TXT (투모로우바이투게더) 'Eternally' REACTION + ANALYSIS

[@astricidity]

I feel like in Hueningkai's part is about him trying to found out whats going on with the members. Cause he's an outsider and the members dont want him involve when all he Hueningkai wants is a happy friendship. And on the window, it said, "Dont go up the stairs", maybe its the members telling him to not get involve or something

[@muzikk67]

I thought his part was the most menacing out of all of their parts. There's a lot of temptation in his part. The stairs for example, materialize in a very creepy way that lead him up to the door. Even though he's not supposed to go up the stairs, he is lead to do so in the dream. Plus if that's heaven, they're all dead. And the other door could be an illusion tempting Kai to fall. There's another angel who fell from heaven, and that's Lucifer. Lucifer falls like lightning from heaven. And this MV starts with a lot of lighting and Kai with black wings

[@muzikk67]

Kai is also the only one who saw the ghost that Soobin did and ran in that direction but he was brought to that creepy door instead of the field Soobin saw

[@calypso961]

I feel like his innocence on the situation just separated him even more with the others.

[@crucify3568]

I think the writing might be his future self writing "don't go up the stairs" for the past self, probably something happened to heuningkai that effected his friendship with the members because he went up the stairs

[@muzikk67]

@I hate earth lol also, another religious symbol is that Huening Kai can initially walk on water, like Jesus. Soobin (section 1) and Yeonjun (section 3) also go up stairs btw, and both of those other times are related to Yeonjun's death. So now I'm thinking Kai is being tempted to kill yeonjun, since he's the only member who is presented with an innocent image of the stairs they're supposed to avoid

[@elenicole7838]

Is it just me or did you watch the mv and literally couldn’t wait for THIS video to come out so you could understand it😭

[@skrrtskrrt3337]

Me too😂

[@Lynatic11]

Same here 🤚

[@aienytab3834]

LITERALLY ME

[@breakingthechains38]

Accurate.

[@tanzeem456]

raising hand✋

[@mmjlkk]

all jokes aside about beomgyu filming everything, i actually think he recorded everything so when he wakes up from the dream he can remember everything that happened in the dream.

[@futhoe3352]

Shookt

[@jkair5352]

Ifiy Agst my head when *bam*

[@dani_moo_]

Oml

[@pragnya_mati]

This might be the reason hes barely shocked or surprised seeing all those visions, he seems to be calm but also suspicious of everything, I believe he knows a LOT.

[@chrisbangsspeaker4249]

Genius

[@gargimondal9864]

Me after seeing this "movie" :Yeonfused and jungshook

[@thenon-painter4747]

Gargi Mondal Shookbin*

[@cookedrisse]

@Yeonfused lmao 👁️👄👁️

[@romy2294]

And soobprise

[@moriahsheltonfilms]

This is so yeontroversial

[@thenon-painter4747]

Yeontroversial ikr! It’s so Taemazing!

[@Vicky-fl7pv]

What if they all together are the dragon... Soobin : long ears Beomgyu: spikes/ scales Yeonjun : horns (Asian depiction of dragons do have horns sometimes) Taehyun : eyes Kai : wings..

[@starrchoc]

woa, that kinda make sense, i never think of it that way before

[@hamster7111]

Wow

[@soo-beanie5057]

Me : yeah~~~👁👄👁

[@juliet4579]

whoa.... 😳

[@beatricebeatrice4481]

That makes sense

[@weshlesarmy6402]

I think that Beomgyu is filming Soobin otherwise he CAN'T see him.

[@muzikk67]

It could be taehyun behind the door. The uniform matches either taehyun or huening kai, but we already know from cysm that taehyun and beomgyu fight, with beomgyu hunched over him like that shadow transformation

[@thenon-painter4747]

muzikk67 I think it’s Soobin or Yeonjun. Mostly Soobin. He had the book in the first place.

[@abr4xas]

@@muzikk67 my theory is that it's taehyun too. but why was he trying to grab the eternity book from beomgyu? if it isn't taehyun then who might it be? and i feel like the person in front of the door used force towards beomgyu and beomgyu accidentally kills the person using his spikes, that's why he looks so defeated in the other scene.

[@cloudxluv]

I think it's not because of that but he is really suspicious about soobin because he kept looking at him following him and filming him

[@yunhology2319]

@@abr4xas it might be because in taehyun's section when tae finds yeonjun dead he blames it on gyu because he had the book which was in yeonjun's possession probably but I don't know about that because soobin dropped it before giving it to yeonjun, but it also could be symbolism in which yeonjun literally dies because of the book

[@grass1659]

“fLoWeRs ArEnT sUPPOsEd tO Do tHaT-“ I said the exact same things when I was watching it 😂

[@raexjl3008]

I literally shouted at my sister when I watch the MV like "OMG THE FLOWER TURNED INTO A SKULL. THAT'S NOT HOW FLOWERS WORK" or something like that

[@thenon-painter4747]

*I believe Kai has dragons wings. Maybe he’s the dragon- maybe that’s his secret*

[@leahthegamingdonut497]

On shat-

[@elo9373]

omg

[@alyamaisarah7579]

O_o

[@im72i.6]

bro that could explain why his wings in nap of a star looks mechanical/manmade

[@thenon-painter4747]

taehyung’s bag of tae. Omg- you’re right😳

[@cookedrisse]

Why are you so underrated like you make theorizing not boring👁️👄👁️🥺

[@evaisgoodnews]

Wait a fricking moment! Magic Island is a reflection of reality, so I believe that Taehyun went to magic island and he saw what was a reflection of Yeonjuns death that was shown in section 3.

[@sausanalyazahra6561]

Okay that's- I'm jungshook right now:)

[@maxinepistachio]

@@sausanalyazahra6561 shookbin

[@cloudxluv]

So is yeonjun not real and the book that soobin and beomgyu is fighting to bring back yeonjun?

[@airbear8495]

I just finished reading a theory about how Yeonjun never left NOAS. When he went there he was never found, which allowed the flowers to overgrow him covering his body. However the others believe that he escaped with them, he isn't real though and is just a figment of their imagination. That's probably why they are fighting over that book there is probably a spell that could bring Yeonjun back. Beomgyu wants to use the books spell to bring him back but Soobin doesn't think it's a good idea to use dark magic or any spells and so that's why they were fighting in that room.

