UPSC CDS 2024 Exam | Polity Questions Paper Analysis by Dr Sidharth Arora | Will Prelims be tougher?

[@upscunstoppables]

🚨 Unacademy Manzil 2024 - The Biggest Event for UPSC | LIVE Event👈 Event Link: kzbin.info2tzmZ-3Ne3c?si=nNdR4rkcQkCcBz1h 🗓 Block Your Calendar | 28 April | 01 PM

[@RahulSharma-hm3fx]

Sir, in question 3 , statement incorporate individual can enforce, but it is judiciary to whom we can request to enforce FRs. Individual by themselves can't enforce their FRs. So , in my opinion option D would be right

[@priyabharatdwaj2849]

Respected Sir, I am one of your PLUS learners I have done polity with you several times and I am very thankful that your method of teaching is totally in configuration with the demands of Civil Services. Cannot thank you enough. THANK U SIR.

[@Aanchal-p5z]

In my opinion In question number 3 option 2 can also be understood by another eg. If Article 17 of any person is violated by another individual (which outlaws untouchability/forbids its practice in any form) and the person goes to the police if the police do not register an FIR ( as it is an enforceable against an individual too) this can also serve as an eg when inaction of the government authority violates the FR of individual

[@monikameena910]

🎉🎉hamare sir ko easy laga to unke students ko kase hard lag sakta h Thankyou so much dear sir g

[@amanisjonsnow]

Recently sc 4 bench judge said right to marry is not fundamental right and right to choose partner is fundamental right .

[@jinfin221]

What's the difference

[@armybrat6915]

Acc to me answer of question 3 is D because indivisuals cannot enforce their right in case of violation. If they feel that their right has been violated then they can move to courts and 'exercise their right under art 32'. Then courts will check wether the right has been actually violated or not. If court find that the right has actually been violated then they will issue writs to 'enforce' the right. Hence the enforcing body in case of violation is the court and not the individual. Also an indivisual is nobody to decide the question wether the right has actually been violated or not. it can only be decided in courts

[@HeySmile-o8p]

somebody needs to callout the way UPSC frames questions! seriously mood off ho jaata hai. The Right to marry person of one's choice how come after the LGBTQ+ case is still a relevant question? if you ask such a question which is recently in the news and has no clarity as of now it shows that how much luck matters in any exam conducted by UPSC. Also question number 1? do they want us to read political theories as well? and then the last question bare acts bhi padhe? at least let polity be a scoring subject! *random rant, thankyou for reading*

[@Manish-vf7cb]

Upsc is a gambling bro.

[@abhisekpanigrahi6098]

Laxmikant mein 21 mein diya gya hai right to maary ...but mein bhi yahi socha tha fir mein risk liya laxmikant ko consider karte hua ..I gone with laxmikant that time

[@manthanzala4177]

Bro just go through pyq that's a repeated questions ye wala bhi galat karoge then toh ho gaya kalyan

[@prajyotshendage733]

In SC verdict on same sex marriage (Supriya Chakraborty v Union of India, 2023) court held that there is no fundamental right to marry in Indian constitution.

[@kirti64132]

THANK U SO MUCH SIR FOR THIS WONDERFUL EXPLANATION .....HAVEBCEEN PREPAING FOR DEFENCE EXAMS FOR YEARS BUT HAVE NEVER SEEN A TEACHER LIKE YOU .

[@nikitamishra0508]

Please explain...the 3rd question of FR...my contention is Individuals can not enforce the rights themselves...they can approach the judiciary to get their rights enforced...so answer should be option D

[@mohdshakib8247]

Your argument makes sense, because it's the courts that enforce the fundamental rights and not the individuals. Individual can only approach the court, for the issuance of appropriate writ for the enforcement of FR.

[@amaanahmad7546]

Sir one question.....how individuals can enforce rights....they are enforceable by....court...not on their own....????

