Top 10 Greatest NHL Defensemen of All Time - The LineUp Ep. 18

[@nicholasmacdonald547]

Great idea for a show but nobody seems to have much hockey knowledge

[@kratoscallofduty]

Chris Chelios is not only my favorite defenseman....he's my favorite player in NHL history.

[@patk24]

where is ray bourque

[@fordprefect4728]

he only has the most points of all time by d-men, he doesnt deserve to b on here.

[@fordprefect4728]

he was a wild card which u dont c on the board

[@Tylerboyd2001]

ford prefect you’re a fucking idiot. Bourque is the 2nd best d-man of all time, and just for points. Bourque was an absolute beast and it was impossible to get around him. He’s been a consistent D-man.

[@N8tiveSon807]

My all-time fav better be on here,,Ray Bourque.

[@christopherhopkins949]

HE IS NOT, this is a joke.

[@tobyryberg]

If they want aggressive, they should push for Bertuzzi.

[@nicholasmacdonald547]

Why isn't Bourque an option

[@lancemilliken9078]

No Ray Bourque? Didn't he win five Norris trophies?

[@luvslogistics1725]

Growing up loved watching Coffey fly

[@toddpick8007]

Mr end to end.

[@cdog1990able]

Couple gripes. First off this was INCREDIBLY disrespectful to Denis Potvin and second of all the Blackhawks are not a dynasty

[@canadiansyrup137]

MVP probably gonna be Bobby Orr

[@canadiansyrup137]

Lol, what did I say.

[@canadiansyrup137]

Erm, what? It shows who the MVP is at the start... Lol.

[@phillytheflyerable]

ya think?!

[@HYP3DSNIP3R]

That was a very hard prediction :/

[@nicholasm4013]

comment section: 20% about the lineup 40% asking for likes 30% about how early people arived 10% asking for subs

[@danrg26]

Dark Nidoking Macolino 1% guys making dumb list

[@zeusethedogzeusethedog7276]

Dark Nidoking Macolino 30% Erik karlson

[@luketratar5185]

The show idea is cool but it gets dumb once a team is allowed to steal a player because it's basically over then

[@williammontroy9024]

Lol shows ya the knowledge here with Kelly being shunned lmao

[@gcvhappy4026]

Orr was the goat

[@ethanj8131]

14:14 Brad Park was never a poor man's Bobby Orr. Interestingly enough Brad stated "I never said I was as good as he [Orr] although others did"

[@bigpapavee]

Before I watch, here's my 10 In no Particular order. Bobby Orr Dennis Potvin Tim Horton Nik Lidstrom Doug Harvey Larry Robinson Ray Bourke Vladamir Konstantinov Paul Coffey Chris Pronger Hororable Mention: Scott Niedermeyer Guy Lapointe Serge Savard Brad Park Borje Salming Dit Clapper Red Kelly King Clancy Rob Blake Duncan Keith Brian Leetch Adam Foote Al Mcginnis Phil Housley Mark Howe Chris Chelios

[@melgreier1630]

Loving the Guy Lapointe pick... often cited as a better offensive defenseman than Robinson and better defensively than Savard; Guy was paired with younger, inexperienced d-men and still shone as the star he was! Two thumbs up for hockey IQ!

[@sammyweed4771]

Great top 10 but chelios can replace Pronger…. Another than that great top 10

[@jarink1]

Stopped watching when the panelists/players/whatevers were shown to be music and video industry people. WTH does that have to do with hockey?

[@dmfour]

Ray Bourque?

[@tudorarada46]

Where the fuck is Erik Karlsson?

[@MrShepperdspie]

Beth -182 Montreal fans still butt hurt ottawa made it further in the playoffs

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

No cups... That is where. :/

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

I will say, however, there are WAY better defensemen than both Karlsson and Weber, that could have been chosen for this list. Neither of those guys have won a cup.

