The Church’s Secret Gospel Revealed! -Rabbi Tovia Singer

Help us combat aggressive Jewish evangelism in Israel: outreachjudais...
Let’s Get Biblical Study Guide (Volume 1 & 2) outreachjudais...
outreachjudais...
www.videvo.net
/ tenaktalk
Music: www.purple-pla...
Music at the end: Adon Olam • ''Adon Olam'' (Eternal...
www.toviasinger...
#toviasinger #Judaism #Christianity #Messiah

[@Ohnpro]

Rabbi Tovia; I know your ministry is primarily to rescue lost Jews. But in the process you’ve also rescued so many of us Gentiles. I bless HaShem for this age; an age where people of all backgrounds are discovering the Eternal truth of the Torah. HaShem grant you many years Rabbi.

[@stoggsherfnik4569]

I hope soon he will Include advice and pathways to conversion

[@Moss2004]

Amén to that! Thank You Hashem!

[@tippytalk]

The Jews were meant to reach out to all the nations, I am so glad there are some Jews that are finally doing it

[@titusthegreat7434]

It’s amazing how y’all think y’all can approach hashem without Yeshua.

[@tippytalk]

@@titusthegreat7434 If you are talking about Jesus, we are saying he is a false messiah. It seems amazing to someone who is sold on Christianity, but to someone like me it is amazing how anyone can actually believe 'the virgin birth' I can't see how anyone can buy into it. No disrespect meant, just really sounds like you have to be totally innocent to believe such things.

[@antonioreid534]

I am Antonio. Thanks Rabbi, and you’re way up there too. Truly truly, you are “Avad HaElohim” in our day.

[@ToviaSinger1]

You are smart! Great question! Shabbat shalom

[@BattleofAlgiers-o9d]

J3sus the Messiah will return. Thank God for the truth. Thank God for Islam 😊

[@antonioreid534]

@@BattleofAlgiers-o9d I don’t understand your sentiment at all. How is Jesus the messiah if he doesn’t fulfill any of the prophecies of the messiah in what Christians call the “Old Testament?” And what would Islam have to do with revealing that truth? Islam essentially has a similar view of Jesus as the Ebionites or Nazarenes who believed Jesus was a righteous human, not a divine being necessarily.

[@sjenner76]

Rabbi Singer, thank you for this and your other videos. I was raised in a dual-faith household, but ultimately I found my way to Judaism. There is a richness in tradition and diversity of thought and debate within Judaism that genuinely would leave the vast majority of Christians, Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant alike, gasping for breath. And I believe for most, they would find the familiarity of the stories, but diverse difference in their interpretation, disorienting. Because Christianity tends to flatten the Tanakh to just one use and aim: the Christ and his justification. While in Judaism they are given complete dimension, in all dimensions, because they get to stand on their own. At least as it appears to me when I read the New Testament, on its own terms, Christianity presents as an oddly dualistic narrative superimposed onto Judaism. From its structure to what it says and how, the New Testament feels like how Ancient Greek and Romans, perhaps somewhat knowledgeable about aspects of Judaism but not entirely understanding of it, would try to interpret it and find for themselves a place within it. Is it a surprise then that Christianity feels so Roman? Jesus comes not as Messiah but as Christ; a condemnation to the Jews but a light to the Empire. And remarkably, it’s the Jews who get the blame while Pontius Pilatus is just a good Roman Procurator dealing with the unruly Jewish rabble (a very Roman bureaucratic perspective).

[@Jason-Jason]

May Hashem continue to bless Rav Singer and William.

[@saschamilenkovic4320]

Really good! This must be one of Tovia's best. Impeccable understanding displayed here. Anyone who is seriously interested in finding out for themselves get yourself a good translation of the Tanakh and get reading. It'll be worth it. No cherry picking and taking verses out of context. We Gentiles have done this for too long. Develop your own relationship with God. Have courage.

[@saschamilenkovic4320]

@V_George @V_George I have it and no it isn't. It's centuries old. Not accessible at all. Unless you still live in the 17th century and speak and think that way. Also corrupted in a few places on top of that. Once you've looked at the Hebrew original you'll know you can't rely on the KJV. The KJV is based on the Masoretic Text, just like my Koren Tanakh is. Same source. Difference is the Tanakh is readable and understandable whereas the KJV is deliberately archaic to put peole off reading it, so that the Church can tell you what it means by cherry picking and taking verses out of context. The Koren version has the Hebrew original on the left of every single page. Does your KJV? And if not, why not? Ever wondered?