[@evelinramosmiranda619]

@@airbear8495 where did you read thar? on twitter? or tumblr?

[@roshnasultan5941]

When Soobin was drawn to the windows and the door because he saw someone breathing on it, you know when you breath on a cold window it shows?? Then you can see after, that the thing/s breathing on it wrote those messages.

[@futhoe3352]

Shookt

[@gwenice]

Holy cow

[@imamoronbut5469]

Right.so that’s terrifying

[@jkair5352]

This is scarry😳

[@ensaymabing5212]

the one who wrote that mustve had a hard time since you have to write them the opposite way so people on the other side can read it

[@farrelltheafaustine]

In my personal perspective, When soobin come back to the practice room (at the end of the mv), soobin seems like lying to the rest of the member about where he came from / what he did outside the practice room, and the rest also lying each other about what they have been through when the time stoped. And they pretend nothing happened and continue their activity like a normal situation when the time come back to normal. Because it seems like they also didn't know what the other member do/feel/experience when the time stopped, so they ended don't tell anything. Reminds me of "who's a liar?" thing, omg. I love sharing theories!

[@rienashannenarito9290]

It may be connected to cysm choreo where they have their fingers crossed as lying and pinky finger out like "promise"

[@youthami2429]

Or maybe they forgot what happened, which is why beomgyu needed to record the whole me thing, and why the writing at the end says “remember my name”?? Lol I really don’t know, I’m just throwing random theories out there

[@lonelyvalley]

im probably wrong but I think that yeonjun became the tree in bts' stay gold mv, with all the purple blood on yeonjun becoming the purple moss and flowers on the tree, basically meaning that txt's story happened a long time ago...

[@mina.dsr23]

saammeee!! i also thought of this.

[@casperghost9309]

woahhhhhhhhhh the heck

[@saigonskastrela]

Well I thought the tree was simbolizing the Spring Day tree in those two mvs but girl😦if the universes were connected... BigHit is genious

[@gunwooks]

Bruh 🤯🤯🤯

[@mina.dsr23]

one of my wild thoughts is that yeonjun's body became the tree itself then his blood became the purple lake. i think no matter what be it past or present yeonjun's is bound to d*e..and he knws that, that is why he looks detached while seeing his d**d body..and what if even in other universe junie is always bound to di*..like what if he is the kid choi that jin's help to but still die. and i think aside from time travelling soobin can also be a seer..but then each time he tried to change something there is always a price. like what if by saving Junnie, Kai will die..and the butter fly effect thing in the multiverse itself. what if even a small thing that happened in BTS universe greatly affects the other universes..and what if those who can time travel can also travel through the multi verse?? p.s. im sorry about my wild theory and my alot of what ifs...😅😂

[@panic.at.the.everywhere0617]

Alright theories time- 1. This did in fact conclude the TDC series, the +u type videos were the songs where the title was present. (TDC: Star - Nap of the Star, TDC: Magic - Magic Island, TDC: Eternity- Eternally) 2. Each of the boys’ cartoon counterparts at the beginning of the MV displayed the same attributes as the Nap of the Star MV. Kai has wings, Yeonjun had horns, Beomgyu had spikes on his shoulder and back, Soobin’s ears amplified like we’ve seen with the hearing devices, and Taehyun’s eyes seem to be the focus like we’ve seen before 3. In Soobin’s vision we’re presumably at an amusement park. At one point we see who I believe is a younger version of Huening Kai do to the focus of the shoes. We see a dice and that displays the pattern we’ve seen in the past multiple times. I don’t exactly have a reason for why Kai was in his vision or who the lady was that hugged him at the end. 4. Yeonjun’s vision had him see the ruined stadium and then in turn his dead body. We also see the blue and green eyed cat which we’ve seen in every single +u specific MV. We see the cat over Yeonjun in the NotS MV, the train had the blue and green coloured lights, and we see the cat in the shadow in Yeonjun’s vision 5. Regarding Yeonjun, I believe the cat follows him around and I think Yeonjun may be the “main character” of the +u storyline. 6. In Beomgyu’s vision he had the mirror effect going on and the mirrors arrived and left like a train. Then Beomgyu’s vision showed him getting beaten up or abused by someone blocking the door as an escape. He seemed to be protecting a book which is similar to the book we’ve seen as a centric in the past. After the book gets knocked out of his hands and he fails to escape, he gets up and we see the spikes growing on his back as well as flashes of the cartoon character. This vision is different from the rest of them because we never saw the cartoon style in anyone else’s vision. When Beomgyu is filming the projection of himself we see a scar on his cheek in the same place as his scar in the Puma MV 7. In Taehyun’s MV it seemed he was on Magic Island and he saw a body. As he got closer to the body it is revealed that it was Yeonjun. He had a flower crown and he was bleeding purple. Even thought there are no visible cuts, the purple liquid was dripping in the way blood would look if his neck was slit. This seemed to reference the NotS MV because Yeonjun’s throat get’s slit after his encounter with the cat. 8. In Kai’s vision he goes up white stairs and ends up in a room of clouds. That scene combined with Beomgyu’s mirror is the exact replica of the cover of the book “Into the Magic Shop” by James R. Doty which has been said to be an inspiration for BTS and TXTs storylines/concepts in the past. Kai looks at the door in front of him and sees the other four members walk through. This could possibly be representation that Kai is watching what’s going on in the friend group (similarly to how he was kind of uninvolved I’m the CYSM MV) instead of engaging. 10. When they appear back in the practice room, there’s only 4 of them and we see Soobin walk back in even though he was in the practice room during the flashes in between visions. Beomgyu records everything like he has been doing the entire MV. When Soobin looks into the mirror he seems baffled by it. The dice still displays the magic symbol and then the mirror is zoomed out to have black surrounding the practice room, similar to how the train was displayed in the Magic Island MV 11. The visions were displayed in the order of the fanchant 12. I saw many similarities to the Wings short films BTS did in the past, this leading me to think that there is indeed a connection that I’ve been theorizing about since I got into this. The black room with the spotlight is a replica of Taehyung’s scene in the Stigma short film. 13. When the room is shaking and the alarm is blaring, it kind of seemed similar to a train departing... could it possibly be another insight to Magic Island? 14. You said in a tweet that this could be Soobin’s dream he was going to tell the others about, but I feel like Soobin only saw what he saw and somehow the others had their own version of the dream too. But then again, if it was only Soobin it would make sense due to the black room with a spotlight in the beginning of the Magic Island MV which looks similar to the scene before each of the members dream. 15. Part of me thinks that the events in this whole MV were strongly influenced by the possible powers/time manipulation TXT can do in the storyline. We see the clock tick backwards before the vision starts and then forward after they end. Sorry for the theory dump 😂 I’ve just had my brain working on overload (btw this was posted before I watched the video so let’s see what you say)

