Umineko Chiru (EP8): Magic Ending - Battler, Beatrice and the Cat Box

[@Arettee]

At the moment Battler held on to her, he truly understood her heart. He fulfilled his promise that he would understand her. And from that moment, that moment of complete and total understanding, they could not be separated. So even though Battler's physical form survived, the Battler we know really did drown with Beato that day.

[@Vedemis7]

Arettee my theory is like this: His soul split apart. One drowned with beato, the other remained in his body. Both incomplete and lacking memories, as shown in the manga. At the halloween party in fukuin house his soul became complete again, the left Part leaving battlers body.

[@blankuchan4394]

@@Vedemis7 So did the half that was in Toya go to Battler/Beato or did the part Battler lost when he drowned with Beato come back to Toya? He did reunite with Beato at the EP8 ??? So did Battler now 100% go with Beato?

[@A_Fridge_Named_Arisu]

Well ikuko release his "battler" persona to reunite with most of the ushiromiya family and also beato in golden land so that he can live as ikuko hachijo in peace

[@blankuchan4394]

Everyone is happy in the Golden Land,

[@onemoregodrejected9369]

@@blankuchan4394 Yes. Battler stoped "being". Even if that body had his memories, Battler no longer existed nor that body accpted Battler nor Battler accepted that body, he went with Beatrice. Toya was born and took over the body. Toya never accepted Battler even after unlocking all his memories and that is it. Toya and Battler are as different as Shannon and Kannon, maybe they are on the same body, but will never be the same person. You could think is mental fuckery, and I agree, but in the other hand, the sense of identity is that weird even on real humans. IF a person cant accept their alter egothey have to separate from it.

[@mads_in_zero]

A catbox in the ocean. An umi neko, if you will.

[@MrTigracho]

ROLL CREDITS

[@エゴ-j7i]

I'll face myself

[@jayIG]

umi neko(bako)

[@jwlry6913]

Нихренасе игра слов

[@cesiumverbal102]

I am dead inside. Thank you, Ryukishi07.

[@whensomethingcriesagain]

Ladies, gentlemen, and witches, behold the saddest scene in written history.

[@BillCipherandFreddyKreugerFan]

🤣

[@kyleco9149]

This was only the beginning of their meta world story from ep 1 so not really that sad. But still sad regardless.

[@goobermagoob9160]

@@kyleco9149 I’m not the only one who sees this as the beginning of the story?

[@badrandom]

@@goobermagoob9160 Well... It actually is. The final chapter of Umineko Episode 8 manga Had an Extended version of this scene, which explains what is exactly going on. Also yes manga only content (additional scenes in the main story) is canon sooo

[@dinogt8477]

no

[@RainbowLizardOne]

it takes two to create a universe but beatrice, a creature of illusions could not leave rokkenjima and so, to create the endless, beautiful world that they dreamed of, battler's heart stayed with beatrice in the abyss of the unknown that rokkenjima became and together, the endless, golden truth of their love remained, theirs and theirs alone. and there, a universe was created

[@eryseayliid1535]

I honestly expected the magic ending to be the happy ending and the trick ending to be the sad ending but man, we've been hit hard...

[@yanikcamm7639]

its been stated in red, this tale does not have a happy Ending.

[@harounou1]

this the true story

[@meeramalhotra33]

@@yanikcamm7639 It's a happy ending if you see it that way

[@_____._..--_]

Eryse Ayliid bernkastel already said in all probabilities and miracles, there was NEVER was a happy ending. So the trick ending was the technical the _true_ and right ending.

[@ВоваМ-х9з]

This moment is NOT the ending.

[@ManuSenpai_]

Ever since I finished Umineko I haven’t been able to fully rewatch this scene

[@綾小路寺清貴-z3o]

THIS IS PEAKKKK

[@adachivineboom]

YOOO MANU

[@addominum]

you again.

[@beatrice0610]

I sobbed so fucking hard when he opened his eyes and Beatrice wasn't there. That and the illusion of Battler grabbing her after he had started to surface was probably just a hallucination of hers as she slowly lost her consciousness. I'm glad that was her last moments, being held by the one she loved.

