What Churchill Thought About the Palestinians and Jews

Support Blogging Theology on Patreon:
/ bloggingtheology
Buy Me a Coffee:
www.buymeacoffee.com/blogging...
My Paypal Link:
www.paypal.com/paypalme/blogg...

[@BloggingTheology]

My mistake in the video: the author of the book is Tariq Ali not Tariq Ramadan!

[@Student.of.Knowledge]

Love you bro

[@nizamm4908]

That was an honest mistake, I believe. Thank you for the clarification brother.

[@philnewton3096]

Music. Imes from the auditory memory as does language.

[@BWFAIZANSRD]

I believe you interviewed him also not long ago.. which was another brilliant discussion on the future of Muslims in Europe.

[@aali1811]

Perhaps you could put a correction insert in the video, every time the Tariq Ramadan is mentioned.

[@noncekilla8848]

My grandad was a para during WW2 and worked as a peacekeeper in palastine for 2 years after the war, he said there will ALWAYS be trouble there.

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤

[@Junkitup]

Thankz to grandpa

[@odysseusprodromou3260]

maybe it was BECAUSE your grandad was there as an occupier and representative of war criminals and genocidal maniacs like Churchill that he felt that way. My dad was there for two years during WWII and was forever sympathetic to the Palestinians. Maybe it was because my dad was from Cyprus, occupied by the murdering British Empire.

[@rickyp6815]

They got on more or less OK for a very long time until then. What changed that?

[@BashaarO.Tarabay]

I don't mean this in a disrespectful way to your grandpa but your grandpa and what he repeated there in Palestine was the core issue and problem, why was a Brit born in the rolling meadows of the English country side in someone else's land upholding a policy by people who enjoyed blood pudding, 2000 miles away , creating and upholding a policy against an indigenous people , in their land , who who absolutely wanted nothing to do with blood pudding , being oppressed by people who had no business being there, do you understand how fundamentally immoral that is?

[@pen8101]

Our uncle served in Palestine after WW2. He said they were not terrified of the arabs but of the terrorists on the other side. The murder of British squaddies and then the booby trapping of their bodies to inflict maximum mayhem and murder had something to do with this but also generally having potshots taken at them constantly. They came out of WW2 having fought Nazism and were exhausted. Why on earth are those squaddies and the ones killed at the King David hotel not commemorated each year on Remembrance Sunday? Britain is losing its sense of self these days.

[@khaledkhatib5116]

I am a Palestinian 🇵🇸. I lost my uncle in the king David hotel in 1946. Rip. The Zionist terror started way before 1948

[@cliodyncycwatch924]

Apologetics & revisionism (and in essence, a kind of neo-imperialism) for those convinced the Muslim-Arab mind will never open, will never start thinking hard about why the Muslim-Arab world is so messed up.

[@peergerber7609]

When you mentioned that Churchill authorized the bombing of a German city before the Nazis bombed british civilians, you did not mention that, before this bombing, Hitler directed the Luftwaffe to bomb a dutch city, after the Netherlands announced their surrender, because it was perceived to be too slow for the Nazis. Since this action was a violation of Germany's announcement, along with Britain and France, not to bomb civilians, Churchill changed Britain's war strategy. Why didn't you mention this important fact?

[@Chean-fo9ru]

Well, the fact is that Germany bombed Rotterdam on May, threatening with leveling Utrecht next; that's when the Netherlands surrendered. The bombings of civilian targets both in Germany and England only started in August. Now, I found conflicting recounts about who bombed who first, so I wouldn't stick my neck out over that one.

[@ricardosmythe2548]

He also totally ignored the facts that at the end of the battle of Britain the nazis switched from targeting RAF bases and focused on London and other civilian centres. It was that action that allowed the RAF enough respite to recover slightly and win the day.

[@daydays12]

Indeed @@ricardosmythe2548

[@elgorrion52]

Wikipedia: "Strategic bombing during World War II began on 1 September 1939 when Germany invaded Poland and the Luftwaffe (German Air Force) began bombing Polish cities and the civilian population in an aerial bombardment campaign."

[@MumT05]

We used to call this sedition

[@hebakhalifa5672]

it is very emotional for me as an Arab with a Palestinian mother to hear the atrocities said and done by such men but my belief is that every passing day truths are reviled and the tide will turn in our favor InshaaAllah, but the difference is as Muslims we would never commit such evils and we will stick to our Islamic code of honor. Thank you very much Paul for this great upload may Allah bless you.

[@warnaoh]

Yeah muslims never commit evils xD Go look at what Muslims did in India or how many slaves they had and how they treated them. But what to expect from someone thinking the perfect man fucks 9yo

[@zeemanzeeman5577]

We Muslim do commit crimes these days and don't adhere to Islamic values. Let's look at ourselves and correct it. Arabs have lots of problems not to mention the corrupt leadership

[@marna7325]

😂

[@kendiamond8722]

​@@marna7325he was a total fascist

[@virtuosa69]

All religions commit such evils. That is evidenced by tens of thousands of accounts and written documentations be them perpetrated by Jews, Christians, or Muslims

[@mamnoona]

Arab Christians, Muslims and Jews lived in peace until the end of ww1 as I remember reading various examples of their collaborations for freedom before and during Ww1

[@elisabethmeziane5003]

Not true. Many criminal acts perpetrated by both

[@georgeh8937]

no noona. under turkish rule muslims would fight with the jewish minority and the turks would not intervene.

[@rolasaid1701]

@@georgeh8937 Jewish were happy and respectful in the arabic lands, there were no problem at all untill the Zionism project appear under lies and false alligation. then the Zionism made conflict in other arabic countries (such as in Egypt zionism bombed a Jewish cinema and pretend that the arab did it in purpose to obligate the jewish to leave Egypt) to obligate jewish to leave their countries and come to Palestine. as many jewish like other christians and muslems considered that they are living in their countries and did not want to move to Palestine. Even in Palestine there are many strories how the jewish lived side by side with the Muslims and christians like brothers before the Slavians ( Russia, Ukrania and other east and west european jewish) come to Palestine and steal the land and ID as Semitic. take a look in the KZbin what the real jewish says ( jewish anti zionism, Naturikarta, JVP. etc.

[@pepp4560]

Following the game plan laid out at the British 1st Imperial Press Conference of 1909, and representing Rothschild interests, J.P Morgan proxies purchased the top 25 most influential publications in the United States in 1915. They then used their editorial control to drive U.S. public opinion into the First World War on the side of the Allied Powers. As a reward, the British cabinet approved the Balfour Declaration promising Baron Rothschild it would endeavor to create a homeland for Jews in Palestine. Now, jump forward to the 1950’s, when the CIA used Operation Mockingbird to penetrate U.S. media, as well as various USG, state, and even certain metropolitan agencies. Today, nearly all U.S. legacy media is controlled by just five conglomerates, all of which are ultimately controlled by the Deep State, which came to power behind the scenes via JFK's assassination in 1963. That is why the JFK assassination is regarded as the Third Rail in American Journalism. The Democratic Party has become its political wing, and the MSM is now little more than its propaganda arm.

[@yusrialtamimi1570]

One interesting fact for you Paul: Marmaduke Pickthall, the famous British writer, translator and Muslim convert who was born in 1875 was a "classmate and friend" of Winston Churchill at Harrow School, the prestigious boarding school in England. They both shared a similar "social" status as members of the "upper class", however, they had very different views on politics, religion and culture. Pickthall, being a devout Muslim, was a sympathizer of the Ottoman Empire and also the Indian independence movement (Did Tariq Ali mention this?), while Churchill was a staunch imperialist and colonialist.

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

Churchill was the butcher of Bengal, watch the video of Dr Shashi Tharoor regarding Britain's crime

[@paulamarsh1]

Churchill often had to choose between the lesser of two evils. Of the two men, it is Churchill who will be remembered.

[@aftabnaveed]

@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn so whatever Shashi Tharoor says is right? Famine happened in 1942 and Churchill was fighting world war II against a monster.

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

@@aftabnaveed lol your name is aftab.. he even gave remarks against Islam and you are supporting him? He was a monster who was fighting against another monster... The another Austrian monster was lesser evil than Churchill because Austrian painter knew about je ews traitors who backed western allies at that time... 3-4 million Bengalis died out of starvation because he diverted essential supplies from the civilians in Bengal to sturdies Europeans... When People writing to him that people are dying he replied why hasn't Gandhi died yet? He compared Indians with animals and he also said that there was nothing wrong in colonization of America Australia he said that a greater race took over another... Is this your favourite?

