TOP SPIN 4 vs TOP SPIN 2K25 - Gameplay Comparison

👇 N'hésite pas à t'abonner si tu as aimé la vidéo :)
bit.ly/3c6AxOJ
Bien le bonjour !
J'espère que cette vidéo vous plaira, si c'est le cas, n'oublie pas de mettre un p'tit pouce en l'air et de t'abonner à la chaîne !
N'hésite pas à me dire ce que tu en penses et quel genre de vidéo tu aimerais voir sur la chaîne (match, tuto,...)
On se retrouve très prochainement pour une nouvelle vidéo !
A la prochaine et vive la passion du tennis !
✅ To support me :
fr.tipeee.com/...
Follow me on my social medias :
✅ Instagram : tennis.experience
✅ Facebook : TennisElbowProduction
Patch used : 2022 Patch by Tennis Experience
www.managames....
Get the Demo of this tennis game here : www.managames.com/tennis

[@juaneparadiso6706]

They made the same game 13 years later but now without Rafa and Nole. Congrats!

[@MM-ul8kx]

Top Spin 4 is miles better, unbelievable how they managed to make a worse game 13 years later

[@rudhiak3907]

Topspin 5 is better than 4. 4’s ball physics are inaccurate and the short topspin shots were too precise and overpowered. Plus, the players stumbled too much on topspin 4. Topspin 5 is better

[@renatodteixeira]

Agree 100% with you Mr. MM-ul8kx, unbelievable

[@mysticmike9125]

Nah top spin 4 is so much more cleaner. When I look at this video from a distance , 4 looks like a real match. 2k25 looks stiff , only thing Better are the graphics

[@master-jj7um]

@@mysticmike9125 what you think about TS4 sound effects? looks like a real match to you?

[@wally19]

@@master-jj7um Sounds are better in 2k25, but gameplay is worse. I have both games. The footwork is way better in TS4

[@martinlascar2774]

The sound of the footwork in ts4 is much much better

[@rabyanaz623]

Footwork seems better in topspin 4 slightly, I think the best part of the game is the realistic footwork and realistic pace of the game

[@richiguru7564]

The sound in ts4 is too loud tbf. Play the sound to someone without the visuals and they'll tell you it's basketball.

[@raedkhmous1292]

Top spin 4 has better graphics and players movements surprisingly

[@LasoffittadelNerd]

The speed of the gameplay seems a lot more realistic in the old version. The new one seems a slow motion version of tennis

[@gouedallica]

absolutely

[@isaacguzman1083]

Thank you! I'm not the only one to have this feeling... Played Top Spin 4 yesterday night, continuing my old MyCarreer, and I really think it feels better, less cuts between animations, everything is more fluid... 2K25 got rushed and we can tell by the lack of attention to details, which was the strength of Top Spin 4...

[@alexxssj4263]

Es un juego vacio

[@LeJuste12]

same thing i thought, looks like amateur tennis

[@jojo_6998]

business model changed a lot on tennis games. i bet topspin 2k25 was made quickly with big cost in license. Top spin 4 has better graphics and gameplay is fun. And old Virtual tennis 3 is good arcade game

[@leftybrasco3206]

Top spin 4 en moins bien..... Topspin2k25: No sweating , no dirt on clothes,no ball rebound on clay hard grass , Sampras agass faces etc......a joke . 13 years.. .13 f****** years..... Its amazing......

[@BornIntoThis20]

But if you pay 70€ for it they will probably make Topspin 2k26 a bit better and with PS4 graphics instead of PS3. So please show good will now! Also Sampras and Agassi are some of the top actual ATP players these days as everyone knows so please stop complaining. Djokovic is a joke, he doesn't exist (or maybe later for an extra 30€ DLC? 😊)

[@leftybrasco3206]

2k26? 😂 The next is 2k37 Top spin 4 is better . Its Real

[@BornIntoThis20]

@@leftybrasco3206 yeah I'm starting to think the same, 2k25 is so slow..