[@laibahasan9748]

Q.1 correct ✅(socio term empirical) Q 2 ✅( elimination method) Q.3 ❌ individuals kaise ??😖😖😖😖

[@upscstudymaterialnotes]

Ques was about govt action and inaction... Word 'individual' was not the focus of the ques.. btw FR can be enforced by individuals. Revise ch7 of laxmikant again

[@johnlocke3077]

But in the recent same sex marriage case, it was held that the right to marry is not a FR.

[@neeteshmishra6148]

Neetesh Kumar Mishra. Gave correct answer of the question related to agricultural land

[@tourismprayagraj]

Right to marry is not a fundamental right as per supreme court judgment, so how answer for 4th Question is (c)?

[@saniyaashraf6577]

It's right to marry with choice

[@upscstudymaterialnotes]

1 unattended - Human rights Coucil ques.. All other are correct

[@harshhhhhh383]

but fundamental rights are enforceable by courts and not by individuals????

[@shefk7325]

Sir, aren't rights in part iii enforceable by courts and not individuals? Or do we consider our right to approach the courts equivalent to individuals enforcing them?

[@guptaji_rk]

Latter one.

[@cynosureupsc]

So many questions still left of polity jo discuss nai karaye isme, legal aid, iccpr etc

[@Flavors_by_Sidhu]

The very 1st question is of PSIR OPTIONAL level

[@Nishant12-o6t]

Yes bro BA 2nd sem

[@Nishant12-o6t]

Yes bro BA 2nd sem

[@ADB3773]

Example for - Inaction by govt for fundamental rights - States/Centre failed to act and provide oxygen during COVID and people approached HC/SC for this.

[@ramkripal1062]

Right to marry is not fundamental Right under article 21 recent judgement of Supreme Court.

[@kishantiwari8434]

Bro right to marry is not a fundamental right but right to marry with the person of their choice is still a fundamental right means you can choose your life partner under article 21 but to do marriage is not a fundamental right in the recent judgement of Supreme Court in lgbtq case.

[@PrashantKumarRam-m1z]

Right to Marriage is not FRs as it is currently change in Supriyo case

[@arpitagrawal6060]

I was exactly searching for this in the comments. The teacher isnt updated himself. Unacademy teachers have a very bad fettish of bad-mouthing others despite themselves being at fault

[@sanyampathak763]

Its not "right to marry" .... it's right to Marry of one's choice.

[@JayarathoreJaya-qt4yi]

Last questions by luck I did right.😅 But I love the way you teach ❤ I'm so thankful for being your student 🙌

[@SHIVAMTHAKUR-gz3yh]

sir, 1983 case where SC said this "Whenever a person is arrested by the police and taken to the police lock up, the police should immediately give intimation of the fact of such arrest to the nearest Legal Aid Committee which should take immediate steps to 339 provide legal assistance to him at State cost provided he is willing to accept such A legal assistance. [346 D-E]" Supreme Court of India Sheela Barse vs State Of Maharashtra on 15 February, 1983, then howcome the second statement be wrong.

[@Dee25930]

Yes, I also had this same query!

[@Manish-vf7cb]

Verdict me aur constitution me likha hone me farq hai

[@krishnanandpandey9420]

Both the statements of question no 3 are wrong because an INDIVIDUAL CAN NOT 'ENFORCE' the fundamental rights ( carefully re-read the capital letters words ) rather he/she can seek form the court under articles 32 and 226 to enforce them because the constitution gives the authority for 'ENFORCEMENT' to the court ONLY........

[@arti3673]

Sir ya to aap sirf Hindi me padhaye ya fir sirf English me..

[@sunkour6721]

In recent case supriyo chakraborty v union of India on Oct 17 2023 said that there is no fr to marry sir can u please explain on which basis that option right to marry is a fr right

[@sanketaher2763]

Yes bhai sahi bola...right to marry not a FR...but once I guess v decide to whom v marry of our choise then Its becomes FR This is explanation from other coach

[@SnehaSingh-982]

Got all the answers correct except the last one Sir.

[@SANATANI_65]

kha se polity ki(source) ?

