top 3 songs from every starkid show by voting

I have to say I am much less disappointed in y'all than I was with the top 40 video.
Google doc with the full rankings for each show is here: bit.ly/33Bgrt6
Same video but with my own personal opinion: • top 3 songs from every...
I just wanted to let you know that my uni is starting online tomorrow/today and there’s also some other stuff in my personal life I have to take care of so I won’t be able to post as often. But fret not for two weeks from now is spring break and I won’t have anything to do again. (It’s not like I won’t be posting but it’ll just be less frequent than it’s been the last week)
If you would like to help fill out a form for a future video of mine then the links to the ones currently open are at: lyle.carrd.co/
(Shameless plug)
My tumblr: bit.ly/34oermO
My redbubble: rdbl.co/3cN7KA9

[@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy]

Would anyone be interested in me doing this same video with my own favourites? I’ve already got my #1 favourites in my starkid/TCB shows ranked video and those haven’t changed, but would people be interested in a full video of just my favourite music from each show?

[@ceruleanhearts7604]

go for it

[@olliebollieboy]

YESSSS

[@hannahbouldin1697]

Yes

[@paige7501]

y e s

[@Emma-6216]

Yess

[@jazzhands8493]

Is this what my life has come to.... going from one Starkid video to another

[@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy]

Sounds like a great life ngl

[@ceruleanhearts7604]

oh this is too relateable

[@TheJuliana0901]

@Sarina Weinberg ...mine too. those youtube mixes? i had some songs on them! legitimate new suggestions of unknown songs! after the quarantine it's all starkid

[@mollypocrass4562]

Honestly same

[@oliverkindaexists]

Oop

[@hannahbouldin1697]

Can’t believe hermione can’t draw made the list but days of summer didn’t

[@pallasnelli1091]

Hannah Bouldin days of summer is amazing I won’t stand for this

[@cosmicafflictions4970]

I was waiting for to have a home and days of summer!!!!!!

[@jamieestes3956]

And To Have a Home? It was done dirty

[@Caseyd200]

Thanks, Herman

[@sabrinab7974]

I think people were like “ima vote for this as a meme since everyone else is voting for the other ones” But then too many people did it for the joke and it beat out the other contenders. Like how in AVPSY fozzy bear had all the votes causing Draco and Harry to tie for last. But this time it wasn’t planned, just the usual Starkid hive mind😂

[@samhhoward]

kick it up a notch getting 600 votes is so funny to me, like all of the number 1 songs have like 300, but kick it up a notch has 600, and it just shows that everyone has good taste

[@musicandloveismylive]

It's also isn't strange that it has way more votes in comparison to the other shows. It's because starship has less song than the other shows. Don't get me wrong, I also voted on it:P

[@samhhoward]

JustSarah that’s almost definitely part of it, but hmb has the same no. of songs as starship, and rouges are we (another very popular song) only got around 300, so idk lmao :p

[@alyssahopson5926]

Your wagon is on fire had quite a few votes as well, and honestly, is was one of my favorite parts of the entire musical

[@samhhoward]

Alyssa Hopson wagon on fire is def the best song in tto, and everyone voting for it has amazing opinions

[@katejepson2487]

I'm ready to disappointed and shocked by the fellow starkid stans

[@zbotello1439]

Kate Jepson same

[@Royal.lol16]

Same here

[@samhhoward]

achmed got remembered boys

[@platinumfate5671]

This is “Happy Ending” erasure and I will not stand for it

[@jamieestes3956]

PlatinumFate it should be number 1

[@Caseyd200]

This is all your fault Jafar

[@kenziegarbiel1692]

Thanks Hermione

[@dustkeeper]

"I've killed three people - BY A BEARRRR OR A SNAAAAKE"

[@genericnarutofan94]

I feel like star kid is what is keeping me sane during self quarantine

[@fallon3216]

Generic Naruto fan same

[@zoenic_ole]

same

[@whatcanidooo]

I feel like it's making me less sane lol

[@grown_teen]

this is coolest girl erasure

[@pippinhart7340]

this is a really small detail, but i love the way you choose the perfect title card song for each vote. like "a song is a dick in sheep's clothing" for the songs video, or "we are womankind" for the best actress segment. it's so much fun to notice which ones you picked!

