Twelve & Clara | Immortality is everyone else dying (8x01-9x10)

[@caomhan84]

I've watched the show since 2005. When the Ponds left, I was thinking that the show would find it tough to find a better companion. Boy was I wrong. Clara arrived with those big eyes and that smile and that spunk, and it was over within the first 20 minutes. I was a lost cause, down for the count. And now, 3 series later...damn am I gonna miss her. Whoever follows her will have huge shoes to fill. The show is about change, sure, and I'll probably like the new companion just fine. But they won't be Clara. No one ever will be quite like her.

[@BrandonB...]

Good summary. She had a bit of a cult following but I think a lot of people felt exactly the same way.

[@itztrixim]

I had a lot to catch up on after the ponds departed, asoon as I saw clara's death I froze with my jaw dropping to ground and just having that really deep cold chill going through me. I was Constantly tell my self " No... no.. no, your screwing with me, this can't be real no I don't believe it" It sounds stupid but I cried for weeks because... Seeing Everything she did with doctor through time and space and then suddenly see her in pure agony and pain, seeing her breath out the black smoke I had to turn away and I still have to to this day. She brought so much so the franchise in my opinion that I don't think anyone else could do. it hurt so much knowing she wouldn't come back. When I saw the episode where the doctor now has no memory of her whatsoever it completely broke me down and I couldn't continue watching doctor who after that also knowing the fact that she remembers everything and he doesn't remember a single thing they did together in all those years I just couldn't take it so I hope they reunite again and possibly be the doctor and his clara in the tardis again. I'd prefer if she was the companion for every single series to cone until it ends but that's not gonna happen. Sounds ridiculous I know but ever since she showed up I change inside and she helped me open up I a way that I thought wasn't possible and I'm a better man today than I was before and I'm so greatful for that. It will never be the same without clara, it's gonna be hard watching the next series but no one can replace her, my favourite companion out of the lot and always will be no matter what... "My Clara" Sorry for it being to long, this is pretty much the only place I cam share my opinion with people who feel the same way. "Clara, My Clara... The Impossible Girl" Always and forever!:)

[@TragGaming]

once she gets in your head... she never leaves.

[@tomthx5804]

I had the same response. Then, I discovered bacon, and all was well again.

[@theimpossiblegirl4091]

I thought exactly the same thing about Clara but i was wrong and i learn to love her! and now she's gone forever just like they friendship! 😘😍😍😘😍😍😍😍😘😘😍😍😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭

[@lordpikazard2330]

She was born to save the Doctor. She reversed the polarity on the neural blocker not out of selfishness to save her own memories, but to stop the doctor from going too far, to end his grief of losing her, the misery of life without her, to save him. Even in her final heartbeat of life she was saving her Doctor.

[@ZemplinTemplar]

"How many have you lost ? How many Claras ?" - Ouch ! Ashildr loves her brutal honesty, I'll give her that ! :-) Nicely made video. ;-)

[@clarasunshine8189]

1st song = got chills 2nd = got chills and tears 3rd = literally killed me YOU ARE A GOD

[@bean6388]

By the second song I was in tears, by the third I was full on sobbing.

[@tomthx5804]

By the fourth, I realized it was incredibly dumb to be crying over a TV show.

[@TheGaroStudios]

Blimey this was amazing !

[@greysfan]

Reliving it in 2020. I love Clara and the Doctor. Her and Twelve in particular was just so good. She's my favourite companion by far. Love this video ❤️ The song changes in this video too 🥺🥺

[@greysfan]

I still get chills every single time i watch this. Just love it so much 💛

[@uniquewaterlily]

bloody hell my heart is already broken after episode 10, and i didn't want anything to remind me of clara's death, but i couldn't resist the tempation when i found this... right from the start i've started to think that this is a video that's gonna leave me speechless with every second of the next melody i was becoming sadder and sadder, and admiring your work more and more but then the third song started to play ... my god, i literally burst into tears and died cause 'Wings' is one of my favourite songs and it suits doctor and clara so sooooo well i can't even think of anything else now this is so heart-breaking !!! how am i supposed to be okay after all of this???

[@tomthx5804]

How Can I live When a TV show is my life It is kinda dumb isn't it?

[@margotrobbiereputation2870]

Shut up, Doctor Who is a really good show at getting you attached to a character and tugging on the heartstrings once he/she leave.

[@joseenoel7142]

11th/12th & Clara was and still is a really beautiful love story 💗. Whouffle for life.

