Top 5 Worst Thomas Wooden Railway Redesigns

[@brightredmogul1912]

The worst part about the Rheneas redesign is that like 4 years later, Wooden Railway released Smudger, who is a WAY better version of the Dolgoch-kind of design, and can even rival the original in my opinion. But NO - Rheneas still stayed the same until 2013.

[@Ink-454]

A

[@AmtrakCSXFan457]

B

[@eevee_mon]

@@AmtrakCSXFan457 C

[@nothingismatter.]

@@eevee_mon D

[@gasparzone_eltipoquecomenta]

@@nothingismatter.E

[@allison122477]

Diesel 10 during TATMR: “Fat hat can’t to Jack squat to me, I’ll crush him.” Diesel 10 in DOTD: “Fat controller scary 😭😭😭”

[@TTTE_Guy]

mattel should take notes on what we learned also great video joey, the editing in this one was epic

[@prussianandgermanempirearm5376]

I just did and took lot notes

[@Domitonk]

Lets just protend HE DID 2:46

[@dylanbaker12]

5:12 actually jumpscared me a little

[@masterfarr8265]

I kinda remember wishing that the wooden Diesel 10 had an articulated Pinchy

[@BIG_RED_PRODUCTIONS_official]

What about the brio diesel 10

[@maddalonefarms]

What do u mean articulated

[@masterfarr8265]

@@maddalonefarms being able to have pinchy move out and in and up and down

[@maddalonefarms]

@@masterfarr8265 They should bring that back

[@NickyTeam]

Fancy seeing you here.

[@darkmariomodder64]

"Bulstrode hasn't appeared in the series since season fou- _leave._ " that killed me 🤣

[@rayryde1724]

He appeared in the stupidly bad all engines go

[@tnytmytx]

@@rayryde1724 *leave* We dont talk about that

[@TrainsAreReallyCool]

Let's just pretend he did. Let's just pretend HE *DI-*

[@FlyingDuckMan360]

I just noticed that the 1994 Bertie has four windows, while the 2002 Bertie has five. It reminds me of the Bart's Nightmare episode of Console Wars, because both things involve buses having the same number of windows.

[@nursestoyland]

@FlyingDuckMan360 I think he means the engines from that time, also I think tomy did do wooden railway at one point

[@TheWagonConductor1899]

2:10 “Tidmoth Tidmoth” Had Me Dying.

[@cherirutherford7435]

"DID THE BEATLES GIVE THEM LSD" 🤣

[@clairebennett9104]

1:08 *_"H E ' S S M O K I N G"_*

[@thepincult2763]

5:31 Smaller huh? 😏

[@Brakevan817]

Idea: since Rheneas has the worst wooden model ever, and smugder has a good one, just put rheneas’s face on smudger and paint it up like rheneas

[@joshuaW5621]

You might also have to sand down the coal bunkers if you want it to be super accurate.

[@allisonkrueger8330]

@@joshuaW5621 they’re the exact same class tho

[@helloneighborfan5139]

I think Rheneas has Sir Handels face because, in the season 4 nameboards their faces are swapped, So they probably based the redesign off of his nameboard shot

[@merlinandmurdoch7837]

It’s actually from his season 4 measurement pictures which also show him with Sir Handel’s face

[@donald.the.scottish.engine]

5:25 wat

[@CommunityBrightHunt328]

Favorite moments 2:38 -> WHAT?! 2:44 -> Let’s just pretend, he DI- 3:06 -> -THIS monstrosity

[@starconverse46productions20]

Everyone: Only a small percentage of people are actually subscribed. Joey: has 100.1% of viewers

[@JerrytheVideoGamer257]

3:06 This part cracked me up!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@basicallypercy2800]

2:38 he returns in all engines go lol

[@chazzywaz]

And has more screen time than edward and henry 💀

[@Bacteriaboi29]

@@chazzywazoh dear,I’m too late to see farona and fredirico-(explosion)

[@nightmarione2529]

1:26 my favourite part😊

[@allisonkrueger8330]

0:48 lol “dumb sh-“ 😂

[@uncklestheenchilada]

5:19 the sick freaks who believed in the promo art

[@kcore1427]

Bertie was absolutely killed by Mattel, there is a big hole in his roof and middle sides for the driver they introduced! ugh!

[@nursestoyland]

The 2013 bulstrode is nightmare fuel. PERIOD

[@tristanoneil3715]

Here's my opinion on these items on your list 5-I would agree with you, it would've made sense to remove the one guy and replace him with someone else but I didn't really mind it because I could use my imagination to put passengers in there 4-I don't have it so I can't tell whether it's good or bad 3-I never got the set that model came in but it looks ugly 2-I would have to agree, I have the 2013 model and that has him smiling too. I prefer the 2000 version. (Which I have that as well) 1-Agreed big time! That is the only model of Rheneas that I have.