[@PLRNZOO]

Remember when the best tennis game stopped releasing sequels? And we just got whatever you call TWT and AO tennis and a few other terrible games? I will reiterate how absolutely terrible those games were. If you’d prefer staying in that bleak reality, dont buy ts2k25. I’d rather get a new game despite it looking exactly the same as an old game for my ps5 because the alternative is absolute trash. I hope the next topspin is better, but for bow take my money

[@GamingDeskmetaverse87]

Top Spin 4 is pure beauty even to this date...

[@jespPH9196]

You forgot gameplay.

[@steveokingdom5883]

Gameplay is wayyyy smoother in 5.animationa are also better in 5. You people need glasses

[@bullymaquire8797]

@@steveokingdom588313 years better? Not even close.

[@takeyourtime3328]

I hope day one patch is going make shots more flat, with higher speed and longer in 2k25. The gameplay definitely lacks of dynamic, speed and shots that touches the baseline

[@jasontomica8938]

The ball speed is so slow on 2k25 weird!!!!

[@sportschool3537]

@@jasontomica8938 No it's not... the player playing just sucks ass... his timing is godawful and he barely puts any power in his shots... so of course it's gonna be slow... plus the AI is obviously not at a top tier level... to judge the speed of the game you need to watch two players who are very good or at least someone who can take the AI at the highest difficulty...

[@_Frexil_]

@@jasontomica8938 no don't worry about gameplay, that is not the game but the (new) player testing the game. The gameplay is a strict copy from TS4 said the dev

[@jasontomica8938]

@@_Frexil_ I noticed with the $120 version. Is it locking courts if you don't buy that version? I hope all the courts are unlocked. That would be crazy with the only Tennis game that ever did that. Do you know about that art is the? Regular version unlock all the courts

[@sportschool3537]

@thefedhd1580 Exactly... also you need to make the ball just a tiny bit faster than TS4 on power shots but otherwise TS4 had very good ball speed to both be realistic and give the player enough time to both react and think his next shot...

[@thelemonones_band]

4:12 grunting for that slice and semi volley is wild

[@nozw100]

😂

[@damanichildrey84]

it's something about low quality textures and the pronounce sounds of Topspin 4 that bring it together.

[@marchmadness76]

Top Spin 4 still the king of tennis games, for the consoles.

[@TennisExperience]

13 years later its still the best game on consoles lol

[@markhewer9999]

Virtua tennis 3 if you ask me

[@Fascistbeast]

Is it just me or Top Spin 3 and 4 the faces and players look better. They look like paper in the new one especially close up. Modern gaming is weird now omg

[@TheMessi2014]

top spin 4 is one of the kings in sports games in general. for me at least. top 5 sports game ever (no, i dont include any racing, because even though f1 is a sport, its a racing game ofc)

[@jackwei22]

Virtua Tennis series which is amazing gameplay wise such an addictive series could play it for hours.

[@ambizytl]

First thing I noticed is ball speed shows in Top Spin 4 but not in 2K5. Also, seems to me sound is a bit louder/crisper in Top Spin 4. If they don't have an audio listing of names possible for created players, then they should make Top Spin 4 for current consoles.

[@nanonkay5669]

2K: * take 13 years to improve graphics, lighting, add new players, improve sound, slight gameplay tweaks* Also 2K: "That was a lot of work. We should sell this at full price"

[@z0rrer0]

TS4 is much better. TS2K25 is too slow :-\

[@jespPH9196]

The question are they the same difficulty setting? It looks like they were played with different setting.

[@jespPH9196]

@thefedhd1580 I know what you are talking about. I dont know if you got my point in here, I am just noticed that in TS2k25, players specially Alcaraz in some point are not trying to hit a far ball while in TS4 either player are constantly reaching for the far ball to hit. I am just thinking that maybe the setting of the TS2k25 needs to be a step higher so the players will always try to reach far balls. Thats it, I like the video and still like both TS. .

