US Astrophysicist Neil Degrasse Tyson Reveals What PM Modi Told Him After Meeting IN US| Exclusive

[@ajkumar6013]

Neil is my favorite scientist :), charming, intelligent and well spoken.

[@patsonbala5427]

Neil says it like it is More national than Rahul Gandhi🙏🕉️🇮🇳

[@chrispbacon5027]

Neil is a stupid woke leftist fool. I do not understand why we entertain him so much.

[@NaaneVinu]

Lady not able to understand what Neil is saying. She just has some questions that she prepared. And it would have been good if she has been sitting in a calm room and discussing this. But still Neil answered all her questions chill and calm, he is true astrophysist and science enlighter 😅

[@ooffactor]

that is how a reporter interviews people. you want to hear a substantive conversation? listen to a podcast.

[@rupaldesai3224]

It's for those , who understand science..not for everyone.

[@bullappa]

Always remember a journalist is not a specialist in any specific field.They Interview all kinds of peoplemand only with politicians they have a field day 😂

[@Q_QQ_Q]

J@n00 qu0ta people 😂😂😂

[@CosmosLore13.6B]

@@rupaldesai3224 ye its not for NPC's

[@dilipsave428]

Such interviews Kindle interest in kids and young people to make space exploration a career. 👍

[@dhruvilkumpavat6037]

Thanks to Isro and people like him, kids are now craving for knowledge about space and thats why now we have more 350 space startups

[@neerajwa]

Neil has a gift of explaining things in very simple terms. He is the spiritual successor of Carl Sagan.

[@ayushprasad5386]

Thank you for this interview. Media plays a huge role in generating interest and excitement for space. Hope you continue to make more such space focussed interview.

[@samirlg5]

He is just Brillant. Oh my God His Thinking is just beyond Human Level.

[@alok.01]

Not at all. What he is good at is making hard science topics easy to understand for those who don't even know much about science

[@lakshay7901]

​@@alok.01 Yes. But to be able to do that, imagine how good one's understanding has to be on the concerned topics.

[@lakshay7901]

Not beyond, Well within human level.

[@stealthoverflow]

Did she just say Zero came from Ramanujan 😭😭

[@Q_QQ_Q]

J@n00 qu0ta people 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣

[@goodmorning192]

I hate it when journalists are not prepared with the topics they are talking about.

[@oolti_chappal]

@@goodmorning192 Please don't blame her (although it is criminally offensive to say ramanujan invented Zero), there must be a very tight schedule for her to do interviews with many people so it is not possible for her to know and remember everything.😭

[@dr.srinivasanramachandran5208]

You are always teaching and enlightening us sir. Thank you very much

[@siddhant07wc6]

Hate these kind of interviewers. It's ok to prepare questions but you have to have an open mind to ask follow up questions. Let me explain. So she asks Niel about Chandrayan 3 and he explained it beautiful about significance of finding water and why water hould be present at the south pole. You should have asked some plans of nasa or what you think isro next move maybe. But immediately went to Ask what modiji said to you. And there also when Niel was trying to remember the name of Aryabhatta as the one gave the world zero you said "Ramanujan"🙄 I can bet if someone falsely tells her well Ramanujan was born 1000 years ago she will definitely believe it🤦 Atleast have some basic knowledge about their works. Nobody is saying one should know all the conjecture of Ramanujan or derivation of general relativity by Einstein but just enough so that you know what they are talking about in general terms.

[@Aadnya516]

They sent the wrong person who is asking wrong questions and trying to pretend she knows it all. The way she cut off the flow and asked him about his discussion with the prime minister 🤯

[@siddhant07wc6]

@@Aadnya516 so disrespectful. The guy took his time to do an interview and you waste his time to not allow him to speak of his expertise and knowledge in the field. Talk science with him, talk about ideas. But no you will live in that colonial oppressed mindset and try to look superior by roping your PM to look good.

[@krs218]

Maybe she and Niel only had limited time and had go cover all her question. And remember it’s not easy for any journalist to keep up with Neil’s knowledge on astrophysics. And he’s talking in very technical terms here. And she was standing in a very noisy place.

[@sugandhigiridhar1989]

Good to hear him say on our Bharat🙏🏻

[@sajishandhuparambil6713]

Space is good for business and betterment of mankind .