[@muhammadNizam748]

"Lest just pretend he did" "Lest just pretend... " "He.... DID" *AEG Bolstrode images jumpscare*

[@tnytmytx]

I think Terence's 2006 redesign should have been an honorable mention.

[@drevianedwardsproductions9244]

The worst Wooden Railway item would have to be the Wooden Railway Fisher Price Bulstrode the faces fine and the details are simplistic for the most part but why would you make him this small? I do remember getting the Cranky at the Docks set from Thomas wood which is the 2018 version and let's just say I think it's simple but good and I literally painted cranky and washable paint back in 2019 and I had nothing to do with Bulstrode at the time but now ever since that they released the new 2022 Brendan Docks set I will definitely will have that set and keep the new Cranky and Bulstrode overall I will respect your opinions on the worst Wooden Railway items.

[@evo_funny_man]

ˡᵒⁿᵍ ᶜᵒᵐᵐᵉᵗ

[@ad-sd-vids5332]

If you do a top 5 best wooden railway redesigns, here’s some options 2006 Oliver/toad/scruffey 2007 daisy 2008 sir Handel Peter Sam and Duke 2012 skarloey, SH & PS

[@cristiantiniguar-sevilla467]

I actually have the white-wheeled Rheanas version, but with the shocked expression, (but the right face nonetheless.) I slapped a piece of masking tape and drew a regular smile with a sharpie marker after I got him. It's been 3-to-4 years, he needs a new one.

[@MickeyMousePlushShow1928]

4:12 He smiles sometimes!

[@MrTrackmaster]

The fact that this man is so cynical is hilarious

[@erickbuicio8792]

1:13 my brother Leo got the 1994 Bertie but I got the 2002 in 2022

[@HexFudge]

Rheneas my Boi... WHAT DID THEY DO TO YOU?!?!

[@StanBlankPlushelodeon]

I wish I could get my hands on the Tidmouth Tidmouth. Looks like a much better set than the Tidmouth Timber Yard.

[@allisonkrueger8330]

Lol

[@TalesOfThomas901]

You should do a video about your top 10 Thomas wooden railway pieces of rolling stock.

[@fridaynightfunkinfan5627]

Here’s an honorable mention: ……THE BUBBLE LO-

[@karenfan010]

even if there was a guy with a pipe kids wouldn’t even know what it is so it doesn’t matter.

[@SodorStudiosAndCoProductions]

4:06 *"GIVE US BACK THE OLD FACE!!!"*

[@fefecayres2995]

-Leokimvideo 2011

[@amtrakp4242]

I own the 2002 Bertie because it was the only wooden railway Bertie I could find at a Flea Market

[@joshpack7330]

leokimvideo referenced the Gordon model from '2018' as being bad because of the wheels being inaccurate.

[@allisonkrueger8330]

It seems like these manufacturers don’t care whether a character is bad or not and just makes everyone smile lol

[@KevintheGreat125]

Stepney: Am I A Joke To You?

[@Controlly_bloxfruits]

3:26 cgi bulstrode

[@Chadlikestrains]

You actually see bulstrode on one of the beaches in the little Western line

[@toadbrunoandbelleproductions]

The guy smoking is supposed to be the reverend wilbert awdry

[@Pandagun.]

James is Here: Sometimes the remake is worst than the original. Me looking at my TM1 version next to my TM2 version on my shelf: yep, he’s right.

[@crockpotninja7947]

5:32 😂😂😂

[@Ella871]

i haven't seen any Thomas the train shows movies or books in a while, but i watch more Thomas the train KZbin videos then makes any sense even for a Thomas the train super fan.

[@metal_wheels]

I love how Duncan isn't even on the vid :O

[@zonic26]

Just came here for the thumbnail a Duncan looks exactly like a yellow Thomas

[@Thomasgam1ng]

The only video in my watch later playlist LOL

[@Declanaroosky]

"If it ain't broke, DON'T FIX IT" -JIH 2022

[@prestonproductions7730]

2:45 let’s just pretend HE DID

[@williamlittles718]

2:15 sO I gUeSs iT diDn’T sElL vErY wEll

[@AwesomeDrawer2017]

Serves you right

[@iceeblueburst03]

Who the hell made that version of Rheneas with that weird face and white wheels?

[@conductorcarson]

I won’t argue about this. I don’t like a lot of these Redesigns either. But I don’t think Bertie’s change is ALL bad. Having both versions could show that he’s not ALWAYS full of passengers 24/7. And The magnet means he can be towed by Butch. That’s kinda cool.

[@pmcl49]

next video: top 5 wooden railway items that have no nose

[@EndrVersace]

I actually have that wooden Rheneas one, but I also have a take-n-play Rheneas. You can guess which one Id prefer more in this case

[@71theredengine]

Rip old Thomas Toy : (

[@ohshoottre5262]

4:36 I was watching this pleasant video in my gaming chair when you were talking about Diesel 10. I was having a great time until you said something that I will never forget. You said "This (Day Of The Diesels) came out the same year TOMY made this change." What you said shocked me. This is wooden railway, not TOMY. This made me feel sick to my stomach. Why would he slip up like this? What you said made this video unwatchable, and I will be unsubscribing immediately. I am very disturbed, and I pray to any other watchers out there to spread the word, and do the same thing I did. Diesel 10 was made by Wooden Railway, not TOMY. Shame on you James, shame on you.