[@takeyourtime3328]

@thefedhd1580 difficulties don't affect the speed of you hitting the ball which looks too slow in and not really flat in ts2k25

[@BornIntoThis20]

Yeah it's slow, looks like they're playing with the Moon gravity. Moonspin 2k25. Serves are floating..

[@sportschool3537]

@@takeyourtime3328 Well, if you suck as a player (and this guy does suck) you don't hit the ball very hard and also your timing is meh so the ball goes slow... the devs did say that they wanted to boost perfect shots... so in this new game highly skilled players will have a bigger skill gap against mediocre players and that's how it should be... I was a top 0.1% worldwide player in FIFA back in 2013 to 2015 and if I played against a Division 5 player (mediocre) I would massacre him 10+ to nothing... that's how it should be... in today's FIFA these same players do muuuuch better cause the skill gap is nothing these days as everything is "assisted" which means the game plays for you... Anyway... if you see two top tier players play this game is not slow at all... but this guy is barely a mediocre player... not even close to good or great...

[@ambizytl]

Top Spin 2K5 is alright, but Top Spin overall is to me a better experience. Thus, I went and got a PS3 Super Slim and a few brand new sealed Top Spin 4's to help with my anxiety level.

[@user-uk7lb8dy7p]

Top Spin 4 appears to be superior. The reason is the sound of the ball, the speed of the ball and the form.

[@vahanboyajyan7407]

Both are unreal. How can all rallies be so long in a real match

[@Kanchen8]

¿Como se puede hacer un juego igual o peor incluso más de una década después ? Nos toman por tontos

[@jasontomica8938]

BALL SPEED IS WAY TO SLOW ON 2K25, WTH IS GOING ON, THE SERVE IS SO SLOW ALSO????

[@troyknights3342]

Watch a video of people actually playing the game instead of this guy who’s purposely trying to make the game look worse

[@onedrawingman]

I need to say that i don’t understand how the 3 previous top spin games (top spin 2, 3 and 4) had beter graphics, physics, body language, sound and graphic design off ball shots??? I mean thank god for at least this much, because we didn’t have good tennis game for over a decade… But, still, this makes me a little sad.

[@laurentfravel6114]

Sur ce que je vois c'est le même jeu que top spin 4 , mais juste moins bien, que ce soit graphiquement, au niveau du roster je t'en parle même pas, et les cris de singes, non c'est pas sérieux tout ça. On est quand même en 2025, la PS3 envoie la Ps5 à la poubelle😢

[@jonathanluciani8839]

Clairement ça sent le gros navet… tu as raison Bon après faut pas être trop sévère il n’ont eu que 13ans……. lol Sérieux…

[@vanessajaud-pastels-peintu3840]

je confirme mon copain y est la franchement les graphisme c'est abusé.... il trouve aussi le jeu lent, j'espère qu'ils vont faire vite des mises a jours, à croire qu'ils ont pris le 4 qu'ils lont un peu modif pour la 5... lol 13 ans comme vous dites c'est dec

[@jaimepastagueule6449]

Même le gameplay je le trouve supérieur sur Top Spin 4, mouvements plus naturels, plus réalistes 🤝

[@FoxyJohn]

Yup. I agree.

[@totalnirvana]

Sauf que sur ps3, le jeu met des plombes à se charger. Insupportable de nos jours…

[@ambizytl]

Another thing I noticed is moving along in Career mode is easier in Top Spin 4, especially for beginners.

[@wally19]

I'm currently playing TS 2k25 carrer mode, and sometimes you feel those WTF moments, like unreal movements from the AI that piss me off. I mean, do I need to lose this match no matter what?

[@Nino-gaming42]

Ce dernier top spin redonne envie de jouer a l'ancien fin du debat 😅

[@jaymontero1529]

Grave je viens de ressortir la Xbox 360

[@user-ho8qr8jp7g]

Étant un grand fan de top spin 4, je suis dégoûté.cest le meme jeu en moins bien... A l'époque du Ray tracying.... Allez sérieux... Je continue sur sf6... Bye

[@richiguru7564]

When we need a remaster/port we get a new game, when we need a new game we get a remaster. Sods law. Glad I had the foresight to check online reviews before buying 😥 condolences to those that didn't.

