Top 10 Scenes Left OUT of the Harry Potter Movies

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Which aspect of the Wizarding World were you most disappointed didn't make it on screen?

[@robin3039]

All of them

[@funnythehaha]

@@robin3039 same

[@KikiSoccer50]

Peeves!

[@randomfandom5891]

Harry’s sass

[@AustraliaHungary27]

Peeves, or maybe Regulus’s backstory.

[@toriwilliams4170]

Honorable mentions: Lupin and Tonks' ENTIRE relationship, The REAL Ginny Weasley, Charlie Weasley, Percy showing up before the battle of Hogwarts, and "Have a biscuit Potter"

[@davidaltman3867]

you did see percy at the battle of hogwarts he was there when they all entered the great hall as harry confronted snape

[@emilymanfield7389]

"Did I mention ,minister? I'm resigning!" Lol iconic!

[@CookieCat712]

Yesssssss ‘have a biscuit potter’

[@Michelle-cl3fl]

Agreed! AND I know it's a small thing but for me it had a big impact, McGonnagalls scream when she see´s Hagrid carrying Harry

[@JadneParks]

Ginny took that last one.

[@jmerna0528]

The scene where Dobby wears ALL THE CLOTHES that Hermione leaves around the common room

[@dylanrich69]

Just more dobby in general we only got him in 2 movies while he was in all but 2 books

[@Loyyd420]

I needed more dobby 😭

[@rubyannen9501]

I have him as my wallpaper and every time I read a Dobby scene in the books my heart just melts. Whenever I get to his death scene, I cry like a baby.

[@lucianlawson-foley5967]

@@dylanrich69 THIS

[@janedowdle9614]

and the entire elf rights thing

[@Ryno_the_Dyno]

Harry and voldy’s very public final battle, where he keeps calling him ‘Tom’ and is so calm. So good!

[@ellie.b.e.]

Thank you! Plus the totally normal human death and corpse. So important for the characters and the healing of the magical world to know he’s completely dead. Not just mostly dead. (Bonus points if you understand _that_ fandom reference…)

[@AK_golden_rose]

@@ellie.b.e. Pls tell me you're talking about The Mortal Instruments

[@ellie.b.e.]

@@AK_golden_rose Ah, no... Princess Bride actually, of all things. But good guess!

[@AK_golden_rose]

@@ellie.b.e. Oh lol. It's been so long since I've watched it again

[@PerovNigma]

It would have been good if Voldemort died to an audience, but I think Harry and Voldemort standing and talking about the Elder Wand would have ground the pacing of that scene to a halt. Better for Harry to just sum it up to Ron and Hermione afterwards.

[@sevenseas4520]

“May I offer you a cough drop, Dolores?” - Minerva have-a-biscuit-Potter McGonagall Iconic.

[@littlemissfinch]

“You yelled at Umbridge?” “Yes, Professor.” “You called her a liar?” “Yes Professor.” You told her He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named is back?” “Yes Professor.” “Have a biscuit Potter.”

[@kaiasmith5404]

@@littlemissfinch I love this line

[@maureenfrancisco8999]

McGonagall is iconic

[@littlemissfinch]

@@maureenfrancisco8999 facts

[@CookieCat712]

‘WOULD YOU LIKE A COUGH DROP *DELORES*’ idk how to do italics on mobile

[@xxtkxxangelxx]

The fact that Hagrid says "Snape is one of the teachers protecting the stone" and then Snape's potion protection wasn't in there has always really bugged me.

[@littlepirat1]

Omg me too!

[@mryoungandbrave1]

same

[@azblueauthor8081]

When the Extended Edition was released I really hoped that the additional scene was the potion puzzle, and was sorely dissappointed when it was still missing, and even more so when I found out it was never even filmed. That puzzle was too important to just be omitted, both for Hermione's character development, and for Harry's.

[@arion1633]

Yeah, I realized it too when I was watching this video first time - like, so many things are left out from the movies so Top 10 doesn't really cover enough ground xD

[@satan6412]

Really! I wanted to see the purple flames and all of the interesting potion bottles! Besides, that room is the reason Hermione cant go with Harry to face Quirrel!

[@charliekicinski9536]

I was balling my eyes out when Dudley told Harry that he wasn’t a waste of space. That was just from the book. With their great acting it would have been the perfect scene of the franchise.

[@emilieshomegarden3677]

They really did a disservice to Dudley... especially since Harry Melling is such a delight, I think their departure, as done in the books, would’ve been great closure and redemption - really tugs on those heartstrings.... also the parts where Harry realizes there were several moments when he thought Dudley was sabotaging or torturing him, but actually trying to subtly help him

[@cheerio3442]

@@emilieshomegarden3677 And the deleted scene with Petunia, Dudley and Harry

[@sireeshareddy3100]

They actually filmed it but they cut it for some reason

[@joyitasen6571]

*deleted scene

[@lydiamv21]

@@emilieshomegarden3677 YES

[@switchglitch]

Sassy Harry was robbed. "There's no need to call me Sir, Professor." and "Gee I wonder what it would be like to have a difficult life." for example. Also the "Have a biscuit, Potter." scene.

[@chrisconcannon6490]

We didn't get that, but we did get Hermione telling Harry that Romilda Vane only likes him because she thinks he's the chosen one, and he replies, "But I am the chosen one".... and she proceeds to smack him on the head with her paper. I could watch that all day.

[@JosePhine-zw1gy]

My number 1 is still the have a biscuit scene

[@WilliamReginaldLucas]

Have a biscuit Potter

[@BournetoRead]

Also: “I’m listening to the news” “again?” “Yes, it changes every day you see” (I’m paraphrasing but the sentiment is the same)

[@chavitanwar2126]

@@chrisconcannon6490 that one is hilarious 😂😂😂😂

[@destroyerdoom1544]

The old title was: The films missed some stuff so here’s my petition to remake them from scratch

[@tommytigert5993]

And it was glorious

[@PorpoiseInATent]

the films missed stuff so sign my petition to remake them from scratch

[@hayleyanna4630]

AND I WAS ACTUALLY READY TO SIGN!!!

[@thefailedjedi4113]

I'll still sign

[@th3iris]

I clicked ready to sign. Lies, deception

[@arnulfoloredo1079]

The things I missed the most were: 1. Neville's parents and his character development (he grows in the movies, but still misses something) 2. Harry repairing his original wand with the elder wand. I almost cried reading how he used the most powerful wand in the word just to repair his own broken wand.

[@dragonivy4779]

Harry was very wise about this. Harry kept the cloak, but dropped the stone on purpose. and removed the wand from continuing to get people killed.

[@CRIMS0N_KING]

I think one of my favorite moments is when Peeves salutes the Twins as they leave Hogwarts. It's just such a great image!

