Top 10 Scary Underrated Creepypasta

[@ReverandSatan]

Concerning #1, Arthur C. Clarke once said, "Two possibilities exist: either we are alone in the Universe or we are not. Both are equally terrifying." And I'd have to agree.

[@rayloui]

Reverend Satan definitely ....

[@gabano1311]

The We are alone one is much scarier but I still agree

[@angelodalton4391]

I’ve always been confused on how they’re both terrifying. I understand it if we’re not alone but if we are????? Someone explain pwease ;-;

[@loldontask4979]

@@angelodalton4391 Well, I mean, just think about it. Us, humanity, the other creatures on Earth, are the only things in all of existence. It may not sound like much at first, but it's honestly quite terrifying if you think deeper about it.

[@tayloranderson7547]

Concerning #1, Arthur c. Clarke onece said, two possibilities exist: either we are alone

[@akianderson4913]

Humanity: “We’re here!” Aliens: “Okay, shut the hell up” lol

[@jocosesonata]

Humanity is like the galaxy's noisy next-door neighbor.

[@jayvhoncalma3458]

Androids : *Facepalm*

[@hikariwrathyt9959]

Apple: What are you even saying?!

[@nathanielberry9195]

Wars to aliens in like domestic violence for continents

[@marshmallowbunnies9290]

Humans are aliens to aliens. Every living species is an alien

[@bernellepete3534]

Rebbeca: scaring us by leaving us confused. Ayman: scaring us by providing much detail as possible. Che: scaring us with some humor

[@tommo8185]

I loooove ayman she soo funny

[@josephdaniels9134]

Lindsay: tells everything

[@aayonijarya]

@@josephdaniels9134 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@samanthaambegia1502]

I love them all but awesome post

[@yourlocaldisgraceu-u426]

accurate

[@frostwolf561]

Why does Rebecca always sound so calm when she's talking about spooky scary things?

[@zanderthezealous5169]

I know!

[@jonmarrie8093]

She's possibly psychotic

[@mercenarychef9465]

Would you expect anything less from the Slytherin Queen?

[@frostwolf561]

@@mercenarychef9465 Nope, not really.

[@ksstudio1351]

I’m guessing she has done this enough to not be scared

[@gavinsuddarth696]

Haven't seen shoulder pads that big since the Golden Girls was still on

[@amystabenow1189]

She is lovely but this dress is not her. Just not right for her body type. But she rocks 99.9999% of the time.

[@amandaschroeder2751]

Lol, IKR!!

[@gavinsuddarth696]

I love Miss Rebecca but DAMN

[@tiredmommy1643]

Actually they're not pads. Its how the fabric is sown together. Its comes to a point,mimicking shoulder pads. And I think she looks lovely!

[@gavinsuddarth696]

@@tiredmommy1643 You're very right, she always looks amazing. Just thought that was a bold choice in shoulder attire

[@nobodytheog3213]

So is our Queen leaving or not cause im having mixed emotions

[@Mikecars2319]

They prerecorded a few videos, I'm just wondering when they run out

[@DestinyKiller]

Is she supposed to be leaving?

[@Mikecars2319]

Yeah she announced it on IG

[@Adam-eg3jb]

She is only taking a break for a while and will be returning.

[@unredacted9142]

Nuuuuu rebecca stays or we go who’s with me !!!!

[@givemespines]

Her: A Creepypasta game you can play yourself! It’s- Me: DOKI DOKI LITERATURE CLUB? Her: The Midnight Game!

[@aniimatedHumorist]

Anonymous Animation lmao

[@angelodalton4391]

Bruh 😂

[@christmassyable]

Lmfao

[@Justadeerthatgames]

I like ddlc

[@LatexGod]

*VETERAN MEMORIES* Why..... Just why?

