Top 24 Dynasty Rookie Rankings Tier List (POST NFL DRAFT)

Top 24 Dynasty Rookie Rankings Tier List (POST NFL DRAFT)
Danny and Bush are back with their consensus Top 24 Rookie Rankings in the tier list format you all know and love. The duo go through each player in the tiers, paints the picture of what they do well and need to improve on as a prospect, and ultimately provides a blueprint to the valuations these guys should have in the context of startup drafts this offseason!
Timestamps:
00:00 Intro
00:35 1st Round Startup Guys
06:21 2nd-3rd Round Startup Guys
17:41 4th-5th Round Startup Guys
27:00 6th-8th Round Startup Guys
44:36 9th-10th Round Startup Guys
54:34 Round 10+ Startup Guys
COME DRAFT WITH US
play.underdogfantasy.com/p-fa...
Using Promo Code: "FSE" at first deposit and signup will get you a 100% deposit matchback up to $100 - minimum $10 deposit
DYNASTY ROOKIE DRAFT GUIDE LIVE NOW:
FlockFantasy.com/FSE - for 30% off any packages
Get 7 Days Free
Signup annually to get 6 months free
Code "FSE" and an Annual signup gets you a free zoom consult!
SUBMIT YOUR TEAM FOR DYNASTY DECISIONS
forms.gle/YjgXsjQntkCwsaA87
FANTASY STOCK EXCHANGE SHOW SPONSORS & PARTNERS
1. Official Fantasy Sports Partner - underdogfantasy.com/register?... using code FSE will get you 100% back up to $100 & Our Weekly Start/SIt Rankings for Free!
2. aura.com/fantasystockexchange to get a free 14 day trial for the best and only cybersecurity tool you'll need
3. Head to Manscaped.com & Use promo code "BUSH" for 20% off + Free shipping!
4. To Get Pro Bettors Sports Picks - bit.ly/ElitzPickzFSE
Use this link for a 7 day free trial & start winning!
5. mintmobile.com/fantasystockex... and get premium wireless for as low as $15 a month today!
FOLLOW US ON TIKTOK:
www.tiktok.com/@fantasystocke...
BOOK A PERSONALIZED FANTASY FOOTBALL CONSULTATION:
forms.gle/8Ym6ZVxyduJAX6ki6
FOLLOW US ON TWITTER
/ dannyfootball59
/ footballstock
Fantasy Stock Exchange Twitter: / fantasystockex
PODCAST VERSION:
APPLE: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/45YpJod...
GOOGLE: www.google.com/podcasts?feed=...
For Business inquiries: [e-mail]
#FantasyFootball #fantasystockexchange

[@FantasyStockExchange]

DYNASTY ROOKIE DRAFT GUIDE LIVE NOW: FlockFantasy.com/FSE - for 30% off any packages Get 7 Days Free Signup annually to get 6 months free Code "FSE" and an Annual signup gets you a free zoom consult!

[@Brothdiener]

So happy the real draft went the way it did for my 1.11, 1.12, 2.01, 2.02 picks in a SF as a rebuilding team!

[@FantasyStockExchange]

I bet!

[@123shoshan]

@@FantasyStockExchange Adonai Mitchell is hundred times better than Keon Coleman this pick made no sense

[@Judoyo13]

He's actually got like no chance at production bro. Pittman and Downs are better target earners and Arich isn't an accurate thrower. Coleman goes in as the #2 target earner with Josh Allen, a top QB.

[@Dylan_zzzzz]

I have the 1.08 and am debating Bowers/Thomas/Worthy. My best TE in 0.5 TEP I’d Friermuth. And a stacked at WR with Chase, Garrett Wilson, Aiyuk, Higgins, Gabe Davis, Mike Williams, etc. in this build do I take Bowers at 1.08?

[@matthewsheyfilms6157]

If its an 8 team league do the wrs move up drastically?

[@MisterBeastMode]

Have the 2.08 and 2.10 who should i be looking at??

[@SuperGriffin84]

I have the 1.07 in my 1QB league and it's looking like Bowers, Brooks, Benson, Williams range will be available. I'm a competitive team with depth. Would you recommend sticking and picking, or I have an offer of 2.08 or Nick Chubb with the 2.11 and a 26 1st.

