Reaction to YES - "Close To The Edge" (Live 1975)

[@deanmccartney5021]

Yes is my favorite group. I have been to 24 Yes concerts in my day.

[@bigjapi1]

Studio version of this masterpiece is perfect.

[@andythecrimson8877]

Totally agree.

[@Randy245850]

Yessongs version is the best

[@sanddab]

@@Randy245850 Agreed!

[@jaquestraw1]

To me the studio version of CTTE is the finest song ever recorded. 💜

[@jimmorris67]

Yes and Rick Wakeman is so good

[@fatjonseatingadventures5429]

The greatest song, just incredible. Live is so good too

[@TigerMtnKing]

You've got to hear the studio version of this song, it will blow your mind! I would suggest listening to nothing but the studio versions of Yes songs at first and then pick and choose the best live versions to watch. The studio versions are masterly produced and unbelievably amazing!

[@JJ8KK]

Hear here! It's almost a sin to listen to Close To The Edge for the first time via one of their live vid performances. A sacrilege!

[@TigerMtnKing]

@@JJ8KK I agree. There is no way to appreciate the greatness that song is unless you hear the studio version first. I think the live version tends to turn people off because it's too complicated and chaotic for them to comprehend.

[@lenordcurry3170]

I absolutely agree

[@Thirdwind2]

I totally agree!!

[@meljones5108]

They are a fantastic bunch of talented musicians & such a great song. Although I believe you would enjoy it more listening to the studio version.

[@sanddab]

I always recommend listening to the studio version first. That said, the ‘Yessongs’ version is my favorite.

[@samuelharvey3496]

Agreed!

[@lewis9702]

I beg to differ. The live versions of CTTE are far better than the studio version IMHO.

[@edflava4121]

@@lewis9702 Perhaps as an audience member. But the best recording is the studio version.

[@vidalmoreno1584]

Ben Jamming on this for years i am 63 now still Jamming 🎧😎👍❤️🇨🇱🇺🇸🔥🔥

[@markhollands6260]

I agree with the consensus above. Treat yourself to the studio version! Enjoyed your reaction and analysis very much .

[@raykalnins9479]

Many progressive artists in the 60s, 70s, were classically trained and made wonderful compositions based on rhythm , melody, harmony and lyrical composition. All lost in 40 years. I was lucky to enjoy all this wonderment in my youth. What a great time to enjoy real music and musicianship.

[@tobytanzer]

Patrick Moraz and Rick Wakeman are near opposites in style. Rick is classical and Patrick is more on the jazz side. Yet he tried really hard to play Rick's part. He comes close, but I prefer the classical style for this piece.

[@avantprog6902]

Patrick was very interesting on ," Gates of Delirium", also with Bruford, which I was fortunate enough to see live in the early 80's.

[@rogerk55]

Patrick doesn't even appear to be trying to do the keyboard parts well. His tone is horrible most of the time.

[@2JorgeBeat]

@@rogerk55 I Agree!

[@johnshannon9656]

Patrick sounds great on this.

[@D_D_L]

Moraz to me was more of the Bruford replacement than Wakeman,to compensate the lack of feel in White's drumming.

[@matthewnoto9380]

Jon Anderson's voice is one of the most beautiful things in creation. All of you haters, seriously, prog rock sucks? You know nothing! Let's see any of your pansy hair metal bands play like this! Couldn't do it with a gun to their heads. Congratulations for discovering Yes, Verdy. You're about to become ever-more amazed the deeper you dig.

[@jimdukeproject]

Who said prog rock sucks? Whoever said that I wouldn't give them a notice. They obviously don't know anything about music to say that.

[@michaelhogan6770]

@@jimdukeproject Rolling Stone mag. They sure think most guitarists are better than SH.

[@1ouncebird]

@@michaelhogan6770 When it comes to covering and reviewing music Rolling Stone is now and was then a useless rag only worthy of being tossed in the trash can. Their writers never understood music of any complexity. A garbage magazine.

