Tribal People React to WAR PIGS by BLACK SABBATH

[@kimberlyallsup8472]

I personally like the fact that you take the time to analyze and explain these songs. For the first time in my life, I have come to enjoy Heavy Metal now that you’ve helped me understand it. My poor sons grew up with me shouting at them to “turn off that noise!”

[@TRYBALS]

It's never too late to learn and accept new things 🤗❤️🌷

[@kimberlyallsup8472]

@@TRYBALS Ha ha! Yes. I have found that out. Thanks for allowing me to understand it

[@123abhinand]

God created the world and then he created Heavy Metal. And he saw it was good!!🤘🏾🤘🏾

[@123abhinand]

@@TRYBALS I just love and appreciate the effort you are putting in. Love it that they are paying attention to your explanation!🤘🏾

[@ericmojave6061]

All you had to do was listen to the music, not judge it because it isn’t what you wanted to hear. Seems simple right?

[@ssshadowwolf6762]

I’ve grown so much respect for the eldest man’s view points and statements. He’s a natural observer of human behavior and spiritual concepts and knows where the divide is often seen as “ gray “. I love he doesn’t let people blame the devil for their own actions . I don’t know everyone’s name except Parvati ( bc she’s the only female and I’m female too ). But the next elder man and the younger one are endearing to me and the heavier man I feel has empathy and I think it’s his superpower . The eldest man however has his eye on reality and this channel keeps me open and thinking and in many renews things I’d forgotten. Btw - you as the one who runs the channel and informs the guests about the music and asks them questions, you’ve made a difference in many lives . I’m incredibly grateful to you . I truly mean this to my soul . Your dialogue with them is fabulous.

[@emeral311]

Red cap is named Casper 🤗

[@johns9478]

The eldest man is named Abdul. He definitely knows what's up.

[@michaelclements5793]

I agree. He is my favorite reactor. He really gets it.

[@nono86753]

There are a few older men on other similar channels I do not like (at all) but most viewers love them and that’s fine with me. I absolutely love Abdul. He is full of wisdom and calm. May God bless him.

[@richfiles]

Abdul really hits the nail on the head right at the very end... The people in power of course label the song as "Satanist"... They sure as hell don't want people listening to a song that's about them! Abdul's wisdom is spot on every single time. Much respect to the man.

[@TRYBALS]

Parvati isn't back, she never left. This video was shot right before each individual unboxed the 100k play button and I had the same plans for Parvati as well but you clearly see how distracted she is, even I couldn't keep track of my mic's batteries running dead. I've said this in many comments these final videos are never the full picture. Each session takes me more than an hour (typically two hours) and I don't have anyone helping me. I found a cameraman a while ago but he left too. I'm not denying a woman's perspective on this channel and Parvati has been like a sister to me but clearly she doesn't want to be in the videos. She just comes there because her family tells her to. I could have edited the video to a perfect level of 15 minutes to look everything normal like asking question cutting out all the parts where someone doesn't get the question and I explain again which I always do. But the purpose was to show you guys things from my perspectives. I am mentally being challenged there, not only I have to work through more and more during the recording sessions but also during the editing as well. If Parvati can show some responsibility by allowing herself a time (2-3 hours per week) dedicated to this channel then it's hers. She can have more than what she has been having. If not, then I don't have any other choice left. In the end, please remember a real human being is present behind the camera. Behind these videos. And I have a limited amount of patience like anyone else.

[@IR240474]

Please, keep on making these videos, they help everyone. Blessings from Ireland.

[@tracybiering6596]

I hate that, but I understand. You're making the right decision, I believe. :(

[@xijzdix]

you are very true in what you express here. dont bow for any injust behaviour. man or woman. family or far friend. these words sound from a heart that is just. love to you all

[@revangerang]

Ah. I see what you meant now... Yeah something definitely has to change.

[@melissahoward4024]

As a western woman it is hard to see that a woman's choices may not be her own everywhere, but we must remain respectful of different cultures and ways of life. I have become very attached to Parvati but she must do what her heart tells her no matter what. Also, you must do what your heart tells you because so much of your time and heart goes into this channel. I'm sure you will do what you need to do for the good of everyone. I do not blame Parvati or you for whatever may happen and wish blessings on you all.

[@RolandDeschain1]

"War is a business of pigs" Amazing.

[@respectfulgamer7232]

Then the 2nd guy kinda blew it :D

[@bareakon]

The conviction on his face when he said it.

[@Whydidyouusemyname]

Do understand that a pig is very very bad to them.

[@arphod]

That man with the white beard and white turban understands everything. Once he heard the lyrics he spoke on the truth.

[@giantrotatingcarrot]

I have a great respect for the elder gray-bearded gentleman. I have sometimes heard him mention that he has received no education. What he does have, that I have observed, is wisdom and understanding. These qualities are much more important than education as they are not something that can be taught.

[@robertwilson2007]

Actually, empathy can be taught. Believe it or not.

[@Boca-do-rio]

@@robertwilson2007 When parrents educate children with love and spend enough time with them, ofcorse... But there are also children born, that had never those kind of parents or where born with a disfunction... So (evil) most also be forgiven, as absoluut perfection does not exist.