[@preedapreeda7818]

Not different, only better graphic . But still want to play

[@flamingo8445]

As a tennis player, I jest remember top spin 2 and I think to myself "what kind of sh*t they're making these days"...

[@Oumpah-Pah]

Top Spin 4 was so much better, just listen to the game sounds, the way it sounds when the ball is hit. The new game has lousy sounds, everything is muffled. I liked the movement and graphics better too. I wish they would have just remastered the old game.

[@renatodteixeira]

Unacceptable that the actual game made 13 years after the previous one is worse, absolutely unacceptable. I loved so much TS4 and was wondering on buying the 2k25, I gave up fellas, I'll try to get TS4 again instead

[@JeanThomasdeVoghel]

So, I deactivated all the bars and visual indicators. And then, you no longer concentrate on a gauge bar, you just look at the ball, your player and when to hit it like on a real court... it's 100x more enjoyable. Your timings are less good at first, but little by little everything becomes more logical and fluid, you hit the ball better and better while having more fun. Online, there should be a mode where all visual aids are deactivated, to have real tennis game, with human imperfections.

[@SalaciousBCrumb-rr3jn]

Which one should I get. £65 for 2k25 or £1 from CEX for 4. Tough choice.

[@robwilliamson6181]

£35 now in CEX

[@vijisrangoli]

Only game that keeps getting better and better is Euro Truck Simulator 2 lol

[@jeremyhayez9013]

Les cris des joueurs ça va pas du tout. Puis TS 2K25 a l'air beaucoup plus lent

[@TennisExperience]

Oui malheureusement c'était pareil sur top spin 4, mais c'est vrai que les cris de alcaraz c'est pas trop ça 😅

[@BornIntoThis20]

Ils ont enregistré Alcaraz quand il était aux toilettes 😅

[@jeremyhayez9013]

@@BornIntoThis20 je pense qu'il était ailleurs qu'aux toilettes. Moi j'espère juste un MyCareer plus complet, car je sais que sur le TS4, on démarrait 80eme mondial donc ça allait très vite

[@sengyo]

​@@BornIntoThis20mdrrr 😅

[@_Frexil_]

mais non le jeu n'est pas plus lent, c'est juste que le testeur sur 2K25 est visiblement un débutant.

[@louisl5086]

They should have just remastered top spin 4. I would have been so happy. The sound effects on top spin 2k are flat

[@glonzai2005]

Andy roddick trademark serve is enjoyable to play imin top spin 4. No nadal & djokovic seems not complete

[@BornIntoThis20]

Insert meme *They're the same picture* Damn I even think I prefer TS4 dynamism and gesture animations, looks smoother. Such a lazy port...

[@master-jj7um]

no one saying how bad was the sound effects in TS4 lol

[@rickyrosario9304]

Looks so awkward when they stand there flat footed waiting to hit a groundstroke

[@jpp409]

c'est normal, le mec ne sait pas jouer, il rate tous ses coups, si il mettait tout dans le vert la balle par très bien, mais là c'est lent car il rate tout

[@_Frexil_]

exactement. Cet effet de lenteur n'est du qu'au fait qu'on a un bon joueur dans le TS4 et un débutant dans le 2K5.

[@flodes8841]

La seule chose meilleure dans top spin 2k25 c'est le son. Le gameplay est à la hauteur aussi. Gros soucis, le roster, les graphismes, bien que moi je m'en fou. Par contre le fait qu'il n'y ai pas les traces sur terre battue en 2024, c'est moyen.

