Try Guys Bake Cinnamon Rolls Without A Recipe

Who's cinnamon rolls with swirl out on top on the very first episode of this year's #WithoutARecipe holiday season?! Watch us bake these rolls with no recipe... uh-ohhhh
Shop our Talking Figurines, Slippers, Hoodies & more on tryguys.com/ right now! And don't miss our holiday deals with sales up to 20% off all winter long!
Are you a business looking to work with The Try Guys? Reach out to us at [e-mail] for all business inquiries!
🎧THE TRYPOD 🎧: watch our new podcast at / trypod or listen at tryguys.com/podcast
📘THE HIDDEN POWER OF F*CKING UP 📘: check out our new book at tryguys.com/book
Get your official Try Guys color hoodies and phone cases at tryguys.com/collections/color... 💙❤️💚💜
Support us! / tryguys . Join our Patreon to get videos a day early, plus, live streams, chatrooms, BTS footage, exclusive merchandise, and more!
SUBSCRIBE TO AND FOLLOW THE TRY GUYS
/ tryguys
/ tryguys
/ tryguys
/ tryguys
FOLLOW THE GUYS
/ keithhabs
/ nedfulmer
/ korndiddy
/ eugeneleeyang
/ keithhabs
/ nedfulmer
/ korndiddy
/ eugeneleeyang
THE TRY GUYS
The #TryGuys is the flagship channel of 2ND TRY, LLC. Tune in twice a week for shows from Keith, Ned, Zach and Eugene, the creators and stars of The Try Guys.
FEATURING
Rosanna Pansino - Baker & KZbinr
Check out all of her amazing cooking content online!
Website: www.RosannaPansino.com
KZbin: @RosannaPansino / rosannapansino
Instagram: @rosannapansino / rosannapansino
Twitter: @rosannapansino / rosannapansino
ALEXANDER PHANEUF - Owner & Chef at Lodge Bread Co
Website: www.lodgebread.com/
Instagram: / lodgebreadco
OR AMSALAM- Owner & Chef at Lodge Bread Co
Website: www.lodgebread.com/
Instagram: / lodgebreadco
Josh Scherer - Food Guy @Mythical & @Mythicalkitchen, and host of A Hot Dog Is A Sandwich Podcast
Instagram: @mythicalchefjosh / mythicalchefjosh
Ted Evans- Voice Over
Instagram: @tedevansvo
EDITED BY
Devlin McCluskey
EXTERNAL CREW
Dawn Shim - Director of Photography
Niki Ford - Food Stylist
Susannah Honey - Production Designer
Krista Lu - Art Director
Mia Han - Set Dresser
Stephanie Scheele - Shopper/Art Production Assistant
Kate Steinhebel - Camera Operator
Richie Yau - Camera Operator
Kevin Castro - Camera Operator
Allen Chodakowski - Camera Operator
Angelo Clarizio - Camera Operator
Devon Hoff Weekes - Camera Operator
Trevor Nitschske - 1st AC
Sarah Davis Brenninkmeyer - 2nd AC
Will Brenninkmeyer - 2nd AC
Abigail Relatado - 2nd AC
Marshall Victory - Gaffer
Justin Thatcher - Gaffer
Dom Ellis - Key Grip
Edgar Castilllo - Production Assistant
Hannah Jorgensen - Production Assistant
James DeVore - Sound Mixer
David Beede - Sound Mixer
Kevin Coons - Boom Operator
John Wassel - Boom Operator
Colleen Tighe - Illustrator
Cable Adkins - Sound Mixing
MUSIC
Licensed from AudioNetwork
SFX
Licensed from Audioblocks
VIDEO
Licensed from Videoblocks
Official Try Guys Photos
By Mandee Johnson Photography | @mandeephoto
2nd TRY LLC STAFF
Rachel Ann Cole - Senior Producer & Head of Post Production
Nick Rufca - Senior Producer & Head of Company Operations
Alexandria Herring - Associate Producer
Jonathan Kirk - Assistant Production Office Coordinator
Jack McGill - Production Assistant & 2nd Try Sound Operator
Kaylin Burke - Brand Manager
Aiko Igasaki - Social Editor
Jake LaRosa - Patreon Creative Assistant
Angie Linzaga - Social Intern
Miles Bonsignore - Podcast Producer
Raine Toll - Podcast Assistant
Devlin McCluskey - Senior Editor
YB Chang - Senior Editor
Elliot Dickerhoof - Editor
Mishelle Martin - Editor
Skyler Klingenberg - Editor
Will Witwer - Post Production Coordinator
Moira Joy Smith - Assistant Editor
Special Thanks To!
Thanks to all of our Gold Level Patrons! Athena, AJ S., Amy Fleming, Ana Camba, Cat Hicks, Elisa Proust, Emma Godfrey, Erica Rao, Jared Aarons, Kelsey Bock, Kourtney Wong, Loretta Wen, Matthew Tadros, Miha, Paulus, Sarah Waxman, Traci Lew, Wendy Tran, Lily

[@tryguys]

Shop our Talking Figurines, Slippers, Hoodies & more on tryguys.com right now! And don't miss our holiday deals with sales up to 20% off all winter long!

[@adeletaylor6143]

What about Jay the total normal business human?

[@SmokenHash]

@@adeletaylor6143 I really want to buy him. ㅠㅠ

[@Amsayy]

Y'all really gotta start allowing more time for these boys to bake their shit lmao

[@JimGamingTV]

WE NEED A REDO

[@SmokenHash]

@@Amsayy For real, when 3/4 are underbaked, it's a time issue.

[@just_a_butterfly]

The guy saying over and over "butter, cinnamon and sugar" while the guys are adding literally everything to their filling is amazing

[@craftymind406]

I was trying so hard not to bust out laughing tbh 💀💀💀

[@off.arretezvousx]

The best part about WAR (without a recipe) has to be the pro saying don’t do this and then it immediately cuts to one of the guys doing the exact thing the pro says to NOT do.