[@HazySkies]

Ah yes, I loved that part ^-^ Right after when Fred and George were with Delores and basically did a "You can't fire us, we quit!" xD

[@Morgan932]

Another great peeves moment his song after the battle of Hogwarts :“we did it we bashed them,wee Potter the one and voldys gone moldy so let’s have fun”

[@SkeletronGames]

One of my favorite moments from the books

[@greattexanbluedragon2773]

YES IM NOT THE ONLY ONE I KNOW THAT SCENE BY HEART

[@jebpayne1710]

Voldemort duelling McGonagall, Kingsley and Slughorn all at once would of been an epic scene

[@Just_a-guy]

And Bellatrix doing 1vs3 fight as well

[@QenaitheCustodianGuard]

I wrote the same, the whole battle is lackluster imo.

[@khalilrahme5227]

@@QenaitheCustodianGuard there was way too much to cover, the movie version was an overview of the battle really

[@QenaitheCustodianGuard]

@@khalilrahme5227 yeah, still lackluster and boring.

[@liamhashmi7750]

I WANT

[@hayhaley8576]

When Nevill visits his parents and keeps the gum wrappers they give him. Cry forever.

[@kaileyforce8306]

The movies left out Ginny's entire personality and Harry's developing feelings for her and I'm still salty about it

[@Sophie-rh2gm]

Same 😠

[@mlg2466]

I was literally about to type this too, haha. Couldn't agree more tbh! It was ridiculous how much they missed/ relied on the viewers to have already read the books!

[@ColeConCon]

Same

[@davishawkins1528]

Came her to say this, honestly Ginny is one of the coolest characters in the books and I absolutely hate her in the movies.

[@annarushlau9722]

Saltier than the Dead Sea over here...

[@cadenedwards403]

You mean your favorite quote isn’t “Whatcha fall over for?”

[@Roll587]

I was looking for this!

[@chloeohalloran527]

Yeah thats what i was thinking

[@ameliaparis3222]

Or "prETTY OBvious"

[@Roll587]

@@ameliaparis3222 Lockhart?

[@littlemissfinch]

“I diDnT tRy tO”

[@KaitlynRiccio]

Remember when they left all the memories out of HBP but they found the time to burn down the burrow?

[@rubyannen9501]

My goodness, that was the worst usage of screen time ever in a movie. What about the Burrow in Deathly Hallows, did it just pop back up out of the ground? And wouldn’t Ron have stayed with his family if his house was fricking burned down? And not to mention him being the slightest bit worried about all his possessions and Pigwideon burning up? OH WAIT, PIG WASN’T IN THE MOVIES EITHER. Never mind, pardon me, but I’m gonna go read the books now.

[@popcultureodyssey4459]

They probably thought all the kiddies would get bored with the lack of action scenes

[@TV-ly3dp]

@@popcultureodyssey4459 They were right on that I haven't even finished HBP because it's soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo....ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo...ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Boring

[@MollytheHufflepuff]

I thought I was forgetting something from the books when that happened!!!!🤣🤣🤣

[@chevon1920]

I still don’t understand what the point of that was, lol 😂🤣

[@talawolf1491]

Mcgonagal’s career interview with Harry where Umbridge sat there arguing that Harry could never be allowed to be an auror and Mcgonagal standing up for him and basically saying Harry is amazing and can do anything. I love that scene in the book so much

[@david94606]

My very favourite chapter!

[@jstan626]

me too. and that 'competent teacher' has to be the best line in the entire series

[@jonahthrane812]

It was probably a mixture of McGonagall genuinely caring for Harry, and wanting to be against Umbridge no matter what.

[@hnnh621]

Harry Potter TV series: Each book is a season Each chapter is an episode BOOM

[@gabyward5855]

but then some episodes would be so much more boring than others

[@christracey5813]

Also the action oriented scenes would eat most of the budget and made for a bland Hogwarts. If the movies did one thing right is the atmospheric and environmental details.

[@Kenub927]

This would be perfect. And what’s good about streaming services is that a short chapter could just be a shorter episode. They don’t have to drag it out.

[@littlemissfinch]

@@Kenub927 exactly. Like they did in the movies, they changed up the setup for most scenes to shorten the movies’ length.

[@CorraThaxton]

Like what Netflix has been doing with 'A Series of Unfortunate Events'.

[@Kelarys]

They cut my favourite line in the series, when Luna is commentating the quidditch match: "I don't think that'll help him find the Snitch, but maybe it's a clever ruse..."

[@sunybaudelaire6074]

And Ginny Weasley- she's very nice I like her

[@MegaGandalf12]

And Loser's Lurgy 😂

[@sarahdominguez3452]

One of my absolute favorite scenes is when Harry and Dumbledore are alone in his office immediately following Sirius's death. When Harry begins screaming and breaking the items nearby, all the while Dumbledore just lets him rage, it just feels so real and raw. I cannot read that without tearing up myself. I do also like the conversation that follows with Nearly Headless Nick regarding loss. Ugh, breaks my heart.

[@RobertFerro3]

Yes, Ootp Harry really gets too much hate for being a traumatized teenager

[@sarahdominguez3452]

@@RobertFerro3 yesss I 100% agree. Poor Harry had already gone through so much, and quite literally just watched his classmate die in front of him in the previous book. I'd say he's allowed some angst lol

[@vianeyboruel504]

Yess just yess

[@pabloarango6945]

This..

[@MollytheHufflepuff]

This is true.

[@leadingblind1629]

- The fake dementor at the quidditch match. The whole scene - Harry's grief stricken tantrum in OotP. -Dumbledore's hero vs prophecy speech - Molly's greatest fear - professor mcgonagall vs Umbridge in her office

[@jonasreich3607]

Kreachers tale

[@Mark_Goddin]

All of this. Amazing. Shame it wasn’t shown.

[@cheesedoodle7]

i think it would have been good to include Harry's First encounter with Draco when buying his robes.

[@90BabyLove09]

Oh yes! Molly's greatest fear adds so much to the scene where Arther was actually attacked. It sets the true fear of him might not surviving.

[@killerkitten7534]

“Do you need a cough drop Delores?” -McGonagall gangster moment

[@charleswaldon8362]

Harry's childhood home, when the sign grows out and say the potter home left in its destroyed state...

[@BlairKillgallon]

Just all of the little moments that were left out of the Battle of Hogwarts. Percy literally falling out of the tunnel from The Hog’s Head, finding himself in a room with the majority of his family and Remus’ wildly desperate attempts to defuse the tension by waving a picture of Teddy under everybody’s noses. Grawp straight up throwing Hagrid and Fang trough a window because he was told to “drop them somewhere near the castle” Sir Cagodan charging through the portraits after Harry, shouting encouragement. Neville’s grandmother being the last one to arrive for the fight. Harry actually witnessing Fred’s death. Peeves dropping Snargaluff pods on the Death Eater’s heads. Trelawney cracking Greyback over the head with a crystal ball. Grawp wrestling with another giant on the lawns in front of the castle. Luna, Ernie and Seamus using the Patronses that Harry taught them to produce to save him from Dementors. The centaurs being shamed into action by Hagrid. Kreacher leading the House-elves into battle.

[@rubyannen9501]

They should have made a whole Deathly Hallows Part Three just for these scenes. I don’t really ever watch the movies anymore because they are nothing compared to the books.

