【TVPP】Orange Caramel - Because Of You (Kelly Clarkson), 오렌지 캬라멜 - Because Of You @ ICON Live

[@JustNatax3]

Raina always seemed like the best singer of them. She has quite a lot more body to her voice in comparison. So nice.

[@TheAfam1234]

That's why shes the main vocal

[@KarlDeux]

Raina is one of the best vocalists of K-pop. She is as good as Taeyeon for instance.

[@igotcheesewannabemypeppero3762]

Oh shit, i didn't expected Nana to have the huskier voice out of them all.

[@ambiebaby9001]

For sure. She never got to exhibit her true skill in a.s but in some of orange caramels songs she got a little spotlight

[@gerriie15]

Nana's voice sounds so much better live

[@Yosnier_]

Raina has the strongest voice, holy shit.

[@gyuul_hyuun]

i'm 12 years late into this but god damn i feel so lucky to have found this on my yt recommendation page :)

[@버키-y7b]

역시 셋이 노래도 잘 부르고 대박난 이유가 있지

[@KPOP4LIFE247]

8 years later AMAZING HOT FIRE!!!!

[@KarlDeux]

Orange Caramel, not legends as SNSD but in our hearts forever anyway.

[@leonardoinhoqui]

I prefer caramel orange

[@Lia2803]

their accents are so funny and cute hahah

[@Rap_Kuma]

레이나 음색보소....어후....

[@BobGolob]

Great performance! Awesome! Well done, girls !!!

[@robielf3596]

This is my first time listening to this song and now i really like this song omg its so freaking good and their voice sounds good

[@seiryu84]

I'm finally just hearing this cover for the first time and my jaw's on the floor. I'm seeing a side of these girls that I had no idea even existed. Especially Raina, her voice is so powerful.

[@아일린-q3g]

por ellas entré en el mundo del kpop y las extraño mucho como grupo :(

[@sarwendah1]

They are amazing and the.guitarist too especially towards the end of the song.

[@emilyyuan2971]

This year is the afterschool 13rd anniversary. I miss them

[@RRrr-tu9mu]

2020? YES ME. I MISS AFTER SCHOOL, SO MUCH. SOOOO MUCCCCH!!!!! 😢😢😢😢😢❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@chris-qj4pi]

So pretty and talented 🥺😍

[@英雄本色周潤發]

라이브되고 비쥬얼되고 춤되고 오캬 쵝오

[@권민경-m1l]

나나님너무이쁘시다

[@파인애플주스-e4y]

레이나❣

[@luvlyzzie]

Esta canción es muy hermosa,las voces de las chicas se oyen muy bien y muy hermosas,son muy talentosas. Las amo mucho chicas

[@deren3798]

*Si.*

[@luvlyzzie]

@@deren3798 hOla

[@luvlyzzie]

Weon, este comentario me da mucho cringe JJAJAJAJA

[@deren3798]

@@luvlyzzie Jajs,,pq?, Si está bn-- 🕴.

[@user-xc4lz3eg4z]

Vale

[@Vagnertransmetro]

Oh!!My god!!!! Beautiful,wonderful,crazy!!! rsrsrs Maravilhosa interpretação ( Brazil ) rsrsrs

[@khaledqaraman]

I will not make The same mistakes that you did I will not let myself Cause my heart so much misery I will not break The way you did, you fell so hard I've learned the hard way To never let it get that far Because of you I never stray too far from the sidewalk Because of you I learned to play on the safe side so I don't get hurt Because of you I find it hard to trust not only me, but everyone around me Because of you I am afraid I lose my way And it's not too long before you point it out I cannot cry Because I know that's weakness in your eyes I'm forced to fake A smile, a laugh everyday of my life My heart can't possibly break When it wasn't even whole to start with Because of you I never stray too far from the sidewalk Because of you I learned to play on the safe side so I don't get hurt Because of you I find it hard to trust not only me, but everyone around me Because of you I am afraid I watched you die I heard you cry every night in your sleep I was so young You should have known Better than to lean on me You never thought of anyone else You just saw your pain And now I cry in the middle of the night For the same damn thing Because of you I never stray too far from the sidewalk Because of you I learned to play on the safe side so I don't get hurt Because of you I try my hardest just to forget everything Because of you I don't know how to let anyone else in Because of you I'm ashamed of my life Because it's empty Because of you I am afraid Because of you Because of you

[@sisca.d]

wow they're awesome! wanna them comeback soon! 🙆💖💖💖👏👏👏

[@xerohmega795]

they're coming, dont you worry.

