Video of aid truck used by Israeli forces in the hostage release operation

"Is it ethical for the occupation army to use an aid truck to rescue hostages?"
Al Jazeera broadcast a video of an aid truck used by Israeli forces in the hostage release operation on Saturday, which resulted in the killing of over 210 Palestinians.
The Israeli military stated that it had rescued four captives from central Gaza in a "complex daytime operation" in the Nuseirat refugee camp and taken them to a hospital in good condition. Those rescued were identified as Noa Argamani, Almog Meir Jan, Andrey Kozlov, and Shlomi Ziv.
Since Saturday morning, Israeli forces have launched air strikes on Deir al-Balah and the Nuseirat refugee camp, resulting in the deaths of at least 210 Palestinians, including women and children, and wounding 400 more, according to the Palestinian government media office in Gaza.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEastEye_TG
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye

[@wilpinkley4662]

If vehicles marked as neutral humanitarian were used in offensive military operations, this could constitute the war crime of perfidy.

[@frogman-152]

Yet you use hospitals to hide your weapons, explosives & entrances to Terror tunnels. B/ S Hamas propaganda!

[@Oil_uj7499]

IDF playing the Hamas insurgency game. No like it, huh?

[@christopherperrote7780]

​@@Oil_uj7499 found the ZioNazi

[@OverlyCuriousEngineer]

​@@Oil_uj7499IDF being a bunch of pussies who have accepted defeat and now resorting to these tactics. Diaper force has proven how crappy it truly is. Not being able to beat an insurgency that developed right under its nose. Too bad.

[@AshabSiddiqui]

​@@Oil_uj7499 learn english before you speak

[@lisalisa1656]

The devil's army...

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎Satan said Devils/Jinns are Superior Race ▪︎Hitler said Ariens are Superior Race ▪︎Those who hold Superior Race complex ▪︎Following God or Satan?

[@JamilJack-vt4xu]

​@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeingsAryns are clearly superior.

[@lisalisa1656]

@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings they r following Satan as was hitler

[@Sleepy_joe2697]

​@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings satan for sure

[@user-dp2ch9lk7p]

Sick army🤮

[@dawudchen9238]

Disgusting.

[@user-gv8of6ux8t]

You are the devil yourself! They released hostages, did not go to kill. This is a problem of the residents of Gaza who love death and blood

[@zehrag3781]

Evil

[@yohanezahmad5818]

Beyond Evil!

[@46-uzairali49]

Ziopigs

[@lisettzamuner2038]

Now they even use humanitarian aid trucks, unbelievable

[@user-ch5xq3lt9k]

Why not?

[@Yusufkh-123]

​😂why not​?? What kind of a question is that@@user-ch5xq3lt9k

[@RogerLewis-ey2tt]

​@@user-ch5xq3lt9k It's a wonderful surprise that the IDF hasn't managed to kill ALL the hostages. My guess is that the IDF killed MORE aid workers and stole their truck. It just points up the difference between those who only want to live peaceful lives, and those who use a criminal act of terrorism by a few people, as an excuse to murder everyone else who was only living in peace, so they can loot their homes and steal the offshore gas fields that the God Israel claims to worship gave to the Palestinians. One thing Goy World has learned: the stark difference between amoral Zionists and real Jews. I feel sorry for decent Israelis who oppose the g€nocide and apartheid; I know THEY get thrown in jail too.

[@lilianafarran1527]

​@@user-ch5xq3lt9kif you'd be familiar with the international laws of war you would not ask such a silly question.

[@crips145]

Rem the kitchen mob same deal

[@DerAraber]

So this is not a "human shield" tactics? They don't use aid trucks as human shields?

[@SordidusFellatio]

I tend to ignore whatever bs statements that came out of their mouth and the people bootlicking them. It’s just another example of a desperation at trying to justify why they’re the good guy and why the entire world shouldn’t hate them 😂 except for India tho, India *LOVE* licking Israel’s ass for some awkward reason, that reason being that they wanted rain of gifts and economic prosperities from USA to help them fight their arch nemesis Pakistan, which they still hasnt win against even after all of that boasting, also the fact that nobody in the world care too is the hilarious part 😂

[@rayoflight39]

What​@@kegamoipa

[@umairnadimulk8736]

I wouldn't use human shield tactics.