[@ramyward23]

To be honest, it's ridiculous, nonsense, and a provocation to the tennis game audience after waiting 13 years for them to release a tennis game at least of the same quality as NBA, PES, or even FIFA! 1- The gameplay is not better than the previous game released in 2011! 2- The graphics are bad and not realistic (especially Roger Federer) as if it's a game released in 2014, not 2024! The shape of the bodies, their movement, and the footwork, all of this is not good, and the ball is very slow, especially in the serve or perfect high power shots. The smash takes maybe more than a second to win the point, while in reality, the shot is over and the point is won in a fraction of a second! 3- There are many missing players, which is a shameful and fatal flaw. At the very least, the top 25 ranked men and the top 25 ranked women should be included, in addition to 25 retired stars and legends, and 25 retired female stars and legends! The NBA game has hundreds of players, stars, and legends, and each special star has more than one version, and teams like the Chicago Bulls, Celtics, or Lakers have more than one version. So why doesn't the company show half this interest in a tennis game as it does in a basketball game? 4- The issue of repetitive and unrealistic tournaments and awards is also ridiculous, annoying, and boring. Are they incapable of caring about this stuff? Or are they truly developers who are not specialized in sports, and tennis in particular, and all they did was build the game on the foundations of Top Spin 4 and make it worse in the end! 5- The issue of making, developing, and training the player is also not as good as the NBA game, and the weak value of the (VC) awards to make us have to pay a lot of money to develop and buy things it is laughable. When you want me to pay you, you should provide a service worth the money, and not ask me for more for nothing! 6- I hope that a new company will develop and release a respectable game that is at least affiliated with the Tennis Federation, and has all the licenses, tournaments, logos, clothing, and accessories, and includes all the players we love, the legends, and the new talents. Shame on 2K for what they offer us; this is more like a free game, not a game priced at 70+ dollars and 120 dollars!

[@vmdz2]

The sound is amazing in the game top Spin 4

[@manolovincentvegadu3788]

Non mais 13 ans pour ça?? C'est pas sérieux là, ça régresse ou c'est moi?

[@cooler9432]

Ils n'ont pas mis 13 ans, ta rien compris lol

[@smoralbr]

2k25 looks like Virtua Tennis

[@charliedurie3013]

Wow. Topspin 4 which which was released 13 years ago looks better! 😂

[@robwilliamson6181]

It's crazy. MW 2019 on the ps4 still looks better than the current one on the ps5 lol

[@ronartest8638]

how is it possible to make a game worst 13 years ago, and without djoko or nadal this era is hilarious

[@robwilliamson6181]

Lazy devs

[@ChimpRiot]

I guess I’m never packing away my Xbox 360.

[@josefernando6186]

Better ball physics, that's good.

[@Lucian86]

Looks exactly the same to me

[@jackfeinster2933]

​@@Lucian86 Yep, it's the same

[@sportschool3537]

@@jackfeinster2933 No, it's not... shots have a bit more realistic ball drop... it's not much of a difference but it's there... plus the devs literally said they're slightly improving the Top Spin 4 formula... they never said their new game would be massively different... they made a good game and they're respecting that game... which is good unless you're stupid and you wanna re-invent the wheel every day... when FIFA was the best football game of all time back in 2013-2015 the key was that it respected it's gameplay and every year they changed only tiny tiny little things... the players were whining about how it was stale and the same... and then the devs changed it up and fucked up everything and now it's a joke of a game... when you have a good product you don't change the whole thing... you're stupid if you do...

[@jackfeinster2933]

@@sportschool3537 I see, thanks for the info !

[@_Frexil_]

@@sportschool3537 so why FIFA is now a shit game ?

[@scotchy0976]

Should of been called top spin 4 remaster 😂😂😂

[@SangAcquiescentFroid]

Even the grunts in Top Spin 4 are better

[@sergiosimbula]

Points are way shorter in 2k25

[@Florent_Stienne]

Clairement Top Spin 4 m'apparaît meilleur, en tout. Vitesse de jeu, réalisme du bruit des pas, transpiration... Cette mouture 2k25 fait tout plus lentement apparemment. Mais le comble de l'exagération ce sont ces cris poussifs d'Alcaraz rien que pour un slice... Même un tennis elbow 4 ou Full Ace sont plus cohérents en terme de reproduction des caractéristiques des joueurs. Plus on avance, plus les développeurs se foutent de la gueule des gens, pognon quand tu nous tiens.