[@bullappa]

Neil is always an open hearted.person with lots of humour. Pleasure listening to him. Thanks Navika 🎉

[@Truthfully12312]

Wow wow…his style of explaining is really convincing

[@aammjaisriram]

I understand that astrophysics is not a cup of tea for a leyman but navika at least you can pretend to be interested when this legend is talking. FYI Ramanujan did not invent zero. Stupid journalists.

[@Q_QQ_Q]

J@n00 qu0ta people 😂😂😂

[@rajeshgangurde9971]

Thanks Times Now & Navika Ma'am for this interview. Watched Tyson Sir on History Channel (Ancient Aliens) series years back. Thanks once again.

[@_Vaibs_]

very good conversation. appreciated.

[@noclicheplease]

WTF? He is not popular because he met our Modi. He is popular in India & across the world because he is a world class educator. He simplifies things in ways that even not so sharpest of the minds, can understand science. I vaguely remember that she was kinda asking for "affirmations from the west", the last time she interviewed Tyson a year ago.

[@Shreya-zt2ne]

unclench

[@noclicheplease]

@@Shreya-zt2ne Hmm! One's vocabulary is built with one's own encounters. Maybe you often clench it so hard, you need to remind others too 😟

[@thiruvetti]

Popular meant Trending now. Cos he is in Trends due to his meet with Modi

[@noclicheplease]

@@thiruvetti How come something that happened in June 2023 be a trending now topic?

[@Being-kind1997]

For her Modi is equal to god, that's why. They're fox news of usa😂

[@sanjoybhattacharjee8731]

Marvelous interview .

[@nlybnrj]

He ia favourite scientist in India, we all follow him.

[@rajasekaranramachokalingam5228]

Carl Sagan has gone on record on Indian comprehension on cosmology and the connect our culture had, he mentions about DARASURAM temple. Carl Sagan was a mentor to Tyson, who credits Sagan's generosity, patience, and dedication to education as lasting influences. Tyson has said that he treated students the way Sagan treated him, and that he hopes to be as famous as Sagan and treat students the same way. Brilliant.

[@Rintesh-Roy]

Great interview with a great enthusiast.

[@kallachnadra]

India lacks (ITIs).."technical-practical oriented schools"..such as electricians, pumbers, brick layers, car mechanics, lath machanics, carpenters, etc. Yes..India have some but India do not have enough. In comparision Germany has a lot of such practical oriented schools, for those who are practical work-oriented. Those who are either not interested in theory books..education, may join such schools for one year..or two year or so..! It is quite obvious why Germany has GDP more than rest of Europe. Let Modiji think of it too.

[@Lessspeedmoreweed]

I agree but there is a big issue with the image of such trade vocations in india. Peoples mindset has to change if we want our unemployed and students absorbed in the workforce.

[@PutyLink-c1g]

good point

[@karthikreddy8567]

Scamgress party intentionally interferes with our education system to establish their pro-british anti-India narrative…..

[@KRISH57676]

Sir/Mam; Your suggestion is very good. But, wouldn't this increase the cost of their labour as well ? We can still call for plumbers, electricians, carpenters, who are working without any training from such schools. And labour cost is just bearable for us. Germany has more GDP than us and the Most GDP in Europe, because it was and still is (at some level) a production and manufacturing giant. Had we not been 'blessed' with such humongous population; we would still be lurking at the bottoms of the bottom. This is because, ours economy is not production based but a consumer one.

[@Q_QQ_Q]

​@@KRISH57676J@n00 qu0ta people 😂😂😂

[@BharatXtreme]

always love watching neil

[@balrajcn9030]

Thank you Mr. Tyson for your brief talk with Mrs. Navin and revealed some exclusive interesting importance of the Moon's South pole expeditions and also other interesting thoughts about Astro Physics.

[@call2dipankar]

He may have recently became popular to Modi fans, after he met Modi, but he's been popular among astrophysics enthusiasts for the last 10/15 years..

[@AtheistVegan]

Neil, thanks for this info.

[@ramadasan7]

Absolutely enjoyed the interview Navika.

[@rc2k22]

He is a great man, always love to listen to him

[@prasubhat]

He is famous in India because he explains science in a way even a kid can understand and not just because he met Modi.