[@partypants94]

this is like the most beautiful 12&Clara video I'ver ever seen. Amazing job

[@kurisutori6186]

I loved how you used that line " How many have you lost how may claras?" And used all the other companions faces genius!!!!

[@legionstark1533]

Immortality isn't living forever that's not what it feels like. Immortality is everybody else dying

[@BudgiesMi]

so... you broke me like literally this my dear is fkn perfect and stunning and let me not even mention; heartbreaking

[@ItalianRory]

I don't have the words to describe how beautiful this video is, or their relationship, or Clara's character. I can only thank you for making this :')

[@deerinthewoods]

I'm furiously sniffling and helplessly crying. I don't know about MY Doctor, but Clara was MY companion, for a very long time, for so many reasons. Impossible girl. Thank you for such a beautiful tribute to her. Just... thank you

[@Estaaaas]

WOW! this was totally stunning:) i really loved how the story of clara ended, it was proper end and she definitely deserved proper ending, she was awesome companion, even if i didnt like her in the beginning, mainly with eleven (probably just because i couldn't get over amy) but with twelve, she was just awesome! and you made awesome tribute to their journey:) congrats :)

[@erykah194]

okay seriously you have ripped my heart out, stomped on it, then stabbed me in the face. repeatedly. and still i watch because this is so lovely!

[@CursedBloodlines]

TOUT CA C'EST DE TA FAUTE!! C'EST DE TE FAUTE SI JE SUIS ACCRO A CES DEUX LA ET QUE JE SUIS TROP TRISTE PAR SA MORT, JE NE REGARDE MEME PAS DUH xD olalal que bella rose!! c'est splendide ce que tu nous as fais la!! comment arrives tu a faire de tels masterpiece en si peu de temps ? reste forte

[@xXdreamer4evaXx]

okay so this hurt

[@manga-monkey]

This floored me. By the second song, it had grabbed my heard and crushed it. Such a beautiful tribute.

[@sourpickles3423]

This is the most beautiful piece of art I've ever seen, I go to a high school for media criticism and video/photo tech stuff, creative writing, and I'm also a huge fan of Doctor Who. Clara Oswald is my favorite companion, I've seen many videos on KZbin of saying goo bye to Clara, or the Clara & 12, Clara & 11, and this is my goodness, the most amazing video, I have ever seen of doctor who, pure genius. I love the ending the most, Clara's last sentence, because she just got done with her last episode. Which I'm just going to pretend like didn't happened. Anyway, just wanted to applaued you on this video that you made, I added it to my Doctor Who playlist. 😊

[@deanmoon5560]

I watching this for a billion time, and I can't stop. This is so beautiful, emotional and cute. When I watch this, I wanna cry, really. You give me all the atmosphere of Whouffaldi. I'm your fan now!

[@abialston8476]

This is freaking amazing. I miss Clara so much😭

[@boredsleepycranky]

ROSE WHY WOULD U DO THIS TO ME? i'm still recovering and now i'm shattered all over again :( how you blended all three of those songs..each one portraying a different set of emotions..and all those beautiful parallels!!! i'm a mess when it comes to parallels and you found so many amazing ones :O pls don't stop with the 12/clara masterpieces..they are all seriously so DIVINE and emotional

[@jessierice2047]

Oh. My. God...this made me cry so hard! Brilliantly done!!! Farewell my impossible girl!!! 💙💙

[@lifexintechnicolour]

i can't even okay? like i was okay, then you are a memory started to play and i started to cry AGAIN, it's 1.22am and i want to sleep but now, i'm sobbing like a child who just dropped their ice cream or something. then wings started to play and you think, OH a happy song! NO NOT A HAPPY SONG IN THIS CASE, everything is NOT HAPPY AT ALL. i am so sad right now but this is beautiful and incredibly done and incredibly dited and beautiful, it's everything and i am not okay. you made me feel things, why would you do such a thing?

[@JubJubBirdProduction]

I love that flower-TARDIS so much.

[@MobsPlay]

Don't have words to describe is so... is so beautiful I felt so many emotions. Thank U for the astonishing work!!! really really thank U

[@mblaqminoz]

What the hell rose..your editing is such a beauty you gave me feelz when I don't even watch the show. stunning ma cheri * ____ *!

[@soph2816]

Thank you. I was in hysterics for absolutely ages, but those words at the end really helped me get through. So, thank you.

[@cece_mich]

I have no words.... This is perfect.