[@jeanettemclaughlin4296]

Yes. A TV series would allow for a rendition that is absolutely faithful to the books.

[@patriciamurphy8307]

They really did Kreachers character dirty in the movies

[@SabaKhan-zp5of]

fred death as well and romiones real first kiss

[@larabremer197]

HARRY AND VOLDEMORT DUELING INFRONT OF EVERYBODY. HARRY EXPLAINING EVERYTHING TO VOLDEMORT. VOLDEMORT ACTUALLY DYING AS A REAL HUMAN BEING BECAUSE IN THE END HE WAS NO DIFFERENT THAN ANYBODY ELSE. I’m so mad, still. They could have done all of that but instead they chose "Let’s finish this the way we started it - together!" an all of that flying-bullsh*t. I’m so. So. SO. mad.

[@devonxyzz]

I'd say Neville being the other 'chosen one' and the prophecy in detail...

[@allisonreilly1952]

I was so mad watching the OoTP movie the first time!!!

[@OkGoGirl82]

Came to say the same thing.

[@Velldog]

Grogu is the chosen one.

[@breadley5159]

No, he isnt because he wasn't marked.

[@skippingalong769]

@@breadley5159 True, but he did take out a horcrux.

[@Narnianerin]

When Peeves saluted to Fred and George Weasley, that was one epic moment! Also I always loved how the teachers showed Harry support like when Flitwick gave him sweets and rushed away and Professor Sprout gave him twenty points for handing something to her

[@cheerio3442]

"screw umbridge, harry potter's _always_ been a star student"

[@davidstone4826]

Neville: "Thank, Mum." Me: crying like a baby

[@littlemissfinch]

“ ‘Very nice to have met you all. Neville, put that wrapper in the bin, she must have given you enough of them to paper your bedroom by now. . . .’ But as they left, Harry was sure he saw Neville slip the wrapper in his pocket. The door closed behind them.”

[@blazeisonfire]

😭

[@cugelchannel4733]

I had a moment like that with my own mother who was suffering from end stage Alzheimers, and I can testify that it's incredibly powerful emotionally. Leaving that out of the movies just destroys all understanding of Neville's motivation and character arc and every reason why he ultimately becomes the most important hero of the books other than the 3 when he confronts Voldemort, draws the sword of Griffendor from the hat and kills Nagini, just because Harry told him to.

[@heatherann9548]

I mean, can you even call it “Snape’s Worst Memory” if you cut out the part that makes it his worst memory?

[@maraudentium2607]

You can if you want to basically assassinate the characters from the books and reinvent them...RIP Hermione, Ron, Harry, Ginny, Snape, Hagrid, James, etc...

[@HPFan4Life81]

it was in the movie look it up on youtube its 23s long

[@hyperhare0624]

TESTIFY. TESTIFY. TESTIFY. (continues chant)

[@ivywisesea2918]

Tbh I thought Snape’s worst memory would be seeing Lily’s dead body, but ok J.K.

[@HPFan4Life81]

@@ivywisesea2918 so being bullyed an then calling your best friend who camed help you a mudblood isnt good enough?

[@marcusgross9395]

the fact that none of the good guys were harmed after Harry sacrificed himself to Moldy Voldy , protecting them with with the same old magic as his mom protected him.

[@salemsmushroom]

I hate that they left out the scene from the end of book 3 when Sirius give Harry the signature he had been wanting the whole movie. it just shows how wonderful their relationship is from the start and it always makes me cry when i read it.

[@MaybeMable111]

Yes, Sirius and Harry's relationship was pretty much wholly left out of the movies. So sad!

[@zohabaig6426]

“You asked a question and she knew the answer! Why did you ask if you didn’t want to be told?” Is my favorite book quote that they left out.

[@bhavanibhardwaj7464]

Romione >>>>

[@zohabaig6426]

@@bhavanibhardwaj7464 the elite ship

[@udaygadge6064]

Can’t believe they replaced that with he’s got a point you know 🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

[@zohabaig6426]

@@udaygadge6064 ikr! Makes me so mad

[@SabaKhan-zp5of]

@@udaygadge6064 ikr thats the complete oposite

[@Kenub927]

And that’s why a Netflix/HBO series with one episode per chapter - Seven seasons, would be amazing and solve all these issues.

[@mztatin955]

Yessssssssssss

[@megumie0ka]

Not really sure about that. 'Cause they will be changing the cast now and that may seem a bit odd knowing how great the casting in the movies are (Atleast most of them).

[@Kenub927]

@@megumie0ka HA!

[@megumie0ka]

@@Kenub927 :D

[@soniccookie655]

They’d do a lot better, I think.

[@deanm7848]

I wished "Have a biscuit Potter" was in the movies! It was totally McGonagall and they left it out! Smh

[@Okay_Is_Wonderful]

^This! Always here for more badass McGonagall

[@jessicapolson7762]

YES

[@Mark_Goddin]

It was such a kind and motherly gesture. And exactly what Harry needed at the moment. She didn’t punish him for stating first-hand experienced facts, but validated his feelings while also teaching him in a subtle way about politics, what not to say when in the wrong company.

[@killerkitten7534]

‘Is it true that you shouted at Professor Umbridge?’ ‘Yes,’ said Harry. ‘You called her a liar?’ ‘Yes.’ ‘You told her He Who Must Not Be Named is back?’ ‘Yes.’ Professor McGonagall sat down behind her desk, frowning at Harry. Then she said, ‘Have a biscuit, Potter.’ ‘Have - what?’ ‘Have a biscuit,’ she repeated

[@Olga_Sittidae]

I was soooo sure it was it the movie as well. Watched them gazylion times, but as Ben said, it's blurred together

[@killerkitten7534]

Things I missed the most: -St Mungo’s visit in book 5. Seriously, that scene with Neville and the gum wrapper actually made me start crying when I read it. -Percy leaving his family, and his subsequent return. Seriously that should have definitely been added. -You mentioned it, but the part where Dudley apologizes to Harry, but also when Dumbledore basically calls out the Dursleys for mistreating both Dudley and Harry which sort of gets Dudley to really start realizing how screwed up his parents were for their favoritism. Tbh in my opinion books 4-6 should have also been split into 2 parts each. There’s just way too much that was left out.

[@katywolffis7678]

Yes! Percy leaving the fam was a huge plot point in the books and a magnificent scene in 7 when he returns to fight.

[@BournetoRead]

Wholeheartedly agree with Neville’s parents scene. I loved the treatment of Neville in OotP tbf but nothing beats that scene where he puts the sweet wrapper in his pocket :’(

[@christracey5813]

They did Film Dudley's apology to Harry but for some reason cut it out.

[@foxforpeace7351]

I also missed the scene in which Dumbledore comes down on the Dursleys. Given what Harry had been through at their hands, it’s amazing that he didn’t suffer from PTSD.

[@mr.bonabo8664]

I think the scene with Nevilles parents should definitely have been in the movies. That makes his character have way more depth than what we got in the movies

[@the_real_boogeyman]

I was so mad when they didn't put Kreacher's character arc in the movies. That was one of my favorite parts of the books. The fact that I can't remember the specifics enrages me and makes me feel like I need to re-read all of the books immediately.