[@jocelynliem4602]

for number 5, I have a feeling that soobin may also be the main character too, as it always seems like either soobin or yeonjun knows/notice something like in the magic island MV when their ears were ringing, and in their concept trailer where the cat eyes appeared again when Soobin tried to walk toward the other members. And in this eternally MV, Seems like Soobin is the only one who is concerned about the dreams he had (Or it was reality cuz of the dice he hold in his hand). Buuut, I feel like in the future, we might see the other members as the main character too and we get to see what they see and feel in this +u storyline as well (I really hope so cuz this is "the story of the five boys"). Anyways, really loved your theory especially number 15, cuz I thought I was only seeing things when I see the clock moving anticlockwise hahahahh.

[@jocelynliem4602]

oh and also I love this +u storyline so much I hope this +u storyline will go looong and won't end even after the dream chapter ends. Seriously tho this is what got me into becoming a MOA after watching nap of the star and magic island.

[@acacia2649]

Why did it look like soobin was the only one who remembered what he saw and beomgyu was recording everything so that means that beomgyu has known what was going to happen for a while (?) and this beomgyu could also be from the future where he knows what's happened and I also believe that there are parallel universes but all the universes have something in common , the disaster or the end in some it's already happened and in some it hasn't beomgyu could be from any of these universes but the question is where is the real or the current universe's beomgyu? There must be a reason he's recording everything, for proof? Maybe to remember these events that happened. Is beomgyu dead? (current universe) and taehyun seemed to realise something when he sees yeonjun dead in the magic island (flowery place where yeonjun's blood is purple) like kind of an epiphany like he realised that everything went wrong in one moment , soobin sees a ghost figure thing , soobin could've gone into the past , where it all began and the white figure could've been the star in nap of a star , like I've always felt that the star was alive and the lady ghost thing could be the star . Yeonjun went to the universe (or future,) and seen his dead self and then he sees the cat , did the cat kill the other yeonjun? Huening tries to fix everything but ends up getting in trouble or dying and the members want to bring him back or fix everything so kai ends up making it worse and they will try to get him back at all costs . They saw everything in one moment and it seems that they forgot

[@ishitadixit7707]

Is it possible that when the large door in run away was on fire, it also set a fire in the world of cysm? Yeonjun wore the glasses and the door was on fire right? So when that happens the fire also sparks in the house and that's why the others looked at him like it was his fault for the world burning and creating a conflict within their friendship? That constant blaming and hatred kept growing on yeonjun and that's why he said 'Save me' in cysm. I can't think of any other reason as to why except the fact that their insecurities are growing on them. In run away there was a line 'So the summoning spell brings us together', and that glowy pattern from the dice creates this spell possibly along with the book at the beginning cause it might have the stuff to fix it? But Beomgyu refuses to give it later in the MV, and we see that those tiny spikes become huge huge ones, I think it's cause he fears that it might make it worse and his insecurities become worse. And soobin went into the past and got the dice probs knowing it could fix everything, and when he saw baby kai, he cried cause of the guilt he felt for controlling his innocence-(cysm choreo reference) not 100% sure cause there's a chance he's crying knowing he could've protected his members better. Another reason why he would get the dice back to the actual room they're in is because of Yeonjun's blood-covered face at the beginning and he didn't want that future realizing it's becoming a mess if they don't act now. Soobin probably said 'Save me' in cysm is cause he knows what's going on but having trouble fixing it alone? Not too sure about the ghost though, it may or may not be the practice room ghost? For Taehyun's vision, we see yeonjun's slit throat like we did in NOTS. The cat is ruining everyone's lives by constantly reminding them of their insecurities and leading to some tragic stuff. This might invoke fear in him about himself cause of the slit throat resemblance??? Soobin has seen future and past and is ready to kick ass, he's also seen the cat in the teaser too so he knows wassup.I'm not confident w this but that's my theory. For kai's vision, it said don't go up but he did and that's completely fine. he just wanted to see his hyungs. Which again acknowledges his innocence, and unknowingly or unintentionally gets hurt ig?

[@showayjo]

panic.at.the.everywhere0 there something that I think about a lot .-. On the NOTS MV if we pay attention to Soobin and Taehyun’s background, their background look really similar to me , the sky is orange and we see the star on the sky. And if we think a little bit, Taehyun is watching something OR someone and it could be Soobin. There is an other thing, on Eternally MV we see that Taehyun is recording the members but mostly Soobin, and at the end the members ignore Soobin but we see that Taehyun still recording Soobin .-. I hope you understand because I don’t really speak English.-.

[@ilostmywig6021]

Rumors says that the Tree on BTS "Stay Gold" was actually Yeonjun. So TXT have lived long time ago.

[@eunhaujung]

beomgyu filming soobin feels like jimin filming the girl and hobi in love yourself reel, jimin, hobi and the girl are on the practice room too

[@melicak8930]

i got goosebumps !!!

[@dolphincultmember1911]

The girl's name is Ryujin

[@djdbakfneo2971]

Maybe the girl is the practice room ghost...😱

[@joicelynnsaquing6837]

For me when it was soobin scene when he saw kai, the background looked like a merry go round which looks like the merry go round in BTS's Spring day MV and also in most of the members scene where they open the door and their shadow is behind them, it looked like Jungkook's Begin MV but they didnt have wings in their shadows. U also think that one of the practice room ghost is one of the members of G-Friend. G-Friend posted the song of the siren pre view and BTS posted the Stay gold MV which looked like Magic Island where TXT and G-Friends had been and now TXT posted the eternally MV. All of this videos kinda involves their story lines kinda meeting. I DONT KNOW WHETHER THESE THEORIES ARE TRUE BUT ALL I CAN CONFIRM IS THAT TXT DID A AMAZING JOB ON ETERNALLY AND TDC:ETERNITY!

[@hi-ok2ut]

It was night when Eternally came out and cos I'm a scaredy cat, I got half way through then decided to watch the rest tomorrow, so I don't get nightmares😂

[@evelinramosmiranda619]

omg are you okay?