[@fairamano6165]

Super late reply, but I'm pretty sure that was the actual Battler. The hint to follow was when Tohya mentioned "I think my boat capsized" (remember he had amnesia, so the details are hazy). Having Battler realize that she had jumped would naturally force Battler to do the same with the goal of saving her, or in this case, die with her. When they sank down, one could imagine that he passed out and floated back up, and was able to survive. Beatrice sank because of the gold she had tied to her leg, and died. It makes sense and doesn't interfere with anything people consider "real" or whatever. Also, it helps to give even more impact to the scene, because, really, who would want this to be a hallucination? Haha. At least the couple "die" together.

[@ErikaBernLambda]

@@fairamano6165 It's not.

[@joejoe-vm1fj]

@@ErikaBernLambda Battler did go jump in to save her

[@GrapeCheckerBoard]

There’s some argument to be made that Yasuda survived and took the identity Ikuko. Part of the evidence is wordplay in Ikuko’s name-apparently the kanji hold the number “19”, which we know was significant to Yasuda. It explains how this random woman happened to find Yasuda’s confession. It explains why Ikuko went to all the trouble of having Tohya treated discreetly instead of trying to find his family. It explains how Ikuko knew about the bank PIN and the smashed Chiesta Sister. Nothing we know about Ikuko contradicts the possibility she’s Yasuda. We only have Ikuko’s testimony that she is an outcast from a wealthy family. Everything we’ve seen can be explained by the gold. Kinzo was involved in housing and even kept Castiglioni in a mansion on the mainland for a time. Ikuko’s sprite in the artwork doesn’t have cleavage. Ikuko being Yasuda gives Ikuko a stronger connection to the plot than simply being some random woman. I’ve heard the objection that Yasuda’s survival goes against the the theme of her story; that Yasuda was a person who closed off any possibility for happiness through her own actions and inactions. My response is that the finale of Umineko is about accepting tragedy and letting go of heartache. Battler himself begged Yasuda to live on, when they were on the boat. Besides, if Battler had grabbed Yasuda and pulled them both to safety, I think Yasuda would be concerned with saving Battler. I see nothing out-of-theme with Umineko or out-of-character for Yasuda to try living if the result of their attempted drowning is Battler taking serious injuries in the process of saving them.

[@sobbuh3378]

@@GrapeCheckerBoard late replay but how would yasuda survived if she was tied down by gold , there would be no way the tie could be broken along with the water pressure. i can see this theory but honestly believing it would be a bit obscure

[@Ahil4421]

The battler that sank with beato is battlers personality the one that drifted into the ocean had already forgotten who he is meaning battler did indeed die in a way..

[@onemoregodrejected9369]

The original Battler went with Beato to start this game and the body left behind went to tell the truth to the person that was the biological sister of the body where a new person was born. And the other ending is Ange ending that will eventually lead her to the biological body left behind by a no longer alive Battler. Is a way to see the story, both endings are the same

[@Nicole_whatsgood]

I like how the "happy" ending is essentially a double suicide...

[@zGabaz]

I thought the magic ending would be a happy ending, when I made the choice. I'm sad and feeling like an idiot LMAO

[@brycerichardson3687]

@@zGabaz It was stated in the red. This story does not have a happy ending.

[@kyleco9149]

It's just the beginning of their story, how their journey began

[@Dahpie]

@@brycerichardson3687 Funny enough it can be perceived one way or the other, ironic given that the heart of Umineko is about human perception. On one hand it's sad what happens to Battler and Beatrice but on the other hand Ange get's to see that her brother is alive at least in Body which is ultimately a miracle.

[@meeramalhotra33]

It's a happy ending because you discover what happened to Beatrice and how exactly Battler escaped the island. You finally get to see the truth you wanted, because you've proven yourself a worthy reader who has love for the characters 🥹

[@Ventras2]

