TURNING POINT: 1929 Palestinian riots

In 1929, disputes between Jews and Palestinians over access to the Western Wall in Jerusalem escalated into violence and the Palestinian riots, or al-Buraq uprising, began.
For Palestinians, 1929 was one of the first significant actions against the expanding Zionist movement. For Jews, the Hebron massacre, where 68 Jews were killed by rioters, was one of the bloodiest attacks they suffered under British Mandatory Palestine.
During this time, a total of 133 Jews and 116 Palestinians were killed, marking a decisive moment in the history of Israel-Palestine.
In this episode of MEE’s history explainer series Turning Point, we take a look at the context in which the riots took place and how the events of 1929 not only strengthened the Zionist movement but shaped the warfare ethos of the future State of Israel, paving the way for the calamitous events of the 1948 Nakba - the “Catastrophe”.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEastEye_TG
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye

[@pathikritchoudhury6611]

During that time there were no Jews & Palestinians. There were Jews & Arabs. The Jews living there were also called Palestinians

[@projectp1821]

So why did “Israel” insist on it creation … this politically movement new it was outnumbered 2 to 1 they would never win control off a equal representative government!! Something else had to be done !!!

[@TheImmoralNosferatuZodd]

Yes, but since then Arabs living in Palestine have inbred themselves into a new ethnicity known as 'Palestinians'. 🤣

[@Ogni374]

You contradicted yourself and still 39 people agreed with what you said, I agree with your second sentence

[@pathikritchoudhury6611]

@@Ogni374 If we think of that time period then all Israelis today are Palestinians. Then do Palestinian activists want to free Palestine from Palestinians?? Israel is just the Hebrew name of that land. Just like India has 2 other names, Bharat & Hindustan. Even before 1948 it was called Land of Israel along with Palestine. If you look at Palestinian currencies of that time then you will notice this

[@TheImmoralNosferatuZodd]

@@Ogni374 🤦 🧠☠️🤡

[@theyellowstudioorg]

Thank you for this presentation. As a Jew I am learning a lot. I pray all Palestinian refugees can be compensated and can go home.

[@jazura2]

Who has ever heard of refugees who have been refugees for over 70 years?? The only group of people in the world. If the 1948 war which was declared on the the newly formed state there would not have been any refugees.

[@saharnouri8110]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@TwiztedHumor]

Youre being brainwashed, she's lying to you about history.

[@saharnouri8110]

@@TwiztedHumor kzbin.info/www/bejne/iqfRkIVqq9h8oposi=77nEO_52Gzg7-kK8

[@juliestanfield8433]

We all learn altogether as Muslims, Jews and Christians.

[@Nehmi]

She left out the part that the Jews massacred in Hebron were all indigenous Jews.

[@LSalmon19]

There’s accounts even on the nyt that they were mostly azkenazi students taking refuge on a local Sephardi Jew house and the 3 members of that family killed but mostly the 20 some killed were immigrants

[@johnsonsmith3421]

Lmao, Jews testified against the Zionists, the Zionists started the fight

[@DipakKumar-tl2zx]

No doubt it is a Objective analysis. But this document also proves that divide and rules was the policy of British colonials

[@AzizanYunus]

Agree, English divided and ruled the entire Africa, example my country Eritrean and Ethiopian and the war still on going 🙏

[@elenal2012]

Absolutely.

[@dolores.t.hodgkins3140]

The british ruling classes have a disgustingly cruel History towards their own , slavery, taking away peasants lands,rape, , torture, etc etc . The "lord of the manor" could mistreat any one he chose, young female servents as young as 8 or 9yrs could be taken from their home by them and used physically and sexually. Without consent of their parents, they transported 1, 000s to Australia for crimes like stealing food, clothing wood, etc because Britains jails were overflowing, just read "Charles Dickens" accounts. I'm British and i'm ashamed of my country just now. 🙏🌺🌿

[@Charlie-hp2oh]

how many languages are there in Ethiopia? The Brits didnt have to divide. Same goes for the arab world with all the tribes@@AzizanYunus

[@sabinereynaudsf]

The British defeated the Ottomans. There wasn't a strong Palestinian movement at the time. Was there even any at all?

[@LowlierThanThow]

Thank you for giving us a glimpse into the making of this tragedy.

[@YouTubeCensorshipStinks]

I thought disregarding the indigenous people was a British mandate? It's like their thing, you know?

[@TBD3.0]

greedy and very sad what they did and still are doing.

[@dogbert52]

Your little flag was designed by a british colonial officer.... mr mark sykes.

[@YouTubeCensorshipStinks]

@@dogbert52 And my phone was made in China, yet I'm anti communism and do not support president Xi. Not every person in a country with an evil government is evil themselves. Hence why I don't hate Americans or all Israelis.

[@exceed.charge]

​@@dogbert52i ain't seeing no union jock on it LMAO

[@dogbert52]

@AlonsoMondaca-lt7nd really long words that only prove i am correct. Your little ji hadi project has 0 originality.

[@CosmicValkyrie]

Britain spreading love and compassion throughout the world!

[@TBD3.0]

The French were also in it... ( see; The Sykes-Picot Agreement 1916 secret treaty between the United Kingdom and France)

[@nastyalfred]

​@@TBD3.0indeed both Britain & France colluded to occupy foreign lands as part of their colonialism ideology. It has not totally ended. Although Muslim countries are now ruled by Muslim rulers they still protect the interests of their colonial masters.

[@Fischer977]

Not even close to muslims

[@CosmicValkyrie]

@@Fischer977 Muslims were better than the Christians. It's not even a comparison.

[@roswellgrey9771]

They had a way of playing divide & conquer, just like they did in India, leaving death & destruction in their wake.

[@rolex6170]

they think the world will not know the reality ever.

[@maingrbr]

Of course, go work, keep eating coke and chips, Netflix, repeat.