[@LadyMagiccc]

god this is so freaking beautiful

[@bellascoles1821]

This is just.. beautiful. I love how you did 3 songs, slowly building up like OMG

[@isabelle113711]

Thank you. Even this broke my heart into million pieces, it was definitely worth watching. Thanks.

[@kashmirkreationsp4945]

You have broken me down into tears after over 4 weeks of mourning after Face The Raven, you have re-broken my hearts and I thank you for successfully forcing me to regenerate

[@iwillcry]

Rest in peace our impossible girl 💔❤️ I will really miss her, and thank you for this beautiful video!

[@Tess1061]

-rips my heart from my chest cavity* TAKE IT!!! JUST TAKE IT!!!! I DIDNT NEED IT ANYWAY!!!!! -falls on ground in fetal position and sobs*

[@Tess1061]

+Tess1061 P.S. I need to know the name of the song with the violin. You know the part that plays during the ridiculous painful montage of clips about the Doctor losing people.

[@rebeccawalker519]

Hi read the song is you are a memory by message to bears and the album is called Maps :)

[@tomthx5804]

You don't need a heart if you have bacon.

[@karenzhen3530]

This deserves more views

[@emilyduda1619]

I'm desperate to know who sings the last song!

[@ladycopine]

Okay I'm dead now. I was eating food and now I'm sobbing with food in my mouth X'D

[@ladycopine]

***** haha thanks...!

[@Luvcatz88]

+ladycopine , omg same thing happened to me. I was eating out of a bag of Froot loops and... now... T_T

[@adama5742]

+Luvcatz88 I don't eat froot lopps much anymore but my food becomes soggy nonetheless... damn onion ninjas...

[@tomthx5804]

I was eating dirt, but then I realized you should not do that.

[@JS-ri2vy]

This was beautifully done..you have captured the essence of their relationship perfectly and you've shown how legendary this pairing is..oh how I miss them, my heart!

[@bluelikeatardis]

I was like "Oh my God I'm gonna cry" and then the last song came and ifjsdsofkosdj. This is sooooooooo beautiful!

[@deathbystick1]

Truly beautiful one of the best I have ever seen, well done Rose. You make excellent work, thank you.

[@cait812]

The show really did foreshadow her death "she'll blow away like smoke"

[@samsgeekspace]

This is gorgeous so well done and now I'm crying all the tears

[@lolamagenta]

A beautiful tribute to one of my favorite companions. Well done :)

[@superwholockdcmarvel6567]

I AM CRYING BUT THANK YOU FOR MAKING THIS VIDEO YOU ARE AMAZING AND SHOULD MAKE MORE

[@Cycyunique16]

this is so beautiful. I just wanted you to know that despite all my sobs and tears.

[@athenapallas7686]

OHMYGOD this is so amazing, i think this vid eventually made me a Whoffaldi shipper. THANK YOU FOR THIS VID

[@Cailus3542]

Okay, this is superb. Seriously superb. Well done.

[@smokalicious7818]

This was so beautiful I already miss Clara so much.

[@Reminji]

STOP I CANT HANDLE ALL THESE FUCKING FEELINGS AT ONCE NONONONONONO (seriously though this is a piece of art, one of the best dw edits I've seen in a while. I've seen so many bad ones out there but this is just amazing, first one that actually made me cry)

[@kc24jack]

pmed you for all the songs. this is beautiful. im not crying...im not. :'(

[@debbie1879]

Who ever step`s into Clara`s shoes has the next companion has got to be really good cause I really have loved watching The doctor and Clara together they make a fine couple.

[@superwholockdcmarvel6567]

+rose I AM CRYING BUT THANK YOU FOR MAKING THIS VIDEO YOU ARE AMAZING AND SHOULD MAKE MORE

[@Coolxmex]

oh my lord your video is amazing and i'm dying inside i will go down with this ship forever

[@valkyrie_cain86]

Ohhh that was brilliant. Words are failing me. Really well done.

[@peterxyz3541]

Wow!!! This is f--King good!!! Thank you! Clara is my fictional dream girl.

[@md6714]

This is absoluetly amazing, nice editing.

[@TWELVETYd]

Absolutely brilliant video! Thank you very much for that!

[@Ambzmusic]

this is so beautiful and so well put together... feel like my heart has been ripped to shreds.. job well done!!!

[@jessicaeddington2732]

Holy Cow!! That's FANTASTIC!!! (my major is in media arts so trust me when i say that this is really good!)

[@felis_felix4282]

I've watched this so many times and it honestly wrecks me

[@ladyflimflam]

Most of these ruined their edits with the music, your music choice enhanced it. Good job.