Hope you, guys, understand that this is not the Ending. It's just the beginning of their META-wold story. So, for you to know the course of events: 1) Ushiromiya family comes to the island where they are all killed by Kyrie and Rudolf (they are later killed by Eva) 2) They only survivors are Eva who escapes to Kuwadorian and later found by the police, Beatrice and Battler who finds Beatrice (YasuShannonKanon) in the submarine base, who tells him everything about the story (of her being male ShannonKanonYasuKinzo'sSonAndBattler'sUncle, of Kyrie and Rudolf, of her sins which are actually just letters which contain different variations of the events on the island and etc.)They decide to escape together. 3) Beatrice kisses him and jumps into the sea in order to suicide. Battler jumps for her, but falls unconscious as he reaches her. His body goes to the sea shore and is later found by Ikuko. 4) That's how their story, the story of the 1st game (according to manga which was confirmed by Ryukishi was trustworthy) begins. Their minds separate from their bodies and they go to abyss together. But eventually this abyss turns out to be META-world, the eternal chessboard. They both appear in their usual play-room, where Beatrice is not male or something, Beatrice is Beatrice, The Golden and Endless Witch. And happy Beatrice sees Battler there with her and asks him how did they end up here. The worst possible thing happens right after that. Battler loses his memory of her being witch, of their love story and etc. He asks her "Who are you? Where am I?" 5) And then Beatrice decides to start the GAME. The game which goal was to make Battler remember everything ( which actually happens in Ep 6., but by the time Beatrice is already Dead and he decides to take her memory and put it into another body). Then they defeat Erika and everything goes accoding to the VN till the moment Ange chooses the door. So, the point is: Ryukishi is a witty bastard who puts the beginning of the story in the very end. But after I reached that I was amazed. Wish you luck, witch-hunters!

[@Phant0mC0bra]

Actually, according to the manga, the reason Yasu jumped overboard in the first place was so Battler could never find out about her "cursed body," so she really didn't tell him "everything."

[@liaw3166]

Featherine: "If I get stuck on writing, I always start with the ending." Episode 1 includes the ending, but only in a certain scene. Episode 1 also includes the beginning. Because in the meta, everything is concurrent and all the events are mixed up. There is still much more. The magic ending with Touya and Ikuko is a "magic" ending. This means, this is real if you accept "magic". And with this, one cannot say that this here is "the" truth. We'd miss a huge chunk of the story.

[@BenkaiDebussy]

Well, this *is* basically the ending of real-life Yasu/Beatrice's and Battler's (since he basically dies and is replaced by Tohru due to the memory loss) story. The meta can be interpreted in a number of ways (after-life, parallel universe, merely symbolic, etc), but at the end of the day the actual people are dead.

[@Wo_9]

My biggest gripe with the VN was them not telling the entire truth about Sayo being three people at once and the Rokkenjima massacre.

[@hopakpocc1264]

btw I think Ikuko is Sayo and your META-world is just her efforts to restore Buttler's memory in real world. But not everything. They write those stories about Rokken together. P.S. I apologize because of my english

[@MemoryDestiny]

I'm crying like mad... Usually...i need a good ending to be ok...but...i don't know, i think that this kind of ending suits this story really well, still i'm so damn sad for them, but it was impossible to live together outside...and i'm happy that he decided to die with her, instead of living alone... i like to think that they will be together somewhere...maybe for the eternity this time...and yet...i can't stop the tears!

[@Harlequina89]

MemoryDestiny It would be best if you just read the visual novel series yourself - right now. It's amazing. And the "happy ending where they get married" that you're referring to is simply the ending of an earlier episode (there are 8 in total). It's not the end of the series. There are two main endings in Umineko - The Magic ending, and the Trick ending. This video is only a part of the magic ending... it's not the full thing. My videos don't cover everything. But if you search for "umineko magic ending finale" on KZbin, you'll find my second magic end video that covers the very last bit of the magic ending.

[@MemoryDestiny]

Oh...yeah, i'm actually downloading it right now... I don't want to see it now...i what to keep some hope for the VN...

[@MemoryDestiny]

Harlequin Hi, i finished the VN..it's just incredible...but there's something that i didn't understand at all...i'm incredibly confused...

[@Destiny_Fvcker]

+Harlequin wait what there is an ending where they get married??? where?? xD

[@Phant0mC0bra]

+DestinyFucker KevinS. SPOILERS It's at the end of episode 6.

[@Earthquakesnight]

I cried..., I cried A LOT.... this is beautiful

[@MsEAVaxx]

Good job, Ohara-senpai and OnoD. Good job. For making us cry from this beautiful scene.

[@someoneelseee_]

It's kind of bittersweet to see Yasu being like this. It gives me the feeling that there are no happiness on Yasu's love story. Like when she fell in love with Battler. Battler broke his promise with Yasu. Yasu waiting for him for a long time. Then when she just finished the riddles that Kinzo proposed, she realized that she was born male, Kinzo's child, and her crush actually is her nephew. In this ending, It just gives me the feeling of Yasu's last wish with Battler before she decided to suicide. In addition, she also gives me the feeling of despair , the feelings that you aren't good enough for your crush and you never be, while your crush is completely out of your league. I just think Beatrice is actually such a great character. In ep 1-ep 4, she probably makes me bit mad. But the more I learn about her from Ep 5-Ep 8. She such a tragic character :')

[@nicbentulan]

ah it's like daenerys and jon snow. but well even more incestuous. nice. nice.