[@acousticluver88]

The part where Kreacher leads all the hogwarts house elves into the battle in book 7 in the name of Regulus Black and is wearing his locket

[@kisamangaluvr21]

I loved the scene they added to DH (later deleted) when Petunia says “you didn’t just lose a mother that day. I lost a sister.” It was the resolution her character needed

[@maraudentium2607]

Eh, the “witch” got what she deserved. I don’t need sympathy for another child abuser.

[@Just_a-guy]

@@maraudentium2607 maybe their hate harry and were that bad for him because they had to live with horxrucs like Ron in 7th

[@maraudentium2607]

@@Just_a-guy read the first chapter of the first book...

[@Just_a-guy]

@Ezra Cohen Why not? This chanel try to convince u that dumbledore had a horcrux :D

[@kisamangaluvr21]

@@maraudentium2607 I absolutely agree that her actions were despicable and unforgivable. I just liked the extra dimension we got for her character in that scene. In the same way that Tom Riddle is pure evil but learning about his difficult upbringing (in HBP) helps us understand him better.

[@GBunnyG]

"It unscrews the other way" is literally my favorite line from the series. Also, I wanted to scream with rage when Harry broke the elder wand without fixing his own wand. Rage. Flames on the side of my face.

[@Jake-fq6ir]

Dumbledore's funeral

[@aldenc1219]

Yup

[@Parker_DNDnerd]

SEETHING. SEETHING FIRE

[@aldenc1219]

@@Parker_DNDnerd Logan from sander sides

[@mysteryshrimp]

My worst "scream internally" moment from the movies is Harry doing freaking magic under his covers.

[@shahancheong9792]

Another scene they should've filmed: "The Other Minister" from D.H. I would love to have seen that.

[@alexbiersner3350]

They should've added the scene where Harry tells Neville about Nagini and that if Harry should die, Neville should help Ron and Hermione finish the mission

[@ugolomb]

Yes, and that should have been there *instead* of his just-about telling Ron and Hermione where he's going and why. That wasn't in the book, but not just omitted -- the book tells us, in a way, why Harry has chosen *not* to do that.

[@soniiabaybee]

Exactly this. How would Neville had known to specifically use the sword. They should have kept him in

[@SomeYouTubeGuy]

Except Harry never said "If I should die" He simply told Neville how important it was the snake was killed.

[@ugolomb]

@@SomeKZbinGuy You're right. More than that: he actually lied to Neville (the word "lie" appears in the text) about where he's going and why, thereby hiding the fact that he intended to die. Neville probably did believe Harry was risking his life, but only to the same extent as all of them (including Neville himself) were.

[@larabremer197]

Tbh the whole moment when Harry understands and accepts that he has to die. I know you can’t picture how he lays on the ground and he feels his heart strangely intense and how he doesn’t WANT to die because he really likes living, but I just looove that atmosphere created in the book. It’s like he’s walking in a trance, how he sees Ron and Hermione, how some people bring in the dead body of Colin Creevey and all of that. I wished they would have tried to create this atmosphere. I hate that he talks to Hermione and Ron. They KNOW what he’s about to do and they would NEVER have let him go.

[@carab3317]

"...and Dumbledore said calmly..." Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

[@hermionethatsme]

This comment deserves more likes!

[@emilieshomegarden3677]

Every time I see that scene I’m like “it reads ‘calmly’ - not shouts angrily!” Lol

[@bobdole4916]

@@emilieshomegarden3677 I've seen that actor in other stuff, and it's pretty obvious he's a dang good actor, but every element of how he went about performing the role of Dumbledore just didn't work. When Richard Harris died, and Michael Gambon got the role, he made a deliberate choice to not perform the role the same way Richard Harris did - so right off the bat we've got a completely different Dumbledore who is so different it knocks you out of the film a bit. And the other major thing he did was refusing to read the books. So, you've got an actor hired to perform a role who refuses to use the performance of the previous actor as inspiration, and refuses to read the source material for inspiration. Is it any wonder that he feels nothing like Dumbledore?

[@nicecute1221]

I swear, this calmly thing for harry potter's fans is much worse than GOT last season for GOT's fans 😂😂

[@slevinchannel7589]

I wanna be brutally honest: Every single of these Directors are total Buffoone people should constantly make fun of. Contrary to common believe; a believe that is simply wrong; its in fact not 'just' Movie 4 and maybe 6 who are 'Lost in Adaptation'. No, its almost 9... and more than 7... if you can guess that numbr. Changes as flippy-di-dippi-di-dumb as making Dormstrang Men-only are to find in the whole Franchise and you cant give those Jokes-of-a-Director enough Criticism for this.

[@mythics102]

Oh I SOBBED at the Saint Mungo-Neville’s parents scene in the books, but I also liked how they had Neville tell the story in the movies and when he says “I’m proud to be their son” 🥺

[@missathepandabear]

I really missed Draco opening up to Moaning Myrtle, that really helped with his redemption and it shows he has other emotions than just anger. I was really disappointed that didnt make it to the movies

[@Hannah_Riddle]

Oh yeah

[@peterkoester7358]

Top missing scene: Who the Marauders were that created the Map.

[@reneecoons5057]

Yes! I hadn't read the books when I saw that movie and I was so confused. My boyfriend (now husband) had to explain who they were.

[@Seenic69]

Yeessssssss annnndd that harrys father can turn into a stag. I don’t remember if they mention that his father was animagus... all i remember is that his expectopetronum is a stag

[@peterkoester7358]

@@Seenic69 If the creators of the Map had been explained in the movie, it would have contained the explanation that James Potter was an animagus that could transform into a stag because the Marauder names were based on the animals each could turn into. Moony = werewolf, Wormtail = rat, Padfoot = dog, and Prongs = stag.

[@tea.5643]

"Wormtail, Moony, Padfoot and Prongs" were in the movie, but JUST the names.

[@DarthWinterMadness]

That was one of the most disappointing things about the movies to me, The Marauders. That's what made me less interested in the movies afterwards, and the next one (GoF) was the last I saw in a theater as it was even more disappointing. I have seen the other movies but can't remember them since I was so disinterested. The Marauders' backstory was my favorite part of the third book, and I wish they didn't leave it in the sidelines. Anyways, I probably will rewatch the movies with a better mindset and judge them from what they are and not what I wanted them to be in the past. Cheers from France! 🍻

[@sup9894]

The Marauders completely, Ron being the best friend and Ginny being brave and strong, and each one that you named make for a complete remake of the movies

[@windhelmguard5295]

also the weaslys are supposed to have hair so red it looks like their heads are on fire. in the movies they're just ginger.

[@SabaKhan-zp5of]

and hermione not being perfect and absolutely beautiful

[@cam1152]

Ben: I have read the Harry Potter books, A LOT Also Ben: And watched the movies, ALSO A LOT Me: in the first 15 seconds of the video, SAMEEEEE

[@winnie7922]

I’ve never read a book twice, or even a passage at school. I’m deciding if I want to reread a book, and if I do it will be Harry Potter.