[@lavenderdemons]

My favorites are: Candle Cove Psychosis The Alice killings Suicide sadie Nurse Ann Nightmare Ally The Pupepeteer Candy Pop Vaily Evans

[@ksstudio1351]

CielPhantomhiveReacts my favourites are also the Alice killings and candle cove

[@Erin-sq1rf]

My favorite are Nurse Ann and Puppeteer :D

[@tayloranderson7547]

My favorite are: candle cove the aice killings nurse Ann nightmare ally

[@lorib.4735]

CielPhantomhiveReacts....I’m telling u I KNOW I sound insane but I’m a bit older(as a woman won’t reveal my age) let’s just say a child in the 80’s and leave it at that...lol!! Anyway sorry to get off track but I do remember watching Candle Cove! I even asked my mom and she said I remember u telling me about it but for the life of me I never could find anything about it in TV Guide!? 😂😳😱

[@KyeKenKen]

CielPhantomhiveReacts My question is: Why does everyone hate or not know Judge Angels?

[@kyleswife9860]

Everyone else : OMG SO UNDERRATED me the idiot who doesnt even know what underrated means : *What*

[@skogomeister]

Wolfy 高清 HELL

[@skogomeister]

Wolfy 高清 IS

[@skogomeister]

Wolfy 高清 COMING

[@skogomeister]

Wolfy 高清 HAHAHA

[@maltorvolt9694]

It means that something isn't appreciated as much as it should be.

[@gingrninja3195]

"THE Couch!!!" me:shoot I'm leget sat on a sofa

[@madisonchandler9441]

I sleep on a couch ;-;

[@mexicanbeans]

Jeah me too

[@dominic_the_slime4699]

Me to

[@dominic_the_slime4699]

Sad

[@skippertheboi141]

i think my favorite scary story is la llorona or “The Weeping Woman” I think my favorite creepypasta is The Russian Sleep Experiment

[@anastasiasmith1791]

She was so pretty 😍

[@aniimatedHumorist]

skippertheboi Creepy pastas are scary stories,they’re the same thing.

[@christmassyable]

The sleep experiment still scares bejeezus out of me.

[@skippertheboi141]

★cherry.productions★ i know, but la llorona isn’t really a creepypasta

[@skippertheboi141]

Shon'tel daLEY same. that picture still gives me nightmares

[@jockeyfield1954]

"we know jeff the killer" HoodoHoodlumsrevenge has joined the chat

[@danaheckelmann2530]

“Were’s my tooooeeeee” I read the scary story’s to tell in the dark book and it’s the best story!

[@Okamineko0]

I just got two for Christmas! Love them

[@farsirens7789]

me too

[@scartell3307]

I watched the movie at 3am and my neighbours had to come round because they thought I was being murdered.

[@walmartdoor183]

i had the audiobook! we blasted it in the car and it was so funnnnnnn

[@Anon-zv3my]

The 80's called and said Rebecca Looks Totally Rad.

[@BaldingClamydia]

Truth!

[@Rd-uy1pz]

Where’s the lie

[@SoggyPotatoo]

wow

[@wierdanimepeep9815]

*Sees the word Creepypasta* Taps with the power of Allmight

[@xxxfoxet-chanxxx6116]

But like same

[@0f44]

All might!

[@bonnieproofrandomnezz101]

Did you tap it or smash it?

[@shawnveloso7036]

Deteroit tappp!!

[@lazzel5596]

DETROIT TAAAAPPP

[@tinydeevil2668]

My top 5 creepypasta are: -Eyeless Jack -Ticci Toby -XVirus -The Stickman -Ben Drowned

[@r3d4cted95]

Same

[@BilletteGod234]

I like smile dog

[@tanisha815]

me: * hears Midnight Man * also me: "Sam and Colby."

[@tomjones3827]

I just ran into my room to cry as I heard about the passing of my auntie. As I was crying my face pressed against my pillow I felt one unmistakable hand on my back applying a tiny bit of pressure but ofcourse no one was in the room with me. However I wasn't scared. I was somewhat comforted. That's one of my stories

[@Lasagnabobby]

What

[@naseemaismail2199]

Ooooookk

[@galaxykittygalaxygaming8615]

I LOVE CREEPYPASTA I LIKE CREEPY STUFF MY FAVORITE CREEPYPASTA IS EYELESS JACK I think I spelled it wrong 😑

[@that1giirll04]

MINE TOO,i also love Ticci Toby, Jeff and Zero

[@shortpotato2785]

Ej is one of my favorites right after Puppeteer

[@jcappsjcapps2243]

You spelled it correctly and SAME

[@jessiebijsterbosch8070]

He's my favorite too😁

[@naseemaismail2199]

Mine is Kuchie Sakie Onna

[@IfYouKnowYouKnow.]

