Top 24 Dynasty Rookie Rankings & Tiers (Updated 2024)

[@Dynastyflock]

Checkout the new prospect database here : flockfantasy.com/flock

[@dful1201]

We are so back

[@Dynastyflock]

Will be uploading more often now, doing a bunch of research & working on the site a ton right now

[@johntighe3081]

I’ve been refreshing flocks feed like the fiend that I am, I guess back to back championships will do that 🫡😎

[@KylerRi]

I’m still taking Nabers higher but BTJ is absolutely in the same tier. There’s arguments for both.

[@Thatfantasyfootballchick]

I’m to the moon with Nabers he’s wr3 for me I have BTJ #7 and a tier below. But I could certainly see the argument for BTJ

[@slime8646]

Honestly the ONLY reason I’m not as high on btj is because when Christian Kirk and engram come back there will be more competition, but he’s talented enough still to put up crazy numbers either way.

[@boychris1947]

congrats you said nothing

[@slime8646]

@@boychris1947 Unc, all I’m saying is that there’s a valid reason why btj ain’t in the same tier as nabers

[@mathieu3778]

@@slime8646 kirk who?

[@grantgunst6143]

Bo is a year and a half older than Caleb, big whoop. He outperformed all the rookie qbs in throwing statistics, can clearly run the ball himself too, and broke rookie QB records…To not even have him as the same tier as the other 2 above is insane. Plus, given quarterbacks last forever, the Bo hate is just weird at this point lol. Penix is the same age and only played 3 games against trash teams, yet is 1 spot behind Nix. Make that make sense Mason…I like your content but you’re clearly missing the mark here.

[@cam8503]

@@grantgunst6143 what rookie records did he break

[@bigt5096]

What rookie records did he break?

[@TheRealJRealer]

@@cam8503Most passing touchdowns by any rookie QB in history at home

[@cam8503]

@ that’s it?Lol you said records with an S. Not to mention 5 of those came from the chiefs backups last game of the season. Not saying he’s bad but come on now

[@loganstull7687]

That Bucky take kills me, let’s give him all the credit then goes on to shit on him. The proof is in the pudding, he literally outpaced White in every metric. You’re the same guy that told us to stay away from him. Not saying he’s a Bijan or Gibbs but why would the bucs ever bring in another RB when they still have white on his rookie deal and can roll them both. Brain dead take imo, but you’re the expert that we should all listen to.

[@Thatfantasyfootballchick]

Also the Bucs were last in rushing in the league two straight years - one year with him and they are top 5

[@Heartattackhero]

Yeah some of his takes are shit. Bucky was def one. Having McMillan as low as he does is bad. If Godwin leaves, McMillan fills that wr 2 role nicely with evans.

[@tylerlesnick1736]

Bucs aren’t drafting a rb either lmao our draft gonna be straight defense

[@tylerlesnick1736]

@@Heartattackheroeven if he doesn’t leave Mcmillian has value

[@Bxnes5]

Yeah, I’m about done watching these guys for dynasty. Some of the worst flip flopping for rage clicks/comments.

[@FNPraise]

We missed you Mason

[@cam8503]

The Ladd undervalue is crazy. If he was a black Wr from LSU, he’d be talked about being the next big thing.

[@treycobb6262]

That’s fine if people think this way. I’ll buy him for these prices easily

[@cam8503]

@ absolutely. I mean the things they say just don’t even make sense. He’s only 9 months older than Harrison Jr, yet he’s too old of a prospect. Or he had no target competition…like Harrison or BT are in the same scenario. I don’t get it, but like you said I’ll be keeping my stock

[@shrekfan6945]

This ranking combines the profile coming and the first rookie year. If we’re being honest, MHJ was a wayyyyy better prospect coming out and had about 900 yards 8 tds vs Ladd’s 1100 and 7 tds. IMO it’s completely fair based on where MHJ was a prospect.

[@robshighlights6431]

Anyone else from this class had a 190 receiving game this year? Playoffs no less. Absolutely an WR1 for dynasty

[@MikeBrown-n2d]

Yea but he’s a white boy in a black dominate sport. Not saying he’s bad but his ceiling is definitely capped. Stay away from the Athletic position white boys they are not playing the same game on the same level facts.

[@MrGaryBarnett]

I think Tracy and Bucky will both have productive seasons next year. I was actually trying to tank in dynasty this year, but bucky kept putting up monster games.

[@BenParthenais]

Daniels should 100% be a top 3 startup pick

[@gallusgaming7430]

Top 3 is a bit steep. Lamar, Allen, Burrow, maybe Mahomes all have locked down jobs

[@Dynastyflock]

He's there in my rankings

[@mjbtics9459]

@@gallusgaming7430 I agree with you besides Mahomes. He is definitely a better real life QB then fantasy.

