Top 10 Dark REAL Stories From People Who Survived The Titanic

[@Brawling_Style]

No one ever mentions the heroes who fed the boat coal and stayed in the bottom of that boat to keep those lights running for as long as possible.

[@KtEnns1]

My great great grandma had a ticket to sail on the Titanic. Fortunately, she became too sick with her pregnancy to board the ship and missed her voyage.

[@boojr0906]

Wow that’s pretty awesome considering if she had gotten on the ship there would be a very slim chance you’d be here. Amazing.

[@rajukaravadra8505]

I’m so happy that she didn’t go

[@itzayakaaa]

HOW LUCKY

[@sawyerthesoysauce2693]

Wow what coincidence you have to be extremely lucky for that to happen

[@robertmofford395]

Same for my great grandmother. She was 6 months pregnant with my grandmother, and her husband refused to let her sail in that condition. They saw the ship leave Southampton. He turned to her, and said "That ship will never see land again." How creepy is that?

[@allylabar21]

8:35 she also survived the sinking as a nurse and another sinking. I bet she was a pro by the 3rd. "You here, you there, hoist, fill'er up, pack em so they stay warmer and the other people can get on!" She called all the shots after the the third!

[@Saul_Alejandr00]

R.i.P. To the members of the band that stayed playing on the titanic and I hope that they're still playing together in heaven

[@sammylane21]

Who on here didn't cry when the group of musicians decided to play on?? I broke down when one said "It has been a privilege to play with you gentlemen" fully accepting his and their fate. You'd have to be a emotionally cold human to break down during that scene.

[@kevinbloom2265]

You'd have to be a(n) emotionally cold human (not) to break down during that scene.

[@Bread-_]

Yea its really sad ( I didnt cry tho-)

[@robinhello9116]

I surprisingly didn't cry but still thought it was pretty emotional.

[@Bread-_]

@@robinhello9116 Same

[@evelinasutliff6768]

Nope not a thing

[@hazelannhtd4lifer852]

I lost family members on the titanic on my mums side may all the souls that died on the titanic rest in peace gone but not forgotten

[@oliviapereira6622]

Cap

[@dede2476]

@@oliviapereira6622 oh shut up how you yk?

[@qu1nn720]

@@oliviapereira6622 wtf.

[@Epiclydumb]

@@oliviapereira6622 your dad is cap

[@naijahwhetstone8430]

You lost?

[@gigimarie3989]

The most heart breaking but also heart warming titanic story I have heard is about Anne Eliza Isham. She was a first class passenger but they wouldn't let her dog, a great dane, on board the lifeboat. So she stayed behind so poor doggo wouldn't die alone. 😥

[@dovetonsturdee7033]

According to the unsubstantiated legend, a woman was said to have been in a lifeboat ready to lower when she was told that she would be unable to bring her Great Dane on board with her. She chose to get out of the lifeboat. A few days later, a passenger on a passing ship reported seeing a woman's body floating in the ocean and holding on to the body of a large dog. It was only in later years that Miss Isham's name came to be associated with the story, as she was the only first class woman lost in the disaster whose whereabouts during the disaster were unknown. There is no actual evidence for this story, however, as Miss Isham did not even own a dog. She was one of four first class women who died in the disaster, and her body was never identified. A memorial to her was erected by her family in Vermont.

[@gigimarie3989]

yeah and?..that is the exact article I read on wikipedia. That is why I clearly put STORY.

[@happy.pets.happy.life.VTKBLNK.]

That is beautiful that dog had a good owner, I would fight the person that said no to let me go on or just sneak in

[@bbcatlover8003]

That’s heartbreaking yet also heartwarming, RIP her and her dog ❤️

[@clairegibbard577]

Omg that is so sad People are so cruel sometimes

[@Saul_Alejandr00]

I always thought of John Jacob Astor as trash for being with a younger woman that was barely legal, but I guess he had a heart since he gave up his seat on the lifeboat to 2 scared children 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@azmo4841]

i dont think it counts back then. woman mostly got married at 14 it was common

[@donnix1192]

My great grandfather Albert Horswill was a crewman on Titanic, he survived the wreck on the lifeboat with the Duff Gordons, the most infamous of the lifeboats.

[@Epiclydumb]

Incredible!

[@jonjahr3403]

William H. Harbeck a pioneer of the early motion pictures died on the Titanic. My mom is with his great grandson. He's shown all different kinds of things about Titanic and was even given an opportunity to play his great grandfather in a couple of scenes of the James Cameron film. However his wife was expecting twins right around the time they would've been filming so he turned it down. It's cool that he got the opportunity though and he even still has the paperwork they sent him. Love that you did this video.