[@alyssaharris9809]

ME TOO Not even kidding though, I have read each book at least 8 times and seen the movies more than that

[@stickpawsos2441]

Ive only watched 3 of the movies but I have read the books a lot

[@shirakrause8160]

I relate to you so much right now

[@algorithmhelper262]

@@winnie7922 let Jim Dale do it for you. I've listened to him read each book dozens of times.

[@o.k3841]

Harry destroying Dumbledore's office in OOTP... That was such a raw, emotional moment...

[@cheerio3442]

Yeah, I didnt understand it when i read it for the first time since i was nine but its so raw and emotional, I feel like Harry didn't even get an ounce of satisfaction from it since it can just be fixed with magic

[@helenaperez4343]

This. This is the cut that makes me the most upset out of all 8 movies. It’s such a powerful scene in the books, as Harry is finally able to let all of his emotions out, and get the answers he was desiring for a year, and the movie… just has a 2 or so minute long scene where Dumbledore kinda-sorta explains a few things. Such a disappointing loss.

[@AlvaroCapalbo]

This. It's my favorite scene in the whole series, and the reason why OotP is my favorite book in them. I understand they needed more time and budget for that incredible duel but it still hurts.

[@SquaredJunior23]

The number one reason why OoTP is the best book is Harry's emotions. I read this book as a teenager around his age, and couldn't believe how expertly Rowling injected 15 year old boy emotions into her writing. I felt that book on a deeper level. The whole 4-8 movies were trash in how much they left out, but Harry's emotional development was the biggest loss

[@hannalulu2350]

On the Peeves topic, the scene where he salutes the twins is one of my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE parts in ALL the books and I was soooooo disappointed that it wasn't included

[@markleal16]

I've always HATED the final battle. We miss Voldemort's outburst at Bellatrix dying. We miss the circling and exposition. We miss him dying a mortal death. Listening to this scene in the audiobooks gives me such chills and I was so disappointed when it was portrayed so terribly.

[@BladedArcher]

My absolute most hated part of the battle is how it was supposed to be in The Great Hall, with Voldemort literally dueling 3 of the best from the Order at the same time, and still somehow barely breaking a sweat up until Bellatrix dies, and then the outburst.

[@harryjohnson1633]

All the Reinforcements charging up the gates and overwhelming the death eaters

[@laurahudson8210]

Yeah. They really screwed up the final battle.

[@brookehaney8782]

Not only did they not include Harry yelling at Remus about leaving Tonks, but didn’t they also not include her pregnancy announcement, or even Harry being named Teddy’s godfather?

[@kaileyforce8306]

YES!!! I need all of the Remus and Teddy Lupin content

[@OppositeofHATE7]

I think it is mentioned briefly in passing, it may be the deleted battle scene where Tonks says she left Teddy sleeping at his grandparent's. Which makes it sad when you see them later dead

[@MakeshiftMelody]

I did a movie marathon with a friend a couple years back who had only seen the movies and she didn't even know that they had a kid at all because its not a thing in the movies 🙈

[@lampekartoffel]

If I remember correctly, they only kinda allude to them being in a relationship in the movies and suddenly you're supposed to care that they are laying dead together after the battle - I hadn't read the last 2 og 3 books before watching the movies because I wanted to find them all in English and read them in the original language instead, so I was confused 😅

[@bluestickystuff1184]

I think Harry still has the line ‘Remus, your son’ in the forest when they’ve been brought back with the resurrection stone which makes no sense since nothing about that has been set up

[@michaelcardini2865]

2 things that always drove me crazy: 1. Cutting Percy's apology at the Battle of Hogwarts completed his story arc and it was wasted with him just sitting with the family after the battle. 2. Dumbledore not performing the Body Binding Curse on Harry at the Battle of the Astronomy Tower. It completely changed the Harry Potter character. In the movie he just stood there and watched Dumbledore die like a punk rather that being immobilized and unable to help even though he tried.

[@kurtreznor]

"that's not what his friends call him, that's what HE calls him." So...that IS what his friends call him.

[@landyncb8751]

😳

[@Gremlin_moops_art]

Ooooof

[@bamabry]

Burn

[@oliviabeal9481]

Thats deep man....

[@BournetoRead]

No I’m pretty sure you have to like your friends

[@oligb1469]

Mad Eye moody assaulting some bins would have been a legendary scene really drive in the "Mad".

[@omgitsrayrayz]

I remember being so confused watching the scene where the death eaters set the Weasly's house on fire and then just dipping, not making any difference in the plot

[@JessicaSmith-mb9pv]

IKR, it was 20 minutes wasted, that could’ve had more of voldys past in the pensive

[@punaisebelkanaal6813]

The Tonks and Lupin love story! Especially that scene in ‘The Halfblood Prince’ after the battle, where Tonks tells Remus that she wants to be with him! MY HEART 😱

[@kelli3814]

My favorite line ever that was left out of the movies: “There’s no need to call me sir, Professor.”

[@princess_mj4396]

this is my favourite line too its tied with the i understand what a nicknnam is

[@kelli3814]

@@princess_mj4396 and “Have a biscuit Potter.”

[@aaronhurst4379]

I haven't read any of the books in over 10 years, but I still remember Harry and Lupin's argument in the Deathly Hallows clearly as day, such an emotional scene indeed

[@hm-pu1ui]

I need the marauders backstory explained in movies. It's literally one of the most interesting things in the series

[@viam14]

Agreed! I'm still holding out hope that post-Fantastic Beasts movies they'll make a Marauders limited series???

[@johndrotos8987]

IKR!! I recently rewatched the third movie and I was waiting for Lupin to explain how he knew it was a map when he gives the marauders map back to Harry but he never does! It would have taken 30 seconds to explain who the marauders were and it adds so much depth to the whole series.

[@viam14]

@@johndrotos8987 Y'know, I honestly forgot that he never explains that! There's so many book scenes/facts so ingrained in my Harry Potter database that I forget what the movies lack

[@jineenmansour]

the movies werent about them so why would they be included? even if we wanted to know more about them

[@aceofspades9503]

Also I think the movies never explain that James turned into a stag, and that's why Harry's Patronus is a stag.

[@nicoleb581]

"What was the fourth movie even about?!? How could it miss so many plot points?!?" she asked calmly.

[@kaiwillbekai3764]

Honerable mentions; Teddy Lupin, Charlie Weasley, the true Ginny, Remus and Tonks’ relationship at all, the death day party, I could go on for a while

[@Grivian]

- "I'm not worried Harry, I'm with you" - Kreachers tale - Snapes worst memory - An accurate portrayal of the first task - An accurate portrayal of the third task - Harry and Ginnys first kiss - Voldemorts backstory - People witnessing Harry and Voldemorts final battle - "To think that the man who taught me a patronus, a coward" - "I want to tell him to trust his instincts, because they are almost always right" - "Will you be godfather?" - A good explanation of the marauders in POA To name a few

[@rolandverde8771]

The dumbledore line is in a deleted scene i think

[@mailyak442]

Omg yes Harry and Voldemort’s final battle! What was that in the movies 😂🙄

[@user-rs3po6ol8p]

I totally agree with this!!!