[@Boca-do-rio]

@@UnsoberIdiot not at all... Education helps to get wisdom. I'ff i teach you as a child how to cross a street more save, it will suport your wisdom when you see a other person make a mistake and get under a car... My theorie then suports your thinking to not make the same mistake... For instance by not looking once to the left, once to the right and one more time left, before crossing. Wisdom is not to do the opposite of what is smart.

[@homeschoolmom2384]

Amen

[@maximan4363]

Yes, he really does! I have been fortunate to meet many people like him from all over the world, both young and old! You can be taught but wisdom is learned! I have been humbled many times and I have had fascinating discussions in the 80's with Physics Professors drunk, stoned & tripping about quantum mechanics (honestly, it really helps to be stoned or tripping to get your head around this!!), but the understanding of this Universe I have learnt goes way beyond what science can prove and even that is mind blowing!

[@peppermoon7485]

My husband is a Vietnam vet ..this song always hits home 🥲a part of him has always been broken since he returned home …I hate war

[@peppermoon7485]

@A killa 4 reala thank you …☮️

[@tubeampsrule1]

Tell him I said, "Welcome home," please.

[@peppermoon7485]

@@tubeampsrule1 I sure will and Ty :)

[@ssshadowwolf6762]

Mine was too. He passed 4 years ago end of last month . I grew up during Vietnam in a military community. My daughter is a veteran too. I hate war. I absolutely hate it .

[@hmpz36911]

Imagine a world where we all did the right thing. A world without war. A world without ego and selfishness.

[@kevinvegas1916]

Great video. All with intent eyes. The gentleman in the white beard was dialed in and understood the message! ✌🏻Peace to all ☮️

[@Io-Io-Io]

"The Gentleman in the white beard'😂😂😂👍

[@ssshadowwolf6762]

Yeah he did . He’s as sharp as a tack.

[@verresmilliterres]

Yes, he was spot on. I like him. He gets it every time.

[@Io-Io-Io]

@@verresmilliterres respect your elderly....

[@televinv8062]

☮️✌️☮️✌️☮️👍🙏🙏🙏👍🙏

[@michellec2382]

I adore each one of these people more with every video. Different facets of their personalities are revealed and it provides the opportunity to know them more fully. Thank you for sharing and I always look forward to seeing new videos. 😊

[@SakSatch311]

The old man was right about everything he said. Sabbath was just making a veiwpoint... look at the world, its almost prescient. Thanks for sharing. Remarkable.

[@regardlessrampage]

unfortunately the message isn't prescient, it's timeless, which is the saddest thing about it.

[@Leatherface123.]

War pigs wasn’t ever intended for the message it sends, originally it was called walpurgis and was far darker, it was about witches gathering performing rituals, casting priests into fires, and destroyed churches, there’s a recording of it on KZbin

[@whispersmith]

@@Leatherface123. I'd argue that version is actually way less dark than the war one

[@Leatherface123.]

@@whispersmith forgot to mention sinners summoning the devil to the living world which leads the sinners to realize they made a mistake, and they run to a priest, who gets casted into the depths of hell by satan himself

[@fraelikkriil830]

@@Leatherface123. still less dark than large scale war

[@dantallman5345]

I Love what you are doing here. These are warm, perceptive people. Their reactions and your questions added to my understanding of the song.

[@SonicImmersion_]

I've been listening to this song since I was a young teen three decades ago, yet I didn't know what war pigs referred to until this Trybals video today. Just like with the Star Spangled Banner video, I've learned so much from this channel.

[@ericmojave6061]

You didn’t know what War Pigs was about? Come on….30 years?

[@clumsiii]

@@ericmojave6061 lol go easy on them.. it's a jukebox classic. Very understandable if someone wasn't paying attention. But ya, lol they missed the boat for real

[@SonicImmersion_]

@Eric Mojave I knew what it was about, from my first listen 30 years ago. But I had only understood the "war pig" phrase as a derogatory referrence to the politcians and other leaders who--while sipping cool drinks in air-conditioned offices thousands of miles from the conflict--send young men and women to fight instead of themselves. My own father was sent to three combat tours in Vietnam, as a Naval Corpsman serving alongside Marines, so I grew up learning from him the ironies of how the people who made the decisions were not those being grieviously injured killed. What I hadn't known prior to this Trybals video was the other meaning of "war pig"--i.e. the literal interpretation--that had been used in earlier times.

[@SonicImmersion_]

meant to say, "grieviously injured or killed". My father, unfortunately, saw so much of that over the three deployments, with men dying in his arms. Their faces still haunt him to this day. When I was growing up, I'd often find my father deep in thought, and not paying attention to what was going on around him. As a young boy I'd ask him, "What are you thinking about?" To which he'd reply, "I still see their faces." "Who's?" I asked. "The ones I couldn't save." Corpsman, as with any other type of combat medic, see the worst of the attrocities that can be inflicted upon the human body. Hardly ever would my dad want speak any further of the troops who died in his arms. After the war, he never again worked in medical settings, choosing instead to work as a repairman of sorts. At least that wouldn't bring back the memories so vividly. Because broken machines don't die the way the soldiers he served with did.

[@bensears837]

"there should be wars on pigs" had me laughing i love your videos. and if i ever become not poor i will give some money

[@steveconner3729]

So funny. He meant it too

[@Bobbyliscious]

Every culture has great art. But because of language barriers, it is hard to share all of that art. I love this channel.

