idk which one I prefer tbh, both have stuff they do better than the other. Like the new one has much better models and animation(like what the hell was old Toriel 1:58). But I also like some of the old visuals like showing several bosses. Also don’t really like how the new one is genocide. I like how with the exception of seeing Asgore with the souls it was kinda left ambiguous if it was genocide or neutral. Also papyrus’ neck in the new one is weird

[@pipootkelter3289]

Toriel must have mixed up the butterscotch and buttercups

[@davidbingham7616]

I legitimately expexted sans to say "GIVE US YOUR BALLS"

[@newbite6394]

this is actually fire when you have both playing at the same time

[@waffler-yz3gw]

im in the (surprisingly small) crowd of people that prefers the remastered one. dont get me wrong, the original has some parts that are better, but the animation in the remastered is really nice and the artstyle fits the song better

[@wynseas]

same here! im honestly really shocked about how many more people prefer the old one, but thats not to say they shouldnt! dont mean to be disrespectful to anyone. just surprising to me

[@Influence417]

@@wynseas "Nostalgia Bias" is how I would diagnose them with.

[@FlaringStardust]

​@@Influence417 yeah, not to say that preferring the old one immediately means nostalgia, but so much of the old one is just gameplay footage or the models barely moving. which makes sense given that it's 2015 sfm, but still. the sheer number of people voting for the old one definitely makes it look like nostalgia's a factor.

[@wynseas]

@@Influence417 yeah, that'd definitely make the most sense

[@woahy1]

finally people i agree with

[@lucaspryde6976]

There is more unsettling detains, like how sans focuses on the viewer in the new, rather than the character. There are unique visual references in each.

[@gravityfallsfan63]

The original gives a little bit of nostalgia so you cant replace

[@This-is-a-commentt]

Og has it’s charm but I think the new one is the one I like better, I’ve been a fan of the animator of the remasters work for a long while so seeing him animate a full song is something I’ve never knew I wanted

[@claudefrolltomstein8935]

SANS' WALK WITH HIS LITTLE SLIPPER FLIPPING LIKE FLIPPERS I CAN'T 😂😂😂

[@rachelisverycoo]

0:34 The og is so iconic but the new one is scary ngl

[@popinthetoast]

i love the sans in the new animation, it captivates me far better, the graphics are top tier, both are great, and speak to my inner child

[@ogom-io3rb]

If I’m ignoring nostalgia they both have flaws and both have strengths there both good in there own way. Really hope someone does a fusion of both animations good parts while leaving behind the flaws of both. But until then the old ones more enjoyable for me cause nostalgia.

[@Sean-qg3gg]

Sans’s new model is definitely loads better. While the texture and animations are better with Papyrus’s new model, I like the old model more. It is taller, and still quite accurate to Papyrus. Just slap a cartoon filter and fix the inaccuracies in color, then I think it fits great, just like the great Papyrus.

[@jazzman3196]

I think the reason why he isn’t as tall is because it’s more accurate to the canon. Cause if you play attention, papyrus isn’t THAT tall. Heck Undyne is taller than him in game. I still prefer him to be taller in the older one but man he feels so short canonically

[@rigboy1234]

Well, Papyrus has a pretty standard size on-game, he just feels gigantic because both Frisk and Sans are short

[@aigeneratedwauigi2696]

Papyrus is probably like 5’2

[@ahmed4363]

Papyrus is actually short, its just when you compare him to sans and Frisk (a literal child) then of course he appears tall

[@SpeedyTheHedgehog1Official]

Sans: 🎺 🎺 🎺 P: LEAVE ME ALONE! Sans: you know i got an act for the trumbone P: 1 more pun And ill be done! Sans: But aint 2 skulls better then one?

[@Vector-jm1qk]

Thanks so much for this!!! Was looking for a video like this and had no luck, till rn!

[@ActualGooberreal]

I just now noticed that papyrus in the new one at 4:08 is a pisshitters reference

[@notazombie...notatall8577]

I don’t understand why people are hating on the remake, it legit looks amazing. Papyrus faces are the best

[@knotcory8]

"how are your balls" -Sand 201X

[@rachelisverycoo]

2:41 the new one gen gave me chills

[@cybertronicgamer9589]

I know right. Sans looked so creepy with that smile and the gaping eye sockets while sitting at that tablele

[@pacifistichuman82649]

Empty-Eyed > Bad Time

[@despacitospider9682]

Both are amazing, but I wished that more elements of the OG were carried on to the new version. I feel like there were many missed opportunities.

[@dinosalud4735]

seeing this video, i remember... *H O W A R E Y O U R B A L L S*

[@Unknown-zw5dx]

The new version makes sans really menacing ngl, and papyrus looks soo innocent in the remastered, I like both but overall, I can’t choose.

[@TheForgottenDetermined]

2:36 Still the best part to me, honestly.

[@pacifistichuman82649]

_youre only still alive because i made a promise_

[@anabanana77]

BOTH OF THEM ARE AMAZING!!!!