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

@@paulamarsh1 for me Churchill was worst than hit ler...

[@bhangrafan4480]

There is a very famous quote from Churchill. I think when he was in the Colonial Office, along the lines (paraphrasing): "The Jews seem to think that we can just get rid of the Arabs to suit them." At this point he was openly critical of the concept of Zionism. Very interestingly, despite being such a well-known quote, it seems to have been completely excised from history. There are people today who are actively trying to deny the facts of history, that before WWI and during the interwar period, the Palestine Mandate territory was an area heavily populated with settled Arab farmers, and that the Jewish population was a tiny minority. A demographic map of the region was drawn up in 1910 for the British government by Maunsell. This shows that the Palestine Mandate territory was the largest area of settled Arab agriculture in the Mashreq. It also shows the minute areas of settled Jewish agriculture. In 1947 at the onset of the creation of the modern state of Israel, only about a third of the population in the Palestine Mandate territory was Jewish, and most of those had only arrived since 1941. An ethno-nationalist Jewish state could only be created in a region where Jews were a minority by the ethnic cleansing of hundreds of thousands of Arabs. This was carried out at gun point by the hard men of Irgun, Hagganah and the Stern Gangs. Men brutalised by their experiences in WW2 on the eastern front. These are simply the facts of history which are forbidden in the USA and highly supressed across the west. I see many American videos on here recently, pretending that the Jews have been the majority population of the territory for all of the last 2000 years. This is either dishonest or extremely ignorant.

[@goedelite]

I think the NAZIs were guilty not only of genocide of the Jews but also of brutalizing the Jews to the Palestinian Arabs. By "Jews"., I mean Jews, worldwide. The Jews of the 1940s just did not want to know what the Arab population was at that time. The Jews just wanted to establish Israel, and did not care because I believe they felt that what had be done to them in Europe gave them license to do anything. I believe that such, too, is the attitude of Israelis today.

[@craigsaunders7037]

Interesting fact. If all stolen lands were given back, no one on the planet would have a home.

[@siddude]

There is no such thing as a historical Palestinian state or Palestinian people. There were Arabs living in the Levant who settled there after the Arab Conquest in 739 AD. Arabs in the Levant were descendants of Arabs conquerors who colonized the Levant.

[@bhangrafan4480]

So what? It is completely irrelevant to the whole issue. If someone comes to your home pushes you off your farm at gun point, hands your land over to foreign immigrants who have only just arrived in the country, then bulldozes your village rebuilds a new one with another name. Stages massacres and terror to drive you and your people out of your homes, then claims none of this happened, If you are angry of fight back you are told you have no right to be angry and that you are only fighting back because you are 'racist', is that something you would accept yourself? If it happened to you? Say in the partition? The reason for a Palestinian state has nothing to do with some abstract historical argument about nationality. The "Two States" solution is a way to bring peace, to find a formula to end the blood feud which will otherwise go on generation after generation. The Israelis were INVADERS. They invaded the country and started this war. It is a simple fact that no one group of people want to live under another group of people. The Israelis do NOT wish to live under an Arab government, that is why they conducted mass ethnic cleansing. The Arabs do not want to live under the Israelis, which is the reality of what is happening now. Only the "Two State" solution brings any hope for peace, but you reject it, why? It is the extremists of Hamas and the Israeli hard right-wing who reject the "Two State" solution, and who want to escalate the war to a final solution of exterminating totally the other. You are supporting this. You have no reason for your point of view except your own irrational hate of Muslims. If you are not an Israeli or a Palestinian (person born in the Palestine mandate territory , or a child of a refugee from there), then why do you choose sides. Foreigners who choose sides in other people's conflicts are usually doing it for their own selfish reasons. @@siddude

[@Danielle-zq7kb]

⁠@@siddudeNot according to DNA studies of archaeological sites. Even if what you state is true (and it isn’t) what does it matter in 1917 or 1948 or 2023 what was going on in 739? What a foolish comment.

[@markashdown1314]

Being a drunk was of no help to Winnie.

[@MrPatrickslovell]

Thank you for this!

[@KilamSabba]

Excellent video except for one small but crucial missing descriptor. The Jews referred to in this entire exposé are white, European, or Ashkenazi Jews. And one of those qualifiers is a required prefix in every case. The “Arab Jews” who were already living peacefully in the Middle East were not considered or consulted in this colonial scheme. The entire affair was a 100% European project. And although native Jews were brought in later to bulk up the Jewish population, they were (and to some extent still are) treated poorly, disrespected, and discriminated against. Today the European Jews are still the mainstay of established power in Israel.

[@lanialost1320]

...and, the Ashkenazi usurpers have not a trace of Semite in them.

[@janetmartin341]

Absolutely. The long standing peaceful relationship of Jews who lived not only in Palestine but in Iraq and other parts of the Middle East was destroyed. Jews were forced to move to Israel from other Middle Eastern countries and became poor second class citizens, forced to leave their homes and business and become refugees. Britain is responsible for much of the misery not only in the Middle East but also in India and Pakistan where you can also see the idea of chopping up land according to arbitrary so called religious preferences and thus have created the modern world of unrest and terror where once was peace we now have generations of misery.

[@KJVreaderFromINDIA]

India still has synagogues in almost all major cities, with some jewish population

[@hamadalkhalifa2323]

All are criminals. The Arabs Jews helped Israel.

[@gerdfehlbaum7059]

@@KJVreaderFromINDIA Like in Cochin. I think the oldest in Asia. Been there. Incredible India! I LOVE your country!!!! Want to go there again.

[@brassedoff2437]

The truth is he was born in the Victorian era and at the height of the of the British Empire. As much as people condemn him and shout "war crimes" at him, his views were explainable given his upbringing and background. This is not to say these were not terrible, because they were, but that history grows from the past and he was a product of his past - like we all are. There was good and bad in him, as it is with all of us.

[@user-qj8pc4dv7g]

British built the railroads of India, which are still used, dilapidated as they are.

[@raycroal]

@@user-qj8pc4dv7g they built them to move their loot and their soldiers, don't make it sound like a gift to indian people

[@user-qj8pc4dv7g]

They also built schools and roads, in fact they built an entire infrastructure and brought them the modern world.@@raycroal

[@raycroal]

@@user-qj8pc4dv7g Do you really believe india didn't have schools??? no they built english schools .strange how they are doing better without us then, did japan bring britain into the moden world in the late 20th century??? i bet you have never claimed that.

[@raycroal]

@@user-qj8pc4dv7g if britain was still looting india, do you think the indians would now be owning some of the uk s most prostigious car marques?? oh! that's right in your view we would have given them our car marques because we are so effin good to them.

[@parmafoi4066]

You forgot about christian Poland, which invited Jews as early as in XII century, and made them welcome for over 700 years, and able to create their own cities (Kazimierz), which means there is more to blame than christianity

[@JoggoJuniorMan]

I only just got to you mentioning how Churchil allowed the bombing of civilian areas in Germany. Haven't the Germans done the same? By the way, it was only considered a war crime since the Geneva convention in 1949. That's 4 years after WWII has finished. And what's Ali's opinion of Hamas and Hizballa shooting missiles into civilian Israeli areas on purpose? Is that ok?

[@Yara-Li]

Only when you have different standards towards Israel and the Jews of course.

[@babezabe9197]

Imagine raving alongside the biggest concentration camp on Earth, and then imagine still claiming victimhood after you had massacred almost 40 times, and wounded almost double that, more of the people you have been holding in apartheid prison for decades prior? Many Jews are also standing up to what Israel is doing, perfectly aware of the fact that Holocaust (committed by Europeans, by the way) is being used to justify the ongoing Gaza Genocide.

[@mohdfahad2219]

Really important video in context to Mohammed Hijab's recent debate.

[@TawhidCodex]

Yo my namesake

[@anneeq008]

Yh he should research more into him. He didn't know the figures well enough in the debate with Schmoly

[@mohdfahad2219]

@@anneeq008 At least he did not make it up like Unholy Scmuly.

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

it shows when people do not know real history. Muslim people have always been in Europe!