[@civil_villain]

Very appropriate timing, and message. This was a good one.

[@passenger-rider]

Always been a Sabbath fan and I love how you explain the song in deep detail to the elders. Keep it up brother! Big love from Spain!

[@bucketheadkfc]

"The cost of war is paid by all of humanity" This man is very wise!

[@AntonioProla]

BLACK SABBATH - Live in Paris (1970) would be a good one to watch another clip from, they can see how good they played live back in the day

[@yoru00004]

bill wards crushed them drums

[@Bstrike69]

It makes me happy to see the opinions of others. The fact that they took the time to sit and listen and he explained the music. Bravo 👏

[@charlotteholmes3056]

It is good see Parvati back to TRYBALS!!! I know that sometimes is difficult to you have her in the videos because her children and husband.

[@kennylaysh2776]

She's awesome. Every time I hear her talk about her life or thoughts on things, I find it fascinating. I can't even imagine her living style, from here in America. She may not see it, but she seems like a very strong person to me.

[@shaynebjorndahl7885]

I found her to be very disrespectful.

[@charlotteholmes3056]

@@shaynebjorndahl7885 Yes. I thought the same. I was happy because she was back, but her comentarys makes me sad.

[@albux]

@@shaynebjorndahl7885 ​ @Charlotte Holmes What did she say that you think is disrespectful?

[@julilla1]

@@charlotteholmes3056 Parvati is Hindu. The concept of "Satan" and "Judgment" in the Biblical sense are completely foreign to her. I understand why she'd think it was "Satanic" if the song is talking about Satan and Judgment Day because the deeper theosophical meanings just aren't a part of her religious beliefs. I think for her, the song mentions Satan a couple of times, so it's Satanic. But I think the more important question to be asked is if she even thinks that there would be anything wrong with that. It doesn't necessarily mean to her what it would mean to someone with an Abrahamic faith.

[@trobasguiblerg4261]

I've been playing this song in bands since 1992 and to this day it is still the most popular cover song we play. It came out in 1970. Whether it's electric or unplugged, young people or old in the audience, the crowd goes absolutely nuts when we play it. People standing on chairs and singing, shouting, going wild etc.

[@arthurfranklin9315]

Same here... The composition and lyrics are all fabulous, but it also has something that modern metal bands find very difficult to replicate.... The groove and loose nature of the 'solo' sections could only have been created by a band that grew up playing jazz and blues. Modern metal is often fantastic but they are missing that foundation 99% of the time and their songs don't move people the same way without it.

[@MrLookitspam]

I am obsessed by this group. I cannot stop watching. Would love to meet them in persons. God bless you all.

[@superchicken5000]

Such incredible personalities. The wisdom and thoughtfulness of their words was beautiful to me.

[@Luvinlife64]

me too (meeting them )

[@Frank-pb2rh]

They are just like us except from a different land ,I have been listening to these songs since I was 12 years old I understand the message immediately!!!people would say Sabbath was Satanic and I would say no they are speaking against war and hate all their songs start with the problem, then say their opinion which is and was always love and peace but we must listen to the whole song!!peace

[@MrOoYT]

@@Frank-pb2rhhow could somebody call them satanic with their huge crosses?? 😂😅

[@Hades-my4jq]

What I took from the title of this song when I first heard it as a teenager, is that those who start/create war have a hunger for it. We associate pigs with gluttony. The ''War pig'' has a hunger for war.

[@dan_hitchman007]

Yes, exactly.

[@leeannrorex1509]

That's the way I interpreted it, as well.

[@AlohaChips]

It seems as if there are a good many interpretations of the title that are all valid. I bet the song writer finds it rather satisfying a choice.

[@powellpatterson4928]

Terry "Geezer" Butler is one of the best song writers of all time. Deep and profound lyrics/message in many , if not most , of their music. My favorite band.

[@KestralWolfe]

This is, I think, my favorite war protest song. People really did, (and still do) interpret this song as something evil against people. Some still do, event hough it's a song damning war, and illustrating the huge, evil costs of war.

[@angelacamargo4309]

A lot of metal songs explore this topic, yet ppl think they are satanic songs 💁🏻‍♀️ I like when musicians use their work to denounce the madness of our world and metal genre should be respected because of this, in fact these are songs for peace

[@ticketoutofthishellhole5992]

@@angelacamargo4309 I agree. Satanic talk is often the automatic knee jerk reaction to anything religious folk either do not understand or feel they should not enjoy based on their teachings. It's easy to shift the blame on a demon nobody has ever met. Despite the different responses, I still see all of them as sincere and kind. The one who disagreed did not seem to be able to fully understand the intention. We can't expect her to immediately ignore her religious teachings in one sitting. We need to give her time and be patient.

[@ice-iu3vv]

those who judge a book by its cover, or movie by its title, simply judged the band by their name. those who regarded black sabbath as satanic have done so because taken literally, "black sabbath" implies evil. nobody "really did (and still do) interpret this SONG as something evil against people". no they didnt get that far, wouldnt listen, and judged the band's name without interpreting any of their songs.

[@rhondamacdougallgale5036]

There are a lot of ignorant people who refuse to listen and think. Most probably didn't even hear this song, they're repeating what someone else told them

[@gladeloy3341]

It's a sing-along to us boomers !