[@nikolaslust8589]

Who cares about cups? Hockey is not the NBA. One player cannot affect the game like a player can in the NBA. There are 18 other players on your team that play a game. Did you watch Karlsson these playoffs? The guy was wordly and they still lost because the rest of the team is shit.

[@tudorarada46]

PRYVTgomerPYLE Karlsson is the best defenseman in the NHL at the moment and has been for the past years. He's leading in points and it's not even close. He did it all on a broken foot while carrying his entire team. Also, cups mean shit. You're telling me Ron Hainsey is better than Ovechkin? That's right. Anyways, it's much easier to win a cup being a star on a really good team. Karlsson was one goal away form the SF on a team that shouldn't have made the playoffs (on paper).

[@salespo6129]

Please get people on the show who actually know what they're talking about. This is embarrassing

[@WuLi4B]

EX PLAYERS. WHO WERE THESE GUYS, BETTER YET, FORMER COACHES. ONE GUY WAS A MUSICIAN AND THE OTHER THREE WERE, I DON'T KNOW. I DO KNOW THEY WERE NOT FORMER HOCKEY PLAYERS. THEY'RE JUST FANS.

[@jh2245]

Duncan Keith ahead of Pronger. Clueless!

[@TSSAmbassador]

The NHL should host a Defensemans game. A game dedicated to the best offensive and defensive defenseman. Offensive Defenseman playing center and wing while each team has defensive defenseman.

[@christenandersen65]

I can't believe Doug Harvey went where he did. 7 Norris Trophies, 6 Stanley Cups, controlled the game as well as Orr, the only coach to win an individual award, maybe in all sports, and you wanna talk tough, how about boxing champion of the Canadian Navy during WWII.

[@kylematthews891]

The final list is complete garbage... how about you get some guest to play who actually know the history of the game.

[@princealbert8128]

3:36 "Niklas LinDstrom" 7:04 "Borea Salming" XD

[@risk_it_4_the_biscuit]

how about phil housley?

[@seinsmeld13]

As soon as I saw your list with two Americans I shut if off. At least you had Orr, Keith, Lidstrom, Niedermayer & Harvey. Carry on.

[@brett4istate]

where is Rob Blake?

[@palms1821]

Ray Bourque was better than everyone on this list except for Bobby Orr

[@cccrazy100]

Chara is a better D-man than Weber. It's close but every reason you say Weber you could say Chara is the same, except Chara has a cup

[@duncanmacock1131]

My list before I'm watching this,bobby Orr Paul Coffey al macinnes al iafrertey, Nicholas lidstom chris pronged potvin from the islanders Larry Robinson rob Blake Scott Stevens Barclay plagur Doug Wilson Chris chelios ray borque

[@phillytheflyerable]

I would pick Erik Karlsson next to Lidström, Orr, Bourque, Coffey probably.

[@carlosanaya4149]

No Drew Doughty? Lol 😂

[@gocubs1815]

Lidstrom > Orr #YeahISaidIt

[@youneedhelp6902]

This may be odd to say this,some will under stand, Ray bor and Nicholas som was as good as bobby orr on defense, but bobby orr was a way better hockey player than any one....

[@michaelkausalik4062]

Where the fuck is Adam Foote?

[@711menace]

Michael Kausalik seriously

[@jimmykarlsson2567]

No Phil Housley, no Larry Murphy??

[@iansveinson1138]

Pronger is the only one to win Hart and Norris since Bobby Orr. Also was robbed for con smythe in 2006.

[@madisonfisk6399]

Upping the stakes uuuuu...upping upping stakes

[@jackbelden3851]

this is like me being given the platform to speak about medical knowledge. get people who know what they are talking about

[@manta5313]

Watched this vid with bauer gloves on lol

[@DurtGurty]

The guy with white hair did not just say “we are of the red headed people”

[@victoriadixon5521]

Scott Stevens ahead of Doug harvey? common.

[@Ryanwoito]

Again no Erik Karlsson why???

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

No cups... WHY???