[@hi-ok2ut]

@@evelinramosmiranda619 😂😂 yeah it was an exaggeration

[@laputa_ghibli3389]

😂😂😂😂, I had to turn on the lights 😂😂😂

[@ricezara]

I was watching it at night too😂😭 I got scared of the cats eyes so I had to take a moment coz I was shook😭

[@zzz6863]

Hahaha me too😂and more to add to that I was in my room with all lights of but I guess it was okay since the light from outside my window was a lot 😂

[@niagericameron9708]

I saw some theories on twitter: -Some people think that Taehyun IS the cat because both the cat and Taehyun saw Yeonjun dead -Beomgyu is recording Soobin because he doesn't trust him -One of the messages on the mirror says, "Don't go up the stairs", and Kai did just that -Also a thing I noticed, doesn't the path Soobin and Kai took look like a subway? (when you look out the subway windows it kinda look like that) (Note: These theories (except the last one) are NOT mine. I'm not that smart lol)

[@sealgeorge9813]

nah thats makes sense tho. cuz taehyun saw yeonjun die in different way in magic island while yeonjun saw himself die in creepy way. and taehyun the only member who can see yeonjun death.

[@ryas112]

And i saw taehyun on his scene with brightness up he had different eyes color (brown/dark green and blue) like the cat!! But i dont know tho :')

[@adeleneeetran]

SKSKDBSKBDSK I STAYED UP FOR THIS- edit: scared Laina is adorable lmaoo

[@aienytab3834]

as the universes are connected beomgyu's scene reminded me of rm's reflection

[@moarmyinsomniaipurpleyou6679]

When i saw it, I knew that I saw this somewhere, I think you are right.

[@rienashannenarito9290]

Also Jin in blackswan, suga in shadow

[@miilktea3321]

I don’t know why but I feel like the girl is someone from Gfriend-!

[@errajiw4231]

Same ig it's eunha or. Umji

[@user-jf3cf1co5m]

I think she looks like eunha

[@rienashannenarito9290]

Same...

[@francisbentoy3994]

I really think it was Eunha when I first saw her...

[@aienytab3834]

it might be eunha

[@envsoraa]

my theory that girl is eunha gfriend,you can see in GFRIEND (여자친구) A Tale of the Glass Bead : Butterfly Effect,that girl really same with eunha

[@gothiclolita251]

If it based on their outfit in the trailer, it might be umji or sowon cause they looks similar with the girl hugging soobin

[@evelinramosmiranda619]

but eunha doesn't have black hair now

[@landasangaspar3930]

but maybe that was the true and deprssed eunha.

[@stangfriend3271]

looks like umji because she has the ability to move out on her body on their fingertip plus the dress

[@amelial3088]

Evelin Ramos Miranda that was a wig I think

[@huasaihun]

writings on glass (in the beginning) said that they should not go up at stairs (what kai did). i got chills when i realised this.....

[@aienytab3834]

KAI COULD BE WORKING AGAINST THE MEMBERS THEN COZ HES MOSTLY SEPERATED FROM THEM AND DOESNT LISTEN TO THEM. or it could just be a maknae thing

[@latifahsow5899]

@@aienytab3834 but kai is the one who is trying to keep them together. I think when kai went up the stairs he entered a false universe where things trick him?

[@muzikk67]

@@latifahsow5899 kai isn't the only one who goes up stairs. Two other members do as well. Soobin and Yeonjun (sections 1 and 3). Both those two saw Yeonjun dead, in a very graphic way. Kai also sees Yeonjun as dead, since it's like a heaven environment, but his image is sweet and seemingly pure. Rather than backing away like Soobin does, Kai steps forward

[@znaltxt]

@@aienytab3834 other people say the rest are trying to keep kai innocent thats why hes split from his members

[@thetypoqueen888]

@@muzikk67 I thought Taeyhun is the one that saw Yeonjun dead not Soobin? Soobin see's Kai when he's little unless i missed something?

[@sienna5494]

7:57 I like how you and Soobin had the same reaction 😂

[@LainaSunflower]

Literally at the exact same moment 😂😂

[@miqelrubio]

When I saw the MV / Movie or whatever this is I stared crying until the end. There's a lot of tea in this MV and now I'm really confused HAHAHA

[@kinoykn]

shes so precious when shes excited and surprised we must protect

[@aki.j510]

Everyone One watching the MV : *amazed and figuring out theorys* Me: looking through the comments to see if anyone saw the ghost in the practice room and thinking if me and my mom were the one who saw the ghost

[@mina.dsr23]

i saw something as well. the white one right? the one outside the door or i am talking a different one?! hahaha

[@rmils7497]

Can you give me a timestamp I want to see it too

[@rainuchiha6877]

time stamps pleaseee

[@hamster7111]

I didn't see her but I noticed that somone or something is there and though if it was her

[@mina.dsr23]

it is 15:20 of the MV. it is a girl wearing white dress i think (?)..just like the one in soobin's scene

[@smolllll5407]

who else is always waiting for laina's theories and reactions

[@laputa_ghibli3389]

😂😂😂😂 me too

[@lou-sk8th]

The blurry scene like a festival with people in soobin's scene reminds me of jungkook's scene in spring day.

[@alejandrar127]

When I saw that scene I literally thought about Hoseok🙈 but honestly my brain isn't that smart so I don't think it's actually related some way

[@arrsylativa8451]

Is it just me or do i think Yeonjun may be the tree in stay gold

[@leahthegamingdonut497]

OMFG THESE THEORIES I'M SO CONFUSED

[@aienytab3834]

the t-tree-

[@ParkJimin-jq8sb]

AND THE SCENE WHERE TAEHYUN IS IS LIKE THE PLACE WHERE THEY SHOOT STAY GOLD OMFG I AM FREAKIN CONFUSED

[@nightappleispoisonapple1775]

Yeonjun is a t-tree?

[@mina.dsr23]

Miigash! i also thought about that..and the reason y the lake thingy in the stay gold video is purple is bcoz of yeonjun's blood.

[@lizzie9875]

I can't believe even the flashes at the beginning were a code. BIG HIT WHAT ARE YOU ? In Beomgyu's scene there seems to be blood on the walls. So did he kill the person he was fighting with, or is the blood from when the spikes came out of his shoulders ?

