UNI+G's Team Orange - Red Flavor (Original : Red Velvet) [The Unit/2018.01.04]

[@aizamimbala6024]

After watching Red Velvet covers I realized Red Velvet's unique vibe that not anyone can copy

[@yukamblayu119]

Agree 💯

[@hellocoree5722]

Wendy's highnote in Red Flavor is really hard to reach.

[@yenolobia3337]

I agree

[@ZippityBopPop]

It’s simple with vocal training. I can hit it with ease while I can see that someone without training could have trouble.

[@user-ff7fs4sj7r]

@@ZippityBopPop w that choreo too?? i dont think everyone with just vocal training can do that

[@ZippityBopPop]

c I mean I can’t dance well, but every time I go on a run I sing so I can train my voice further. I’m sure it’s the same as dancing.

[@neocxty1298]

@@ZippityBopPop same but i dont train..

[@duyduy07]

After watching this I realize how wonderful RV is Specially Wendy

[@blackpearlwendy1684]

Tea

[@luviedeul2823]

lmao

[@bof8oom]

lmao true

[@sabananadg503]

lol agreed

[@blue.kiwi.3220]

That's why they're my ult bias group!

[@leonardodavinny421]

Now I understand why it's rare to see people covering SM Songs for auditions and performances.

[@ohdaddy1982]

leonardodavinny when you said it, you’e right I’ve literally never seen (or maybe seen it but forgot) any auditions that covers Sm songs

[@leonardodavinny421]

@@ohdaddy1982 I've seen some auditions in Produce but they were either so-so or really bad. The Loveshot performance in Produce was good tho but it's not an audition.

[@huanathan]

@@leonardodavinny421 Pd48 Stone Music girls covered Chewing Gum by NCT127 tho and its great

[@leonardodavinny421]

@@huanathan yeah it was good. One of the few

[@edmondantes1334]

@@huanathan sorry chewing gum by NCT dream not NCT127

[@reveljane]

Red Velvet has no cute concept. That's a misconception to them. RV has vibrant concept instead, that's their red side. Hope RV songs will be given justice in the future. 😭😭😭

[@onlyjhopecansmooththis6063]

I think rookie is their very first cute concept

[@yizhuoluv2186]

They have cute concepts, but red flavor isnt one of them

[@onlyjhopecansmooththis6063]

@@orxihui but its still a cute concept

[@mnaufalzidki4712]

@@orxihui rookie is seduce concept haha

[@alondsss]

Rookie is cute but with swag. It is vibrant. You can't explain Red Velvet song with one word. They are 2 in 1 HAHAHAHA well 🤷‍♀️

[@bituinn]

8:57 she’s the only one that delivered well. the one who looked fresh not cute.

[@cindyyu8396]

She left the show though :(

[@derastuff5123]

Well i think same:)

[@aleena158]

What is her name?? I don't really watch the whole show

[@cindyyu8396]

@@aleena158 I think her name is i

[@cindyyu8396]

ahmad seasearch up I the unit

[@minyoongi6198]

Red flavor was meant to be a mature/growing up kind of concept,but their voices are over exaggerated, also their cute gestures

[@yanlu7729]

Their mv was fruit themed, what’s mature about that?

[@julslapena195]

Yan Lu LOL HAHA

[@madi22415]

@@yanlu7729 I'm guessing you know nothing about 'Red Flavor' Don't talk on subjects you know nothing about. If you watch the M/V and pay attention you'll understand WHY its that concept.

[@yanlu7729]

How rude and disrespectful. Maybe I don’t know about the concept, and guess what? Maybe I think the concept doesn’t matter! They focused it on totally owning their own routine, not trying to copy RV’s MV. This routine was great in their own style. They weren’t supposed to copy RVs concept. I’d appreciate it if you’d apologize but that’s wishful thinking. Idc about the concept, it’s the music and dance that matters

[@madi22415]

@@yanlu7729 You made a comment saying their concept was about fruit and how that's mature. Now I'm not gonna explain because it takes forever. I was NOT being rude and disrespectful I was trying to inform you that the concept WAS mature and or about growing up. Now when I read your reply you just sound self centered and that's on that. But yes they weren't supposed to copy the M/V and whatever but they didn't have to put a fake over the top cute voice that was obviously forced. This is just my opinion and you don't have to agree with me. Now I'm gonna just not reply to any more of your comments because I'm not trying to start an online fight, That's trashy. Have a GREAT rest of your day/night. P.S. You aren't getting an apology. Sorry.

[@victoriazamora5275]

I’m having flashbacks to the rookie cover from idol school 😬

[@shiningksg]

That was a total nightmare for me.

[@mihanni2214]

Oh my god I can't stop thinking about it now. But at least most of the girls here can sing reasonably well

[@Coquettelectricmilk]

IMO this team is better than the rookie team Lmao

[@hollywu2921]

I'M CRYING ABOUT THIS COMMENT BUT YOU AIN'T WRONG 💀

[@alexgrae8226]

The forced cutesy voice is already making me cringe but the face they are making are giving me stroke.

[@TheLittlePaloma]

They seriously sound like babies. I don't think they listened to RV's song properly their voices are not meant to be that high or babyish.