[@ronanlee2399]

Eugene did the butter cinnamon and sugar but bloody

[@cutie5lexis]

It’s like watching a child disregard your simplest asks of them. 🤣

[@daveed6281]

“It’s Starbucks creative” is this season’s “You should pursue other means to honor your father”

[@ellap2851]

WHAT VIDEO IS THAT FROM

[@averymontemayor8420]

@@ellap2851 the bagel episode I think

[@possiblychey]

@@averymontemayor8420 yep! Bagel episode! One of my faves

[@besassyxo]

omg who said the last quote thats so funny

[@gia205]

@@besassyxo one of the judges in the bagel episode

[@schuyleramethyst8409]

ned saying "it's not a mistake, it's a choice" didn't age well

[@killjoyer]

OMG 💀

[@yamisice]

I choked watching that part😂😂😂😂

[@maylin827]

Aged like my half-eaten avocado sandwich

[@kinagrill]

At least it wasn't mommy's favorite choice.

[@KL-bt3gp]

Also, most of his foods represent himself pretty well: "look kinda delicious and decent on the outside, but flavorless and unedible on the inside", aka, a huge deception 😂

[@alexiswoodberry9119]

I really appreciate Eugene having the red eyeshadow in all these thumbnails so it's easy for me to come back and find all the evil episodes

[@mars7609]

I do the same lmaoo

[@faithparish6337]

Josh trying to insult Ned by saying his roll could be sold at a starbucks but little does he know Ned is the most basic out of all of them and would be HONORED to have his cinnabaklavaroll at a Starbucks.

[@sadie1347]

add a pumpkin spice latte and you’ve reached peak Ned-ness

[@koostattoos-8859]

i dont think he was trying to insult ned, just trying to explain to him how his wasn't v creative

[@Priya-zc1mi]

@@koostattoos-8859 it kind of annoyed me tbh, I feel like the boys really just kind of try and top themselves with ridiculous ideas to the point where they stop making sense (i.e. Keith's, they didn't even really understand it). If they have a truly one-of-a-kind idea, that's great, but I disagree that Ned's isn't creative enough, or that being "Starbucks creative" should count against him just because he balances creativity with other criteria.

[@cloudpuffs9977]

@@Priya-zc1mi Ned never makes anything memorable. I literally forgot what he made after watching this episode. Eugene and Keith are so creative I love them so much!

[@sadie1347]

@@liamgallacher he’d order it for Wes and Finn 🥺

[@Theamazingchubaness]

Love how Rosana's standards for the Try Guys' cooking, after judging multiple seasons, is just that she wants the goods to actually be baked/cooked all the way through lmao. Bonus is even that low bar is not always met

[@linda3455]

They set the try guys up, literally right when the guy said bake it for 45-50 mins, they jump to the try guys only having 30 mins to bake. If that isn't setting them up for failure, idk what is (just saying, the crew should have done their research, before giving them that amount of time)

[@Kim-id1tf]

@@linda3455 I was thinking the same thing. Everyone’s food was undercooked basically like what,

[@Tiernan422]

@@linda3455 agree, they should've had a countdown to finish making all their stuff and then cook them all together for the same time

[@vitzveer]

@@linda3455 They even set to make everything on the first day and the second day was for baking only and they got 30 minutes? That made no sense whatsoever. Why can't they have maybe an hour at least, since there was nothing else to be done on that 2nd day anyway.

[@reginatrigos8215]

@@linda3455 naaah, time management is part of baking just like in baking competitions.

[@carissamacdonald5600]

So funny that since Rosanna has been here since the beginning she is just “hoping for something cooked” while all the new judges are asking for specifics in texture etc. she knows our boys.

[@kenna176]

This is exactly what I was thinking. I love where she set the bar.

[@gabriellahaug2844]

This is the comment I was looking for! I knew someone had to think the same thing!

[@ariba5544]

she’s just like as long as i can eat it, it’s great 😂

[@sarafontanini7051]

and sadly they didn't even get that right

[@eleanorcooke7136]

​@@kenna176 and sometimes they can't even reach that. The bar was on the floor guys...

[@iwanttoeuthanizemyself8502]

Eugene looks evil, Zach looks scared of cinnamon rolls, Keith looks confused as ever, and Ned looks like he’s planning on ruining his marriage.

[@neven0629]

😂😂😂

[@Sh1roNekoshi]

16:10, he's totally right

[@RainbowSunny1]

Oop

[@CinnamonToast77]

I was gonna say that that aged perfectly but then i saw the date

[@abybergdahl]

Love this lmao

[@ElizabethJendrzey]

The new judges talking about crust texture and quality of rolling while Ro is just like "Please be cooked, my standards are so low here"

[@Marianasia12345]

And still they fail her bc it wasn't cooked like at all

[@b0rahae0613]

@@Marianasia12345 Well, They weren't given enough time to let it cook through so it's not their fault either. Probably poor time management by the crew.

[@eleanorcooke7136]

@@b0rahae0613 it's probably because they film all the episodes in one block as they only rent the space for a day or two. The expert said to cook the rolls for 45mins but those were huge so 15-20mins would be fine for the guys. I think the issue came with the ovens.

[@lillianj2048]

Keith's cinnamon roll: has no cinnamon and is not rolled Keith: doesn't win Keith: 👁👄👁

[@davydoesthings]

Yet somehow his wasn't the worst🤣

[@Subterranean_sebastian]

@@davydoesthings I believe he didn’t lose because of the points he got for creativity

[@nakynie463]

Lmao so true

[@tama3442]

Have faith in JESUS CHRIST as LORD and SAVIOR for HE SAVES from hell❗️ *What is the Gospel?* The true gospel is the good news that God saves sinners. Man is by nature sinful and separated from God with no hope of remedying that situation. But God, by His power, provided the means of man’s redemption in the death, burial, and resurrection of the Savior, Jesus Christ. Ephesians 2:8-9 For it is by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of GOD, not a result of works, so that no one may boast. Romans 10:9 9 because, if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. JESUS CHRIST can come anytime! Just Believe ❤️ Love you and GOD BLESS

[@Subterranean_sebastian]

@@tama3442 I’m Jewish…

[@p.5944]

Eugene going for Dark and Bloody but having it taste THE MOST like a cinnamon roll is basically an allegory for him as a baked good.

[@youknowwhat1352]

aw

[@harimukund4785]

Yes i agree i would devour him too

[@abbieplate1785]

I also find it funny that before Eugene's judging, there was a cute little bunny before it with evil music in the back.

[@mahshidsoleymani3962]

looks it would kill you... is a cinnamon roll!