[@ashleywhite2033]

They also didn’t even start loading the lifeboats until an hour and five minutes after the collision. The ship sank about two hours and forty minutes after they hit the iceberg. And they didn’t start loading lifeboats until an hour and five minutes later. So they only had about an hour and a half to get people off the ship before it sank. Also, the telegraph officers never left the communications deck. They stayed in the entire time to transmit sos signals trying to get help. Even after the communications weren’t readable anymore. They never stopped trying to get help.

[@jeromeschlicker6629]

Lawrence Beasley wrote not only about his own experience but he also wrote down quite a few of the the third class passengers stories for prosperity

[@ra8640]

I love the way He tells the stories. So much enthusiasm. Great stuff!

[@tiger31623]

Whoever's reading this, i pray that whatever you're going through gets better and whatever you're struggling with or worrying about is going to be fine and that everyone has a fantastic day! Amen

[@lisaskinner485]

I pray the same for you and your loved ones. Thank you!

[@iamnsane]

If anyone has Disney+ I would definitely recommend watching “Titanic 20 years later”.

[@mallabook1]

Although they requested binoculars I don't believe they wanted them for night time use, many look outs have stated that they would have hindered sight in those conditions and likely would have had a similar issue. The way the water, sky and weather was all had an effect on their visibility creating essentially a mirage. Depth perception was off so the iceberg sort of appeared out of nowhere.

[@beanburrito8903]

I love this guy's personality. Good job 👏

[@jamesporter8841]

Do you know his name ? He’s got a great sense of humour,,

[@bassitz2559]

Can we take a moment to appreciate how much time and effort he puts in the videos for us😇

[@nicoleleonard5633]

I'm. Subbin

[@FollowingTheWay81]

Yasss i love Taylor!

[@satoko6370]

Same i love amazing top 10! And subbed

[@little.zayzay]

We need a full movie of Molly Brown

[@XGamerFPS2164]

Ngl I like how they have so many bloopers at the end of the videos of them going over the stuff they are going to say but then still end up messing up information. #8 for example, explaining the story of the woman but saying the steward came to get them to the boat deck then somehow instantly went to the Carpathia and then didn’t arrive to a “safe ship” until the next day???

[@cokemud]

an interview with a titanic survivor stated that no music was played during the sinking of the titanic

[@dovetonsturdee7033]

Equally, interviews with other survivors stated that it was. Dance tunes, apparently, rather than 'Nearer my God to Thee.'

[@shatharis]

Interesting fact: Molly Brown survived multiple ship accidents. This is where she got the nickname "The Unsinkable Molly Brown"

[@terrydavis3976]

I love the bloopers. Keep up the good work. Your great!

[@zeldalink2394]

I love titanic the movie came out the year I was born 1997!:) I remember getting the movie on dvd when I was a kid it’s an amazing movie!:) love the history:)

[@batasgamer8511]

It's chilling that if you think about it... that everything seems to be perfectly laid out... like at the time... someone wants the titanic to sink and have less survivors.

[@cobrajr188]

There’s actually a conspiracy theory about that involving insurance fraud. Basically the name plates of the Titanic and Olympic were swapped after the Olympic had collided with another ship. There’s a lot more to it than that and realistically it is easily disproved by serial numbers in parts recovered from the wreckage, but it is very interesting nonetheless.

[@Momoneymmiproblems]

My great uncle was the first officer on the Carpathia.

[@Kat-pr7qm]

I believe the boat went back when the sun came up but it was too late.

[@user-bu8gz4bm7u]

At number seven when they talked about the binoculars. But that many peapole dont know is that the ship would most likley sink even if because normaly you see with your own eyes and you use binoculars to se what you have seen

[@karamedley6229]

Idk if one has been done but someone could do a story on peoples' pets that were lost, maybe another of pets that did survive, if any did. Just feel it would be a nice way to honor the pets that died on the Titanic and maybe even the owners.

[@bigdave3151978]

Bro no offense but u are one of my favorites on top 10 keep it up Tyler love ur stories

[@tkdan2121]

The orchestra people tho respect for them🙏🔝 they played until they sank tzz😢

[@georgecarella5055]

I saw the lost footage of titanic inside where the water kept coming and i can hear the screams and also i can hear the band playing. So sad

[@HudBoiLmao77]

That footage was fake

[@roberto-cm1rb]

80% of the comments here are people just saying their relatives died on the titanic 💀

[@shasthasampreeth2424]

Yo bro thank you for your information

[@lukycharms9970]

Please don’t listen to these. There is 1 maybe 2 that are actually 100% accurate

[@lalaladiva808]

You rock my mind love it 🥰

[@itsbandyyy]

The captain, and all the crew members were kinda cocky before going on voyage.