[@samvoron1727]

@@Viral_Christology Beware of Books that add or subtract to what is in the Tanakh Jewish scriptures. God said the first commandment of God is "God is one" and do not add or subtract from the word of God (for example by adding God is "three in one" or by adding Antichrist or by adding fallen angels). Do not let your knowledge come from books like the KJV Bible, Book of Enoch, Book of Jubilees and Book of Revelation and the Epistle of Jude 1:6 which contradict Tanakh because both the Gospel (Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3) and the Quran (Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and Quran 5:68) confirm Tanakh is the truth from God for example teachings about fallen angels contradict the Tanakh (Torah and Prophets and writings) meaning books like the Book of Enoch did not come from God because the Book of Enoch and similar books contradict God in Tanakh Hebrew scripture where angels always obey God and angels never rebel against God and angels never fight with each other in heaven or fight with each other on the Earth and angels never have intimate relations with woman and Satan was never a rebellious fallen angel meaning all such teachings are not from God. . Giants in the KJV Bible is a wrong translation of the Hebrew word Nephilim which means powerful people like kings, and princess and judges who fell from the mercy of God (because of their wicked behaviour when they forced women to have children with them) and also comes from the Book of Enoch and Book of Jubilees which is not accepted as canonical scripture by most Jewish and Christian sects. . The Book of Enoch and Book of Jubilees is not accepted as canonical scripture by most Jewish sects because it mentions fallen angels which contradicts the teachings in Tanakh Jewish scripture where angels always obey God meaning angels never fall from the mercy of God because angels never disobey God and angels never fight with each other in heaven or on the earth. . In Tanakh Jewish scripture angels never rebel meaning all Old Testament Bibles with mistranslations of the Hebrew were not inspired by God and all books that mention fallen angels were not inspired by God but followed ideas contained in Books like the Book of Enoch which mentions fallen angels and is not accepted in Judaism because it contradicts Tanakh Jewish scripture where angels are created to be the messengers between God and His creation meaning they never rebel. . Anything that contradicts the Tanakh is not canonical. In Tanakh angels always obey God therefore all stories about fallen angels contradict the Torah and are rejected because the word of God cannot contradict meaning anything that contradicts Tanakh is not inspired by God. . Old Testament Bibles are Christian translations of Jewish scripture and are not used in Judaism because most contain wrong translations of Hebrew words and different verse numbers and wrong tenses. Jewish people use the Tanakh Jewish scripture.

[@anonymousanonymous-qx7mv]

​@@kenny87ification another pagan religion?

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

@@kenny87ification Another trinity? No thanks.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

@@kenny87ification The belief in a divine trinity is an idolatrous concept, since it is a belief that God (or according to some, a second separate divinity) has characteristic features, and the characteristics of a body.

[@LoreneRaeWard]

Thank you for being here for all of us. We all have much to learn each and every one of us. I ❤ listening and learning from you!

[@oracleofaltoona]

I am very relieved to hear what the Rabbi is saying in these videos. something has always seemed "off" to me about what I heard preached in (Catholic) church. Now I know why.

[@dorothyjohnson6743]

Same for me. ​@@oracleofaltoona

[@bigtomboye]

🙏 Fascinating as always

[@noahgoldsworthy1159]

May HaShem continue to give you, and William, many mitzvot. Yasher koach to you both for what you do.

[@lynmills6436]

It amazes me how blind and ignorant I was before I started listening to you, I thank Hashem for sending you to me with your wealth of knowledge. Why would anyone believe the mashiach is a mystery that only a very few should or can know. Praise be to Hashem that this isn't true. Thankyou Rabbi Tovia.

[@frankfortjuggalo5936]

You got fooled by his half truths, if you read the Gospels for your self you will find that Jesus revealed himself as the Messiah plenty of times made the high priest mad by doing so on more than one occasion.

[@lynmills6436]

I have read the gospels I was a born again Christian for many years and never got my questions answered fully because of " half truths" as you call it from the Christian side. I know now I only need to repent and I'm forgiven,(Ezekiel 18: 21- 23) no man can die for another's sin (Exodus 32: 30-35, Deuteronomy 24:16, Ezekiel 18 whole chapter and Jeremiah 31:29-30. Read the Torah and you will see that Hashem wants a personal relationship with you alone and doesn't need to go through a man he's created to do so. Please start at the beginning and you will see ❤❤

[@frankfortjuggalo5936]

@@lynmills6436 Thank you for the response, I have been watching this Rabbi to get a better perspective of why the Jews still don't accept Jesus. I opened my Bible and read all the scriptures you sent me and in my response I would say that as far as Exodus 32:30-35 goes Moses could not forgive them of their sins because he is not the Messiah. As for Deuteronomy 24:16 Ezekiel chapter 18 Unless you are saying that you are now without sin or have never committed a sin, both of which would be a lie, then this still applies to you and only reminded me of Romans 3:23-25 For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God; Being justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus: Whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood, to declare his righteous for the remission of sins that are past, through the forbearance of God. I looked at Jeremiah 31:39-30 and all I got out of that was if you read the next two verses you see God's promise of the new covenant. And yes you are correct no man can die in behalf of your sins. Jesus was not a man, he is God that became man. Luke 5:24 But that ye may know that the Son of man hath the power upon earth to forgive sins 1 John 5:7 For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one. 1 Timothy 3:16 And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory.