[@Ryanwoito]

PRYVTgomerPYLE well weber has no cups and no Norris trophies. And karlsson has two Norris trophies younger and leads his team in points each year. How is that not better then Weber or at least deserving to be on the draft pool

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

And what I am saying is.. Neither should make the list. Larry Murphy - 4 cups, 3 allstar games and in the hockey hall of fame. Tim Horton - 4 cups, 3 allstar games and in the hockey hall of fame. ^ Better credentials then "he has a hard shot" or "he almost won a cup." -_- #FanboySomeMore

[@nikolaslust8589]

You cant be in the hockey hall of fame until you retire so that's probably the stupidest thing you could say. Winning a cup also depends on the team built around you. Also not very indicative.

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

"Fan boy" some more... He is not comparable. Period.

[@DreDollaz]

DAMN A WATCH MOJO VIDEO WITH 5K VIEWS?? WTF HAPPEN?

[@christopherhopkins949]

Weber did win a Norris

[@zacharybocciastudent242]

My top 5 best defenseman ever would be, # 5. Chris Chelios # 4. Paul Coffey # 3. Ray Bourque # 2. Bobby Orr # 1. Brian Leetch

[@sammyweed4771]

Nicklas Lidstrom has to be in top 5 my friend.someone has to go

[@gamingwithjacob8927]

I'm glad Duncan keith was at least in the wild card

[@gmtv6710]

Where is Pierre pilote??!!

[@lancemilliken9078]

GM TV and what about pontious pilote?

[@ryanweintraub9448]

DENIS POTVIN REPPING 1980s ISLANDERS! YES YES YES

[@dj5BIT]

Ristolainen, Timonen, Vatanen?

[@SledgerPlays]

lol

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

You are obviously Finnish. :/

[@Jatkalisäämällätunnus]

loll1pop hereille

[@dj5BIT]

Oh and don't forget Määttä

[@phillytheflyerable]

lol

[@TheBoy984]

no Karlsson or Doughty ? but Weber is there...

[@dankmeme8849]

erik karlson and no victor hedman and shea weber is up there bruh?

[@cameronbrown3693]

Aheam .... cough cough bobby orr cough

[@grimreeper2243]

I love watch mojo

[@Hukooma]

Sergey Gonchar! :) (of course not)

[@dmfour]

OK then. Wild card 2

[@pridefulwharf58]

NO DREW DOUGHTY OR BRENT BURNS CRAZY

[@colinsambrook248]

Some grade A quality green screen you got there.

[@SumiIsGoat]

Erik Karlsson or is he too young?

[@TheBoilingBoyle]

Greatest undrafted players.

[@Brainman234]

29 seconds and i see that

[@NathansWargames]

Stop trynna make this sport Relevant outside of Canada.

[@marcnystrom5720]

Sharky Productions It's already relevant outside if Canada.

[@christopherhopkins949]

NO RAY BOURQUE? This is a joke.

[@nikolaslust8589]

Erik Karlsson has a legitimate case for top 3 defensemen of all time.. or at least on his way, but you have.. Shea Weber in there...?

[@cdog1990able]

Nik L sit down no he doesn't. Not yet

[@nikolaslust8589]

Explain to me how he is not?

[@cdog1990able]

Nik L because he hasn't been around long enough. Not enough Norris's and no cup

[@nikolaslust8589]

Don't give me the Cup argument. There are 18 other players on his team that play every night. Did you watch him these playoffs? He was basically unstoppable and the Sens still lost because the team around him is shit. He isn't the GM or the coach. He already has two norris trophies, probably should have 3. He is 27. The combination of his Hockey IQ, speed/skating abilities, defensive and offensive awareness put him up there with Orr, Lidstrom.

[@cdog1990able]

Nik L he is average in his own zone. In no particular order Potvin, Robinson, Leetch, Coffey, Lidstrom, and Pronger were all better

[@slippy1809]

where's Luca Sbisa of the Vancouver Canucks? such an amazing player. He's an absolute legend. He's far superior to most of the players on the shows lists. lol jk

[@toddpick8007]

Paul Coffey hold or shares 33 records in the show, give your balls a tug.