[@wackyd9863]

always love your vids! I liken the end of the song to a tightly wound spring coming undone just like the soldiers lives. I had to edit my comment to say, I LOVE that Mohammad Riaz Jutt hoodie with his quote "It's heavy matter, sir!" on your merch page!

[@alementary4065]

The fellow with just the mustache has the soul of a poet or musician.

[@MNWILD43]

Such awesome people. So many great people that we'd never know about, if you didn't upload these for us!! Thank you!

[@vikingboodah6889]

I love these videos. I love watching Muharam just enjoying the music. so wholesome.

[@JixedUp]

Maybe something you could do in the future, but I’d be interest to see their perspective on different dance styles! I’m Spanish so of course flamenco is what I’d love to see them react to, but equally Irish dancing, breakdancing, ballet etc, they’re all art forms that transcend language too and I’d love to hear their thoughts

[@fd9448]

Yes! This would be amazing! I’d also love to see them share some of their own culture’s dancing for comparison and explain to us viewers about it.

[@Ant-bm1qk]

We really needed this right now with what’s going on with Ukraine. Love to hear their thoughts and opinions on War/Governments and such topics

[@bigfrankfraser1391]

as the son of crimean parents who died at the hands of ukrainians along with my 12 year old brother, i wish this war to end to, but ukraine has more than earned the suffering they go through, even there president wants his people to suffer, he refused peace negotiations. i do not have hatred towards the innocent, but the government of ukraine deserves all that is happening edit: the worst part is i have had westerners tell me im wrong, that it was russia that killed my family, westerners know nothing, it was russian medics that operated on my little brother for 5 hours before pronouncing him dead, it was russian soldiers who got me out of crimea, it was russia that gave me a new leg and hand. my heart goes out to all innocents suffering, but i also wish pain on suffering on the guilty and corrupt

[@deandee8082]

they live in Sindh Pakistan, (Sunni judging by the beards) so they know about it all too well..

[@Leatherface123.]

@@bigfrankfraser1391 i do believe what you said, but, I will say this, no matter what happens, nobody deserves torture and death no matter how bad their past is, except people who touch kids and touch animals

[@bigfrankfraser1391]

@@Leatherface123. so child murderers do not deserve death? is that what you believe, what about ukrainian women deported from germany after they said they would go to russia to kill children, do they deserve to be be spared, no. my brother was 12 when he was shot, the ukrainian soldiers who did it were laughing as they claimed he was "russian sympathiser" and shot him in the chest with smiles on there faces and left him to die on the street, i grabbed him and ran to russian base, even after i broke my leg i kept going (in the end i had to have leg amputated) once i got to russian base, they got medics in, but in the end my little brother died, every since that day, i have ice cold hatred for ukraine. i do not care about the innocents in ukraine, since they did not care about the innocents in crimea edit: i do not support war, i do not believe in war, but if ukraine suffers, i cheer, they more than earned some suffering

[@PBNIP]

@@bigfrankfraser1391 thank you for this. Far too many people here in the west believe ukraine to be an innocent country. Truly ukraine is the most corrupt country in europe and surely because of foreign interests. You can find videos of ukrainian soldiers shooting russians prisoners in the knee caps and genitals one after another. Then taking there phones and calling their mothers to tell them what theyve done. A terrible government

[@matrind6996]

You should show them about the Afghan and baloch camaleers who came into Australia back in the 1800s and married aboriginal women and to this day there is still indigenous baloch in Australia, it's a really interesting story and that's where my family comes in alhamdulilah

[@TRYBALS]

Can I have a link? I do however know about a similar story which involves USA and JFK. It's not well known but is accurately documented by the JFK admin's archives. I'll share it someday with our group and the audience as well. It's so interesting.

[@matrind6996]

@@TRYBALS kzbin.info/www/bejne/oIe3n3eCn8-MfZY

[@TRYBALS]

Thank you for the link, will check it out soon :-)

[@matrind6996]

@@TRYBALS 🤙👍👍

[@thequeensjester8660]

I absolutely adore everyone of these precious people. Thank you so much for sharing. This song is one of my all time favorites. With the climate of war throughout the world, this song definitely speaks truth to power. Governments lie to start wars, people dying for oil, regime change... This channel brings us all together and shows that no government, no language barrier can separate us from the humanity we all have. I love you all so much. Thank you for this.

[@andrewjacks2716]

As always, the heart and soul that all involved put into making these videos shines through! A timely message from these folks too, wars are terrible. Wars destroy innocent people at the whims of leaders who themselves are shielded from the suffering they cause. This is a message that seems to come from all corners of the world, and yet seems all to often to go unlearned.

[@poolhall9632]

*“War is the business of pigs” - A WISE MAN* 0:56

[@jacobmarshall23]

These videos have a very unique perspective on these songs, that I think comes from the difference of languages. Whenever you have to translate, you have to explain it in your own words. As a result, you take away a much better understanding of what the lyrics are trying to portray. And I think this forces you to have to really understand the meaning of the words, which you then share with your guests. All in all your reaction videos are among the best on KZbin. They are very educational, entertaining, and genuine. Keep doing what you're doing. God bless you all!