"Hands under the covers when they sleep." LMAO

[@hell_on_earth666]

Exactly my reaction

[@bluester9988]

,’ ;)

[@jaxtonqwq-ihatemypictureso754]

XDDD

[@EnjoyingS0up]

omg that’s so naughty! i don’t know why anyone would even dare do that lmao

[@thebelen2359]

I was just like wtf

[@jacobharding5843]

I am a creepy pasta my self- underrated and creepy

[@elivandrisse]

You're not my uncle!

[@sweedereed]

Are you ok

[@jacobharding5843]

OH GOD DO NOT PRESS THAT LINK

[@sweedereed]

What is it

[@krisninoorpatrianti8262]

Your beard is so scary

[@hyp3rc00kie]

Who else is watching this without socks 😂🥺

[@amanda04061]

Me!

[@BigT613]

Me

[@galaxykittygalaxygaming8615]

ME

[@eightpathshellsgate6983]

Me

[@galaxykittygalaxygaming8615]

@@SquirrelGold know what?

[@shortpotato2785]

My favorite creepypasta has to be either Puppeteer, Eyeless Jack, or Sally

[@kittykatz6697]

Who's sally?

[@mystic.xeonii2501]

@@kittykatz6697 Sally maryam williams is a ghost child that was killed by her uncle,she came back dead and killed her uncle

[@kittykatz6697]

@@mystic.xeonii2501 OH ok thanks

[@hopsqotch1852]

I’ve heard some of these stories on snarled/Something scary

[@martalover17]

Yes

[@mikaylapayne6454]

Yesssssssss

[@graphtonix6607]

I love Jeff the killer, Jane the killer, Teke Teke railroad ghost girl and Sally Williams.

[@VivisSymphony]

But... But They all succ

[@muggy1834]

@@VivisSymphony GOT EMMM

[@AnastasiaCant8]

Anthony Taylor Network I like ticci toby

[@xxxfoxet-chanxxx6116]

Yes

[@VivisSymphony]

@@AnastasiaCant8 more like THICCI toby amirite lads

[@ScrumpehDrinker]

Seeing rebecca and hearing her voice makes me happy and puts a smile on my face :D

[@jordyDarko613]

How to survive in hell narrated by Mr. Creeps is my favorite

[@jackmason5278]

The scariest thing I've encountered is the rumour that Queen Rebecca is abandoning us.

[@voxtek-enterprise]

oh yes something to keep me up at night! also can you do top 10 scary Child killers? or kids that are killers so i wont sleep more

[@quinniciajones6455]

I really really like the classic ones such as slenderman, jeff the killer, etc. i love all

[@morgan2538]

Slenderman isn't a creepypasta, it's an urban legend but ok ^^

[@kattherascal9867]

@@morgan2538 not even that. hes a meme. he was created for a photoshop contest

[@Gamefan113]

My favorite creepypasta is called, "it Has No Face."

[@justseanyt]

That isnt a real creepypasta

[@justseanyt]

It is Mr mc creeps creepypasta I believe

[@justseanyt]

Not tryna b rude

[@Mr.Tw1sty]

It's gotta body but no face

[@isa_the_icequeen]

My favorite CreepyPasta is Borrasca. It genuinely freaked me out and made me cry at times. I go back and listen to MrCreepyPasta's reading of it every now and then and it still hits all the right feels for a creepy story.