[@Thatfantasyfootballchick]

@@gallusgaming7430I’d take him 3 over Burrow - the rushing upside is just too much. I’d still do Burrow over Hurts though

[@NYJetsForLife2024]

I see you put mcmillan up there but didnt say anything about him, i feel like hes worked his way up between that E and F Tier the guy was averaging 20 PPR points a game the last 5-6 weeks of the season his trajectory is up hes working into that godwin role

[@tylerlesnick1736]

Dude has no knowledge about the Bucs. They are not drafting a rb with the defense being the way it is.

[@NYJetsForLife2024]

@@tylerlesnick1736 their defense needs a ton of help one of my best friends is a die hard bucs fan so I know their defense is weak also they allow so many points scored

[@tylerlesnick1736]

@@NYJetsForLife2024 the Mcmillian disrespect was wild too. But it’s ok buy from the people who don’t know.

[@NYJetsForLife2024]

@ drafted him at the 2.12 in 1qb, but fucked up passed on Irving shouldve drafted Irving first than Mcmillan at the 3.5 but whatever haha

[@kevinjones9974]

You overlooked Coker. His future is brighter than most people realize. I'd have him ranked somewhere in the teens on this list.

[@alexspears700]

BTJ is 3 or 4

[@DanisonDJ]

I had 1.3 and 1.4 this year and drafted Malik Nabers and Brock Bowers. I have zero regrets.

[@tommcneill6292]

Bucky Irving deserves C tier for sure. Dude is a special runner.

[@chaseomelia9956]

The Bo Nix ranking in insane. He should at least be in the B tier. Even in the back of it.

[@jasonallen1712]

Precisely

[@jeremypearlman1090]

Jalen McMillan missing?

[@Dynastyflock]

You're right. I have him ranked on the site top 24. No idea why I accidentally left him off here.

[@kylewojciechowski4998]

Respect the takes but bowers is absolutely S tier, like dude was TE1, record breaking all pro 1st team and is 21, pls tell me how he could’ve done any better/improved

[@AUSTYN_1]

Thanks as always! Great content

[@nicholaspreston4417]

You’re giving Bo Nix NO respect! Made the playoffs with a weak supporting cast, WAY better than Caleb and better stats than Maye. This is criminal negligence

[@Thatfantasyfootballchick]

I invested heavily In this class and they actually contributed a lot to my best fantasy season ever I loved loved loved Nabers 16/24 shares, Tracy 12/24 (selling), I got BTJ at 8/24, Bucky 8./24my regrets were I passed on Ladd and I did have more Caleb then Jayden I won 6 titles, 5 2nds, and 6 3rds. I only had 3 teams miss they the playoffs

[@gagers618]

Been waiting for this video. Won at 10-3 after going 3-10 last year, ready to cook this offseason

[@Sweatydogwater]

missed u man

[@Apolitically-Correct]

I was the biggest Ladd Stan, but I don’t see him continuing to make up that much of the team’s production going forward.

[@CJStew06]

Probably true, but if the offense's volume production can raise as a whole, his raw totals can still increase

[@Apolitically-Correct]

My question is, are you knocking down doors trying to sell high on Ladd? Or do you think he’s a cornerstone asset going forward? Also, would you sell tracy at market or above in leagues where you’re desperate for a rb? Or just hold?

[@benjaminweinberg3812]

I have nabers, Daniels, bowers, Bucky and pearsall in my 10 team 1qb half ppr league😂 building around Gibbs and G Wilson too

[@philipppietrowski98]

Man this class was loaded.. 😮

[@jasonallen1712]

Where you have Bo Nix is embarrassing.

[@thekingofsports9265]

What should I be doing with Jerry Jeudy in dynasty?

[@jamesk1115]

Mason, in a keeper I got to choose between McCarthy or B.Young as my 3rd QB to keep...one I have to release. Thoughts on who is better next year? Young closed really well but McCarthy to unknown but that might also be a good thing!

[@Connor-ug8dj]

In s/f there’s no argument for anything but A or S for Maye. What he did with the talent around him and his potential rushing upside moves him up.

[@Thatfantasyfootballchick]

He’s easily a top 20 start up

[@daniel-ym9un]

I have 2, 4,5,6,7 on the same dynasty roster, and finished in 7th place. Don't think I'll be finishing 7th next season and seasons after that. Just need to trade for Bowers and my team is set for the next 7-10 years.

[@nolanrj44]

If you take out the games Maye played less the 31% of snaps, he averaged like 20ppg.

[@slicedmittens]

If their situations improve, I see both Malik Nabers and Brock Bowers moving up to S tier. Hopefully those two terrible teams make some changes this offseason

[@morganhart1396]

The Isaac Guerrendo disrespect is crazy

[@joshuagonzalez908]

We Need a Underdog BBM update!!!

[@damienMeyer1]

He’s backkkkkkkkk

[@connorbland3006]

More dynasty content Mason. All the degens play dynasty, we need more.