[@eriklaitinen4656]

where is Zdeno Chara? epic fail

[@Crunch2525]

Where the FUCK is Mark Howe?????

[@7b8bk95y]

WHERE THE FUCK IS KONSTANTINOV????

[@jmarx3943]

Wow, team blue might be the worst team yet on this show

[@djguapo2025]

J Marx yeah those guys sucked

[@csquire667]

I don't understand why you chose to make the game show all about hockey that makes no sense at all next time think harder when you decide to make a game show don't make it about sports next time so this is a epic fail

[@cobyjones7723]

Man no Eric Karlsson questionable

[@chaynecastonguay623]

karlsson

[@empaldinou]

Adam Foote? Rob Blake?

[@semiretired86]

Zdeno Chara?

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

Umm... Larry Murphy? :/

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

4 cups 3 all star games and he is in the hall of fame.

[@PRYVTgomerPYLE]

Tim Horton is better than Shea Weber ever thought about being. Plus (like I said at the beginning) Larry Murphy. :/

[@lancemilliken9078]

PRYVTgomerPYLE respectfully, Larry Murphy is not even an all-time top 25 defenseman. He was very solid, no doubt, but no way is he one of the greatest top 10 in the history of the sport. I think even Larry would agree with me

[@jennygholson33]

Spam much?🙄

[@stuardstuardnx3134]

i see on 1minute

[@liamherr4446]

Duncan Keith over EK65? Lol

[@DPK1255]

Liam Herr Keith is better than Karlsson though.

[@liamherr4446]

Daniel Kee Ok bud

[@DPK1255]

Liam Herr It helps that Keith is with the blackhawks but he's still proven his worth aside from playing with Kane and Toews when he won.the Conn Smythe over both of them. Karlsson has a Norris or two sure but he has 0 cups to Keith's 3

[@liamherr4446]

Daniel Kee Keith has three because of Kane. And the Sens up until a few years ago were a JOKE. Also, you cant win a Conn Smythe if you dont make the cup finals. Guaranteed if EK65 won this year he would have a cup and a Conn Smythe

[@DPK1255]

Liam Herr Well Kane didn't win him the Conn. I agree if the Sens won that the Conn was his if not Rinnes. But they didn't win.

[@RealFreeZ]

#1 Lidström.

[@zacharybocciastudent242]

LEETCH

[@sean1629soon]

Hi

[@victoriadixon5521]

Shea Weber is not better than red Kelly. red kelly is a top 20 player of all time.

[@michaelbarry1293]

Why'd that guy gloat about not getting Leetch? Leetch was among the the top 5 all time defenseman.

[@adamsons2890]

This is terrible. Only one guy there knows anything about hockey. They are all great players even without Chara on the list.

[@gimmick7389]

weber lmfao

[@fabshibawarrior436]

Potvin way too late

[@davidleo518]

No respect for the leafs ffs

[@greatnate8686]

Chris Letang

[@glazyfn4072]

1337

[@KP-05]

this is horrible.

[@pridefulwharf58]

NO ERIK KARLSSON OMG WTF😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲

[@mirkostjepanovic8256]

Hii

[@timmullens9479]

Doug Harvey-great in his era-wouldn't make a team today

[@ginnyhodges6498]

itts ok

[@salthe21st47]

13k views lol

[@marcelomejia2278]

7th

[@thewindysuomi7590]

Im Gay

[@matthewhare8456]

Nikalas Kronwall?

[@williammontroy9024]

No . Love him but no .. now if we were talking hitters it would be different

[@michaelsnake8]

the team with the mvp wins every single time this show sucks

[@csquire667]

Jonathan Drouin no this show sucks because it's about sports

[@Bouquez]

actually I think I remember a couple of times that the other team won... Honestly most of the time I find that the team who wins the forced trade tends to win...