[@wreckageggs8616]

New Fish is my favorite. A classic prison lockdown told to perfection. NoSleep is better than Creepypastas by a long shot, am I right? The only Creepypasta that can hold a candle is “The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas” and maybe “The Showers”

[@yourboychuck2869]

29 views and 78 likes KZbin is doing their thing today

[@nobodytheog3213]

Its cause some folks like it before the video is over

[@scarlett4024]

laughing jake as always been my favorite creepypasta

[@annachild4051]

I WILL WATCH THIS WHOLE VIDEO EVEN IF I’M IN CLASS!Which I am!😀

[@VivisSymphony]

no one cares

[@jonathangaldamez4083]

God of Beans lol

[@tomjones3827]

It's 1:00 AM where I Am

[@sweetiepoo9631]

God of Beans u don’t have to be so mean to people 💢

[@DivsDivinity]

@@VivisSymphony then don't waste your "precious" uncaring time into writing useless rude comments.

[@yukichan1630]

Definitely check out ‘My Friend is a Plastic Surgery Monster’

[@Screamingonthefloor]

My favorite scary story or creepypasta is Bloody painter or also known as helen otis

[@xxxfoxet-chanxxx6116]

Mine is laughing jack

[@emd1494]

Mine is "abandoned by Disney".

[@bubblegum7602]

Damn I have a lot but if I had to choose I’d say Eyeless Jack

[@0f44]

Mines Smile dog Hes so bootiful SuBscrIbE tO mE iF yOuR hErE tO sUbCrIbE

[@Screamingonthefloor]

@@0f44 done

[@cjliu5152]

The fact that she's leaving some cliffhangers...

[@savannahrichmond6757]

My favorite creepypasta has to be laughing Jack eyeless Jack Jason the toymaker or Candy Pop I cannot decide between those

[@r3d4cted95]

Those are really cool

[@emilyturtle4091]

Eyeless jack and ticci toby. I relate to them so maybe I'm going to be the next creepypasta

[@marinaduchesne1197]

I love when Rebecca does the talking

[@allinfordoge7111]

Yes!!!!

[@marinaduchesne1197]

@@allinfordoge7111 yessss Queen

[@joshjames311]

The story “The Cleansing” has always freaked me out and no one seems to have read it except me. Be warned... it is messed up beyond all belief.

[@Prophet1]

Nah ive seen a Jake Paul video nothing can be worse

[@elivandrisse]

I watched this video then slept with my leg over the edge of my bed. :O

[@zoeesworld9582]

These are normally scary to me but with you narrating them it feels much more safe

[@lillianahollis2292]

Love you rebbeca my favorite scary story is sleepy hallow

[@zoeesworld9582]

Lilliana Hollis same

[@lillianahollis2292]

@@zoeesworld9582 hello friend lol

[@RandomPerson-rp6eg]

Almost same. Except its my 4th fav. Sowwy😂😪

[@lexi1666]

Ticci Toby is my favorite! He can't feel pain has Tourette Syndrome. His life was pretty normal besides kids bullying him for his disability. For his birthday his sister and him plan to go on a trip, only to get in a car wreck. She dies and he lives. Toby starts hearing voices and kept seeing slendermans figure out his window. He chews the skin off his hands and eventually his mother takes him to a psychologist. Refusing help he returns home and that night he hears something in the hallway. Being curious, he walks into the hallway, expecting his mother but found his messed up looking sister. She's torn up from the wreck and he gets terrified. Within a week he loses his sanity and begins to listen to the voice. One night his dad is drunk and he beats toby. Toby loses control and grabs a knife, stabbing him. He then runs to the garage and grabs two hatchets along with a gas can. While his mother is asleep he pours gas everywhere then lights it as he runs into the woods. Sirens approach and he expects to be caught. Then slender appears in front of him, causing him to pass out. His mother survives the fire and keeps trying to say toby is innocent, that he must have ran off into the woods only to get lost. Sorry mum your son is a killer lol.

[@mathiash2734]

First

[@sweedereed]

mathiash 273 nice

[@alkebulanawah4242]

"Be quiet or they'll hear u" '_'

[@likeyoucare381]

I always stay till the end of Rebeccas videos because I love the way she says "bye". p.s. we'll miss you😭😭😭😢😢

[@flaming_biobag]

I'm confused is she leaving?

[@shakimamorris1253]

Just was about to ask the same thing

[@likeyoucare381]

she has been saying that she is in a few of the recent videos. So........... I have no idea but I hope she doesn't leave.