[@anikathu]

THE NIGHT BELONGS TO SNARL MADE TOP 3 IM LITERALLY SO HAPPY ABOUT THIS

[@littlecat7128]

ME TOO

[@cass8167]

Dark, Sad, Lonely Knight nearly almost getting the appreciation it deserves

[@cyanogeniccyanide5150]

Me, watching the AVPSY top: Oh, "I was" is second, I am sure the first is gonna be either "Wizard of the year" or "This school is mine", really hope it's the first one. The video: AM I THE ONE THAT TAKES YOU HOME mE: DE FI NET LY N O T

[@xxsallykittyxx5654]

It a fan favourite pfft, and heya look at the title.

[@moss6962]

Theyre all bops

[@itamarolmert3549]

Hmmm... I sure do wonder what tgwdlm's #1 will be.

[@dvdcbb]

bOy i WOndER

[@mtayl0r]

Itamar Olmert the anticipation was killing me the entire video

[@kenziegarbiel1692]

I have no idea

[@kenziegarbiel1692]

@Dr. Diofenshmirtz Of course it will be. It's just figuring out the most show stopping number that's difficult

[@meld7164]

HmMmM...

[@catalystisonline]

unpopular opinion: i really like angela’s voice and i really think her voice makes califormia a really good song

[@bluexbeanlyn]

yes.

[@daniellevanrhijn1822]

henry hidgens is that an unpopular opinion!? Shame I love her voice in the songs because it fits her character so well

[@kieranparker6932]

Me too! I think she was absolutely perfect for the role and the songs

[@fionacamm5386]

henry hidgens ikr!! like when i watched it the first time i was just not into it but now i love it so much

[@dmg3736]

It’s not terrible but to choose it over Dylan in If I Fail you is downright irresponsible

[@jortsofficial173]

I voted in this and I NEVER expected that If I Believed (Twisted) would make the top three!!! I’m so PSYCHED!!

[@gracieliz95]

As someone who has only recently watched the non-Harry Potter musicals, I’d like to say: 1. Starship is underrated 2. Jamie is way better than I thought she was. Like waaaaaay better. 3. I am in love with at least 75% of the cast members.

[@haley8254]

finally sidekick is in its rightful place

[@sunshinesolace3540]

It makes me really sad that Lost Without You is barely ever, if not ever voted in the top 3 of any TTO ranking. It's one of my favourite starkid songs but people have different tastes 'n stuff.

[@adamzheng4362]

It's not really that Lost without you is bad, it's that there are too many good songs. (I don't really like Wagon on Fire though)

[@jordanne229]

Okay some thoughts: 1. It is an outrage that To Have A Home and Days of Summer weren’t in the top 3 with AVPS (Hermione Can’t Draw is still just a joke song) 2. All of these are mostly in the range of 100-200 and then you got Kick It Up A Notch And Wagon on Fire 3. I honestly was NOT expecting Climate Change to be first with Firebringer. I did not know the general consensus on this song was so good Great video!

[@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy]

I don’t get why everyone is just mentioning kick it up a notch when wagon on fire had 530 votes?

[@Infinity600gaming]

Climate change is an amazing song

[@jordanne229]

Lyle The Water Aquatic Guy Well I didn’t read it right the first time around and thought it said 330

[@alisondices]

It’s wild to have black friday like properly one starkid videos now Like it’ll be wild if people start making like funny moments/out of context that goes between black friday and others. It’s just so new it’s weird you know (in a good way)

[@owls2223]

Sad that Even Though wasn't on the MAMD list but at least Listen to Your Heart was #1 and that's the AJ Holmes rights we deserved

[@mitchelpaulus4078]

Okay the achmed scene is my favorite StarKid scene period! But, the opening number “Dream a little harder” got robbed big time.