[@user-fy8ln9if1w]

How can a truck be a human shield, it’s not human I don’t think you understand how the human shield tactic works

[@Kim-se9yb]

It’s a Trojan Horse.

[@nettiumar5699]

the most immoral army

[@Faiter.Re_Ri]

جيش كولوم الشفهي😂

[@divad1818]

Isn't it the pro Palistineans who came up with the phrase "Every accusation is a confession"? Sooo true.

[@Faiter.Re_Ri]

@@divad1818 😂 the phrase is from you not pro-palestinian, because you're confused in your life ☝️

[@divad1818]

@Faiter.Re_Ri You are mistaken. Look at any comment section regarding Israel and "Palestine". 95% of the time, accusations come from pro-Palestinians: "They're committing genocide!", "SatanYahu," "They're so evil!", etc. It's just nonstop smack talk from you guys.

[@claudiak.7803]

Warum keine Videos von Hilfsfahrzezgen wo die Hamas ihre WAFFEN transportiert. ziemlich einseitig die Videos

[@malakfalah7996]

The most moral army in the world 😂😂

[@user-fq3es2xf9d]

Immoral army in the world👌

[@black-db2my]

Yes, they should check ✔️ the word "moral" in a dictionary

[@ahmeda.3198]

They’re the most moral Lingerie Force in the world, they only wear grandma’s bras.

[@208flatheads3]

Why were they keeping hostages in the middle of a refugee area? 🤔

[@ahmeda.3198]

@@208flatheads3 The whole area is a refugee area. Mainly refugees from 1948. Go checkout some clips from the documentary Tantura, and when you see the IDF smile as they recall what they did, you’ll have an idea of what they were refugees from.

[@handmadesoap8327]

Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@amberjohnston781]

This gets more and more despicable

[@neylaw.6272]

Evil! Evil! Evil!

[@Maria-EU]

They shouldn't hide in aid trucks, they might accidentally target themselves.

[@t.h.i.n.k.970]

This is sickening... may Allah Taala protect and enlighten the believers.

[@mazizul112233]

Sickening both US and israhellish...

[@hadijakaitare7594]

At least they look well fed and not beaten up like Palestinians who are in Israel prison.

[@craigbrown8180]

Prisoners in Israel get 3 meals a day and visitation rights. Yahya sinwar had brain surgery while in an Israeli prison.

[@idontknow6151]

​@@craigbrown8180 Most prisoners shouldn't be there in the 1st place! Now talk about the prisoners who had their hands amputated because the ropes were to tight? Talk about the sodomy in israeli camps. Talk about kids as young as 9 years old being placed in isolation. Most of the food is not edible. Kids come out with broken bones. Get out of here with your fairytail.

[@craigbrown8180]

@@idontknow6151 I'm not sure where you get your information. Your name gave me the answer. "I don't know "

[@robinhammoudeh9136]

​@craigbrown8180 is the 3 meals and visitations before or after the torturing? Did the 27 people who have been murdered in those prisons since Oct 7th get 3 squares and visitations do you think? Were they allowed to remove the blind folds during g those meals which were given to them by straws and do you think they sat in the stress positions during those visitations? Were there hands and feet untied during those visitations especially the ones who had amputations because the zip ties were so tight and on there so long? Did they bring there family's from gaza for those visitations to those hidden prison camps were cnn couldn't even get in? 🤔

[@idontknow6151]

@@craigbrown8180 Yes my name is "I don't know" as in I don't know how you can be this blind. You could've searched it by now but you don't want to face that reality.

[@user-tp4zw7dh5g]

210 died for what ?!!!!!! 4 hostages !!!! Horrific !!!!!!😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

[@user-gw6sq4ox8e]

Looks like you are the only moron here....go scream at #it's not real for killing half of the hostages then come tell us how much that sucks...