[@HK00088]

I’m not a big fan of church hill because of things done in India

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

Brilliant i have read the book its fascinating insight of imperialism . He was a ardent racist and imperialist.He hated the working classes and was ready to get the military to kill when they striked in London on the railways! To think of him as anything other than a a racist imperial is astonishing!He was also of the most unpopular pm in England but later became a hero just at the end of war! Everybody should know about how callous he was! Bury my heart at wounded heart is also good to read it has many parallel with what is happening in 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

really Muslims were always in Europe ! Shame you don’t know historical facts!

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

So if you have any other racist type answers come back with something more tangible fool!

[@fl5537]

​@@atlasto9052You can worship your false gods. But Muslims were already in northern Europe since the Viking period.

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

exactly they were already trading with the arabs! Man its funny how these so called keyboard warriors no very little but first to hate!!!

[@DJsaima]

you wouldn't be in Europe either without the Muslims who fought your WW2. you have a lot to be thankful to the Muslims for @@atlasto9052

[@FiveLiver]

2:59 Britain did not do this first. The Germans bombed Warsaw and Rotterdam as they invaded Poland and the Netherlands. It was only a matter of time before they bombed Britain. The Germans started the war and started the aerial bombing. To lay that at the door of Winston Churchill is absurd and dishonest.

[@tektables6635]

its wrong to assume that Churchills views were those of the English workingman, they werent, he was appointed during the war because extraordinary times require extraordinary measures, but when he was elected PM in 1950 and it came down to policies the British public couldn't get rid of him quick enough, i read his biography (or one of them) and he seemed an incredibly self aggrandizing character, I was expecting every chapter to end with, "naturally, I had the last laugh and they were sorry"

[@PMAB8]

These are the views of the British government and laws. This is part of your history all over the world. You believe that you are better than everyone else in the world. Look where your country has been they is miserable conditions xenophobic bigotry racist white supremacy nationalism agenda. America 🇺🇸 Africa, Latin America, Asia and Australia 🇦🇺. Your greed for power enrichment of your country in the name of your racism in the name of god save the king.

[@robertscott6930]

You are correct. My late father (1920 - 2016) disliked Churchill for his politics and his class. However, my father begrudgingly accepted that Churchill was the man for the moment in WW2. Its always worth noting that early to mid 20th century Britain was, across all society, racist but not in a violent way more of white Britains are superior sort of way. It was normal. Now things are different.

[@shulahamilton9025]

Tariq Ali Ramadan was not only an ANTISEMITE, very clever with his discourse. Please read "Brother Tariq" by Caroline Fourest (not a Jew) He was the grandson of Hasan al-Banna, Founder of the Muslim Brtotherhood, and the apologist for Jihad.

[@Dimaaa88]

He made a correction on his mistake - the book was written by Tariq Ali NOT Tariq Ramadan.

[@Kuppasy]

Anyone criticizes Zionists fascism becomes anti-Semite, as per white askhanazi colonial settlers. When Zionists see truth hurts they fling the anti-Semitic coin. The most funny but inhumanly cruel people on earth are Zionists

[@evelynmariayeshua]

Thank you for your information. ☑️ clarifies things…. 🙏

[@nickstone3113]

Tariq classic hypocrisy

[@Kuppasy]

@@nickstone3113 as said by a Western European askhanazi hypocrite

[@sohailagha1803]

Churchill was a Barbarian in his soul and action. Needs condemnation from all of us who are human.

[@monaliza3334]

He wanted to start a war against USSR in 1945... That was his "thanks" for USSR winning the WW2 and freedomfor EU....

[@busterbiloxi3833]

You need condemnation!

[@fidelcatsro6948]

condemned🐱👍🏿

[@here_we_go_again2571]

@@monaliza3334 USSR did not >""winning the WW2 and freedomforEU"< *USSR enslaved all of Eastern Europe* *and half of Central Europe*

[@TheSunship777]

So were the Mongols

[@fenlander7114]

Much appreciate your positive affirmation of Winston Churchill, deeds not words.

[@1271diana]

Sounds familiar to the Australian story. Where the English mentioned that there is nobody living on Australian soil

[@dankoppel6271]

After most Arab nations expelled their Jewish populations in the late 40's, the influx into Israel of these Mizrahi Jews outnumbered the "white Ashkenazim". These Jewish refugees from Arab lands also outnumbered the Palestinian refugees, a fact not commonly known.

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Prove that

[@dankoppel6271]

@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763 There's this thing called "google".

[@samcohen1625]

The idea was to populate Israel with as many and with any kind of Jew as possible in order to strengthen it. From India, at first only white Jews were accepted, then after a lot of debate the Bene-Israel Jews were accepted. They were of mixed Indian race and came to India long before the so called white jews from Persia. Indian Jews left in their droves for a better’ life after being fed heavy Israeli propaganda. They were also deeply in love with the idea of having a nation of their own. Tariq is right. Anglo Indian Christians generally abused jews, a throwback to colonial times.

[@RegiaManos]

Sure it’s commonly known , if you ask a Jew in Israel whatever they’re from most are from Iraq, Syria, Lebanon etc.they’re not all Europeans .. the question is why were the expelled from their homelands to be put like rats in Israel

[@lisaprendergast9716]

Why is calling The Jews, “ The Jews” anti semetic, and as it was said by an Apostle?? You lost your argument right there. You may be a bit delusional.

[@dankoppel6271]

Next week's discussion: how the 7th century Arabs came out of the Arabian peninsula and how they conquered and colonized the Levant, all of North Africa, and southern Spain.

[@jeangordon]

And murdered those who refused to convert to Islam.

[@theearlybirder-videos]

And east to India.

[@clivekahn4305]

Tariq Ali is a Pakistani-British political activist and a member of the editorial committee of the New Left Review. Winston Churchill was a British patriot that saved the free world from Nazi tyranny. Paul Williams, the presenter of this video has also presented videos "My journey to Islam", and "Becoming Muslim".

[@mireillelanglois6947]

Merci, ça m’éclaire!

[@dbrucie]

I clicked on this to find out what Churchill thought about Jews and Arabs, but you started talking about England bombing Germany first before Germany started bombing London (called the "Blitz"). Where and how was that? I'm reading "The Last Lion" and I didn't get that part.

[@stevenrevins]

it's about context, you see it's 30 minutes long?

[@babachandrasekhar2452]

Tariq Ali forgets to mention that the Jews who came from Europe purchased the lands from the absentee landlords in Syria while the local Arabs were only tenants on the land.

[@jeangordon]

He didn't forget to mention it; he purposely omitted to mention it because it interferes with what he wants people to believe.

[@jesus_isamuslim]

☝️ Ya Allah please help and protect our brothers and sisters in Palestine🇵🇸😭🤲, children, women, elderly and all innocent civilians!🤲😭❤️🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@OZcomingFRoo]

What the fuck is that profile name? And that pity comment.... You're not even trying to be clever with you deception Muslim boi... The Christians will have fight you. All all this shit because of the nature of your religion...

[@robertmitchell8630]

Huge chunk of Hindu land today call Islamic Pakistan an Islamic terror heaven Byzantine citadels of Orthodox Christian today call Turkey??? Zoroastrian Iran Assyrian Christian Iraq Syria Coptic Christian Egypt Buddhist Afghanistan all under illegal Islamic occupation 57 Islamic nations and yet you Muslims crying over a sliver of land call Israel? Shame on you Muslims Jews Christians pagans totally extirpated from Arabia Sorry the civilized world must unite and stand up to these Islamic bullies

[@mamunaaltaf2849]

Boring boring response to muslims if you dont like us just get lost useless key board warriors.Christianity. has no clout now or essence it sold itself to the devil!

[@MuhammadHasbullah07]

Amiinn free Palestinian 🇵🇸 amiinn Allah SWT bless and protect our brother and sister amiinn free Palestinian 🇵🇸

[@robertmitchell8630]

@@MuhammadHasbullah07 Amen aimmin is from the ancient Egyptian God Amon Ra Moses brought it out of Egypt Is Ra El Is= ISIS Ra= Amon Ra El= ancient Phoenician God Free Palestine from Hamas Free Balochistan from Islamic Pakistan

[@johne.mckenzie9344]

Thanks so much!

[@valentinamilashkina3424]

you should judge any person by the laws of time when that person lived. It is not proven yet that the norms of our time are irreproachable.