[@yeshayahuhomberger2079]

Verdy beautiful reaction 🤗

[@pauld669]

Just saw Jon Anderson 2 weeks ago perform this. He still sounds great at 77 years old. You must listen to the studio version.

[@magmasunburst9331]

Well John is 2 sevens, 77 pretty cosmic number for him.

[@urex1717]

A brilliant collection of virtuosos who came together and graced us with their genius.

[@heinzbucksandcastle2053]

Yes was one of my top two or three bands growing up. Brilliant!

[@Lightmane]

I don't know if you've heard the studio version, but I recommend that you 'usually' listen to the studio version first, and then watch a live performance. You'll 'usually' enjoy the live performance more, if you've listened to the studio version first... usually : )

[@mannylopez42]

Hello Verdy ... This was a great concert, I WAS THERE IN, 1975. I, STILL LOVE YES!!!!!

[@rodrigoodonsalcedocisneros9266]

Where was it?

[@sethrichardson9974]

I am impressed that you remarked on the relationship between the voices of Chris Squire and Jon Anderson. Many people miss that -- that Chris's voice behind Jon's were staples of Yes vocals.

[@DerekB99]

Close to the Edge is in my top five favourite albums of all time - I have been listening to this song for over 30 years. Favourite group. I have never seen this concert before, so thanks for the reaction. Maracas: " ma-RA-cas" aussi en anglais. Hi from Canada.

[@vicprovost2561]

Agree with others, listen to the studio, better sound and pristine mix, it is truly a masterpiece! Live is great but you should hear the studio first... 🎵

[@andythecrimson8877]

I agree.

[@wimve4719]

Already impressed that you're reacting to Yes .... yesss!

[@mermaidmelodies1492]

Gates of Delirium is another epic Yessong that you may love, the ending is SO beautiful.

[@Divedown_25]

Fantastic tune. Awaken is another amazing song that is a must for Yes

[@Scorpio-kd5it]

I agree with others that say this live version isn't as good as the studio version. You need to do a reaction video of the studio version. Instruments are much more clear and less chaotic than what you hear live and doesn't give the base player the credit he deserves. I think you'll enjoy the studio version better.

[@PeterBuwen]

Close to the edge is in my opinion the greatest work of rock music in the 20th century. For this I subscribed to your channel. You really need to listen to the original studio version from 1972.

[@caroleann_2142]

YEEEEESS!!! 🥰🎶🎵🎶💯 Americas Bi Centennial was 76' We went to see Gary Wright, Peter Frampton & YES June 12 1976 All Day Event Est. 130,000 to 150,000 people at JFK Stadium in Philadelphia Pa. So mesmerizing. Words can't describe that day.

[@davidspalten1304]

She'd love Frampton's Do You Feel.

[@caroleann_2142]

@@davidspalten1304 Yes she would, She does a great job! When she goes bk..to College she'll be doing more again. I support her on Patreon. She deff.. should Do something with Music. I believe it's her calling.🥰

[@ronaldmorgan7632]

Saw them a year later in 1976 (my first concert). It was inside, so maybe 10-15,000 people. Included a laser light show that fit the music perfectly. They played about forty-five minutes, took a break, then another forty-five minutes. Still today the most incredible display of musicianship I've ever seen from a rock band.

[@jimmorris67]

The studio is epic and a must listen.

[@edf13]

This is an interesting version but not the one I would recommend for a first listen even if you were intent on hearing a live version. This version of YES was obsessed with experimentation which makes this a challenging listen. Also Rick Wakeman is essential to this composition.

[@unstrung65]

Better to listen to the recorded version for this piece .

[@TheReaperMan275]

I agree. As good as Patrick Moraz is, I think he improvised a tad too much with Rick's solo. For a while, it sounded like a different song. So, Yes, I agree that the first listen should be the studio recording or baring that, the Yessongs rendition.

[@dolfinpt]

Except …in this vid it’s Patrick Moraz isn’t it?