[@SeeYou_Slater]

Love that analogy

[@katrinna7311]

“IT’S NOT A MISTAKE, IT’S A CHOICE”… this needs to be made into a shirt. All proceeds go to Ariel and her kids to pay for a divorce attorney

[@couch2558]

I would 100% pay for that. Especially if on the back its said "-Ned Fulmor, the guy who cheated on his wife" or something

[@kendra6577]

Omg yesss

[@mrgayfish2960]

Yes please someone make those shirts

[@atinyseonghwa6653]

*college fund

[@melsthemagnificent8179]

Ooooohhh

[@caithenry8429]

Josh was EXACTLY the chaotic energy this show needed to evolve past Zach's chewy tea BTS ice cream cake and Eugene's spicey firetruck

[@licia_bobishka]

Yes! I’d like him to be a permanent judge like Ro

[@finnolson1992]

@@licia_bobishka no

[@fishbo_uses_soap]

​@@finnolson1992yes. Josh is great

[@8happybunny]

Literally screaming that Eugene’s pigs blood cinnamon roll was more of a cinnamon roll than Zach’s normal cinnamon roll

[@Kat-qr7hv]

I love Eugene’s villain origin story but I was absolutely gagging every time it showed the blood

[@A.CMc1997]

I am used to seeing pig blood COOKED. This is probably the only time I saw it used used raw AND for a pastry hahaha 😂

[@80sGamerLady]

I could never even eat it. I'd throw up.

[@jillianj310]

@@A.CMc1997 they said it was cooked, so I think it was boiled previously.

[@Rebeccaa54687]

@@A.CMc1997 Eugene mentioned he boiled it beforehand and it was all safely and throughly cooked

[@designerKAYA]

Josh's excitement and pure glee at both the concept of bloomin' onion cinnamon rolls AND the use of pig's blood is so ridiculously in character and perfectly in keeping with the things they come up with in the Mythical Kitchen.

[@goldilox369]

Was looking for this comment. His unmitigated glee over pig's blood made me wonder how long it will take for a version of this to show up on Rhett and Link. 😂

[@gracechapin6128]

Pigs blood is such an og gmm thing

[@AndaPanda2992]

@@gracechapin6128 Eugene even boiled it for safety

[@mars_mayday]

I've never seen Josh in a video before but this video made me immediately love him. He seems so supportive and open-minded!

[@eleanorcooke7136]

​@@AndaPanda2992 I wonder if they were in the UK,it would've worked better. Because of the precautions taken with our animals, out meat, although not meant to be eaten raw, is safe to do so. In the UK he probably wouldn't have needed to cook it so maybe the flavour would've been stronger.

[@C0ZYx]

It’s sad all of their dishes were raw because they didn’t give them enough time to put cinnamon rolls in the oven. They didn’t even give them like 45 minutes, which is what the baker said you should put them in for, but they gave them 15 minutes less too!

[@regarded-raccoon]

exactly!! not even just this episode, they constantly are given not even time and the judges always say "well if you had more time"

[@viacoffey6580]

i think the reason that the judge’s rolls take so long is the size (they’re genuinely head sized) whereas the boys didn’t make them nearly as big. i make small ones at home and it takes 15-20 minutes

[@ZaynMalik-sq2li]

The boys also consistently have issues with the oven, either replacing it or using the blaster that’s outside would work much better than their current oven.

[@itsnooooofun]

@@ZaynMalik-sq2li the problem with the outside oven is just that it's much harder to watch your stuff while you do something else, so it ended up burnt a couple of times. they should either give them more time during the baking phase or just replace the inside oven

[@Bugbrainedmess]

They have 4h over 2 days for each dish so they had plenty of time

[@gennabourquin5287]

the cuts between the “butter, cinnamon, and sugar” and them putting NONE of that in it is comedy gold

[@suzyq0076]

My favorite 🤣 And Zach the “I’m so bored” after being denied Cinnamon Toast Crunch. The whole part with the filling had me DYING.

[@erich33]

1000% need Josh judging with Ro again. They both have immense technical knowledge, but the way Josh encourages the bad ideas is gold.

[@silja6838]

He clearly needs to be Ned’s cooking mentor 😂 both of them love bad ideas!

[@erich33]

@@silja6838 The way he lit up when Eugene said "Blood" was great. If anyone knows how to cook with blood, it's Josh lol

[@viacoffey6580]

yessss. i especially love that josh matches the “aggressive” energy of the boys when they lose

[@SaintShion]

Josh does some crazy stuff on his YT Good Mythical Kitchen

[@eleanorcooke7136]

​@@silja6838 ouch

[@decrane100]

Eugene: "Does it have to be rolled?" Crew: "It's cinnamon 'rolls' " Eugene: "Ugh"

[@lillibriggs]

Meanwhile Keith doesn’t roll his cinnamon roll 😂

[@mildetryth]

I can't explain it, but Zach yelling "it's my kitchen" while Josh is yelling "I do what I want" is on the same level of mindblowingly funny to me as Keith hissing "You will never meet my father" at the judges in an earlier episode.

[@yoMC18]

It was heckin funny to see Josh standing up yet laughing

[@leinaamatsuji-berry561]

Josh is bringing, perhaps uncannily matching, the absolute CHAOS with his comments - Starbucks? Pig’s blood? This guy’s baseline of normal is so fun to have with the traditional bakers, bless Mythical Kitchen 👏

[@maplelump]

His reaction to TikToks made me realize how much I judge food I don't understand. I respect his adventurousness.

[@Nightbird8272]

He’s such a great judge for this show. I hope they bring him back again.

[@trycethomas939]

Honestly Eugene was so lucky he did the pigs blood when Josh was a judge.

[@hannahg5479]

Ok, I got a bone to pick with this episode-- they were given half an hour to bake AND plate their rolls, but cinnamon rolls usually take an hour to 1.5 hours to bake? That's not really their fault. Who decided to give them such an impractical amount of time for the one thing that is essentially out of their hands?

[@Amy-mo5xb]

Thats exactly what I'm saying, you can't possibly cook AND ice and plate it all in 30 mins. Of course they were all uncooked

[@luckbear87]

The crew did them so dirty with the timing restraints

[@bugiblvrd7164]

yes!! and i believe that oven was not doing its job, so even if they crank it up the highest it will still turn out raw

[@user-nv5tm9xs8f]

Tbf, I think the judges knew that that's why in the final judging they kind of ruled out the baking issues as the Leftmost judge said. 46:56

[@dededeedles]

Yeah, they literally went, "Gotta get this in the oven, I only have 30 minutes!" Then the expert said it takes at least 45 minutes. I'm like, "Huh? How's that fair?"