[@hopefulperson9057]

​@@kegamoipahasbara troll. Free Palestine and the world from satanic Zionism 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@se3rat]

@@kegamoipaso killing 210 innocent people to save 4 people is okay? Are you braindead or something?

[@myth_buster_]

​@@kegamoipajust agree to the ceasefire deal if you have some commonsense

[@beeb8293]

@@myth_buster_ Stop killing babies would be commonsense

[@HassowMohamedbiko]

Shame on nyatenyahu and his government

[@ibrahimfarah8378]

Shame on mileikowsky and the fake senile biden

[@farihafatima5695]

This is despicable

[@soofian147]

They don't stop surprising me

[@zoo-xibbitjayne2081]

Hamas guerilla fighters won't target an aid truck is the reason they're using it i suspect. Hamas fighters are too moral to target an aid truck or...a hospital.

[@pentaxtp7527]

lol

[@louisjeandin1970]

You got a point there

[@gemmameidia8438]

You reminds me of that israeli mom and she was with both of her children that told a story when haman entered her house and what hamas said smtg like, "we are muslims, we dont attack you" and when one of hamas saw a banana on the table what he said was, "May I eat that?" And the mother said, "yes ofc" bruh, this kind of mannerism shows a lot what kind of person they are.

[@Uncanny_Mountain]

​@@pentaxtp7527 so how many times did they shoot the helicopters Evacuating the injured?

[@charlessmith-vh9cw]

hamas shot fleeing palistinians. hamas hides under palistinians using them as shields. hamas puts arms supplies inside palistinian refugee camps. how stupid can one person be?

[@user-vq3wb2nu2j]

Real face of Israel.

[@claudiamagangna1685]

Just imagine how these hostages should feel, knowing that they are the reason for the death of so many people!!!

[@NemoElohemi]

Really? 😂 I tell you how they feel. They feel they shouldn’t be kidnapped in first place. Not to mention so many of their friends and families killed at the same time. Hamas killed 1400 Israelis in six hours, kidnapped 252. All of this is on them and their supporters. They are just happy to be free.

[@oanapopescu6176]

@@NemoElohemi actually half of 1200 isrealis (not 1400 by the way) were killed by your moral army. And 400 of them they actually were soldiers. And they knew they kill their own citizen. And by the way we all know now that this didn't started on 7 october. So don't try to gaslight us with your zionist propaganda.

[@marwamahmoud2279]

​@@NemoElohemi Why aren't you updated of your government lies ? They update the number to 1200 , then an investigation of your Haartz and testimonies of the survivors revealed that many of the victims were killed by the IOF

[@alanhat5252]

​@@NemoElohemienough of the BS hasbara! 😮

[@cbluejay2499]

​@@NemoElohemiwake up!

[@user-ij9ph8dh2u]

Shame on you IDF diaper Forces

[@darrenmohamad8370]

Free Palestine

[@je.sy.]

So heartbroken 😭😭😭😭😭

[@user-ue6qb4po3g]

This is what you call it using civilians and human for protection. IDF ethical code

[@user-ue6qb4po3g]

Free free free free Palestine

[@Inioxos]

Free Palestine Stop Genocide...Ο λαός της Ελλάδας στέκεται στο πλευρό της Παλαιστίνης 🇬🇷🇵🇸🇬🇷

[@bensweiss]

How despicable.

[@legendsucuk2057]

#freepalestine #savegaza #alleyesonrafah

[@specialingu]

Think its against rules of war? Perfidy? perhaps.