[@soupsoup4245]

I love how 2/3 of the best Twisted songs were Dylan's solos- It's what he deserves

[@mollywhiteman8956]

and the last one was a song about a guy who fucked a tiger lmao

[@sarahkinsey5434]

I'm sorry but HOW COULD YOU CUT IT OFF BEFORE "SOMEWHERE"!?!

[@arianafrias646]

Sarah Kinsey the BEST part of the whole song

[@beck4557]

MY THOUGHTS EXACTLY

[@hannahmurdy8902]

Thank you that’s what I was thinking too. Absolutely outraged

[@lottekomkommer]

I'm really but I don't know what song it is, tell me and I'll be offended with you☺️

[@hannahmurdy8902]

Lotte it’s the song from Twisted “If I Believed” if you haven’t given it a listen all the way through yet you definitely should hahaha

[@morgan615]

I’m pretty excited about how Status Quo made the list cause i was not expecting that and it’s one of my favorite starkid songs

[@belasundead]

I wonder how everyone ranks the songs? How emotional they made you? How much you enjoy listening to it? How catchy it is? Just a thought, because some really good starkids songs always get overlooked because they aren't as "catchy" as others. IDK, I just know I rank by how much it makes me feel.

[@j.9481]

bro i'm just going off of pure Vibes

[@RosieWillatt]

I voted based on how much I liked the songs musically - like the lyrics, melody and ways the singers sing them, that's how I base whether a song is 'good' to me or not, it's all comes down to my personal taste and how much I re-listen to them.

[@andrea7239]

i do it by how much i enjoy listening to it

[@ezelfrancisco1349]

Mine are: 1. How much does it help the plot? 2. How good they are? 3. Do I remember them after the first time I watched it?

[@emmablanche9954]

glad to see the night belongs to snarl getting some appreciation

[@luciamezzapelle3854]

So you’re telling me Hermione can’t draw got more votes than Days of Summer, To have a home, coolest girl and no way?? Seriously???

[@izzie9020]

Right!? I'm highkey pissed ngl

[@salembarchard322]

the dynamic duet got ROBBED

[@pellaw8011]

THEY'RE SAYING "YOU GOT THE FORCE??". god, I'm such a dumbass. your girl thought they were saying "oh, you got it! oh, oh, you got it! you got diVORCED!"

[@mirror728]

I'm laughing so hard rn

[@hannahxx8420]

I was so shocked that Voldemort is going down wasnt in the top 3 for avpm

[@mariajosefinasaporito5189]

Wagon on fire having 530 votes gives me life tbh

[@oddballgoose409]

how did people not?? vote for made in america???

[@eoincampbell1584]

because they have?? different tastes and opinions???

[@oddballgoose409]

@Linnea Larsson 9 I don't think that they've released the studio recording of Black Friday songs yet like they have for other musicals but... don't they usually cut out most of the dialogue that happens in the middle of songs for those recordings? So I'd assume that the song by itself officially includes a lot less dialogue but idk

[@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy]

They have released it, they released it before the actual show premiered on KZbin.

[@LU-qr3kh]

If Duck is Lord was an option for Firebringer it would be a unanimous vote

[@TheJuliana0901]

I honestly had no idea how much the starkid fans loved wagon is on fire until I did a survey of my own

[@bean3550]

We all knew Show Stopping Number would be top of TGWDLM because stunning iconic amazing but I'm delighted that Let It Out was so close to it.

[@lashandaking-topic5181]

This is Guys Like Potter erasure to me, you did a good job putting this video together!

[@charliespector]

I don't know why the date at Duck Is Lord made me laugh so much but it did and I thank you.