[@danielperezcabezas109]

I agree with most of the comments.The studio version with Rick Wakeman on keyboards sure is better.Anyway is always joyful watch these great musicians in a live performance

[@freddiebarber4972]

Now you have to treat yourself to the studio version. Note: studio version has different keyboard player (Rick Wakeman) ...who is a master of his trade. Note II: I seen them on this tour in Roosevelt Stadium in Jersey City, New Jersey.

[@JJ8KK]

And a different drummer...

[@joefeld3697]

I was there too . Jersey!

[@rodneygriffin7666]

My favorite song of all time.

[@irish14500]

Saw Yes 90125 concert. Was awesome

[@johnshannon9656]

The free jazz opening is killer.

[@michaelbaxter8046]

Well that brought back memories, I was there. An amazing gig. Glad you liked it.

[@shimwooley]

Second best LP they did. The Yes Album was best in my opinion ! I've seen these guys about 7 times. excellent Band ! Still going strong and still touring. A new singer (Who is very good) and a new bass player. RIP Chris Squire.

[@lyvmyk9988]

I've seen 5 Yes concerts, in almost every configuration. They were always exceptional, no matter who was playing what. Still the gold standard for Yes songs are their albums. Chris Squire makes my best 5 bass players list. Steve Howe makes my best 5 guitarist list. Rick Wakeman makes my best 5 keyboardist list. Jon Anderson makes my best 3 singers list. And Alan White and Bill Bruford certainly make my best top 20 drummers list. With a pedigree like that, they had no choice but to be spectacular.

[@alancritchley5901]

I love the fact that there are younger people like yourself who appreciate timeless classics like this. I think you would like the live version of "And You And I" from the Union tour in 1991. There is a video of it on KZbin posted by Imagine1960.

[@brianbatson2239]

Keep going. Verdy. I get up l get down 🎶Ur vibes r definitely UP……

[@JJ8KK]

I was looking forward to you reviewing Close To The Edge, but you made a major, _major_ mistake in not listening to the studio version first. I get that people are curious about what a band looks like & all, but one of the most supremely admirable things about YES' masterpieces is the perfection they achieved in the studio mix. Close To The Edge is such a perfect sonic creation in its studio manifestation, I doubt any band will ever match it. This live performance doesn't come close to doing it justice. It's a song that is difficult to reproduce on stage. Those who love it will find the parts they love, but it's such a pale imitation of greatness. Another first listener to Close To The Edge did the same thing you did, got a LOT of feedback in the comments that he should listen to the studio version. So he did it and his eyes were opened. He said that though he had watched the vid, he hadn't really _heard_ the song & was blown away. He even reprimanded his audience for steering him to the live version when the studio version was so much better. Please do yourself a favor & _now_ treat yourself to the studio version. You won't regret it.

[@Phi1l]

Thanks for all your reviews, I love to see how much you enjoy discovering new music, or should I say old music? lol. This live performance was at Queens Park Rangers football stadium in London & their record attendance for a football match in 1974 was 34,000, so you would have to subtract how many people to fill one end & add how many to fill the pitch. If you want to listen to a great Yes concert (maybe a bit too long to review) look for Yes 1978 at Wembley Arena on You tube & just enjoy 2hrs of magical live music.

[@nicodegallo7886]

Please listen to the studio version!!

[@ErnestAbikis]

Hearing this song live in 2001 was a spiritual experience. First row, a few meters from Jon's loving eyes.

[@krisdoggett483]

Jon's loving eyes?😳😆😂

[@krisdoggett483]

The Close To the Edge album is one of their greatest accomplishments. Three songs on the album. You need to experience that one for sure. Jon Anderson has a great voice and you're right Jon and Chris's vocals complement each other perfectly.

[@kontolek]

słucham bez końca.. piękne !

[@michaelhowell7275]

2 of the best live songs in 2 days.....Impressive.

[@dylanbrown5414]

Always listen to the studio version first!

[@jimdukeproject]

This was the first Yes song to get my attention as a kid and has a special significance showing the talent of their individualism within the song. Odd time signatures and rhythms even at the same time then coming together at the specified point.