[@moarmyinsomniaipurpleyou6679]

What is the code here?

[@lizzie9875]

@@moarmyinsomniaipurpleyou6679 She said it means TORTURED.

[@daniellegarcia1599]

For some reason in beomgyu part it reminds me of taehyung when he "killed his dad" And taehyung had blood in his hands but idk 🤔

[@crucify3568]

I'm fully convinced that in soobins scene where he was at the carnival, he was crying because of heungkai, for example we see the boxes on the members heads as kids just like in the nap of the star mv, while they were all having fun, heungkai probably ran away (he doesn't have a box on his head) the members didjnt realize he was gone, so heungkai felt invisible, note: that's how soobin feels right now, anyways soobin probably saw where heungkai went as a kid but didn't look into it, now that the older soobin saw this he felt guilty and hurt that he never really took care of heuningkai and felt ashamed and sad, for that is why he is crying Also the writing on the walls are from their future selves. In taehyuns dream yeonjun was clearly in that chair for a loooong time from the flowers and vines are growing on him and seeing that the flowers are alive from his "blood" (where he got slashed by the cat) he was most likely a sacrifice to maybe keep magic island alive, it also signifies that yeonjun;inside, has always been dead. In soobins dream we can see soobin finding beomgyus(?) Diary and he's about to hand it to yeonjun, yeonjun turns with blood running down his face and it startled soobin which makes soobin slip on a rock, yeonjun probably tried to grab him and he did save soobin but yeonjun fell and probably "died" when he fell off the boulder, this Connects to yeonjuns dream where he saw the outcome of what happend, also I believe yeonjun is the closest to the cat, maybe yeonjun knows more about magic island than the other members. Or has the the memories of meeting the cat and his horns than anyone else, yes and I do believe the cat made a deal with yeonjun, also in taehyuns dream we can see that yeonjun was wearing white, and the outfit is strangely similar to one of the can't you see me outfit, I think that is why yeonjun is so mysterous and a little evil in CYSM, maybe he's mad that no one even realized what he feels Heungkais seen is NOT innocent, his future self wrote to him "don't go up the stairs", but heungkai always wanted to get closer to the members but I believe his desire to be there for the members always will leave him in shreds in the future which is why his future self wrote that to him Also I believe all of them well get desperate to save themselves, especially yeonjun seeing that he saw his own dead body, well they will all get desperate and probably paranoid leading to a not so good friendship That's all I have for now, I'll update on this and be free to add on to my theory or make your own!

[@btxtboys]

how can bighit not UNDERSTAND HOW MUCH STRESS I-MOAS FEEL WHEN THERE IS KOREAN TEXT ON THE SCREEN AND IT DOESN'T HAVE TRANSLATION ON THE CAPTIONS😭

[@leo_senados]

Maybe one of the gfriend mem is the mother of soobin. Like the story of greek gods were 6 girl and 7 boys they have 5 children

[@nuuufeee]

The ariadne and dionysus story. If rm is dionysus (because he's the one who held the staff in their performances), its still unknown who is ariadne (it may be sowon because she's the leader and then there's an unpopular opinion that said she's the sun goddess based on sunrise. It may be yerin because she held rope in fallin light and it's said that ariadne gave dionysus a rope/string to get out of labyrinth. It may also be yuju because she sang "aria" part in fever and she almost debuted with stage name aria but then changed to yuju) My point is : anything can happen at this point hahaha I'm just gonna let others to speculate the theories

[@niishii2704]

I also think about that too

[@melodybeloevved6577]

Sowon could possibly actually be Ariadne. And the ghost could’ve been her cause if you watch the new video uploaded for GFRIEND’s new comeback Sowon and Umji wore similar white dresses as the ghost. But the ghost may not have even been a GFRIEND member to begin with. Idk this is just what I thought after watching gfriend’s new video.

[@gothiclolita251]

Based on gfriend member outfit in comeback trailer A tale of glass bead : Butterfly effect. Sowon or Umji outfits really similar with the girl hugging soobin

[@harnaz]

Sowon is Ariadne and RM is Dionysus

[@megha8130]

I wonder how nobody noticed that when Soobin looked out the door the first time and then looked back inside the practice room, it looked like someone in white was running behind those foggy windows.

[@blossomerie3078]

THIS ETERNALLY MV IS SO RELATED TO GFRIEND!!!!!! Each one of txt and gfriend has his own universe and own stories (and theories aaa imma sue bighit :") XD) BUT the thing is these two universes crossed each others and they are connected. (If you want to understand gfriend's universe, go watch their MVs and also read some theories, also it's not only crossing the road with txt's universe but also with BTS' universe) I read that the girl who hugged soobin is actually eunha (we saw her in other txt MVs and she was wearing a white dress, the same one she wore in "A Tale of The Glass Bead: The Butterfly Effect") ,She is the first one who went to Magic Island and she doesn't want the same thing to happen to txt so she's trying to protect them. Also In the "A Tale of The Glass bead: the Butterfly Effect" that was released 2 days ago, the narrator said " we followed the blue light (or something like this) and we saw eunha running towards the left road, and in "Eternally" mv Yeonjun looks at the cat who has a blue left eye and a green right eye. His left eye is "blue", and eunha went towards the left road saying she followed the "blue" light. Aagahhhhhh these theories are killing me. BIGHIT WE NEED AN EXPLANATION!!! Love your videos by the way and your theories are so interesting 💜

[@nadianadou1771]

I totally agree with you 💜

[@naiap2905]

The ghost kinda reminded me of Lilliandil from Narnia (who Caspian called "a star") so the ghost might be the star??? Idk i suck at this...

[@SimiChan-12]

I thought the same

[@sofiad5748]

I thought of The Chronicles Of Narnia before and went searching up in the book where the stars appear however I didn't find anything about a star singing, to be sure I would have to read it all again but I'm kinda lazy because the book is so big :p

[@dancersupreme3023]

What about the star from the Nap of a Star video

[@acacia2649]

That's literally what I said in another reply 😂

[@strawberrybanana9728]

WAIT WHAT??(sorry i have to mention this) UMJI FROM GFRIEND MENTIONED THAT THEIR TRAILER LOOKS LIKE(THE VIBE) FEELS LIKE THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA

[@ntlbrn7260]

The 3 messages that were on the window in the same shot were this: (1) "I can't breathe." (2) "I have to get out." (3) "Don't go up the stairs." Also, I don't know if it is just me, but didn't they make it look like their real lives this time? At least with Magic Island, we knew that it was still a storyline life and not their real ones, but this one, Kai was practicing the Fairy of Shampoo choreo and everything seemed like it was meant to look like their REAL lives and it scared me so much but it also is so cool. Am I the only one that thought that way??