[@bethanyg95]

Ned is very right! It’s not a mistake, it’s a choice. Don’t convince Ariel you ‘accidentally’ stuck it in another woman

[@katelyndwyer1692]

I was waiting for this comment lmao

[@CoRLex-jh5vx]

He just ACCIDENTALLY slept with someone else for nine months straight

[@cheyenne9846]

@@CoRLex-jh5vx Nine months?!

[@CoRLex-jh5vx]

@@cheyenne9846 they got together in December, and got found out at the beginning of September. That's nine months

[@cheyenne9846]

@@CoRLex-jh5vx Jesus. What a long time to lie to someone you're supposed to be committed to

[@MNandi]

“It’s not a mistake it’s a choice” that didn’t age well

[@sutton.s]

that’s what i was thinking lmao

[@luminous_geek7651]

🤣🤣🥴😬 I just didn't wanna be the 1st to say it 🤣

[@andreas_iced8297]

📸

[@KelseyDrummer]

Yeah...

[@tasiazigler1092]

Thank the Gods someone else said it lmao

[@lilagonzales1145]

I died laughing at how Josh’s eyes lit like a Christmas tree at the idea of Pig blood in the cinnamon roll and frosting. Eugene was aiming for Chaos and chaos prevailed

[@donnavalentine6515]

He is a DELIGHT as a judge. I hope they ask him back a lot!

[@nicolefrey4322]

@@donnavalentine6515 He was so hype, I enjoyed his energy!

[@deprofundis3293]

Being from the GMM kitchen, seeing pigs blood was like reuniting with an old friend. 😂

[@melaniemagolan2241]

@@deprofundis3293 I was about to say the same thing! Considering the things Mythical Chef Josh has made, yeah, Eugene’s offering was right up his alley!

[@libipash3798]

"All you need is butter sugar and cinnamon" The try guy: "Cream cheese" "Corn starch!" "BLOOD! "

[@RenaRain]

This comment needs to be a meme, like, yesterday.

[@srushtipawar5488]

Onion

[@nelagomzam4693]

I have a question... Eugene use real blood??? It was real blood???

[@annaluciaschmitz]

@@nelagomzam4693 Yeah pork blood.🌚😂🖤

[@FirebaII0]

@@nelagomzam4693 yeah pork blood same stuff they use in blood pudding and many other bloody deserts

[@serianc9036]

The moment when Eugene is being evil and Ro delightedly squeals “me too” and flaps her hands is comedy gold.

[@Kwisten050]

I like when Keith and Eugene are paired up. The banter is hilarious.

[@sethwohlers5012]

Zac is great but Keith and Eugene have always carried this

[@hannahandersen6869]

I love the different dynamics between the try guys! Keith and Zac are wholesome, Zac and Eugene are like a married couple arguing, and Keith and Eugene have the best witty banter 😂

[@flyingsushiball]

Josh needs to be a permanent judge on this. He balances Ro's vibes perfectly and has the perfect chaotic-will-try-anything energy for this!

[@melsthemagnificent8179]

He is the chef for Good Mythical Morning. He is the master of zany dishes and perfect for this.

[@hilzbilz09]

Possibly one of my favorite YT crossovers

[@41tinman41]

If anything, we need a second part to these episodes where Josh helps them make the ideas actually work. Especially the Sin & Run Rolls Evil Eugene made.

[@coopercalled]

Yes and his knowledge of different foods adds a really interesting dimension to the show!

[@incasewediemylove]

Yes! He's the best!

[@kat_the_ot]

Eugene, tell me you just got back from the Met Gala without telling me you just got back from the Met Gala.

[@juliaaz711]

or he just got back from a makeup test run for the met gala

[@Harri_Jay_Kay]

@@juliaaz711 He has the same nails he had for the met gala as well.

[@breathebeloved]

Watch his documentary on the met gala experience, and you'll see the story of how he got off the plane, still jetlagged and sleep-deprived, returning from the gala, and went directly into filming this shoot.

[@alexstarker9435]

They also show it on their second channel, second try

[@Sarah-zb2hv]

@@alexstarker9435 wait I've watched them for YEARS and never knew they had a second channel! Thank-You!!

[@jacquelinesanabria755]

It is SO SAD that they didn’t have enough time to adequately bake their cinnamon rolls. They were all raw 😭

[@Truecrimeresearcher224]

They wasted time. They had 2 days and 4 hours they wasted time

[@lovetoes7722]

​@@Truecrimeresearcher224cut them slack man they were doing 4 episodes and they didn't know geez

[@FabricatedPheonix]

​@@Truecrimeresearcher224Yet they were only given 30 minutes to actually bake them. The bakery owner even said you needed 45-60 minutes. They were not given enough time on the last segment

[@SilentMartyrPhotogCo]

Ned's, "What should I do to mess this up"... just kind of hits different now, you know?

[@Char.yeet1]

It definitely seemed unfair that the format of the game didn't give them enough time for their rolls to cook properly. Huge oversight especially when they had a professional tell them(the team) how long it should be baked.

[@roborat]

Yup

[@racheledwards3813]

Came here for this comment, now I can enjoy the rest of my day in peace. Thank you 😌

[@thethmooteresa]

Yu

[@YourCreativeDreamer]

It honestly makes me so angry lol

[@praalgraf]

yeah definitely

[@gwynnethkobold7234]

Every time the judges introduce themselves they all have high expectations but rosanna. She’s like “you haven’t experienced this… i just hope its baked”

[@mariannamckenzie7854]

She sets her expectations LOW from the beginning. Then, she gets excited when their food is edible

[@nemashan3701]

Rosanna before seein the food: "please be edible PLEASE be edible"

[@andreas_iced8297]

Ro is an OG, she’s seen too much

[@Nikki-tx6kh]

Rosanna is me with the Big 5 at Eurovision- I don't expect them to do a masterpiece, I just want it to be fully cooked. Except Italy, but I trust Italy, they basically the Eugene of the Big 5, they can do whatever they want and they'll pull off.

