Underwater Cities Board Game Review

[@photoben]

Glad the Kickstarter money has helped getting Elaine involved more, great review!

[@AthexTube]

Thanks for giving a great overview of the mechanics, and the details of the important points of this game. Also your videos keep getting better and better keep it up!

[@Table53]

Which underwater city has a poor understanding of irony? Atlantis Morisette! I'll show myself out..

[@StigSlashBro]

holy shit i love how funny you guys are. subbed.

[@c.w.2000]

Elaine, I love the colour of your sweater. It contrasts nicely with the blue board.

[@DiscoveryDarks]

0:54 That's 100% Xzibit down to the braid pattern and everything lmao

[@BeeCeeJay]

You are my favorite reviewers going, keep up the great work! :)

[@Skarpo89]

I love your reviews so much. Can't wait to meet you at UKGE!

[@feekygucker2678]

Played this three player a couple weeks ago... near perfect review imho: a fun, quite satisfying engine builder, but with a fair risk of AP and the regular euro point salad, but served in three courses with snacks (AHHHH! boardgames are not food!). Only thing I'd highlight is just HOW MUCH engine gets built in those ten little rounds. Cheers folks :).

[@pauk.w]

I'd go even further than that - the engine is all in the last six rounds! The first four rounds are little more than an advanced set up. Things really heat up after the first resource phase.

[@treyalsup]

The card draw is a problem. You can just crap out on your draw. Same is true of Race for the Galaxy, but Race is so much shorter, so it's less bothersome. Race also gives you more tools for addressing the card draw "problem."

[@Knudegon]

I actually disagree. I've played the game around 20 times now, and I feel like the card management is the real beauty of the game, that forces you to change the path during game. For every game it feels less important what you draw, and more important how you make the most of the cards while still focusing on some kind of overall masterplan. For me it's a really key part of what I like about the game, that the cards really forces me to rethink my plans - and somestimes even ignore the cards, and go for the much needed action, or at other times go for certain actions mostly to get a strong important card played.

[@drymeatpowered]

Great Review. This is my favourite game from 2018. Absolutely love it. I really like that I almost never need to look at the rule book. The cards have both symbols and explanations. Since you discard cards at the start of your turn it gives you something to think about between turns. I’ve avoided 4 player and that doesn’t bother me much. The game gives me a similar feeling as Castles of Burgundy another favourite of mine. Another game that’s better with lower player counts.

[@ilk3000]

6:05 You can only upgrade the structure you just built though. Which can be frustrating, but helps make turn order super important when everyone wants to do upgrades at the same time.

[@EzFlyers10]

So it's finally gone up for sale in the US, got my copy yesterday and they have changed the production from your review! The player boards are very thick.. just as thick as the board. There are only a few x3 tokens, too; lots more singles, which is better

[@redsands1001]

Only played with 4 and one of my usual players has AP. Long but enjoyed it. The others did remark on the rulebook being very good. Especially compared to Last Will and pret a porter

[@BeingFriends]

this makes me really want this game.

[@krzysztofwrona2426]

I found it interesting that the game designer's surname is Suchy, and he made a game about cities underwater. "Suchy" translates to "dry".

[@eticaraface]

Glad to see you both back ;)

[@johnpanagos5835]

great review! im on the edge to buy this! i will propably etch upgrade it, if i do. thnx for the video guys

[@Ruloathesome]

Great refreshing review guys

[@ThymeKeeper]

Mmmmmmm......card-driven engine builder.....oh baby....

[@marcelcwertetschka-mattasi5467]

Nice review - the one thing that makes a difference between terraforming mars and underwater city is for me: Terraforming Mars is all about long term planning and payoffs for your engines, while Underwater Cities is all about adapting to your current situation (available actions and cards) - in a way like Strategy vs Tactics - thus I really like playing both.

[@Spoofsc]

Great review as always. Thanks!

[@Table53]

1:30 Did this joke come from a That Mitchell & Webb sketch?

[@NoPunIncluded]

Not until you mentioned it.

[@bb-8droid364]

Great review. You both looked like you were having a scream.

[@stuartcoyle1626]

"A little green rosetta make a muffin better"

[@Carighan]

I think my biggest problem from the video is the bendy bender boards. I hate how everything from china feels more like a wrap nowadays, less like a board.

[@titwarbler]

what happened to Efka's thumb?!

[@titwarbler]

paper cut? dang, board game reviewing is more perilous than I thought

[@chrismurphy9932]

Great review, you guys are quickly becoming my favorite reviewers. I've been on the fence with this game and I have yet to watch a review that helped me make up my mind one way or another. Until now, that is. It is definitely not for me, it's got too much of the same problems that Terraforming Mars has for me. I know they're different games, but my issues were randomness of the card draws, length of the game at higher player counts, bad components and art, and lack of theme. All of which this game seems to have in spades. Thanks for saving me time and money though, much appreciated :)

[@TheBoardGameKaptain]

I have to ask, how was the Kelp Beer? Great video as always guys!

[@NoPunIncluded]

Much better than expected. I don't tend to like darker beers because they often have one dominating flavour and this was just not that. Also, not as briny as you would think.

[@pupski69]

Good beard, nice hair, love the pink..

[@TravisPrebble]

Lyle's Black Treacle is trademarked, but treacle by itself is not. Yes, this is what stood out to me.

[@chrismusix5669]

Today I realized that 'action' rhymes with 'distraction'. I'll have to remember that.

[@i4m3rr0r]

Why is the Mansions of Madness Expansion not standing next to the base game? What is wrong with you guys..

[@robertchmielecki2580]

I definitely get an invigorating feeling from bras!

[@RansomATP6266]

That is a pretty good beer

[@jonathansaah9163]

You guys, this is brilliant!😀

[@Skarpo89]

That must be one big bathtub, or poor baby sharks :(

[@egoDEATH33]

card driven engine builder

[@TheLuminousCleric]

Actually, a city on its own is worth 2VP, a city with a single factory is worth 3VP.

[@ashleykilgour1903]

Ninja mic stand!

[@ktotheramer]

Ah, classic meta kelp beer humor! Well played!

[@AhJong0]

Lol nice Mitchelle and Webb look reference with the script being in existence.

[@HeadCannonPrime]

That 4 player thing isn't a minor problem, its a huge problem. I pretty much only play games with 4 or more players which puts this game RIGHT OUT.

[@jacktorrance3522]

This seems to be new trend in board gaming - god awful graphic design. It's subjective, of course, but I think that Terraforming Mars looks like a prototype print-and-play with it's shonky artwork and while the theme of Underwater Cities appealed to me more (I hated TM to be honest) when I saw the artwork I was really disappointed. The most recent game to suffer from this is Ark Nova. Hard pass on all three for me.

[@onepingonly1941]

Neither of you transmitted genuine liking of this game. It sounds more painful than enjoyable, kelp beer or no kelp beer.

[@Tantusar]

“Does it say how we end this sketch?” Abruptly.

[@billable1861]

😂

[@GeorgeZupster]

So it feels, like EVERY SINGLE ONE MADE BY STRONGHOLD GAMES???

[@paulrumohr]

I love great artwork in games... and this just doesn't have it. With so many options, that have both great art AND game play, this game is a pass for me and not going into my collection.

[@billable1861]

Can you give me some recommendations or examples of what does both well? I’m new to board games but I can handle relative complexity.

[@sunlioness1]

@@billable1861 Trickerion, Vinhos, The Gallerist