[@menakadhilip8756]

I WAS WAITING FOR THE MV AND SUDDENLY FORGOT THAT THEY WERE GONNA RELEASE IT...WHEN I CHECKED MY PHONE I WAS LIKE "WHAT!!!!!!!"

[@fairyofyeonjunie3123]

OMG....THE LONGEST AND THE BEST VIDEO EVER

[@andidono]

24:45 Yess I think that's Sowon from the Glass Bead SOS, but also remind me of Eunha at the intro of TFTMN

[@aienytab3834]

ONCE THE MV CAME OUT I COULDN'T SLEEP AND WROTE SOME STUFF ABOUT IT

[@alejandrar127]

Wrote some stuff???? THEORIESSSSS

[@rheansantos8101]

No one: Laina: that's a booOk (Edit) eternally MoVie is probably heaven for you XD all theories and clues, I'm excited for your other theories

[@noorie9796]

Thank you so much for reaction!!! I loved watching it! Another observation some really smart MOA made was that in Run Away we can see that on the whiteboard in the classroom, Taehyun and Soobin’s names were written on one side of the board whereas Hueningkai, Yeonjun and Beomgyu were on the other side. This might represent those who died, Hueningkai, Yeonjun and Beomgyu and those who are alive Taehyun and Soobin. In Eternally we see Yeonjun has passed, from Taehyun and Yeonjun’s perspectives. Perhaps Beomgyu died defending the Eternally book and as for Hueningkai, in one of the last scenes where it shows him on one side of “Where Heaven meets Earth” scene, this could suggest Hueningkai is in heaven in the present timeline of Eternally (although I’m kind of confused by the timeline but I’ll go with it 😂). This could also explain why Soobin began crying seeing little Kai in his dream.

[@cookedrisse]

Is it only me or 14:54 I already read his mouthing Yeonjun and I was like bruh- is he ded?👁️👄👁️

[@alejandrar127]

That scene hurt me so much :( Taehyun was screaming "Yeonjun hung!" but the other didn't respond cause he was ded...

[@cookedrisse]

@@alejandrar127 𝙸𝚔𝚛

[@kimberlygomez3951]

When I first saw the mv literally got chills in how accurate your predictions were🤯

[@jojitwentysix6776]

Not gonna lie, I cried so hard at Soobin’s part that I had to pause it, cry for another hour and continue watching the amazing art of BigHit.

[@mrymxiddiki8691]

i don't know but at the start when i watched this i thought that this is happening at the same time as bts ON. because of the clouds at the start when jk blows the horn/shell thingy? and then the meteoroids fall from the sky and destroy everything? idk these bighit theories is getting to me..XD

[@cattyun]

OMG I wasn't only one thinking that ever since ON mv came out i thought of that

[@user-kd4gn3uf5k]

The pansy flower symbolizes the love or admiration of one person for another. According to Google.

[@bepbobbap]

Text on door: what did we do wrong? Mirror text section 1: Find what’s floating in the sky Text on the board: Do we end up like this? “I can’t breathe” “I need to escape” “Don’t go up the stairs” credits: Naz G

[@zjayyy7705]

I think that yes soobin was the one that beomgyu was fighting with in his vision thingy. Maybe soobin took the book from beommie because he wanted to give it to yeonjun (we see that he was tryna do that at the start - in his dream) Kai was always clueless as to what was happening aound them mostly bcoz the hyungs didn't tell him anything cos he was too young or smn. That's why we see them on opposite sides in heaven but just maybe I think he died and are seeing them and wants to go back :/ As for soobin I think he sees kai in the past bcoz he feels guilty that he died and wants to maybe bring him back.

[@Charkive_]

In Beomgyu’s part after he grow those horn-like things out of his shoulder, there was like a outline of a person or something behind him and it looks like it’s Soobin. (Sorry I’m bad at explaining things.)

[@snowlight172]

When you said that this is before Magic Island, I remembered the lyrics from Run Away "Please be my eternity. Please call my name" and it actually fits with the album itself and the last writing on the window "Remember my name". Also, that ghost appearing in front of Kai as if she was asking him to "run away with me". The same goes when you said the cat is probably offering him a deal and the actual translations of section 3 Yeonjun's section is "promise" which can be equivalent to a deal. It also says "In that moment, I thought it was salvation" idk if this makes sense but yeah 😂 my mind bout'a explode man 😂

[@marysicle]

Has anyone noticed that Eunha's outfit in A Tale of the Glass Bead: Butterfly Effect is a school uniform in the same color as the ghost girl on Magic Island?

[@hyunjinnie6893]

Plot Twist: The cat is actually their savior

[@aniluzavala5480]

Past Laina: Don't die Soobin... Me: Oh no... who's gonna tell her...

[@Yana-px9sp]

People keep saying that the girl is from gfriend...but u know what I thought of first.. "Hey, it's Soobin sister"🤣🤣

[@asdfghjklasdfghjkl9486]

theory: Kai dies in the present and Soobin goes back in time to save hyuka. That is why he cries when he meets baby kai. But kai died still, which is why he ends up in heaven, and the other 4 boys all look at him from a distance cuz they couldnt save him.

[@kaylamazza]

this might be a stretch, but i think the other person in the room that was fighting with beomgyu was actually soobin. as we know soobin had the eternity book at the beginning of the mv, however what i find interesting is that the techno part of the song plays twice in this mv, the first time its in beomgyu's section, then it plays again at the end when the focus is on soobin. possibly hinting at the tenseness between the two members as something may be going on, also, not to mention that beomgyu seems to be the only once that notices soobin before and after the time stops.

[@yourinternetbf]

I was thinking about how at the end when Soobin looks into the mirror and the video zooms out that maybe he notices something is watching them. I think it would make sense because when the writing on the mirrors were shown it was written in fog and none of the boys wrote the writings obviously lol. But thats just what I thought.