[@AL-ku1zq]

I wonder if the esteemed historian who wrote this book about Churchill will write the equivalent book about other leaders of the past. Maybe some historical figure from the Middle East? Not sure why that area came to mind. There must be historically important leaders from there, although none come to mind immediately. Doubtlessly none from there ever did anything ruthless or killed anyone. Very peaceful area after all.

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤❤

[@ntdisciple]

​@RussianFans-vn6cj Galatians 5 10 I trust as to you in our Master that you will NOT consider OTHER BELIEFS, but that the one troubling you shall bear the judgment, whoever he may be. xref-2 Galatians 4 9 But now, knowing Elohim, but rather being known by Elohim, how do you turn again to the weak and poor principles to which you desire again to come under their bondage (note) xref-1 These were people who were before patterning pagan cultic practices and now came to faith in YHWH and are now known by YHWH and were turning back to the former pagan practices. Galatians 1 6 I am surprised at how soon you have turned to another good news, away from Messiah who has called you to grace.

[@cathiemarvellous]

Maybe because Churchill is put in a pedestal and Britons are still living in a delusion that they are somehow civilised when in fact then murdered, pillaged and looted more than most other nationalities.

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Your comment just proves your lack of education

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Yes, that area was peaceful until Europeans...anything "wyte" people touch gets destroyed. They are the literal authors of confusion

[@Kafkaesque786]

This channel deserves all the support we can offer. Thank you

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤

[@JessJoanne]

By a bunch of 'white supremacy' talk that does nothing, but spread more hate against 'whites' whatever that means. Guess I'll go around calling people tans, yellows, red and browns then. It is damaging to our children. I can't even watch the last 7 minutes, but at least I gave the video a chance.

[@nickgent9949]

If you read your history. Churchill did not want to be too tough on the Germans after WW1. He already had a deep understanding of history, in fact more than most. He was a colossus of his age and is one today.

[@BRUMARTUBE]

Thanks to Churchill we won the war against the nazis. Germans could have surrender early, but they didn't, and the bombing seems to have been necessary. Similarly, after Hamas horrific attack on jews, it was predictable that Israeli will attempt to demolish the military headquarters of Hamas, and warn them in advance so that the civilians could flee, but Hamas made this impossible, and is entirely responsible of the death of the Palestinians, which they simply called "martyr", like in their chart they consider women as martyrs factory. We, europeans and Americans, have to stand up for all democracies when attacked by autocracies, even more so when they have inherited nazism. The chart of Hamas is even worse than "Mein Kampf", if that is possible, as they want to destroy all Christians, and to obliterate the women's right. This video contains many truth, but seems to abstract them from the context, and lack much comparisons with the enemy of the time, and today's.

[@karlgreene2177]

Who's we?

[@BRUMARTUBE]

@@karlgreene2177 We the people belonging to secular democracies.

[@danieljames8770]

Regarding Churchill’s thoughts on former colonies needing guidance, I think it’s worth noting all former colonies, in Mideast and Africa, upon independence and many under Islamist rule have fallen to chaos and ruin

[@MrPete0282]

British/US colonialism's legacy to the "3rd" world, the term itself being obviously racist btw... with Palestine being the masterpiece, a humanitarian crisis conceptualised and materialised largely by the British, gj. You could say everything you touch turns to shit, like Mida's touch in reverse!

[@geraldwalsh6489]

Ireland and Malta are very much exceptions then......both nations now thriving after independence...I should know.....i have been to both countries

[@BCSTS]

So I guess the superior attitudes of imperialists/colonizers is well founded & correct ? They were/are more superior ? 😑

[@duellingscarguevara]

Racism is not a lifestyle choice, or, is it?..I think I spot it, well enough in others, but bad neighbours are a fact of life...(My neighbours don't think a great deal of me, I'm sure?), but I think I'm a great bloke, (within reason), but, don't we all?..

[@Amidat]

sure - if you left them uneducated. Yet Hong Kong and Singapore thrive because the Chinese people made sure they educated themselves.

[@SunnyandWillow]

Churchill was a nightmare for india. Partition has proved a nightmare for Muslims and Churchill stoking tensions in the 1940s very deliberately between Muslims and Hindus is to blame for a lot of the evil that happened in partition.

[@SionTJobbins]

Neruh and the Muslims wanted Partition. It would have happened in any case in some way.

[@SunnyandWillow]

@@SionTJobbins something happening is very different to a bloodbath. He predicted it because he was helping engineer it !!!!

[@HangTheTraitors157]

@@SunnyandWillow So it wasn't Churchill then? Make you mind up. England for the English.

[@user-ln6cc4rf5z]

VERY TRUE, ASS HOLE DIVIDED OUR PUNJAB, TO KEEP A PIECE TO BOOST FAKE EGO OF WEST.

[@ken8of8]

@@HangTheTraitors157 A damn shame the English didn't stick to England, the World would be a lot better off now had they. Assuming you are English, how good was the ODI World Cup eh??? Who won, how did England fare???? (Not the Moral World Cup)

[@ET_LWO]

Ordered times & crimes from Amazon & just opened it today Thanks for the recommendation/work

[@lamoitte1]

" Britain bombed Germany first and the Germans retaliated by bombing London? " That's 'rich' , very rich.

[@normsky5504]

His comments wouldn't have raised an eyebrow during his time. Right or wrong, attitudes and standards were different in his era.

[@kitemanmusic]

Yes you could speak your mind in those days!

[@EwanCummins]

But his comments did draw objections in his own time. By no means did everyone agree.

[@benjaminluc1208]

This analysis of the treatment of the Jews in the Muslim world would have benefited greatly from even a superficial research effort which would demonstrate that antisemitism is by no means a uniquely Christian phenomenon. In different time periods the treatment of Jews has varied significantly the world over. Accordingly, there are numerous cases of antisemitism under Muslim rule, such as the 1066 Grenada massacre and in the 1656 Jewish expulsion from Isfahan (along with many other waves of expulsions and forced conversions). All of this is not to mention that - even though the majority of Jew hatred once came from a Christian populous - the countries that hold the most antisemitic views in the world today are more often than not Muslim majority countries. We could determine this by using a number of different metrics but as we've mentioned expulsions already let's start there. The most recent expulsions of Jewish populations have been from countries such as Yemen, Morocco, Egypt, Iraq, Algeria, Libya, and Lebanon. In total nearly a million Jews were expelled from or fled from Islamic countries in the 1940s and the 1950s. In many cases these communities had established traditions in these countries, going back hundreds or even thousands of years (there is archaeological evidence of Jews living in Baghdad as far back as the early sixth century BCE). This may help explain why the current Jewish population in Israel is majority Mizrachi or Sephardi ('Non-white' Jews who lived in the Middle East and North Africa). Although of course there are also sizable 'white' population in Israel, but many of them are the descendants of holocaust survivors so the theory that they are 'privileged' could also do with a swift rejection of that particular null hypothesis. As to your take on Churchill, it is too great of an undertaking to contextualize each of the misleading statements you put forth so I will just say a couple things. First, the trouble at understanding why Churchill referred to the 'Jewish race' and not to the 'English race' as the 'best race' may be understood as an homage to the indebtedness he felt the British owed to the moral and technical contributions that Jews and Judaism had made and that we only feel uneasy with his language because he was using terms that did not yet have the negative connotation they hold for us modern viewers today. If we judge people of the past by modern standards we generally find them lacking because we are not in the same context they were in, we rarely have taken the time to learn about that context, and we (hopefully) have developed morally in the meantime, at least in certain respects. Second, I think that a lot of the examples of 'racism' that were brought up could be far better understood through the lens of paternalism rather than race hatred. He certainly believed that there were different levels of technological and civilization development, but I would suggest that scientific and developmental indices agree.

[@Chean-fo9ru]

Dear friend: you seem to have a deep understanding of Jew history. Maybe you can answer this for me: Why? Why is it that Jews are so poorly treated or even driven out from everywhere? This is a honest question, I'm not anti-semite or anything of the sort. It's true that we don't have many Jews here in Spain... (we drove them out 4 hundred years ago).