[@wandacora1295]

The Little Paloma someone probably forced them into this I bet or probably they thought red velvets song was cute

[@Qteecherry]

@@wandacora1295 from what i see it was their dance teacher the first one looks good but then she said it not refreshing enough

[@hilamonalexamikaellec.5779]

bae bae yeah and because she’s the DANCE teacher she meant that the first dance wasn’t refreshing enough.... and i agree.. the dance teacher had nothing to do with their overly high baby voices ..:. It’s just their misconception of red flavor

[@theetaurus1832]

i mean at the end of the day it’s THEIR performance so they do it how they want, that’s clearly the range the probably are all around as a group so they sang in that range. it’s literally basic chorus or singing rules. dumbass.

[@xxsrnxx8112]

not to be rude but why are they covering RedVelvet’s song knowing Red Flavour is a fresh and bright song, not a cute one. Their voice suits Twice song better i swear.

[@lionelmarcussolaris2858]

I will agree. I think it's the "trend" thinking. Maybe because they think it is on the Aegyo trend but it's more of a complex song. It should show happiness, not cuteness. No wonder many love Red Flavor due to it making people happy and feel refreshed. Unlike the cutesy concepts which makes you cringe unless it's not over the top cute.

[@카빠프라이드]

Their voices will not suit twice songs. There’s a reason almost no groups cover twice songs in its original arrangement. It’s harder than people think and people underestimate twice’s vocal capabilities.

[@potatohead4997]

카빠프라이드 i agree, and even if twice does cute concepts, this group will not suit twice song, their voices are too cute and i’m not sure if they can reach the high notes (depending on which song)

[@qwrlrp4183]

Tbh the first one (the one at the training stuff) its veeeeery different than the one ots, the first is more red velvet like and the stage more cutesy like, so I think they supposed to do better but the trainer make them change it at make it more cutesy

[@카빠프라이드]

@@qwrlrp4183 they are actually told to make it simpler not more cutesy. So I guess it's the groups fault that they interpreted bright and bubbly differently.

[@est.2oo417]

Red flavor doesn't suit in cute concept. Its suit at Nature and fresh .And i think the aegyo is too much.

[@thirisu1673]

Right

[@wirakuma2954]

Now you know being Red Velvet wasnt easy, their did 3 comeback last year. How hard they practice.

[@lulutania8587]

wira kuma yeah

[@alondsss]

Jjang!

[@AConfessionOnline]

They also had to practice "Look" and I bet they was a really hard dance

[@junia4129]

This makes me realized that Red Velvet is AMAZING.

[@nyotfang8761]

8:55 i wish they wouldn’t have split wendy’s part, the long brown haired girl sounded like wendy and sung her part so well

[@vwinky7195]

ikr i love her voice so much, she kinda sounds similar to yeonjung from produce 101 :D

[@feslisa-8312]

she is b1a4 baro's sister

[@danielac.9974]

@@vwinky7195 yes, yeonjung vibes

[@yoonhan3512]

i agree

[@yoonhan3512]

i agree

[@claire5306]

The rap... God, this version gives me an image of a bucket of sugar being shoved down my throat instead of a refreshing juice.

[@btscristianchimchimstrashc2436]

Jibangchii where does it start?

[@yushinie9533]

BTS CRISTIAN CHIMCHIM'S TRASHCAN very dirty 8:14

[@exowthyou]

The Yeri part was better than the first part ig

[@sagit1165]

COPIED COMMENT

[@elishafilomeno3369]

Btw Im sorry but this performance is like cake that has too much sugar, a bunch of frosting, and a bucket load of sprinkles which Is a bit too sweet for me

[@jaedenn877]

oh goshhh.. I relate, it was too much aegyo for me. Too much unnecessary gestures and expressions for me ＼（〇_ｏ）／

[@jaedenn877]

@〜I see that I'm ICY〜 Yeaa, at least it was better than the rookie one..

[@mutlifandomar3114]

Red velvet isn’t meant to be cutesy. They tried this in idol school too, it didn’t work and it isn’t working now.

[@mutlifandomar3114]

They’re talented people but this didn’t fit them.

[@littlechocs]

agree

[@maikom8693]

I feel so sorry towards Red Velvet

[@kelseygonzalez5610]

Agreed

[@yay8371]

The song isnt really for cutesy type but it really is hard when thats you strong point and want to show it to the fans its hard to adjust. Overall i didnt like the performance but i think they were just unlucky with the song.

[@kaelanhilliard9969]

It was better before the teachers gave their input....they kept talking about it needing to be refreshing but it seems as the final result they're confusing refreshing with cute. Red Flavor is a really refreshing song indeed, but the only person who came close to suiting the songs tone is 아이 (I). I like that they tried to make it their own, but sadly this is a case where they shouldn't have done that, Red Velvet's concepts are too unique to try and venture into another concept. None of their songs or dances work with cute expressions or cute tonality...Yeri just naturally has a cutsie higher voice but even then she doesn't try at all to be cute, she uses her full natural voice to fit Red Velvets vocal concept. But I blame this on the judges/teachers....

[@ughgowonsscalpandcrunchyvo4926]

lmao am I the only one who thought that the original girl ( long black hair ) who was supposed to sing Wendy’s high note sang better than the blondie?

[@daaisyrose]

No. It's true

[@melleonA]

Aely it’s a fact.