[@gns-vo4uh]

멈출수가없네...

[@vitosebastianargotemontero898]

Raina

[@aleynaylmaz7181]

Raina seni çok seviyorum çok tatlısın bu arada ben Türk'üm (TÜRKİYE)

[@kgoh9760]

Raina you 👍

[@andckkjkjkjkjk]

나나 영어로 노래 부르는거 왤케 귀엽지..? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@AdamFJH]

Happy Kahi day and merry Christmas everybody #HappyKahiDay #Happy_Kahi_Day #HappyChristmas #HappyChristimas2022 #MerryChristmas #MerryChristmas2022

[@AdamFJH]

Happy Kahi day and Merry Christmas everybody :D #Happy_Kahi_Day #HappyKahiDay #HappyChristmas #Happy_Xmas

[@javieralmagro2691]

i like the song because of you

[@ayleenj2665]

omg how i love this song❤️ and their voices :( ❤️

[@루시아-z9r]

2024년입니다 레이나님 덕에 좋은기억 떠올리고 갑니다~ ❤

[@andrewrudenko7245]

Волшебные девушки! 🌟🌟🌟🍊🍬👍 Навсегда!

[@맨챔우-q5r]

2024년에도 듣는다

[@푸하하곰-q7h]

세바퀴에서 김구라, 조형기가 감동받았다는 레이나의 노래~~

[@AdamFJH]

Happy Kahi day and merry Christmas everybody #HappyKahiDay #Happy_Kahi_Day #HappyChristmas #HappyChristimas2021 #MerryChristmas #MerryChristmas2021 #AfterSchool #OrangeCaramel #Pledis #Kpop

[@rodrigojeske1857]

Raina 😯😯😯😯

[@mariajosemunozgarcia5946]

cachetona te amo ❤ Raina

[@pedrorey7943]

Lizzy 💝😍❤️

[@paulcastillo5435]

#Raina is super voice~~ (o^_^o)

[@colinfun]

I am curious if anyone can tell me why is the "d" at the end of most of her words so hard for Raina in particular to vocalize? I totally understand how hard it must be to sing in English for them overall and they really do give so much effort, but that particular incident seems more noticeable to me than the others.

[@flashkims]

나나 분위기 그윽하네 . 아름다워

[@sheilarebeca6295]

i don't know that Lizzy can singing well too..

[@nah6148]

You should use “I didn’t”

[@antoncutie]

i think she is a lead vocalist

[@witthawinkrachonsuk7396]

Miss U

[@권민경-m1l]

YG 블랙핑크 리사님, JYP 트와이스 모모님, 켈리클락슨 내한버전으로도 봐보고싶다🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@장학사]

외모 깡패 가창력 깡패 다시 나오면 아이돌 씹어먹음 지존 레이나

[@flashkims]

실력과 뽕삘과 충공깽과 외모를 두루 갖춘 걸그룹

[@femaleg4l546]

Imiss afterachool

[@rodrigojeske1857]

Elas cantam muito bem.

[@АлександрЗамотай-з9л]

Привет прекрасные девчата с красивым голосом всех благ вам желаю удачи. 🤩🤩🤩🤩🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🙏😎

[@karlkyle3449]

I’m surprise u guys doing well

[@ezko02]

Tres para llevar por favor.

[@amazonz8590]

Who is the one in the far right with long reddish hair that's down like nana's? Her English is the best

[@bohyechoi1462]

myzzio Her name is Lizzy

[@TheAlexR96]

myzzio from left to right: Raina, Nana and Lizzy

[@mikeike83]

Yeah, that's Lizzy. she was taught much English and its pronunciation when she was younger.

[@hexaciousjinx6923]

She's so under rated

[@Jailma_Lima]

parece 3 bonecas ....

[@kimble90126]

Wow

[@hippogriff4793]

2021 anyone??

[@phantasm402]

dam Raina like Beyonce from Destiny's child. trying to one up the others

[@Theyook]

Hermoso

[@hitoshishinsou1034]

NANA

[@t07281234]

最左邊那位黑溜溜小姐，唱的最好聽

[@Boguchany]

Супер!!! ))))

[@ludwigwittgenstein9243]

멀었다

[@willy1988]

Can’t even make it 😓😓😓

[@KoujiIsAmazing]

Bee coge ov u!

[@leonite934]

Nana in blonde?