[@joelosminski4525]

This is the coolest shit I’ve seen in a very long time. There’s so many things that our so over saturated in the world. This channel is doing something that I’ve never seen! It’s so fucking cool! Rock on 🤘

[@LockhartSpain]

A superb choice. Incidentally, this is also my favourite visual representation of the song. As always, a wonderful video. I would very much like to help with your work.

[@davidseabourn9303]

All intently fascinated. No head bobbing, air guitar, ect. Perfectly stll. As watching cultures colliding Brilliant.

[@monogramadikt5971]

theres no way that the members of black sabbath could have imagined how far into the future this song would reach and how many people it has affected in its expansion over time

[@mitchelltower6232]

why war is part of the human equation for as long as we have been and those in power always use it for their gain at the expense of the common folk, nothing strange or hard to grasp about it, and its nothing new but it's also never ending ... maybe at some point but not yet look whats happening now a war starts and is now being used as a proxy war while the powerful get rich the common people are loosing their homes and lives ...

[@fluffskunk]

Or that we'd still be having the same arguments about things like war and exploitation 50+ years on.

[@Sarahminks75]

I think that's true, no one can ever know how fat reaching their voice will be heard. That's why I never stop talking LOL 😆

[@digitalblues01]

Could not have picked a more perfect video for the times. People can learn a lot from this, Thanks and as ever Stevie Ray Vaughan please.

[@Hamarkameraten]

Poor people die twice. Once during wars and then due to inflation.

[@brandonday2494]

Wisdom of the heaviest order.

[@glenclarkchidley3637]

I would love to sit and have conversations with Parvati. Besides being beautiful on the outside, there seems a beauty inside that can’t escape a culture not quite in this century. Love all their open mindedness.

[@All-Fur-Coat_No-Trousers]

The timeless song with this video never fails to bring me to tears, it's just overwhelmingly powerful. This is one of my favorite reactions I've ever watched, bar none. All because of these wonderfully insightful people you've brought together.

[@charlotteholmes3056]

It's a very relevant song to this dark time...

[@fuselpeter5393]

As long as humans roam the earth it will always be relevant.

[@amandatheyahoo411]

Parvati is just reacting the way she's reacting. Everyone chill... I love the honesty of our friends. I think the viewers need some tolerance and love. A little Ustad Rogers and Ustad Ross 😀. Don't ever change! Anything! The production reactors etc you are doing a GREAT job. ☮️❤️🎨

[@vernonsalisbury5276]

I'm here to say, I LOVE this channel, you brothers and sisters reacting to music. Your not tribal, you are my brothers and sister that are across the world. These are the BEST reactions on KZbin. Love all you guys, I hope and pray for all. Thanks for bringing great music to great people!

[@ZekeThePlumber86]

Perfect song for right now!

[@tracybiering6596]

Parvati, we see you and we love you. Hugs and strength to you. ♡

[@calvinc9634]

thank you so much for these videos. I discovered them today and love them.

[@Blu9_Nin9]

Abdul is a very wise man. I could see myself going to him for advice in life and faith. I respect him as I would my own father, and he himself is respectful to those less experienced and wise as himself. Mohammed is a very kind and sweet. He seems like a good friend. I understand that his son is not well. I can see the exhaustion on his face and can tell that he feels a lot of stress. My prayers to him and his son. Mukhtiar is such a pure soul. He's kind and has the innocence of a child, which is something that far too many people lose as they grow older. I pray he never loses that. Muharam is so eager to learn and see things he hasn't before. His curiosity to experience new things, and his appreciation for those things, is so refreshing to see. That's something not everyone in the world has. Parvati is a beautiful woman. I understand that, as a woman, she is forbidden from many things. And I understand that her home life may not be very healthy. She is in an interesting position to experience things that society has not allowed her as a woman. It must be difficult to go against what have was taught and speak her mind on the channel. I can see how that while dealing with her children at the same time can be difficult. And you, sir, are doing the Lord's work. Your patience with the reactors, explaining things to them, asking questions, and taking the time to teach and help them understand is commendable. On top of the work spent recording, editing, operating the equipment, renting the space, working social media, and all the other jobs that we don't see. You're showing the world a people that most won't ever see and know very little about. Your passion and dedication for your work shows, and is obvious to the world.

[@joshuawood1436]

Why do you assume the woman's home life is unhealthy? She isn't over weight, unclean, and wearing rags. She isn't physically ill, or maimed, she looks healthy to me. Did you mean mentally? Because then again she seems happy, smiling, content, and naive which means her innocence is intact, and others worry about things she does not have to. Would you think she were healthy if subjected to Western lies and propaganda about feminism, and LBGTQ nonsense? Should she be over weight, depressed and on pharmaceuticals, with blue hair and hating her fellow citizens, and man? is that what you mean by "healthy" home life? I am sure she would gladly decline your offer. Lastly, i notice you didn't mention the attractiveness of any of the men, and ignored that she is married. It's disrespectful in any culture, or country to speak about a man's wife. You clearly covet her, and think she deserves you to show her the corruption of Western life. Shame on you bud.

[@KitWriter]

Aww, I love that her child is there with her. That's really awesome. Thank you for letting her child come with her to this viewing. A mother's job never stops. You've done some really amazing videos, and I see by the way you bring up older videos, like Bob Ross, Zombie, and other things they have seen in the past, that I have some catching up to do. :)

[@KitWriter]

WOW. I really like that she has her own opinions, and her beliefs are based on some things she's been told by her ancestors and superiors, but she has free thinking thoughts and that's really awesome. I'm glad you made her feel comfortable enough to express herself so honestly. That was refreshing and powerful.