[@julidiaz1295]

Facts

[@aubreyparungan1401]

She's kinda straining her voice that's why the trainer said that it's risky

[@Moonchild99]

@@raphaelmartinez7638 but it's dangerous for her voice. It's a vocal health issue not a aesthetic one. Her voice it's prettier but it's dangerous

[@liezammm]

No hate. but they sounded like chipmunks being squished. Oh my ears. I need the original to get this headache out from this 😭😭

[@exowthyou]

I went to rv real quick after watching this lol

[@horriblesquidparty]

Rather than drinking a refreshing fruit smoothie it was more like eating a tablespoon of sugar.

[@승민전-s6v]

jeon cena This comment 😂😂

[@aijazkhan5026]

lol 😂😂😂😂

[@thehope-jiofyourlifeu7456]

IM CHOKED

[@areyoukirringmeirriyaa]

STOP KCJNVDO

[@prettyfreak4269]

errmmm no

[@junsookhererenjunsgirlfrie7520]

I dont know why but seeing other girls cover RV songs just made me so proud of RV, I really can’t compare their vibe to anyone when theyre performing!! RV is classy and cute at the same time 🔥

[@fourthofoctober8436]

I had to rewatch RV's performance of this. I don't recall them doing much or any aegyo at all. They give off a natural entrancing vibe without trying. Edit: I'm so confused bc of I's name hahaha but I love her

[@user-qr6gs3nm9f]

A e d // I Real name is Cha YoonJi

[@まき愛]

The group gives the choreo a bit of their own touch and feel to it with the aegyo, thats why they did it, not to be trying too hard or anything, they are a cute group!

[@sakurachan5039]

8:56 I like her voice. Her voice is so strong and she is not trying hard and not trying hard to be cute. I Think she is my favorite

[@alex-pu6pr]

Sakura chan she’s what the concept is supposed to be . along with one other girl I can’t name . but this concept is fresh not cute

[@mihanni2214]

@@alex-pu6pr Sebin or Yujeong maybe? Yujeong is from Brave Girls, who do strong and powerful concepts so I found her to be less cutesy than the others (excluding I, she did wonderful)

[@phetsoisa]

girl 2:28 had the best vocals in my opinion, I think she could have done the bridge part on her own

[@christineselena3437]

I totally agree with u

[@KenSmith-lv7qd]

It was risky that's why they didn't do it

[@pretendtheresaname9213]

I don't know why they didn't go back and forth between her and the blonde? The line is divided in 3 parts, give her the first and the third, the blonde gets the second so the brunette can handle the third one better and everyone takes the chanting (that strawberry part). It seems like a no brainer arrangement.

[@haesoo215]

@@KenSmith-lv7qd if there is no one better than her in the group then it is not actually risky at all. I agree to the op that it was better

[@khatching2811]

they should've performed twice's or momoland song if they're going to do it like that

[@yunhotheestallion1230]

khat ching their voices wont even suit twice song this teams voices are too cutesy

[@boss_boy8777]

@@yunhotheestallion1230 exactly. All of twices song are just high in range. The be belting in the fucking chorus😭

[@wannableishere1156]

I am imagining them singing cheer up in a squeaky voice with pouting lips and excessive winks... errrrr no thanks XD but I'm sure the girls are nice off stage, just perhaps they thought being cute was the trend? But their cuteness seems to be too forced :((

[@lilychen1229]

See idol school cheer up pls

[@lucas_xx4447]

What are you trying to say about twice

[@mih8ko]

WHY IS EVERY GROUP THAT HAS COVERED RED VELVET ROOKIE AND RED FLAVOUR MAKE IT CUTESY AND VERY GIRL!?!? ITS NOT SUPPOSED TO BE CUTESY!

[@ゆい-h6g4y]

Clearly you havent watched the show, please watch it before commenting anything like this

[@mih8ko]

@@ゆい-h6g4y Lmao sorry if I offended u ngl I forgot I even wrote this, I didn't phrase it well I admit but sis I still stand by what I said✌️

[@skyelightss]

This is a late reply but yeah I agree with what you said. Red Flavor is supposed to be a summer concept and meant to be also about graduating, not like a cringy cute concept. Sorry but this performance gave me those vibes.

[@tahwann]

FOR ME The girl @7:32 is the best in this show 😊 she has a good vocal

[@rnianee]

Ketnapa Insang I think the same cause she’s the oldest and has more experience

[@julidiaz1295]

Much better than the blondie for me

[@nctea2545]

yeah same. I really don't know why they didn't let her keep her part

[@imaushanakim1956]

sameeee, Jiwon just shown her cute side yet she's the one who has the highest vote.

[@VyNguyen-mw3bf]

@@nctea2545 I think they were afraid that she wasn't stable enough for that long part, they had to dance too that's why they decided to split it .. but yeah she definitely has a better voice than Yebin. But I think Yebin can have a really pretty voice too with practice

[@bangtansbae3985]

From doing well in rehearsals to being a hot mess on stage... WTH just happened?

[@daaisyrose]

If this was in X Factor, Simon would be like "It's a complete and utter nightmare"

[@mai-uj6zn]

sometimes i hate him for being too honest but in this case, i would have loved him saying that...

[@esther-er3jx]

Red velvet is not supposed to be a cute concept. That’s why it never works when groups act cutesy when covering red velvet songs.

[@jungjoon66]

Eugene Poubelle they thing about this is that its ok bc its has be a bit differrent and there own style the don't have to be exactly like red velvet I like it bc it has kindve there own color

[@wannieluvs2274]

The opening sounded like a group of kid singing

[@alondsss]

Eugene Poubelle I don't know, but they can act cute. But the thing is, there is a bit of swag and sexiness 😍 only red velvet ofcourse.