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Are you European

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Also of Muslims are the worse then why would Israel want to be in the middle east? Make that make sense. They should be in Europe where they are loved

[@chrisperkins7331]

I am European(British), and spent much of my adult life married to an American Jewish woman. I asked her and a number of her family members the same question, as to why are Jewish people the most picked on people in History. Also why is it that even the most mild question about the behavior of the Israeli settlers in the west bank, brings about accusations of me being anti sematic. As an outsider that cares about the future of the Jewish people, I think Jewish people need to stop calling your self the chosen ones and realize you are not special and just like the rest of us. As unless you do you will spend your future at war with someone somewhere in the world.@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763

[@muhammadsharif7990]

Regardless of any race "contribution" to the society, NO ONE has the right to call a race "superior" to other! That should be the fundamental morality of any HUMAN!!! Stop trying to distract from this principle!

[@jimhitchcock2383]

Churchill was heavily interested in the maintaince of Britan's Naval and world trade "empire". I note there was no mention in your post about the worlds 4 Naval checkpoints. Prior to the opening of the Suez and Panama Canals there were two. The straits of Singapore and Gibraltar. Churchill probably didn't want to call attention to Britan's interest in "controlling" lands on both sides of the Suez canal openings. He probably hoped the effect of Britan "helping" the Jews would "secure ' east side of the Suez opening to the Med..

[@aodhfinn]

I haven't read the book , but thank you for the presentation . I'm sure that you do , in some detail examine the root connection between the Jewish people and the lands of Judea and Galilee at least , and explain that the nation of Israel is possibly the oldest in the world , it's people's suffering almost complete obliteration after the Ben Kokhba revolt begun against Roman occupation in 132 Ad . The resultant depopulation didn't lead to a cultural or religious loss of identification with the ' chosen land ' . This perhaps is a point often missed by commentators regarding the current suffering of so many people , Palestinian, and Israeli today and recently .

[@jeromelobo2297]

If one goes by 2000 year old records - some touching on Fiction, other religious sects have them too, then it 'pulls the rug from under the feet of the colonials in North America, South America, Australia, NZ. Those lands belong to the NATIVES of those lands and NOT to Colonial Whites ! ?????????

[@ledpup]

Your understanding of this history is super messed up. Israel is only 75 years old. It is one of the newest nations. It was settled by Europeans. The people who had been living on that land were displaced. Prior to and during the European settlers turning up, starting from the about the turn of the 20th century, the land was controlled by Ottoman and then Britain. There isn't much else to it. Whether the European settlers used to live there or not (thousands of years ago) would be impossible to substantiate. The people who had already been living there may have been, for a very long time, but that's also effectively impossible to prove. Records don't go back that far, and there is no way to know if they were fabricated.

[@Mk-xe2qc]

​@@ledpupThere are, for example names Judea and Samaria, the Bible, the archeological artefacts and many-many other things. But for people of not Judeo-Christian culture there is "no proof"...

[@ledpup]

@@Mk-xe2qc I don't think you understand the argument. If we accept that everything in the Bible is true, and all the other evidence you mention is too, how can any particular European settler link their heritage to it without whatever evidence they present (some sort of document that has their family tree going back 2000 years perhaps?) not potentially being fabricated?

[@aodhfinn]

@@ledpup your ignoring ancient history and archaeology ..unless your in deliberate denial of it , or , both sources of knowledge are false

[@ttystikkrocks1042]

Wow. Churchill has always been presented to me as a heroic historical figure. I had my suspicions that he had a darker side but the realization that he was perhaps the single most responsible individual for the uncountable murders and incalculable suffering of the area over the past century is stunning. I've lost every shred of respect for the man.

[@supersurfer1]

All the western heroes are questionable. Real heroes are painted as villains and criminals as heroes.

[@marioceva7163]

Churchill was more a criminal than an hero. He push bombing german civilians iWWll knowing that was not usefull to win the war. He push rhe war.

[@anjelakewell9671]

Don’t believe everything until you do your own research and try to put yourself into the society of the day. It is fashionable to paint many of our great men in a bad light. It would be very interesting to also read Churchill’s own book ‘The Wilderness Years’ where he outlines his deep fears of wars being created unnecessarily to hide a much deeper and sinister agenda by the Zionists. Nothing is at it seems until you read every angle and every account. One of the very best documentaries I have ever watched is ‘Europe..The Last Battle’ it is eleven hours long and a very disturbing watch. Those whom you think were helping us had a very nefarious agenda indeed.

[@Thomas...191]

OK. There is good criticisms of him. But this book will be obviously sell the dark side and even exaggerate the possibility of his dark soul. I'd recommend a biography, which just follows his life in a non-bias way, and perhaps one that is bias towards him. Its about balance.

[@marioceva7163]

@@Thomas...191 most of biographies are not objetives. Propaganda for the Empire.

[@StephenS-2024]

Well done, Sir.

[@littlebubba6199]

It’s sad that there’s so many groups of people who are too cowardly to realize that there’s a legacy of protecting the holy land, the knights Templar rejected people in their journey to the holy land, and the holy land itself knowingly that it would be taken over by the caliphate if they let their guard down and it was also honorable to protect all the different ethnicities, traveling throughout and indigenous to the area even Thomas Jefferson, who is also being maligned these days by much special interest as they are trying to vilify Churchill what are these guys supposed to do just except the Muslim takeover in their day of things that many people rightfully hold sacred so we’re just supposed to let the caliphate take over or be a threat to the whole world like the Barbary pirates and enslaved people in their Arab KKK supremacy nonsense religion that’s a false religion than actually rewrite the Bible and disregard the gospel

[@lolesp1084]

Paul I'd like to thank you for this channel and this lesson.

[@BloggingTheology]

Alhamdulillah

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤

[@dalew801]

@@RussianFans-vn6cj Not true . . . it is a fraud just like Moo . . . Jesus said "I am the way the truth & the light" . . . he was God. Moo was merely a prophet . . . for an old tired Arab god, who was one of many.

[@waynemongo]

​@@BloggingTheologyremember the Luftwaffe bombed Warsaw before the RAF bombed German cities.

[@meoswald9131]

​@@RussianFans-vn6cj Never understood why every religion of lokal origins is pushing their agenda for the rest of the world as the only one and only right one and everyone has to obey them....?

[@frankfischer1281]

Mr. Tarique Ali is using 21st century standards to judge a 19th century man. Yes, Churchill was an imperialist. In Churchills’ time, most European leaders were imperialists.

[@Peter-ud9bx]

He's also pointing out things that are true that most people don't know. Also, many people in Churchill's own time disliked his attitudes and actions. What about the objections to the East India Company and ti slavery in the 18th and 19th centuries? What standards were they using?

[@RomeshSenewiratne-Alagaratnam]

A couple of facts of relevance: 1. Winston Churchill was the first vice-president of the racist and elitist Eugenics Education Society, founded by Charles Darwin's cousin Francis Galton and son Major Leonard Darwin. 2. The eugenics doctrines had profound influence on the treatment of dark-skinned people and indigenous people in all the British colonies. 3. Churchill, like the British Monarchs George v and VI, was a Freemason.

[@elfinia]

Not a crime to be a Freemason.

[@koosleroux9862]

This esteemed author should see how the African people messed up South Africa: Self-enrichment of the leaders, inefficiency, corruption and crime.

[@sibyllelugo447]

Thank you for your great content and interviews on your program. I've been following sometime.

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad you like them!

[@eliyahyahweh4266]

The capital city of Ethiopia, Addis Ababa, the best and longest road, the main street named after Winston Churchill!🏆 That speaks louder than what you trying to portray about Churchill. I think he was someone who were blessed 🙌 come on he had bitten Nazi and Musoluni 😮🏆👏

[@Rmbraun02]

The 160,000 Arabs remained in what became Israel are now almost 2 million Arab Israeli citizens with full rights . No racism.

[@dianazaharieva5293]

American native populations of many tribes like Kenia 30:22 now outnumber the figure from 200yrs ago. Can we conclude no ethnic clensing took place.. Hahaha

[@khalid2010ification]

Dear brother, could you devote a video to talk to us in some detail about the positions of Arab leaders regarding the plans related to the establishment of Isr ael?

[@Harley-ir4er]

It's astonishing how the British press and Media refuse to discuss the Balfour declaration that has put the Palastenians and the Jewish people on a 75 year collision course. Not a single Journalist. TV channel or newspapaer wants to discuss it.

[@kovie9162]

It's actually often brought up but usually just in passing because they realize that most people won't have the patience or interest in learning about the entire history in all of its details, and prefer to stick to their preferred narratives.

