Review of Dewalt Cordless Orbital and Sheet Sander

[@Airplane10]

I bought the DCW200B. I was skeptical but was trying to spare my wife the task of pointing my shop vac at every drywall patch. I was STUNNED at how well it worked as I did the first half-dozen nail holes I’d sanded. There was NO drywall dust in the room, on the floor and even the tool wasn’t dusty. I was a fan. Then things somehow went bad. It stopped collecting drywall dust. It wasn’t blocked (and yes, I’d emptied the bag) but what started as fantastic dust collection was now almost nothing. To add to the fun, the dust escaping the pad was thrown everywhere by the air coming off of the motor/fan. I even tried hooking my shop vac to the sander’s dust collection port. That didn’t help. I’m done with my project now having used the sander with my wife holding the shop vac. I planned to recommend this tool to everyone but as a sander/vacuum - it’s a good sander doing only half of what I’d hoped for. Love DeWalt tools and I own several but this one came up short for me. Please do a couple of rooms sanding spackle and prove me wrong. I’d be delighted to see that.

[@adorkable81]

For the sheet sander, Just turn the dust connector upside down and reattach the dust collector. You will be able to fit FlexVolt battery in

[@ToolsThatBuild]

You could you could also remove it altogether I suppose. I wouldn’t use above a 5ah on it anyway it wouldn’t balance nearly as well and I’d rather just change the smaller battery than add all the unbalanced weight for little runtime gain

[@elifire4147]

And for the love of GOD put a shop vac on the dust collector port.

[@elifire4147]

@@ToolsThatBuild Volumes too low.

[@jerryoliver5591]

I purchased a used one as the piece is a bit pricey, but the machine kzbin.infoUgkxG6fbm3cHBd7CNTjk5D-dwYe9c9tCB9ZN has surpassed my expectations. We sand small parts by hand often, sized around 1"x1/2," and specifically look for a piece that's designed to be vertical. The motor has plenty of torque and great speed settings. The only inconvenience I had is that the disk measures 5" where we trim 6" stick-and-sand disks down easily by mounting it then cutting with a box cutter.

[@rosaholland995]

How do u keep the pads on the orbital sander when I turn it on the sanding pads fly off is there a trick to keeping them on .

[@ToolsThatBuild]

No trick, you need to use hook and loop sand paper. It Velcro’s the paper to the sander. (Make sure it’s 5 hole so the dust holes can line up)

[@newagemuscle2010ss]

I just purchased both of these today because I am going to be taking on the task of painting my kitchen cabinets. I figured they would be great for surface prep. I bought both of them because I assumed I would need both for the job. Do you think it's necessary to have both or is the orbital just enough? What is the advantage of one over the other? I have never used either of these before or anything like them. Thanks

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Hey I actually did my cabinets not to long ago. For stripping the orbital is what you need. The sheet sander is more for finishing. If your re staining you’d want both but if your painting the cabinets all you need is the orbital. Strip, prime and paint. Buy lots of sand paper removing the poly as well as the grease etc. will clog the paper quickly.

[@newagemuscle2010ss]

@@ToolsThatBuild Awesome thanks. It was either do it myself or I had a company that was going to do it for $4,900. I almost pulled the trigger last October but got covid right before they were going to start, so that delayed things from ever happening. I'm kind of glad it worked out that way now because I think it would have made me sick to pay someone that much money for something I could have done myself.

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@newagemuscle2010ss absolutely it’s not a hard job just takes a long time. Make sure you use the proper stain or paint and primer as well it will keep lasting a long time

[@joshusanders3127]

@@ToolsThatBuild orbial wont get into the corners i would of thought

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@joshusanders3127 either will the sheet sander unless it’s a 90degree corner. You can get a soft pad for the orbital that goes between the sander and paper to allow it to get into corners and detail. Beyond that tight corners have to be done by hand or a mouse sander is best for tight corners on cabinets and trim.

[@아둘람교회묵상채널]

Hi~ I have a question. Can I use the Powerstack 5ah with dustbags?

[@enhancehomeimprovementstoo1802]

Good information on these sanders. Which one works best?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Depends on the job your doing. Each sander is best at different tasks. The orbital is the go to for most jobs but it’s not for everything.

[@enhancehomeimprovementstoo1802]

@@ToolsThatBuild I plan on using it to sand down cabinet frames?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@enhancehomeimprovementstoo1802 you want the orbital then (DCW210B) it is a perfect solution for that. You don’t need the fine finish of the sheet sander.

[@2011FCBARCA]

@@ToolsThatBuild how about to sand a deck

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@2011FCBARCA hey it depends on the species of wood but usually I use a large orbital sander (the type meant to refinish hardwood usually just rented at a homedepot) and then a smaller orbital like the one in the video for the smaller spots. You could do the whole deck with the smaller orbital it will just take way longer. Of course make sure you work your way up through different grits for the smooth finish, use 80grit to strip and work up from there.