[@btxtboys]

When u said that the whole scene in the beginning might be the dream soobin was talking about in Magic Island, idk why BUT MY HEART SKIPPED A BEAT KAJDKDKDKFKDK

[@sidrahussain5899]

what if just from my imagination what if the cat is the witch that can transform and is trying to rule the magic island so she cursed the TXT members and is trying to break their friendship but somewhere in the future they(TXT) realize what is happening but it is too late and the witch is already ruling the magic land and they(TXT) are trying to fight against her

[@ellie_ackerman4296]

Wait.... Tell me if I'm the only one seeing this.... but I think I saw the cat right after Soobin picked up the dice when he went into the past and saw Kai. If you look closely in the darkness in the back you can see something like two eyes... one blue and one green.

[@acacia2649]

I saw something but idk if it was the cat

[@bladelogic923]

Your videos are the only way I understand what is going on, at first I had no idea what any of the storylines meant now after watching your videos I understand so much more, thank you for helping me understand 😊😊🤗🤗😊😊😊🤗🤗🤗💜💜💜 Theory 1: Huening Kai is the dragon(which would explain the wings) and he’s afraid of the other members finding out(remember he was asleep when it was flying through the sky in Magic Island) Theory 2: The girl comforting Soobin is Umji or one of the other members of Gfriend Theory 3: the writing on the window was left by the “ practice room ghost “ which could be the cat or one of the members of Gfriend(probably Umji because it’s probably the same girl) Theory 4: Yeonjun saw the future when he opened his eyes on the train to magic island(in the magic island MV) because when he opened his eyes he saw a building collapse Theory 5: Beomgyu was filming Soobin because he couldn’t see him otherwise(that would be weird) Theory 6: Soobin went back in time to when Huening kai was a kid to a point in his childhood that might have something to do with him being the dragon Theory 7: Yeonjun followed the cat and he ended up wherever he was and the purple stuff on his neck was on the same place as the cut the cat gave him Theory 8: In the beginning Soobin had the book and it looks like he dropped it so maybe he was fighting with Beomgyu to try to get it back Most of this was just stuff I noticed not actual theory’s but if it helps anyone understand what’s going on, let me know

[@misssoobread5246]

I’m still waiting for big Hit to drops it’s own movie with the big Hit universe actors and actresses. Then we could have laina to decode everything for us

[@almond_soobin3317]

I’VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS I CLICKED FASTER THAN LIGHTNING

[@yeonjunpambansanglambinger8386]

There's really a ghost and kai saw it. And afterall, Eternally is connected to Magic Island because this is soobin's dream?

[@chocolateandtea2666]

I've noticed that Soobin goes to the past, Yeonjun the future, Beomgyu the past (?), Taehyun the future (possibly?) but idk about Kai, I think also the past

[@melicak8930]

Beomgyu also seemed to be the future but im not really sure about him and even kai

[@iva7478]

Not theory related but the scene with small Kai droping the ice-cream reminds me of the TO DO episode where the staff dropped the ice-cream and then Kai fell off the chair shbfsjdbghf

[@muzikk67]

Okay so I watched the MV again after that "don't go up the stairs" comment, and it's interesting. The MV opens up with all of them having walked up the stairs except soobin. And when soobin goes up the stairs, he sees yeonjun with blood. The next person seen going up the stairs is yeonjun, he also sees himself dead. And the last person is huening kai, who faces the rest, with yeonjun at the front, seemingly all in heaven, with all of them dead. The stairs seem to be linked to yeonjun's death, and the one who is tempted the most with them is huening kai. The two others get negative images linked with the stairs, but kai gets a seemingly innocent image wrapped in white, bright skies, and clear water. Huening appears to be able to walk on water, which is what Jesus could do. But given that the image is a temptation and that he wasn't supposed to go up the stairs, this will start the tragedy the boys face. In cysm, yeonjun burns the house after huening kai turns against beomgyu and yeonjun's antics

[@alejandrar127]

I don't know if this might be related or not but in cysm the bedroom is probably upstairs and there Beomgyu chokes Taehyun...also there's the scene where Kai in sitting in front of the bed while the others are standing almost distancing from each other and Kai seems upset? Although we don't see any of them going upstairs during that mv so...

[@muzikk67]

@@alejandrar127 I'll have to re-watch the MV but that's a very interesting point. That upstairs room is where they have those mental breakdowns (at least 4 of them do)

[@PBAT7]

Please react to tale of a glass bead butterfly effect

[@esmelecrystalleclarissefre7078]

Yasss

[@dipironadasilva]

yessss

[@nsninja1304]

In fake love mv, 2:31 to be exact it's a namjoon part where he is watching his reflection on the mirror the actual fact is that his reflection is wearing a green outfit and Actual Rm wears a blue one. There are lot of blue and green shades in fake love! I am just wondering if they are connected to the cat?

[@lilasm0411]

Okay I found some things 😂 - 17 is a number which mostly brings luck, helps you and stuff like this, but it can be a number which is a symbol of illusion, naivety, utopia and selfishness. Also, in Italia, the number is "cursed" or brings bad things (I think it was something like this), and is even banished from some building or elevators. - You said that they're in a school gymnasium, it makes me think about run away, I can't remember exactly the MV but I have the memory of a moment when they're in a gymnasium, with a swimming pool. The place also makes me feel like a subway, you know with the door A-3. And whe can hear a sound like a train who's passing up there, it can maybe be the train of magic iland ? - I also find that the girl looks like a member of gfriend, maybe eunha or umji...? - The dragon is maybe an other representation of their pains : he has wings, spikes, eyes of course and horns I think...? I couldn't see his ears well. - With the number 17, I wrote that it could be a symbol of selfishness. It is maybe for this reason that it's on the door in Beomgyu's scene : if it's Soobin who fights with him, it's probably because of the book. Soobin wants the book for himself. It's kind of selfish. He don't want the others to know abt this book, or the content of the book. It can also be to protect them. My theorie abt 17 is a little bit twisted but it could be an explanation. - We also saw that the fire's still following Yeonjun. And the cat. I don't know if the cat is good or bad or maybe both, but the cat (or the train-cat) is the one who pick them out of magic iland, who probably put the glass between Soobin and the others, and he was with Yeonjun when he had his horns and now when he finds himself dead. I think the cat has something to do with the fact that time freeze. And I think he has a bound with Yeonjun, more than with the others. My theories sucks but it's so chaotic in my mind rn 😂 also sorry if I made mistakes but I'm not english ☺️ P.S : Laina's reaction « flowers aren't supposed to do that ! » killed me 😂