[@lothanyfountain9443]

At this point i don't really care about the ranking, I just come to listen to the songs

[@stp82]

The fact that missing you didn't make it is a crime

[@dimitra_k]

The blatant erasure of Those Voices and Not over yet is appalling

[@BABY-dc3xb]

in my opinion what if tomorrow comes is really overrated. i LOVE kendall’s voice so don’t regard this as any criticism on kendall because i wish she had been given a full song. my criticism of what if tomorrow comes is that it doesn’t feel like a full song, the lyrics are repetitive and it’s strange to me that songs with amazing scores and lyrics like “our doors are open” and “black friday” are overlooked in favour of it. just my opinion though! there’s got to be something special about it if that many people voted for it lol

[@catalystisonline]

BABY i agree! i see it so much on people’s top 3’s and i’m like how? her voice is beautiful but i agree that the lyrics are repetitive and not that creative as other songs from the show. and it was a great throwback to to tgwdlm but there are so many greater songs imo

[@musichica09]

BABY yeah, the lyrics might be repetitive, but the harmonies and the way everything layers and builds is stunning. Also, the choreography (what we can see anyway) is just so subtle and beautifully done. Every time I listen to it, I get the same kind of gut punch as when Paul starts singing in Inevitable. That ‘oh shit they’re not safe’ realization.

[@pearlexquisite935]

Both feast and famine and it are definitely overrated. Both are wildly popular for their vocals and choreo but no one considers how simplistic the structure of each song is. Vocals and a catchy underlying beat do not make a good song.

[@justhere5895]

I agree!!!!!

[@geb2282]

I felt like the repetition was intentional as it shows that the day is on a loop and that hatchetfield will always be destroyed no matter what they do. That's just the take I got from it. The cast changing into TGWDLM characters kind of solidified the theory in my head that this is an alternate universe and so Jeff wanted to show that through the repetitiveness of the lyrics. Idk if I'm just looking too far into it though.

[@paridasnapesnapesnape5584]

Ok ngl these results are a lot more satisfying than the top 40 one 😅

[@abby4034]

How do I become this amazing as a Starkid channel?

[@emilyjfreer2895]

Inevitable and let it out! Hell yeah

[@izzie9020]

I will never for the life of me understand this fandom's obsession with Hermione Can't Draw

[@zeinfeld]

the hmb one killed me. be a man is so good

[@alexbrabo4471]

Unpopular opinion. Hermione's Can't Draw is absolutely terrible. Days of Summer and No Way are so much better

[@anni2539]

I think Hermione Can't Draw is pretty good and catchy, but I can most definitely agree that No Way and Days Of Summer deserved better

[@Ro-yl5cm]

Yeah I agree with you to a certain extent. Days of Summer and No Way are soooo much better but Hermoine Can't Draw isn't terrible. It's just catchy and fun as stupid as it is lol

[@troyjuhn7346]

But Hermione can’t draw is meant to be bad. That’s why it’s so funny

[@lilliealicea8002]

But Hermione Can't Draw is meant to just be a poorly written song, I personally don't think it's comparable to most of the other songs in the show

[@yuvalmaharshak5566]

"Ah no fuck a you"

[@misut2]

Different as Can Be erasure? Absurd!

[@amityislandchum]

YOU'RE absurd!

[@misut2]

sharksandsheep That’s Absurd!

[@snarls3760]

Tbf avpm has a lot of bangers so sadly a lot of amazing songs had to be cut out of top 3

[@LordNicoDiAngelo]

I would have DEFINITELY voted for Chorn as the top song in firebringer

[@ICommentCuzILike]

i can't believe 'those voices' wasnt in the top 3 for very potter sequel D:

[@givemebarleysugars1076]

yo what happened to kick it up a notch reprise in the doc why

[@downstageright3298]

Man the amount of effort these videos must take. Wow! I am impressed!

[@dvdcbb]

Everybody check the full google doc with the whole ranking before you get mad.

[@SuperTaylorfan11]

No Coolest Girl OR No Way??