[@alicoskun42]

seems like you finished the vn. Can i ask you something?

[@justanothernguyen2334]

@@alicoskun42 what?

[@FichaGris]

@Mizuhim3 Not exactly

[@索蘭婭]

@@FichaGris biologically female

[@jeirigi5694]

beatrice jumped into the sea with a block of gold on her ankle, battler tried to reach her but couldn't take it and lost consciousness, so she died the moment she closed her eyes. Since the magic are decorations after the event happened, we can know that later when Tohya recovers her memories, he writes a forgery to explain the loss of her memories where his soul reached Beatrice and thus give it a happy ending to her life.

[@latemporis5430]

I love this ending so much. Beatrice telling Battler to close his eyes then kiss him, the two joking around, making the reader believe this is a happy moment and a happy ending is coming only for Battler to open his eyes and Beatrice is gone. She has always planned to commit suicide, she doesn't believe she can be happy. It's heart-wrenching, but makes perfect sense and not drama for the sake of drama.

[@ziwawe]

I replayed the last chapter recently and went impulsively for the trick ending without intending to... A defense mechanism if you will, I can only stomach so much emotional damage. Thanks Ryukishi.

[@saraslavica2128]

The amazing novel, amazing story, and characters thank you for the ride, i really enjoyed it to the very end

[@eletrica_]

EP06: Battler: "...That's right. If you reach the Golden Land, ...all love will be satisfied. ...However, like heaven and hell, that's not a place in this world." George: "I wouldn't want that. ...Love has meaning because we find it in this world. I could never support a sad lovers' double suicide, where they're only united after death. ...I'll stick to my love in life. I won't lose to anyone." oof... this foreshadow hurts

[@rizqmadani8529]

Thank you ryukishi, for writing the best story I have ever read, rest in peace beato

[@Jetshay]

i read umineko years ago and this scene still makes me lose my mind. the cutaway from the joking and kissing, to battler opening his eyes and both beatrice and the ingot being gone is a gut punch. did they really exist on that boat? or was this just another possible answer to a mystery that can never be solved? sayo's cat box, locked at the bottom of the sea, never to be opened. this scene makes me lose it

[@Satella_witch_of_dreams]

If you interpret this ending without magic, it would seem.... Sayo Yasuda just commited suicide but Battler dive in the water trying to save her but failed she actually drowned with the heavy ingot and Battler washing up somewhere in a nearby shore but got amnesia.

[@Dekross]

​@Fish_Eye-kun With or without magic, this is exactly what you are reading in this part. They are telling you clearly lol.

[@enkarion01]

BEST...GAME...EVER...!!!!!!

[@ambrose7196]

Maybe this is what Ophelia was thinking when she drowned herself. That her dearest Hamlet would reciprocate her love where none was to be seen.

[@SolarPhoenix61]

I cried like a little bitch when this happens. I read Umineko 5 years ago and still wish that I could erase my memory to experience this again.

[@ivoturi]

So it's been 10 years

[@DemonShirubia]

This has to be the saddest scene in any anime/manga/visual novel I have ever seen. Dat tears qq

[@adachivineboom]

Huh, to think today's the day Beatrice decided to close her eyes and seal the catbox of her life and Rokkenjima, and took us all with her in the depths of the abyss, forever resting peacefully in the sea... Oh, Beatoriche...

[@1114Daisy]

Most beautiful and best love story ever.

[@DanielGoodLarson]

This jumped loreley to the top of my favorite ost list

[@highlite888]

This is the true endíng and there is nothing after it, I believe in it! Both are and will stay immortal in their world. Best ending.