[@nicolebuffone7636]

Mr. Bear had to be my all time FAVORITE creepypasta! It’s extremely long, but keeps you reeled in the whole time! Definitely a must read!

[@graphtonix6607]

What is the name of the background music in this video??? Please let me know.

[@goldsea1678]

My favorite is “I relive the same day multiple times, today ends badly”

[@kSubscribersWithoutAnyVi-eo1ux]

Me: *sees notification* I’m gonna wait I’m watching Billie Elish cover on The Voice :))

[@Perkz.818]

10k Subscribers Without Any Videos? *you clicked and commented anyway-*

[@jacobcarlsen929]

@@Perkz.818 #Exposed

[@DJARlN]

Wow you listen to Billie you're so quirky 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

[@Kitty_JL7]

@@DJARlN what do you mean by quirky? (I actually don't know what does that word mean)

[@DJARlN]

@@Kitty_JL7 Quirky means having a trait that's unique, I was being sarcastic by calling them quirky because she listens to Billie Eillish even though thousands of other people do too

[@reactionswitherin5504]

“Room 733” is my favorite. I don’t know if it is necessarily “underrated” because I have heard several people talk about it on KZbin and Reddit, but it never fails to give me chills.

[@annalise7320]

Omg the hairy toe!! 😂😂 If it's what I think it is, I loved that story when I was little! We stan

[@sakurasensations4786]

Me, as soon as I opened the video: “Are those Shoulder pads?” XD

[@ronnymckindra5558]

And on the 4th

[@mikaelarichards8072]

I love your videos!! I will search through all of them in order to find yours!!! I like the way you tell the stories!!

[@PXL-Green_Dragon]

For Number 10 it sounds like the other civilization was trying to warn him to stay quiet because there’s other civilizations that are dangerous that will attack or destroy the planet for resources if they keep broadcasting...

[@Lilly-yh8lp]

I love how I've heard most of these... Great video though!

[@fidelquiroz6613]

I cant wait to watch this video✨✨🔥

[@christmassyable]

I love that she gives enough information to give u a lil chill but pique your curiosity to go read the stories to find out if there’s more or what scared them

[@avashannon6989]

I absolutely adore rebecca she is so amazing everytime I click on one of these videos I hope to hear hello and welcome to the most amazing channel on the internet I'm your host rebecca felgate

[@GCKMimi]

Omg thank you so much for this list. Can't wait to start reading these. My favorites are the Man in the Field ritual and The Children on the Stairs. Oh, and Tailypo is my tip top fave.

[@Ari___________]

The number next to the like button is the percent chance that Rebecca won't leave.

[@dove.9833]

That dress is beautiful on Rebecca! 🥰💖

[@CJ-sp6lh]

I love horror and I was born at 3:33 am... Coincidence?

[@tobiszetsu119]

Humans:WERE ON THE MOON Aliens:SHUT UP IM PLAYING MINECRAFT Humans:wh-

[@gagedueber5370]

My favorite Creepypasta is Laughing Jack

[@gagedueber5370]

Laughing Jack is the coolest clown ever

[@jerseygirljay78]

Yyaasss!!

[@bubblegum7602]

Laughing Jack is me in my emo stage just black and white

[@Yeet-vl8hz]

View 5

[@crystalhector8924]

So many creepypasta are super underrated and some of them are really cool and creepy.

[@adamgonzales1189]

Oof

[@lindseyfishel3909]

My favorite creepypasta that I don't think gets noticed enough is about a girl who thinks she has some weird powers but it's her half ghost sister who is watching out for her , is protecting her from people who wants to hurt her

[@iclassifyasataco3976]

*This is Such a great idea of me watching this at night!*

[@RoxasHaz]

Who I love in MA? I love everyone in MA especially Rebecca. She’s beautiful, knows sense of fashion and the most i love about her is that she’s fun, giving the positive vibes and i smiled when she did jokes. 💕💕

[@derp8200]

I have an underrated creepypasta.

[@skyisherelol3492]

Which one?what happens in it?