[@jacobculp9723]

You’re competitive now. 26 is awhile away I’d just pick someone who helps now.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Keep the pick unless you get an offer u can’t refuse

[@NATED0DOUBLEG652]

Need some opinions, I have 2.09 currently. Pearsall and Polk are available, who do I take?

[@FantasyStockExchange]

I would take Polk but they're virtually the same, early career production favors Polk slightly

[@dickcheeseaccumulator7325]

Pearsall, even though he has target competition, he’s a freak athlete and great route runner and he has good coaching. Right now, I’d prefer Pearsall

[@tylerhebner2417]

10 team dynasty Sf, I have 1.01 and 2.01 this year with TLaw and Deshaun Watson at QB. Tee, Ridley, Olave, Schultz/Njoku, Addison, Marquise Brown, Jeudy. 3WR 2Flex. What do I do?

[@sportsdude856]

I’ve gotten Nabers at 1.07 in 2 different drafts and I couldn’t be happier 😂🤩

[@MikeyCoinSnatch]

Whatttttt 😂

[@GaugeS00]

I have a superflex rookie draft coming up in a couple days and keep going back and forth with worthy or BTJ not sure which way to go

[@FantasyStockExchange]

I prefer Worthy, Danny's on BTJ for me Worthy is the better option because he should see the field sooner and has less competition for targets at WR especially if Rice is suspended a few games & because he's tethered to Mahomes that early career production could really skyrocket his value

[@GaugeS00]

@@FantasyStockExchange I also have mahomes in that league so that stack is really enticing. Thank you for the input!

[@brockduncan2269]

@@GaugeS00if you have mahomes I would heavily lean towards Worthy

[@antonioromero7940]

Should i take worthy over bowers? I have rashee and hollywood already, but I also have Kincaid so im kind of torn.

[@aaronw4526]

Gotta get the best value and go with Bowers. I might be in the same position during my next draft. I’m a Kincaid owner and have 1.07. If Bowers is the best available I’m going with him

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Difficult, I'd say you're right on the fringe with Kincaid, I'd explore trading down a few spots

[@kevinblue1976]

Nutted landing spots as expected for the mid tier WRs gonna be a fun season

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Yesssir!

[@123shoshan]

@@FantasyStockExchange Adonai Mitchell is hundred times better than Keon Coleman

[@henrymuto1417]

Would you trade picks 8 and 12 for pick 2 in a 1 QB 1.5 TE PPR league ?

[@FantasyStockExchange]

In a 1QB, go and get Marvin imo, you're basically giving up one of the top RBs/Ladd + Coleman or the QBs or Legette for almost a sure thing like MHJ

[@kingjabree]

Love the content fellas 🔥 10 sf start 11 got offered Justin fields and Hollywood for a 2025 2nd the 309 and the 305 this year. My qbs are Kyler and burrow the 2nd is an extra I have.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

don't mind taking the shot there on Fields if you like him

[@MT-UK]

What about if you have Hurts & Murray at QB in a superflex and you hold 1.01, 1.07 and 1.10 & 1.11 but your best WR is only Nico? Still go for Caleb ?

[@OhSknapp11]

Came out of my draft with Nabers, Odunze, Brooks, and Polk. Really feels like I had the best draft of my league

[@FantasyStockExchange]

That's a great haul!

[@Miscreant777]

Does a 10 man league affect where you'd put JJ? I'm likely deciding between JJ and Worthy. There isn't quite the QB shortage when you're in a 10 man league, but they're still very valuable. If too many of these qbs hit though I might not actually have a buyer for jj next year

[@-alostsoul-6902]

My rookie draft just finished today, 1QB non TE premium. I already have a very good team without many needs, had picks 1.11 and 2.10. They always say when everyone else zigs its time to zag, and WRs were flying off. So I took Benson at 11 and J.Wright 2.10 to add to my already stacked RB farm. Then i bought back into the 4th round twice with future late 3rds to scoop up Penix Jr. at 4.05 and A.Estime at 4.08. My RBs now include Bijan, Etienne, Monty, Benson, Wright, Mostert, K.Miller, Roschon, Allgeier and Estime lol

[@henrymuto1417]

I am starting 5 FFPC rookie drafts today (All 1 QB). In 1 of them I have picks 1.01, 1.07, 2.01. I took Harrison of course at 1.01. Well I just took your advise I took Worthy at 1.07 even though I don't see it with this kid at 165 lbs. I don't want another D-Jax so I am hoping he is more like Tyreek then D-Jax. I was leaning Brian Thomas at 7 but he went 6th. So my 1st pick of they year were I was unsure what to do I went with your advise took your #5 ranked guy (in 1 QB leagues).