[@lolwtf9267]

I still don't understand what Red Velvet's concepts are. All their songs sound weird af (not in a bad way)

[@Buffaylo]

RV concept is cult

[@christyweng]

why are they trying so hard...??? they sounded so much better during rehearsal and now they have the fake aegyo going on

[@fullmoon2349]

ikr. it was supposed to be fun concept not cute

[@yenniestan]

Yes, that choreographer ruined everything HAHA She should say that it was good... Sorry, but I think it was her fault LOL

[@mariri725]

David Andrey i dont think so.. she said to keep it simple since their formation was all over the place and too much was going on

[@yenniestan]

Justin Mari but they changed after what she said, right? I just watched this video.. maybe I gotta the wrong idea lol

[@jhopefirsthixtapemademyday659]

David Andrey she said simple is better then the group make super cute voices that doesn't sound simple at all

[@exog8848]

This song had a fruit concept because it should be fresh and natural, not trying hard to be cute and sounding cute! Just please!

[@allycat8290]

EXO G hahaha, I liked it.

[@littlechocs]

yep

[@arinmths]

were they really trying so hard to be cute? i feel like their charms are being cute. i’m not a fan of rv but i think this is one of the best rv’s covers.

[@鈴木-s7t]

agree

[@onceuponablink7666]

They were kind of coached to be a certain way but honestly I don’t think they’re being overly cute a lot of them just have higher voices than RV

[@LinhBui-yh5fy]

after watching this performance, I realize vocal in Red Velvet is very very good, and not anybody can replace well. Their concepts is not just cute but a more mature, this performance is so sweet but singers are not good enough

[@tharrasethurathnam7364]

don't wanna be rude and im not hating on them and I know they put in a lot of effort but lets be honest... they really butchered the rap

[@hurulynusama2854]

like they just learn how to talk fastly

[@arshiaden4170]

Honestly realised how fucking amazing yerene are in that rap

[@chrysantheemums]

sadly, but I agree

[@paparachiiiiiii]

it wasn’t that much different from the original live,, red velvet aren’t exactly known for their amazing rapping

[@rmblc]

I would like this comment, but it's already at 666

[@Balqissuraya96]

7:33 i only like her. Her high note is greater than the blonde one

[@siskakamilah925]

yes i think 아이 better than yebin. 아이's voice was natural, very natural and not annoying my ear. she was not trying to be cute as other girl. ahhh 아이 ❤

[@Balqissuraya96]

Siska kamilah junianatha ikr her voice is not aegyoish like others i love it. What group is she ??

[@siskakamilah925]

+balqissoo 아이 is soloist under wm. ent please support her! btw, she is so beautiful haft -_-

[@Balqissuraya96]

Siska kamilah junianatha agree... 👍

[@ughgowonsscalpandcrunchyvo4926]

balqissoo I agree I like her tone better. the blonde girl’s voice sounds flat

[@deatriamanda837]

Why do the always make that cute expression all the time.... Its too much tho😐

[@albabyahya]

most of them i think, i just watch red team doing "Gee" cover but it wasn't like my expectation :(

[@weijianau3057]

Exactly!!! ‘Red Flavor’ is not the type of song that 3-year-olds sing... the tone they use to sing is also tooooo cute, not in a good way unfortunately.

[@melodymachuca9024]

It's a South Korean show catered to South Korean viewers...basically the more cute the better. These shows aren't catered for us.

[@humanbeing8845]

taepudding basically, the cuter, the better*

[@melodymachuca9024]

you understood what I said, why the attempt at correction?

[@icanthandlehobisboogieboot5077]

*I'm so sorry but the extrem aegyo made me cringe so much.* And I think, like nearly everyone else here, that the song isn't suited for these (fake) cute voices. I'm sorry but this performance was... not horrible but very close to it. The rehearsal was much better tho, so we know the girls are better than their performance!

[@potato_stuff_stop_looking]

Yeah, I think this! The feedback RUINED their performance ;AAA;

[@zacvarg3530]

aegyo just makes me feel kinda... eugh... half the time it comes off as trying too hard.

[@allokdallok2378]

Red velvet is so amazing. Their quality is on next level. Wow.

[@chilla9907]

Blinking and winking once yeahhh that's cute But blinking and winking too much, thats cringey af

[@exowthyou]

7:35 worst thing I have seen in my life

[@ekasekarramandani4427]

@@exowthyou and 9:05

[@rafida1018]

Even smiling for too much is cringey for me🤢

[@chirucherryverse]

@@exowthyou omg that was sooo cringey😣 and everyone were saying that it was cute

[@essee7988]

While they couldn't stop smiling I couldn't stop cringing

[@phoebe6533]

Koreaboo version of red flavor

[@phoebe6533]

@@bubbletea4829 I’m not calling them koreaboos. I’m just implying that this is how a koreaboo would perform red flavor. Cringey~

[@purrplex8793]

Wouldnt it be weird if they performed Red flavor without any sort of expression? Yall complain so much when the mentors would tell them what to do on stage

[@pinkgyalxxie]

@@purrplex8793 fr

[@purrplex8793]

@@phoebe6533 stop acting like you onow how to perform better than this team, its utterly disgusting,

[@samsantos4499]

Now question me why redvelvet deserve the best performance award.

[@exog8848]

Sam Santos Dem freaking preach!