[@martinaburke1469]

Parvati being a woman has to look after the children as well as reviewing the content but the men don't have to do this, they are free to give their sole attention to the task at hand. I hope Pravati stays with your channel....

[@AIMLESS-NAMELESS]

I have watched every one of your videos and I discovered you yesterday. You do such a wonderful job of explaining the context and I even discover new meaning in things I have loved for a long time. Thank you for all your hard work I hope it gets easier for you ❤️

[@arjay9745]

Poor Parvati. You could see she was distracted right from the start, then she felt on the spot when she was asked questions. Reminded me of school days, when a teacher asked me something and I'd been daydreaming.

[@Kiyarose3999]

So glad I come across this vid, really interesting, and great to see a positive feedback, one guy was getting into it. Haveto share this, many thanks! ✊🏽🌎🌻✌🏽

[@jcfink9468]

I’ve been thinking about this song since Russia invaded Ukraine. It’s spot on perfect for a description of the modern war machine. In ancient times the king would actually fight on the battlefield. I’ve often thought that war would end all over the world if that rule was still in place. If Parvati was able to come alone, without her children, I feel she could pay better attention. If her family wants her to attend the session, can they watch her children for a few hours a week? I also think she would react more if given a chance to watch something that isn’t about war, destruction or men being evil. Could I suggest something like having everyone react to cake decorating, animal videos or more videos featuring people like Jane Goodall, Gilda Radner, Harriet Tubman?

[@jameswoodard4304]

So, is Zelensky a pig for leading his people in war? This was written during the Vietnam era, in which American soldiers (mostly volunteers who were treated very badly when they returned) were sent overseas to *stop* the aggressive spread of an evil system which led to the deaths of many millions from spreading around the world. But American leaders were evil, monstrous, pigs watching their poor classes die just for the fun of it? That is a disgusting take on the reality of war. War is bad. But it is both the field for humanity's true nobility to shine through the darkness as well as it's evil and cruelty. Such simplistic depictions of war tar the sacrifice and nobility of the one with the same brush as the evil cruelty of the other. Also, Sabbath is using Marxist themes to criticise a war being fought against the spread of Marxism while also promoting class struggle (ie. war). Basically, "starting wars is evil and leaders better stop doing it or the people will rise up and be led to war to stop them." "War is bad unless I say so." So, it's more than a bit hypocritical. It's an insultingly naive take on the realities of war. People just like it because it hits basic human emotional buttons, but if you think about it for five minutes...

[@jackknife4547]

What is Putin looking for? No one bombs a country without reason don't be so naive

[@ColtraneTaylor]

9:52 This section here comes from the Indian music influence prevalent in the 60s. Very psychedelic too, even though people think of Sabbath as a metal band that is blues influenced.

[@Vidchemy]

It was interesting, how the host tried to demonstrate critical thinking to Parvati. Because many women do not participate in society at the same level as men, due to their culture, she is not used to considering "why" she feels a certain way about a topic. Good job,

[@oo0OAO0oo]

I applaude this channel and everyone involved in it. You are doing a very important thing for humanity. I feel connected to you, your thoughts and feelings. I am very grateful for what you do. You share your minds with us and you open your soul and I see love, wisdom and kindness.

[@myreallife6386]

I really think I understand to an extant how many factors are going into Parvati’s behavior here. It’s not fair to you but you are also trying above and beyond to let her remain on the channel. I am imagining that her family is demanding all she can do and more without giving her any help on the days she comes to the studio. Plus probably some emotional abuse for whatever “reason” they give her a hard time about it. At the same time they want the benefits. I think the stress is what is causing her to loose interest, or she shuts off her mind and emotions to push through. Maybe I can’t know. But that is my guess as a woman who has experienced getting no help and also being bullied and asked for money. I love what you are doing and it must be a lot of stress and heartache at times. Thank you for all the hard work. This channel and the others like it are doing so much more for humanity than we even know. It’s really beautiful and my eyes have been opened. I don’t see the lives the men and women have at home but it’s great to see them in the studio and remember that the news shows us mostly political propaganda about other countries. Not the everyday goodness and struggles. Love from California.

[@TRYBALS]

Jen, your reply is so kind. Like you deeply care about her and me at the same time. You are correct, she goes through hell back at home. And I make sure she feels like a queen in the studio but it sometimes becomes too difficult for me. I'm not going beyond my limits. I deeply care for her. She has so much potential inside and I know it very well. She just needs a little encouragement and support. We sat down for a couple of hours today and celebrated the women's day with a cake. I know it's tomorrow but she was here today for the usual video but instead we just talked for hours and hours. So, we came with a possible solution and I hope it will work out for both of us, the channel and the viewers at the same time. Video will be up today or tomorrow hopefully. Hope for better, she needs all of us. She not only is emotionally abused but physically as well by her husband. It's not just another reactor for me to replace, I truly care for her as a brother and I know she can be a symbol for other women in future as well. She has come a long way since she joined here and I believe there's so much more she can learn.

[@TRYBALS]

All I want to say that I believe in her, I want her to be here. The world needs her. We need her!!!

