Pretty Little Liars Fan Theories With the Cast of "PLL: The Perfectionists" | Vanity Fair

[@estellafields9610]

"Emison all the way" I LOVEEEEEEE SOFIA!!!!!

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

0:10 Sasha admits that Marlene changed the PLL story because people guessed it...

[@midel04]

what des the theory please?

[@scaredfromthepast6666]

The Legacy of Gaming No. Can you stop with that? Marlene told Troian that she is the next villain, before even the Cece reveal. They can't just replace Ren with Cece for two weeks.

[@aubreyanahale3084]

Yes we all guessed it was wren so she changed it. I will go o my grave thinking that

[@scaredfromthepast6666]

Aubrey Ana Hale I'm just glad that you are still mad about it. The true fans are happy about ungrateful and vengeful fans. 😘

[@felipemejia3501]

Are we surprised? The story was a whole mess and it was all over the place

[@raeofsunshine7276]

"mArLenE has PLANs fOr eMisoN " "sHe TAkes cARe of EmiSoN" THEN WHY ARE THEY ALREADY HAVING PROBLEMS AS OF THE PERFECTIONISTS EP 1 😤😤

[@arianatormixerblinkoncemy]

xRaex727 right? lol. Also, she didn’t put emison together until the last four episodes of the series.

[@scaredfromthepast6666]

HarmonizerMixer ArianatorCamilizer Because there was no possible sequel without the new problems between them. You are always ungrateful.

[@arianatormixerblinkoncemy]

Gery Nikol Your response makes no sense.

[@scaredfromthepast6666]

HarmonizerMixer ArianatorCamilizer Still, they are not gonna be together. Get over it. It's a spin off.

[@scaredfromthepast6666]

HarmonizerMixer ArianatorCamilizer And actually it makes sense. You are just dumb.

[@allisonreyes9405]

lmao at Sofia mouthing “Emison all the way” at 2:55

[@agapemoreno5627]

allison reyes A MOOD

[@cowmow2385]

💞💞💞 I LOVE SOFIA

[@allisonreyes9405]

falls autu I love her too 💕💕

[@na6389]

Hahah and her cringing at hearing Paily

[@allisonreyes9405]

N A I think we ALL cringed in that part

[@rebecca-gc6lu]

2:49 - 2:57 Watch Sofia cause that's a whole mood

[@inga2314]

2:57 Sasha "I mean I prefer Emison...because...you know, obviously..." 😍😂

[@MilaSmith]

So glad Sasha and Janel are finally getting the recognition they deserve, they are so humble& talented! Ahh love their friendship!

[@indiegogurt]

Mila Smith they also seem like such genuine people!!!

[@MilaSmith]

Carissa Y exactly!! :))

[@sangeetasharma3302]

Lpllllllplplllppppppplpplpppppllpppllplppllllpllllppllplplplplplllpl

[@sangeetasharma3302]

Lppppplpppllllpplpppp

[@sangeetasharma3302]

Plp ll

[@gabriellanesmith5719]

At 3:25 Sofia and Eli do the "A star is born" face thing... So cute!! 😂

[@erinmyers571]

Ik awwww 🥰

[@javiermoney365]

righttt!!

[@-4subscriberswithahammerad521]

Glad they included at least one guy in the group

[@moon9106]

-4 Subscribers with a hammer addiction naah

[@jasonlang9074]

Mary Narcissus hammer addiction? What does that mean?

[@moon9106]

jason Lang honestly idk lol

[@darksky4486]

Well I mean the show was called pretty little liars why would a guy be in the group?

[@babis6919]

Same. It was kind of satisfying watching a guy as a Liar

[@valeriabarragan1829]

Did anyone else notice how Janel reached for Sydney’s hand at 7:08? That was so adorable.

[@albatoolabdrabboh8446]

Valeria Barragan whose sydney

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

@@albatoolabdrabboh8446 ...

[@albatoolabdrabboh8446]

Ohhhh i thought she was shay mitchel!!!

[@mathilda4711]

@@albatoolabdrabboh8446 wtf are u even fan and it's shay mitchell

[@albatoolabdrabboh8446]

Made W no its not 😂 she said her name in the beginning but I didn’t realize

[@weirdpotatoe9533]

When fan theories were ACTUALLY better than pll s7 finale

[@Anam.Fatima19]

true.