[@rolex6170]

@@maingrbr thank God i dont have any of those habits. and thankyou for ur concern

[@marcrauch8213]

1. Three quarters of Palestine (75%) was given to the arabs, they named it JORDAN. 2. The only Palestinians were the Jews, the muslims refused to be called Palestinians, they referred to themselves as either arabs or Syrians. 3. Of the remaining land of Palestine, about 70% was offered to the NIMAs (non-Israeli muslim arabs) under the 1939 Peel Commission Plan. The muslims said no and rioted, again killing Jews. World War II broke out and the Peel Commission Plan was dropped. 4. In 1947, the United Nations offered about 30% of the land to the NIMAs, 15% to create the international city of Jerusalem, and the rest to the Jews. The largest portion of the land for the Jews was the barren Negev desert. The NIMAs and the surrounding muslim nations swore to attack the new State of Israel and annihilate the Jews. 5. In the War of Independence, the Jews and Israel survived. Jordan took Jerusalem and several west bank areas and annexed that land to Jordan. Egypt took Gaza and annexed Gaza. The NIMAs were not given anything by the Jordanians and Egyptians. 6. In 1967, the surrounding muslim nations again planned to attack Israel and annihilate all the Jews. The Jews kicked the living daylights out of the muslim armies and humiliated them. 7. In 1973, the woeful muslim nations tried again and were again humiliated by Israel's male & female military. 8. All the land west of the Jordan River belongs to Israel, forever!

[@chiangju-an2330]

One thing is in-sufficient. The role of Mufti Mohammed Amin al-Husseini isn't mentioned in this video.

[@karimb972]

Negligible quantity. Zionists like to inflate his importance and significance. Much more important is the Zionist lobbying the Nazis and Western governments to help them colonize Palestine and make sure that Jews cannot migrate to other countries. What matters is that Zionists wanted to take over Palestine from day 1 and were helped by the British and the Americans in their quest to take over Palestine. The Zionist nightmare is soon coming to an end.

[@maximushermanite]

A very important figure that when left out of the story, completely changes the narrative. The propaganda that Husseini spout leading up to the Hebron Massacre is on the same level of propaganda we’re seeing today. History really does repeat itself.

[@baikorg]

What was the role?

[@Vlinder57]

​@@baikorgHe and Hitler shared the same goals: kill all Jews. It was no " uprising" but one of a lot of massacres.

[@Vlinder57]

As reasonable as the presenter seems, it is one- sided. There were dozens of Arab massacres for more than a Century.

[@HarryBalz-mx3ss]

Thank you so very much for this incredible video. I wish everyone in the western world would watch this and learn from it. Peace be with you all.🙏❤️

[@user-uv9tl4jt8w]

Westerners are not so gullible, they will not believe terrorists, so the West supports Israel.

[@martapfahl940]

What should I exactly learn from that? The root cause is muslim hate against Jews, I already know that. Just imagine being killed for singing your anthem like the lady in the video explained.

[@ianworcester4640]

You just want more anti semetics. & more converts to Islam

[@impeachbiden5003]

This video should be shown to everyone in the West

[@bigkuriboh3814]

Yeah to show them that the arabs started the massacres.

[@franceswalker2986]

History opens our eyes to the present massacres of Palistians. Great detail in this video. 1929 wa the depression years that must have had an impact of daily lives of both Palistians and Jews. From this video appears Zionism way back 1929 triggered the uprisings and u rest. Britain didn't help situation by treating a Jewish prisoner leneitly but hanging three Palistians, both parties involved in the incident that resulted. Also Russian Jews expelled from Russia about this time was seen by the Palistians as an insult when they took over vast agricultural Palistine lands. Today I see a turning point.....Palistine WILL have its own State as world opinion is clearly on their side. Thank you for my history lesson.

[@TBD3.0]

It's a miracle the Palestinians have endured such injustice for 70+ years anyone else would have tapped out, it truly is sad and heartbreaking.

[@YEY0806]

​@@TBD3.0then you see the dipshits cry over Hamas while being completely silent and encouraging of Israel's FAR more severe atrocities

[@mikerozenblat5258]

At that time Jews were also Palestinians

[@god-codm9676]

​@@mikerozenblat5258Jews and arabs never called themselves palestinians , but just jews and arabs. Don't try to re-invent history.

[@goodojoe]

@@mikerozenblat5258 And the Arabs did not consider themselves Palestinians, but Syrians.

[@lolqqqlol]

You missed that the uprising was due to the 1928 negotiations that started between Palestinians and the British being revoked by the Zionist lobby in British parliament. So basically the reason wasn’t religious it was political indifference by the British to even negotiate with the Palestinians and the Zionists not allowing them to (note were talking about the British secular and christen zionists who’s’ main goal was an antisemitic rejection of Jewish people in their country biggest of which was bloody Balfour) Please note the religious tensions didn’t play as big of a role as you make it seem based both on Arabic and Jewish historians such as Ilan pappe

[@mcata3625]

Yes, it's very strange this video wiped this history out

[@lolqqqlol]

@@mcata3625 it should be mentioned since many historians do point to it as the real reason, Trying to decide for Palestinians and forcing them never goes well, The uprising The Partition The 2005 elections The Abraham accords In all instances it was a 3rd part only listing to their internal Zionist lobby and considering Israel as the only party to consider. While sidelining the Palestinians in their own fates.

[@RipDon7]

@@mcata3625 They didn't wipe it out, it started at the point of the 1929 event.

[@RipDon7]

This is mostly true however, religious underlying tone was always there. It just didn't become very apparent until much later and the support for it became much more accepted once the US got involved and the Zionists started to heavily invest in lobbying for their interests in the States (but also in key European politics).

[@mcata3625]

@@RipDon7 no

[@panagenesis2695]

The British Empire has blood on their hands.

[@Polentaccio]

Every empire does. Please give me a country or state that is truly a victim.

[@Mr.BlackSanta]

No mention of the Mufti? Pathetic!

[@rdsc.455]

Yes that Mufti and his correspondence must be mentioned.

[@The_Voice_of_Reason748]

British Rule: Divide and Conquer

[@Raj007-]

#WeINDIAstandWithPALESTINE🔥🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸💚🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳👍 #FightAgainstZionistRacism&ApartheidState👎 #FreePalestine🔥🔥🔥🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🔥🔥🔥

[@wootwootwoot32]

There is no Palestine. Who was the first Prime Minister of Palestine? What is the currency of Palestine? "The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct 'Palestinian people' to oppose Zionism. "For tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa. While as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan." (PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein, in a 1977 interview with the Dutch newspaper Trouw.)

[@hxmdnv]

pls, it was under empires and kingdoms and had representatives and controllers in Palestine. This is does not de-legitimise the natives there

[@autograndeunlimited]

Yes they do exist they descended from the caanites who came before the jews. Try again

[@corvacopia]

There is no New York. Who was the first Prime Minister of New York? What is the currency of New York?

[@VCatCrusader]

The brits are no different now. The Israeli are no better, in fact possibly worse. 🇺🇦🐾💙🐱💙🐾🇵🇸

[@asherb6095]

Nice you support the very same as your next leader 🇷🇺

[@veterinarychemistry6947]

Thank you for the truth

[@abduazizkhasanov3426]

In shaa Allah Palestine 🇵🇸 will be free ☝️

[@WiseAsSerpentsHarmlessAsDoves]

From Islam too we all hope🙏🏼

[@abduazizkhasanov3426]

@Originalongrace Islam brought justice to the whole world, and without the Islam world, it will not be as just as it is right now.