[@andrewbracht7939]

Our rookie draft is a bid format. Who would be your top 3-4 targets to address needs for this win-now team? QB: TLaw, Fields, D Jones, Carr 🤮 RB: JT, Saquon, Swift, Javonte, Dowdle 💪 WR: JJ, AJB, DJM, Aiyuk, Ridley, Sutton, Downs, Dotson, J Palmer 🔥 TE: Pitts, Njoku ✅ 2-PPR, SF, non TEP, 6 point passing TD. Start three flex, 10-team league. I’m thinking it’s just all QB… Grab as many as I can… very aggressive bids… haven’t been able to address through trades… The other thought was BTJ for the TLaw stack… or Nabers…

[@kittehninja999]

I have the 1.10 and the 1.12. I have an offer to give those away for the 1.06 and 3.01. I have great WRs. 2 Qb league, need someone for future with geno as 2nd QB. Kelce and Ferguson at TE, need depth RB too. Loaded stuff, any advice?

[@evan2323.]

Stroud or Caleb? 6pptd. Might be able to stack Caleb with rome. Need response asap Pls!

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Stroud

[@evan2323.]

@@FantasyStockExchange thanks!

[@arwarn89]

I have the 1.01 and 1.05 in a SF. Should I take Williams and Odunze or MHJ and Daniels? Current QBs are Lawrence, Richardson, Levis. WRs are Olave, Pittman, Moore, Addison, Reed.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

In you're spot I'd be fine taking Williams and Odunze, but try and sell that Daniels pick on the clock and see if u can slide to 1.06/1.07 and get Odunze there

[@arwarn89]

@@FantasyStockExchange My TEs are Kmet, Shultz, and Otten. If I go Williams/Odunze that’d give me 4 Bears. Should I be concerned about Chicago overload on my potential roster?

[@achyuthakomarlu4539]

Where would Kyler rank in your guys rankings in startup drafts?

[@andrewmirage8572]

1QB. Would you trade 2.5 and 2027 1st for 1.12?

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Probably not, to me there's not a huge difference between those picks at all

[@mattgloor1837]

1QB non TEP. Team is rebuilding and have picks 2, 3, 7 and 9. I was offered 7 and 9 for pick 4. So then I’d go Nabers, Rome and Bowers. It’s start 8. This a smash? Or use picks 7 and 9. Thanks guys!!

[@alshiram6484]

Is the 1.10 too early for a guy like keon coleman? I also have the 2.3

[@FantasyStockExchange]

I'd hope he falls to you at 2.3, can't pass on Worthy, Bthomas, Ladd or Nix for him

[@BrianDBacon]

Oh boy Here we go again

[@FantasyStockExchange]

🍿🍿

[@curtismurray3128]

Picked nabers and maye at 1.04 1.05, JJ was surprisingly at the 1.10 and the brooks and Mitchell at the 2.04 2.05. Traded JJ, mitchell and a future 3rd for Odunze and Keenan Allen. Have Murray, stroud, Lawrence, and maye at QB so figured it made sense to do

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Love those moves!

[@markwapinskiii5736]

Javon Baker might be better than Polk in their rookie years. He's a better value, you can get him later

[@codyatterbury5796]

Man I am on the clock with the 1.06 and I also own the 1.08..it’s SF so Maye, JJ, and Odunze are left. I need to walk away with Odunze preferably…is it dumb to punt on the QB choice and grab Odunze and take whichever QB is left? I already have Stroud, Herbert, Caleb…

[@benroche3408]

Drafting in a startup rn, Drafted BT as wr21, worthy wr32, legette wr39, pearsall wr40 and Polk wr50. Heavy on rookies bc honestly the value is just too good. Bo nix qb27, Brooks rb17 and Lloyd rb27. I think these dynasty rankings are criminal tbh rn

[@FantasyStockExchange]

I don't think any of those values are outrageous, other than Lloyd RB27 I don't really disagree with any of em

[@polandk2]

To get s Caleb and Rome stack in your rookie draft sounds amazing to me

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Yessir!