[@zo8797]

So true

[@rewatripathi1367]

thats cuz the fans guessed it so marlene changed lol

[@babis6919]

So true

[@carlycrooks4873]

Mona is working with the FBI to find Mary & Alex Drake after they escaped her doll house! 🅰️ #plltheories

[@Lena-zn4re]

Oh shoot.... that's right. What happened to Alex and Mary Drake? If Mona is in Beacon Heights, then who's watching over her dollhouse?

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

@@Lena-zn4re They said they're gone. It's in episode 1

[@Lena-zn4re]

@@thelegacyofgaming2928 Ahh, okay. I haven't started watching the show yet, that's probably why I wouldn't know. Thanks anyways.

[@marianaherrera9728]

The Legacy of Gaming have you seen the new episode the detective confronting Mona ?

[@aishaally3351]

I MISS THE REAL SPENCER😭😭😭😭😭

[@peachy.fabulous5095]

Spencer was amazing

[@kingbil3993]

Troian was amazing 😭❤️

[@aishaally3351]

Ikr!

[@madisontv4515]

Aisha Ally Me too whyyy I just got done crying

[@zoekatz8192]

Am I the only one who misses the old casts ?

[@kingbil3993]

Zoe Katz Yes I miss them so much 💔😭

[@MaivMorrigan]

I only miss Spencer, maybe Emily too, for some reason.

[@RamyaNarendran]

I miss them the most. When they said Caitlyn is Spencer 2.0... I disagreed, no one can play their characters so well and no one can be a character's doppelganger.

[@MaivMorrigan]

@Ramya Narendran preach 👏🏼 I think some of the new cast is just over-acting.

[@RamyaNarendran]

@@MaivMorrigan so true

[@melsvts]

I don't think Nolan is dead,I think its all part of their "plan" to fake his death like taylor did so the take their family down without anyone suspecting what the are doing since they are meant to be "dead"

[@Missmagazinebura]

I think Nolan is with Taylor

[@Sabrina-yu7kr]

Maybe he’s still alive, but those spikes kinda say different

[@promiseholoman1361]

Good point I think that two

[@maggie1000]

Michelle Ampofo No Marlene said flat out he’s dead and it’d be hard to fake your death when everyone saw your dead body on spikes. Normally if someone isn’t dead she’d just tease like “idk what do you think” but I saw somewhere she was like “guys he’s dead ok”

[@peachy.fabulous5095]

He is dead. We saw his body. This is not Alison 2.0

[@melsvts]

Whoever shipped Paige and Emily there must be something wrong with you

[@Angelina076]

That's actually really rude

[@sarahvictoria9555]

LMAO I HATED PAIGE

[@aichaboo3742]

Michelle Ampofo right lmao

[@urfavgirlboss7917]

Ikr

[@javiermoney365]

right paige is so annoying

[@souls9988]

Wait Omg i just got it Spencer- Caitlin Emily/Hannah- Ava Alison- Nolan Aria- Dylan

[@Ashley-wd5fk]

Dxddy x more like Dylan is Emily and Ava is more like aria

[@peachy.fabulous5095]

Emily is dylan.

[@peachy.fabulous5095]

@@Ashley-wd5fk ava is more hannah.

[@kellyrodgers5203]

i could see ava - hanna caitlin - spencer dylan - emily nolan - alison taylor - aria (possibly?)

[@cestlaviexx]

Ashley Alissa Noooo Caitlin - Spencer Dylan - Emily Ava - Aria + Hanna Nolan - Alison PEROIDT

[@user-zp9px9xk5h]

Sofia Carson: a lot happens between Ava and Nolan My guy dies in the first episode

[@jaylenelizabeth9340]

i laughed at this.

[@sinduvarghese4952]

Sofia Carson just sitting there...not knowing what to do😂😂

[@leanna3288]

2:56 sofia in the back “emison all the way” i get you girl

[@amiyamickens5725]

Anyone else hear Sofia say emision all they eat when they were trying to choose which one was better😂😭

[@alexwallar8608]

I did she says it quietly but she said it.

[@angelicalocquiao8559]

Does anybody think that the original cast aria,spencer,etc should be in the perfectionist just a little

[@caitlin9354]

Angelunicorn YT they were going to be in season 2 but not anymore

[@angelicalocquiao8559]

Caitlin L oh that’s sad

[@josie1370]

@@caitlin9354 I was upset when they decided to cancel it, but I heard they might bring it back

[@LeBeautiful]

Pretty Little Liars on Vanity Fair? I'm a believer now.

[@weasley2o13]

Vanity is the girls middle name.