[@frankfortjuggalo5936]

@@lynmills6436 I read all the scriptures you sent me and yes Mosus was not able to forgive sins because he was not the Christ. As for the other scriptures unless you are saying that you are now without sin or have never sinned both of which would be a lie then this still applies to you. And made me think of Romans 3:23-25 And you are correct a man can not die in behalf of your sins. Jesus was not a man he is God that became man. 1 John 5:7 1 Timothy 3:16 1 Corinthians 8:6 2 Corinthians 13:14 Colossians 2:9 Isaiah 9:6 Isaiah 44:6 John 14:9-11 Revelation 22:12-13

[@frankfortjuggalo5936]

@@lynmills6436 and thank you for your reply, I am just trying to get a idea of of others people's beliefs and understanding. 🙏

[@charleslitherbury8600]

Thanks to you Rabbi Singer, May the whole World hear your teaching! God Bless!

[@BattleofAlgiers-o9d]

J3sus the Messiah will return. Thank God for the truth. Thank God for Islam 😊

[@ranmatardis4236]

I received my Stone edition of the Tanach and decided to look up these chapters. The christian new testament is somewhat abridged. It changes the meaning from editing. Yes Rabbi Singer says this but there is nothing like reading it for yourself. Something about myself, I started going to church during my deployment to Iraq and when my spouse passed away became more involved. All of my life I have had a calling to be Jewish. I believe I have not so distant ancestors that were Jewish. I have lost my faith in the Christian Church. What sort of God is spilt up into three equal parts but is still one? If they were one, why do they talk to each other?

[@atomnous]

Don't believe in Christian doctrines, just read the Gospels, there is no co-equal trinity whatsoever in there.

[@ranmatardis4236]

@@atomnous The New Testament is the problem. I overlooked the problems and then one day could no longer read fiction. Might as well find God in a comic book. It is either conversion or atheist. There are NO Orthodox Jewish Synagogues in Oklahoma. I can remain a Noahide or become a conservative Jew.

[@ranmatardis4236]

@@atomnous it is too late to stop conversion. After reading the Tanak, I can see the truth.

[@powerfulaura5166]

@@ranmatardis4236 You should survey the historical evidence for the resurrection of Christ, He had God's stamp of approval.

[@NelJes]

They talked to each other because God wants to "show and prove" that He sent Jesus (Himself) into the world for rescued us. Not talk for themselves, talk for show us.

[@ronaldbezemer8439]

@isaaclosh8082 - I agree! It is unprecedented how much knowledge Tovia Singer brings to light here. These types of contributions shake the Christian faith to its foundations.

[@elroi8325]

Lol it's been two thousand years this way, Christianity started from few to billions. Shake Shake 😂😂 maybe that guy shake

[@lawanddisorder903]

As a Muslim now (and a former Christian), I still like to trawl through the New Testament from time-to-time and try to make sense of it all. I've come quite a way in doing that, I think, but this video revealed as much to me in sixteen minutes as years of reading have done. Paul was really a Gnostic. Now, some of his truly weird pronouncements make perfect sense. Every Christian should watch this presentation.

[@liljade53]

this is garbage. Paul was not a gnostic. So absurd

[@LiaPelitawati-gs4hb]

Alhamdulillah

[@swaterman2017]

I was also a Christian now muslim early in my journey I used to listen to Rabi singers by grace of Allah he became a torch to the truth about New Testament .

[@TheBrandgineer]

​​@@swaterman2017You should use Tovia Singer on Isa. Based on his assertions that the Jewish Messiah must be from the tribe of Judah and the only way for a Jewish child to inherit his tribe is from the father (Ezra 2:59 and Numbers 1:18) Thus, because Isa doesn't have a father, he cannot be the Jewish Messiah. Jesus has no problem. I've found evidence that an adopted father can pass his tribe to a son. I love turning the tables on Muslims who follow this false rabbi. Because if one does research, one will find a bunch of evidence from Jewish sources themselves refuting Singer. BTW, I'm pretty certain that 2 Muslims who followed Singer and tried to destroy the NT, have apostotized from Islam because of me 😂 Heck, Singer helped me go from an atheist to become a Christian

[@321ssteeeeeve]

There are some who present a possibility that everything Paul wrote did not express his own opinions, that it was merely a (failed) ruse to infiltrate and thwart an extremist sect (led by Yeshua) at the time whose planned uprising would cause what ultimately happened 70 ad.

[@tylrchnlt]

Profound ‼️

[@bb1111116]

Yes. There are several things which Rabbi Singer has masterfully put together in this video about Paul’s Greek/Roman/pagan religious creation which became Christianity.

[@bookmouse2719]

Thank you Rabbi

[@mariawolf5843]

🎉❤❤❤thks rav Tovia Singer HaShem s blessing to you to your family and all Israel. Shalom Myriam

[@shainanash8518]

I love the commentary and the music. I love Adon Olam.