[@oliverkindaexists]

I love how the clip you picked for every song is the best part of that song

[@Baseiscc]

My top 3 Tgwdlm songs were literally this one but reversed

[@sabrinab7974]

The guy who didn’t like musicals one felt way off from what I thought

[@Jun-cc6qs]

People vote Show Stoppin Number because of that Manion voice

[@sabrinab7974]

Junberia Khor Oh I understood that one being the top pick (we love Robert in this household😂). I was just referring to the 2nd and 3rd picks

[@albieemery2828]

Sabrina B Same. If I had to rank TGWDlM songs it would go 3: Join Us 2: Not Your Seed 1: Inevitable

[@mayag224]

The fact that happy ending isn’t up there is a tragedy.

[@LosTrilocos]

Joe Walker: MAMD - duet in Ready to go AVPS - solo in Stutter HMB - mostly solo in Dark, sad, lonely knight, significant part in Super friends AVPSY - duet in I was Twisted - mostly solo in No one remembers Achmed ANI - dance in Ani and The force (You got it) Firebringer - dance in Climate Change This man's talent is infinite, endless. Too bad he's becoming more and more underrated due to not participating in Hatchetfield's shows

[@lenap319]

I see my fellow twisted stans have excellent taste

[@meld7164]

I'm really happy that What If Tomorrow Comes got some attention, because it was the first song I heard from Black Friday, and that song made me want to listen to Black Friday in its entirety. It's probably one of my favorite Black Friday songs, but then again, there are so many.

[@christianfigaratto5860]

LISTEN TO YOUR HEART GOT SOME RESPECT, DAMN

[@weirdwonkywild3867]

How the hey howdy hey does Independence only have 99 votes 👀

[@littlecat7128]

I'm so happy with this rankig, you're all have good taste!

[@bethan2600]

I mean occasionally I’d but the three in a different order but I agreed with the top three in every one wow...

[@fallon3216]

I called most of these lol also why wasn’t hideous creatures on there I love that song way more than kick it up a notch

[@laratoya7088]

YOU DIDNT INCLUDE THE WIGGLES I AM DEEPLY UPSET

[@jahnabanana]

That SLANDER for The Way I Do tho. Absolute God-tier song, nothing better.

[@avast47]

I genuinely thought that Chorn would be first for Firebringer, but then I remembered that all of the music in that show is good.

[@lewisf2909]

Thanks for making this i need this in my life

[@skyellewelyn3275]

For once, someone remembered achmed.

[@mistyrahne2001]

Am i the only one who actually likes “Even Though” from MAMD 😭😭

[@alexiayuen2245]

Mystique Hohenschuh even though is probably my second favourite in mamd

[@thiabot3335]

it’s a shame stutter wasn’t number one. that song gets stuck in my head a little to often.

[@sipulikorva8717]

Only two songs I missed on these were Those Voices from AVPS and Chorn from Firebringer.

[@TiaMat99]

Wizard of the Year (Gilderoy) wasn't in the top 3?? Absolutely criminal, y'all must repent.

[@isabellalesher8487]

Me thirty seconds in with Granger Danger being second: "Ummmm what's higher than this?? Whatever." *Does the dance.* When it gets to the "Draco wake up" I knock my glasses into my face because of how hard I did it because I'm tired and under my fluffy blanket silently singing songs like this in the privacy of my bedroom.

[@meld7164]

ok but how did Duck Is Lord not make the top 3? I am appalled smh jk, great video!

[@snarls3760]

The duck is not pleased

[@Brooke-ov4bo]

Can we appriciate the transition from “but know snake is bigger then this snake!!” To the emotional song everything ends in avpsy

[@cecilie8420]

Tto is so underrated!!