[@MaybeMable111]

To add the to the GoF mess: How amazingly kind Cedric actually was 😭😭 He was a typical jock for the most part in the movies who only was nice to Harry to return the favor. In reality, his kindness only rivaled Luna's and Lupin's in the books. Like how he caught the snitch in his match against Harry in PoA because Harry fell 50 ft because of the dementors, and how he immediately started calling for his own catch to be unfair because of what happened to Harry. Or when he was the one of only kind ones to Harry after his name got drawn too (which would obviously took away some of his own glory since he wasn't the only Hogwarts champion). Or when Harry basically pleaded with Cedric to take the Cup, but realized the only way he could convince Cedric to take it was to share the glory (because Cedric had endless excuses why Harry deserved it more, even though he was actually about to be first).

[@vianeyboruel504]

Agreed Cedric exemplifies the qualities of a true hufflepuff as harry does his houses qualities

[@jonahthrane812]

Good example, Cedric from the books death hit me harder than in the movie, because I actually really liked him in the books, he was exceptionally nice, and him dying hurt more while reading. But his fathers cries in the movie, that was a very emotional scene and very well acted.

[@MaybeMable111]

@@jonahthrane812 Yes, his dad's reaction was incredibly heartbreaking!

[@theresemartin7930]

I was looking forward to seeing the Weasleys share the minister's box. It's kind of a crucial scene because it's where we meet Winky and find out she serves the Crouch family. Why did they change it?

[@oliviabeal9481]

I really wanted to see more of the Weasley Twins pranks! Especially when they left the school and the pond on the stairs was funny.

[@AchmelvichIsAce]

Percy's story line, Ginny and Harry actually having a relationship (not just a few awkward moments), Tonks as an awesome character, History of Magic classes, Firenze teaching divination...so so many in addition to all the excellent points made in this video

[@SabaKhan-zp5of]

pevves too

[@mattrobinson4663]

I'm rereading the books as an adult now and just finished OotP, does Tonks really grow as a character in the last two books? She's mostly just a clumsy nuisance to Molly in OotP.

[@Jake0666]

The history of magic and Firenze teaching r both so pointless to add to the movie so there’s no reason to

[@Caroline-jl2us]

I'm with you, Ben! So many moments, so many!!! 50% of GoF, including that scene where Harry realizes the Weasley family came as his family before the 3rd task. Plus, the Howler sent to Petunia

[@A_Stray_Child]

“I wanna see Harry be smart.” I think everyone does. 🥸

[@TheDanishGuyReviews]

I have one l haven't seen anyone mention: Hagrid's backstory. It's one of the moments that stuck with me as a kid. Grawp, his Dad, the mission with Olympe. Little Hagrid moments of coolness scattered throughout the books, too, like slamming Karkaroff against a tree for thinking Dumbledore is a nutter. More Hagrid, dang it! (Also: Scourgify! If you know, you know.)

[@makakowsky7042]

Mmmmm, soap 🙊

[@SabaKhan-zp5of]

the fight umbridge attacking hagriid for being half breed and hagrid no teven being hurt and umbridge getting stressed mcgonagall standing up for hagrid

[@SeraphimCramer]

I never liked that they had Harry break the Elder Wand not just 'cos he hadn't used it to repair his wand yet, but also because the book implies it should've been unbreakable.

[@kaiasmith5404]

It doesn’t fully fit yet it is the kind of thing he would do

[@charlesbrowning9748]

I didn't like that harry didn't use the elder wand to repair Hogwarts and then break it.

[@acethedrifter1201]

Harry does break the elder wand in the book after he repairs his wand tho

[@SeraphimCramer]

@@acethedrifter1201 No he doesn't. He puts it back in Dumbledore's tomb. He says "I'm going to put this back where it belongs. If I die a natural death, the wand's power will be broken."

[@acethedrifter1201]

@@SeraphimCramer ok my bad one of those things where the books blend into the movies in my memory lol I reread the last chapter and saw I was wrong lol whoops

[@robinjohnson9611]

Dumbledore's funeral, especially with the centaurs giving tribute. Grawp* needed more screen time...

[@royalpain9281]

I can kinda get why Grawp wasn’t in the movie much he would be to expensive to even be sitting there

[@cheerio3442]

The mermaid tribute, the centaur tribute, it was beautiful

[@KittenSprite]

@@royalpain9281 He was, he was in OOTP when hagrid introduced him.

[@dr521]

- “It is night, Diddykins. That’s what we call it when it goes all dark like this.” -Harry exploring Diagon Alley in POA. -Harry getting birthday cards for the first time ever in POA and actually enjoying his birthday. -Fred and George knowing “Muggle tricks” like picking locks to break Harry out in COS. - “We know we’re called Gred and Forge” -Ron and Hermione being prefects and having extra prefect duties. Harry upset that it wasn’t him but being a good friend. -everything with the Firebolt in POA. Wood flipping out at McGonagall. -Trelawney and McGonagall’s rivalry especially at Christmas dinner in POA. McGonagall being even more of a legend in general. -Hermione and Krum being “pen pals” -History of Magic classes. -Ginny reminding Harry that she’s the only one who’s been possessed by Voldemort. And Harry thinking he’s possessed in general after St. Mungo’s. -Phineas Nigellus Black -The Muggle Prime Minister -generally just regular classes and regular days that just make you happy because it’s Hogwarts and regular days at Hogwarts are the best and they’re just happy being the trio.

[@jenniferwettervik4495]

Yesssss all of this 👏

[@noemilaszlo7771]

Omg Harry and Voldemorts face to face "dance of words" in a circle, before the final "expelliarmus". My favourite scene of all time

[@YaeliEz]

I was hoping one of these will be “Ginny being awesome”, they didn’t even give Bonnie a chance...

[@dank6129]

10 out of 9 times this is my answer as well. Ginny is my favorite character in the books when she gets the chance to shine.

[@phtuber5469]

Thats what ive been telling people all this time, its not Bonnies fault, it was the writing. People need to acknowledge this.

[@MaybeMable111]

Yes, I think Bonnie would have done phenomenal as who Ginny was supposed to be! If only they didn't make her mega awkward.

[@johnyshadow]

Yes! More awesome Ginny! I can´t remember, but was that scene where Ginny wins the quidditch cup as a seeker, and Harry kisses her in front of everyone, in the movies? (I don´t think it was...)

[@MaybeMable111]

@@johnyshadow Yes! That was such a good first kiss for Harry and Ginny! The one in the movie was the terribly awkward one in the Room of Requirement where she hid the book while he closed his eyes, they she came back and kissed him. So cringy haha 😅

[@bradleyboger456]

I wish the mini "battle of hogwarts" at the end of the Half-Blood Prince, where Bill Weasly got bitten and attack by Greyback

[@walky2]

I remember, I watched the movie 6 premier (show started at midnight) with a friend of mine, and we were furious after, how they screw up the end. We called other friends who watched it in another cinema just to ventillate.