[@DeanneSanchez-q8u]

I just started listening to your podcasts and I’m learning so much I’m so grateful Thank you so much 🤎

[@franstein9277]

Thank you for this information

[@jamesfields2249]

Shalom Rabbi Singer.. Another great lecture dissecting, christian heresy and paganism. Thank you for continuing in obedience to “The Book of the Law.” Serving as a light to the nations, be Blessed…😊

[@muhammadrehman6395]

Sholom Rabbai.. may your blessed continue to enlighten the believer's of Prophet Abraham monotheism! Your work has changed me and many other's to there attitude towards Jews and even towards the need for existence of Israel. May eternal peace return to that land.. Amen

[@dorothyjohnson6743]

You are very good at cutting through the confusion and getting to the nitty-gritty thank. I m so happy to have found thi

[@bertikahernandez93]

I can’t get enough of your teachings Rabbi 😊

[@pamelaleibowitz3019]

Thank you Rabbi!

[@andrewmays3988]

I love your mind, Tovia, and how your use of it is bringing profound understanding and knowledge into a forlorn world. Thank you !!!!!😇

[@davidmadge5811]

I have conversed (Twitter/X) with a popular KZbinr Christian who regularly points out the ignorance of people (many topics, but especially Americana). When I challenged him about the contradictions between Jesus and Paul, he replied with a very Pauline stance. (For example, Jesus, “I have not come to destroy the Law, but to fulfil in Matthew). This Christian took a very Pauline stance and then I never heard from him again. He had become what he preached against (ignorance).

[@corneliuskinara3369]

Can I see the contractions between Paul and Jesus...I am ready to answer you.

[@georgethomas9343]

​@@corneliuskinara3369He gave you a example...go ahead scholor

[@abdar-rahman6965]

Paul was a hijacker

[@KenMills-l6e]

Thank you for the true light and your shirt tales hanging on tight

[@josephnyongesa193]

Baruk Hashem! Just gained a new insight into this gnostic idea. Wow! Rav, May Hashem grant you long life so that you can continue spreading the light of Torah from Jerusalem B`ezrat Hashem.

[@sissy9393]

Great for you! It’s so much fun when this happens! I hope you have learned much more since. 🙏🏼✌🏻♥️

[@Mojtala41]

I have an Islamic background and have left religion forty years ago, but still interested in religion. I think Mr. Tovia Singer exposed this question masterly. Thank you.

[@bulldogface8259]

Other awesome video 💯

[@asseryarafat-f6j]

Tovia is my Jewru.😂

[@bigtomboye]

Love it ✅

[@susanlett9632]

💜❤️

[@BattleofAlgiers-o9d]

J3sus the Messiah will return. Thank God for the truth. Thank God for Islam 😊

[@isaaclosh8082]

Rabbi Singer should have 840,000 subscribers not 84,000. Go sign up your friends

[@susanlett9632]

I'm a Noahide and recommend him to other Noahides and to xtians struggling. I've been there and it's agonizing

[@CYMRUKID69]

​@@susanlett9632I have walked the same road. Thankfully I've now left Christianity behind and have embraced the noahide laws. Glory to God for guiding me to the truth.

[@mennavanessa]

He used to have many Muslim subscribers but we all left when a video of him saying that Al aqsa mosque should be destroyed came up

[@dartheater7348]

​@@rollingknuckleballhe said noahidism. Its not Judaism. It is the 7 basic rules that Judaism recommends for non-jews to have granted access to heaven/world to come. Christians can also go to heaven, as well as most non-jews. Judaism does not believe in eternal damnation and almost everyone spends a short amount of time in hell. This is usually a few months, which is effectively zero time in comparison to eternal heaven

[@dartheater7348]

​@@mennavanessacompletely out of context

[@johngallati8164]

AMAZING

[@GilbertGreich]

Todah Rabba!

[@karenabrams8986]

Sketchy texts is an understatement.

[@TheJo201]

Rabbi you are Absolutely Correct

[@yonason6047]

😳 WOW! I knew it was a 🦨 , but that takes it to the next level, as it were. Thx!

[@ZubairKhan-vs8fe]

Fascinating

[@mauriciolopez1235]

I was in a gnostic sect for about 12 years. I can atest to this 100% .

[@chrysostomos347]

Were you in a gnostic sect in the first century?

[@mauriciolopez1235]

@@chrysostomos347 The so called masters claim the gnostic movement has no time beginnings of endings. I don't know what you need to prove. I got initiations and so called occult knowledge that's what I mean about understanding Paul's gnostic teachings.

[@chrysostomos347]

What was the sect? Just curious @@mauriciolopez1235

[@Tys-k5o]

It's the quality and not the quantity, dear rabbi singer Hashem is very proud of you, who doesn't understand it now is different for every person, but the seed of the core has been 🌷 🌷 planted.

[@chrisstathe9183]

When it comes to salvation only the elect will understand truth and this is because the one who is the truth atoned for their sins before the world began and was obligated to finish this salvation at a appointed time.God is their righteousness through Jesus and this makes them blameless since Jesus was blameless.