[@hawkeye7740]

Tennis Elbow is way better and way cheaper

[@rcertac45]

Why the PS3 version looks way better? Ball physique, game speed, rallies, excitement...

[@videogamesart8057]

OMG, TS4 has better animations, player motion and sounds!! Just some slightly better graphic details in TS5, see the court, but not graphics of the characters. The gameplay looks the same. That's weird! After 13 years you would improve game intelligence to have some more rich gameplay and unlikely situations, just like in real tennis. See the odd shots in many youtube archive videos. Plus, many complain about invasive in-game purchases in TS5 and mandatory on-line connection. All reviewers give TS5 ratings way lower than TS4.

[@dandan3045]

will wait once it hits $10 on sale.

[@TennisExperience]

you can wait 😅

[@ersincandemir2448]

4 much better

[@souhailtahiri2572]

Top spin 5😢😢😢 top spin 4 ❤

[@Nr2003isfun]

They copy and pasted the game… but removed all the players 😂😂

[@_Sokarbank_]

No..ts4 looks better😂

[@mpa1931]

Top Spin 3 was even better than both of them

[@rafaelodossantos4210]

La balle est ultra lente

[@_Frexil_]

Very bad player 2K5. Graphisms a bit better in 13 years ! What a shame ! But anyway i never played TS4 because i'm a PC player and i refused to buy a PS4 only for 1 game. So thank you 2K for this game on PC ^^ They should do the same with EA and UFC5

[@rafaelodossantos4210]

Alcaraz is shouting as if he was trying to make a poo

[@gauravthemagicalman]

just release the top spin 4 for pc. we don't need this high priced gimmick.

[@dnugros412]

4 is obvious better

[@Moose185]

Top spin 4 looks better, they completely ruined top spin 2k 25

[@psyche6580]

Top Spin 4 ❤

[@ver.1.580]

2k25 is as boring as playing wall tennis.

[@rabyanaz623]

I think world tour tennis will suit you

[@gouedallica]

Top spin 4 doesnt exist on PC ..

[@CarlosAkox]

put the emulator

[@troyknights3342]

He’s playing the game purposely bad

[@tancredelegalileen9777]

It looks terrible, Tennis Elbow is far superior

[@EugeneMiora]

Top spin 2k25, big scam.

[@enricovaioli]

federer movements are way way better .. just it… other thinks are almost the same … maybe worse than ts4… 13 year after ahaha … okok i’ll buy it whatever 😭🥲

[@sportschool3537]

People these days are retarded... if you watch the video you easily see that all the animations are way better... not just Federer... but of course this is 2024... gamers only shit on everything cause whining is "cool" these days and never give any valuable feedback to devs cause all they do is complain about everything so the devs most of the time can't even tell which parts of the game are bad since according to their audience "everything is bad"... and of course players never offer an idea... only say "it sucks"... well, how can we make it better genius??? Ummm... "I don't know... it just sucks... you suck... you all suck..." This is society in 2024... thankfully I grew up in the 90s when getting a new game made us actually grateful and we didn't complain about everything cause we were gamers... we were happy to experience what was offered... today people want every game to be magically built exactly as they imagined it in their head and if it's not 100% that way they just shit on it, use a fuckton of emojis (which shows a serious lack of IQ) and throw a tantrum like a 5yo.... If the game is sooooo bad then don't fucking buy it and play Top Spin 4 and shut the fuck up... there are only two options with a product.. you either buy it or you don't... and if you buy it then you have no fucking right to whine about it being bad... you bought it... so deal with it... if you bought a bad product knowingly then question your IQ, not the maker... you're the stupid one...

[@rabyanaz623]

Hahahaha this is the state we are in 😂😂 how pathetic games they have released since top spin 4