East-West Line train disruption to continue into 2nd day

[@nawwk79]

35 year old train still don't wan to scrap, our cars only 10 years force us to scrap already. 🙄

[@LawrenceWank001]

The forces of corruption at play.

[@antonette2113]

same as ex-transport minister, out of service! too OLD!

[@mcjohnmouse2016]

Singapore too small that's why need to scrap. And what happens if people start buying cars without the 10 year rule? Singapore will overflow and you'll be left complaining aiyah.

[@maggiemee2978]

this is nothing new in singapore, its all about milking profits off peasant's

[@hiroshi.galaxy.infinity]

WHY THE SMRT STAFFS ARE NOT ABLE TO SCRAP OLD SMRT TRAINS? WHY DID THEY WANT TO KEEP THE OLD TRAINS FOR?

[@pacer1705]

This happens when government agreed to remove redundant bus services parallel to MRT stations.

[@LonganLee]

Not because of military chiampons? I know how to send people to DB and route march

[@joynolives]

as a foreigner living in SG, I just want to say I’m super grateful for the MRTs here that have made my daily commutes so easy. Hiccups like this are rare, and things happen. Overall, very grateful for the safe journeys I’ve enjoyed here for the past few years.

[@whiz16]

obviously the train fare hike is not enough to bribe the sky to stop raining.

[@jimk3487]

Maintenance does not mean wait for anything to break down then get ready to repair. There is this thing called safety check by visual inspection, not AI and take action before any sudden incident that screw up everything. Earlier this year, during heavy rain, few ceiling board dropped off from Lakeside station, just before I stepped out. Upon looking at it, anyone can tell it needs replacement long ago. So who is checking?

[@hafiziichiro1145]

This is a good observation, to be honest I have noticed for years the entire east west-north south line which are first generation stations have zero maintenance regime. Dirty unpainted walls/roofing/ventilation pretty much everything is run down. Compare this to Thailand train system, damn they make us shitty. Wonder where all the funds go to annually???

[@LonganLee]

In military, you don't question your leader. You choose between DB and booking out

[@zenweaver]

Basically old train caused this big issue.Increase in fares constantly but cannot change train.Highest paid Transport Minister in the world cant do his job who is responsible for SimplyGo and ERP 2.0 screw up.Just one F-35 fighter jet can buy at least 10 trains.They will ownself check ownself and say unexpected issue and all their contingency plans in case of such an issue is top notch.

[@mr_crazh2254]

The trains are changing just gradually nothing happens overnight blud if u think your better than him why are u not the transport minster LOL

[@zenweaver]

@@mr_crazh2254 Because i am not a yes-man.He is one, and talented people are not.

[@JanLCn]

@@芸道 Highest paid transport minister still corrupted and taking bribes lolz

[@B100085]

@@芸道 Not enough new trains. Some trains have minimum or no air conditioning.

[@muhammadhuzaifahmohamedsal2697]

@@芸道 they are already serving the big banks WHILE being paid obscene salaries in their ''part time'' posts. Which Singapore you living in? This is public knowledge at this point that they are practicing legalised corruption.

[@tinatan2031]

Thanks for many efforts to minimise the disruption! I know all are trying your best!!👍👍👍

[@azroyrinho]

This is the worst thing happen they all need to stop increasing the fares and make sure they maintain the mrt

[@gator5001]

SMRT CEO seems very quiet throughout this whole incident

[@quad6752]

Question is does he has knowledge about rail system or he was a previous general?

[@rommelsim7317]

​@quad6752 no he doesnt.

[@LawrenceWank001]

Public arrows CHT. CHT arrows SMRT CEO. SMRT CEO arrows management. Management arrows staff. Staff arrows public. The cycle repeats.

[@maggiemee2978]

CEO : because fuxk you poor peasants that takes take public transport while i sit in my throne counting money

[@unfathomable_duck]

Lta and minister for transport not bothered. Period.

[@LonganLee]

Well, democratically empowered by voters aka singaporeans

[@LSH0202]

Maybe CNa insider can do an episode of documentary “why Singapore train always experience breakdown ?”

[@LonganLee]

But what type of people are in the inner circles? Like-minded?

[@PureLand88-w8b]

The disruption on the East West Line raises concerns. Why are we paying such a high salary to the Minister of Transport when he is not performing his duties effectively? We should consider reducing his salary as a penalty for this. Why has the Minister raised transport fares while providing outdated trains to commuters? This causes significant inconvenience. The Minister's performance is disappointing

[@nickng-jm1vk]

There is one old saying: "dont have this ass, dont take this laxative" likewise" dont have reliable system, dont take 6 million people" obviously current system cannot handle 6 million people yet.

[@FreshSmog]

You get what you vote for!

[@B100085]

@@FreshSmog Some do not get to vote.