[@urmomraquel5407]

LMAOOOOO

[@borroborroborro5711]

I do. They cant even stay on stage without falling and breaking all their bones

[@kitbittkit]

@@borroborroborro5711 dude that was a staff error. Wendy was told to walk in an area where at the end would be stairs. Pitch black with no markings telling her where she was so she ending up falling several feet. Not her fault at all

[@everydaesundae]

I was cringing the whole time, sorry, I'm a reveluv myself and they didn't give Red Flavor justice ☹️

[@Kawaii21forever]

Sundae Indino ikr

[@putiya14]

Ok i actually agree with you 😭 they shouldn't force themselves for being cute

[@Jenica-g3d]

i cringed alot tbh *i appreciate their performance n they worked hard but its too much lmfao*

[@lovinnyu]

Agree :')

[@janelamoyo6413]

The voices are too much ...and they should not cute too much and it makes me cringe

[@bernaldenicemarie7493]

In conclusion, Red Velvet is a standard that no one can reach.

[@julidiaz1295]

3:16 Blondie was glaring at her like wtf. I think the brown haired girl is better than the blonde girl's voice (in the high notes)

[@wandacora1295]

Oi Felix the “blonde” girls name is yebin also I feel like you should know there names since if you have been active of watching them.

[@vwinky7195]

ikr i love her voice so much, she kinda sounds similar to yeonjung from produce 101 :D

[@CarmsLopez]

Calm down Wanda Cora the blondie ruind the song

[@wandacora1295]

carmslopez nah lm good thanks for the suggestion btw could you do any better? :)

[@wandacora1295]

carmslopez well not to be your just giving hate also the girls could’ve been forced into this cutesy aura you don’t know anything else about it so I don’t need to chill also it’s not the truth for me I have my opinion’s too :)

[@RVSVTTK]

It’s a good thing to see a cover of red flavor because this song is a bop. I really appreciate their hard work. It’s not an easy song to perform. Actually i’m really glad they did it in a different way, since it’s a cover so they don’t need to do it exactly the same as red velvet did because they’re not red velvet. I hope people could give them some supportive comments rather than being harsh on them 😃

[@myo2513]

Only red velvet can sing their songs. All the cover seems failed to me.

[@lulutania8587]

Bae Reveluv yeah i think so

[@alondsss]

Even the rookie 😥 Mygosh.

[@hallyuworld6786]

Bae Reveluv Nobody care about your opinion : ))

[@myo2513]

Hallyu World okay :)

[@luccabellag5443]

Hallyu World its a fact though-

[@pineapplewonho5146]

this is why red velvet is the best (no hate) but when will people realize, despite how cute the song might be... it's not supposed to sound 'cutesy'

[@exog8848]

pineapple wonho ikr! Only Red Velvet can do that. (I'm talking about why haters should not hate RV)

[@noppiichi]

Red velvet has got such unique concepts. Also they've got really strong vocalists like Wendy Seulgi and Joy

[@noone7780]

pineapple wonho it's a cover it doesn't have to be exactly like the original?

[@pineapplewonho5146]

no one i didnt say it has to be like the original, but why do they always have to make it so... cutesy? and yeah it's a cover that of course - depends on their future to see if they debut or not

[@rizamayasari2656]

@@noone7780 the purpose of cover is to make it sounds as close as originally intended. If they want to diverge it called remake. It is just simply bad, noy different.

[@deez3000]

"But why isn't it refreshing?" -Everyone in the comments

[@whenyoucantchooseabias5679]

4:46 lol

[@Nini0195]

Lee Suji killed it!!! Also, "I" should have kept her original part she sounded better in my opinion although I do like Yebin too but that's just my thoughts :)

[@candyyy6690]

I wonder why all of them tryin to sing this song in cute voice?

[@MaxineBryceAngelyCLiong]

candy 숭 I agree with you almost every girl group that covers red velvet songs they always make their voice cute especially girl groups that is in a survival show eventhough red velvet doesn't sing their songs in a cute or small voice.

[@leeanneparungao1277]

ikr! even their facial exp.

[@krystalissoojung5114]

seeing this video makes me realize that NO ONE can cover RV song as good as RV..

[@ngatlin34]

candy 숭 that's probably how their voices are...cause its a possibility

[@kingkrystal6123]

They sounded okay practicing but performing .. they didn't sound good at all

[@capstar4394]

This perf make me feel annoyed . Red flavor concept ain't being cute n all . They did well but they are trying too hard to be cute . Now , i know why rv is the best 💪

[@wirakuma2954]

Imma Fabulous ikr

[@albabyahya]

ikr (2)

[@reveluvarmyyt547]

Agree!!

[@tdk1236]

it was ok during practice but on the stage just...nope

[@spawesomegamerjakemineblox5254]

Imma Fabulous this is why its a cover

[@meatamusballonamew]

I think Suji and I are the most natural one, they’re using their own voices, which is something that I’m thankful for

[@firdhanaura6203]

Park Yeollie yebin’s voice is always like that so i think she’s natural too.. but the others..

[@sgrplm5453]

I thought Suji and you 🤣

[@meatamusballonamew]

Sugar Plum Hahahahahahahahaahahhahahahaah

[@WhoAmI-un3kz]

Yebin voice is natural u can see yebin singing

[@meatamusballonamew]

firdha naura Yup, I can tell just by her talking.