[@yognaughtron]

True that! I had to cry, but only because the music made it so emotinaly intense.

[@thedoctor8263]

+rose what songs are these, please?

[@melisbas6398]

The Doctor birdy-wings cover

[@JDeeNeal]

Well done!! Now on my WHO list of KZbin videos. Great work & TY

[@Juljuliejaina]

Very beautiful. I truelly loved it! thank you.

[@flickinger275]

This is fantastic. You did a great job with the music and the editing. This video is very good.

[@lily-qp3vl]

you know what? I can't help me crying. all these words, the 11th call. tears are too hot and my heart hurts. it's 5.30 am and I.. I just want to say, rose, that you are an amazing editor. you feel this show, you feel it the same as I do. and thank you. the doctor already has to be the doctor and not to be alone.

[@aerocombatpilot]

WHAT THE HECK ARE YOU TRYING TO DO TO ME..MAKE ME CRY ALL OVER AGAIN!!! GREAT JOB!!

[@YoungxHeart]

She's woven into his time stream and was born to save the doctor so I'm praying she comes back. :(((((( Lovely vid.

[@No1sonuk]

Considering how she left, it's entirely possible.

[@norasshelfdiscovery7883]

This is such a great tribute

[@Arth90]

I'm crying right now. This is amazing and heartbreaking at the same time.

[@Sahtumy]

I'm crying. This is too beautiful and heartbreaking.

[@Serialangel]

TOO MANY FEELINGS. I'm just watching this with tears in my eyes.

[@LetYourLiteShine17]

I love this video I loved Jenna and Peter, I'm really going to miss their companionship, but such is the reality of Doctor Who. I felt the same when Karen left Matt :'(

[@ivysayshello]

this is so amazing--thank you for making this :')

[@julietterozier1991]

La vidéo la plus réussie de Twelve et Clara sur KZbin (et crois moi, j'en ai vu énormément). En tout cas, l'alchimie entre Jenna Coleman et Peter Capaldi est extra. :)

[@SharonStudio626]

It made me cry. wow. Thank you!

[@Emmanuelle.s]

I'M NOT CRYING AT AL IT'S WRONG… Okay seriously it's a perfect video, for resume their relationship, there was fun, friendship, love, concern about each other, monsters and traveling around the world and spaces. She miss me already, thank you clara oswald, thank you doctor who.

[@joswin899]

ok i'm crying, so beautiful

[@akakibaracaskett9027]

ASDFGHJKL what the ... how dare you make me cry like this... i love this ♥ D':

[@GhostDcuo]

Really nice edit, and sad to see her go, miss you impossible girl :(

[@daniellexavier8820]

this was so beautiful! 😭😍

[@KimJansenn]

this is beautiful, thank you or making this

[@lifexintechnicolour]

this is how a tribute is done

[@Jian89]

and I just broke... this was awesome.

[@Ben-js2uz]

THE LAST MINUTE MADE ME CRY SO MUCH

[@alexnaumov4752]

This is incredible! Bravo!

[@harrypotterfantng]

This is beautiful!

[@alexfh357]

Fantastic job. I'd really like to see a version incorporating Hell Bent. I think it can be done without changing this too much. Very good choice of music and a great tribute to the best pairing this show has ever given us - and considering some of the ones we've had in the past like Rose and Ten, that is high praise.

[@iithedevilsarehereii2692]

Ohhh my heart is broken.... Perfect vid *-*

[@pineapplerobin2007]

Why? Like seriously why? I'm crying so much right now :'( This video is amazingly done tho!

[@Natalia-hb7pk]

OMG, this was the best pain I've ever experienced

[@TimeLadyVictorious]

whY ARE YOU D O I N G T H I S T O M E THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL AND I CANT STOP CRYING PLEASE HELP ME

[@julietterozier1991]

Right in the feels...

[@ariannazancuoghi2056]

Wtf this video is killing me inside, it's so beautiful

[@aleksandramierzwa6444]

amazing. perfect. I love it!

[@debaparnadas2036]

you just picked up my heart, tore it to shreds, and dumped them into the sea. why, why make me cry so much!!??

[@mantra4ia]

What have you done to me?! all the beautiful sound bits. what you did with the Doctor's war speech at "when I close my eyes." You have made five masterful minutes of Clara's companionship, and I hope that the Clara video I am making now turns out a 12th as good.

[@PhantomGuyver]

I want her back, this was painful to watch but I loved it.