[@souredfigs]

THE QUEEN HAS ARRIVED

[@ilikebread3116]

ahh I luv your profile photo

[@17swimfroggy17]

no 17: I think the 17 refers to the 17th track in the series which is Maze in the Mirror, the themes of the song fit the sections visuals. "Where is the end, I try to run but In the mirror, a maze A restriction called protection has locked me up I can’t complain anymore even though it hurts This world, world that hid me Please don’t give up on me We’ll be going up, don’t fall In the mirror, above you Trying to fit myself in this big frame I feel so tiny and still so small Find me please, please I surrender in front of the mirror again It’s too dark here My delicate shoulders Neither can I hide nor can I straighten them..." 19th track is eternally. no idea for the 3-A

[@mercyfailana6135]

The demolished building(at the first part), I think thats the demolished building in MAGIC ISLAND mv. oh god I DONT KNOW WHAT IM SAYING LOL

[@LainaSunflower]

Yess I think so too! I said it at one point but if it’s not in there I might have cut it accidentally 🤡 tbh the last 9 hours are a blur

[@jung5500]

Is it just me that she's so cute when she's nervous or excited??🥺

[@enyarodriguez3667]

I dont know maybe is just me but when Soobin is going to close the window... there is kinda like the shape of a person on the window .... sooo maybe he there was actually something in there

[@aeii__]

Idk why but the MV remind me the bts mama vcr: • Future meets Past • Past meets Present • Present meets Future

[@panganibanharveya.3139]

Goshhhh!!!!! Finally!!!!! Totally same reaction!!! Now can't wait for the reaction/theory abt GFriend's butterfly effect

[@Kim_Imyoung]

I feel like the song of the sirens will answer some questions.

[@auxerae]

I really can't be the only one who gets strong midsommar vibes at Taehyun's part? Especially with the sounds and moving flowers

[@rienashannenarito9290]

OH MY GOSH

[@Emgee78]

I thought the same.

[@pastelhotmess9299]

THAT'S WHAT I WAS THINKIN

[@jeon_eden1092]

Laina: IS HE ON MAGIC ISLAND IS THAT MAGIC ISLAND

[@Gabi-rl1xv]

OMG THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR DOING THIS!! I was literally sooo confused when I watched it (and maybe just maybe I was sobbing). TXT universe is just too much for my brain 😂 Although can we appreciate how if BigHit made the BTS and TXT universes into movies they could probably win Oscars 😂

[@ricezara]

So Beomgyu was protecting that book pretty hard like he had it in his jacket. So the book is obviously important otherwise he wouldn’t be doing so much. Maybe the book isn’t something that should fall into the wrong hands and the person who was trying to take it was the “wrong hands” and that why Beomgyu got his spikes, because the other person got hold of it when they shouldn’t have. Like you see everyone’s features appear only in the cartoon flashes but you actually see Beomgyus irl so I think it definitely has something to do with the book.

[@leahthegamingdonut497]

I was honestly just waiting for you to drop a 30 min video because some of us moas are dumb af.(Like me)

[@samanthaabad1232]

OMG i just noticed kai and Soobin are the only ones wearing white at the practice room

[@vee3387]

I thought I was the only one who was kinda scared of Eternally

[@kayellejeon]

About Beomgyu's dream the number 17 is a symbol of self-discipline and responsibility. If this number enters your life, it means that you are able to take your life in your own hands. It is time to be independent and to take responsibility over your life. in biblical term, seeing that number frequently means that you will keep balance between the physical and spiritual world. Idk, i just searched it though bcs i ws curious about the significance of the number.

[@rosilawatikamaruddin5385]

What if the cat is actually kai pet.... Maybe it got lost when kai still a child... And it kinds like the hyungs need to protect kai from the cat? Cuz the cat actually a demon? Maybe?

[@youngdevil2034]

Am I the only one who thinks Beomgyu could be secretly protecting everyone? Like red and green are the colours the cat can see, so during the CYSM mv when it first turned red on Beomgyu's part, he looked at the camarea, so he noticed the cat looking at them. The second part with Taehyun, he could be hiding Taehyun from the cat by covering him with a blancket, but Taehyun doesn't know this so his surprised. And in the Eternally mv, I don't think it's any of the other members in Beomgyu's scene because it just doesn't seem to fit and the body comparison doesn't fit either. So maybe Beomgyu's protecting the book from someone from his childhood? because i read somewhere that 17 is the age where your childhood kind of ends or something.

[@_yanninaazmi_8311]

When I watch the music video I was really confused because I don’t know what’s happening like soobin crying then this ghost lady came and hug him then heuningkai going through a white door that I think is the door to heaven I just don’t know what’s going on mean while my sister is scared of the mv😂 because of how scary it looks😅

[@envsoraa]

this mv actually answer new problem in bighit universe,not the highest but firstly problem arise when they all wake up to butterfly effect.

[@seventeengfriend209]

i personally think the “back then i thought it was salvation” line refers to the cat bc the text appeared right after the cat appeared

[@melicak8930]

yeah the cat has a sinister/mystery/spooky kinda vibe through the +U mvs

[@hannah900]

yes! also adding onto that, in the nap of a star mv, the cat appears menacing and makes yeonjun run away. but here the cat eyes have a more innocent look to them i think. so maybe since yeonjun appears to have died, the cats trying to reflect the guilt onto yeonjun himself?? idk lol it’s my first day here 😂😂

[@stemb-cuaresmacrisdaniel6909]

I just discovered that when eunha was running to the forest and I think she get lost and she encounter TXT and Eunha got scared because of the fire and the ghost I think it's umji be if she was eunha it's gonna be blonde hair when we see in gfriend tale of the glass bead.....that's what I think of it And I watch every theory that you made and I got goosebumps

[@nicoleta494]

I was waiting for this video so bad.😭😭😭😭 This video is already creepy on his own but if you read the text is all an other level of anxiety.

[@kirstenelwin1063]

Beomgyu is in the” maze in a mirror “.I think the person recording like a concert scene is beomgyu but I also don’t think so.

[@miqelrubio]

OMG I WAS WAITING FOR THIS SO BAD!!!!

[@zbii__5605]

I think that when they are in that room (in the Eternally MV) maybe the witch is watching them but only Soobin notices. I don't really know but I think it's possible