Tudor Black Bay 54 First impressions review

Hi, this is my first impressions of the brand new Black Bay 54 37mm from Tudor. Could this be the perfect fit for me and my wrist? I think it's probably as close to perfect as it will ever get? Thanks for watching. You can find me on Facebook and instagram. Here are the links...
/ alan.williams.50309
/ time_time_again
Ps if any of my subscribers would like to send me a watch to review (preferably one that would be suitable for my 6.25') please get in touch on the socials :)

[@johnnyguitar6697]

Looks great on your wrist. Tried it on my 7in. wrist the other day, and it fit like a dream. More so than I thought when just reading about the proportions. It feels more like a 38mm-38.5mm.

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yeah I’d agree it wears slightly larger! 👍

[@serifdincer208]

Stunning watch

[@thebadguy4206]

Incredible watch, I hope to own one too!

[@johnhealey6455]

Great review. I love the 1950’s styling. This may be my one-watch collection.

[@Time_and_time_again]

Thank you 🙏👍

[@rabtrekker]

Fits like a dream, well made, versatile, suitable for a lifetime of adventures. That's why i bought one too, suits my 6.5" wrist also 😊

[@Time_and_time_again]

Congrats mate 🙏👍

[@cheesychester9647]

Love it! Mine arrives in 2 days, it will be my first nice watch!

[@Time_and_time_again]

🙏👍

[@austinzizzi1142]

I don’t see how it gets better than this for a vintage inspired diver as well. I would have made the dial matte but that’s just me. It’s my one watch and we’ll see if it sticks but I don’t see myself giving it up

[@RabbitWatchShop]

My next watch : ) Thx for the review.

[@Time_and_time_again]

Good choice! Thanks 👍

[@puttenicole]

It's a beautiful watch. A bit unsure if it will fit my 7.5 inch wrist. But its a candidate for my first expensive watch.

[@johnnyguitar6697]

It wore well on my 7in. wrist when I tried it, but you have to try it for yourself. At 7.5in., you might be more at home with the BB58.

[@Stevencroasdale]

Beautiful watch and suits your wrist down to the ground. (I have the same sized wrist). I’ll have to go and try one on. Very tempted!

[@Time_and_time_again]

Thank you and yes I’d still highly recommend this watch and definitely go and try one on if you can… you won’t be disappointed! 🙏👍

[@lukejwoolley]

I absolutely love this watch. I’m 28 this year and said I’ll get this watch for my 30th birthday… Let’s see if I can wait until then 😂

[@Time_and_time_again]

If you can wait it’ll be all the more satisfying when it comes for your birthday! 🙏👍

[@ItsPitterPatter]

That is a perfect fit!

[@goldfools5445]

So if you liked the Pelagos. I see Watchdives is now selling a 39 mm with a similar style. Looks awesome, has some SanMartin tweaks, which really work.

[@Time_and_time_again]

Thank you I will check that out! 🙏👍

[@LAVA1980]

Excellent review.... I whole heartedly recommend the BB58 half link from Uncle Seiko

[@Time_and_time_again]

Thank you I will get one ordered! 🙏👍

[@austinzizzi1142]

No this is the one for sure. The pelagos 39 needed a matte dial that’s what was missing for me, but I’m buying this 54 within the next couple days

[@Time_and_time_again]

I’d agree! 🙏👍

[@sharpe340-]

This is one of the few watches that I actually think would benefit from male end links. It does look superb either way though.

[@laszlokliegl3214]

Nice video, thank you.

[@Time_and_time_again]

Thank you mate 🙏👍

[@spencerwood3330]

Keen for one of these, wish I trusted eBay

[@Time_and_time_again]

The good thing with eBay on a watch over £1500 is it goes to eBay authentication centre before it comes to you. Even if you’re not completely happy with the watch you still have the right to return it. So as a buyer that’s great! I always just make sure the seller has a great feedback score too 👍

[@Treetopflyer777]

Great video. Just picked mine up. Having the same tightness/ looseness issue. Was the same on my BBGMT and pelagos. Uncle seiko is the best fix. Looks like I’m in for another uncle seiko 1/2 link. Question for you. When you push straight down on your bezel (pushing it into the case) does it appear to “float” or feel spring loaded? Mine does. Never had that on a watch before

[@Time_and_time_again]

Sorry for the delay (I’d taken a break) thanks for the comment. I no longer have it so can’t remember sorry 👍

[@margaretisolan9189]

Nice review. How do you like it compared to the CW Trident Pro 300 38mm?