[@FantasyDon]

Kind of saddening you focus on the website so much now. Your takes used to be so much better.

[@boychris1947]

"historical comps for brian thomas jr includes brian thomas jr"

[@grantbrown6502]

I like Coker more than Legette now after what I saw this year. Idk, just a good feeling about the dude moving forward.

[@D0UBL3D0P3]

1 flex qb no super flex half ppr, I have Josh Allen and Jayden Daniels. Do I trade one?

[@chasebeal-sharp383]

I’m in trade talks and the guy has both Jefferson and Nabers. Which would you rather have?

[@IAMLEGIT2323]

damn that's tough... Probably Jettas tho, much much better situation and proven to be 1/2nd best receiver in the league

[@chasebeal-sharp383]

@ thank you. What about Kyren, JT, Chase Brown, or Breece Hall? Which two would you want?

[@IAMLEGIT2323]

@@chasebeal-sharp383 Breece and JT probably

[@IAMLEGIT2323]

@@chasebeal-sharp383 either Breece and JT or Breece and Kyren. Ideally Breece and Bucky if you have to stay in that range.

[@chasebeal-sharp383]

@ thank you! I have JT and Chase Brown rn and he has Kyren and Breece

[@GO-wb1gf]

Nix being in C- tier is ridiculous as a Ravens fan. That team was supposed to win like 4 games in a rebuild year. Dude has very few weapons and led em to the playoffs with 34Total Tds.

[@calebphillips5185]

Brian Thomas should be in the same tier as nabers. Imo it's not even arguable

[@shrekfan6945]

You know it’s an elite receiver class when we call 700 receiving yards as a rookie a “faceplant”

[@brendanrunge818]

how on earth do you not have Brian Thomas in the same tier as malik and bowers? there’s an argument that his ceiling is higher then malik

[@jasonallen1712]

No, he's where he should be.

[@TDogg-yw3ww]

The Bucs have way too many needs on defense to draft another RB in round 2 or 3. Bucky has never been a good measurables guy he’s just a damn good football player

[@noahriley9717]

Nabers over BTJ is wack.

[@rodiperez7918]

HOOK EM HORNS 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@frankielobos]

The Bucky disrespect is real. You got him in the same tier as dudes that didn’t play much or underperformed.

[@quentin6274]

Jalen McMillan getting ultra disrespected but him on the same tier as a hurt player wtf!

[@mattsfc7530]

The mcmillian disrespect

[@blakekubat2137]

Ladd is an older rookie, but he’s only 7 months older than Marvin?

[@dylanparker5313]

What makes Malik better than Thomas?

[@tfFlyer-e9w]

No Gurrendo ?

[@Shiny_KingT]

Where is mcmillan?!?

[@Esscarrgo376]

The BTJ disrespect is real

[@GermSauce]

Maye isn’t on the right path? Did you watch the games? Clear box score watching here.

[@AwayAgain]

Bowers broke every record for a rookie te and took some overall te records how is that not S tier?

[@dylanpaton3276]

superflex

[@BigDawger1987]

137 Days until the draft 🤣

[@larrywoodard2639]

Dude Jalen McMillan helped ne win my league great last 5 weeks and you didn't even talk about him but we waisted breath on laggete. Didn't love your takes man. Week takes for sure overall. Sorry you didn't draft lad but he's a stud. Thhhhpppp I give you a bad rating as a talking head.

[@OrnitorrincoSlayer]

Coker > legette

[@TheShadowswagg]

Bo nix still getting disrespected ill never understand

[@hopes9614]

Horrible takes

[@marc8317]

Sleeping on Bo Nix

[@TF2vid]

BTJ > Nabers

[@TheRealTiam]

Buckys too low

[@quentin6274]

This ranking is awful please stop making videos

[@seandooptc]

Ladd C tier is embarrassing. Legitimate argument for Ladd over Nabers or BTJ. There's no reason to believe moving forward him and Marvin are equal.

[@dylanpaton3276]

no legitimate argument over nabers or btj, and him and marv are in same teir, that means u can take either and its fine

[@seandooptc]

@ Correct tiers would have nabers btj and ladd in the same tier with Marvin lower. There's no good argument to explain why Ladd is below btj/nabers down with unproven marvin

[@dylanpaton3276]

@@seandooptc no no no, marv is younger than ladd and had a elite prospect profile, remeber this is dynasty not redraft

[@seandooptc]

@ I'm not sure if that's sarcasm it sounds like sarcasm. If that's serious I'll say valuing age and prospect profile over actual performance and tape is how people get burnt

[@mykonmorales7706]

Horrible take on Bo Nix…you sound like a clown

[@dylanpaton3276]

nah hes not wrong hes already gonna be 25 its realistic shut up

[@DomePieceRecka]

This is such a stupid tier list mason is smoking tranq