[@oliviabrock7128]

All of what comes out of Neds's mouth has 100% backfired on him.

[@kwingle]

It’s not a mistake, it’s a choice 😀

[@Utinnibikini]

Watching these back makes me kind of glad he isn’t part of these episodes he’s so damn boring , the others are having fun and doing crazy stuff and he’s just basic white B**** aura the entire time 😂

[@nnbk_fornow]

Rosanna is like their indulging mom who tries her hardest to love them as gentle yet firmly as she could.

[@judyl.7811]

she reminds me of welsey mom in harry potter!

[@angelikarts6668]

If everyone's isn't cooked I think its more likely they weren't given enough time. Ned literally put them in straight away and still not cooked in time

[@paytonbergman5918]

in a cutaway to the experts he said to bake for 45-50 minutes and Ned made a commitment about having only 30 minutes

[@avathecreator]

Payton Bergman I think that the experts cooked theirs for that long since they were HUGE. Usually you’d bake cinnamon rolls for 20-25 minutes😭 I’m still not sure why they all had baking issues-

[@inspiritedchristian]

Though with the extra baklava layers in between, hard to say if it would’ve cooked properly in 45 minutes anyways.

[@bryngeiger7695]

Yeah when they said they had 30 minutes when the expert said he took 45 to cook his, I was concerned

[@ItsLexy]

Yeah when it's an issue for ALL the guys it's definitely a sign there wasn't enough time for ANY of them. It's like if a whole class fails a test, that means the teacher didn't do their job right.

[@Magenta4ever]

Josh is exactly the judge that this competition needs! He's open to their weird ideas, but still understands the process and requirements. Plus he's just as insane as the Try Guys. Please bring him back!

[@EmilyMusic3v3]

YES!!!

[@matthewjzack.9447]

he honestly needs to be a staple along with Rosanna

[@jianlisa4885]

Totally agree!! Please bring him back!!

[@trishmaloney5674]

And he’s easy on the eyes 😏

[@tatianabowman]

Definitely!!

[@BlackMasterDryne]

Eugene: tries to shock and disgust with pigs blood cinnamon rolls Also eugene: basically accidentally makes a classic cinnamon roll only red

[@nasus_zepol9047]

Lol all the cinnamon rolls where raw because they were only given 30 minutes to cook when the pros said you need at least 50 minutes to bake 😂

[@katrinarosival9815]

That’s always annoyed me!

[@Scintillate9]

I was hoping someone else noticed!!

[@corneliastreet2491]

Also I am just realizing the point of the pigs blood being safe is it was supposed to cook out, so for “drama” they really risked giving dangerous unheated pigs blood dough to the judges…

[@phoenixrising7777]

@@corneliastreet2491 the pigs blood was cooked out before it was even added to the cinnamon roll……so the rolls being raw has nothing to do with that. It was safe.

[@Mmorguemusic]

Right not fair at all 😂

[@Ohhelmno]

Listen, adding Josh to this was a stroke of absolute fucking brilliance. Having him sit next to Rosanna Pansino kind of took it to another level. They should be your default panel from here on out.

[@fourscorekd8834]

Yes.

[@magpie871]

Yes please!!

[@themoviedealers]

YEEAHHHHHHH

[@aduckwithayoutubechannel]

WE NEED MORE JOSH!

[@PazurLikeALazer]

I AGREE STRONGLY

[@ayumi3004]

The funniest thing is that no matter what Eugene does wrong, his recipe is always the tastiest omggg

[@thc1597]

i love the way the other try guys looked at each other when john and ro said it tasted good

[@raerohan4241]

There are a couple of times where it messes him up. But yeah, in general he ends up doing well even with the hijinks

[@pingkeuchan5114]

This did not age well haha

[@pavlinafricova2038]

@@pingkeuchan5114 exactly lol

[@Whatadreamfr]

@@pingkeuchan5114 OHhhh what happened?

[@cooperjordan9268]

To whoever edits these: The cuts, the sound design, the backing tracks, y'all do so much to elevate the humor of the show and y'all are underrated. God, really listening to the backing tracks in particular, they're just.. prefect? Anyway, also to whomever choses the Generic Animal Cuts animal of the week? You're doing gods work and I love you.

[@jocelynnguyen2812]

Omg the naked disappointment on Eugene’s face when he realized his cinnamon roll actually tasted like a cinnamon roll and not blood 😂

[@mosskii6832]

Everyone's talking about Josh's reaction to the pig blood but the 'starbucks creative' comment was BRUTAL. Please bring him back for more WAR his energy is amazing

[@lanagaga7504]

yes

[@TheCraftofPetra]

Agree!!! He should be a regular judge!

[@elleeeish407]

I love Ro. This isn't her first rodeo. She's just looking for cooked food.

[@princessfaith925]

and poor thing, she didn't even get that

[@Artnotforthesakeofart]

@@princessfaith925 XD

[@mary-ct3wr]

Her face when Keith tries to explain what he did should always be the thumbnail, hilarious

[@katchatty26]

SO TRUE LOL

[@maggie1000]

Zach: Tries to make just a simple cinnamon roll - completely misses Eugene: Doesn't try to make a cinnamon roll and just wants a bloody mess - makes the best cinnamon roll So the key for Eugene is just to try and do the opposite of what they're supposed to be trying to make

[@theblackcatwarrior]

"It's not a mistake, it's a choice, it's not a mistake, it's a choice" that was such a great idea to say multiple times Ned

[@Truecrimeresearcher224]

If only he knew what was coming

[@sloanesnow9791]

Josh is probably the perfect judge for this series because he's so fearless with food like he'll put anything in his mouth.

[@whitney32592]

Yes! I hope they bring him back.

[@TheCraftofPetra]

Totally!!!

[@cadavher]

I was so excited to see him!

[@elizacarrie7433]

I started crying laughing when Keith said “I know you’ve been wondering WHERE’S THE ONION?” And Josh said back “I have been, thank you Keith.” And then when Eugene said pigs blood Josh went on a genuine positive rant about the positives culinary possibilities of pigs blood in cinnamon rolls

[@raissasantosa]

AND HE WAS SUPER APPRECIATIVE

[@nelspd]

"Needs to be cooked for 45-50 minutes" *Gets 30 minutes with an oven that didn't work well*

[@jazlynwilson5420]

fr its not fair and the judges complain about it being raw broooo

[@Willgtl]

@@jazlynwilson5420, to be fair the judges did not put any weight on them being underdone in the rankings. Now if they did weigh doneness, then that'd be bullshit.