[@mogbr7786]

​@@WiseAsSerpentsHarmlessAsDovesIslam is the only thing on earth that gets bigger and stronger the more you resist it; it gets so powerful that you might even fall under its spell. So keep up the good work.

[@MuhammadJasoor]

So in 1929 the Palestinians first attacked the Jews about a rumoured division of Al Aqsa ? And from there on the violence spread to other parts of the country.?As a Muslim I need few clarifications here : So the Palestinians first started the riots ? If yes what's the reason that motivated them to start rioting (a.k.a) the initiator of aggression ? Was there any particular reason (like being prosecuted by the newly arrived Brits and Euro-Jews)? Any Knowledgeable person, please enlighten me on this . Please forgive my ignorance of my question if any , I am genuinely looking for answers here.

[@user-gn8su7ro7w]

Division of western wall in 1928, she noted then zionists march, and arriving every year thousands of Jews to Palestine and taking land made worry Palestinians about future and lie of British abou their independence after ottoman empire

[@zeron7192]

​@@user-gn8su7ro7wsorry can you tell me the about the british promise ?

[@stompie51]

It’s in the video. The Palestinian Arabs just didn’t like Jewish immigrants coming to the land and buying pieces of it. Multiculturalism, mass immigration and tolerating large political/religious protests by minorities is a modern European thing. Didn’t go down well with the Arab locals in British mandate Palestine. Really didn’t go down well and led to murder and rioting.

[@MeirHarZion34]

They did the same in 1834 long before Zionism, they are simply inherently violent and intolerant.

[@voaniopalm3209]

It started when the mufti of Jerusalem, haj amin al-husseini (later became a nazi collaborator) spread a rumor that the jews want to destroy al-aqsa. The rumor spread across the british mandate of palestine and arabs started riots and massacres against the jews

[@MultiNakhoda]

„Let us not ignore the truth among ourselves, politically we are the aggressors and they (Palestinians) defend themselves, the country is theirs, because they inhabit it, whereas we want to come here and settle down. - David ben Gurion, former Prime Minister of Israel

[@mosheg112]

Never said it - fabrication

[@MultiNakhoda]

@@mosheg112Ben Gurion said this in a speech he held in 1938. It is cited in many books, you can, if you want to, check it on page 141 of „Zionism and the Palestinians“ of the Polish-Israeli historian Simha Flapan. Learn about your history and do a little reading before you make accusations.

[@anthonyagbojo1408]

​@@mosheg112even if he said it, how is it different frim what the video shows?

[@salradin4970]

@@MultiNakhoda Muslims raped and murdered their way across the East. It used to be entirely Christian and Jewish. Muslims enslaved North Africa for over 1300 years and systematically raped girls and women, and systematically castrated boys and men. Religion of peace.

[@verysmartultrahuman939]

@@anthonyagbojo1408 so now you admit that he said it? man you're all over the place.

[@elephantintheroom5678]

Wow. So it started with the British Mandate...

[@12q8]

Yeah, and it just get kept getting worse and worse, until terrorist attacks by Zionist paramilitaries caused the Brits to leave the mess it created.

[@truthseeker4280]

Ben Shapiro should see this short documentary. Different from the fantasy he speaks of in his speeches.

[@wonjubhoy]

If he did watch it he would wonder why the grand mufti of Jerusalem's close co-operation with the nazis wasn't mentioned.

[@docorwhatever2168]

⁠@@wonjubhoy 1. The meeting you are pointing to was in 1936, not 1929. 2. It wasn’t a cooperation. Nazis didn’t do shit to Palestine, and neither did Palestinians. 3. Both Jewish militias & the Mufti sought an alliance with the Nazis against the Allies. Read about the Stern Gang & Hitler.

[@bakloulaya789]

@@wonjubhoy I can say the same about stern meeting with nazis in Lebanon

[@ufosrus]

Theodore Sturgeon deeply impressed me with his take on Gestalt consciousness and the evolution of mankind with his masterpiece "More Than Human" which is told in three parts that includes "Baby is Three." This last stands as a short story in its own and if you read it first, you need to read the whole novel to learn where it leads. Perhaps our narrator will include "Baby is Three" in his list of future choices?

[@youngeagle5953]

"The tragedy of the people of Palestine is that their country was “given” by a foreign power to another people for the creation of a new state. The result was that many hundreds of thousands of innocent people were made permanently homeless. With every new conflict their numbers increased. How much longer is the world willing to endure this spectacle of wanton cruelty?" ~ Bertrand Russell

[@sfahri6374]

Could you provide the sources that detail who initiated the conflict on August 16, 1929?

[@jazura2]

Its not hard to research.

[@Swsnsdn686xzxzxy]

I've read numerous history books and have never encountered this information, especially the claim of a Jewish massacre by Arabs. It appears to be fabricated; consider reading the channel description. Given that this channel is funded by the UK, it raises suspicions that they might have distorted the information for their own benefit.

[@aiza6830]

@@jazura2 it lowkey is ..... im trying to find sources but usually its all biased and using the massacre as an excuse for colonialism. and since there's a lot of propaganda flying around, the truth could be buried underneath.

[@Amirz-go1sz]

as an Israeli that grow up in religious settlement in Gaza strip (back where those existed) I can attest to the importance of 1929 on the education of Israelis. whenever you try and explain why the Palestinians are resisting the settlements, they will remind you 1929 massacre which happen before the settlements or the state. and we all heard the detailed accounts of families murdered and rape that occur there. yet of course dir yasin seem to this people as a footnote... hopefully we can find peaceful and just solution that include return of refugees in a way that will preserve the security of Israel. seems far as ever

[@Mohammed-ps2gu]

The truth is Europeans Jews aren’t native to Palestine . That’s not there native land i promise you

[@CBT5777]

I Just don't want my tax dollars supporting them. They need to take care of themselves. I'm from the US.

[@12q8]

Dier Yasin, Safsaf, among others. Bringing up Hebron in any other discussion or as a way to legitimize whatever other actions are taken is a diversion, and although tragic, is not really helping solve anything, but simply attempting to legitimize a never ending revenge and marginalization.