[@user-uz7dm6qn3y]

Being that "Palestinians" were only concocted in 1964, relegates your proposal to nothingness.

[@karlgreene2177]

How do you know being an American?

[@CarlinConnolly]

excellent point... how many conflicts are a direct result of arbitary lines drawn up by imperial powers to suit their own purposes... too many.

[@jimseltzer2002]

It is astonishing how you would make a statement with no basis in fact whatsoever, and declare it with zero proof.

[@desmondmccarthy6408]

I watched that interview with Piers Morgan and he acknowledged that Churchill was flawed, did some bad things. By no means did he portray Churchill as whiter than white as you are suggesting. He spoke to thex3nd world war leadership he provided and acknowledged that. And winning that War was indeed an heroic thing for the people of this country.

[@ilamilam9154]

Stalin defeated the Germany too, does it make him a good person? Unbelievable argument.

[@geofftoase3855]

As a figurehead he excelled. Unfortunately he fancied himself as a military strategist. Tens of thousands of British servicemen were sacrificed on the altar of his hubris.

[@leslie-annmills-gomez8763]

Well he wasn't great for black people so who exactly is he a hero to?

[@mjh5437]

@@leslie-annmills-gomez8763 If Britain and the Allies had lost WW2 to Germany,when the Nazis had finished exterminating the Jews they would have exterminated the entire black race too,so there`s that🤣😂🤣😁

[@user-yi4gm8ym3l]

David Irvine's books have great insight into Churchils funding during the wilderness years when he was not in parliment and his paymasters (handlers) , his alcoholism .And also his attempt to bomb germany with anthrax .A great insight and excellent read . especialy the abdication of the king and refusal to let anyone read the offer of peace from the NSDAP .

[@safpsy]

David Irving has been totally discredited as a historian. He is a known NAZI sympathizer and has had judicial judgements that found he manipulated/obscured or just plain lied to present the NSDAP in a good light.

[@gregsutton6258]

David Irvine is wrong, Churchill was without a seat in parliament for a very short time, lost his original seat and picked up a seat in a bye election not long after

[@user-yi4gm8ym3l]

@@gregsutton6258 oh dear was he also wrong about the alcoholic part and the anthrax or the refusal to let parliment read the suit for peace ?

[@user-yi4gm8ym3l]

@@gregsutton6258 Following the Tory electoral defeat in 1929, Churchill lost his seat and spent much of the next 11 years out of office, mainly writing and making speeches 1929 to 1939 is a decade how long do you think is a very long time in a political career vacation 🤣 Did you even read Irvines book ? In fact have you EVER READ A BOOK 🤣

[@user-yi4gm8ym3l]

@@gregsutton6258 Really ? Following the Tory electoral defeat in 1929, Churchill lost his seat and spent much of the next 11 years out of office, mainly writing and making speeches

[@nickgent9949]

I am a serious student of Churchill….not only was he a deep humanitarian but also a founder of the modern welfare state. When he became Prime Minister, in May 1940, he stood alone, not only against the Nazi threat, at a time when Europe was collapsing (the US did not come into the war until December 1941) but also within his own class who wanted to parley with Hitler. Our situation was nothing short of desperate. In case this is not enough to assuage his critics, they should have a look at the eulogies following his death in 1965. They could not be more laudatory and were highly moving. I’m going to quote an extract from Attlee’s tribute. He was Churchill’s deputy in the Coalition Government during the Second World War as well as his great political rival, Churchill losing to him in the 1945 General Election “.......I do not think everybody always recognised how tender- hearted he was. I can recall him with the tears rolling down his cheeks, talking of the horrible things perpetrated by the Nazis in Germany. I can recall, too, during the war his emotion on seeing a simple little English home wrecked by a bomb. Yes, my Lords, sympathy-and more than that: he went back, and immediately devised the War Damage Act. How characteristic! Sympathy did not stop with emotion; it turned into action......... Then I recall the long days through the war-the long days and long nights-in which his spirit never failed; and how often he lightened our labours by that vivid humour, those wonderful remarks he would make which absolutely dissolved us all in laughter, however tired we were......and I recall, too, as the most reverend Primate has said already, that when once the enemy were beaten he had full sympathy for them. He showed that after the Boer War, and he showed it again after the First World War. He had sympathy, an incredibly wide sympathy, for ordinary people all over the world.....He saw himself there as an instrument. As an instrument for what? For freedom, for human life against tyranny. None of us can ever forget how, through all those long years, he now and again spoke exactly the phrase that crystallised the feelings of the nation. My Lords, we have lost the greatest Englishman of our time-I think the greatest citizen of the world of our time. In the course of a long, long life, he has played many parts. We may all be proud to have lived with him and, above all, to have worked with him.....” There are too many examples of the perpetuation of time-honoured myths (often the fault of “copy and paste” writers masquerading as historians), built on the very shaky foundations of ignorance and prejudice and calculated to denigrate the Churchill legacy. It is high time that these myths are laid to rest. Detractors - please note. If anybody should be “judge and jury” of Churchill, it should be Attlee, the much-respected, long-serving Labour leader and Prime Minister (1945/51), who got to know Churchill so well during the war years. Churchill was a colossus in standing up, almost alone, to tyranny, he should therefore be judged a giant no matter what the age. It should always be remembered, though, that his greatness was combined with him being a deep humanitarian - that is why he was (and still is) respected and loved by so many and why I am a crusader in upholding his legacy.

[@amh9494]

Lloyd George was the PM who brought in the pension will before Churchill's time and i think that's clearly the beginning of welfare.

[@theonlymeaning]

@nickgent9949 Very, very beautifully written. Thank you.

[@Amidat]

He copied the "welfare state" from the Nazis

[@philpryor7524]

You are deluded, incorrect and should start again, seeking truth.

[@nickgent9949]

You are an ignoramus. Can I suggest you read Martin Gilbert, Roy Jenkins, Andrew Roberts and others. You are going against the grain of history. What is your reading list? I suspect that you are a woke leftie, who has no respect for history as you don’t want to be deluded by the truth.

[@noorsaadeh]

Brilliant as always! Vye vye vye Churchill! Thank you Paul for bringing our attention to such crucial information.

[@RussianFans-vn6cj]

It is my responsibility to aware every one Quran is the last book of God which revealed on prophet Muhammad saw quran is the only source of guidance in whole world quran will show you the right path quran also verify bible and torah and other scripture kindly once time you study whole quran and aware yourself from the aim of life and got success in long run ❤❤❤

[@-Ancalagon]

Jesus description of the "Jews" was entirely accurate.

[@catholicpog7183]

Most Christians are starting to wake up when it comes to Israeli influence.

[@AnnieBadger]

There are good people among them, that I have no doubt. But most are led and blinded by godless criminals

[@70AD-user45]

Yes, Jesus made a prophecy about the Synagogue of Satan that was prophecied in Revelation, 2,9 & 3,9. The prophecy was about fake Jews like the Ashkenazi Jews who converted to Talmudic Judaism in 740 AD.

[@Thoth_al_Khem]

Here is the kill count NOT including the Flood or Sodom and Gomorrah. God (figure) 2,476,633.....Satan? ONLY 10 so in John 8:44 Y;shua is ONLY talking ABOUT Yahweh. The 2 faced KILLER.....as E.Pluribus unum is really......OUT OF MANY (gods) ONE.

[@heythere4218]

​​​@@AnnieBadgerthe good people are less than 0.1 % 99% of them are hypocrites and liers

[@user-it4qv3xi4u]

Churchill like most humans was not 100% but his 75,% outshines most other leaders at their highest

[@joezingher4770]

At the moment that the first German soldier crossed the border into Poland, Germany was waging a war of aggression (a war crime) and was therefire outside the protection of the Geneva Conventions. This act and many more that followed released the Allies, including Great Britain, from any obligations imposed by Geneva. Or didn't you know that?

[@mohamadabukela1837]

Thank you brother for demonstrating excerpts of this amazing book and I wish you unravel Winston Churchill conspiracy and betrayal of his own countrymen when he standstill and concealed purposefully the terrorist attacks of murdering against English troops done by the Hagana of Israeli terrorists and even though he knew for sure that they slughter hundreds of British soldiers and officers in the land of Palestine. However, he chose to do nothing. He also had not raised a finger against these Hagana gangs when they sent two of their top criminals to Cairo in November 6th, 1944 to assisinate Lord Walter Guinness Moyn, the Minister of Colonial affairs of the Middle Eastand killed him and his driver in front of his house in Zamek Cairo. What a traitor to his people and nation!