[@bixiebee6165]

his cinnamon rolls were massive tho. small/medium cinnamon rolls dont take that long to bake, 15-20 minutes is how ive always done them and they come out fully baked. the issue is thered be no time to ice/decorate (bc theyd be warm) so yeah theres time issues but not around baking time

[@bixiebee6165]

his cinnamon rolls were massive tho. small/medium cinnamon rolls dont take that long to bake, 15-20 minutes is how ive always done them and they come out fully baked. the issue is thered be no time to ice/decorate (bc theyd be warm) so yeah theres time issues but not around baking time

[@DUSKvsDAWN]

Yeah that kinda pissed me off.

[@itsanniesdi]

Seeing Ned promote his date night cookbook with his wife, now that we know what we know 🤬🤬

[@hew2356]

I know, he smarminess is sickening.....

[@TKZells16]

Wasn’t even that good of a cookbook to begin with

[@moonjunhui13]

I like how every time they are putting something in their filling, they replay the "butter, cinnamon, and sugar" part of what he says 😂

[@evelynneufeld7610]

Mum used brown sugar in the filling❤️

[@pearlofori-som819]

Josh's face of pure bliss as Eugene is describing his cinnamon rolls as everyone is in utter shock is the most Josh thing ever

[@emberurbach1819]

Rhett and Link are like jfc now we have to have baked blood food tests.

[@maggiekelley3426]

blood food is usually a punishment in his line of work 😂

[@isismg4119]

I was hungry before watching this… I’m not anymore, my stomach is as shocked as I am 😂

[@donnavalentine6515]

The Joshiest Josh to ever Josh. 😆 it was such fun to watch!

[@deprofundis3293]

Being from the GMM kitchen, seeing pigs blood was like reuniting with an old friend. 😂

[@IfISmileWillYouPee]

they definitely needed to be given more time to cook their rolls. sucked that no one had enough time to present cooked food

[@bethanyd4257]

There’s no more forgiveness like in season one 😂 but the chef did say 45-50 minutes and the guys got 30 minutes which does seem a little questionable 🤨

[@MarieForest]

I think they should give them a soft warning about how long things take to bake 😅 just so they have half a shot of having them cooked through, the guys always assume things take a half hour and that’s rarely the case

[@GadereneLegion]

@Bethany D The baker’s rolls are huge, so maybe they were going more by how long it would take to bake a regular sized roll. I agree with you though.

[@zombiesinflannels]

Also the fact that the main oven wasn't functioning correctly so they all had to take their stuff out 10-15 min in to transfer it to the other one, which effs up the baking process... I'm surprised that there was zero leeway considering that the oven was the main problem re: the raw dough, because that was a factor that wasn't in any of the Guys' actual control.

[@smilesfordays]

@@MarieForest baking is such a huge science project every time… I have a sneaking suspicion they do this on purpose to have them fail…

[@RavenG77]

I love how blunt Josh is to Ned. That makes me happy.

[@avaheld7055]

“It’s a worse version of a blooming onion and a worse version of the cinnamon roll” two minutes later “I had no problem with it, Keith, they bullied me into it”

[@kilarthmac]

The fact that Eugene literally filmed this after coming back from his stressful fashion show experience is so crazy to me

[@mindlostguy]

But the energy is so there too tho lol

[@mind_palace]

But this might be his form of therapy as well. Taking out all the stress giving 0 f's😅😅

[@chachi0614]

Judges all terrified of Eugene’s rolls Rosanna: “CREATIVITY IS GREAT 💅🏽🥰🤩🌸🍰”

[@silentstatic564]

This is really late, but I highly doubt Josh was terrified. The man loves pigs blood.

[@mau6068]

She knows not to expect anything normal 💀

[@Chronically_Bored]

She's been here for so long she's learnt to take eugene's eugene-ness(?) In stride

[@pretendperfection]

16:12 Ned saying “it’s not a mistake, it’s a choice”. Someone should remind him of that nowadays

[@kaishefferly5965]

12:58 Ned: Are you feeling the urge to fuck it up? Me: I don't know, are you?

[@ASMRShanny]

The fact Zach said “I’m so good at this” then the whisk immediately broke has me dying 🤣 9:24

[@ForNeverYoursAlways]

Same!! I've been there 🤣 Dough Tip: use the stick end of a wooden spoon to mix your dough if you don't have a mixer with a dough hook

[@hiilikekoala1894]

Gone a little bit too good at it

[@vera6337]

The whisk was a paid actor

[@niceuser1237]

This happens if you either celebrate too early or you spoke too soon 😂

[@lavendert2905]

@@scarredshortstv7954 wtf that is horrible

[@ry.the.stunner]

Imagine that. Keith spents years trying to win on his cinnamon-raisin "Daddy's Favorite" and ended up losing the Cinnamon Roll battle because he didn't use cinnamon.

[@SD-ft5xj]

Now that you said it, this is so funny to me.

[@plw8414]

The irony!!! Lol

[@neversaygoodbye4]

Right?!

[@dreamchasingcat]

I can’t wrap my head on his decision not to at least sprinkle some cinnamon on the blooming onion bun! It wouldn’t change the savory taste he wanted, and it would’ve given it a pass as technically a cinnamon roll! Gah, “the irony” indeed…

[@345xz]

anyone else back after hearing that ned cheated on ariel and you’re sitting here watching everything he does just to say “ yeah something a cheater would do”

[@Manu-dp4ls]

Im glad i finally have a good reason to dislike him. Cuz i was always way more fond of the other guys than him.

[@taralovesdarcy5085]

The whole time in my mind I’m like “shut up ned”

[@nymling24]

Ned @ 16:12 “It’s not a mistake, it’s a choice. It’s not a mistake, it’s a choice.”