[@V0X_TVd3m0n]

I love the new but I like that parts in the old kne where sans is "serious" and flowey's old face

[@ELPRO-uz1qw]

Bro Pyparus hand isn’t holding,he’s just floating

[@2SidedDragon]

0:34 THEY INCLUDED THE SOUP MEME

[@AIGOC]

Both are too good, left is just a legend, right is a quality masterpiece.

[@themonotone7971]

The title to this video is very exact.

[@AURORAREVEALNOW]

The whole reason they remastered it was Sans being Sans.

[@animationsz9055]

The first animation had more movement for the characters, dynamic poses and actions that fit them perfectly. Especially for them expression their emotions while still sticking to character.

[@JackSmith-yj4sz]

Do you mean the remastered animation. The old animation was pretty robotic in movement

[@animationsz9055]

That’s the besssssttt part :D@@JackSmith-yj4sz

[@aigeneratedwauigi2696]

You mean the remastered animation right?

[@animationsz9055]

THE ORIGINAL

[@azuredem]

I liked the proportions of the characters in the first one compared to the remastered because Sans' head is SO big compared to Papyrus. Also, Papyrus' movement is a bit unnerving as well as all of their walk cycles being a bit too over exaggerated, they all flip their feet like they're trying to kick snow. They did however make Sans and Papyrus feel more in character, with Papyrus seeming less menacing/angry and with Sans being more true to cannon rather than just heavily leaning on his "ooo scary blue eye i know what you did" trope. The ambience, storytelling, transitions, lighting, and humor are obviously MUCH better compared to the old one. I think if they tweaked some of the models and messed with some of the animation so it wouldn't feel so off, this would be perfect.

[@fr3dm3rc0ry4]

the new models are more accurate to the in-game sprites

[@azuredem]

@@fr3dm3rc0ry4 yeah but it just feels a bit wrong dont you think? it's already stylized a tone, why not fix it?

[@fr3dm3rc0ry4]

@@azuredem no

[@wendigoswithhats8593]

The damn dragging in the og is so funny

[@mrman55555]

the deeper you go the messier it gets is actually more creepy than the deeper you fall the messier you fall.

[@isolated_illustrations]

Kinda sucks that everyone thinks the new one isn't that great, Coda is a really good animator, abd to spend time working on something like this only for the response to be basically just "it's alright I guess" kinda is a bit saddening...

[@Influence417]

"Nostalgia Bias" It's a trope fans have when it comes to remasters of songs or anything in general.

[@glitchispider8201]

​@@Influence417can you blame them tho?

[@aigeneratedwauigi2696]

@@glitchispider8201yes

[@krysias.7063]

Both versions are beautiful

[@sadtrash8009]

I love the new one but Sans and Frisk’s walks are so funny

[@vsptylore3639]

I like how Papyrus kept the shutter shades

[@Marulauriu710]

The song itself: I prefer the original voice mixing and as for the instrumental track, it's on par with the 2016 version. Animation: I feel like characters are a little too noddle-like and sans' cheeks are a little bit too big BUT DAMNNNNNNNNN THE SHADING IS AWESOME. Overall I like it, they did an amazing job, very solid remaster, 10/10!

[@pacifistichuman82649]

what "cheeks"

[@rigboy1234]

@@pacifistichuman82649💀

[@pacifistichuman82649]

@@rigboy1234 I was joking about him being a skeleton. Are you seriously thinking about *THOSE* ones?

[@Ridlay_]

The new one looks great. But hey, I'll always appreciate the old charm of the original.

[@a_capybara_warrior2056]

I love the new one but the left sometimes shows more personality between Sans and Papyrus but if i had to choose right is better.

[@crazystateofmind4832]

the old one has much more personality like the way pap moves his head at 1:51. sometimes the minimal movement adds a lot more than more movement

[@theultimateswagon]

Man the improvement in quality is so massive. Besides some classic shots, it's like a direct upgrade

[@KaijuRhino]

the new version is like objectively better when it comes to every animation principle im surprised this is as divisive as it is

[@Influence417]

Maybe why I don't watch comparison videos often. Reminds me of divisiveness in communities.

[@CasenOMG3Returned]

I like the old version because of how it has the gameplay from Undertale as well as it just being nostalgic. I like the new one because the animation is extremely good and the character models look amazing. All in all, both great music videos!

[@BigheadYT]

almost everyone uses the same 3d undertale sprites but then the sans sprites are like always different

[@commonlegend44]

1:18 goes so hard! The lyrics sound like something out of shin godzilla

[@thatchillasian8924]

I don’t know how to put into words why I prefer the old version. The best I can describe it is that the newer version seems too in-your-face for my liking, it seems like it’s trying to flex its more complex animation too much. The older one seems more modest in a way.

[@SkyPearlzG]

Yeah that explains exactly what I was thinking too😭

[@5Chr5ome5]

its literally just fluidity 💀

[@rigboy1234]

It’s like that to fit the vibe of the song and the personality of the characters, It fits pretty much

[@Dragonceratops]

so coda using the tools at his disposal is "flexing its more complex animation?"

[@New-Rhino]

I just love how in old version papyrus has correctly made skull and it looks like he's always smiling 😁

[@TheFourAmigos47]

the new one made sans so much more intimidating than the original