[@markdelcheccolo9191]

I love their opinions because it's on a whole different level. The elders interpretations are so great and I have much respect for the elders.. Absolutely Wonderful !

[@LorenTravels]

This song is very pertinent to what is going on in Ukraine. Glad to see Parvatti back. I hope you can work it out, its a shame to let those who try to supress her win. Give that girl wings.

[@troywest]

17:24 - Absolutely true statement ... dying twice, if the war does not kill you the poverty will. The elderly gentleman, Abdul, is extremely wise, he has deep insights into human nature.

[@amandatheyahoo411]

I am going to rewatch this one. I had so many thoughts I need pen and paper. LOVE this song. Never knew alot of the meaning as you were describing it. I'm not joking (well kinda:)) when I say that this is definitely heavy matter, sir. Well done. ☮️ & ❤️ to all. Peace 🕊️ P.S. My sister Hollis just started watching a little. She is curious if you are going to play Bob Dylan? She requests Subterranean Homesick Blues to be precise. Now she's adding Blowin in the wind. 🤣 Anything Dylan 🎶✌🏼

[@amandatheyahoo411]

I'm overriding my sister... I vote Blowin in the Wind. Lol

[@d4mdcykey]

This was one of the most amazing videos I have ever seen, so much to unpack. Your ability at carefully detailing each part of the song within context they may not know regarding Western content. And then to have such excellent video quality and editing to witness their reactions. Superb job; new subscriber. Also, on a side note, the more years that go by the more undeniable it is that War Pigs is truly a brilliant song at a groundbreaking moment.

[@christinamadvig1468]

This song is so spot on ..down to the red flag...love what you are doing bringing so much of the world to these group of people..whom otherwise may not have ever experienced on their journey here. ✌❤🙏

[@johngeen5633]

I truly wish everybody would so open and understanding. These beautiful people have my respect. If they can do it everybody can. Love and respect from the Netherlands.🇳🇱🇺🇦

[@DimensionDevices]

Yo... I hope she doesn't feel this is impertinent, but Parvati looks GORGEOUS in red and black!

[@fjb2986]

I just found this channel. It's amazing. I enjoy listening to viewpoints from other cultures. I learn so much from there view points. I subscribed..

[@johnthompson6374]

Great timing for this song. Wise reactions as well. I have a guess on the song that you are building towards and I would ask you to consider the Jane's Addiction cover but I understand the arguments The VIP Trybals may endure just by the name of the song, so why ad trouble. Who could be mad at The Rolling Stones? Peace/JT

[@veroarg2091]

Hello People. I have just discovered your channel and have almost seen all the videos. So interesting! Congratulations for this maravellous idea . Greetings from Argentina❤

[@fairdose]

You should also play them the total opposite of “War Pigs” namely “Enjoy the Silence” or “Personal Jesus” by Depeche Mode

[@thomasosteen7110]

I have now watched many of your videos...I am 51 year old caucasian American....and I am overwhelmed at your understanding and appreciation of the content you speak on ...I am saddened over the politics and the media that drive agendas and keep many to stay only sheep when we truly need more lions...I would truly like to sit with anyone of you and have discussions..much ❤️

[@tomharrison4012]

Thank you for creating these videos for us to enjoy! Black Sabbath is one of the greatest bands ever. Another one that i would love for you to react to is Led Zeppelin. Anything that you see of theirs is well worth listening to but "stairway to heaven" and "when the levee breaks" are excellent places to start. Have fun!

[@TheGstein]

I really enjoy your questions and explanations! Great job with these videos! Much love from the US.

[@charlotteholmes3056]

Wow!!! Just in time...

[@richard1849]

amazing thoughtfulness, timing and content all around. down with the war pig up with Sabbath, ever since I was young

[@criseist9786]

I must've missed whatever situation is going on in the comments, but I want to say that you do what you need to. Stay healthy

[@drakeswarchannel2530]

I highly respect that these introspective people have provided their opinions on this music.

[@drakeswarchannel2530]

What does hallelujah literally mean? Hallelujah - Wikipedia The phrase "hallelujah" translates to "praise Jah/Yah", though it carries a deeper meaning as the word halel in Hebrew means a joyous praise in song, to boast in God. The second part, Yah, is a shortened form of YHWH, and is a shortened form of his name "God, Jah, or Jehovah".

[@jacksmith4460]

09:25 I love this dude, he is always so amazed by everything, they are all great, but he always seems to feel the messages

[@roachdoggjr45]

Glad to see her back!!

[@Tristum1970]

Folks can only judge from their experience - what they have seen- I don’t think Parvati has any way to gauge this song. This is heavy lifting for anyone.

[@stockpilesrus]

Thank you for these videos. It is so wonderful that we can eat share with each other and learn and appreciate and to give honesty. You have a new subscriber here and I also shared your videos to my Facebook page. Peace be with us all

[@mazdaman2315]

My ancestors have fought in wars for generations and in my mind war is evil but also in some cases a necessary evil just imagine if no one stood up to the nazis just what kind of world would we live in then, billions more would have been killed than the amount of people that ever died in that war, Asians, and Africans would have become either slaves of the nazis or been wiped out entirely, democracy would have been wiped out from the face of the earth, we may wind up with peace eventually but would you truly be able to call it peace if Jews Arabs and Catholics are wiped out or in internment camps?