[@AmtrakCSXFan457]

R/facepalm

[@ohshoottre5262]

@@AmtrakCSXFan457 silence redditor child

[@WatchVidsMakeLists]

You might r/woooosh me, but just in case you actually don't know, the Thomas Wooden Railway range has been produced by several different companies including Learning Curve, TOMY, and Mattel.

[@ohshoottre5262]

@@WatchVidsMakeLists i didnt actually know it was produced by tomy. thats pretty cool. thanks (:

[@WatchVidsMakeLists]

@@ohshoottre5262 Yeah, they held the TWR license briefly in like 2013 or something, and that's where the original (kinda weird-lookin) CGI face toys come from :)

[@SCAX865]

2:18 Serves you right.

[@BraedenOfficial]

2:37 WUT?!???!!!1

[@gwrduck]

I thought the white wheels on Rheneas were a mistake,

[@pmc1000]

I have the original 1994 Bertie. Weird.

[@sonicdrew]

as a kid 2:04 I can confirm this is very true.

[@alexcutionman4569]

I might have a classic Bulstrode in my attic somewhere…I’ll take a look later

[@allisonkrueger8330]

3:30 why the f**k is he smiling? 3:32 exactly

[@TheSudrianTerrier653]

5:31 SMALLER PE- I MEAN FUNNEL

[@shanestrains548]

Okay But 2002 Bertie looks really good

[@TheThomasCrew2024]

It was sold longer than the tidmouth milk 🤣😂

[@chavopatyfanstudios2005]

1:52 it dosen't matter where it takes place

[@prussianandgermanempirearm5376]

Mattel is so mad rrrreeeeee

[@Tyler2K7]

Thats me in a way (with most not subbed) 0:44 But nice job on the video

[@vartvoon44]

I’m surprised you didn’t mention Stepney lol

[@hgostudios2005]

It look like the 2013 bolstrode looks like his face is on steroids

[@justsomethingyouseeonline7387]

Well at least unlike the previous version of Diesel 10 they got Pinchy's color right cause ever since Magic Railroad his claw was this dark brown not a light tan color in fact I fixed my "magic Railroad" Diesel 10 by removing the normal Pinchy and replaced it with the Pinchy I got from my "Day Of The Diesels" version of Diesel 10

[@brendencraft200]

no what Rheneas

[@AC34D]

Crazy part is I have both Diesel 10 and Rheneas….he looked better in orange if you ask me….and those wheels are supposed to be gray for some ungodly reason….

[@MsBabydice]

RHENAS MORE LIKE RENASS

[@kadenrobinson7067]

Oh boy I can't wait to get my favorite set tidmouth tidmouth

[@WalterAndMatt4084]

James Is A LEGEND

[@prism182]

man your lucky my Rheneas looks like a milk tanker

[@Trainboy17]

Smaller Pe- I Mean Funnel

[@germantanker131johnny2]

Oh no. 2D Bulstrode.

[@Victuncio]

Bro the emotion in your voice is so freaking good and funny lmao

[@mikofox9798]

Me who just bought that diesel 10 because it was the least expensive for Canadian:

[@Leonardo-cw1dd]

i got my bulstrode with the sodor light house set

[@bigzim437]

Timothy should have been on this list tbh

[@charlathomas2181]

I get the feeling that james is here hates rheneas

[@thenotsofunnyengine1325]

Bertie’s redesign is just Thomas going from the early seasons dark themes to the s25 reboot

[@merlinandmurdoch7837]

It’s not season 25, it’s it’s own show

[@jaidengreene8275]

I have that original bulstrode toy. My little sister's don't want it and idk what I'm going to do with it. Do you genuinely want it?

[@SCAX865]

5:23 Did the Beatles give him LSD?

[@Mr_FredDude_Guy]

give a idea for james is here:tOp 5 ThE GrEat WODeN RAlWaY THoMaSz merch1!1!1!!1!1!1!1!1!

[@BrimmySP]

AEG Bulstrode.

[@tyd521]

NEBL: Not Enough Bubble Loader

[@thegtukid2009]

oooh Rheneas.. WHAT THE HELL WHO THE HECK THOGHT THIS WAS A GOOD IDEA WHO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I AM SO FRUSHTRATED AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH KILL ME

[@edwardrhg]

A smaller P- i mean funnel

[@voidvoidvoi]

I’m still wondering who okayed the learning curve rheneas

[@CollinFifer-l7b]

3:51 Im SiNkInG

[@trippq.]

thoughs on bill C-11.