[@Sanjaykumar-ke9zp]

IS UPSC CSE GS paper and UPSC CDS GS paper is same ?

[@aarushbhatnagar4860]

In Question 3 I instantly gave the answer as C because after reading Statement 2, there was a click of MANDAMUS in my mind…. I’m grateful… 😊 sir thank you for this session 🎉🎉

[@ishleenkaur7185]

Question 3 me language sahi h statements ki? Individual can enforce rights.....

[@chackboard4091]

Very well explained sir i m ur student really i was able to do most of the questions among them easily 😊

[@parasyadav-l9j]

Court can enforce rights how individuals can enforce?

[@UPSC_poetry]

Right to marry is not a FR in india, SC stated this in recent same sex marriage verdict!!

[@akshadharamesh6265]

Is it duty of the police to inform the nearest legal aid committee immediately after arrest of person?

[@harshitrana3358]

Thank you sir it was a wonderful session I scored 7/9 🙏🙏🙇‍♂🙇‍♂

[@rr1111]

Well explained Sir👍

[@krishnanandpandey9420]

So answer for question 3 should be D

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans D human rights councils

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Yes sir Ans C. K.S.Puttaswamy case

[@_kajalverma7527]

Thank you sir🎉🙏

[@rishurounak9320]

In supriyo chakroborty vs UOI cas related to LGBTQ right to marry SC stated that right to marry is not a fundamental right under article 21

[@krishnachakravarti4571]

Right to marry is not a FR but right to marry with the person of their choice is a FR. Both r different statement and have different meaning

[@shiviinandal2191]

Thankyou sir, it was great and very helpful session

[@bulbul6855]

Sir whoever is going to watch this video, already have basic understanding and knowledgeable aspirants so there was no need to make unnecessary things to waste the time....next making such videos keep in mind you should give analysis about the pattern, sources, nature of questions rather than "panditya-pradarshan".

[@Sanjaykumar-ke9zp]

Is UPSC CSE GS paper and UPSC CDS GS paper is same ? Plz reply anyone those who have known

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans D.article 32

[@Kkk-yt4cv]

Sir please reply Election for the post of the President of India can be postponed on the ground that lok sabha has been dissolved and election are yet to take place ? Yes or Not

[@Akshu471]

3rd question mei 1 option mei to fr to pvt entity ke against bhi h like article 17

[@amezonlearning5101]

Hello sir I'm your Plus learner , only 1 St question wrong 9/10 .... thank you so much sir❤🙏

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Thank you so much more sir this cds questions up coming upsc prelims exams ko trending change the aspirants ko challengeable hey

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans D.neither 1 nor 2

[@saaranshshergill6024]

Sir please make a crisp video on star campaigners. In context of the recent ongoing general elections

[@quid_pro_quobudha1656]

Fssi not working properly, adulteration in food is pretty common these days hygiene ki to band hi bji huee h. Isnt violating my fundamental right ? Article 21.

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

CDS question papers mey almost all upsc aspirants ko interview mey all these type of questions all interview chairman of the 4 to 5 members asking these type of questions sir this true sir I am youtube mey watching in this type questions in top rankers interview sessions hey

[@ananya_0701]

Thank you sir ❤

[@kritikamalik320]

mera vo last wala ques thik h bcoz m saari list ke items yaad karke gyi thi sir meri chocolate....???

[@Vishal-j5k5x]

Bhut achaa sir ❤

[@Sanjaykumar-ke9zp]

Is UPSC CSE GS paper nad UPSC CDS GS paper is same?

[@shubhamkmahajan8005]

que 4 i used same logic anf got C

[@bearded_ashu]

but sir SC recently rejected right to marry as a fundamental right

[@rajatsharma6728]

Sr i have one doubt related to Q No 4… According to Supriyo vs Uoi 2023, Right to marry is not a FR under article 21 Plz do correct me Sr . if same question repeat again in UPSC civil service so what would be appropriate marking ?