[@thierrycasties6633]

Hello...I'm from Paris, France. It's a real pleasure to follow you discovering all those masterpieces.. I love your beautiful deep voice...I suggest you to listen to the album version of Close to the Edge, and also the two other tracks of the album....And if you like the way Yes is always surprising us, please listen to the double album Tales from Topographic Oceans..it will kill you..!!

[@blitztim6416]

I saw this tour as a teen at the Hollywood Bowl. Great show. Great band. Wasn’t sure about Moraz on keys but I grew to like him.

[@samuelharvey3496]

The little cymbals above the xylephone are called crotales. Tuned small cymbals, note they look like piano keys.

[@avantprog6902]

There is a live version of, " The Gates of Delirium ", you must hear! I'm almost positive it's from this concert.

[@JimmyRJump]

Saw Yes in November 1977 at Sportpaleis in Antwerp, Belgium. Was nice but also sad. The tickets were numbered and the number corresponded to a seat and a good friend of mine had died in an accident in-between the day I bought the tickets and the day of the concert and the seat next to mine was empty. Another strange thing was Donovan, a British troubadour kind of musician, was the opener for Yes. A la prochaine.

[@rodneyhearne3405]

Nice reaction, still my favorite!

[@your_local_dummy4137]

This live version (6/10) is okay but the studio version (10/10) with the amazing Rick Wakeman on keys is absolutely perfect in all ways. Give it a listen and do not worry there is no video because Yes could build amazing soundscapes without any video. But you must listen to the original studio version with Rick's magnificent and majestic keyboard playing. I think Patrick played about with the keyboard parts too much and made them sound a bit like Dr Who at times. Don't get me wrong Patrick is a great keyboard player and to listen to him on Relayer is a must but he is different to Rick Wakeman.

[@dolfinpt]

As a Huge Fan of Yes -I too suggest the studio version first for this masterpiece! It’s a lot to take in. Love seeing them live! (48+ times) Do your self a favor and listen again to the studio version! Besides it’s been said to truly appreciate Yes-you have to listen to a song 3x!❤️

[@djmcgranary714]

Love the ..do, da da Doo da, da Doo reference!!!✌️🤟💚

[@markroberts8864]

Enjoying the music you are reacting to, count me in as a new subscriber.

[@GrouchyMarx]

You should do the studio album "Close To the Edge" in its entirety as you did The Yes Album and Fragile. The album's title song takes up one whole side of the LP and side 2 contains just two long and very awesome songs you'll love too. ✌😎

[@samuelharvey3496]

To me, the beginning, seemingly discordant intro to CTTE is like cleansing your palette after you ate a type of food. A bit of water, to clear out that first bit, but then, it's the best 2nd course you ever ate, or heard in this case. Also Dessert!

[@markmotley8516]

Greg lake and Keith Emerson are two of the most talented keyboard players ever.

[@gilbertthouin5295]

Un autre groupe que j ai bien aimer et que j ai vue en spectacle 2 fois leurs voie son superbes

[@taylort5672]

I loved Yes at the time, but I'm not sure why so many praise this piece, it just shows me why punk took over,

[@SymbolRudolf]

I just want to say this likely sounded A LOT better at the concert. I've been to several YES concerts and they take you on a journey and the energy just kind of flows through you. Closest thing to that feeling I know of is TOOL. I am too young to have seen Zeppelin in concert but based on the Madison Square Garden they might have been the best live band ever... and probably just the best band ever. For me, YES is an amazing collection of talent and definitely in my top 10. Great reaction. Can't wait for the live 1973 Whole Lotta Love reaction...

[@philflower7778]

Arguably Yes best song ever!! No disrespect to Patrick Moraz but Rick Wakeman missing from this live version is considerable. Just an epic master piece though!! Love it!!

[@danielfox6907]

Former keyboardist Rick Wakeman put out his solo album( Journey To The Center Of The Earth) after YES, and you will be astounded by his musicianship.