[@turkishrene1007]

Raina Hyerin _INRI > LIZZY -Rosie , Nana Ana Rainbow !

[@turkishrene1007]

When I was a Baby to my first years anyone who get near me I blinded the eye ! Including cousins I was that fierce so unimaginable when I was Growing , all destroyed in my paths!

[@권민경-m1l]

....

[@turkishrene1007]

Because of me How terribly devastated are You Raina ! Please My Love ask for Love medicines Help from China Japan also to cure your Love problems !

[@methane2966]

whos bette filipino or korean

[@turkishrene1007]

If Atilla is born with a Blood on his fist m the scourge of God ! I was Born with Skins all over my Body and Head coverings aside from thal is secret !

[@turkishrene1007]

Before the americans pulled out their Nuke Bases in Phillipines , I passed by in Ulongapo in the Barcluds called Black Jungle Territories , There I drank with my 2 Brothers in Blood Beers with 2 ladies from Ulongapo our Host in the City paying every Bill for welcome for us ! We drank and smoke cigarettes Phillip Morris and Marlboro with Black americans ! When we came out I met the White spirited commander since Birth you because Blak Jungle versus white territories is Hot , so the White powerfully spirited Navy Officer immediately challenged us , among my brothers I am the most spirited even more so than My Father ! we collided spiritual warfare began split seconds automatic , Firirng ancestral wars , since then The americans Pulled out their Nuke Bases ! anything could have happened!

[@girlcrazy7]

elite vocal talent. puts Kelly Clarkson to shame. they are also cute hugs and squeeze adorable.

[@z0mbjes]

Really man?

[@sammy5942]

"Puts kelly clarkson to shame" chill g it's good but no where near the original

[@Erik-xe6oz]

I am not agree, but I don't want to compare it to Kelly Clarkson. Orange Caramel did great tho

[@turkishrene1007]

Only Girls cousins Sister of Mine can carry me when I was a Baby ! You know they carry me at the Back with traditional woven clothes !

[@hohoho7078]

리지 나나는 답이없다 음정도 안맞으면 어떡해 가수가ㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 코러스 언니들이 혼자 불러도 더 잘할듯; 그와중에 레이나 없었으면 총체적으로...

[@turkishrene1007]

Simply TargeT is the Most powerful Family Units contest worldwide ! coz these are the Persons Headquarters Human Body Carriers of ancestral forces commands ! I was just a child at 3 years young O knew these ! At 2 Years Young I see ancestors Ghost and learned to commands on both sides of equations I made them to war to develop my top secret silence wars of hearts and minds commands ! at 4 ancestral commands who sided with me top secretly Programmed me undetectable , Then Brainwashed completely to begin again simply impossible to detect !

[@methane2966]

mother trucking accents hahahhaha

[@권민경-m1l]

가창력은 ㅈ박았네ㅋㅋ

[@권선비-v3p]

리지 눈에 웬 털이 저리길게 났어 귀에 털나는 이모증하고 비슷하게 안모증 같네...

[@turkishrene1007]

who Taught you this song Raina? You Know Because of Me all civilizations all time war programs of ancestral super divine forces disintegrated since my childhood coz I must to stand to my Ifguao responsiblities global appointments commands eversince Our great Mother Empress Godez ! All Ancestral Organizations treaties alliances disintegrated Raina ! I mean it!

[@turkishrene1007]

Atok Kelly from Millsite in between is Where I lived in a Gold House made by The Gold mIning american Corporation .. Kelly > Clark airbase Jets of USA Airport U know where the Atomic Nomber and jets Lifted ? Clark is the most powerful airbase of USA Jets since then of the Airforce , the Navy is in Ulongapo Zambales > on the Beaches 3-4 kilometers since Spain inhabited thus far , With USA the same compass ! Only the Gold Mines about hundred Kilometer Inland is Coto Zambales the Gold Mines Hearts and minds Reliigious commands of the Navy Backing Holy Missions ancestral forces ! I lived there central House of Eden sorrounds with Fruits , There I received american ancestral Hearts and minds commandments , I was 7 , There Holy Mary Lived to defend me in my dreams Like she is the white Lady appertained by Movies !

[@turkishrene1007]

There on the Gold House the american 2 Jet Global Patrols Passed overhead above the Gold House !

[@gloriatep8156]

The vocal is so poor... Sorry

[@femaleg4l546]

Imiss afterachool

[@femaleg4l546]

Imiss afterachool