[@DanielGoodLarson]

I personally love the interpretation that the entire magic ending is counterfactual and is ange’s “blood red truth” she wrote when she killed herself. But, in the theme of the story, that in itself doesn’t make it any less of “the truth”

[@alrest8060]

@@DanielGoodLarson Magic ending is canon ending

[@ManuSenpai_]

This is where fiction peaked

[@goswamipratibha2010]

I loved the magic end with all my heart but I wish they had enough resources or time to put out the subtlety that they used in Manga to show that Battler who sank with Beatrice was mere illusion. Like in Manga, Battler wasn't able to speak inside water , also did not have his coat on. And later on, the one who catches Beatrice deep down the depths of water had his coat on, was peaceful and spoke normally to her.. But I guess both the VN and manga works in its own way. Loved them both ❤️😭

[@WatashiYutu]

The way the Novel does it is by pounting out that Beato saw Battler clearly floating to the surface but suddenly felt him right behind her

[@user-wb2tm3hv8w]

I officially declare that there won't be a single time in my life of me watching this without crying

[@Battlesthegolden]

OW , MY HEART! No but seriously, this was a perfect ending.

[@camicave9891]

I'M GONNA DIE FROM CRYING.

[@marcospisanis739]

A game that begins as a murder mystery horror game and then ends at being a modern tragedy.

[@_____._..--_]

If I want to summarize this story in a couple words, it’d be murder mystery incest romance fantasy story.

[@rexemuwu]

Or "Shit just went from 0-1000000 real quick."

[@zanemiracle6121]

3:34 My friend told his girlfriend this once...it did not end like this scene did

[@nemodog6977]

Hahaha! What happened?

[@somerandomguy6233]

💀

[@alejandroespin2183]

I can't... Too much tear to handle...

[@shockwave2291]

This scene is even more fucked up when you realize Beatrice/ Sayo is related to Battler, and is herself the product of incest. Jesus what a tragic life she had.

[@joejoe-vm1fj]

no she is related to all of them except battler, because he is actually kyrie's child and not actually related to any of the Ushiromiyas

[@fai_z]

​@@joejoe-vm1fj uhh aint like battler is son of kyrie and still also the son of rudolf?

[@joejoe-vm1fj]

@@fai_z yes he is not related to kinzo in any way, and therefore not related to beato

[@SeiyaTempest]

@@joejoe-vm1fj Huh? Rudolf is Kinzo's son, unless I'm forgetting something.

[@joejoe-vm1fj]

@@SeiyaTempest no rudolf married kinzo's daughter, rudolf is not kinzo's son. he married Asumu Ushiromiya, and took her last name.

[@IIIlIIIlIIlllll]

I cried too much.

[@froufroudeluxe]

Welp, here I am watching this video again knowing damn well I’m going to be a blubbering mess. Why do I deliberately keep doing this to myself?

[@ordinary60]

They already achieve the eternal of loving each other,they seal the cat box so that their tale still live on.This is not the ending of their love story,this is their beginningt of eternal love tale.Thats why at the end of the credit scene it wrote "I offered this tales to my beloved witch, Beatrice".

[@DanielGoodLarson]

And if you look at the lyrics of ricordando Il Passato its literally this “Rest in peace in the story that I have written, you can fly in freedom” is enough to make a grown man fall to his knees in walmart

[@toshio1334]

It's interesting how in the manga we can see this scene more from Sayu's point of view.

[@shadowcouncil911]

i cried like a bitch.....

[@MemoryDestiny]

Me too...

[@shakirashipslied9721]

Frederica Bernkastel Yeah Me too

[@Andy-lr6cc]

We all did. I cry everytime I see this.

[@mariohernandezgonzalez3283]

I am so happy because I knew Umineko. Peak fiction

[@ManuSenpai_]

Still the greatest thing ever

[@dmsys6516]

Definitely is

[@nievesshiratama3964]

The most beautiful scene in history, hands down.

[@DanielGoodLarson]

GOAT

[@josuelafountaine5147]

Just for the record. The multiple personalities theory is just a means of explaining and segwaying into what it truly is but many people fail to pick up on. Yasu created Shannon, Kanon and Beatrice as characters/imaginary friends/roles to act to give her life meaning. Much the same way Sakutaro is Maria's imaginary friend. The entire scene in episode 4 with Maria and Rosa can be interpreted as a major hint to how Yasu works. "Sakutaro is DEAD. Sakutaro is DEAD" "Kanon is DEAD. Shannon is DEAD." Yasu is not a delusional crazy person with multiple personalities. She's much more than that. Also for the record I DO appreciate and love the RosaTrice theory. I just don't see how it can discredit the ShKanonTrice theory in any way. Since most of the "proof" that it does, is based on mistranslated red. I like both theories because I have a strong understanding of both.