[@bristolrovers27]

Interesting as always

[@YX_15]

The question was why in Mark 4:12 it seems to say that people will not hear the message; in Mark 4:11 Yeshua is speaking with the disciples and states, " “To you the secret of the Kingdom of God has been given; but to those outside, everything is in parables," the disciples were Jews. Yeshua is saying for those of you in the covenant with HaShem understand the secret or how the chosen people will Teshuva and return to Torah. If taken in context He seems to be pointing to the Torah.

[@timothylevin2661]

Good points, makes sense

[@joshmarkham9065]

Thank you, Rabbi.

[@Oneize]

Before the throne of God above I have a strong and perfect plea, a great High Priest whose name is "Love," who ever lives and pleads for me. My name is graven on His hands; my name is written on His heart; I know that while in heav'n He stands, no tongue can bid me thence depart; no tongue can bid me thence depart.

[@roberttucker5571]

Thanks for the video. 1 John 4:15

[@Matthew_Scan]

They found some early writings 15 or so years ago about Jesus that didn’t end up in the Christian Bible it says Mary Magdalene hung around with the apostles and Peter didn’t like her .

[@JohnHoulgate]

In the Gospel of Phillip, a non-canonical gospel that was considered a Gnostic text, reported a scene where Jesus openly kissed Mary the Magdalene on the mouth. Peter complained to the other apostles about it, saying that he favored her over them.

[@bookmouse2719]

Yes, but eventually they formed a group Peter, Paul and Mary.

[@BagzAndPresident]

The Gospel of Phillip, Mary, and Thomas all state that Peter did not like Mary Magdalene or women in general

[@JohnHoulgate]

@@bookmouse2719 Like all groups, they had to split.

[@JohnHoulgate]

@@tyronecox5976 You must have read Joe Atwill's Caesar's Messiah.

[@andrewfine2576]

How do we get Joe Rogan and Rabbi Singer to sit down together. Imagine the reach that could have

[@GetSaltySalt]

Thank you Rabbi Singer

[@CarolAnnD1]

God so loved the world he only told Paul, so everyone else would be guessing and go to hell if they didn’t understand. Not my God.

[@chrisstathe9183]

God loved the world and it points to only his elect by sending out the gospel to save them.

[@piouswhale]

Reformist theology is inherent contradictory and nonsensical

[@SeekingToServe]

😂 😊

[@alexanderrubino932]

​@@chrisstathe9183Get lost! Have you not realized you are most welcome to not listen to Rabbi Tovia Singer. Go read some of Calvin's dark theology books, or even De Nederlandshe Geloofshbelydenis. You'll love it! All grim, hell and brimstone for the *many unelected!* 😂😂

[@edwardmiessner6502]

🤣🤣

[@susanmullins7713]

My older reading plus this talk==💡💡💡💡

[@prophetkimape]

❤ @rabbiToviasinger I am KIMANI from Nairobi Kenya. Since I started to listen to you I have lost interest in Christianity. I have been a pastor since I was 12 years but now I hear preachers preach and I just hear lies. Thank you very much sir. May you live long to show us the way to Hashem Gadol. Shalom.

[@mooshei8165]

The secret is. Sin all you want as long as you believe in Jesus as the God, you’re going to heaven and the rest is going to hell.🎉

[@mooshei8165]

@@nathanielmash1897 no. That worshipping a man

[@naveedshaik7640]

😂😂😂

[@ru_ra]

Do you have any logic behind this statement? Do you not understand that’s exactly what satan wants you to follow? You are accountable for your wrong doing. I understand you are knee deep in it and accepting it is very scary but covering your eyes won’t make it disappear. You have been deceived.

[@Jasn_Chvz]

Amen

[@LP-MeAndMyShadow]

I believe everything you said is true. I also believe that all religions, including atheism, are like school grades. Not everyone is in kindergarten and not everyone is in university. In truth, eventually, we all grow up.

[@Nai61a]

LP etc: Just for clarification, atheism is not a religion.

[@dioclecianoayala3866]

The impact of Jesus Christ in the world!! Every time you say today is _ _ 2024 !!your are recognizing this is the year of our Lord Jesus Christ!!!

[@shaydowsith348]

That is like saying every time you say Thursday you are saying that Thor is g-d. Besides, we Jews have our own calendar which preceded and is not dependent on either the Gregorian or the Julian calendar. By the way, there is an Islamic, Chinese and there was a Mayan calendar as well. The domination of the Christian calendar has more to do with military dominance.

[@dioclecianoayala3866]

@shaydowsith348 whatever makes you 😊happy!!! Today is 10 06 2024 the year of our Lord JesusChrist and the world knows it !!that makes me super Happy 😄!!!