[@StickyBud9395]

Wow this takes me back to my teens, I love watching these people's reaction to things on this You Tube channel.

[@Pwecko]

I feel that the lady in the video said what she thought you wanted her to say. When you asked if she thought the song was satanic, she looked for a sign from you to give her a hint as to what to say. The fact that you asked and persisted in asking probably made her think that it must be. She didn't seem to have any thoughts or opinions of her own. She just wanted to please you.

[@guinep]

I agree. If the song/video didn't make her feel anything, then she shouldn't have to feel like she was supposed to feel something. Apathy was her genuine reaction to what was being presented to her and that's fine. Obviously, that doesn't make for the most entertaining reaction, but it certainly is authentic and true to her character. I appreciate that and I'm sure many other viewers feel so as well. I also feel that Parvati already has so much running through her mind concerning the practical matters of her life, that she doesn't have any spare room for the more abstract thinking that is being sought from her in these types of videos. Lastly, I know that Adnan has reassured her that he encourages her to speak her mind and to challenge his perspective, but I can imagine how daunting that could be for her when she's been made to hold her tongue and to do as she's told by others for however long. I wouldn't be surprised if she's still wary of his leniency and is afraid that it's some kind of trap to get her in trouble with her husband and in-laws. We have to put ourselves in her shoes.

[@karenthorne2574]

I love hearing the different perspectives of the Tribal People. The one elder in the group seems like he has such a big heart. The young man that likes Cindy Louper has such a keen eye. He sees things I never noticed before. The gentleman with the thick beard challenges me to think a different way. The dear lady in the group, educates me on living in her society. The man behind the camera is very well informed about everything regarding these songs. I am very impressed by everything I've seen so far. I'm sorry I don't know anyone's names yet. I just started watching today. At the end of the song, they kept playing the same rift over and over again just before it speeds up. It seemed almost like the group was saying that war keeps repeating. Then the speeding up of the music is fast forwarding through the future till Judgement (when the music stops) and there is no time left to change. I know what you were getting at when speaking of whether anyone could hear anything satanic about the song. It's sad to say that some people spend more time criticizing than listening to music. I had an argument with my pastor about Pat Benatar's "Hell Is For Children". I kept trying to explain that it was about child abuse.

[@SuperbusQuartus159]

I would love to see everyone's reactions to "still feel" by the band half•alive. The song is so catchy and groovy and the music video is super cool, too, so I think you all would like it!

[@user-mu5ny1ks6t]

I am really appreciative of the insight of your guests. I like to see how people around the world think. These people look at things more deeply than I think the average American does. I would enjoy getting to know these people more.

[@Jay-fv1ph]

Hello! I love your channel and i have been thinking about a song i have wanted to recommend to you all for a while it's called "Bread and Roses" my favorite version is by Judy Collins. The song was originally a poem written by James Oppenheim based off of a suffragette speech in 1911. The slogan "Bread and Roses" was used throughout the women's rights movement in the early 20th century and has been quoted during other equal rights protests and movements since then. I think it would be really cool to see what they all think of its meaning and its impact.

[@calafiamedia]

Yesss I’d love to see this. Beautiful song too. Solidarity 🌹

[@donnasqueo6599]

I've been a bit busy lately. Now getting back to some of the content here again. I am excited for this.❤️

[@michaelcurtis8419]

She is beautiful!

[@ericlitts9917]

I love the content. It's just humanity. Wisdom. Grace. Humility.

[@emeral311]

Go on Reddit and find a girl like you who can explain things to Pavarti. The concepts are totally different and I understand why she would say something is satanic. And if you've read John Milton's Paradise Lost you can understand what Pavarti may have been implying (if the translation of Satanic is correct since there is no concept of Satan in Hinduism if I am right). Pavarti doesn't get it now but she will get it soon. Trust me. It's frustrating. But I saw it when she was watching the lead singer of the Cranberries yell. Something in her clicked. She's very smart. We just need different tools to get to Pavarti. You're on the right track. Keep it up!

[@BobbySusenbach]

Great reaction. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. Soundgarden was musically inspiring during my youth. Chris was on another plane, vocally. Makes me sad to think about him now.

[@SonicImmersion_]

Another excellent anti-war song that also happens to be heavy metal is Metallica -"One". Showing the horrors done to the individual soldier. Official music video on this one adds a lot of context and emotion, both in the movie scenes and the pained expressions in the singer's face and voice.

[@fmfdocbotl4358]

Johnny's got his gun

[@gertrudelaronge6864]

Great analysis of the song. I really enjoyed that, thanks.

[@SteveSmith-zz4ih]

Parvati is back, good to see her, she adds a woman s perspective.

[@garycoates4987]

Blessings to you all, you should react to JINJER again with their song "home back" which is about having to flee their home town in Ukraine years back when Russia attacked, now it's very topical as Ukraine is under siege again, Jinjer are working for building aid and support for their country right now

[@TRYBALS]

I'm following them on insta, it's beautiful how they are using the band to help their country. I'd love to show it to our group if it could help Jinjer or their country. P.S: Mukhtiar is already a fan of Tati lol

[@garycoates4987]

@@TRYBALS I believe that it would help , also a lot of creators are pinning the video that Eugene put up of his "message from Ukraine" the situation is truly heartbreaking but the band has risen to give back and help