[@KJ_nyc]

The sandpaper clamping system on the Sheet Sander seems so arts-n-crafts class to me. Otherwise, the design of the tool appears modern and sophisticated. I'm concerned about the longevity and practicality of that clamping system. I hate my current Milwaukee sheet sander because the paper moves badly while sanding. How is the clamping system holding up for you?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Im assuming you mean the wire part. Most sheet sanders are the same. So far no issues with paper movement, it’s been a while and it all seems good. I mostly use mine for finishing after using the orbital for removal though so finer grits.

[@KJ_nyc]

@@ToolsThatBuild Thank you for the answer. Yes, I meant the wire doo-dads. One would think these designers could come up with something strong, streamlined and almost invisible. The paper clamping systems have changed in the last ten years. But I'm not sure they have improved. Guess I'll have to take a chance.

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@KJ_nyc agreed. Do come back and let us know if you find the yellow one an improvement I’m sure people will want to know.

[@ferndogg4427]

Which one be better to sand drywall?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Depends on what your doing, are you removing paper or paint? Or are you talking drywall mud? I usually hand sand my drywall but if you need to go powered the orbital would be the one.

[@bradleykornele]

Do you have link to 20V Sheet Sander Model DCW200B chute extension

[@Stavrossspand]

Can I ask a question? I am a beginner. Can I use it to scrap some paint of a concrete wall?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Stavros12 sspand12 hey you definitely could use it for that, make sure you use a solution first to make it faster. That being said it will work but there is better tools for removing paint from concrete depending on how much surface area and how thick the paint is.

[@Stavrossspand]

@@ToolsThatBuild Thank you very much.

[@davesmith7328]

I just bought the orbital sander. I can’t wait to use it in the morning. I maybe be buying the sheet sander as well. We will see!!

[@ToolsThatBuild]

I think you’ll like it. I’d love to hear your thoughts once you try it. If you like the orbital you will like the sheet sander as well for sure.

[@davesmith7328]

That sander is awesome it’s got a lot of power. Again I was just sanding down some Mudf that I primed but it made life a lot easier. My old sheet sander might be heading by by. When by the new cordless sheet sander.

[@Marcoosianism]

@@ToolsThatBuild Why would the sheet sander produce a finer finish over the hook and loop sander? Does it not depend solely on the sandpaper grit?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@Marcoosianism it does not, you will work through the grits to improve the finish however a orbital uses a rotating motion to sand (which is why on softer wood some people end up with swirls) and a sheet sander uses small vibrations which is a finer motion hence the finer finish.

[@rbergqvist85]

So if i want to sand things like my dinnertable to get rid of paint from children, and random things at home. Which one is ideal?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Realistically either would do the job but the orbital is ideal for stripping paint.

[@sconrady123]

I didn't know the plate was used to put holes in the sand paper

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Beats a screwdriver

[@williamcattr267]

Which one of these would be good for automotive body repair with sanding bondo or fiberglass?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Orbital sander but I would look into sanders meant specifically for automotive

[@georgebrill3072]

You could a little more volume on your audio. It was hard to hear you.

[@ToolsThatBuild]

George Brill second person to say that. I’ll adjust it for the next video thank you

[@sercancakr219]

I have 18V batteries, can I use them for a 20V MAX tool?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Unfortunately no

[@Bryson-510]

Instead of buying both, can I use a fine grit on the random orbital sander and get the same finish as the sheet sander?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

You won’t get the same finish but you can get pretty close. Most people only own a orbital sander and it suits them fine. Just remember to set your speed depending on the wood and not to much pressure or you will get swirls.

[@peteg9403]

I guess skills that matter above all to get a job well done

[@kahanakitty]

thank you sooo much! i was looking for this specific comparison, and you showed the essential functions. i will be getting both, especially after reading your reply about adding a soft pad for the orbital, although i guess the oscillating multitool could do corners.

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Hey glad it was helpful. The multi tool sanding attachment can also do corners yes but be careful especially on harder woods it’s a different vibration than a normal sander. Start at a higher grit than you would normally start with and don’t put pressure on the head as the multi tool is much more likely to scratch the wood than a sheet or orbital sander.

[@kahanakitty]

thank you for that advice! i didn’t even think of that!

[@treystewart544]

@@ToolsThatBuildthat thing sucks up pretty good and it sounds funny like a buzzing bee 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Delana4321]

I have limited funds. What are your recommendations for my first purchase, an orbital or a sheet sander?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Orbital

[@jackfryer3617]

I’ve got the dcs356 oscillation multi tool which I use as a sander. Would you say the orbital was similar? What would be best for say floorboards or sleepers etc

[@ToolsThatBuild]

The oscillating tool sanding attachment isn’t similar to the orbital at all. The attachment sands by making small vibrations which is basically the worst way to sand. The orbital makes tiny circles. The orbital will do a way better job in half the time not to mention it is a 5” pad so the surface area is much larger. For floorboards I would use an orbital sander and work through the different grits. You could always start with an orbital (I would use larger that a 5” for floors) and then finish with a sheet sander for a nicer finish but an oscillating tool sanding attachment is really just meant for tight spaces when you have no other option.