[@richardbradley1532]

Probably my favourite prog track but will need to save until tomorrow as it's time for bed.

[@davidspalten1304]

I saw Yes twice during the early-mid '70s at Madison Square Garden. Incredible shows. Another great progressive band I'd strongly recommend, but with a harder rock edge: Jethro Tull. Try the Aqualung Album for harder rock or Thick as a Brick for their more progressive aspect of their work.

[@Brian-tb1zs]

Madison square garden must have been a great show, I saw Yes in 1980, at the Spectrum in Philadelphia

[@andythecrimson8877]

Progressive Folk.

[@samwatson2039]

Regular Organist Rick Wakeman left group for his own Solo tour . Patrick Moraz was a well needed replacement. He did a commanding performance even though wasn't perfect. I believe this was live performance at Roosevelt stadium in Jersey City , New Jersey. I was sitting on blanket on grass 100 feet from stage . Was amazing to watch these incredible musicians live

[@barriehull7076]

Modern maraca balls are also made of leather, wood or plastic.[6] A maraca player in Spanish is a maraquero.

[@dannylast8707]

i saw them back then..great show..rick wakeman!

[@Divedown_25]

When listen to this almost 50 years later…. Where do you find this musicianship today? Yes there are really great bands out there with Polyphonia, Dream Theater, Nightwish and many others are as well really great… but on this level when it comes to composition?

[@denislaferriere2693]

Tool is at that level of musicianship imho.. Not the same genre....but ull be flabbergasted by their absolute talents

[@pablofumega505]

Hello, to better appreciate the song Close to the Ege live, watch that song at a recital in Switzerland in approximately 2017... there is the original group from the album and you can enjoy Alan White and Rick Wakeman in all their splendor

[@pablofumega505]

Live in Montreux 2003... The Best!!!!!!!!

[@jackknife8317]

studio version URGENTLY

[@benridge6570]

Thanks for the video, had a couple of yes albums. Back in the day. Start off like Frank Zappa Album. Nice reaction 👌

[@tcanfield]

It’s understandable that they had occasional “ off”nights. I looked up a schedule once for 72’ (when I saw them) to check the date I saw them and was blown away by how grueling it looked. I think they were averaging about 5 gigs per week ! They were young, but man were they under lots of stress to bring their magic so often, when they must have been so tired.

[@lsp3]

One thing you missed out on from this instead of the studio version is the great bass playing of Chris Squire. Also, the high mix of the cymbals drowned out a lot of the vocals and the rest of the instruments. You can hear everything much clearer on the studio version.

[@ajones957]

This is unfortunately about the worst live performance one could pick to evaluate this song. As others have mentioned, I'd highly suggest the studio version first. And after you could probably pick just about any other live version and it would be better than this. The studio version has masterful playing from Bill Bruford, the original drummer who is far more subtle than Alan White (RIP) and Rick Wakeman, whose style and playing is far more appropriate to the music than Patrick Moraz. Now before people get pissy about Pat Moraz, I think he was great on Relayer.

[@frankmarsh1159]

@Matt Leppard They may have been good performances but unfortunately they were not mixed properly. This video syncs up a remix of the studio tracks : kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y5_UY4udpa-bmpI

[@caroleann_2142]

As much as I appreciate Patrick Moraz as an original keyboardist,, Rick Wakeman is Bar none & he is Classically trained, just perfect! He put his style into an already incredible Band & it showed. The Keys were so important. Just Look at "AWAKEN"...

[@PlatinumBlack90038]

@Matt Leppard First three albums.

[@frankmarsh1159]

@Matt Leppard It goes to the remix when I click it and who is Doug?