[@derp8200]

@@skyisherelol3492 kzbin.info/www/bejne/moLaZapvjMyLmbM

[@martalover17]

Carpeted bathroom

[@Mr.Tw1sty]

@@derp8200 I just got Rick rolled

[@novelofchaos901]

Ticci Toby, Lazari(I can't spell), Sally, Eyeless Jack, Zalgo(still can't spell), Masky, and Lost Silver to name a few. All 'less known' creepypastas that I know quite well especially Sally. Sally reminds me of myself.

[@davidgillum6356]

Please, please don’t leave Rebecca xx My husband and I love watching your daily video’s. I myself have cancer and I’m currently battling this dam disease. Seeing your smiley face and happy persona on a daily basis makes my day. But on a serious note, good luck Rebecca! Sending love and best wishes, David & Andrew Gillum-Campbell, Sunderland UK xx

[@lunarmist8330]

Ghostfox is my favorite creepy thing. It is about a demon fox in Wildcraft who havks and kills people. I am so weird, I know.

[@afa13829]

I love the perfect daughter, the sandman, the 11 mile ritual, and the staircase ritual creepypastas.

[@laurenbaldwin3216]

omg i love all of your outfits rebecca! so cute ❤️

[@glennl5375]

#1 reminds me of 'the dark forest' hypothesis. everyone's keeping their existence quiet so they don't get obliterated

[@RedChaoticRain]

My favorite creepypasta has been “Penpal”for a looong time

[@RedChaoticRain]

Thanks for the kind reply. Borrasca is also one of my favorites but I haven't heard of The New Fish so I’ll check that out.

[@greggrim4965]

@@RedChaoticRain Penpal is one of my favs if you like that check out "the showers"

[@emoboyzzz4life]

Yassss

[@RedChaoticRain]

@Greg Grim the showers is actually another fav of mine too!

[@emmathornley4745]

One of my favourite stories is "Both my parents were surgeons and I used to talk to furniture"

[@Ted_Bundy]

I bet you won’t pin me

[@rastarappa2269]

And she won't

[@Ted_Bundy]

I know

Polybius isn't a creepypasta, that legend stretches back decades.

[@simpjuice3103]

OMG YAAASSSSSSS

[@earlfrancart5687]

polybius was an urban legend long before this creepy pasta.. and it started back in 1978/79. i remember it quite well. people didnt disappear. but several people in their teens suddenly died of heart failure after playing it, and there were rumors that gov looking men would come and check on the machine, but that after the deaths the game was removed by these men. and never seen again

[@brettreeves4369]

Ov heard who’s got my “skinny” toe

[@martalover17]

I loved that story

[@Invalid-user13k]

Ooh Creepypasta. It is one of the heart and souls of the internet. Let's go and have more of these

[@tyrantmaxx8663]

I like 11 miles

[@deedeehodges7069]

Once there was an 11 year old girl. She was in the car with her godfather, and he had a massive heart attack behind the wheel. After his car wrecked due to his heart attack, the girl's mother got a phone call from a payphone at a hotel across the road from the site of the wreck. Nobody at that hotel knew the girl or her family.

[@alexstuby3185]

My favorite is laughing jack or smile dog.

[@Mr.Tw1sty]

What smile.doggo

[@Unknown-yy9kz]

Another underrated creepypasta is the one titled "Borrasca".

[@botanicalmink6797]

Petition to never sleep again 1 has signed let’s get to 100

[@itsmith14]

My my favorite creepypasta is mother’s call. About a girl who hears her mom call her to the kitchen, but when she starts going to see what she wants but her mom pulls her into a closet and tells her not to go in the kitchen because she heard the voice too

[@ernaasic5242]

Shout out please?:/

[@pokelynke8232]

My first creepypasta was Ben Drown... The first one I ever read I mean. I didn't sleep well or play games for weeks. I had no idea that creepypastas were just meant to be scary stories told around the campfire and were likely not true.

[@someoneworthit]

ok, that happy sun daycare one is now one of my new favorite stories

[@batsnghostz]

Ok but 10 thru 7 are underrated and good af. Finally one of the videos this channel makes is actually good