[@annarushlau9722]

Battle of the Astronomy Tower! I KNOW

[@MaybeMable111]

Yes! And it was replaced in screentime in the movie with that terrible scene where the Death Eaters attacked the Burrow instead. They had all of the right characters in that scene for the one that was supposed to happen, so why not make it actually happen at Hogwarts?? Oh, and Ginny was MEGA awkward in that scene, and her choice to dangerously run into the brush after him was a bit random and not set up.

[@mai_cool_beanzz5109]

Yeah and as much as I ship wolfstar I also kinda like remus/tonks and that scene in the hospital is just so pure (idk if I’m using the right words)

[@e.m.2230]

yes! and the scene where bill is in the hospital wing and fleur and molly become on good terms when fleur says that she’s good looking enough for both her and bill, proving to molly that she’s not just in love with bill for his looks! that was one of my favourite scenes in the hbp book and i was so upset that it didn’t make the movie and they just introduced bill’s scar out of nowhere and with no backstory in the deathly hallows!

[@carterkohler7271]

The fact that they never say that Umbridge sent the dementors before she is taken away by the centaurs has ALWAYS infuriated me. Like that's a HUGE plot hole ?!?

[@keriiluv]

that’s the best video title i’ve seen in a while edit: i clicked when the title was “the films missed stuff so sign my petition to remake them from scratch”

[@dominikac.5506]

I can't believe you didn't mention Trelawney telling Harry that it was Snape who overheard the prophecy. This detail is so important...

[@dominikac.5506]

@SAM STROMBERG But Trelawney told Harry that Snape interrupted her job interview with Dumbledore. And Harry made the connection himself. So yes, I know that Trelawney does NOT know about the prophecy but she still tells him about Snape.

[@chavitanwar2126]

@SAM STROMBERG TRELAWNEY DOESN'T EVEN REMEMBER MAKING A PROPHECY!!!!!!!

[@chavitanwar2126]

@SAM STROMBERG I know but I thought it should be even more emphasized on

[@armadillolover99]

I think even if they included this scene, it would've gone over most movie-only people's heads and I'm sure that was what they were thinking "most people won't notice or care so let's try to use that time for something else"

[@slevinchannel7589]

Hi, magical stranger! I'm currently gathering people for a good Cause. Basically and summarized: sharing Links leading to bad people, so the good can report/flag the bad. Simple, right? (Well, its not that simple, but whatever...) I dont wanna seem like i try to persuade you to join some club or somethin', so i just drop some links and hope you do the right thing! kzbin.info/door/PkzNt6_5HCsI1NEwmt1ycQabout -Cybermobbing. kzbin.info/door/kfx4FiFG8HX31dDKnnVkUAabout -Slightly insulting brat. kzbin.info/door/g1jrDwUVFVj489Wwa77cbwabout -Repeated Heavy Insults. kzbin.infoabout -Extreme Insult-Rants, sometimes over 100 Words long! Really intense stuff, like „r%%% mothers“. kzbin.info/door/tsDNGgF54yKLaV5yeCvIAgabout -EXTREME Insults, again, also about hurting mothers left and right. A Psycho. kzbin.infoabout -Hey! Someone who actually got deleted! Shows that it sure can work. Hope exists. Either way; have a wonderful day at Hogwarts! And DO NOT go into the Forest alone!

[@agnetebutk]

The moments in Chamber where it looked like Ginny wanted to tell what was happening to her but didn't get the chance to speak

[@anneliesv.7441]

Harry and Ginny's relationship; man, did they swing a miss on that one

[@slevinchannel7589]

Hi, magical stranger! I'm currently gathering people for a good Cause. Basically and summarized: sharing Links leading to bad people, so the good can report/flag the bad. Simple, right? (Well, its not that simple, but whatever...) I dont wanna seem like i try to persuade you to join some club or somethin', so i just drop some links and hope you do the right thing! kzbin.info/door/PkzNt6_5HCsI1NEwmt1ycQabout -Cybermobbing. kzbin.info/door/kfx4FiFG8HX31dDKnnVkUAabout -Slightly insulting brat. kzbin.info/door/g1jrDwUVFVj489Wwa77cbwabout -Repeated Heavy Insults. kzbin.infoabout -Extreme Insult-Rants, sometimes over 100 Words long! Really intense stuff, like „r%%% mothers“. kzbin.info/door/tsDNGgF54yKLaV5yeCvIAgabout -EXTREME Insults, again, also about hurting mothers left and right. A Psycho. kzbin.infoabout -Hey! Someone who actually got deleted! Shows that it sure can work. Hope exists. Either way; have a wonderful day at Hogwarts! And DO NOT go into the Forest alone!

[@sambhavchugh1958]

Ron being actually helpful. They butchered his character in the movies

[@maraudentium2607]

Butchered a lot of characters when you get down to it...they made Hagrid an illiterate buffoon, they made Ginny into a wet sock, Harry was made into a bit of an idiot too, Hermione is a Mary Sue in the movies, etc...

[@slevinchannel7589]

@@maraudentium2607 I agree with all you just said in your comment, but allow me to go off-topic from that: Hi, magical stranger! I'm currently gathering people for a good Cause. Basically and summarized: sharing Links leading to bad people, so the good can report/flag the bad. Simple, right? (Well, its not that simple, but whatever...) I dont wanna seem like i try to persuade you to join some club or somethin', so i just drop some links and hope you do the right thing! kzbin.info/door/PkzNt6_5HCsI1NEwmt1ycQabout -Cybermobbing. kzbin.info/door/kfx4FiFG8HX31dDKnnVkUAabout -Slightly insulting brat. kzbin.info/door/g1jrDwUVFVj489Wwa77cbwabout -Repeated Heavy Insults. kzbin.infoabout -Extreme Insult-Rants, sometimes over 100 Words long! Really intense stuff, like „r%%% mothers“. kzbin.info/door/tsDNGgF54yKLaV5yeCvIAgabout -EXTREME Insults, again, also about hurting mothers left and right. A Psycho. kzbin.infoabout -Hey! Someone who actually got deleted! Shows that it sure can work. Hope exists. Either way; have a wonderful day at Hogwarts! And DO NOT go into the Forest alone!

[@yousucks2222]

They butchered almost all the weasleys

[@TV-ly3dp]

@@yousucks2222 The only one's that weren't butchered were Aurther Weasley Molly Gred and Forge (Fred and George) like why us Ron just an annoying person (I know he's not but he is annoying as heck in Goblet of Fire) Where is Charlie

[@audreybosak679]

@@yousucks2222 BUT FRED AND GEORGE STILL ROCKS

[@Beefbeff]

Whole of Ginny's personality. That's number one for me. The whole reason Harry falls for her.

[@samuelgeranton2644]

I really wish they showed the wesley's coming as harry's parents before the maze in the goblet of fire

[@franzkissel1369]

Yeah, that was a really heartwarming moment.