[@angelinthemorning434]

Emison deserves better

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

Mona was in the forest when they were discussing Nolan's death, because she chews gum a lot. Also the body was a fake body on the spikes, Nolan doesn't have a twin.

[@scaredfromthepast6666]

The Legacy of Gaming Hhah, you wish.

[@Missmagazinebura]

Gery Nikol Nolan is probably with Taylor

[@angelrenwick2464]

I think it was fake and he planned his 'death' so that he could run away with his sister

[@Missmagazinebura]

Angel RENWICK that would be predictable

[@hottestpersonalive6620]

It’s definitely real. Allison’s faked death was at least in the books. His isn’t. Julie (one of the OG characters, don’t even get me started on how they took away main characters, like Julie, Mackenzie, and Parker, completely changed the remaining ones, like fr Ava used to be the smart one , like how in the book Taylor was Caitlin’s brother who killed himself bc of Nolan’s bullying, etc.) had a mental breakdown and killed him and got split personalities. I mean I guess there’s a. .000001% chance that he could be alive, since his killer in the books isn’t a character, but it’s highly unlikely.

[@livcooo8276]

just like Ali’s death *sofia does quote on qoutes* cuz she didn’t die ahahha

[@weasley2o13]

Oh no HE'S REALLY DEAD. Watch it and you'll see.

[@livcooo8276]

I’m talking about Ali I know mason dies and wow if i didn’t thanks for the spoil dimwhit הגר גדליוביץ'

[@jolinkels]

I can’t believe Sasha is actually younger than Sofia!

[@javiermoney365]

wait whattt omg

[@samuelfishman8079]

My Theory: There is someone in Beacon Heights who was also effected by A and is waiting to confront Allison and Janel!!!!!

[@thatsovin9562]

Samuel Fishman I would HATE this if it happened bc it’s happened so many times in the original pll it’s like a string of butthurt psychopaths

[@prettypoisendheartgatcha7681]

When I realised that Sofia was there I literally lit up but felt like crying because the other cast wasn’t there ;-;

[@estellafields9610]

everyhting around sasha this lastest interviews is EMISON!

[@MAXKIDDO8888]

And anyone that thinks Nolan is (spoiler alert) actually dead you obviously aren’t a PLL fan

[@hottestpersonalive6620]

Max Bingham 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@sloimix7405]

They saw his body 👀

[@nellielandes6696]

We actually saw the body, and everyone saw the body and he's confirmed dead, this isn't Stranger Things -_-

[@ruzzelladrian907]

I love when Mona talks to the mirror. It's so 007.

[@okayyjen3372]

They really covered the apple sign 😂😂💀

[@aleta14]

okayy jen omfg i didnt notice lol

[@tiaspencer6394]

Did anyone else notice Sophia and Eli doing the a star is born finger run down the nose 😂

[@pvstch5673]

is no one gonna talk about how they spelt ali allie...

[@youknowwhatimsaying9228]

Wishing PLL season 7 is being premiered all over again...getting the feels❤️❤️❤️

[@thefandomedits2358]

Correction season 7

[@naomiwatson8075]

@@thefandomedits2358 what

[@thefandomedits2358]

@@naomiwatson8075 i corrected them 3 years ago, they've fixed it now

[@naomiwatson8075]

@@thefandomedits2358 ok

[@nathanielshaynetagilala2223]

I wish Emily returns (Shay Mitchell)

[@elizabethb6283]

I just think Taylor killed her own brother Nolan so he wouldn’t tell anyone she was alive like he planned

[@happysmiles4339]

Nah, coz Nolan told the killer that Taylor is alive... Doesn't make sense for him to tell his sister that she's alive lol!

[@melsvts]

@@happysmiles4339 I think its all part of their "plan" to fake his death like taylor did so the take their family down without anyone suspecting what the are doing since they are meant to be "dead"

[@Missmagazinebura]

Wouldn’t it be messed up if Mona faked Nolan’s death ?

[@uncantitodelmundo]

Michelle Ampofo J

[@courtneycornett8637]

I think Taylor is very sus. If Nolan thought he was meeting Ali, and Ali and Taylor look so much alike, it would have been really easy for him to think he was talking to Ali, when it was actually Taylor, especially with the hoodie and it being dark.

[@armaineniahrobles7031]

emison all the way!!!

[@059_madelineabigail5]

I hope Alex Drake is out of Mona's doll house and somehow become Ali's student... Or becomes someone important in BHU.... And maybe that someone who killed Nolan was Alex, cause Nolan asked for "help" and we all know Alex was just super genius these... I know I am hallucinating, but, it's okay isn't?