[@nickng-jm1vk]

@@FreshSmog should be i got what others voted

[@Jon-bf2rs]

Govt planning for 10 million people not announced but everyone knows 😂

[@LonganLee]

But this is not the first time. Years ago, we already know the infra could not handle the influx which I won't say is for new citizen votes.

[@wowokingxoxo]

Never learn their lesson.

[@sariel8406]

Lets increase fares higher!

[@quad6752]

soon SMRT or LTA will raise bus and train fare due to high maintenance cost

[@LonganLee]

Yes we must! See, if Iswaran were paid much more......

[@Rabbit-x8f]

Corruption? Need to check material reliability also. Is not the first time transport minister is found corrupted

[@mikesiow1279]

The is such a thing call Preventive Maintenance, if they have done this, incident like this will not happen! Good thing, this time no one got hurt when the train derailed, but who is to say more serious incident will not happen if this keep going on! The government keep stressing the important of safety but incident like this keep happen to these GLCs. It like a slap to their face!

[@LonganLee]

Military is not Engineering

[@MrBoliao98]

Get the Jurong Line to Haw Par Villa. Cannot be so many people, but no spare line. People Bedok have 3 spare line, Tampines have 2. Woodlands also 2, AMK 2. Need spare line.

[@roseline5684]

I hope friday will have mrt. for us hope everything will ok

[@LonganLee]

If pay them a few millions more, maybe the chief can work wonders?

[@nau2030]

Lai increase transport fare

[@LonganLee]

Of course the voters say, "Aiya, this one ah....this one is the Bo Bian one mah". They Enable

[@lee1039]

"The Public Transport Fare Review Exercise (FRE) 2024 sees an overall 6.0% increase in bus and train fares with effect from 28th December 2024. Adult card fares for buses and trains are set to increase by 10 cents, while Concession card fares are set to increase by 4 cents.10 Sept 2024" Public Transport Fare Review 2024 Looks like even the Train God is unhappy about this increase.

[@quad6752]

Circle line , SW Line constant breakdown shows is SMRT has competent people to run to maintain the system ? Second, I see constant escalators constant under so-called repaired , is their monthly, quarterly maintenance system are effective as well as spare parts are always available on demand ?

[@W-Sfire7000]

Really man SMRT, Systemic Failure!

[@LonganLee]

But passengers aka voters must condone to ensure more of the same. Until voters learn their lesson. But gaslighted beyond salvation

[@lazyjane1223]

It was such a horrible day

[@tanpengjoo7205]

Is the system on regular maintenance outdated that can't detect any fault . With more lines coming up be prepared to have more failures. Those late for p s l e will automatically pass their examinations

[@LonganLee]

To get you your answer, you would need an independent audit to investigate every transaction in the accounting books from about 30 years ago. Independent from the establishment.

[@firdausbj1]

Get an Anywheel bike and cycle home!

[@tanpengjoo7205]

Wheel dropped off, whats next, door will drop too .still dare to increase few cents , basic maintenance already can't maintain still keep thinking increase public transport fares year in year out just want to meet revenue k p I.

[@LonganLee]

This patch work is not likely to sustain

[@LonganLee]

Majulah or Malulah?

[@user-ck2cp3lt3v]

End of year Still got big Bonus??

[@manmathankunji8687]

Dec 2024 SG public transport fare increasing. This kind of standard fare goes up. shame SG

[@LonganLee]

World class standard or Majulah or Malulah? Song Ni La of the tama?

[@agathiarbabaji1240]

The minister's pay need to increase so that they can work efficiently.

[@godsamazinggrace5331]

Biggest hint that tiny island aint suitable to have 6 million people

[@LonganLee]

As long as it grows the GDP and new citizen voters can dwarf the rise in cross over votes, I am ok. Influx is the lazy mans way to grow GDP. You don't need capability to for this

[@ryokolynn6948]

These trains were built by which country ? and which country do the major services for these trains for singapore ?

[@tutonreliablo2421]

and our fkin pap govt got the cheek to raise the transport fares

[@TheSunMoon]

Else how get bonus gao2?

[@Way2go926]

@@TheSunMoonthat’s our tax money..

[@rommelsim7317]

Ikr this gov is fking greedy

[@TheSunMoon]

@@Way2go926 That's why we must vote wisely when the time comes

[@reallife3015]

World class transport in the air , but certainly not on land . What a😂 ..........

[@luv-nnd]

6+ millions residents! You think the facilities can handle that?!

[@kengleetan63]

No problem. Pay for a over $100k COE and buy your own cat...i mean car. Cannot? Then not their problem too!😆😆😆

[@tiny_fern]

kanasai west sider all kena… why us 😐

[@LonganLee]

Please vote for more of the same

[@servehonestly]

our inability to resolve the problem within hours is a national shame... this is a national crisis not resolved within hours is A SHAME... NO EXCUSES

[@susanngan366]

Via media/news..LTA could highlight how e train transition works in Queenstown n why? Many confused commuters..