[@Theodoredarling]

Is this non TE premium

[@Widmurder]

So here’s a unique question for you In a 12 team, start 9 ppr. RBs get 1.5 ppr, and Tes get 1.3 ppr. I have the 1.08/9/10/11 I have mark Andrews and Chig at TE My initial thoughts are XW, BTJ, Ladd, and brooks…. But I’m unsure about letting bowers go over any of those guys. But also benson with the rb premium. And my QBs are stroud, Watson, Rodgers…. And sounds like nix and Penix will be on the board……

[@chriscash9493]

10 team start 10 SF full ppr .5 Te premium 6 point per pass TD start 1 QB 2 RB 2 WR 3 Flex 1 W/T 1 SF so not required to start a TE. Is Caleb still the 1.01? I have the 1.01 1.05 and 1.07 and I’m pretty sure nabers will fall to me at 1.05 and jj or maye will be there at 1.07. My team is qb : Kirk Geno D.Jones Minshew AOC so I know I need an upgrade at qb but could I get by with having JJ Chase Addison Kupp Dhop Dionte and kincad. I’m tempted to take Marv and nabers and worry about qb at 1.07 bc I have qb depth

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Caleb, you need a headliner at QB

[@codysmith5051]

What if you need a QB and WR?🤣 I took over an orphan that had rb1 - jamaal williams, wr1 - Jeudy and qb1 - DeShaun... two years ago. I have picked up Breece and Bijan last 2 years but best wr i could pick up was Nico and Josh Downs. Tua is the current QB1. Do I take MHJ or Caleb 1.01? No super flex

[@lg1886]

I have Murray and burrow .. I’m going with mvh and nabers with 1&2

[@aaronw4526]

Grabbed Benson at 2.04, Legette at 2.10 and Wright at 3.10. Happy with the value I got on all of those, especially Wright.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Very good value!

[@TylerBrown-zc5pt]

had 1 2 3 6 11 in the first, ended up with Williams MHj Maye Daniels and Brooks, could have gotten Ladd at 11 but couldn’t pass on Brooks

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Great haul! I would've been okay passing on Brooks for Ladd but definitely solid regardless!

[@RockyDyno]

Traded AD Mitchell and a 2025 2nd for Malachi Corley and Calvin Ridley

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Meh, if you love Ridley that's a fine move

[@RockyDyno]

@@FantasyStockExchange I definitely like him more than AD!

[@Jacksealmufc]

In the dynasty superflex startup 10 team ppr im in drake maye fell to me all the way to the 7th round! People really dont like the spot 😂😂 For context daniels went in the 3rd round and jj mccarthy in the 6th

[@FantasyStockExchange]

What in tarnation

[@crockbo]

1QB, 10 team, 2.01 No idea who to target

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Likely looking at one of those WRs (Coleman, Legette) or maybe the RBs Brooks or Benson slip to you Assuming that Marvin, Nabers, Odunze, Bowers, Worthy, BTJ, Ladd + Caleb are all gone

[@bt2084]

who do you guys see as a potential bust that ppl have been hyping up?

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Jayden Daniels, Brian Thomas Jr, Adonai Mitchell, Jonathon Brooks could be volatile due to the injury, Penix would be my picks

[@KingzGambitt]

Where does Bowers go in a 10 team 2 point TE premium?

[@FantasyStockExchange]

I would rank him around the 1.05-1.07 range in that format

[@bigboi301slg]

Drake Maye is definitely the faller here, I've consistently seen him go 1.06 and as low as 1.09

[@FantasyStockExchange]

That's mental, he shouldn't be going any lower than 1.05 imo

[@Rommie26]

Why do you have pearsall so low? He hit a lot of your metrics in previous video and plus the niners know how to scout talent

[@FantasyStockExchange]

He's low simply due to the class being so good + year 1 value would be a concern knowing Deebo and Aiyuk likely stay for 1 more year

[@jacobculp9723]

I already have Kyler and Herbert I’m going nabers at 1.03. I’ll grab jj at 1.08

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Great plan!