[@Time_and_time_again]

Thanks! I like them both but if I had to choose it would be the 54! 👍 I’ll be doing a video shortly comparing the 2 👍

[@grahamcartwright5141]

Love this watch, I currently own the BB58 but tried this on at my local AD & it felt like a totally different watch. I guess the BB58 will have to go 😀

[@michaelriera6277]

I think the 54 looks very austere when compared to the 58. There is a warm charm to the 58 that has been lost with the removal of the gilt bezel and the color pop of the iconic Red Triangle. Also, the 54 is a direct replication, whereas, the 58 has a more original design that borrows cues from Rolex/Tudor of past.

[@johnnyguitar6697]

@@michaelriera6277 I'd agree that this is a pared down version of the BB58, but I actually welcome it. Not just because I love those old Rolex / Tudor references it is directly inspired by, but also because I thought Tudor had overdone it with the gilt accents on the black BB58, which I prefer in blue for that particular reason. It's really down to individual preferences between the BB58 and the BB54, and it's great to have the choice.

[@jeanlouisdubillon4212]

@@michaelriera6277 i think thé opsosite

[@luqman_4053]

​@@michaelriera6277I absolutely agree with you. The BB54 looks more refined without the red triangle, the golden indexes on the crown, and its more contained size. On the wrist, it is "sexy" unlike the BB58 I find. However, I hope that next year TUDOR will offer the same watch without its flaws. : a BB54 without the false rivets, with a transparent back to contemplate the movement. A movement that TUDOR will need to dress up a bit to make it more pleasing to the eye. And for it to be ALMOST perfect, a higher quality bracelet in L916 steel or failing that (because it's too expensive), a minimum class 2 titanium bracelet like the PELAGOS 39. I'm starting to save...

[@doml8959]

I picked one up last week and have the same issue with the fitment. Initially had 3 links removed but it was slightly too loose and the t-fit was pushed all the way in so couldn't get it any tighter. Removing 4 links it fits fine, but the t-fit is pushed all the way out so there's no room for adjustment when my wrist swells in the summer. Ordered an Uncle Seiko 1/2 link so hoping that will help, otherwise I may have to sell it. Shame Tudor couldn't fit a couple of more notches of adjustment in the clasp. Don't have this problem with my P39, 3 links removed and that put me right in the middle of the t-fit, giving me lots of room for adjustments.

[@ShamrockRagEll]

I'm in the same boat exactly. 3 out it's a little too loose, 4 out it's kind of tight when the T-Link is fully extended (no adjustment possibilities for the summer).

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yeah it’s a shame the t fit doesn’t give a few more adjustments! Please let me know how you find the half link when it arrives. I’m ordering one but I’m in the uk so may take a bit of time 😊👍

[@Time_and_time_again]

Looks like the uncle seiko half link is the way to go for us! 👍

[@ShamrockRagEll]

@@Time_and_time_again Funny, just put one link back in and now it fits perfectly for me. Probably because its got a few degrees warmer here since last time i tried this configuration. I’m good for summer, let’s see how it’s going to fit in autumn then 😆

[@doml8959]

@@Time_and_time_again Just received the half link. Definitely helped. With 4 full links removed and the 1/2 link added, I now wear the watch comfortably with the t-fit pushed all the way in bar one notch, so I can go a bit tighter if needed, but more importantly, I have lots of room to expand when the weather get hot.

[@anoldslowhorse]

Great video. How did you get on with the sizing of your BB54 bracelet? did you remove another link? is so how does it fit now. I have the same wrist size and going to get one, so I'm very interested! for the best fit for a 6.25" wrist how may links are required at the 12 and 6 o'clock sides position ? thanks in advance for your help

[@Time_and_time_again]

Sorry for the delay I’d taken a break! I got the uncle Seiko half link in the end and that fixed it perfectly 🙏👍

[@nothingbasic]

How do you feel about this vs the Pelagos 39 now that it’s been some time, I am leaning towards this exact piece over the 39 for the reasons you have mentioned

[@varbane]

Would like to know as well

[@Time_and_time_again]

Sorry for the delay (I’d taken a break) I still like both and can’t pick a winner although the 54 wears much better on my 6” wrist 🙏👍

[@thrifty85]

How does this compare size wise to the CW 38mm pro 300? Does it feel larger or smaller on wrist in comparison?