[@oldmarbles4310]

7:32 she’s the only one who didnt overdo her voice. Cha Yoonji (I), honestly this show did her so dirty, didnt even gave her the screentime she deserved while singing. There was a reason on why she left this show and this performance is just an example of it.

[@psark]

Watching other people cover red velvet is such a wake up call because now I just appreciate my girls even more. Like... They were out there slaying in the vocal and performance department flawlessly and none of us were giving them their due credit.

[@maryamsiddiqui4968]

8:30 till 8:43 was the best part tbh. They didnt make their voice cute and just kept with their own. Red flavour isnt a cute concept.... Justice to red flavour 😢😥

[@denoreo7962]

Cha Yoonji saved them to be honest! Her voice is so natural unlike the others

[@lynvilleanneho8645]

They tried to look and sound cute just too much😰

[@daventoyhacao]

Lei Anne Ho Riiight. Red Flavor was never meant to be cute, it should meant to be fresh and calm. Maybe they thought it was cute because of their attire and the lyrics of the song.

[@the.obagussanjaya8070]

i'm a fanboy of red velvet. believe me, i wanna to puke out after saw the half of it. you can ask any boy how they feel when they see this or see someone trying to sound cute too much. (i can write my own opinion right?)

[@buputrooms5131]

I agree

[@ssrb_poi6572]

the.o bagus sanjaya I'm a fangirl and this was definitely too much. Their voices were way too high pitched and didn't suit the song. Red velvet's voices aren't so high, their voices are powerful, especially Wendy. And I cringed when they did Irene's part. Not hating on the girls or anything but red velvet did much better

[@minsussailoroutfit1767]

VIXX version is better

[@oksure7131]

Honestly the girl "I" the one with long straight hair from WM ent. Fits the song better. She doesn't try to be cute like the other girls. And also she was given so little screen time. I'm angry for her

[@lonelinessscent8759]

This may be years late, but I seriously think Yoonji (I) leaving this show was not only because she was sick. They seriously did her dirty.

[@xxxxiina]

What happened?

[@JuriAMV]

they did I so dirty by giving her lines to yebin, biggest injustice since giving the rappers more lines in Give It To Me

[@themosquitowhobitjin6457]

Juri AMV that pisses me off so much. the disrespect towards her is just ughhh...she definitely show them real hard in the performance on how to slay a song. doesnt mean in practice she doesnt do good,she cant fix her mistakes. im kind of glad she left this show lol

[@kwells1111]

I hate how the dance coach said theres too much going on. Obviously theres gonna be alot going on, this team is doing a choreo thats originally for 5 people, no matter what they do its going to look hectic b/c the dance is already jumpy and energetic and the stage is crowded with 9 people. I have a feeling that when she said to simplify it, they decided to completely tone down the dancing and made everything cutesy which hurt their performance.

[@rosinjulyz]

Ikr i liked the choreo they made first

[@MoonKei]

Do they even watch rv actual performance lol

[@ahiseeyoureamanofcultureas1306]

MoonKei I LEGIT SEE YOU IN EVERY COMMENT SECTION

[@minsussailoroutfit1767]

EYE KEI ARE

[@altheaunetaitsokay6488]

True, I saw rookie in idol school and I have to admit Red Velvet is the only girl group that can pull off the essence of their own aura without losing the freshness.

[@jiminslefttoenail]

MoonKei clearly not xD

[@lisaoppa5784]

7:32 she’s the only one who didnt overdo her voice bruh

[@feslisa-8312]

she is b1a4 baro's sister

[@kathmiraclebana]

because she’s actually the only one who can SING, that’s why. imo. the others were just meeehhh especially the pink and blonde hair

[@karalourson1863]

@@kathmiraclebana the girl at 8:30 tho I think she did a really good job

[@mihanni2214]

@@karalourson1863 That's Yuji from 3YE! She was a member of Apple.B when she was on the Unit

[@karalourson1863]

@@mihanni2214 oh that’s very interesting thanks i knew 3ye but i didn’t know that was her

[@jeyd5339]

It started from bad to worst especially the rap part. >.

[@ehhh9659]

lol

[@1015creamy]

Nobody can sing red velvet song better than red velvet themselves

[@ysabeljavier2391]

red velvet shouldn’t watch this

[@jiminslefttoenail]

They would die of cringeness xD

[@yerimiestoleseulgisjam7488]

@@jiminslefttoenail true

[@julidiaz1295]

@방탄소년단 TAEHYUNG Bc red velvet's concept isn't supposed to be cute

[@shiloh8734]

That's kind of mean. I'm sure RV would appreciate their effort and be proud of them.

[@borroborroborro5711]

Red Velvet should disband so you all cry your eyes out

[@maddi8799]

Why did she say the song suited them when they sang it cutesy.

[@tinayay3208]

ButterLollipop because they're singing their way

[@karazor-el6440]

they should have chosen other girl groups if that's the case. did they pick the song themselves?

[@danilopaz1778]

No, it was random.

[@infinitelyinspirit11]

Kara Zor-el I think red flavor and gee were the only cute concepts they had

[@jasmine-hc7ru]

lowkey this performance is kinda bad bc Red Flavor isnt really a cute concept but more of a refreshing concept

[@aminael-haryry6547]

2:25 i think she sing it better than the other girl

[@summrsautumn9870]

I thought I heard red velvet on helium

[@nikki4176]

You made me crack up 👍

[@Ravenstar2296]

Hmm I disagree with the coach about splitting the part. Yebin"s voice hit the notes but didnt have the impact that I's did. I wonder if I just practiced it more whether she could hit it or not

[@siskakamilah925]

hmmm i think only 아이's voice can handle this song. her voice was natural and she was not trying to being cute like other. halla and 아이 were natural ❤

[@maiyoseob]

The rap part is mess

[@trenaoboh]

Agree I want Yeri to react to it. Since she wrote that rap and talk about how it's supposed to sound.

