Tried Every POP-TART Flavor To Tell You Which Ones Are The BEST - Pop Tart Challenge

[@lynniev]

The raspberry rant made my entire day. "What kind of bullsh*t is that?!" I felt that in my soul 😂😂😂😂

[@bella-mccord]

This reminds me of the Cheat Day episode with Joslyn and Lily, when you gave them hints in the background 🖤. Also takes me back to my high school days, when i would buy the strawberry ones out of the vending machines occasionally for my lunch as a "treat" lol

[@Stephrp613]

Love the unfrosted strawberry toasted with a cup of tea for dessert occasionally

[@emilywynstra]

Ok picture this....a S'mores Poptart TOASTED in an actual bonfire!!! That flavor and frosted sprinkle strawberry were my fav as a little girl 😋

[@erical8437]

Growing up, a lady in our neighborhood used to give out the silver two packs as Halloween treats. It was kind of fun getting surprised once you unwrapped them! Maybe an idea for you!

[@laurensteenkamp7693]

The day after Halloween; Parent; No, you can't have sweets/ candy for breakfast. Child 1; But... Mrs Smith from ...Street gave me Poptarts. A few minutes later... Child 2; What did you get? Child 1; Brown sugar cinnamon, you? Child 2; Cookie and Cream

[@catherine-eggallergyinmd]

Raspberry is my favorite because to me it's more tart/tangy which makes it taste less sickeningly sweet. When eating my pop tarts I break off the unfrosted no filling bits and just eat the center part 😅. I felt that strawberry preserves vs. grape jelly. I dislike all things that are artificial grape flavored because my parents only gave us that kids grape cough syrup growing up 🤢.

[@Adrianaaaa365]

Loved this video Erin! You should try every Blue Bell ice cream flavor next, my favorite is banana pudding!

[@tbrown7911]

Is Blue Bell sold in her area?

[@ErinRobinson]

Great idea!!!!!!!!!

[@RosieO83]

The wild berry looks like Rocko’s shirt from rocko’s modern life . Love watching your videos.

[@HassanRaashid]

13:41 You're so funny! I love watching your food vids so much, especially when you give little backstories into some of what the flavours taste and feel like 😂

[@crimsonmason1281]

Stores near me also have frosted Boston crème donut and Apple Jacks flavored ones!

[@Witchy_Woman55]

I’ve been looking for the Boston Crème

[@calinique]

“We did it Jo””!” Hehe! IYKYK ☺️

[@ashleymolina2177]

I love that you have a Christmas tree in the background! I have had a Christmas tree up for three years! I like the lighting ambiance in my living room when I’m watching tv at night

[@cindynoel585]

I say it every time but you truly are my favorite food reviewer ❤ You are so adorable and funny! This was fantastic

[@ElizabethNicoleSchwartz]

My parents only let me get strawberry or brown sugar cinnamon growing up. which... I was definitely missing out. Personally I feel like the chocolate type ones are better than the fruit ones.

[@ErinRobinson]

What is wrong with parents?!?!?!?! Why were they like this?!?

[@ElizabethNicoleSchwartz]

​@@ErinRobinsoni guess they thought they were healthier? Which is arguable 🤣

[@bethrobinson2136]

I eat the chocolate fudge ones with Tostitos. Make a sandwich out of the little circles. Game changer. Any corn chip really

[@Star_dogs12]

I never got any pop tarts maybe a few times on the vacations we went on but that’s all

[@jessicagates7652]

Lol mine did the same but it was because Costco sold a big pack of those two flavors together

[@ashleywalker2675]

You have to put the smores in the toaster. It would bump it up on your list for sure. Also my second favorite is the Sugar cookie one that comes out around December

[@hannahhargett447]

The strawberry (frosted and unfrosted), brown sugar and frosted blueberry are the GOAT's of pop tarts. Toast them and put butter on them girrrrrrl... only way to eat them.

[@bethany9008]

My absolute fave is the frosted raspberry. Sweet/tart..yum yum

[@DaughterOfTheKingdom16]

As a preschool teacher, I will tell you right now it does smell like bacteria, infections, pop, tarts, and goldfish crackers

[@Toasterr15]

I used to love the pumpkin pie toasted with butter spread over it… but I’m glad I’m not the only one that appreciates the unfrosted. 😂

[@kira_333_skz]

Glad you started taking your bites from the middle. So much better that way!

[@breannawyche8745]

OMG when you wore a blue shirt similar to the box color! Brown sugar and wild berry are my favorites! But I do love s'mores, strawberry, blueberry, the chocolate fudge and the Oreo one. The frosted cupcake is good too but I can't finish a whole box. They have a cinnamon roll, peanut butter and jelly, and red velvet cupcake too I heard are pretty good.