[@yosefbenavraham]

Wow, this is HUGE! And so brilliant! Wow, this is so brilliant. What insight to see it from the inside out and understand the underlying psychology. And then to clearly demonstrate that the entire apologetic sensibility and rationale of the NT is completely contradictory to and undermined by Tanach - wow! Why can't christians hear this?? It's so clear! The Bible says the real messiah will be a mystery to NO ONE when he arrives! It's interesting also that the NT states that if rulers had this alleged "gnosis," they never would have killed JC. But isn't the killing/death of JC that which provides the substance or content to the gnosis itself,? I.e., the "knowledge" that JC died for everyone's sins? Without the death of JC, what would the so-called "gnosis" then represent? Gnosis of what? JC as "savior?" But JC wouldn't have been the savior if he hadn't been killed and thereby supposedly died for everyone's sins. No gnosis of anything related to what they claim it constitutes could exist. The failure to put him to death would therefore invalidate not only JC as the "savior," but the sine qua non of the alleged "gnosis" itself. Lol, it's too convoluted by far and, as usual when dealing with christianity, makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. 🤣 Leave it to Rabbi Singer to uncover one of the most glaringly ridiculous mistakes underpinning the entire christian religion! It not only contradicts Tanakh, it even completely contradicts itself. Rabbi Skobac, btw, also makes the excellent and related point that at his trial, JC claims that he never kept anything secret from the world (John 18:20: "I have spoken openly to the world [LIE].... I have always taught in synagogues and in the temple [LIE].... I have said nothing in secret [LIE])," in direct contradiction to this continual theme of keeping everything secret. I'm sure Rabbi Singer is familiar with that argument. But this is a whole other level! By definition there's no gnosis without JC dying (because the gnosis is of JC as savior), and if the rulers had had gnosis, they wouldn't have killed him and made him a savior because they knew he becomes the savior by being killed? Lol, it's too absurd by far. And underlying everything, come to think of it, is the subtle or not-so-subtle, but typically antisemitic propaganda of the NT, in that the implication is that if not to kill him signifies (completely illogically, as we've just seen) that one has gnosis, then necessarily to kill him means you don't have this "gnosis." And who do they blame for killing him? 😂 So yeah, the poor Jews don't have "gnosis," see how wrong they are? 🤣 What. A. Scam. 🤣

[@Contentedetreici-qy3rm]

Thank you, Rabbi, for your answer. It makes a lot of sense to me and explains why there are "mysteries of the faith" in Catholicism that we're supposed to believe without understanding. I have a related question. In my bible there is a footnote for Mark 4:12 that refers to Isaiah 6:10, showing that Jesus was quoting from Isaiah. What is the meaning of Isaiah 6:10? Why does God want to make the heart of the people gross, its ears dull, its eyes shut so that they can't see, hear, understand or be converted and healed? Thank you.

[@miriam8026]

Someone explained it quite well I think @yosefbenavraham 10 kuukautta sitten (muokattu) Wow, this is HUGE! And so brilliant! Wow, this is so brilliant. What insight to see it from the inside out and understand the underlying psychology. And then to clearly demonstrate that the entire apologetic sensibility and rationale of the NT is completely contradictory to and undermined by Tanach - wow! Why can't christians hear this?? It's so clear! The Bible says the real messiah will be a mystery to NO ONE when he arrives! It's interesting also that the NT states that if rulers had this alleged "gnosis," they never would have killed JC. But isn't the killing/death of JC that which provides the substance or content to the gnosis itself,? I.e., the "knowledge" that JC died for everyone's sins? Without the death of JC, what would the so-called "gnosis" then represent? Gnosis of what? JC as "savior?" But JC wouldn't have been the savior if he hadn't been killed and thereby supposedly died for everyone's sins. No gnosis of anything related to what they claim it constitutes could exist. The failure to put him to death would therefore invalidate not only JC as the "savior," but the sine qua non of the alleged "gnosis" itself. Lol, it's too convoluted by far and, as usual when dealing with christianity, makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. 🤣 Leave it to Rabbi Singer to uncover one of the most glaringly ridiculous mistakes underpinning the entire christian religion! It not only contradicts Tanakh, it even completely contradicts itself. Rabbi Skobac, btw, also makes the excellent and related point that at his trial, JC claims that he never kept anything secret from the world (John 18:20: "I have spoken openly to the world [LIE].... I have always taught in synagogues and in the temple [LIE].... I have said nothing in secret [LIE])," in direct contradiction to this continual theme of keeping everything secret. I'm sure Rabbi Singer is familiar with that argument. But this is a whole other level! By definition there's no gnosis without JC dying (because the gnosis is of JC as savior), and if the rulers had had gnosis, they wouldn't have killed him and made him a savior because they knew he becomes the savior by being killed? Lol, it's too absurd by far. And underlying everything, come to think of it, is the subtle or not-so-subtle, but typically antisemitic propaganda of the NT, in that the implication is that if not to kill him signifies (completely illogically, as we've just seen) that one has gnosis, then necessarily to kill him means you don't have this "gnosis." And who do they blame for killing him? 😂 So yeah, the poor Jews don't have "gnosis," see how wrong they are? 🤣 What. A. Scam. 🤣

[@ched22]

They said to Him, "Why do You speak to them in parables?" Jesus answered them, "To you it has been granted to know the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven, but to them it has not been granted. For whoever has, to him more shall be given, and he will have an abundance; but whoever does not have, even what he has shall be taken away from him. Therefore I speak to them in parables; because while seeing they do not see, and while hearing they do not hear, nor do they understand. In their case the prophecy of Isaiah is being fulfilled, which says, ‘Hearing you will hear and shall not understand, And seeing you will see and not perceive; For the hearts of this people have grown dull. Their ears are hard of hearing, And their eyes they have closed, Lest they should see with their eyes and hear with their ears, Lest they should understand with their hearts and turn, So that I should heal them.’ But blessed are your eyes, because they see; and your ears, because they hear. For truly I say to you that many prophets and righteous men desired to see what you see, and did not see it, and to hear what you hear, and did not hear it" (Matthew 13:10-17).