[@jamilabagash149]

ZIONIST NEED TO BE RETURNED TO WHERE THEY CAME FROM, EUROPE, FOR THEERE TO BE TRUE PEACE. THEY HAVE FORGOTTEN WHAT A NEIGHBOR IS. THEY ARE JUST AVARIOUS LAND AND PROPERTY GRABBERS. TO TAKE 1929, AS AN EXCUSE IS ATROCIOUS AS THE LAND GRAB HAD ALREADY BEGUN AND THE MARGINALIZATION OF THE INDIGENOUS PEOPLE WAS EXECUTED BY THE BRITSH AND THE ZIONISTS ALIKE. STOP FUNDING AND SUPORTING THE ILLEGAL ZIONIST REGIME.

[@shahidabdoullakhanzorovr1564]

@@CBT5777 Your tax dollars support all kinds of god-awfulness as it stands, but a little basic decency is a step far? Sounds American to me.

[@AzizanYunus]

Oh my God, thank you for educating us on the history ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Mr.Peace777]

Thank u

[@cristalp00]

The Jewish group, which marched to the wall and sang the Hativkwa did this to protest that Jews were being harassed by Arabs since 1928 whilst praying there. The Arabs threw stones on them or harassed them during their prayer by shouting at them. This isn’t mentioned in the video and makes it biased as there aren’t mentioned a lot of details which are important in order to understand the whole thing. It’s a bit a dangerous video, as must of the points are true, but as I mentioned above, details which are important to understand the whole context aren’t mentioned on purpose.

[@batmanrobin6848]

Interesting. Also read that Middle East Eye is funded by Qatar. I wonder what other details they’re omitting 🤔.

[@Polentaccio]

Of course it is biased. People should listen to both sides of the argument and form an opinion rather than just the one that supports their own bias.

[@paulthompson5966]

The question is, were the Arabs throwing stones at the Jews praying there twenty years before? It was only after the influx of radical Zionists and their attempts to impose themselves on the place, with British complicity/protection, that the problems really started

[@cristalp00]

⁠@@zjg4gcvnFirstly it’s about what and not why. And then it’s not the topic of discussion here.

[@IgnatiusAyers-rz6js]

You’re saying that non-Jewish Palestinians were faced with the threat of becoming a minority in their own homeland? In 1922, Jews represented 11.14% of the Palestinian population, while Muslims accounted for 78.34%. In 1931, 16.9% of Palestinians were Jews while 73.52% were Muslims (Factsheet: Demographics of Historic Palestine prior to 1948, CJPME). The Jewish population weren’t even close to becoming a majority. Rumours that Jews wanted to “take over Al-Asqa”? You mean, the mosque that was built on top of Temple Mount, a historically sacred place for Jews?

[@factsoverfear9771]

Once the world finds out who the real Israelites are. …. My oh my ✌🏽❕

[@JewishAtheist]

"It is a well-established fact that the only accusation you make against Israel and the Jewish people is that they are a pariah religion. This unjust label is often perpetuated by a combination of Islamic, white supremacist, black supremacist, and Communist ideologies, uniting in their animosity towards a shared enemy."🤣🤣🤣

[@maingrbr]

The Palestinians?

[@JewishAtheist]

I respectfully suggest that we address the fact that the Jewish community has faced attacks from various groups, including the Marxist, Ku Klux Klan, black supremacists, and Islamists. Despite this, we are aware of our role as a target for those who wish to impose their ideologies upon us. It is unfortunate that this has led to a coalition against our community, but we must remember that this is not the first time we have faced such challenges, and it will not be the last. We are fortunate to have a country and the protection of a higher power.

[@caramelbilquees]

​@@JewishAtheistJewish ? These are whites white people with a tiny tiny tiny bit of Semite blood who say they have a " claim " to the land. I mean go back to EUROPE you pretender fake Jews your not natives to that land

[@factsoverfear9771]

@@JewishAtheist You being YT to I automatically supposed to say you are Christian kkk ? Then why the judgments when I believe anyone can be saved 💡. Let’s go with scripture to show you who not the ppl. Genesis 10. 2 through 5 kjv says the Ashkenaz ppl are Gentiles . It’s well known in Germany that they changed their name to Ashkenazi 💡. Still the same ppl of Japheth Gentiles not Gews ✌🏽

[@albertosierragil9374]

Masacre de Tantura 1948

[@ET_LWO]

Thank you for your work

[@basherkp3119]

Yes that is True history to know the new generation

[@fahiimaqueen4054]

Thank you For telling the real sory

[@TBD3.0]

Constantin Kaysar Zurayk coined the phrase Nakba he also wrote about it the book is called معنى النكبة Ma'na al-Nakba published in 1948 in Beirut. Also The Brits betrayed Hussein bin Ali King of the Hejaz, Hashemite Sharif of Mecca. Research the Arab Revolt. and Hussein-McMahon correspondence The Brits made a deal with France, research Sykes-Picot Agreement 1916 Those lands were basically stolen 1916. There are some other components to this story the creation of (i.e. Zionist) late 1800's. names to research. 1. Vladamir (Ze'ev) Jabotinsky (Ukrainian)1890-1940 Participated in the 1903 world zionist convention, he voted and rejected the Uganda proposal. 2.Theodor Herzl creator of the zionist congress formed in 1897. There are more layers but you can discover them for yourself.

[@themoroccanball]

What? A 13 y/o participated in a Zionist convention?

[@saharnouri8110]

That’s really sad.

[@penhdog2207]

Thank you. Educational.

[@balzisharez]

KZbin videos to watch al-nakba: the palestinian catastrophe episodes 1-4 and Palestine 1920: The Other Side of the Palestinian Story | Al Jazeera World Documentary

[@GerdesDK]

Things are never that simple. What a rollercoaster ride. And all the history befor. Wonder if there'll ever be true peace in that region. Hope so

[@wendyfay16]

I think that they need to turf out the rabid Zionists & agree to a 1 State solution because the 'settlers' have inundated the Palestinian lands to such a degree that it would only cause far greater upheaval, animosity & bloodshed to remove them out of the lands to the 1948 division, which if it were to be a 2 State solution, would have to return to the 1948 division. I really believe that it could work, IF everyone agreed to TRY to RESPECT each other's similarities, as well as their differences. *** However, hearing Jewish children singing about wiping out all the Palestinians isn't a good way to start a peaceful coexistence! That's how the Na*is brainwashed their youth! Hearing that told me that this has NOTHING TO DO WITH RELIGION, OR GOD .... because that is nothing that I've ever read, or more importantly, understood the Bible to be teaching. But then again, I'm only an Australian who was raised in the Christian faith, but who now believes that there is One God and He teaches LOVE of one's fellow man. Maybe the Torah teaches war, but I don't know any 'religion' that teaches vengeance. My only recollection of 'vengeance' in the Bible, is 'Vengeance is mine saith the Lord.' None of us are 'the Lord'. Do the Israelis really want to use their previous oppressors as a role model for their children, especially if they want them to grow up with the security that properly socialised, humane people live with their neighbours?