[@user-np9co2nm1z]

Is this a 10 minute recap of the movie Titanic? Count me in!

[@brianstabile165]

*sigh*

[@mallabook1]

During the time of the titanic the lifeboat regulations were very different. From what I gather ships were rewarded or encouraged to carry less lifeboats because they truly believed their designs to be unsinkable. When it comes to launching them during the incident, they didn't begin to launch until way after the initial crash which massively hindered loading and launching. They didn't follow protocol with loading, often having not even half capacity so in all a lot more people could have been saved even with what they had.

[@xenoxen343]

1 min ago and dont be scared by the dead be scared by the living

[@ashleybaby8749]

The fact they are making a replica for full use

[@starrsmith3810]

Titanic exceeded the amount of lifeboats required at the time. Which was 16. The lifeboat laws were massively out of date and really that’s due to the thoughtline that they’ll be a ship nearby to help ferry passengers from one ship to another. None of said reasons will ever be to avoid the deck getting cluttered. Which sounds ridicules because there’s PLENTY of spaces for first class passengers to be.

[@superyamky]

Next time add more life boats please

[@magsmcgarrigle981]

It was so preventable.😢

[@dovetonsturdee7033]

Most tragedies are, after the event.

[@daltoncraig8300]

i know

[@dylanhagsauce8629]

Not really, the iceberg came out of nowhere. Policy for life boats were different.

[@cobrajr188]

So the ship didn’t ignore emergency flares. Emergency flares are red, and for whatever reason, the titanic had no red flares only white ones. The other ships captain saw them, and simply didn’t think there was an emergency because they were not emergency flares.

[@sittingpretty3631]

Love this guy I watch all the time and show my niece 😝😎🤓

[@lukycharms9970]

the Californian wireless operator shut it down and went to sleep because Philips, one of the 2 wireless operators on titanic told the Californian to shut up while it broadcast iceberg warnings cause Philips was busy sending out personal messages for guests to their families back home. Had he not reamed the guy out, the Californian probably would have still had their wireless up and running.

[@dovetonsturdee7033]

Californian's only Marconi operator shut down because his shift had ended and he didn't work 24 hours each day. What people have interpreted as 'Shut Up' was nothing of the sort. Marconi operators used a form of shorthand when talking to each other. Phillips' signal was probably DDD which could just as easily have been read as 'clear the frequency.' Or even 'Please clear the frequency.'

[@avawashburn6161]

the unsinkable mrs molly brown was in the movie( that’s my fav movie sorry)

[@jasonbrown4836]

they had more then the legal amount of lifeboats, yet they were not filled to the max

[@rosalynnduke1452]

The Titanic radio man told the radio man on the California to shut up that's why his radio was switched off and he went to sleep and there were many warnings from multiple ships about pack ice and ice bergs all were ignored so no one can blame the California and SOS rockets were not common at that time so anyone on sea or land would have easily mistaken them for fire works.

[@shirleytaylor5055]

So.......why not make a video of brave souls giving up their space or demand return of shipwrecks?

[@piazorchid]

Molly brown was a badass we need more people like her in the world now.

[@NolanProdzz]

4:28 It’s not actually Californian captain fault about the flares. Titanic crew forgot or didn’t loaded red flares so Californian captain thought it was a party or something...

[@smileyface7974]

Yup - distress flares were red but the titanic was setting off white flares so the captain thought it was fireworks.

[@X0.LA_BRAVA.X0]

"Yooo that party looks fireee, wish I was there"

[@brianstabile165]

That image is a black and white version of titanic footage FOR THE MOVIE

[@penrithholba3355]

I love this channel so much brooo

[@traceytaft6101]

Messed up TF...... Wow 😲

[@richardivory606]

John Jacob Astor didn't give up his seat. He was rejected a seat. He was found half crushed possibly because of the funnel falling.

[@candiceperry7916]

The video is awesome&bizarre

[@jeromeschlicker6629]

John Jacob Aster wrote a book called A JOURNEY in other worlds

[@Davidsavage8008]

The flares were white not red. Red is a distress white is nothing. Besides the binoculars being locked up. They had no red flares.