[@nomad7734]

Interesting conclusion … not sure about the in between comments BUT your close was thought provoking 🤔

[@JohnHoulgate]

It's interesting that when the Christian bishops coalesced in the early 4th Century around forming a unified Church, they excluded what they called, Gnostic teachings. However, Christians still carry Gnostic ideas and if you want to pursue a Gnostic lifestyle, you could join a Monastery or one of the clerical orders where you would have to renounce things of this world. One thing I've learned about Gnosticism is that, by nature, it cannot build institutions of any meaningful size. They're too obtuse for that. Institutions are built around orthodoxy because the mindsets have to be commonly shared among greater numbers of people.

[@WillemvanPelt-f8m]

Thank HaShem for yisrael, for Rav Tovia❤❤

[@dpollard5286]

Wow, what an answer. However, it was a mystery to anyone who did not seek out the knowledge. God has always wanted a personal relationship with his children and that is the reference that Yeshua was giving. He wanted people to search for Him and follow Him in order to learn about Him and the gospel. That is why the disciples knew the mystery, because they were seeking and following Yeshua. The same concept that God put forward in the Old Testament in Deut. 29:4, Isa 6:9&10, Isa. 44:18, and Jer 5:21. It is the same as someone asking a Rabbi about scripture, seeking out knowledge in order to have a closer relationship with God. Yeshua said "seek and you will find, knock and the door will be open". As far as noone thinking that Yeshua was the Messiah until after He died is incorrect. His disciples thought he was, Pontius Pilot called Him Messiah, even the Jewish leaders punished Him for calling Himself the Messiah, so it wasn't a new concept after He died.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

God is not your man-idol.

[@retribution999]

You say Christianity has nothing to do with the Jews but Jesus came for the lost sheep of Israel. He addresses the Jewish nation only and sets right the law. Enjoy your lectures very knowledgeable but always raise more questions.

[@saegmam]

merci

[@cookiemonster3147]

I had tea and biscuits with Sai Baba this morning when he appeared on my porch!

[@WillScarlet1991]

😁😁

[@Over-for-now]

God's absolute sovereignty is HIS way and He will do ALL HIS counsels. His ways are not our ways

[@florisv559]

The quote from Mark about listening and not hearing is from Isaiah 6:9-10, a pretty scary text. It always struck me as odd that Jesus always tells people not to go tell around that he's the Messiah, until it finally dawned on me why. In the end, he couldn't even trust his disciples, who completely lost their heads once they realized that he was the messiah: The people would have risen in revolt, and it would have ended in a terrible massacre.

[@chrysostomos347]

Thank you, finally someone who realizes he's quoting Isaiah. Can't believe the Rabbi didn't even mention or deal with that in his it's all gnosticism theory

[@L.v.Oosten]

❤

[@kathleenwharton2139]

God Does Not Keep Secrets. The Ten Commandments are in the OT and Jesus gave us the Sermon on the Mount. I completely fixed my life with with the commandments. And God is With us..each individually..as well. He has been with me since I was six years old..helping me all of my life live a good life in Peace. Could not ask for more 😊❤

[@jamesmichael2717]

Paul was a poetic apostle writer. IMO

[@rariel3801]

❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@VandalIO]

It’s so funny 🤣 I’m getting Christian evangelical advertisements on rabbis video

[@VandalIO]

@@pomegranate8 they don’t !

[@paul_storytiemimages]

Is it true that yeshua follwers went to horrible deaths but never denied he died and rose again, that he was messiah, people need to really think about how horrible the torture would have been for some and all they had to do was deny what they saw and heard from jesus..

[@lamananderson1477]

He said those who hear his voice. His sheep understands him... like what's up with Jeremiah 7.? That's old testament. Pretty bold statements was being made. Kinda interesting also.

[@joyma82stonebridge91]

Also when someone asks Jesus if he is king he said u say rightly that I am a king

[@anthonycarlisle6184]

This whole story [ot/nt] deriving from greek translation, the mystery is the bachic mystery & the anointing, the christing; 'when one dies & comes back'. Most of the back story, context, of the story, is left behind.

[@edyartzi]

What is so funny is that the messiah is jewish. So first of all he has to fulfill the jewish requirements to be one in the first place and Jesus just doesn’t simple as that.