[@eleanorcooke7136]

​@Mackenzie Houston also, he was never as funny because he was piggybacking off the other guys' jokes. Like "mommy's favourite" and "making money moves"

[@Sometimes_I_Want_Violence]

I freaking love Eugene, the fact that he just wanted to create something horrifying and won accidentally 💀💀

[@darianstenson3374]

Josh is literally the only person that would fully appreciate Eugene’s blood rolls and I am so happy he is judging them

[@celaya-s4e151]

I was thinking the same thing lmao! Love him

[@southafricanaustralianzedo2772]

vampire? lol

[@burritosandboobs]

Mythical kitchen would absolutely come up with something like this lmao

[@LennoxMatt1]

Let's face it, Josh has the perfect energy to judge this, because no matter how out there they go, he's going to be onboard

[@NekomikoLove]

Chaotic neutral

[@isabellamet7157]

His sometimes chaotic creations at GMM has prepared him for this. Love Josh!

[@isabellamet7157]

*have

[@suzylu333]

the king of creativity tbh

[@chicgeek2008]

Official petition for Josh to join Ro as a permanent judge!

[@stardust_and_stories2424]

eugene's cinammon roll : looks like it can kill you but is actually a cinnamon roll

[@nathanwilkins6107]

Josh is a perfect guest judge for this because he’s a bit of a gremlin in the kitchen himself

[@disnothic8098]

TBH, Josh should be a permanent judge on this show. His experience with wildly creative and questionable meals on Mythical Kitchen makes him uniquely qualified.

[@iandowall153]

God I love Josh, he's such a polite shit talker.

[@cassieosaurus_9217]

I agree!

[@hannahweddel9895]

Agreed!!

[@sarahwatson3192]

And like hed be the only one to be willing every time to take a bite. The man knows what the cooked genitals of way too many animals tastes like and has eaten raw cows tongue with Abe Lincoln on camera… they just need him to be there to say that honestly he’s had worse.

[@alytemple2168]

I was so excited to see him on here!

[@mollyhofer8241]

Them talking about Ned’s being “a skin graft” and “unsettling” when they hadn’t seen Eugene’s yet…😳

[@NSAB120]

I know I was like just. You. Wait.

[@Picachki]

I love how Eugene tries so hard to fail but still ends up winning! 😂

[@ToAckerman]

Date night cookbook perfect for those date nights with your affair

[@yamisice]

God I’m cackling😂

[@phoenixrising7777]

There are chapters called disappointment and commitment 👀

[@melsthemagnificent8179]

Barnes and noble put a sticker over his face and marked it down 90 percent

[@jacqueline8121]

One of these days I want Ro to just go "No. You know what, nobody wins. Nobody gave me a cooked product and I'm tired"

[@gayvagina7353]

They didn’t have any time to cook, you want cooked products give them more time.

[@jessa4282]

As a former Starbucks barista, Josh really nailed calling it “Starbucks creative”. My jaw dropped because he gets it😂😂

[@maddieclarke258]

Just an absolutely FOUL insult I love it 😂

[@roninsteel]

Firing Ned is probably going to make them so much money. So many people are watching old videos to figure out what's the deal.

[@cheyenne9846]

Yeah, I'm currently binge-watching all of the "without a recipe" videos 😂

[@saharaliake8970]

I'm getting recommended all their videos because of the traffic but I'm not complaining lol

[@mayo597]

i'm pretty sure they even reached 8m subs after that incident ☠️

[@Kakashi-san]

@@cheyenne9846 Same

[@arqwii_4461]

@@cheyenne9846 SAME!

[@isysnelms3179]

Zach: "I just copy Ned" Ned: *cheats on his wife* Maggie: 👁👄👁 Zach: "I take it back"

[@emmab3275]

Expert: "I cook it about 45-50 minutes" Ned: "We only have 30 minutes!" Uhhhh I think I know why they were all raw

[@rebeccalaine7980]

10/10 agree! I wish cooking time wasn't incorporated into the challenge time. Give the judges something they can safely consume 🙏

[@vs1954]

right? I think that's kind of unfair if that's all they were given

[@katrose5179]

Doubtful. Compare the size difference in the rolls. Normal ones take maybe 25 minutes. They just didn’t make cinnamon rolls.

[@ChocoQueen24]

The professionals' rolls bake for 45-50 minutes because their rolls are literally the size of goddamn basketballs bro. Normal/smaller sized ones should not take that long.

[@randomtology]

They were talking about massive sized ones. Normal sized cinnamon rolls take about 20-25 minutes to bake. So they were given enough time. The problem is they went for the blaster oven that cooks at a higher temperature so it cooks the OUTSIDE quicker-- but not the inside.

[@MizuHime07]

I’m down for Josh being another permanent judge! He’s just as chaotic as the contestants

[@TheCraftofPetra]

Yaaaas!!!

[@oiiwweew]

agreed!! I was looking for someone to say that

[@magnusbane420]

I absolutly didn't expect him to scream back at Zach lol

[@therranolleo468]

I'd love to have him as a permanent judge, he shares the chaotic energy perfectly and he's probably the only one who could react positively to something as crazy as pig blood cinnamon rolls due to his own crazy cooking show

[@paigelouise8198]

i'm a bit surprised at how many people like him! i thought he was really annoying hahahaha

[@laurelelizabeth4965]

Zach is the Alex Russo of this series. Slowly learning from his mistakes in order to beat them all someday in one final competition

[@mollyrae0918]

i love this comment

[@theulitmatepieceofgarbage2335]

Let’s hope all his character development doesn’t get completely ruined after in some horrible extra film

[@hireath3842]

I WANT JOSH TO COME BACK SO BADLY, literally he’s so entertaining and collage well with Keith, Eugene, and Zack!

[@Ilikefrogs..]

Keith: "I'm sure you're wondering, where's the ONION??" Rosanna: *stares at the camera like Jim Halpert*

[@katie8429]

28:38 I’m dead

[@elizacarrie7433]

@@katie8429 makes me wheeze laughing every time. This whole episode makes me cry laughing so hard every time

[@danico3070]

that was nothing like Jim Halpert

[@eleanorcooke7136]

I loved the epic music when they brought Keith "cinnamon roll" out.