[@rohitraman2767]

Here the option is one’choice ….and choosing a partner is a fundamental right

[@biswabhanu10]

Hope guruji I can crack by your ashirwad my answer was right all of them

[@SANATANI_65]

Bhai gs kha se padha hai please bta dijiye

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans A ir B

[@yashpradhan9333]

Thnx for your session really helpful,🙏

[@yashpradhan9333]

You confused me with saying by elimination.... earlier i Choose c ...but after that I change it to a thinking that it not only inter religious but also inter caste.....in 5 q

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans C

[@Pikachu-dn9yb]

thank you sir for this amazing session...

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans A

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans 4.A

[@newindia7345]

D sahi mara mne last wale ka...

[@megharani6339]

Thank you sir.. jai hind🙏❤️

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Yes sir Ans B

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans A.1

[@Dee25930]

In the right to legal aid question, can anyone help me understand that why option 2 is incorrect! Upon researching online, I found that the statement in option 2 is directly cited from a judicial decision, namely, Sheela Barse v. State of Maharashtra

[@pawanupadhyay3701]

read supreme court judgement of oct 2023 regarding marrige rights of lgbtq community. SC ruled that right to marry isn't a fundamental right.

[@Dee25930]

@@pawanupadhyay3701 Okay! Thanks for sharing the information! However, my query was related to a different question about the right to legal aid

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans D.1,2 and 3

[@ashutoshmishra00777]

Sir, Right to marry of one's choice, though acknowledged by SC as part of FRs,how is a part of FR when SC has denied LGBTQ their right to marry.

[@ramkripal1062]

Right to marry is not fundamental Right, recently judgement of Supreme Court

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Yes Ans C

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans A.1and 2

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Thank you sir

[@aleemawolrd4537]

Option B

[@parasyadav-l9j]

But Sir recently in LGBT case Sc says Marriage is not a fundamental right

[@vinodraut1471]

Got all correct except one

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans B.2only

[@Sarthakstm]

4th Question Ka C hoga Sheela barse vs state of Maharashtra mai Court ne khud yeh ruling di hai ki it is the duty of police Duty of police hai Google pe bhi likha hai Logically bhi C hoga Kyuki agar koi ekdum gareeb aadmi hai jiska is duniya mai koi nahi hai uski application kaun le jayega Isliye isko duty of police mai likha gaya hai taki sabko justice mile

[@IndianShorts0067]

Bhai,jo poor hai unhe Free legal Aid article 39(b) under milti hai fundamental right me nhi, Aur ha Police ko only Magistrate ke samne 24 hours me pes Krna hota hai.

[@Sarthakstm]

@@IndianShorts0067 bhai Google karlo ya answer key ka intezaar karlo

[@IndianShorts0067]

@@Sarthakstm Google par viswas nhi hai, answer ka hi wait krna padega 🙃

[@rupalipandey2051]

Thnkuuuu so much sir

[@akashramani6047]

In question 3 ...What if gov authority takes those actions under emergency situation....?? Article 19 and no remedies lies...post emergency and all tht ?? Even we study, they are not absolute in nature...

[@prachimodi1568]

Sir, I've studied polity from u! U have not just made concepts clear but also has ingrained deep respect for judges & army! Was only confused with que 3rd rest all were correct! Hope I'll make u proud in prelims

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Ans A.1only

[@Manoj__Sharma7048]

Sir question ko hindi m bhi translate kar dia kariye

[@mahadevaswamybmmahadevaswa8419]

Good afternoon sir namaste

[@TusharKumar-lr1sp]

All correct except 1

[@huntsuccess2024]

Right to marry is not a fundamental right . Said SC

[@aleemawolrd4537]

Option C

[@naharsingh331]

Upsc bhul gayi h humare ssb k bare ME 😠😠😠😠😠

[@aleemawolrd4537]

Option A

[@yashpradhan9333]

7.d

[@aleemawolrd4537]

Option D

[@deveshgarggarg]

all correct

[@yashpradhan9333]

1.d