[@littleprincesskamilia2852]

How about the stern group, haganah and stern bother were terrorists, however both of them were sitting on their asses while their families were being slaughtered in Europe. They were depending on British to something about it

[@abderrahman9043]

great highlight !!

[@KJVreaderFromINDIA]

In June 1967, the USS Liberty, an unarmed Navy technical research ship, was attacked by Israeli aircraft and motor torpedo boats in international waters off the coast of Egypt. The attack killed 34 and injured 171 Americans.

[@peterkilbridge6523]

​@@KJVreaderFromINDIATrue. The book is "Assault on the Liberty". After the attack, President LBJ did not protest to Israel or even tell his own country. Even now, this is taboo to even mention on TV. Now do you know who was 👉 chosen 👈 by G💮D to rule America?

[@Gaby-gyaba]

Churchill save Europe from.the Nazi

[@lancehilton8017]

Paul... I'm always amazed by the segment of society that feels the need to apologize for their great fortune... The reason that you have the freedom to pontificate openly on this platform is because German cities were decimated. Before you start quoting anti-colonialist foreigners, you should fact check their literature. For example. 1914 the Ottomans had completed a census, including Lebanon... also what he fails to mention in the passages you read is that the Muslims indigenous to the area were not Arab Muslims, they were Ottoman Muslims... yes, they were the predominant religion represented and their offspring still reside within Isreal today. Post 1918 Arab Muslims flooded British Manditory Palestine, they displaced and massacred indigenous Muslims, Jews, Christians, and Bedouins... they were later routed by the British, and even later, the Jews themselves with the aid of the indigenous Muslim population. One needs to be careful when quoting information from one-sided sources determined to diminish the greatness your society.... even if you agree with his leftist ideology.

[@marzymarrz5172]

I dont know if he was a hero, but given the choices available he was the right leader at the right time. I base this opinion mainly on his roll during WW2. A lesser known thing about bombing in WW2 is Naples, Italy. I read in a biography of Churchill that the allies bombed Naples Italy every day for one year. I realize the strategic importance of the Bay of Naples, I believe its a deep water port, but the impact on the non combatants was pretty horrible. If there was a hero in that war, in my opinion it was the Russian army. I would hate like hell to say anything good about Stalin, but Russia's importance to the VE day cannot be over estimated, in my opinion. What amazes me about Churchill is that he was an amazingly functional drunk. In that same bio I read that Churchill said he drank one bottle of champagne every day.

[@GardG4m3r]

​@@MartinJoyceUFOConspiracy OK brother the jews by themselves said they are killing the Palestinians and the jews betrayed France in ww1

[@mjh5437]

Speaking as an alcoholic I can say a bottle of champers every day wouldn`t even touch the sides if he was a real alkie lol

[@lakitawright6003]

Is that why WC starved millions of Indians during WWII?

[@sirfrozsomji3984]

He suffered from manic depression. He called it his "black dog"

[@user-iz1hd9si3m]

Hitler on the other hand was a teetotalling vegetarian, our image of those two men is wholly manufactured rather akin to fairground mirrors.

[@lindadee2053]

Unless I misheard, England and America didn't bomb Dresden until very late 1944 / early 1945. This was several years after Hitler ferociously bombed England in the so-called Battle of Britain. In other words, Hitler and Germany started everything, including WWII.

[@danielrutschman4618]

This is an excellent example of revisionist history, in which a relatively few historically accurate facts are mixed in with many unsupported allegations and much innuendo and inference to create a false narrative of history supporting a particular political ideology. Well done, Sir!

[@beth1979]

Revisionism is just taking another look at history focusing on the understanding that people of the past were capable of lies and propaganda. Just because it disagrees with your current perceptions of history and your race, doesn't make it automatically wrong.

[@3ehahn]

Rubbish!

[@larrybedouin2921]

🙄

[@unionofsa]

🙄

[@unionofsa]

😂😂😂Revisionism is stupid.

[@instruogroup]

Alhamdulillah. Much appreciated Paul Williams for the historical insights. Many of these things are not openly known. May Allah make us one in our families, communities and one body as an ummah. May Allah grant ease to the people of Palestine. Ameen.

[@Tom-fo5ce]

I believe Allah is a man-made fake being. I do not want to be part of something believers in a silly mythological figure want.

[@ntdisciple]

Galatians 5 10 I trust as to you in our Master that you will NOT consider OTHER BELIEFS, but that the one troubling you shall bear the judgment, whoever he may be. xref-2 Galatians 4 9 But now, knowing Elohim, but rather being known by Elohim, how do you turn again to the weak and poor principles to which you desire again to come under their bondage (note) xref-1 These were people who were before patterning pagan cultic practices and now came to faith in YHWH and are now known by YHWH and were turning back to the former pagan practices. Galatians 1 6 I am surprised at how soon you have turned to another good news, away from Messiah who has called you to grace.

[@r.p.vanloon6403]

I take it you haven't spoken with Hamas recently?

[@anonymousano3430]

This is a very one-sided talk. He quotes only what suits him but omits what does not.

[@Raelven]

I can't take one Punjabi writer's opinion as historical fact. The ME has a longer and more complex history, starting long before the British Empire meddled in it.

[@Charlie-ii5rr]

“The strong do what they can; the weak suffer what they must”. ~ Thucydides

[@marttiereeds3494]

The weak are not meant to suffer, you make it sound like suffering is their destiny, even the Bible doesn't agree with you

[@elbmw]

In the interests of fairness we should also recall Winston Churchill's secret fact finding mission to Cyprus in 1907, which upon his return to Britain wrote a secret memo to parliament ('Condition of Cyprus.' Memorandum by Winston Churchill) lambasting the colonial office for the maltreatment of the Cypriots and urging parliament to intervene. His motivation appears to be more about Britain's prestige than the plight of the Cypriots but it's well to know that it was so damning that the memo remained secret for 100 years. It can be found online at the National Archives (UK) if one wants to fact-check what I said.

[@MrFernandesb]

Churchill was a child molestor

[@sigmanfloyd7179]

~ "...his motive appears to be..." Can you prove that? If not, please keep your theories to yourself.

[@elbmw]

@@sigmanfloyd7179 Have you read the document? If not, please keep your ignorance to yourself.

[@davidwebber8028]

rather ironic that open borders in Europe has led to unfetter Muslim settling of swathes of countries. Where again the wishes of the existing inhabitants has been ignored and dismissed.

[@gordonflash8976]

ya great numpty, he just gave you the sorce of his comment which contains the proof. It is nonsecical to then ask him to prove it. To make any sence you need to read it and fact check it in order to counter his claim. What you have done is to ask for proof of the proof when that is as good as it ever gets in the way of proof even in court. Historical documents, first hand accounts, eyewithness reports. History as you know it is build on such that may not even be that good. @@sigmanfloyd7179

[@danabennett4098]

From 21:07 to - 22:32 - LISTEN TO THIS STATEMENT - of the reason to just ignore the Palestinians' longtime (millenia) residence in THEIR land.

[@user-lh2og2ib1i]

In 1910 Churchill tried to pass a bill allowing sterilisation of the British poor. The man was a full blown eugenisist

[@petermcinerney6418]

Conveniently, you have obviously overlooked the many Zeppelin bombing raids of British cities during the First World War

[@user-zc5gd8ki3u]

Say what you like, from the comfort of your armchair. When you are surrounded by murderous neighbours, all the nuances of your history disappear rapidly up your rear end.

[@yasim9435]

Just read again the quote at 19:22. The country needs capital and POPULATION and Jews could provide both” - confirm that the areas that Jews purchased was not populated .

[@rimabadalians3517]

Thank you. The information is an eye opener.

[@warrenpaine]

"History will be kind to me, for I intend to write it." ----Winston Churchill.

[@_North_European_Union]

"Islam to a man is like rabies to a dog" - Churchill Got to love him!

[@GardG4m3r]

​@@_North_European_Union oh yeah you Europeans are cowards and the most criminals in the world😂

[@ledpup]

​@@_North_European_Union yeah, he's a tidy little racist.