[@albertaanindiadhari2773]

+Trena Oboh yeah!!

[@sana-gc5qc]

Do you even know what she's saying no so how would you know it's not suppose to be the same as the original there suppose to have a fun twist on it and be creative I really don't understand you people

[@trenaoboh]

@@sana-gc5qc No it's just the whole rap is an mess. No hate towards them they did it a lot better in rehearsals.

[@sana-gc5qc]

@@trenaoboh oh ok I understand

[@mysea7778]

7:31 One and only person in this team that fit the song vocals and concept also not exaggerating or forcing cutesy (such aegyo) she just smile naturally 8:55 She nailed this part! 9:34

[@Lee-qw3bp]

2:26 she sounded just fine to sing on her own. Should’ve given her more lines to save the performance.

[@alreshyadheana9949]

7:25 cringeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee- and red flavor, is not a cute song. ONLY red velvet can sing their own song WELL.

[@otakukawaii3783]

So true🌚👏

[@whiffingcream7111]

And she got 1st place for that ..

[@maki-qv6es]

not only that remember when they(red velvet) sang Gee? and it was so identical? not completely but like 98%

[@trenaoboh]

@@maki-qv6es there gee cover was amazing.

[@kora2360]

ye I think no one can preform red velvet songs better than red velvet

[@TheMistyMolly]

I cringed the whole time... they have talent but whoever made them act so cute ruined the stage for them...

[@emmashadowkat5250]

This song doesn't suit cute

[@tykaika]

Emma shadow kat i should give you 100000000 likes

[@capumayannl]

Emma shadow kat your right they dont suit the song

[@HaiHai-mg6vz]

Their voices tho it's a bit too cute and all adorable 😂

[@twice3408]

Emma shadow kat This song is a cute song wth?? Did you even watch the video?

[@aisyahfitriazalia6002]

Red flavor is cute but this performance is way too cute. they are more suitable with twice or lovelyz song

[@lucynda6105]

Ai's technique is probably the best suited for the song, not too cutesy and is a chest voice. Yebin's voice falsetto and is quite bad technique, hence the unstableness and squeakiness. A lot of its pretty bad, but the part where Yebin replaced Ai's line just did it for me. Ai should've gotten the lines. And this is overdone. Drawback the aegyo because Rv did not comeback with this song with extreme cutesy in mind.

[@sophreads1619]

Well, covering red side of RV is indeed hard.

[@Frandahab]

The issue is that people don't understand the red side, it's not cute, it's refreshing and vibrant

[@cyl1833]

07:25 and 08:25 scared the shit out of me. Trying too hard.🤢

[@ohmygodsomeeaan6020]

The first one, Jiwon, wasn't trying too hard. Believe it or not, that's her actual personality.

[@lamiaprokrity3908]

@@ohmygodsomeeaan6020 yes thats why i love her!!!!

[@ohmygodsomeeaan6020]

@@lamiaprokrity3908 I'm still sad that Good Day isn't coming back, and C9 Girlz is now a thing. I miss Genie!

[@KiyuArate]

@@ohmygodsomeeaan6020 Im pretty sure Jiwon is actually redebuting in a new group called CIGNATURE

[@ohmygodsomeeaan6020]

Kiyu Arate They were called C9Girlz, now they are CIGNATURE. Haeun (Now Yeah), Viva (Now Sunn), Lucky(Now Belle), Jiwon (Now Jeewon) and Chaesol are in the group with two new girls. I'm so excited for their debut!

[@vivtano9611]

No hate but I singing Wendy's part was way better than when Yebin sang it. Her notes were flat and unstable.

[@littenkittenmeow]

Agreed. It seems the whole situation was made up. I clearly sang it with better technique, and it seemed like she just pretended that she couldnt do it to add some drama.

[@nyetre7665]

i think it was not on purpose. I just thought that korean really do prefer cute voices than stable and powerful ones. They really did not give justice to red flavor. It's understandable that they had to make the song as their own so they turned it into cute concept but it just doesn't go well with too much cuteness.

[@vivtano9611]

Nue True i've listened to a couple of DIA's songs before and I know for a fact that Yebin's vocal quality leans towards the cutesy and pitchy side. I understand that. However, what I didn't like was that you can hear her struggling while singing those lines compared to the rehearsal. Her notes were flat and shaky and she sounded breathy especially the last part (....yeoreumae neo) whereas "I" wasn't like that throught the entire performance at all. She would've given more life and justice to Wendy's lines had she sung it. Probably would've made the entire perf a little less of a disaster.

[@Kai-chow]

Idk this show been setting I up for failure since day 1 and thank god she got the hell outta there even if the show apparently forced her out because she better than this

[@pedronolasco4480]

yeah, better tecnique, better voice, more powerfull and...