[@Time_and_time_again]

Sorry for the delay I’ve been on a break! I’d say the bb54 somehow wears a little larger 🙏👍

[@terryjordache6985]

Lovely! Did you sell the Pelagos 39 in the end?

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yea I did Terry. I’d have kept both if I money was no issue 😊👍

[@terryjordache6985]

@@Time_and_time_againSold my Pelagos 39 yesterday as it wasn’t getting any wrist time since I picked up the 54 and I’m kind of a one watch type of guy. I think the 54 is more versatile since it’s SS and can be dressed up or worn casual… hope I don’t regret it. But the 54 is a step monster, wearing it on a nato it’s super light and comfy and great for summer in London.

[@Ferien7]

I like the smaller size, but the color temperature mismatch between the cool toned bezel insert and the warm toned dial and markers bothers me. Guess I’m too ocd for this watch 🤷‍♂️

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yeah I can see why that might be bothersome for some 👍 I like to think of it as the bezel colours are matching the bracelet rather than the dial 😊👍

[@Lucmercurius]

This is my problem with this watch too. The color feels a bit off. Nevertheless, the watch still beautiful.

[@scollyutube]

Completely agree. White lume and dial paint to match. Be even more different from the BB58 then too.

[@continuum4]

This is aligned with the original, however

[@scollyutube]

@@continuum4 yes agree, so is the BB58 too. Imagine if these both had straight Black and white colour options too, wouldn't need a Pelagos 39 then.

[@happytravels2480]

A very important dimension that often gets overlooked, is dial diameter. That can make a huge difference in perception when it comes to size. Does anyone know what the actual dial diameter is? The traditional 40mm submariner is 29mm I believe. I find that to be perfect.

[@Time_and_time_again]

Very good point! I will have a measure today and let you know 👍

[@happytravels2480]

@@Time_and_time_again I just saw on another review that the crystal/dial is 28.7mm across.👍

[@Time_and_time_again]

@@happytravels2480 ahhh great thank you 👍

[@Noface.rari3]

Im tossed between saving for this 54 or the CW Trident pro 300 i mean w the same money Im looking to buy the c63 sealander and the c65 dune. Having worn both, which is your recommendation?

[@Time_and_time_again]

Sorry for the delay (I’ve been on a break) I enjoyed both watches but value for money you can’t go wrong with the CW! 🙏👍

[@nlaout]

Is it a new zenith pilot resting on the table? My next two targets :-)

[@Time_and_time_again]

It’s not unfortunately! It’s a sinn556a, great watch!

[@stephenso3]

Did you manage to get a better fit by removing another link? Is wrist 6.25 or 6 cm? I have a 6.25 so kinda wary that may have the same issue if I remove just 4 links.

[@Time_and_time_again]

I ended up getting the uncle seiko half link and now have the perfect fit! Mine is 6.25 like yours so I would highly recommend getting the half link 🙏👍

[@stephenso3]

@@Time_and_time_again thanks for the info. Sorry did you install it close to the clasp? Saw a video from UptickWatch and he did a similar thing.

[@Time_and_time_again]

@@stephenso3 yes I saw that too and copied 😊👍

[@jng9324]

Nice one, whats your wrist size?

[@Time_and_time_again]

16cm mate 👍

[@bd7944]

Nice watch. Wish they dropped the faux rivets and somehow made a ceramic matte bezel to avoid scratches and dents.

[@johnnyguitar6697]

An aluminum bezel will scratch / fade, but if you apply big enough a shock for it to bend, it is likely that a ceramic bezel would simply break. And they're more expensive to replace than an aluminum one.

[@Time_and_time_again]

I know there’s a few who think the same but I personally like it as it is I think. Ps sorry for the late reply I’ve been on a break 🙏👍

[@Dämonenjägerin]

this lady sure has one hell of a masculine hand

[@Time_and_time_again]

Have a great day 🙏👍

[@robbasilio7235]

If u had to choose one, Pelagos 39 or the 54?

[@Time_and_time_again]

Can’t separate them!