[@luthientinuviel3883]

The Weasleys really got the shaft in general which sucks because they were perfectly cast.

[@allis_o2628]

-More development on Tonks/Lupin, because they freaking shoehorned everything about that in, including Teddy. - the destruction everybody tried to cause Umbridge, including Mcgonagalls sass. - Molly giving Harry a watch on his seventeenth birthday. -Lupin and Sirius giving the whole backstory to the Marauders in POA. They just skimmed trough all of that in the movie to.

[@SlidellRobotics]

Yes, especially that it was her brother's watch, and Harry's reaction. He's officially a member of the family. It also foreshadows when Harry gives Kreacher Regulus' locket, which they also left out as it was the beginning of Kreacher's redemption arc.

[@Girasse]

Yes, I would have loved to see Lee Jordan put the nifflers in her office and the portable swamp the twins set off that Flitwick could have easily gotten rid of but instead watched Umbridge struggle to remove it for weeks.

[@SabaKhan-zp5of]

mcgonagall vs umbridge was amazing

[@lisaandothers]

@@Girasse and Flitwick eventually cleaning up the swamp save for a small part that he purposely leaves as tribute to the twins

[@cjg8763]

I was always disappointed that the Gaunts were not included in Half Blood Prince. I was looking really forward to that scene.

[@Jurtaani]

I would have loved to see the journey and the interactions with the giants, when Hagrid and Maxime were trying to ask giants to come to their side.

[@robin3039]

Who was here when the tittle was “the films missed stuff so sign my petition to make then again from scratch” 😂

[@stickpawsos2441]

That was on the notification, guess I tapped too slowly

[@eacgaming9806]

Me

[@aldenc1219]

Was here just in time

[@aldenc1219]

@@stickpawsos2441 same

[@riduanaqil1452]

Its in my notification

[@miguelmrusso]

My favorite scene left out was when Umbridge had then just read in class and Hermione one ups her by having read it all and knowing it well enough to asnwer all her questions. That moment of hard work and wit defeating autority was amazing!

[@eirikastokes9652]

The BIG one I want is Harry's explosion of grief and rage at the end of Order of the Phoenix.

[@imqqmi]

The scene of Harry having to catch the garden gnomes at the Weaslys as main family event. Just a bit of 'normal' wizarding everyday life would've been great. The letter from Lily and James to Sirius Black, seeing baby Potter on a small broom zooming around the livingroom. Confrontation of Harry with Remus Lupin about getting together with Tonks, being guardian to the unborn child etc. Very telling of the kind of character Harry had and what relationships he had.

[@cheerio3442]

i wouldve loved a novel about simply living at hogwarts, the conversations over breakfast and frustration over magic and homework, though if there wasnt a conflict it would be bland. little moments of everyday hogwarts and wizarding life is my favorite thing

[@user-rs3po6ol8p]

I honesty wish that J.K Rowling would have made a Maraueders Book just because it would have been nice to have an extra book explaining them.

[@kristiethefairy8594]

"wadiwasi" "if you know,you know" never been more proud of myself for knowing that reference!

[@aathisankar6432]

It's like the in Malayalam, adiwasi, which means jungle people

[@erindavies211]

@@aathisankar6432 Tribal people.

[@aathisankar6432]

@@erindavies211 I just didn't got the word😊😊

[@kristiethefairy8594]

@@aathisankar6432 looool

[@Hannah_Riddle]

Yeah bc the J vs Ben Lupins quiz

[@norakropp_]

“the films missed stuff so sign my petition to remake them from scratch 🤩”

[@copito42]

Then Clicked on and I was Dissopointed

[@brandi3981]

i absolutely would

[@projecteer4498]

How about a series instead so we don't end up with 4h long movies and can keep all the information in!

[@chevon1920]

I would love an animated version of it so they wouldn’t have to worry about budget too much.

[@chevon1920]

@@projecteer4498 yes, that would be good too like his dark materials or game of thrones.

[@thecartoongirl22]

A scene that I really loved was the scene in The Goblet of Fire where Harry got trapped on the stairs under the invisibility cloak and Peeves is yelling with Moody (Crouch Jr.) and Snape talking, Moody(Crouch Jr.) helps cover up that Harry was out at night. Good scene! Also, Anything with Charlie Weesley and Dragons will be very much missed!

[@soybean9373]

" 'I knew Ginny was lying about you have a tattoo' Ron said looking at the bair chest" sadly isn't in the movie

[@90BabyLove09]

Yes! Also, "She asked if you really had a tattoo of a hippogriff, I told her it was a horntail."

[@markomandaric4786]

It is in the movie.. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Zn3KcoeentB_erM

[@monicabowen6204]

The whole speech scene in deathly hallows BEFORE he repairs his holly wand

[@Bookbee09]

Ben: ''She Makes Bartey Crouch senior seem way more sus... Am I using that correctly?'' Me: Yes Ben you are using sus correctly

[@kelbichristina]

i just wanna talk about them leaving out harry and ginny's entire relationship. like all their best moments just arent there and instead we just get awkwardness

[@MEG4nerd]

This feels like a temporary title....but sure I will sign

[@seaweedbrain1930]

what was it when you right the comment

[@unicornilluminati9019]

Hey op what was the title

[@luv_lynnie]

Yesssss

[@jaycobobob]

@@seaweedbrain1930 the movies left out some stuff so sign my petition to remake them all

[@dejabradragon3790]

@@seaweedbrain1930 “the movies missed things so sign my petition to remake them”

[@lexipainter2183]

I needed the best part in the books of all time... Fred and George What r we neighbors in Order of the Pheniox when Molly says sum along the lines of now everyone in the family has been a prefect when Ron gets the badge when everyone thought Harry would get it and this is self explanatory GINNY!!!!!

[@jasozilux3791]

Harry Potter fans: THEY LEFT OUT MY FAVORITE SCENE FROM THE BOOKS! Percy Jackson fans: oh really? Tell me more...

[@Mary_Studios]

Haha yes we get to compain that they messed up the plot in the first one and then as a result had to deal with the mess for the second one.

[@evlovesbooks]

I was an idiot when I decided to watch the second movie

[@robinsuj]

The only thing the movies and the books had in common were the names and some of the setting. The movie "reads" like bad fanfiction

[@despicablepenguin]

@@robinsuj it's like they skimmed through the book took the characters and settings, threw the book away and made an entirely new story. It's like filling in mad libs

[@despicablepenguin]

THAT'S WHAT I WAS GOING TO SAY! Just watching this video I'm like, mhm. Yep. Just keep talking Ben.

[@MoreThan7Digits]

I thought ben’s favorite line was “What you fell over for?”

[@pinkajou656]

WHATCHA FALL OVER FOR

[@sanchitipatil]

I wished the last fight in great hall with that dialogue between Harry and voldy should have been included!!

[@laurahudson8210]

THIS

[@PerovNigma]

I would have loved to see them fight before an audience, but I think conversing about the Elder Wand would have killed the pacing of the scene. Better to have Harry summarise to Ron and Hermione afterwards.