[@BenkaiDebussy]

Finally, someone who actually has decent reading comprehension. It's amazing how many people completely misunderstand what is going on with Yasu.

[@AirahsELL]

No, she has it but it's portrayed more realistically. There are many times when someone with DID is unaware of the "other" but the "other" is fully aware of who and what they are. Yasu wanted to be everything for everyone since she was desperate to be loved and would adopt the different personalities in order to do it.

[@meeramalhotra33]

@@AirahsELL Having imaginary friends and playing their roles isn't DID smh. You could say she had an identity crisis, but not a brain disorder.

[@AirahsELL]

​@@meeramalhotra33 It was definitely DID and not just imaginary friends, although that was a part of it. Sayo believed herself to be Shannon, Kanon, and Beatrice all at different points. It wasn't just her acting like someone else.

[@meeramalhotra33]

@@AirahsELL You've obviously never read about or encountered people afflicted with DID then. It's a very debilitating mental illness and a chaotic one at that. There is absolutely NO WAY someone with DID can go about being undiscovered by the members of the Ushiromiya household for so many years; especially the employers; even with sheer dumb luck, due to their strict conditions and hostile environment. What's even more impossible is planning and executing such intricate murders, which would then require Yasu to CONTROL which alter will be in charge of their body and when at any given circumstance, and cope with the accompanied memory loss experienced by the host personality during the transition. Especially when it's during a time of great mental instability like the annual family conference, you'd expect Yasu to be under so much stress that she'd be glitching in and out of alternate states due to the immense stress of executing her plan. And yes, she believed herself to be those versions of herself, because to her, they WERE different people even if they didn't really exist, and who is to say otherwise? It's just like how Sakutaro was a real friend to Maria even though it's obvious she's only playing pretend and being a ventriloquist for the stuffed lion doll.

[@YaminoSeigi]

if Yasu=Ikuko theory hold any water this scene can be interpreted as both Battler and Yasu decided to throw away their identity and live a new life though some accident happen and battler got amnesia when he reach the shore.

[@hopakpocc1264]

www.reddit.com/r/umineko/comments/7mq6rx/sayo_is_ikuko/?

[@KnightOfEternity13]

I really like this theory. I haven't think about it myself before, but actually it gives a lot of sense.

[@suhas5650]

actual copium

[@grimkaizer8417]

@@suhas5650 Right? People can't appreciate a bittersweet or tragic ending.

[@suhas5650]

@@grimkaizer8417 somewhat annoying too because that theory directly undermines the magic ending.

[@wafellzdude9210]

such a beautiful scene

[@All_Powerful_God_Enel]

The moment fiction peaked

[@hachijospaniard5643]

And then, fiction die.

[@ŸYenØôô]

Stop overrating

[@dr3549]

Man, this scene is close to perfection

[@joaquinjovane135]

and why close. but not it

[@이한결-d7f]

This is sadest ending I know. I want to cry.ㅠ.ㅠ Poor and sad destiny of Beatrice.

[@Sophia-s7z7n]

I made research about there couple befor and i already like her and god i now i finally see her death, i'm about to cry its so beautiful and sad in same time.😢

[@adnaP_esreveR]

If I read this comment some time ago, I'd say: "Fuck no, they're the antagonist and the protagonist, there's no way this would happen." ...Then I read Chiru and horribly regretted the fact that I did not listen to my female instincts that were whispering: "Hey, Beato loves him." and tried to find a 'logical whydunnit' for Beato. I'm a kind of person who wouldn't lend an ear to sound of her heart, unless she thinks it is 'logical' to do so.

[@blandon93]

When I saw Kanon in anime adaptation, my first thoughts were "Hey this girl is really depressed". I wish JessLambda or BatKanon's ending was canon in some kakera.

[@twiinapocalyp2e2]

i only now understand that the reason the ingot disappeared is probably because yasu intended for it to weigh her down so she could drown.

[@fm0363]

You're right, it is shown in manga

[@blackteagentleman9235]

Beatrice the best waifu!