[@karimb972]

No. Zionist like to say things are complicated to obfuscate and confuse from the simple reality: foreign racist supremacist colonizers lobbied the Europeans to give them a land that wasn't theirs to establish an ethnocratic colonial State. They expelled the natives with unbelievable violence and cruelty and established apartheid and persecution to maintain racial supremacy of one group over the other. Every attempt by the natives to gain their rights was crushed with the help of the British and the Americans. End of story

[@FreePalestineAotearoa]

I stand with Palestine 🇵🇸 Maori like myself are a minority in our own lands E Tu Tangata Whenua O AOTEAROA

[@nanananere]

Aaah the British 😅 always there to spread love and peace between people

[@lukenineteentwentyseven5051]

FREE PALESTINE

[@zeenathbaig2203]

😢 But while the jews were forming militias what were the arab Palestinians doing? Why were they not armed?

[@12q8]

There were attempts, some formed but they had rivalries among each other and different goals. Zionists had plenty of support from abroad, including even the Jewish mafia in the US, while Arabs were colonized by the Western empires.

[@anchorread68]

we can see the difference between Israel and Arabs country, on one side, perform mandatory military training, while on the other side, perform mandatory education. War-like vs peaceful.

[@anshuraj4277]

​@@anchorread68funnily Israel is ahead of Arab countries in education too

[@anchorread68]

@@anshuraj4277 arabs university can't do much for student career because the tuition fee is 1% of western universities. Usually, university assist graduates to do a start-up and assist finding investor but cheap university can only teach students like a typical school does.

[@anshuraj4277]

@@anchorread68 they don't have tradition of academic excellence and they are dictatorship One more thing no one gives a fuck about Golden Age of Islam in whatever century.. It's 2023

[@ralphbernhard1757]

Yes, just like all other states which originated as a result of a large influx of mostly European passport holders as immigrants (South America, North America, South Africa, Australia, etc.) Israel has a settler colonial heritage, and was founded on imperialist principles.

[@Fischer977]

Where are you from?

[@ralphbernhard1757]

@@Fischer977 Oh bother. *So you can voice your projections?* 😵‍💫

[@Fischer977]

@@ralphbernhard1757 what are you afraid from?

[@ralphbernhard1757]

@@Fischer977 I'm not afraid of anything. Instead, I can already predict what you are going to write, when I tell you where I'm from originally 🤣 Dude, I've been around for a while, and snooped at some of your other comments, and who you subscribed to ... I'm from [drumroll] *South Africa.* Now, fire away... 🤣😂

[@Logik1002]

The head rabbi of Hebron/Al-Khalil yeshiva (Jewish madrasah) Baruch Kaplan said that this massacre occured with Zionist provocation.

[@stompie51]

You can intellectually dance; you can intellectually prance; but this video is pretty balanced and it ain’t great for the oversimplified narratives.

[@skontheroad]

Source??

[@MTx485]

Just take the L bro. Your “side” (as if it’s a damn football match) isn’t perfect. Get over it and engage like an adult

[@Logik1002]

@@MTx485 “Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages. You do not even know the names of these Arab villages, and I do not blame you because geography books no longer exist. Not only do the books not exist, the Arab villages are not there either. Nahlal arose in the place of Mahlul; Kibbutz Gvat in the place of Jita; Kibbutz Sarid in the place of Huneifis; and Kefar Yehushua in the place of Tal al-Shuman. There is not a single place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population." ~ Moshe Dayan, address to the Technion, Haifa, reported in Haaretz, April 4, 1969

[@Logik1002]

@@stompie51 "We have forgotten that we have not come to an empty land to inherit it, but we have come to conquer a country from people inhabiting it.” ~ Moshe Sharett, 1914, (Benny Morris, Righteous Victims, p.91)

[@wendyfay16]

Palestine was a thriving country with shipping & railroad transport, for trade to North Africa, Asia, Europe & Britain, before the end of WWI. The 400 year old Ottoman Empire was defeated by the British & French during WWI, with the help of the Palestinian Arabs. The British were concerned that they were losing the war so promised the Arabs self-determination in their own land of Palestine, if they assisted the Brits in the war. However, they also promised the Jews, via Lord Rothchild, a Jewish land of their own, for no other reason than to have allies in the Middle East both to secure freedom of shipping via the Suez Canal & to de-stable the Arab countries. The land was 10% Jews & 90% Arabs, who had worked & socialised together until the end of WWI & the introduction of the Balfour Declaration in 1928. Although it was Arab land, the British split it up giving 40% Arabs & 60% Jews. The Arabs were given the poorest land, whilst the Jews were given the arable land. The declaration was that Jews could live there & have their own land, but all current peoples living there, weren't to be moved, and basically, their rights were to be respected. That's when the European Jews began arriving in droves after being forced out of the Russia as it was at that time. This is when the Jews began forcing the Arabs out of their homes & off their land. They knocked the houses down & uprooted all their trees so there was nothing left for them to return to. That's when the Arabs began to stand up for their homeland in 1929. The Jews then continued to immigrate to Palestine, but instead of being satisfied with already far more than was a fair division of the land, with the huge continual influx of Jews before, during & after WW2, they then took over the Palestinian land, forcing the Arabs out of their homes. The British had thrown up their hands when their mandate ended, then the USA recognised the State of Israel, leaving the Palestinians out in the cold, and taken over my the Israelis. That's what led to the event of 1948.

[@averagekyungsoolover]

You are wrong on several accounts. There was no such thing as "Palestinians" at the time, simply Arabs who lived there and hundreds of thousands of Arabs who arrived to work for the British Mandate. Jews and Arabs did not live peacefully in the region. Arabs were looting and burning Jewish villages way before the creation of the Partition Plan, while the Jews tried to defend themselves and keep a quality of life. When the Jews began to arrive, they built their own settlements and sought to make peace. In return,the Arabs pillaged, burned and raped wherever they wanted, as the Jews did their best to defend against the invaders. In 1929, there began to be real Jewish casualties. Petah Tikva was attacked by masses of Arabs. Jaffa Jews were beaten bloody and raped by the Arabs they thought were their friends. Thousands of Arabs arrived in Hebron on the Jewish Sabbath, yelling for Jewish blood. The Jews who had lived there for generations locked themselves in their homes, but this did not stop the Arab mob. They advanced house by house, shooting, raping, mutilating and looting, as the Jews screamed for help. 67 Jews were brutally murdered that day as the British policemen stood by and did nothing. This and many events just like it happened before the Partition Plan, decades before the State of Israel and the so called occupation. The Arabs wanted Jewish blood. A century later on October 7th 2023 they still want Jewish blood. That is the extent of the conflict. Check your facts. The Jews were willing to compromise and give land. The Arabs would not compromise and instead used violence, over and over again.