[@Lwolff8912]

The vanilla cupcake one in the toaster is AMAZING

[@carriesessum2505]

Yay !! I’m without little ones today for a few hours and was just getting bored ! You saved the day 😁

[@ErinRobinson]

I'm HONORED!!!!!

[@mizzbritt2082]

Pop tarts are totally a breakfast food....I only eat them in the air fryer now! Lol

[@ErinRobinson]

OH MY GOSH...I bet in the air fryer they are AMAZING

[@jimw966]

Definitely a raw dog pop tarter and brown sugar cinnamon was my go to. Of course it’s been a few years since I last had one and they probably taste like cardboard now 😂😂 Have a fabulous day Erin 😃

[@shannonwatson8840]

My favorite is non frosted strawberry warm and with lots of butter. I also like chocolate fudge right out of the box!

[@NeilDeal2023]

I'm old enough to remember when all pop tarts were unfrosted. One of my fav frosted flavs was Dutch apple. Not sure what made them Dutch, but they were so good! 🍎

[@ErinRobinson]

Wait, was that a thing?!?! All of them came UNFROSTED!?!?

[@NeilDeal2023]

@@ErinRobinson Yep, they did. I think the original concept was supposed to be like a real tart (for the toaster) but Kellogg’s probably realized they would sell more if they added even more sugar.🧁

[@DanielleLegacy]

We somehow always had poptarts in the house, but only certain kinds: plain, strawberry frosted, & brown cinnamon. Then, later on we added in smores, wild berry, & cookies and creme on occasion. I remember loving the smores. But you gotta toast them!

[@ashleynorris1066]

Unfrosted cherry is my favorite but now I’m gonna have to go try a bunch of these! Erin, you have to try the raspberry cheesecake cookie at subway, it may change your mind about raspberry 🍪🍪

[@jeoffmetry]

When you said “Kids Google rugrats” I suddenly felt my age 😩 Like oh yeah kids didn’t grow up with rugrats like we did 😭

[@kimmurray9346]

I do love that Blueberry ❤

[@heathermcelwain3857]

I'm surprised you don't like Raspberry. I love Raspberry anything

[@SaraahBear]

i'm not big on heating them up, BUT the Hot Fudge Sunday ones, i do put those in the freezer, because it makes taste closer to ice cream, and i love it that way, best way to eat those imo

[@tyggrlili26]

I have always thought they were all to swee,t so my preference is the unfrosted Strawberry hands down. Great video as always!

[@summmnshine1998]

Toast the pop tart when my Dad would let me buy them. Frosted strawberry ( all day every day) is my jam and the only one we could buy! Now I need to try the cookies and cream!

[@clwm2dlw]

Wow there are alot of pop tart flavors I've never heard of. Blueberry is and always will be my favorite❤❤

[@KelseyPaige1984]

Brown Sugar is ALSO the only Pop Tart my mother would buy! 😢 It is still my favorite though, but Frosted Strawberry is definitely the 2nd best!!

[@HassanRaashid]

10:54 omg, I'm literally the same way, I do not like cherrys, but Cherry Coke, Cherry Lollipops and any Cherry flavoured sweets are so good! 😋

[@LarrietDarling]

The s'mores ones have been my guilty pleasure since college. 😅 I need to try those eggo ones. You've piqued my interest.

[@tisheba]

A toasted, unfrosted poptart with butter on it is delicious. Perfect dessert.

[@christymurcia-chavez3586]

I loooove the unfrosted strawberry toasted!! I feel the frosting is just a bit too sweet. But always toasted!! (Unless eating on a road trip)

[@Lauren-yq3ds]

Agreed!!

[@nowaboutthatpod]

Put that cookies and cream in the freezer. Chefs kiss!!!

[@abbeystreich2260]

Hot fudge sundae OR s’mores-freeze them and then eat them. SO delicious.

[@maggiek48265]

4:22 Ohh the Oreo one is good too. I guess I never realized how similar they taste. Man now I want pop tarts hahah 😂😊

[@crystalbarfoot]

Ah, Love this Erin. 💗 Long live the Strawberry Frosted and Chocolate Frosted, toasted! 🤭😂

[@emilybilbow4990]

Sugar cookie pop tarts that come out at Christmas are really good!! I disagree with you on rankings but enjoyed this thoroughly!!!!

[@coffeegirl18]

I was always allowed to pick a treat out for vacation and I'd usually pick Blueberry PopTarts. It's very nostalgic and still delicious. Confetti Cupcake is my new fave. I bought them to stop myself from eating worse food.