[@peachy.fabulous5095]

Well it's up to Troian. If she decides to play Alex then wam bam thank you mam. We have Alex. If not then no Alex.

[@bryansilva6090]

3:22 watch the back Ava and Eli are saying the theory is “On the nose”

[@erinmyers571]

Bryan Silva no they’re doing the a star is born nose thing 😂😂🤷‍♀️

[@user-ut4qv4lb7r]

Its Sofia no Ava

[@min_min7891]

Love how pll the perfectionist is in Oregon love that my fave show is now in my actual state😂😂😂

[@emilymarierobertson]

Me too! 👏👏

[@meganpearl914]

I just found out they’re filming really close to me but I never leave the house so I doubt I’ll see any of them ☹️

[@rixt6538]

I think that Alex and Mary Drake killed Nolan or watching Allison and Mona, because Mona and Allie spoke about france. Allison said: “ What are you doing here?! I thought you were in.....” Mona: France? Yeah that was great for a while, but the reason i was there escaped me.” And in the last episode of the normal pll you saw Mona in France in a doll store. And underground there was a kinda dollhouse. And there where Alex and Mary!

[@oliviacastaneda8582]

XD Sofia And Eli Are The tAllest Lol

[@user-gk6vw7ck8z]

Aw sasha and janel ❤️

[@jaessoul]

I miss Aria, Spencer, Emily and Hanna so much ugh

[@maribellabindao1479]

Eli : me and Nolan are also secret lovers Sofia : no you're not

[@scoutlafoe3246]

Let’s get this straight. Nobody can ever replace Spencer, or the original PLL cast.😂💖 I love this show though.

[@hashi6068]

Idgaf if ava had bin Ladin as her father any relationship with her is more than acceptable

[@carolinatorresdiaz4727]

Am I the only one that is wondering why they are all here filming videos (that I honestly love) instead of filming the second season????

[@killerineverygame]

Not seeing the original cast makes me sad. I hope they visit alison one day or somethin to be in the show at least once

[@joshuaneal2316]

Emison has always and will always be my favorite ship ever come at me

[@Claireay]

3:23 lmao what is going on back there I’m dying.. I guess that theory is correct lmao.

[@Originalistas_21]

WE NEED SEASON 2!!

[@sharonshebangs3087]

Okayyyy... I think that Jeremy killed Nolan. And, like in the book, there is a split personality disorder- and that Jeremy is Caitlin's other personality.

[@missliv6562]

Sharon Shebangs I personally don’t think that’s what’s going to happen but honestly I hope it does. That is a genius plot, especially since Caitlyn and Jeremy can’t be SEEN together.

[@PatrickFresno]

HUHH

[@AngelLoveQuinnx]

I love that and that would be Genius! Considering that Jeremy has not been in public with anyone and only in secret with Caitlin!

[@estellafields9610]

"you love emison" janel

[@Goldensapphire.]

i lovee themmm 😩😩 cant wait to see more of pll the perfectionist 💯💯

[@kimberlycombs809]

Does anyone ship Sofia and Eli??

[@Sofimyfavperson]

Me

[@alexjohnson1261]

Since the show is cancelled can they tell us who the professor was and how the show was gonna go?!?!?!

[@marinaalexis]

Oh hey, I think I know that first theorist. 😉

[@aitanapastoriza1687]

Emison:like Paily:coment

[@mo0n_head]

Did anyone else never understand how Allie became a teacher because she missed 2/3 years of high school, went to prison and was suspected of murder, how did she get a job at all. No hate I love pll and Allie I just didn't really get it.

[@scoutlafoe3246]

3:26 Sofia and Eli doing A Star is Born Reference😂💖

[@graceeklingensmith3360]

Sasha's eyes are so pretty!!!😍

[@bridgetboyle35]

3:23 - Sofia points to her nose. Like that theory is right on the nose.

[@carleewatterson985]

OMG I FREAKING LOVE YOU GUYS!!!😂❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@bryankelly335]

Sydney is beautiful

[@Bataowata]

I LOVE Eli aka Dylan but he’s so monotone reading these comments

[@maggie1000]

Hanna: Ava Spencer: Caitlin Aria: Dylan

[@vilmaakerblom6691]

When is it coming to Netflix?

[@xgamerqueen2900]

Most likely when the first season in finish but its on Hulu!