[@timeintheuk]

Would like to try one on however i dont think i would buy

[@Time_and_time_again]

Think you might want to when you try it! Sorry for the late reply I’ve been on a break. Maybe you own one now? 😊👍

[@gameonn3461]

The problem I have with this watch is, the dial feels just so small on the wrist. 37mm diameter is normally okay but since this is a diver watch and bezel is thick, the dial looks quity tiny and does not look well proportioned when you look yourself in the mirror. Despite the superior bracelet on bb54, I have picked 58 as it felt more comfortable with the size. Ofcourse this is me and you cannot go wrong with bb54 either

[@Time_and_time_again]

I understand what you mean 🙏👍

[@austinzizzi1142]

Put it on a tropic rubber strap instead so it looks period correct

[@Time_and_time_again]

I’ll certainly be trying it on a rubber strap yes! 👍

[@johnnyguitar6697]

That will be the first thing I do when I finally purchase this watch. Black tropic.

[@austinzizzi1142]

@@Time_and_time_again the integrated rubber Tudor sells it on is more of a 70s style and doesn’t really work with the 50s design imo

[@DC-si8xw]

I think the Black Bay 58 was a thick and flat case. that's probably why it felt big

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yes it was definitely thicker than the 54 😊👍

[@grneal26]

Do you still have the BB54?

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yes mate 👍

[@grneal26]

@@Time_and_time_again I am thinking about getting this as my one and done diver. Do you still love it or do you have mixed feelings?

[@Monkey-gt.official]

The watch is lovely and fits your wrist perfectly. But Tudor need to upgrade their bracelets. Them rivets need to go. For the money you’re paying it could be better. Is it a keeper?🤣

[@Time_and_time_again]

I think it is a keeper but I’m not going to commit just yet! Haha. The rivets honestly don’t bother me in the slightest and I think the price is excellent! I have put it on a waffle strap now and love it on that too 😊👍

[@DanonOP]

What’s your wrist size?

[@Time_and_time_again]

Sorry for the delay, 6.25” it was then 👍

[@jacobelx5841]

If I did not own a modern Rolex diver, I would’ve gotten either P39 or BB54. They are nearly flawless. Since I did, I had to go all the way to the other end of the spectrum, the gilt BB58.

[@tockingwatches2377]

Agreed. I’ve got to admit wondering if replacing my Sub with this and freeing up funds for something totally different…🤔

[@DomaDful]

Wrist size ?

[@Time_and_time_again]

The black bay 54 is 37mm 👍

[@DomaDful]

@@Time_and_time_again Yes, I mean your wrist size ?

[@Time_and_time_again]

@@DomaDful ahhh, I see, 6inch 👍

[@DomaDful]

@@Time_and_time_again Thank you.

[@chrislim7976]

Why does the wheel look unfinished.

[@Time_and_time_again]

The wheel? 🤔

[@chrislim7976]

@@Time_and_time_again Where the watch hands meet. centre of watch.

[@Time_and_time_again]

@@chrislim7976 ahhh I see, I’ve let the watch go now but never noticed that 👍

[@j.m.4444]

That's a cute little watch.

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yes indeed 🙏👍

[@michaelriera6277]

The BB54 has a better bracelet and possibly a more refined case, thank the BB58 but you are forgoing a lot. I feel 39 mm is the perfect size for a sport/dive watch. Also, at some point you may want some wrist presence in a watch and I love BB58’s gilt bezel numerals, red iconic triangle (red triangle and larger crown references the classic Rolex /Tudor Big Crown of the past) and the snowflake seconds. I even like the coin edge bezel matching the crown. Without these characteristics, the BB would be rather dull. The lugs on the BB54 are also proportionally bigger giving it a less elegant, squared look.

[@Time_and_time_again]

All valid points but unfortunately 39mm isn’t the perfect size for everyone! I really think that this 54 is perfect for smaller wrists and the 58 is perfect for regular sized wrists. Both are great choices and both have different design elements that folks will appreciate. The beauty of all of this is that there is choice I think 😊👍

[@Mega-zi7ys]

Rolex lookalike

[@AR-ok4gg]

Most luxury brands are trying that already. At least Tudor is a sister company and created by the same guy. This watch is more than that…

[@Time_and_time_again]

Yes indeed 👍

[@picanha694]

Well its owned by rolex 😂