[@magdalen5108]

❤

[@tenniswilliam]

I think there is a mistake in your preamble where you set this conflict in the context of aspirations for a Palestinian state. There was as far as I know from research no view of a Palestinian state until much later in the sixties and thus 1929 had nothing to do with statehood aspirations. A key figure Amin Al Husseni was the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and basically the leader of anti Jewish sentiment. He was schooled in Egyptian Salafist theology and inherently anti-Jew and promoted a pan Arabic nationalism and a broad Caliphate across all of Levant rather than a Palestinian state. I do not think in 1929 any notion of Palestine as a nation was born. You also assert that Arab nations in the 1949 war sought to prevent genocide by Zionists. Maybe but it seems more that these nations were motivated by pan Arab nationalism. The Grand Mufti too in to the thirties and early forties had great influence with other Arab leaders. He was instrumental in the getting alignment of Arab countries with Hitler in WWII and influenced tens of thousands of Arabs to go fight vwith the SS. He admired Mussolini and went to Munich to meet with Hitler representing Arabs. Arab nations and the Grand Mufti were convinced Germany would win WWII and were counting on Hitler to solve their Zionist problem with an extention of the European genocide and facilitate a path to pan Arab nationalism. The concept of a Palestinian state only emerged much later and was not in the cards in 1929 or even through to 1949. Anti jew sentiment was a key driver as taught in Salafist and other religious traditions. I cannot see that ever getting resolved. Yes people lost their land and dignity - happened a lot in history. Likewise Jews lost a lot in history. Palestinian people will not be able to recover and move forward until they come to grips with the Jew hating baked in to the religious traditions. How is that going to come about?

[@NEMBL013]

Thank God for ppl like you.

[@ahmedhussen]

I think that you are not providing correct data in many aspects and that you are fabricating things and taking things out of context 1- You are totally wrong about the existence of a Palestinian state as Golda Meir, the former prime minister of Israel carried a Palestinian passport which refutes your propaganda that there was no Palestine (you can check her interview if you want). I actually find it very impudent to go to a place and that place host me then I turn against it) 2- The Ottoman Empire actually welcomed the Jews escaping from eastern European countries as well as before forced (Belford himself called Jewish people are alien and hostile race) (Actually, modern Antisemitism is actually imported from Christian Europe) ( I am skeptical if you even understand what is meant by semite) 3- The percentage of Jewish people in Palestine was less than 10% before 1917 and later they became a settler colonial system, what do you expect out of that from people living in a place and then finding later that people taking over their lands (You can read the agonizing book called The ethnic cleansing of Palestine by the Jewish Israeli Historian professor Ilan Pappe if you want) 4- You are confusing zionism with antisemitism (I repeat that you might not understand who are the Semites), Zionism is a settler colonial ideology. 5- Many Jews actually were forced to leave their countries and go to Palestine. The zionist ideology wanted the Jews to leave their native countries and go to Palestine. For example, the Mossad agents planted bombs in Jewish worship places (Synagogues) to make them even more unsafe and force Jews to leave their countries, you can check the Baghdad 1950-51 bombing if you want 6- By the way, the Vatican was supportive of the killing of hundreds of thousands of orthodox Serbian Christians by the catholic Croatian Christians just because they were following different branches of Christianity not because someone was taking over their lands as in the case of Palestine (does that make the Vatican a terrorist state in your eyes?) I asked this question in response to your saying that Muslims and Arabs want to get rid of the Jews? 7- Regarding your talks about Muslims and their mistreatment of the Jews. Early Muslims who directly succeeded the Prophet Muhammad, Umar Ibn-ElKhattab about entering Jerusalem, gave the Jewish people lands and allowed them to build their places of worship. (During the Byzantine times, Jewish people were mistreated by the Christian rulers, even the Christian patriarch of that time opposed this suggestion from The Muslim Caliphate)

[@shahidabdoullakhanzorovr1564]

@@ahmedhussen Alhamdulillah for ppl like you.

[@shahidabdoullakhanzorovr1564]

No one has h8d the Jews more than your forebears, with the possible exception of Pharaoh. You think they killed your "god", after all. When you lot were butchering them in Europe, who were they running to for sanctuary?

[@BOZ_11]

@tenniswilliam The Jewish minority in the levant lived peacefully shoulder to shoulder with Palestinians for many many centuries under the Ottoman Empire (an islamic caliphate). The violence only started once the European Zionists arrived in the 1920s, committing terror attacks, murdering British police officers, bombing stations, and the bombing of the King David hotel in 1948. The European Zionists have always used terror tactics, and they don't even care about Jerusalem, they wanted Uganda back in 1904: The Uganda Scheme

[@smoothsnooze]

❤❤❤

[@Mr.CabadoTrucking]

MEE read very closely what I’m going to write here. ( You guys need to open a channel in Spanish, even if is only Spanish subtitles . Because the Spanish community are believing all Israeli propaganda and gems videos like this one should be watched by the Spanish community ). Please open a Spanish channel.

[@user-oz8ss4kt5v]

There would not have been NAKBA if the Palestinian Arabs and five other Arab countries, Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, and Iraq didn't attack and start a war with newly established Jewish nattion, Israel, in 1948.

[@returniniman1997]

That establishment was illegal and upon Palestinian lands. Israel is a thief

[@jcbw9975]

@@returniniman1997 its their rightful lands learn jewish history and you see why they are there agains and jews lived there for 4000+ years

[@eiribe5081]

Its interesting how you use the term "Palestinian"; the very footage you use shows us it was just Arabs and Jews; both were Palestinian at the time.

[@caramelbilquees]

Or Indigenous people born with generational ties to the land and the other WHITE invaders with a tiny tiny from thousands of years ago....... possibly claim? This seems very much like the Native Indigenous Americans fighting off the White invaders again

[@12q8]

Nah, it is accurate since Jews compromised a mix of migrant Ashkenazim, Mizrahim, Sephardim. Some Palestinian, some not.