[@ashleymolina2177]

My mom always loved the chocolate fudge toasted and she would rub butter on both sides when it was still hot

[@OHSloopyIO]

I always liked mine warmed up just a tad in the micro. All time favorite the frosted blueberry and then the grape. Then the snickerdoodle. And I'd eat anything pumpkin first. I am one of those. Now I want a Pop Tart. Darnit!!!

[@Kanoelani1995]

Blueberry without the frosting was the best!

[@lukethomas6900]

Frosted Cherry, Cookies n' Creme, and Brown Sugar were always my favorite ones as a kid.

[@spaceghost27]

all of them are improved by heating up. love the new banana bread flavor so much.

[@alwaysbeingbelle4409]

The frosted banana bread one was soooo sweet I almost gagged.

[@lauraellerman9443]

I love the blueberry unfrosted plain!

[@sunny5ma]

Lmao ahahaha Erin, you definitely are funny!!! This was so fun and enjoyable to watch ❤❤❤❤

[@ErinRobinson]

I don't know about funny but I definitely have a good time doing these!

[@laurensteenkamp7693]

Most people worry about their partner cheating on them, Matt should be worried about Erin cheating on him with one or more Poptarts (Brown sugar+ cinnamon definitely in the mix)

[@lextasy227]

Growin up i never heated up poptarts but as an adult i do and boy oh boy what a game changer!

[@ginajen2217]

I’m going to try the Oreo I trust you. You help me find the BEST ranch ever!

[@ErinRobinson]

You know I got you! I bet if you warm it up it will be even more mind blowing!

[@jenniferwillis2611]

My favorite besides brown sugar cinnamon is frosted blueberry toasted slathered in butter. Blueberry muff vibes🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@soniabarnett778]

Blueberry frosted, chocolate fudge, cookies and cream, strawberry and brown sugar cinnamon. Toasted please.

[@daniellejones2962]

My favorites are forever gonna be the S’mores, Wild Berry, Apple Flavor and Cinnamon Flavored, since 17 years old, they have been my go to, I’m an 80’s baby

[@laurak5174]

I stooped eating PopTarts when my tongue swelled up after eating the Brown Sugar Cinnamon ones.

[@ashleyn5466]

Great video love when you post. The only one I think you missed was the Boston cream donut one

[@chelseawalsh2224]

The frosted chocolate fudge is great warmed up

[@Luigi-2025]

Cherry and chocolate fudge are my favorites ❤

[@delaniealina2557]

The blueberry are superior And I really like the snickerdoodle. They have a banana bread one out that’s new that I really want to try.

[@blugreen123]

My favorites are the brown sugar cinnamon and the frosted blueberry. Growing up, we usually had the strawberry, cherry or occasionally the brown sugar. Before they were mostly frosted, we used to toast them and put butter on them. 😍 My husband still slathers butter on the frosted ones.

[@PeriWinkle33957]

SAME, exact same.

[@preciousonejewel]

this vid was so incredibly relatable lol i was only allowed the strawberry pop tarts as a kid (if i was allowed them at all, which was hardly ever) i agreed with everything you said except for the raspberry, i love rasberry things :) but other than that yesss lol especially the comment about the wildberry being just "the 90s" lol thats so accurate. and switching from grape jelly to strawberry jam..that TOTALLY happened to me haha

[@xhal.editsx7943]

My favorite is the red velvet!! ❤

[@monicacannamiss9631]

Cinnamon roll is really good. 👌 didn't see that one in the video. Haven't had it in years though lol not sure if it's even around still. And you are funny girl lol. Blessings ❤🙏

[@CadenceJones821]

I love raspberries! I like all the fruit poptarts. I was screaming every time you took bites with the crust to judge this, that's the worst part 😂😂. I never even eat the crust of the poptart.

[@WhisperingMeadowss]

S'mores and wild berry, are superior !!!!!!

[@PSpringer18]

i used to get chocolate chip cookie dough, redvelvet and i've had blueberry muffin. I also remember a strawberry milkshake.They may have discontinued these flavors

[@NorseButterfly]

My youngest son loves the wild berry ones. I'm fond of the raspberry. We don't do unfrosted Pop Tarts in our house, even my 77yo mom won't eat those. Occasionally, limited edition flavors are a nice change, but the peach cobbler flavor was just wrong.

[@robynroberts3576]

My favorite is the unfrosted strawberry toasted with melted butter on top

[@jadebarr80]

old navy has the blueberry pop tart in a sweater 😂 it’s literally a cream/white color with the colorful specks 😳

[@kelbystewart4325]

The only poptart that comes out on top is Wild berry with the blue squiggle. Second is the Chocolate chip cookie dough with the chocolate squiggle but freeze it and eat it . Then the classic brown cinnamon sugar

[@CourtneyVisconti]

Same! We only ever had frosted brown sugar but my Mom would have a secret stash of unfrosted Strawberry which was only hers… based on ur review now I know why! 😂 They do make an actual cookie dough pop tart too that I’ve seen.