[@carriesaundersson]

The beautiful ship built in my home city, Belfast ❤️

[@samryan5880]

Toured the Titanic museum today in Belfast, N Ireland where the boat was built and launched. Women and children were not allowed first on the life boats actually. It was a first come first serve. There’s an entire panel about that myth at the museum

[@starrsmith3810]

What?

[@jasminehubbard6217]

I like watching your video

[@R.X.V.E.N.Z.E]

Final destination vibes.

[@ashleighnixon3843]

I have them boneclorea

[@boatymcboatface1492]

that one paniting was of the rms lusataina not the titanic but there are some photos of the titanic butt not a lot

[@ur..local..l0ser261]

24 to like 5th to comment New record YEY

[@melon3996]

They got rid of the lifeboats because apparently 1st class needed more room to stroll the deck

[@Sarah0583]

No ocean liner of that era had enough lifeboats for everyone back then. Cunard’s Lusitania and Mauretania carried even less than Titanic before she sank. Titanic carried more lifeboats than required by law at the time, thankfully the law was changed after the sinking.

[@dylanhagsauce8629]

​@@Sarah0583 Crazy how you give an excellent comment and reply without even a like this world is weird.

[@dylanhagsauce8629]

Wrong

[@phycoticstudios1440]

Ok, so there is one story I heard I'm not sure how true it is but apparently there was a fire when the ship was bieng made. That left a small part in the ship were it was softer. The iceberg happend to hit that exact spot. If the iceberg hit a diffrent spot, the titanic would be known for one less thing.

[@dovetonsturdee7033]

It isn't true. Except in the mind of a journalist.

[@Davidsavage8008]

Big money big crimes.

[@adognamedsky6598]

Margret brown was actually in the movie

[@Bread-_]

Not the real one tho

[@adognamedsky6598]

@@Bread-_ yeah I meant that the character in the movie was a real person

[@Bread-_]

@@adognamedsky6598 Oh yea that makes sense

[@faithx9260]

I feel like it was set up for some reason...hmm

[@dovetonsturdee7033]

No. It wasn't.

[@Cl_5218]

There were no icebergs

[@Davidsavage8008]

Aster was killed. No way was he a nice person.

[@donnarussell7966]

Somebody in my family was on the Titanic.they were survivor

[@MrTommytyler]

You make them sound dumb for ignoring flares, titanic was one of the first ships to use them as sos. The other ship thought it was a firework display. After the sinking maritime law was changed to include flares.

[@josephiajanke9850]

The Californian crew knew they were SOS flares They didn't want to rescue The Titanic survivors Darilection of Duty

[@hunter-sm7ix]

This is so sad

[@almasabanovic485]

If i was Rose i would push that guy who hated Jack

[@daniellechambers4921]

Where's Jos?

[@Fleur-de-lis4]

Rms majestic was only launched in 1914 and only acquired by white star line after the first world war!!!

[@dovetonsturdee7033]

RMS Majestic was launched in 1889, and withdrawn in January, 1914. The Majestic you appear to be thinking of is the ex-German Bismarck, constructed for the Hamburg America line, launched in 1914, but not completed until 1922, when she was handed over to White Star as part of German war reparations.

[@wmred]

Is this guy Chris D’Elia’s son?

[@dariusjackson5584]

The musicians didn’t play on

[@Sarah0583]

Why is everyone saying that ? They stopped playing shortly before the final plunge, it doesn’t change anything about the selflessness and bravery of what they did, they played for most of the sinking. People who don’t know the story of the ship might read these kinds of comments and think that the musicians didn’t play at all.

[@sheliahall2130]

No the life boats was a lot of money so they did not want to waste that much money

[@starrsmith3810]

False.

[@Bread-_]

No, They Simply didnt want the deck to be overloaded.

[@starrsmith3810]

@@Bread-_ false as well. That sounds absolutely ridicules considering first class passengers had MULTIPLE hang out areas.

[@dylanhagsauce8629]

​@Starr Smith So much misinformation, thanks for clearing these fellas up. I wonder if it's ignorance or just trolling at this point. Why do people comment before they even know what they are talking about humans eh.

[@jamieashwell2583]

This guy looks like a skinny version of Chris D'Elia.

[@JacQues58]

People look to Cameron's fictional account as the truth. It is a made-up story. And he did not deserve an award. There have been countless Titanic films with the best being the BxW Classic, A Night To Remember. Written by Walter Lord, it details a lot of the tragedy. I suggest y'all read this tome and watch the film instead of the Cameron farce.