[@stormyxx2298]

Erika best waifu

[@BrianSora]

Stormy Xx hell no

[@venor2612]

*do you mean Shannon?*

[@mynameisjugemu-jugemugokon3345]

@@venor2612 funny they are the same person

[@venor2612]

@@mynameisjugemu-jugemugokon3345 lmao yes

[@Treeskrub]

Honestly I love magic ending so much that it makes me not want to see the trick ending in fear of ruining the magic ending

[@TheBBCSlurpee]

Bro is leaving the catbox alone

[@thefable2874]

I don't know, Be sad, Be happy, that was amazing

[@SeiyaTempest]

What a perfect ending to a visual novel masterpiece.

[@tenaciousrodent6251]

You know what: There is a limit to the dose of post-modern i can absorb before my brain turns into green goo.

[@han8281]

i keep cursing and crying at the same time. what KIND OF ENDING IS THISSS *cry*

[@airmanon7213]

I think this one got me in the feels.

[@Sorablu12]

And I'm crying

[@abowlofsangria3412]

I have something I want to get off my chest as of right now: MY HEART HURTS! Best pair I've seen n I'm crying. Rest in peace Battler n Beatrice.

[@mekakode]

I cried.

[@Vinnygatari]

i've never been the same after this

[@patri_zzz5013]

Even after I finished watching the video, IM STILL CRYING omg

[@Destiny_Fvcker]

omg they kissed. ugh i wish it was shown. i srsly died.

[@A_Fridge_Named_Arisu]

Well if you read the manga tho...

[@Beta_World778]

Read the manga

[@irishock]

I think she realizes at the end that Battler would have accepted her no matter what

[@cesiumverbal102]

/SPOILERS AHEAD though i dont know if I would need them here but The Battler Beatrice died with is most likely an illusion, considering how he floated to the top and became Tohya... Which means Yasu died alone.. I...

[@jujuyoyo26]

There is two différents interpretations of this ending: 1. The person who is beatrice (probably yasu) came with battler on the boat, then she "fell", and battler survived, but i don't like this one 2. More symbolic, battler was always alone on the boat, but he couldn't forget beatrice, so his mind "died" with her, that's why tohya has not battler's memory, and the reason why the 4 first tales are full of witches and all is because battler's mind won't remember anything but a witch, hé doesn't xanthiques to have a human culprit

[@ehhhthell2236]

+YoyoGames Well its more like Battler and Beatrice left on the boat together, but Beatrice couldn't live on with the guilt and such, ended up deciding to fall using the ingot as weight to hold her down. Battler went after her in the ocean to try to save her, but ended up rising and surviving in the end. Though "Battler as a person" pretty much died along with her.

[@Phant0mC0bra]

+Ehhh Thell Actually, if you read the manga version of this scene, you'll see Beatrice's reason for jumping ship wasn't simply guilt. It's pretty sad.

[@BenkaiDebussy]

#2 wouldn't explain how Battler knew how to get to the boat in the first place.

[@BenkaiDebussy]

Yeah - she basically realizes (or at least assumes) that her love with Battler is doomed to fail the first time they decide to sleep together, and would rather just die now before their relationship is ruined. For what its worth, I think that Battler may have actually been okay with it. Not George though, that guy would have probably murdered Yasu if he found out Shannon wasn't actually (physically, at least) a girl.

[@unowen19]

Best pairing ever!

[@johan8485]

This ending would make the toughest man cry

[@DanielGoodLarson]

Falling to my knees in Walmart listening to ricordando il passato

[@marialuke2116]

9:14 That's where if I were Battler, i'd attempt a leg lock. Awkwardness be damned, I wouldn't let her die.

[@asuraspath2262]

You are a weeb, you wouldn't do Jack.

[@tofi5952]

What about standing really close to Beato instead of locking her?

[@han8281]

*crying waterfall*

[@my-san569]

The manga version shows the truth of this scene, but is not recommended for those who value the essence of the story. If you want to understand Yasu, by all means, go ahead.

[@redvelvetstars1980]

There’s another part to this ending 😢💔 it still makes me cry though

[@goobermagoob9160]

I’m not crying , you’re crying.

[@Малиновка-с2з]

прям прослезилась...

[@Rorotte]

Only the final episode has a choice you can make.

[@The.Youtuber.with.no.Name.]

Remember, if you remove the meta, you can see the truth. Nothing happened, there was no love and there was no Beatrice. Battler ran to the dock, found a piece of gold, took it with him, undid the boat and ran away. Then, as he tried to remain steady, as it was shown that he didn't love movement, the shockwave of the bomb knocked him out of the water and he slowly drowned in the water causing irreparable damage to his brain. This what happened to Battler in Prime.