[@BAMJo11]

Then again when he says onions cut in half remind him of cinnamon rolls (literally 3 seconds later) lmao

[@marianoche2718]

“Can you taste the… blood?” “It tastes like a cinnamon roll, yeah.” “Are you… horrified at least? A little bit?” “I was at first, but now less.” Well, if that’s not Eugene’s entire character arch since the moment he became a Try Guy 😂 Wow. Scary. Intense. Shocking. BUT ACTUALLY THE MOST PRECIOUS CINNAMON ROLL

[@heyifeoma]

This is such a sweet comment

[@alexanderbrambila8274]

He tries so hard, a very precious cinnamon roll indeed

[@buttercroissant1359]

You're like describing a scorpio

[@redacted4273]

I love how Josh ALWAYS matches energies, and he’s really used to Rhett and Links tantrums so Zach’s was nothing compared to what he deals with everyday 😂 45:11

[@AlexxeMJFAN]

And that's why Rhett and Link are my favorite duo ❤😂

[@MasochisticMaiden]

Rewatching all of the Without a Recipe for the holidays, still bothers me that they’re like “undercooked” when they only gave them a 30 minute bake time for something that needs 45-50 minutes to bake. Unless your baking includes store bought dough after proving you need more than 30 minutes. Also as a mythical beast, we need more Josh on this segment.

[@MCRsHelena]

Can we keep Josh as a judge?! He's funny and understands food! Plus it seem like him and Ro get along well!

[@celaya-s4e151]

Agreed!!

[@ydoowj]

Josh gets along with everyone and matches energy well.

[@unpeudevin3837]

He is annoying

[@hermitxd7369]

He's my favourite judge

[@Nsobloo]

YES LMAO but he’s so busy with GMM

[@wateryourcermet]

Ned’s deep sigh, followed by “what should I do to mess this up?” 😂😂😂😂

[@melsthemagnificent8179]

Just like his marriage...

[@Truecrimeresearcher224]

Like his life

[@kidgirl7]

Ned: "It's not a mistake, it's a choice" 😶

[@duolingobird1234]

Just like him cheating🤭

[@JN-be3sz]

A quote that age very righteous and badly 😂

[@TheOmNomGirl]

Obsessed with Eugene’s reveal. You can see how all the judges were laughing like “haha he’s so dramatic, this’ll be fun” and then as soon as he lowers it onto the table just stunned silence. Their jaws dropped, the professional bakers were straight up horrified, none of them could say anything as they tried to comprehend what was in front of them. It was exactly what Eugene was going for and I am so excited for the rest of the season

[@emiemiemi4769]

this gave me chills

[@mlmg5787]

bit dramatic don’t you think?💀

[@amandalupacchino6728]

Me: Let me guess, Eugene is holding a pitcher of red wine. That’s gonna be interesting… Eugene: “I am using blood…” 😳

[@vickyvic8619]

He now has to make the Trunchbull's cake.

[@jmsantos1317]

i thought it was wine too🤣

[@courtz4051]

My dumbass thought it was some kind of soy sauce 🙈 don't judge me

[@ReptilianTeaDrinker]

Eugene, always the villain in these challenges. Love that for him. lol

[@bluehoodiehog8624]

16:12 Ned saying “It’s not a mistake, it’s a choice” is very ironic

[@rc8613]

Rosanna’s hesitation in telling Keith he got 3rd place is so reminiscent of when he COMPLETELY lost it in the cake episode

[@carlaviz6605]

When the judges are listing all of the things they want from a cinnamon roll and Rosanna just wants it to be cooked haha. She knows to keep her expectations low from this show!

[@artikagunathasan4040]

Her expectations were on the floor and yet the boys dug below ground level. Everyone presented undercooked rolls 😂

[@emilyodonnell4928]

Last time she just wants it to be edible

[@sknevel17]

I feel like the "underbaked" in all of them is unfair. They should have given them more cook time to make up for the fact that the oven didn't work and they couldn't cook them properly.

[@biancacolmenares620]

Yea I'm very confused on this oven that doesn't work or maybe can't handle two dishes at the same time. Seems really not fair.

[@SimplyTinielle]

I was looking for this comment. It had to be a production oversight for sure if ALL were underbaked, although they even waited til the very last second to take them out the oven.

[@TheCraftofPetra]

Yezzz! Agree on that!

[@Thiderem469]

Completely agree! I might have heard wrong, but I think they only got 30 minutes to bake and make the icings? And the guy with the actual recipe explaining how to make a cinnamon roll said they bake theirs for 45-50 minutes....

[@yoakefuyu]

Honestly the fact that cooking time is involved in the prep always seemed unfair to me given that this show’s selling point is creativity and experimentation

[@dreamyadrija4059]

I just love the fact that Zach and Josh were freaking fighting and yelling at each other but at the same time Keith was hugging Eugene and Ned for not coming at the 4th place. By the way I just love Eugene's creativity. ~xoxo💜

[@katmaggie]

4:37 "i'm not overthinking it, i'm just making things that make me happy" seems like a reaccuring theme for Ned 😶

[@jaxbrowns9585]

DAMN-

[@NSAB120]

Rachel: I make them on Christmas morning Zach: [shrugs in Jewish]

[@evabailey3860]

Meanwhile Eugene uses PIGS BLOOD 😂💀

[@aki_4191]

The fact that they have 30 mins to bake and then immediately after he said you need 45-50 mins is definitely gonna left us with raw dough

[@valorielafaele8568]

100% and weren’t they having like, oven problems?

[@fionamckenzie9271]

tbf his were way bigger than theirs, he also said his had 14 eggs and ofc they weren't using that many

[@thecomorbiditycurator8018]

His recipe was much larger and the volume of ingredients and size of the cinnamon rolls was far more than what the guys were making. the bigger a recipe, the longer it bakes. when I make cinnamon rolls at home, it takes them about 15 to 20 minutes to bake all the way through. what screwed them over was their inconsistent dough from poor activation and proofing, too thick pieces (eugene's hands and keith's bowls in bowls in bowls), and the presence of texture-altering ingredients (pig's blood, filo dough, acidity from so many onions, etc.).

[@TheDarkAngelxoxo]

I agree. They should have had an hour

[@shawnabasallo7515]

I just commented the same thing! Couldn’t agree more

[@CairineTheElfHearted]

I conceptually love the idea of a sweet onion roll. You could have it with eggs for a nice savory breakfast.

[@evelynneufeld7610]

Bacon please!

[@PixelPower0615]

But the execution...

[@TheGoosebumpsGirl]

Josh is the perfect judge for these videos. Most judges are like “what you used blood in your dish???” And Josh is here for it from the start, not a doubt in his mind. Allows the guys to steer more chaotic in their cooking and not worry that it’ll be an issue, because Josh won’t dock point for it being weird