[@RaeWojo]

Great overview

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Thank you

[@it02s28]

Why would you use one over the other?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Orbital sander has more power and is fairly versatile suitable for majority of tasks. A sheet sander is better for finishing work like paint and stain prep and hard wood finishing. Basically any time you need really smooth clean finish.

[@itzNickyJayBeats]

How long does a battery last? 5 A.H. or different options if you know as well?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

I get an hour on high with constant use with a 5ah battery. I also wouldn’t go above 5ah on it just for balance and comfort reasons.

[@trevorhayes1079]

Can you buy pads to sand plaster

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Trevor Hayes yes same pads. Slower rpm on the sander since it’s a soft material. I would use net paper like abranet or similar.

[@sheridanstaley7378]

cool, i got the sheet sander for $60 online and the orbital for christmas🙌

[@ToolsThatBuild]

$60 is a great deal I think you’ll be really happy with both.

[@pama1]

Wtf it's 2yrs later and they sell these here in Europe for 170-200€

[@estZEN]

I have the orbital sander and I'm very happy and yesterday I bought the dcw200b and it creates too much dust compared with the dcw210b and the orbital sand much faster (I uses them as a painter not on wood but for spackle )

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Ya for your use the sheet sander isn’t ideal. Sheet sanders are more used for fine grit finishing work. The sander is meant to be moved slower which helps improve the dust extraction especially with a vacuum hooked up. For plaster removal I would never recommend a sheet sander of any sort.

[@promo130]

haha, they are not build for spackle, you have special sanders for spackle but they cost about 5 or 6 times as much then these dewalt sanders

[@treystewart544]

That dewalt sander sounds funny it’s sounds like a bee buzzing outside lol sounds funny 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@daveb2182]

Always look on the bright side of life

[@stephaniesolis9707]

I just want the battery off of the thing! I cannot get it off

[@stuntasylum]

If I'm using on brick walls filling holes ready for painting which one would you use ?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Orbital sander

[@stuntasylum]

@@ToolsThatBuild Thanks

[@NB-Philly]

Nice review, I came to find out what the purpose of each type is. If I only had to purchase one, which one would I get more benefits out of. Thanks!

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Thanks, general use and finishing is the difference in a nut shell. If you could only get one the orbital is the way to go. It will do majority of tasks.

[@NB-Philly]

Thank you so much! I’ll be picking one up then. Thanks!

[@dannymeil3294]

I finally got both of them I first got the orbital with a 5.0 battery for 99.00 but waited for a lifetime to get the finish sander for 109.00 no battery but I have many batteries now with other deals and two pack deals. Since I’m not in a rush I’m willing to wait for great deals.

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Absolutely getting them on sale makes them an even better buy.

[@samueljimenez1925]

Thanks for the vid. I’m thinking on buying the square 1. I’m removing the carpet in stairs.

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Hope you enjoyed it. The sheet sander is a great sander I think you’ll be happy with the purchase.

[@kevinstrickland1077]

Good video👍

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Thank you

[@promo130]

Eu version can use hook and loop sandpaper Way better

[@ToolsThatBuild]

The orbital sander uses hook and loop also in NA unless you mean the sheet sander?

[@promo130]

@@ToolsThatBuild but not the sheet sander, the eu version does

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@promo130 ah yes, we don’t have hook and loop sheet paper as readily available here so wouldn’t make much sense. Maybe one day

[@promo130]

oke, we have plenty in europe, and your from north america?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@promo130 yes

[@toomuchkidd]

Is this good for drywall

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Which sander are you asking about? What on the drywall are you sanding?

[@nathansheldonlance]

Thanks

[@kas8887]

Thanks for the video. Good man

[@ToolsThatBuild]

My pleasure, thank you for viewing it

[@flatlander523]

Would be nice if you would have told the difference between the orbital sander and the RANDOM orbital sander. And I agree on the volume. Good video otherwise.

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Hey thanks for the input, this video is not meant to educate on the different types of sanders out there just strictly look at these two and give my opinion on them. Audio was a mic issue corrected in my newer videos! Thanks for viewing it and the info

[@danielemansilla]

Then strictly a nonsense video

[@EricHarris-e9q]

Sipes Branch

[@keithlabbett4565]

Mine was terrible the battery quickly became lose making it garbage! Full charge and other Dewalt tools work well so it's not the battery!

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Sounds like a lemon is it under warranty?

[@BrillianceAutoSpa]

What's better?

[@ToolsThatBuild]

Depends on what your using it for. Orbital is a more all around sander and sheet sander is better for finish work. Sheet sanders are underrated but the orbital is kind of the one everyone should have.

[@BrillianceAutoSpa]

@@ToolsThatBuild thank you, Sir!

[@Mersault316]

@@ToolsThatBuild you said sheet sander is good for finish work. What do you mean by that ??

[@ToolsThatBuild]

@@Mersault316 I'm not sure how I could be more clear on it. The sheet sander will leave a cleaner final finish and it will do it faster than the orbital especially on softer woods.

[@Mersault316]

@@ToolsThatBuild so sheet sander is better when you're using higher grit paper.. Idk how dewalt came up with making another sander when theres already orbital ones are existed(which is good).

[@MarileeGardner-b7s]

Audrey Canyon