[@whatthefitt]

Pay And Pay!

[@abdulhamidsuip1266]

Rather wait for half an hour for the bridging bus, just take bus even thou you want to go the East.

[@songthamratrat304]

The railway system shall provide a spare track to park the faulted train clearing the railway for the rest to operate as usual and repair the electricity system trip quicker and also this spare track amd divert the train to bypass the broken track for the smooth service not just to keep the failing system on hold like this

[@acc9940]

bring in more FTs PAP

[@astutity5137]

Unacceptable! No need to work next day?

[@andrewng265]

Sia Suay never admits wrong fare increase but products never improve 😂😂😂

[@captainmacmillan9785]

Trained actually derailed guys

[@cookingwithfluffytiny4371]

Strange moe says if arrive before paper end? Should post pone.

[@LawrenceWank001]

This is an online petition to call for the immediate resignation of transport minister CHT. We are looking for 100 likes. In addition, we are making a request to Leader of Opposition, PS, to file a motion to vacate for the transport minister, CHT, for his failure to provide a safe and reliable ride to commuters. For this, we are seeking 200 likes.

[@Gorgor9651]

you cow beh cow boo clever

[@FireFoxGaming56]

😂😂😂

[@FireFoxGaming56]

Typical wayang singaporean who loves to complain - go live in America and know what real problems look like when your next door neighbor pulls a gun on you for trespassing 🤡

[@noprob7820]

Stop boasting... Stop demanding... get your act together first.

[@__tachibana8072]

Can dont go work tomorrow?

[@donutlordl1806]

I think they better upgrade up the rail or trains something or else they will be more disruption

[@yewfei3324]

We are not a poor nation how come a train that have service for 30 odds year still operate had MRT authorities knew the consequenes many working class had to face now.

[@godsamazinggrace5331]

East west line old trains super filthy and stinks badly

[@a7128]

since Jason start everything broken la

[@CRaZyAbOuTYuGi]

Gg to my friend who staying there

[@tonykwok9763]

TRANSPORT VOUCHERS FOR ALL INCONVENIENCE CAUSED🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉👍👍👍👍👍

[@sfbefbefwfvwfvsf2722]

tomorrow confirm a lot people will utter 4 gold letters word

[@littlemissdimples88]

It was really freaking bad this morning 🤯

[@AntonyV14]

No worries, nobody gonna suicide after this disruption

[@angiemf9033]

Please lah. No need to demand for transport minister to resign. Increase in fare price is justified. Maintenance needs $.

[@gst8506]

Cheap hardware???

[@mrtienphysics666]

Will this impact the exams and the GE?

[@quad6752]

Is part of on the job training programme

[@leechuaong9443]

nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

[@toontoon8039]

nobody ask why bus fare increases ah? service like crap sia

[@titusphilip1310441]

sack the maintenance team asap!! this is not acceptable!! ridiculous!!

[@yeoengchai957]

Who is accountable for all this happening. Shouldn't the government ask those so call privatisation to give us an answer. Gov give out 500million dollars to SMRT n SBS transit also rising of fare to have this kind of transport standard.

[@snsdjerry]

Take mc la

[@Leo-gb1mo]

Please change your name to Mass Rabak Transit .

[@goodmorningandnight4690]

lmfao sohai kia

[@Callsign-Blade_RunnerSG]

It’s always in situations like this that I couldn’t find those commentors whom likes to blow Hot air and brag that Singapore’s Transport system is “so convenient PLUS efficient”, so much so that you “do not even need a personal Car”, even for those with large families… 🤔 I’m not suprised if it turns out that these so called pro Public transport warriors are actually private Car owners themselves… 😂

[@leechuaong9443]

aaaaaa

[@misschibai]

no worried la.. million to come. by then everything will be good. 🤣 best every week breakdown.

[@佛力]

Ya I agree, make it every wk break down

[@sleepypanda7293]

all the paper generals occupying the top post of cos can talk. why the ceo of smrt did not even come fwd n explained ??? just like why must ex Lui explained n explained n explained until he also dulan bcos the ceo of smrt mr des just hide behind ??? dn need to talk so much n merry go round the garden. basically, the wheel flew off. why ? bcos the locking device dropped off. why locking device drop off is the key issue n need to explain to the public !!! never do maintenance ? ok maybe after [saw ph] era, still smrt did not get the service & maintenance manual from Kawasaki bcos LTA dn allow ???? the train can b 35 or 350 years but the wheels n the boogies cannot b 35 years. especially the wheels, bcos of wear n tear they cannot b 35 years. so, talking abt 35 years old train is irrelevant to tis incident !!!!! imagine the wheel flew off the track n onto the road hitting the cars n pedestrian below, who should b responsible ???