[@WhateverULike02]

We know it was a made-up account. He DID deserve the award.

[@missraven420]

I've watched both documentaries about the Titanic, especially the one how they built that movie set. Cameron wanted to have has much of the reality of the Titanic but he also did that fictional story. I've never met people who took his movie as fact, most actually went deeper into the tragedy to gain more facts for it. Reading old new articles about it, reading what other historians spoke about it. There had been a challenged about how it really sunk. No one who lived through the tragedy can't even answer it, though they might not be able too. If you haven't heard - the challenge was that the iceberg never what caused the sinking but rather boilers just finally exploding. It was also challenged that the owner(can't remove his name) that fled on one of the life boats knew about the high chance of them exploding. They believed that small (big but I'm not up close to it, I can only see it through the screens and books) cut in the ship wouldn't cause that sinking but they wanted to use it as an excuse. There had been a rumor that the ship never did the proper testing because they wanted that ship out to beat it's competition. The Captain, the Crew, The people who approved of the ship's test, and the owners knew that it wasn't fully safe because of the test proper and they just got paid off by the owners. But it's just challenges, and Cameron said on the documentary about his movie, it was meant to be a mix. Having the real life tragedy, with actual people doing things the people that died on the real people did while it was sinking. But he also wanted to have a story made, he could've done it the easy way and not follow the actual tragedy and try to get as real details down and just called it the Titanic after the ship. Also there was an award for it? I don't know much of awards, and such. I barely know any Actors so I'm leaving the award thing out.

[@kevinbloom2265]

Do the others have a topless Kate Winslet in? No? I'll not bother then

[@gigimarie3989]

I remember A Night to Remember being in our reading list when I was in school. Very good book. And you do realize A Night to Remember was also based on a fictional storyline and characters? It also won many awards. Not nearly as many as Cameron's version but it still got the recognition it deserved. And it is conflicting information was really happened on board the boat while things were as hectic as they were.. so different versions on the movie are going to go by what they heard happened from different accounts.

[@starrsmith3810]

You clearly never saw James Cameron’s movie. While there is quite a few inaccuracies and at least 2 less then stellar portrayals of real people (something ANTR had as well), there was things that legitimately did happen and real people getting depicted.

[@arthur._.tapia857]

Taylor Mcwatters don't lafe on mostamazingtop 10.

[@Sprigatito687]

What's Titanic

[@gellerbingsgaming]

I came here after mojos facts about titanic, who said that nobody was discriminated by class when it came to being allowed on a lifeboat, but you said first class men were allowed on after women and children, so which is right? Other than that great video.

[@starrsmith3810]

Watchmojo wasn’t wrong and the way this guy put it was kinda inaccurate. It was women and children first but that’s not to say every officer didn’t allow men on. Murdoch let women and children on first and if there wasn’t any left, men would go. Lightoller was the one who didn’t let men on. He went by women and children only. Will interpreted that way.

[@thunderaxezerothree8759]

first

[@tiger31623]

Bot nobody cares about what you say what a waste of a comment it's time to zipper your mouth shut

[@sluur]

8 mins ago

[@maryguthrie3862]

I love this channel but can Woody Host more?

[@CRAIGKMSBISMARCKTIRPITZ533]

THE TITANIC WAS DOOMED FROM THE START OF THE CONSTRUCTION 😂. WHITE STAR LINE ORDERED GRADE 2 RIVETTS INSTEAD OF GRADE 4. GRADE 4 AT THE TIME WAS THE HIGHEST GRADE. ALSO THEY HAD AN INCOMPETENT CAPTAIN 🤬

[@Sarah0583]

Then how did Olympic, which was built with the same rivets as Titanic, have such a long and successful career and survive several collisions (she even rammed a u-boat during WW1) ?…

[@Bread-_]

@@Sarah0583 Exactly.

[@anthonyberardo3910]

As a member of the Titanic Historical, I have to say that your piece is full of untruths and mistakes. Read the Book On a Sea of glass-the Life and Loss of RMS Titanic before you put more crap about the ship and its passenger on You Tube. Even your photos of other ships are wrong..

[@emilycoffin3106]

i all done my song my heart will go on is done on happy anniversary of the titanic still hear my Friends Captain Smith he talk to me calling help no blame him.

[@noahmcdarby5417]

When you really put it into perspective some of those first class passengers were very important people whose deaths undoubtedly cause a ripple affect. Not saying their lives were more valuable just saying

[@tro999]

first