[@Ilyaz3207]

😂

[@Ilyaz3207]

Love him or hate him, he's now where he belongs trust me

[@robertcampomizzi7988]

6:05 Why was the Ottomon Empire good but the Britiah Empire bad? Did the Ottomons ever consider giving a state/self rule? I didnt think so.

[@Marya2476]

The Ottomans respected private property and did not seek to displace them with a Turkish population…

[@youtubeaccount3230]

Bruh the british were like a snake devilsh

[@robertcampomizzi7988]

@Marya2476 the jews came in and bought property legallly in the 1880's... in the 1900's BEFORE The British arrived there were already problems. So there is that.

[@georgeh8937]

@@Marya2476 oh marya. must you invent excuses for islam? the reality was the palestine region was not important to the turkish rulers. it was pretty desolate. palestine had 200,000 people. the empire had 20,000,000 people. so a hundred times more.

[@dianazaharieva5293]

Ottomans ruled not on basis of other nations but religious confessions. And Yes they were all independent from sultan and islam. Just taxed additionally if no muslim

[@rhodaberger7262]

It isn't because of Jewish mistreatment of Arabs that relations between them have changed. And let us not forget that Jews have always had to live as Dimmi (second class citizens) in Muslim lands. It is because a Jewish nation was established within the Muslim Umma that the rage erupted.

[@watchfulrasputin]

No. It''s the fact that Palestinian Lands were confiscated from ordinary Palestinians for the benefit of European Jewish invaders who have treated them disgracefully throughout the past 75 years. Palestinians are actual 2nd class Citizens in israel itself while they are little more than Internees in the lands of the West Bank and Gaza.

[@sabrinashahab795]

Jewish were upper class in the middle east . Unlike the west , they were very well treated in the Muslim countries . It was Eastern European and Western Jews who created Israel , not the Arab Jews . It was not a question of a Jewish state , but question of displacement and ethnic cleansing . If it is racist to have a white and Christian state , why should be there an artificially created Jewish state . What West dont do in thier own countries , why do they support that in Israel .

[@rhodaberger7262]

@@sabrinashahab795 In Muslim tradition, non-believers are considered lower class - their status is Dimmi and they have to pay a special tax. Israel is mostly composed of Jews from Arabic countries who were ethnically cleansed (kicked out) in 1

[@rhodaberger7262]

@@sabrinashahab795 In Muslim tradition, non-believers are considered lower class - their status is Dimmi and they have to pay a special tax (jizzya). Israel is mostly composed of Jews from Arabic countries who were ethnically cleansed (kicked out) of Arab countries in 1947. It is undeniable that Muslim countries who ethnically cleansed their Jews are now ethnically cleansing their Christian populations even as Muslims migrate to traditionally non-Muslim countries in the west. Israel is mostly composed of Jews from Arabic countries and also has a 20% Arabic population as well as a minority of European Jews. Israel has a long history of being a Judean country - the word "Jew" comes from Judean. Many European Jews, who were persecuted for centuries for being Judeans went back to Judea after the holocaust. Dig anywhere in Israel and you will find archeological remnants of Jewish history. And why do Muslims feel that they have a right to create a large and vocal presence in the west but there can't be a single, tiny, country in the middle east that is not Muslim even when that country affords equal rights (not second class citizenship and special taxes) to its Arab citizens?

[@davidwalden2887]

Churchill the 1st Sea Lord and Kitchener chief of the army during WW1, almost as a team were well on their way to being joint Dicktators of the UK. Churchill was the creator of the Gallipoli invasion of Turkey, almost all of Australia's solders in this campaign including my father hated Churchill all his life.

[@lovepeace4065]

Winston Churchill was indirectly responsible for the deaths of over 3Million bengals , did you know that when he stopped the ships taking food !!!

[@HangTheTraitors157]

Yeah, sure he was.... Churchill evil blah blah blah.............

[@kendiamond8722]

Churchill was a fascist English establishment bastard.

[@joselugo4536]

Not to mention his very well devised plan of drenching Anthrax on German cities as to render those places unhabitable for many decades around! Not even Stalin was able yo thought that brilliant idea!

[@mirali3405]

Yes it is remembered by Bengalis as a major catastrophe as Bengal experienced unimaginable sufferings of people.

[@calioumarx4289]

Winston churchil was responsible 4 millions people genocide Bengal people

[@peretzo]

How much self-hatred could a privileged Westerner have. It’s always amazing to me. Britain (under Churchill) stood alone against Hitler and kept Western Europe free.

[@cheds1]

All backed by the Vatican

[@peetsnort]

Time has taught me that you never know whats in the heart of people. But their actions and achievements will be the litmus test

[@BruceMullen-iv8hx]

Churchill seems to have been influenced by his American Jewish mother, Jenny Jerome , the daughter of a very wealthy Jewish New Yorker.

[@DevorahC]

so then by Jewish law, Churchill would have been considered Jewish.

[@susanpotter9720]

Tbh people will make up their own minds and remember him the way they chose he was a man of his day,.like so many before and after him from all nations and faiths.let he who has no sin cast the first stone.or better still don't throw stones in glass houses..

[@superlinux]

The title of the book is bold and blunt saying (his crimes). that's seriously shocking. It's a public accusation.

[@user-fq2mb8wf9d]

Thank you so very much Especially at this time and everyone needs it and needs the support and the true what’s going on is a deserters but we love the story of the History and thank you so very much and keep it up and you are the here’s to mantids

[@abdelghanibeneddine]

Dr. Paul, I am an Arab Muslim. I have a request, which is that I would like to support the content that your channel publishes with a correct Arabic translation. If you have people who are fluent in Arabic and English so that we can understand the content, there are Arabs who follow your blessed channel... May God protect you and reward you with goodness and grant you a good life in this world and in Paradise. Satisfaction in the afterlife.

[@nijadbahnam9859]

GB played a double game promising a nation for both sides in same area and when shit hit the fans they bailed out saying it isn't their problem.

[@georgeh8937]

hey nijad. rather than blame the brits ask why didn't the arabs in the mandate start planning for statehood? after twenty years was any arab group ready to form a government? quote "In December 1920, Palestinian Arabs at a congress in Haifa established an executive committee (known as the Arab Executive) to act as the representative of the Arabs. It was never formally recognized by the British and was dissolved in 1934. However, the platform of the Haifa congress, which set out the position that Palestine was an autonomous Arab entity and totally rejected any rights of the Jews to Palestine, remained the basic policy of the Palestinian Arabs until 1948." seems like arabs wasted decades trying to keep jews out of the region rather than build a functioning government.

[@Fiachraraven]

Thoroughly fascinating, have subscribed. You are a gifted commentator. Thank you.

[@BloggingTheology]

Alhamdulillah

[@user-qg5zc1kf4f]

​@@BloggingTheologywhy didnt you talk about ur boy Mohammeds war crimes against the Jews at Medina. Mohammed was a scumbag who took sex slaves from any ppl he could overpowering.

[@beenishm3205]

Sir, just wanted to clarify because you mentioned Tariq Ramadan several times - did you mean Tariq Ali throughout?

[@BloggingTheology]

oops!

[@user-lh2og2ib1i]

HG Wells also a eugenisist agreed with many of Churchill's views although drew the line at sterilising the British poor.

[@jeanelizabethmarybowyerdem4181]

Very true. This goes back well before the creation of Israel. The Sykes Picot 1916 agreement ( division of the land to control the wealth of the land) must be included.

[@maymunahsydow6276]

Wow very very interesting Paul, tx for the History lesson! Precious that we know this! What is so amazing is the many myths that managed to survive so many years! Time for all to recealed! Tx so much for ur enormous contribution so much much appreciated! On random opening of the Quran i came across a Surah LIX titled Hashr or the Gathering or babishment! Should make for some interesting reading! Tx Paul and God Bless!

[@elgatofelix8917]

Wow no comments yet except for one? Last time I was this early, Israel was still Palestine.

[@nathanearle516]

Battle of Britain=1940 Bombing of Dresden=1945 It is a vicious slander to suggest that Britain targeted German cities first.

[@sinjersable]

Russia was instrumental in targeting Dresden. The plan was to demoralize a defeated Germany to expand their sphere of influence over Eastern Europe and create the USSR.

[@sandraward1371]

And thank you. This was educational and interesting.