[@MarlyLynn]

I’m a raw dawg break in half pop tart eater. Pleased to see we agree on something here with the s’mores, blueberry, and wild berry.. and of course brown sugar cinnamon 😊 Also- I couldn’t agree more.. WHY don’t expensive restaurants have indulgent apple pies?? What a great thought!

[@elise85391]

Cookies and Crème has been my favorite for the last several years, but I may need to try some new flavors! Also, if there are any other pop tart connoisseurs here, does anybody else remember the Sugar Cookie pop tarts? They used to be seasonal like around Christmas I think. But I haven’t seen them in ages. Now I’m wondering though if that cupcake flavor would taste similar??? Not sure if I’ll ever fully forgive poptart if they completely got rid of that flavor😢

[@ErinRobinson]

Time to venture out!! You have good taste, so I believe in you!!

[@neilvarma]

Blueberry and raspberry work as tarts !!

[@kaylad760]

Frosted Rasberry is my all time favorite pop tart 🥺😂

[@kaylad760]

With grape as my second 😂

[@Witchy_Woman55]

Strawberry Frosted toasted are my favorites. I’ve been looking for the Snickerdoodle ones

[@adrianruvalcaba3897]

I'll love this chocolate, strawberry, peaches, and more.

[@samanthalillis3831]

Pan fried in butter on the backside is what we do when we go camping and it slaps

[@eddiew2325]

i deep fry mine in breadcrumbs and dip it in sirarcha mayo

[@evanj3535]

In terms of inanimate objects, they made several Toy Story movies, a Lego Movie, and a Barbie movie. They should make a Pop-Tart movie and have you in it.

[@joannepreston611]

Ironically a pop tart movie is out now on Netflix called Unfrosted. You either love it or hate it. I wanted to love it but hated it😅

[@tlittle6056]

I have to try the chocolate chip now. ^_^ The chocolate fudge is awesome heated up though!

[@jaime9718]

you need to do every frozen eggo!! waffles, pancakes, french toast, etc!!

[@OpenWorldGirlMR]

The most underrated flavors that are my #1 faves is the strawberry milkshake and vanilla milkshake. The vanilla milkshake one i used to get in middle school around christmas time and they had snowmen and stuff printed on them. Iykyk.

[@OpenWorldGirlMR]

The snowmen might not have been milkshake flavor but i have a very strong memory of that.... any poptart experts help me out lol

[@skylarhamilton3913]

1. Cannot believe your tree is up 😂 2. If you toast, the s’mores pop tart and then have it with a small glass of milk. It is a match made in heaven. I do like that flavor plain as well. The other flavors honestly sound too sweet. 😢

[@jacquelinemaat]

Should’ve tried the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough flavour!!

[@amandag3716]

Well, before my gluten intolerance was stumbled upon 🙃 toasted all the way!! Girl, you should have toasted them!! Oh how I miss poptarts. Also, my fav was always the go to brown sugar cinnamon, even without being limited. I used to lick the top before I ate it 😅😅

[@wickednailsrylee]

🙋🏼‍♀️🙋🏼‍♀️🙋🏼‍♀️😢

[@ErinRobinson]

I debated on toasting them but I figured I should stick to my preference to make sure my reviews were pure 😂

[@AverageJoe483]

Micro wave them really quick , way better than the toaster oven !

[@eternalbookwyrm9481]

I love raspberry!!! Both regular and golden!!! I like them better than blueberries. The lemon pie one is my fave. I now need to get the Pumpkin poptarts!!

[@ErinRobinson]

Is the lemon pie seasonal!?!? I didn't see that anywhere

[@pinkyfrosted6769]

I grew up with my parents buying the strawberry when we were little and then the s’mores when we were older. I now love and find BSC superior and I warm them up maybe 1/5 of the times I eat them.

[@Sarah-ul9ec]

Hot fudge sundae is thee best! You gotta toast it !!!

[@kaitlynmayton6926]

You should put the hot fudge Sunday one in the freezer! GAME CHANGER!!!!

[@catherinedorin5046]

I haven’t had Pop tarts in years. I did not heat them up, ate them from the package. My favorites were the Brown Sugar Cinnamon and Chocolate. I love your videos!!!😊

[@matteaoatman6403]

The fruit loops ones are straight sugar but my faaaavorite!!

[@nighthawkdragonfly8339]

I am with you about not hearing it up although once in a while I do heat them. Unfrosted just why ? Lol Kind of jealous about all the flavors as we dont have some of those in Canada I dont think. Thanks for another great video.