[@DestinyOMylife]

Just download the Freeform app and watch it 😊

[@kamila4332]

Like the entire 7.5 mins it was only Mona, Ali, and Sofia talking and Eli and Sydney just like 😐😬. Also around like 7 minutes Sydney said We should change the gc name to that. awwww

[@semaj2856]

My theory is that Mona is the one who killed Nolan and she has multiple personality disorder and she couldn't remember how she killed Nolan. And my theory about the Professor is that he was just threatening all of them and pretending to be the one who killed Nolan.

[@RamyaNarendran]

I hope all the cast of Pretty Little Liars comeback on Pretty Little Liars: The Perfectionists one day. Not just for one or two episodes like cameos.. but as regulars I understand that they are busy, but my imagination and expectation gets me excited so badly, that I want them to comeback so badly.

[@amnabaloch1074]

Sofia is a whole as moood

[@ThuggyMacho]

I'm so mad that this flopped. This show was so good

[@riottkicks2258]

the first theory was actually so interesting omg

[@jadenfuzzell1846]

I think that Alex and Mary drake killed Nolan because in the first episode Mona said "They escaped me." Hmm that sounds very fishy to me what about you!!!

[@roshanyrosa1838]

Sofia is so me when she said “ Emison all the way “ lmfao

[@abbyg3212]

I love how you can tell what’s true by their facial expressions😂

[@livcooo8276]

*we stan pll the perfectionists*

[@brunamalheiro8608]

I really hope Nolan isn’t really dead, i really want to see more Nolan and Ava I found them so cute. It was so sad to see Ava grieving over him because to her he was the only person she had left. If it was up to me Ava and Nolan end game.

[@itsyourmadre3472]

Tbh, honestly kinda sad that the other girls that were in the OG pretty little liars weren't there or at least Shay (Emily) for Ali

[@billiexo4368]

Sofia looking at Sasha 👀🥺

[@ChrisLaRoseII]

LOL “marlene’s mind is amazing!” right after they just talked about how marlene would read fan theories and then run to the writer’s room to change scripts - most likely to STEAL fan ideas, because they are always muuuuch better than literally a single thing marlene and her apparent joke of a writing staff ever came up with themselves... except they’re PAID for writing, they just suck at it.

[@kelseylynn9]

Chris LaRose actually i think it was the opposite - that Marlene went to the writer’s room to change what she originally wrote bc fan theories were nearly 100% correct and she didnt like the fact that the plot was so guessable

[@amazingemily3986]

I think Nolan knows Allie’s background because his mom is the head of the place. Maybe his mom lets him in on the secrets of the school. This is why it seems like he has dirt on everyone.

[@Claireay]

Sofia barely talked..

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

None of the 3 talked. Just Sasha and Janel

[@Claireay]

The Legacy of Gaming true

[@RK1409]

Sasha’s face is so much brighter than my future! 😍 love all the cast ! Amazing show 🔥

[@tori-be7vc]

I agree w/ Sofia : emison all the way / love you sash

[@jaessoul]

We all prefer Emison

[@veroniquehill9314]

Spencer 2.0 doesn't exist, no one can come close to Spencer, ever 😤

[@yogirlshani8563]

Are there going to be anymore episodes

[@elizabethjulia20]

An example of doing a spinoff right.

[@Unknown73837]

Hey what happen To Ad and A in pretty little liars

[@Lena-zn4re]

A was Mona and then it was Charlotte. Then Charlotte was killed in the bell tower. And AD was Spencer's evil twin who was eventually caught and became a literal doll alongside Mary Drake inside Mona's little doll house.

[@ΧρυσαΠανταζοπουλου-ν7δ]

Sofia carson is amazing

[@jadenfuzzell1846]

You can leave Rosewood but Rosewood will never leave you!!

[@shanisruth7681]

Sasha is soo INCLUDED here more than the PLL interviews, it's a good thing

[@nellielandes6696]

Same for Janel; I mean at least Sasha was in some of them! Janel wasn't in any interviews with the Liars. Which is weird because she had more screentime than Sasha :/

[@_REV0_0]

Wow I just found out they are filming in Portland, Oregon I lived there my whole life and recently moved

[@theresagirl8994]

The moment she said : Alison Dilaurentis I smiled and started to cry because I love her so much😩

[@kyilee1657]

Guys what if it is Ava? Hmm? She could of got mad at Nolan when he cheated so she had a reason and set it up when talking to kill idk? Nolan is sill alive! He told his sister to explain to Ava when it is over with...guys I’m going insane