[@dipmallick7350]

Zero was given by the Great Aryabhatta not by Sir Srinivasan Ramanujan.

[@ElN246]

Neil is the only person who got extra time from navika to speak 😂😂

[@snoopyapk5331]

We need more content of this sort there many scientist who influence the world

[@freedom3040]

America is so much polarised society. When talking about space, Involve this person as he isn’t a political analyst with vested interests like others.

[@prateeklokare8747]

We should invite him for session in India at regular intervals in various parts of the country and sure all enthusiastic would love to join, doubt numbers would beat Cold play...but definitely good than else where...

[@Shan56566]

Fantastic

[@abybhattacharya8782]

USA supported India verbally by condemning terror attacks etc but supplied weapons to Pakistan, also their ministers visited PoK. India is just returning the favour.

[@dantepal7948]

I hate it when journalists are not prepared, please take your job seriously.

[@SunBurst2022]

Why is she asking a long bragging question ? By the time she finishes her question, the essence of the actual question is diluted

[@sharathahuja8261]

PM should have met. Bantval Jayant Baliga-Millenium Technology Awardee for 2024 and inventor of IGBT.

[@Vikasit952]

Physce- 16 is a Prime Immediate Dream of 1.4 billion Indians. Can India and USA work in Partnership in this field .? Jai Hind !

[@sasikumarrajan5334]

This is Goin to be a legendary move for space era.

[@dantepal7948]

She thinks he famous in India after he met Modi meet him, somebody please tell her he famous all around the world and in India also many Indian listening to him and will continue because of his passion to teach everyone in simple and entertaining way.

[@dipeshpal9428]

I have seen all the episode of Neil deGrasse Tyson in cosmos episode.

[@jaderivers3727]

My neighbour was saying that Navikas popularity is flagging

[@Aadnya516]

Let’s stop seeking validation from other counties. We know Indian space institution is brilliant and keeps doing the best. We don’t need other countries validating it. Let’s start owning it and ask others if they think they can do the same.

[@sachinmohite217]

she wanted to say aryabhatta but accidently said ramanujan.

[@sureshkrishna6833]

C’mon lady, you are talking to an international specialist. Please look interested and think of asking intelligent questions. Have you read any of his books? He is as good as it gets as far space is concerned.

[@tubelz]

Someone else should have conducted the interview. She doesn't have the background or interest.

[@Mayank-m9z]

Pity she can't do muslim-hindu here ,she would have rocked the debate then

[@arundathikrishna5543]

Absolutely. She could have atleast listened while he answered instead of reading her notes. And really did you have to choose the busiest noisiest intersection in nyc to conduct an interview? You were basically shouting your questions!

[@KamranAhmedkhaan]

5.29 she's clearly not interested in science. Pity that we have such idiots running our media. PS: This is not a Hindu -Muslim issue. 😊

[@henripoincare77]

​@@KamranAhmedkhaanExactly

[@chitradoraiswami6630]

What a guy!

[@ramadasan7]

Wow!

[@Abhijeetraurale1234]

Anybody who consider themselves a hardcore scientific guy 👇👇👇

[@jyotichattopadhyaya618]

Nice interview. Very able lady. Thanks

[@AmazedNik]

No question on reasons to colonize the moon? He went at great lengths to explain complex stuff in simple terms

[@anandkulkarni8313]

In one sentence, the astrophysicist put astrology where it belongs. The planets and stars don't care about our future on the earth. Please bring more physical science into astrology, like mathematics, statistics, and probability theory, to make it believable..

[@kirank1012]

Please send Navika Kumari to English speaking course.

[@hazelwilkinson4790]

So striking that Navika always addresses her Indian guest very respectfully by their professional titles like Dr Ranganathan, Ambassador Mukerjee etc but never not even once address Dr Tyson by his professional title as Dr Tyson. Come on Navika, you can do better than this. Please respect a Black professional. He deserves your respect.

[@teachersconference8932]

Navika is always parading her long , winding questions ..she needs a break from.journalism and needs to get her questions right esp on Indian TV debates .. Dr Tyson always super

[@Gear_labs]

*_Neil, India is also planning of Dyson sphere after station_*

[@srutidebmahakul]

Arabs .......learnt Mathematics from India... as it was a transit point..... between east and west....