[@alshiram6484]

See if the team with the 1.04 needs a qb. If he does then swap with him and pick up a small add on top

[@123shoshan]

Adonai Mitchell is better than all those guys

[@daniel-ym9un]

Raiders will probably draft a top tier rookie QB next draft. Then you have an elite TE paired with a potential elite QB. He isn't tied to Minshew forever.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Absolutely, just happens that he's in a rookie class with 4 top 10 QBs with good landing spots and 3 absolute stud WRs - him being available at 1.08 is a great value sure, but not like I can really take him any higher

[@daniel-ym9un]

@@FantasyStockExchange after this rookie draft in my 1 QB league I'll be sitting with Herbert, Bijan, Pacheco, Marvin, Nabers, Bowers, Nico and another flex spot. Should be pretty set for years, after replacing Pacheco. Also hoping to get Brooks and Benson with my 1.08 and 2.01. Already locked down the 1.01 in 25 too, got the 1st from absolute worst team in the league.

[@DrewSorensenMusic]

Jayden Daniels is last years Heisman winner. Can throw dimes and run. You are out of your F’ING mind. Having Maye over him.

[@parkerphelps5202]

He’s also a 5th year senior who was throwing to two 1st round WRs and had never broken 3k yards prior to this year. Maye put up 4,300 yds as a sophomore with Josh Downs as his best WR

[@FantasyStockExchange]

He's a great option and no issues taking him 1.03 if you love him but for me I will pass for Maye and Nabers because those two are superstar prospects, we did the research, watched the film and came to that conclusion but of course the rushing production could still burn me hence why 1.05 is the floor

[@richardcheese9152]

Just got offered my 1.03 for 1.08 and Josh Jacobs. Also have 1.02 and 1.10. Only RB that is startable is JT

[@daniel-ym9un]

Keep the 1.03, and draft Benson or Brooks with your 1.10.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Not a terrible offer but tbh I'd rather sell that 1.03 for one of the big 3 if you're looking to get some RB production, 1.08 is like a 6th round startup pick + Jacobs about the same for a 1.03 pick that's a top 24 dynasty asset, not enough imo

[@richardcheese9152]

@daniel-ym9un that's what I'm thinking. I countered by offering him 1.03, 1.10, and 2.02 for Jefferson and Jacobs lol. When he inevitably declines, I was planning on doing exactly what you said. I also have Kyler and Burrow so at 1.02&3 I'm going Marv and Nabers and then will take RB1 with the 1.10 and probably RB2 with the 2.02 as well if things fall right

[@richardcheese9152]

@@FantasyStockExchange yep. Gonna do my due diligence as well on moving that 1.03 for one of the big 3 like you said, it's just so tempting to go Marv and Nabers at 2 and 3 and have a WR core of Chase, Wilson, London, Marv, and Nabers

[@daniel-ym9un]

@@richardcheese9152 could go with Marvin and Nabers and try to trade London for Jacobs.

[@grimly-ji1ef]

12 team ppr SF no TEP, Nabers or Aiyuk and TJ Hock

[@tcwheeler3978]

Brock Bowers to the Jets eh? Saved them receipts.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

We all wanted it lol

[@jontayebrown6865]

Brooks is supposed to be healthy by camp

[@FantasyStockExchange]

I'm sure he is, but we know RBs can struggle post ACL still and we have no prior information in the NFL of Brooks' talent level so if he doesn't quite look as explosive year 1 it would be concerning for his value

[@Prob1017]

I’m not a JJ fan at all, but let’s be real as long as he tied to the Viking offense (Jefferson specifically) he will have insulated value for 3 years.

[@FantasyStockExchange]

Exactly, i think he’s good but even if you don’t, so much time to sell given the situation

[@onGod_B92]

Sorry, I saw you replied back to me on one of your last videos, yes our 10 man dynasty league is full of “degenerates” lol football fanatics. Off-season leaves us all itching for more

[@FantasyStockExchange]

All of us are degens

[@onGod_B92]

@@FantasyStockExchange there’s way worse out there to be addicted to is how I look at it

[@dickcheeseaccumulator7325]

Let’s gooo!

[@FantasyStockExchange]

😈😈