[@jwarren7971]

Rabbi, is the concept of ha Mashiach in the Tanakh supposed to be the literal fullness of Hashem incarnate? Furthermore, how could anyone think that it is possible for the fullness of Hashem to incarnate (as doing so would automatically break both the 1st & 2nd of the Ten Commandments)?

[@corneliuskinara3369]

What is the meaning of the little horn in Daniel chapter 7? Rabbi, I have many questions you need to answer me...I would like to have a peaceful debate with you about the Messiah, the Sacrifices and the destruction of the temple as per the book of Daniel.

[@GlorifiedTruth]

Abby: "Can you please tell me when the Messiah will come?" Jason: "Gno, sis."

[@gabrielleangelica1977]

Why doesn't the Noahide Laws include "love thy neighbor"?

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

Because your neighbor is an idolater.

[@11jimbo11]

When will Jeremiah 31:33 occur?

[@matthewmcclure3181]

I like listening to Rabbi Singer in a "the enemy of my enemy is my friend" way. Jewish activists aren't a major threat in the U.S., so live-and-let-live. BTW, what Julio Iglesias album is the theme song on?

[@josephherring3807]

Yes, there are other scholars who also claim Paul to be a gnostic.

[@MichaelJamesLorinReviews-wg8br]

Psalm 119:105

[@LadyRose2023]

How do I ask Rabbi Tovia a question

[@abc_6]

Calling the ‘Devil’ lord of this world as it says in 2nd Corinthians 4:4 is 100% idolatry. The Creator has no partners end of discussion.

[@RamismTamoid]

2nd Corinthians ( both seem to have actually been written by Paul; it is widely acknowledged he did not write all the epistles) is also known to have been a liar & a hypocrite; so anything he says should be taken with lots of salt! If Paul were alive today he would probably be in a psyche ward! He clearly did not get along with anyone (mostly men) which is why he surrounded himself with women; who could be duped more easily & probably were.

[@NickSandt]

You must be unaware that the Jewish scriptures were inspired by ancient Sumerian, Akkadian, Babylonian and Assyrian stories in which the same Old Testament stories are told but instead of one being it’s multiple beings, but wait … Elohim is the plural form of Eloah 🧐

[@anthonycarlisle6184]

Hebrew's, the actual tribal people, not the jews who are their successors didn't even have yhwh as God, they had all those listed in prior comment, along with canaanite el, ba'al, etc. Took a minute for them to stick with storm god yhwh, and this was when they were cool with Cyrus & peace was around & time to focus & build their story was available

[@carlwallace448]

Tov Maod Raboni love you

[@ManageDeMaia]

Paul is the poster boy for being high on your own supply

[@bigtomboye]

😂very funny

[@SendyBenAmi]

@@bigtomboyeand very true,

[@edwardmiessner6502]

🤣🤣 Wicked funny! 😝

[@andrewmays3988]

​@edwardmiessner6502 Without the letters of Paul, there never would have been a New Testament or the 45,000 different Christisn denominations worldwide, today!!!😇

[@SendyBenAmi]

@@andrewmays3988 just think, without the letters of Paul, there would likely not be millions of dead Jews; killed by xtian nuts through the last almost 2000 years.

[@Greywolf-ry9mc]

There are fragments of pemarkable gospels that have been found.

[@renesoucy3444]

Is it a fair vision to see the Gimmel Hebrew letter on the forehead of Maschiach? He also has a ring on His Right Hand Middle finger and on that ring is the letter Shin, the Eternal Flame and the Gimmel letter represents the Rich man running towards the poor one. His right Eyebrow represent the Yud of G-d and the Right tooth of a Lion. He holds the Staff of G-d which is the Vav of G-d from His Left Eye to the Right Hand of Messiah. Messiah is the Leviathan curling around the Vav of G-d.

[@Thutmosis7]

I’m more of gnostic in this modern age. To truly understand it you have to be into occult. But I do agree with some of the things rabbi talking about Christianity. Christianity was created by the Coptic Egyptians priests to appease the Roman Empire. I do think Serapis worshippers were the earliest form Of Christians.

[@Nudnik1]

Mark 16:9-20 Added in not in earliest original koine Greek new testament.

[@AlanWolf-d7l]

Yes still has the 9 candle Talmoud Huaankia. Is Pharsee theology. Not Blicial. Lol😊

[@frankmickeyumeh4303]

i have said this.... no one,.. absolutely no one can defend Christianity😂😂

[@matpieterse3287]

"So that they would not perceive", sounds like mindgames. "The whole Is a great mystery". With the dissapiont of church promises that don't happen, the christian bible starts to sound like bad sarcasm.

[@chrysostomos347]

Well, he's quoting from Isaiah 6:9-10 so I guess the OT prophets were into mind games then

[@michaelmiddleton2977]

Revelation 2:9. “I know your tribulation and your poverty (but you are rich) and the slander of those who say that they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan."

[@rekhavirik6343]

Correct again Rabbi. In any case, I don't believe a good Father would allow his son to be crucified. May the true Moshiach be born....today....Happy Birthday Moshiach!!! ❤