[@roshanhemrom4906]

Hello Startalk! bring Lord chuck

[@tosanjumd]

When Neil was talking about invention of "0", the lady barps out "Ramanujan" !! How do these people get to call themselves "journalists"!

[@kdreamscosmos4279]

He was popular in India way before he met Modi

[@majorsandeepunnikrishnan991]

Very good conversation....👍🏿👍🏿🇮🇳

[@NandKumar-qq3xk]

Planet's God and healping to a personality who is claverly rightfull ?

[@devangsrivastav]

9:12 Ramanujan Was A Great Guess , I Guess

[@EvolutionG789]

9:21 Yo she just said Ramanujan founder of 0 😂

[@youtubersworldwide3713]

Goat

[@domainofdiscourse]

Ramanujan 😂

[@Gear_labs]

Since 10 years ago i always assumed him Indian, still in doubt😂

[@pvnewport]

My god. Neil is in absolutely wrong company here 😅

[@International-indic.]

Maybe he should be with you

[@IndianTiger-0P]

​@@International-indic. Eat Gowbhar Godhi bhakt. it's very tasty for sanghs and godhi

[@RoKuSa007]

​@@IndianTiger-0Pna i will eat your m.0.m 😅😂

[@KaushikSarkar-uo2lt]

What kind of God. The one from the desert.

[@pvnewport]

@@KaushikSarkar-uo2lt I can only sympathize with you if your god is stuck in some desert 😀

[@sugathasagar]

19:21 Maha maate not Ramanujam, BrahmaGupta 628AD Brahmasphutasiddhanta

[@IamAlphaNOmega]

Question was on Modi... but he ended up doing the American thing...advice on the so-called minority 😂.. who are 20cr.😂😂😂

[@IndianTiger-0P]

Those 20 cr are also Indians and they Owns the same Rights and ownership as any citizens in Bharat

[@IamAlphaNOmega]

@SoorajSuseelan10001 their number becomes a bit more they will want Sharia, you will need to pay Jizya to survive....am I making this up??? Go google and check what is happening in Bangladesh. Todays Bangladesh bdw is making of American CIA. Some can never live with others, whateveryou do. Wake up before it's too late. Live in reality. Hindus not treating them unequal its not their religious teaching... but it is of the 20cr...you want me quote you references???

[@IamAlphaNOmega]

@@IndianTiger-0P ... 20cr peaceful for a reason... Surah 2:191, Surah 3:151, Surah 9:5 and Tafsir Surah An-Nisa 155

[@IndianTiger-0P]

@@IamAlphaNOmega But nobody can ammend constitution of India. So that will never happen. There are central agencies here like NIA, CBI and etc. It's their job. not yours or any citizens. So why not live peacefully without this nafrat

[@IamAlphaNOmega]

@SoorajSuseelan10001 no one has nafrat. It is not our way of life or teaching. Maybe yours. The Constitution was changed by Congress after Indira Gandhi and over the years to appease 20cr only. WAQF board scam, Religious places Act etc. Texbooks made Akbar, Babar heroes...real heroes ignored. The Constitution will be reverted to 1947 original. We not doing Gazwa e Hind... your 20cr are so hateful of others they wanted to live exclusive following their bigot role model...broke this country into Pakistan...for themselves. US must protect their minorities not lecture India.

[@ayushbalgote5242]

Navikas voice feela like nails being driven into my eardrum.

[@pb234]

Aryabhatta by the way not Ramanuja

[@Being-kind1997]

Thankfully she didn't said Narendra Modi 😂

[@Hnrt100]

ramanujan?

[@VedicYoddha]

lmao, she isnt very bright.

[@drishaantrivedi159]

Navika, It wasn't ramanuj, he was simply 100 years back Neil, It was not Muslim but Arabic. Real scientists do not need to be politically correct.

[@IndianTiger-0P]

Don't you know the golden age of Muslims

[@_Johnny_BRAV0]

Arabs ain't muslims?

[@s-qc9ns]

The reporter know nothing about space. Whatever he said went over her head 🤣🤣

[@sriken9]

Ok. But what's wrong with that? Many things go over our heads every day.