[@ajones957]

After I read my comment I want to ensure I express that I recognize this isn't the fault of the reviewer. My comment was made in haste and I know this performance was recommended to her. I rather enjoy her reactions and I am simply suggesting that she check out the original studio version first. And through the various incarnations of Yes - i think they all play their role. I enjoyed the original incarnation with Tony and Peter, but I do think "The Yes Album" is one of their best, and I rather like Steve's guitars on it. Sorry, Matt... I thought Pat Moraz did a great job on Relayer. Not sure Rick would have given it that kind of frantic energy it needed on "Gates..." But I do think each serves their contribution the best. I'd like to hear Tony on his originals, and I like to hear Rick on his. And I think Alan White was great for his original compositions. I don't think Billy would have been into Tales or Relayer. And despite others' opinion, I rather like the "Big Generator" version of Yes. I just don't compare the incarnations - much like I don't try to compare Genesis with and without Gabriel. I just appreciate them as they are. But I hope she give Close to the Edge a listen on the studio. I just happen to think this version is woefully inadequate.

[@stephenignatz8364]

Steve was playing a Coral Electric Sitar on that Break you liked.

[@stanleymerritt4722]

As many other have said, please do yourself a favor and listen to the studio version.

[@roimerlopez1275]

Amazing reaction my friend....In 2017, the music world was shocked by the bursting onto the scene of a 22-year-old singer named Dimash Kudaibergen, who performed on the famous Chinese competition show for professional singers called “The Singer”... It was just It was necessary for this young man to make his first appearance, making a cover of one of the most difficult songs in the world, a famous French composition called "S.O.S. D'un Terrien En Détresse", to be considered from that moment on as the best singer in the entire planet....No one in the musical field had ever seen a human being, being able to reach vocal ranges above 7 octaves and several semitones, that is, all 88 keys of a digital piano, which reaches a little more than 7 octaves and as if that weren't enough, sing the more than 12 languages...Since then all kinds of experts (Vocal coach, analysts, singing teachers, youtubers, reactors, etc.) have dedicated themselves to reviewing their presentations to try to understand how someone can sing this way...The incredible thing is that that presentation in China was in 2017 and 5 years have passed since then, but what Dimash has done in these 5 years is to further improve his wide vocal range, which is currently practically above of the 8 octaves... The Covid pandemic stopped his concerts worldwide, all with tickets sold in just seconds, via the internet, but at the same time it ended up catapulting him to the top of popularity worldwide...Anyway, since I think you are one of those reactors who have not yet met this impressive singer, here is the link of that presentation in China in 2017, with the song S.O.S. and I would like you to mention my name as the person who recommended him to you..It is a more recent video than the others, so it does not have the same number of views as the previous ones, which have millions of views, but it is a more complete video, with an intro, subtitles in several languages and with the improved quality of audio and sound....kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHW7ZHmeot6Bl8U

[@MartGaebler]

I prefer the version from `YESSONGS`. I bought the three LP-Set spring 1975 and it´s one of my favourites live albums ´till now.

[@paulbrinkman5631]

From Chaos to Creativity.

[@DerekB99]

When this keyboard sound is introduced here, kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2OueYJsoMt8p8U. On the studio album, the keyboard played by Rick Wakeman, the original keyboardist, at that point , is a cathedral organ! Listen to it, and turn the volume way up! Wakeman studied at the Royal College of Music in the UK.

[@hugoalderete2434]

Hello, you should have heard the 1972 version live with Rick Wakeman on keyboards, who was the one who originally recorded it

[@markroberts8864]

Other than the studio recording, I think the best live version is on, "Yessongs".

[@reneelyons6836]

Patrick Moraz is playing keyboards. The usual guy playing keys is Rick Wakeman. Masterpiece!!!!!!!

[@jimdunagan4180]

Yes is like....hmmm...not caviar but something like that...it's hard to like it all but it's elite.

[@jamescorcoran2273]

They were great in concert esp with mesc or lsd hahaha

[@lesblatnyak5947]

Ladies and gentlemen Chris Squire and Yes the greatest show on earth. Nice version of CTTE but definitely not their best live version. Recommend always listen to the studio versions first to get the full journey the band is telling. South Side of The Sky is their best vocal adventure. Enjoy your Yes journey.