[@miguelmelhado7089]

A small and fragile tale... Of the deepest depths of the darkest shadow where a faintly glowing golden rose rested Stupid tears...

[@dlwk1988]

True ED, Best ED = This ED

[@1o1opanda-74]

Im not crying i promise

[@shambridevino4775]

Wasn’t it Shannon’s love for battler, but then Beatrice/Yasu took that love into her own heart because she wanted to know love.

[@lambdadeltasfanclubmanager9078]

Beatrice and Shannon are different personas of Sayo Yasuda (the human culprit/writer of the message bottles/the true identity of Beatrice, Shannon, and Kanon). Sayo gave rise to her Beatrice persona through the pranks she pulled on other servants, but soon gave the witch persona her love for Battler along with the qualities of Battler's ideal woman (blonde hair, well-endowed breasts, a feisty personality). Added the fact that Sayo (who was simultaneously Shannon and Kanon) had to deal with their love for the other cousins, with George being for Shannon and Jessica being for Kanon. It's complicated, I know, but Sayo Yasuda is a very complex character that Umineko tries best for you to understand her. Everything about her heart is laid out in the story, begging to be understood and maybe even one day, loved.

[@davidfuckingblood]

the cat's out of the bag

[@eyerocks]

The story plays out until this part, he gets found by whats her face and he develops brain problems and plays himself as a man named Tor- something. That woman with him is featherine (The story writer inside the story and outside.) since battler was too brain damaged, he remembered all the events as Battler's not his own and eventually found Ange as "Kotobuki" He delays their meeting for years until finally they meet, have a sad moment, meet once more, official ending of story as the weight of "Battler Uroshimiya" is now taken from Tor- something.

[@razuhiko27]

i wonder why battler doesn't seem to be affected on what happened on his last 2 days on rokkenjima. this makes me thinks he's kind of accomplice or sumthing.

[@mopsicool]

+Razu 027 No, he acted like that for Sayo. Just before this scene, he is shown not being able to accept the fact that his relatives died, making Sayo act like Beatrice to cheer him up. (At least in the manga.) But it does seem strange.

[@BenkaiDebussy]

It could also just be explained as shock at that point.

[@jillian5785]

YOU! YES YOU! This is the truth. THE ONLY TRUTH. There is nothing but the truth right here. Please don't search for any other ones :'(

[@IStoleThePies]

Best scene in Umineko

[@DanielGoodLarson]

Of all time tbh

[@waltahh]

This is peak

[@TheBBCSlurpee]

I feel so fuckin empty after finishing this

[@user-zj5gf7ht4k]

For me it's the most beautifull end that I know.

[@Troyjr2423]

i'm not gonna cry... i'm not gonna cry... ;3;

[@gumimegpoidtm2626]

Sorry Master, is a last favor... I can subtitle this video?... Why? Because it's one a of the most beautiful scene from Umineko no naku koro ni Chiru, and is my wish than the people than speak spanish also can see and listen the last cat box... This is my wish... Please Master. :) Thanks for read. P.D. Thans for the video. Arigatou sensei. :).

[@Harlequina89]

Sure thing, I understand. So go for it. :)

[@gumimegpoidtm2626]

Thanks. It's the last time :).

[@latiaos11]

+Carly Spayd Nope, Battler died and BATTLER sinked with her, Tohya was born from Battlers corpse

[@lptc5]

I guess a simpler way of putting it is that Battlers conscience stayed with Beatrice, but his body didn't, which is why Tohya survived but lost all of his memories

[@TheXxxprotogirlxxx]

battler surviving goes aganist the red absolute truth so toya isnt real

[@latiaos11]

no no you dont get it. Battler as a person died, he lost all trace of memory, everything. So he can't be considered as himself even tho it's his body, everything else was gone, so he couldnt be considered as Battler since his old self was gone forever. Think of his body as a vessel for a new person, since ''Battler'' left the body, a new conciousness had to take place, and that was Tohya

[@VOZZIFY]

+latiaos11 Exactly, in the same way Kanon was 'killed' in Episode 6 when Beatrice saved Battler, and took on the identity of Shannon.

[@zoeyk7369]

The game is so much more amazing then the anime.Im 7 years late lmao

[@xynium.]

Umineko in a nutshell:

[@KingMidasBDO]

The golden "Rose" T___T

[@highdark4]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who cried ;_;