[@adamb.m4844]

Not all jews are Palestinian thé majority of them are coming from other part of thé world

[@drats6433]

How does this make it different? Many Arab Palestinians migrated to the area also. So it's back at Square one.

[@eiribe5081]

@@drats6433 the reason it's important is that it implies is Israel stole the land from the so called "Palestinians" when in fact there just Arabs. There are many countries for Arabs-

[@flimsyjimnz]

10:07 -a very revealing letter.

[@RobinHerzig]

Everyone watching pleeeeeeez share this documentary explainer 👀

[@hamzamuhammad9005]

A very good documentary.

[@user-qe7xo1ze1x]

Footnote there was no "israel" as the criminal zionist entity didnt come into existence

[@user-eq1ty1bh9g]

🤔😔☝️🤲🤲🤲Peace all of the world.

[@idecho948]

BS. It was the Hebron Massacre against Jews made by Palestinians in 1929 starting the violence in Palestine. The Arabs also cooperated with Nazi during WWII - Grand Mufti of Palestine - the SS Arab Legion. Palestinians could have built their own country according to 1937 Peel Plan(Britain Peel Commission), 1947 UN 181 Resolution, 2000 Camp David Israeli-Palestinian Summit and 2008‘Land for peace' Program.But they rejected all international resolutions. In 1947 16 Arab nations waged 5 times of wars at Israel with populations of only 700k from 2rd day of Israel establishment. After war, they seized the property of Jews and deported them. They lost the war and nd since there, they start to play victims.They are trouble-makers everywhere even their Arab brothers dont want to shelter them

[@JM.5387]

Don't forget, they also could have established an Arab-Palestinian state during the years from 1948 - 1967 when Jordan ruled (occupied) the west bank, and Egypt ruled (occupied) Gaza. But they didn't, because that was never their goal. Their goal was to make Palestine Judenrein, and to subjugate as Dhimmi the few Jews they allowed to remain.

[@piruz87]

Temple mount was far older than the al aqsa mosque.

[@rosdisaid9402]

O Allah, please help Palestinians

[@satnamo]

1072023 turning point

[@prezervezefunk]

Hahaha , jews wanting to take al aqsa , we are not even supposed to go to the temple mount ( al aqsa ) , the rabbis don’t allow it … the beginning were Tel Hai and Nebi Musa riots in 1920 and who attacked first …as usuals … local arabs ( not called palestinians then ) … at least one pro palestinians channel talk about what happened before 1948 , I should not expect they do a balanced job , It is already something positive as the more Palestinians learn about their history and the more they ll understand that their claim for the land is weak and they should stop dreaming of kicking us out

[@AhJodie]

Thank you very much!

[@Saida-vm5xt]

😢😢😢😢

[@larrydickman5936]

Why couldn't Lord Balfour promise London or Berlin to the zionists ?

[@jackbale5846]

Because the Jews came from Judea. not London or Berlin...

[@elitebutdumb]

Because that's where they were booted out from. Europe which includes Britain. There was only ONE MP in the UK parliament who argued not to expel Jews as they belonged here but oh no! No one cared. Then they ended up in Palestine and hell broke loose each day. 75 years on they still won't give up trying to wipe out the natives so the only argument left is, there was no Palestine hence there's no such thing as Palestinians. 🙈

[@mogbr7786]

Exporting problems. Whatever problem they couldn't fix they just shipped it to their colonies or occupied territories. And the Jews were a problem. Besides, the Zionists promised him they would drag the US into the Great War against Germany; they wanted Palestine in return, and the rest is history.

[@andrewplater1782]

Well the Arabs of Palestine didn't want the land west of the Jordan.

[@davidliebman4023]

Kind of skipped world war 2

[@teamrk5150]

"A thief comming to ones house and stealing it" is where it all became problematic

[@tommyjohansson4935]

You forgot 1936 till 1941

[@doc.zaid949]

Such a great video and presentation of the Palestinian cause! #Free_Palestine 🇵🇸

[@BAFREMAUXSOORMALLY]

IF I QUOTE THE BIBLE, I WILL BE ACCUSED OF "HATE SPEECH"???

[@ohnotheyatethecookiesrun]

not unless you use it to justify palestinian genocide

[@monicaucdm1091]

Palestine is a name the Western Empires (Roman and after they recovered Jerusalem, Britain)gave to that conquered land. No Arab with a minimum of education would call themselves Palestinian, but they did.

[@gilabola4642]

In short, nothing good resulted for owner of the land everytime european colonialist arrive

[@drewjohnson4811]

Owner of the land was the British in this case.

[@gilabola4642]

@@drewjohnson4811 i bet you thought british owned india too 😁

[@drewjohnson4811]

@@gilabola4642 Arabs colonized the land by the sword themselves in the 7th century. It changed hands multiple times until the Ottomans controlled it. When the Ottomans were defeated, it changed hands to the British. It was never an independent nation of Palestine. This video conflates "Palestinian" with "Arab". There were was a mix of Arabs and Jews in the region. The Arabs were/are upset that Britain allowed additional Jews to settle there. Britain had already split the region of Palestine and given the Arabs the state now called Jordan. They, and later the UN, were going to split the remaining portion (now Israel) between the Arabs and Jews but the Arabs rejected the offer. The surrounding Arab nations declared war on the new state of Israel and lost. The refugees are those Arabs who fought alongside the Arab nations or those who were perceived to have. They were seen as hostile towards Israel and weren't allowed to resettle within the borders. They were pushed into the carve-outs that had been the UN's proposed Arab state in anticipation of them accepting the two state offer. They never have and continue to remain hostile towards Israel. Anyone who lived within the borders could have just become citizens of Israel like the Israeli Arabs who make up ~20% of the Israeli population. Instead, they remain consumed with wiping the state of Israel off the map. There are over 20 Arab countries across North Africa and the Middle East covering many times more territory than Israel, and they don't want the Jews to have one sliver of land. They keep trying to drag the world into backing them in taking back over this small area.

[@gilabola4642]

@@drewjohnson4811 sorry to dissapoint you, canaanite were there before jews arrived and guess who has DNA closest to canaanite? The palestinian, not jews who tradittionally do not practice mixed marriages. About 7th century, arab caliph invited jews back to jerusalem after they were expelled by roman. Thats fact not zionist propaganda

[@pichepc7796]

Victim, always victims. Stories always are said at each one point of view, sympathy, inclination or anyway want to be said.