[@zer0thousand]

Unpopular opinion: Show Stopping number is overrated. It’s a good song, but very overrated (Don’t hate me lol)

[@al_exists]

y e s

[@luciaelizalde5243]

It's not number 1 for me tbh

[@cereal_picnic]

While, on the flip side, Show Me Your Hands is criminally underrated

[@luciaelizalde5243]

@@cereal_picnic YES

[@annikak.1554]

Most of this video was stuff that I 100% expected and while it doesn't make me unhappy it feels hollow almost. Nice to see that Sidekick rep tho because that song is so good, and some Independence! because it feels like people don't appreciate that song a lot. I'm not even going to bring up TGWDLM, but Black Friday's ranking surprised me a little and it was a good surprise.

[@ameliajane8355]

JOEY AND DYLAN I LOVE BOTH OF THEM SO MUCH OH MY GOD

[@sapphicrose8213]

Unpopular opinion: Jamilla's lament is the best song from Firebringer (With the exception of duck is lord of course), but nobody wants to listen to it because let's be honest, it makes all of us bawl our eyes out.

[@allythebidisaster4744]

Hi this is one of my favorite videos ever now

[@adamzheng4362]

This is the closest to my personal rankings. There's usually one in every show that I don't like that much, though.

[@bumblebeeproductions1673]

I love how tgwdlm didn’t have competition…we all knew it would be ‘Show Stopping Number’

[@ameliaawan6188]

Oh boy do I wonder what 1st place will be for tgwdlm

[@graemestowe3004]

I noticed the 420/69 at the end. Don’t think I wouldn’t!

[@vividly_valeska5738]

Listen to your heart is my favorite song EVER oh..wait wizard of the year. Okay actually can I just say I’m in love with AJ

[@Nicolelovesyou]

*RIGHT IN THE SAPINAAAA*

[@orls216]

My fav Starkid song has to be Going Back To Hogwarts.

[@featherlight858]

So my personal ranking for the songs from the shows I have seen so far: AVPM: 1. Going Back To Hogwarts 2. Voldemort Is Going Down 3. Different As Can Be AVPS: 1. It's Not Over Yet 2. Guys Like Potter 3. Harry Freakin' Potter AVPSY: 1. Tonight The School Is Mine 2. Wizard of The Year 3. Sidekick Starship: 1. Status Quo 2. Hideous Creatures 3. Kick It Up A Notch (Reprise) Twisted: 1. Twisted 2. Dream A Little Harder 3. I Steal Everything TGWDLM: 1. Show Stoppin Number 2. The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals 3. Not Your Seed

[@tessakraynak8454]

this is VALID guys like potter AND not over yet appreciation?? we LOVE to see it!!

[@featherlight858]

@@tessakraynak8454 I feel like especially It's Not Over Yet deserves to be praised more, it's such a good opening number AND a villain song. Also I've watched the rest of the shows in the meantime so I can also say that: MAMD: 3. Ready to Go 2. Listen to Your Heart 1. Even Though Trail to Oregon: 3. Dysentery World 2. Independence! 1. Wagon on Fire Ani: 3. Back on Top 2. Ani 1. With My Own Eyes Firebringer: 3. The Night Belongs to Snarl 2. What If 1. Climate Change Black Friday 3. Feast or Famine 2. Our Doors Are Open 1. Made In America

[@tessakraynak8454]

@@featherlight858 yes totally! I definitely agree with most of your opinions, which isn't common lol :)

[@featherlight858]

@@tessakraynak8454 So which ones do you disagree with? Because I'm curious now.

[@tessakraynak8454]

@@featherlight858 I think I would have Missing You or To Dance Again at 2 for AVPM, Get Back Up somewhere in starship, and my AVPSY would be a bit different. But other than that, pretty accurate

[@MorriganReads]

Looks like they remembered Achmed!

[@jacobmorejead8122]

It seems everyone has collectively forgotten coolest girl exists 😞

[@deepbibble9536]

This video is everything lol

[@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy]

That profile picture is everything lol

[@deepbibble9536]

Lyle The Water Aquatic Guy :))))

[@c00lmcbeans]

I guess people remembered Achmed for him to get his song number 1 for Twisted

[@sabrinab7974]

Speed Run was done dirty