[@npc8348]

Why did you choose this live version of all things...? LOL As everyone else has said, I recommend listening to the studio version first. If you want, listen to the album of the same name with "Close to the Edge" on it, as well as the subsequent releases "Relayer" and "Going for the One" in their entirety! And be struck by the magnificent musical world Yes has created!

[@your_local_dummy4137]

I think several modern reactors like and are attracted to song versions with video. That is the established format now. But little do they know that back in the 60's and 70's it was all about the audio. Video was non-existent or some-what primitive. So the technology supporting studio audio was so far in advance of video.

[@willythughes1486]

Hello Missy V I enjoy your reactions and love your musical journey as you explore the depths of what was. If you really want to see music being made check out the Lexington Lab Band’s “ the making of a band” on KZbin. They are incredibly talented and a great cover band.

[@user-zl9qb3fx8tq]

J'adore Close To The Edge mais j'ai trouvé cette version plutôt poussive et assez approximative. Je ne peux que te suggérer la version de l'album live "Yessongs" et la version studio sur l'album éponyme de 72. 💚💚

[@gavinrogers4055]

The quality may not be great but it sounded fine on the day. I know because I was there.

[@verrilli]

That's not Rick Wakeman on keyboards. Maybe Patrick Moraz? This performance is a bit raw. Later live recordings of this song are a more refined. Still, very interesting to see it and to hear your reaction!

[@lesblatnyak5947]

Correct this version of CTTE is interesting from the standpoint that Moraz does the keys and its simply not up to snuff. Plus the soundtrack is not up to snuff.

[@bobblethreadgill4463]

Verdi, take the time to treat yourself to the studio version... I think this is Patrick Moraz on keyboard, Rick Wakeman played the studio version..., I could be wrong though...

[@RedVynil]

Maracas: The way YOU pronounced it was almost correct and what we call them, too. It's basically, ma RA cas. Only, in this case, Jon only had one so it was maraca. "That guitar" that you mentioned about 12:00 in is actually an electric sitar. Too bad they never actually showed Steve playing it! On keyboards was Pat Moraz, from either France or Switzerland, I'm not 100% sure which. He's taking over for Rick Wakeman, who was on the album version of this song. By this time, Rick was doing a number of solo albums. Again, had they bothered to show Pat playing for more than 5 seconds, you would've seen that he probably had a dozen keyboards surrounding him. The bass player, Chris Squire, possibly sings slightly lower than Jon. I've never been able to figure it out because they both sing quite high. Sadly, he and the drummer in this video have both died! Alan just died about 2 months ago. Chris died several years ago just after I met him. I would say there's closer to 100,000 in that arena. Now, you wanna see a HUGE crowd, watch the Woodstock movie!! There were nearly half a million people at that concert for 4 days!! Too bad you don't live next door to me! I could fill you in on SO MUCH music and it's history!!

[@christianrene7479]

Close to the Edge est probablement un chef d'oeuvre de la période rock progressif des années 70s... autant la pièce que l'album du même nom... malheureusement, au risque de se répéter, cette version semble avoir de nombreux problèmes au niveau des volumes de chacun des instruments... les claviers sont parfois trop forts... la bass, qui a une partition très originale dans cette pièce, est un peu perdue dans le mixage... il faut faire une réaction de l'album studio absolument !!! Cette pièce a tellement de détails et de complexité que cette version rend plus ou moins justice ! Bref, Verdy, bienvenue dans le monde du meilleur groupe de rock progressif (en tout cas, selon moi!) 🙂

[@michaeljones9301]

The best eve Live version is ABWH in 1990. Nothing compares. Bills drumming completes the song.

[@lylesmith3506]

As mixing Chris and Jon’s voices. Check out Turn of the Century, off of the Going For The One album. Perfection.

[@PREPERMIKE2012]

I really like that your starting to watch Live performances now. I also like that your videos do not skip or break up the song in editing like you have done in the past. Although I do like the band "YES" for me this particular sone was not one of my favorites, I have seen other videos from this same performance of songs I think are much better IMO. Keep being you Verdy.