[@Ikhlas99]

My Allah bless the Islamic world bless All innoncet Peopel

[@nurlindafsihotang49]

Now Middle east eye, you forgot the palestinian jews! Differiante between european jews migrant and the original palestinian jews! You should be better than this!. And what about the bombing and destruction of palestinian church and synagoge not be mentioned too!? And cite resources of the migrant was russian jews!? Most of the eastern european jews comes from hungary, poland not russia. Russian jews are amongst the 1st one againts zionism, are you kidding me!?

[@stompie51]

Interesting and balanced video. Thanks for sharing.

[@weatherfordbran2041]

So basically Arabs got made because Jews were practicing their religion and because they were proud of their country and sang their national anthem? What were the Arabs (not Palestinians, they didn’t identify as Palestinians only Arabs) not or acting their religion? What was there national anthem?

[@perpersson5562]

its time to make peace now. Hatred must be washed away from both sides-

[@aharonharel314]

Pure Pallywood propaganda narrative

[@mrss3058]

Shameful british politicians then and now

[@haralehariharale9720]

Before the State of Israel, there was a British Mandate, not a Palestinian State. - Before the British Mandate there was the Ottoman Empire, not the Palestinian State. - Before the Ottoman Empire, there was an Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. - Before the Islamic State of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was a Second Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian State. -Before the Second Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was an Ayubid Sultanate, not a Palestinian state. -Before the Ayyubid Sultanate, there was the First Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem (created Godfrey of Bouillon, conqueror of Jerusalem in 1099), not the Palestinian state. - Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there were the Fatimid, Abbasid and Umayyad caliphates, not the Palestinian state. - Before the Fatimid, Abbasid and Umayyad caliphates, there was the Byzantine Empire, not the Palestinian state. - Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not the Palestinian state. - Before the Roman Empire, there was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. - Before the Hasmonean state there was a Seleucid state, not a Palestinian state. - Before the Seleucid state, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, and not the Palestinian state. - Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was a Persian Empire, not a Palestinian state. - Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not the Palestinian State. - Before the Babylonian Empire, there was an Assyrian state, not a Palestinian state. -Before the Assyrian state, there were the kingdoms of Israel and Judeah, not the Palestinian state. - Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judeah, there was a United Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. - Before the United Kingdom of Israel, there was a coalition of the twelve tribes of Israel, governed by judicial leaders, and not a Palestinian state. - Before the coalition of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. In fact, there was everything on this piece of land EXCEPT THE PALESTINIAN STATE.

[@elitebutdumb]

Correction there was everything on the Palestinian state except EUROPEAN JEWS 😅

[@FrogLehane]

Before people used memes to argue complex political, historical, and geographical issues, they were using actual knowledge and cognition.

[@haralehariharale9720]

@komalik4694 European jews that violent Islam drove out millennium ago...you know history goes beyond 70 years...

[@basedon3334]

You missed the biggest and the most important turning point of all this, and that was when the Arabs( Hussein bin Ali al-Hashimi ) betrayed the Muslim Ottoman Empire and supported the British and Western powers in to hope of allowing them to have a country and leave the Islamic Ottoman empire. It wasn't a very smart move to betray your Muslim Turkish brothers and trust non-Muslims with the holy land. May Allah return the holy land in the hands of Muslims umma again.

[@Maniglia878]

Sweetie you’re not accurate, Jews didn’t just come out of the blue. Explain the complicated task the British Empire had to endure. Let’s not forget that Palestina is not a race but was the name given by the Romans. The Ottoman Empire lasted 600 years and the Arabs living in that territory didn’t call themselves Palestinians. Judea comes from Judas. We must be logical about the historical events that took place. In one hand we have the Jews where they were organized and efficient in developing agriculture and on the other hand the Arabs didn’t produce much. The British called the territory Palestine and the passport was under their laws. Jews wanted to work the land and create a wonderful life and they did meanwhile like most Muslims countries are poor and oppressed by their leaders. Anyway, I understand the Palestinians feelings but the smartest thing do back in the days was to come together and prosper together but as a secular Nation. BTY Jordan never really wanted the Palestinians that are basically the same people and create a prosperous Country. Gaza was part of Egypt and I don’t think they thought they were occupied by them. In Israel there are many many Arabs and they love it because there is democracy. If you are a gay Arab you won’t be killed.

[@DoronTuber]

1929 was the massacre in hebron where palestinian arabs massacred palestinian Jews. Then it was still called palestine which was the name of that region. It wasn't a country. And all the rest is history.

[@redseantlworld]

The Turkish empire didn't collapse. It was the will of the so called Muslim people. They didn't like Shariah. Research the word Shariah. Because it can also mean helping ones elderly non Muslim neighbours.

[@PaulBCohen]

The Arabs were given Jordan. The original boundary of Israel included Judea and Samaria. The Arabs never made a state in Jewish territory a priority - never built infrastructure or took advantage of multiple offers and help to form one. Their number one priority has been, no Israel. When they lose this delusion they will be able to have peace and prosperity.

[@sanahgdcvh]

Free 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@bigkuriboh3814]

So many lies and convenient things forgotten.

[@agnieszkapasinska8314]

That's great but the story give the many questions to explain the some goals of the conflict: who first said Palestine for the area? Many, many centries ago🏛️🫣? The next one is for example: children of emigrants can't never come back home? 🤔What about introducing Islam there of course 📝📖 very, very peaceful many times? 😉 Nobody is sante here📜📰🗞️📢⚔️🗡️🛡️🗝️💣: any Muslims, any Christians, any Israelitias🫣? For ages. The story is older the first date in your film.🫶🏻🫶🏿🫶🕊️🪽👩🏻‍🏫👩🏿‍🏫👩‍🏫Many people are interested in historii and today isn't the problem to find answer for the questions? The problem is that objectivity is difficult art and the ability to forgive each other🤔🌍Many 😉God peaceful for you Holy Land of 3 religous and many opinions.🫣🤕🪽🕊️

[@chessman70]

European colonialism again.........

[@AbdulMajid-bc6xf]

By right who are people of( Israel)Because i see Israel as a country. Whoever that's born there is that county's citizen.

[@ET_LWO]

11:09

[@lilianesakarikos3994]

Ich denke, mann muss sich auch für die ganze Geschichte der Juden interressieren vor 1929 und warum sie überhaupt angefangen haben in ihr Ursprungsland zurück zu kehren.....Ich wünsche mir Frieden für beide Völker.

[@paulamarsh1]

1929 Hebron massacre. Please be factual and tell both sides. Both sides committed atrocities! 🙏😞🔯🇮🇱

[@ohnotheyatethecookiesrun]

#FREEPALESTINE

[@TwiztedHumor]

Another one for legal deportation.