[@DestinyDrumgold]

Lucky is always getting looked over, poor doll. I'm glad Jiwon got first, I was hopeful for her and Yebin. I kinda thought 아이 would be last, she was kinda struggling to get noticed

[@adign027]

아이 is second ❤❤❤

[@722Mil]

only 아이 (I) is singing' everyone just trying to look cute -__-

[@aikotoba-he9qr]

"I" has a better feeling at the stage she is actually really good at singing an dancing live thats why she got the second place, the fact that she was crying here maybe cos she was really unconfortable with all the situation in there, lets place also that she left the program for a health problem, and I´m actually glad that we at least got her increadibly performance, and dont want to be rude but i found Jiwon really annoying with all her fake/cute acttitud at all the performance there are some other girls that deserved to be on 1rst place more than she

[@gaan792]

I think jiwons looked a bit sad when she got first because her good day band member got last

[@joswanlauwkung]

Lucky is unlucky

[@alondragisell7860]

8:21 *C R I N G E*

[@edlwes]

Yes so disgusting

[@arvie2681]

watching this 2021. Wendy’s part is the hardest one. I stan the right queen! 💙

[@ap9532]

Red flavor sweetie I'm so sorry (2)

[@exo-lnpandatrashofkyungsoo2475]

I don't know why this performance irritated me... sorry

[@streetreport07]

They are talented and all but they sounded like little kids.. not like a cute girl concept :') that's what irritated me.

[@loveghibli]

EXO-L N Panda trash of kyungsoo n eunji same

[@jimired]

Red Flavor is a fresh, cheerful song and not "cute", there's a difference right?

[@keshabaryal8789]

Yes there is a difference. Cute is like Twice Knock Knock. Not Red Flavor-

[@seulgientertainment5752]

RED VELVET vocals are truly a treasure.

[@otakukawaii3783]

8:45 worst high note 어이 is BETTER

[@christineselena3437]

Agree!!!

[@islisforlife1549]

She did It well

[@naadiyamxmed8717]

@@islisforlife1549 the girl she took the part from did better then here to be honest

[@Nathan-xn6ge]

ears are officially deaf

[@tinayay3208]

Techias Good

[@tinayay3208]

Now you get to leave yay

[@neginak1343]

I agree 👍

[@laurentciajocellin6919]

true

[@star1alwayswithsistar788]

hahahaha

[@brightlotus6612]

Why do i feel this is so irritating....

[@em.k814]

Bright lotus the overdose of cuteness

[@brightlotus6612]

Emily Lin i think if they did this more naturally, it will be better

[@em.k814]

Bright lotus I agree it was just so cringey to watch

[@pinkpanther560]

Red flavor chipmunk version lol

[@reffifathur4816]

Black Velvet Blink & ReVeluv best comment lol

[@francenicoleeborde3505]

Black Velvet Blink & ReVeluv ikr

[@mnm1022]

This comment deserves many likes. Sadly, I can only like once

[@judielynpontaneles8084]

Pink Panther your comment made my day HAHAHAHAHA 😂

[@NeHa-gl3ys]

Hahahahaha yeah correct 😂😂🤣🤣

[@mganmai]

7:24 jiwon of cignature 7:28 belle of cignature 8:30 yuji of 3ye lmk if any others have debuted! 🥺

[@borroborroborro5711]

Yujeong of Brave Girls

[@joshualwrnc]

I was expecting something nice but they sound awful

[@sierraburkhart]

the only person i liked was the girl with the straight black hair in the red v-neck sweater

[@Manzana835]

And it's not the worst cover in existence

[@mingi1489]

Manzana835 Rookie from Idol school is the worst

[@themosquitowhobitjin6457]

ONLY CHA YOONJI(I) IS GOOD DONT @ ME this performance is just no. im sorry but the scene of cha yoonji singing the wendy line and the vocal trainer didnt like it pisses me off. When the real perf starts,only cha yoonji is good , continues with not cutesy voice and didnt crack her voice.

[@hello-pf2ew]

tru

[@sheannekayecruz1502]

Agree

[@Jamie-oc9bx]

ikr... does that vocal trainer even know she's doing?

[@lynvilleanneho8645]

I really loved I's Wendy feel

[@zel2920]

Am I the only one who feel irritated right now after watching this? ( I'm not hating the girls it just that its too much.)

[@nursyarahadiba6128]

Zell Napao same here I felt they tried to hard to be cute

[@nazwawa2373]

Same here too.

[@sihyunss777]

i honestly dont know why every cover of red velvet on survival pros always tend to be overly cute bc honestly the concepts that red velvet has are fun concepts rather than cute ones

[@marilynmeza1272]

Yes, they try so hard to look cute and thats not rv style

[@midcara]

Yea I really wasn't a fan of Jiwon or the girl who did Yeri's rap...they left me with so much cringe :/

[@whitneymouse]

I feel like I watched Twice try to cover “Red Flavour” and I am not feeling it (that isn’t a jab at Twice. It’s just that that type of aegyo concept fits Twice and not this song). Red Velvet hasn’t done an aegyo concept and I think it shows when groups try to cover their stuff super cutesy. It just doesn’t work.

[@borroborroborro5711]

God Red Velvet stans are insufferable. You're all just big haters who hate on anyone who even does anything relating to RV.

[@agirlwholovesapinksnsdiuit2568]

i like the voice of 7:32 and 8:30! their voice are not cringey to listen + natural facial expression… not overly acting cute.

[@722Mil]

7:32 is cha yoonji sadly she is not in industry no more

[@vitor5085]

8:30 is someone from 3YE (Former Apple.B were on THE UNIT as an Apple.B member) I THINK she's haeun, not sure