[@ramesh40220]

Atleast you understood what Niel said. Don't be a Pappu

[@Phanindra_Bhupathi_Raju_]

See . It is not 1 on 1 talk . It doesn't matter she knows anything about space . The only matter is she asking Right Questions or not ? Because news Are for Viewers ..Listen And Learn is our duty not hers .. her duty is just collecting news and put in front of us ..She is good in that ..

[@Mayank-m9z]

​@@ramesh40220lmao it's fun to see butthurt bjp supporters when they realise the clowns they follow religiously are stupid af

[@Itsworkinggg]

It’s frustrating when someone can’t even focus while talking to such an important person. It feels like a complete lack of respect. If you’re not interested in truly learning, why even ask questions? Let someone else, who actually understands and values the knowledge, take the interview instead of wasting the opportunity. If you’re just going to throw random questions without absorbing anything, why bother?Let someone who actually values this step up, instead of playing interviewer just for show. She was continuously looking at the paper or somewhere else while he was explaining, nodding her head even though she wasn’t understanding or at least listening to what he was saying.

[@royrand8521]

Simply luuuuv the new la-di-da accent..... Could we look forward to a Texan drawl when this Eminent Personage visits the UK ( or maybe a Yankee twang?) & that could be succeeded by Aussie whatever etc etc..... She'll then put the other Lady Media Personages out of business....

[@sontuudaybhasker5187]

sorry... Albaruni and all other arabs of 7th,to 9th have clearly mentioned the source of their mathematical knowledge and please verify

[@aniruddharao]

Arabic "scholars" regurgitated and translated the works of Indian Rishis and scholars!

[@aakpaakkarrepak2165]

Aryabhatta who discovered zero not ramanujan ( small correction)😅 9:22

[@ramesh_rm]

Yes , My reaction when she said Ramanujan:🤦🏻

[@CosmosLore13.6B]

Wow we got a collab between kachra and a genius before GTA 6

[@samurai-f77]

Bet that 'kachra' is more smart than your dad.

[@adityasuryawanshi4430]

now some people's will say he's Sanghi 😂

[@TheS-Man]

I don’t think Navika has prepared enough. She says Neil is famous in India because he met Modi 😂, really?

[@skhurana333]

anchor needs to be to the point. Too big questions...can summarize

[@chilarai1]

(!) Dr deGrasse makes a good case for a 2-party system in India. It is idiotic to have 1000+ parties. But who in India will make it happen even with a massive mandate? (2) The Muslim "golden age" in science and math was when they took Indian mathematics and astronomy, translated and transmitted them to Europe, taking all the credit. This is similar to today's westerners calling Dhyana or meditation "mindfulness" just to own it.

[@Viessue]

Aryabhatt, not Ramanujan

[@kirankakde]

Navika says Tyson is popular in India because he met the PM! Shows how little Navika knows or cares about what's happening in the real world. Sad to see journalism so consumed by incompetence!

[@pb234]

Everything is going over Navika maam's head. 😢😢😢

[@shibashishdas7982]

Bet Navika didn't get any of the water ice and any of the rocket fuel.. jumps straight into Modiji wala question

[@Jhaaninc]

Neil is more nationalist than pappu can ever dream/fantasis about!

[@g.o.a.t2005]

The reporter was total jack shit, kudos to Tyson for being so kind and accompanying to her

[@tripody1]

Who is actually running the US ? The Champions of Hypocrisy.

[@kaushalgagan6723]

When know nothing about science but you have a job to act like you understand it😂

[@bigheartsmolpen]

"Neil The Grass Tyson" 😅

[@kshitijkolas]

Did she really said Ramanujan gave us 0?

[@knowquietly]

what is the purpose of talking in public place, specially in traffic place

[@knowquietly]

Not Criticizing it But I'm just Curious

[@avinashmishra6783]

No. Not him. I remember Mangalyaan mission. He was asking about inclusion of every strata. Bloody hell!!! Who is he to tell us such things! Why not just celebrate achievements? Why meddling in our internal matters.

[@NaveenKumarfeedback]

After this interview ofcource it's not Neil thinks How come times now wasted this much money on Navika Kumar insted they can put an ai auto voice for asking questations 😂 hope this suggestion will save some money 😬

[@kandaboy3026]

The interviewer was not listening..except noding occasionally to look like she was. Sad.