[@abuansari05]

Spot on, let’s see what the American and British bigots say about this massacre

[@Uncanny_Mountain]

Isn't it time we the people took responsibility for our own collective failure to hold our leaders to account for far too long. _"All People's have the right to self defence from Colonial rule, including armed resistance"_ UN Charter: Protocol 1 Call for Government by People's Referenda: Peaceful Encampment of our Capitals until it's installed, or run Mascot Candidates Single Issue Referendums with thresholds and a social contract means Communities can vote their own laws. A Public Authority can audit police and prosecute bad cops in our own courts. Nationalise resources and give Indigenous peoples the right of Sovereignty over them as Guardians. This can be achieved through a General Strike or Velvet Revolution, much like the Occupy movement, peacefully occupying State Buildings until a People's Mandate can be implemented. With the appropriate checks and balances, you could have a national digital forum where qualified professionals can debate the issues in a public setting without all the disinformation and bad faith antics, hatespeech etc. Any vote would need to pass the 70% threshold, with a veto or _rewrite_ vote needing 30%. The issues would be debated, the public educated, and then a vote taken. Votes that fail will have to wait a year before trying again. Any new proposal (Citizen Initiated Referendum) would have to reach a threshold of support before it made it onto the register. This would be subject to a Social Contract (New Constitution) that forbids human rights abuses and discrimination. That can be written in the same manner based on the core principles we all share. Councils and Boards could operate in the same fashion at Scale. It works in a way that obligates people to better educate themselves ( that is to use logic and evidence in their reasoning ) for a better understanding of the issues, and then take collective responsibility for the outcomes. As opposed to the divisive US v them scapegoating and bi-partisan finger pointing the current Capitalist Pyramid Scheme runs on. Enough is enough We need Government by People's Referenda, either through Mascot Candidates or Peaceful Encampment of the Capitals until one is established. Make it an annual March on Oct 14 Under a single white flag 🏳️ You can copy/share 🙏 It's about Peace and Democracy; don't give them anything to twist Done without shouting or banners, this strategy cannot be stopped once in motion It's time to end the Colonial State #Decolonise the Middle East

[@muhammadesa2517]

So if hamas attack aid trucks and take food then why wasn't this attacked by em ages ago

[@majl7917]

Our intelligence showed the truck was fine and not in need of any aid. This was NOT an aid truck. - every Israeli statement that only makes sense to them -

[@briancrowther3272]

Never forget and never forgive. Is lies must be stopped. Free Palestine. Anglo sydney australia

[@user-wc8lw9km4w]

No way they used an aid truck!😅 what a moral group of people

[@ayshaalbusmait9935]

💔💔💔💔

[@sabriahabib893]

Evil nation and evil army

[@viptravels1542]

Is there any greater humanitarian aid than freeing hostages?

[@alanhat5252]

...and killing 210 of the people the aid was intended for?

[@RayleeMoon]

🇵🇸

[@naheedzaman4475]

For how long? Speechless 😡😡

[@Yusufkh-123]

What kind of army use an aid truck and civilians cars to save a 4 hostages 😂

[@michaelw2288]

An army fighting a force that operates in civillian clothes, civillian vehicles and out of civillian facilities. The only surprise is that Hamas did not try to sieze the aid truckfor their own use.

[@RogerLewis-ey2tt]

​@@michaelw2288oh please. That's a Hasbara way to describe Israel's g€nocide. 10/7 was just an excuse to make Gaza Palestinianrein and steal the offshore gas fields that the God Israel claims to worship gave to the Palestinians.

[@ayshaalbusmait9935]

🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@punkrockpolitics7982]

Can't read what he's saying ad it is block by donation tabs and other tabs

[@aurifaber81]

- A humanitarian aid truck, and we know how much the people of Gaza need aid. Is it ethical for the occupation army to use an aid truck to carry out a rescue or hostage release operation? - Yes, that is what they did. - This truck just passed by. We have been following it now, specifically, this [aid] truck passed in these scenes.

[@muhammadesa2517]

The IDF used aid trucks to recover those 4 prisoners And they say hamas attacks the aid trucks and takes food

[@WAUWAU4587]

kamas never target aid truck used by israel....wow thats a whole big story who was kamas and how coward the IDF was using aid truck to bring the hostages back...

[@SR-np1od]

I'm sorry to hear about the Nuseirat massacre. That must have been a terrible and tragic event.Isreal is certainly capable of great cruelty and violence, which is deeply saddening.While it's important to condemn atrocities and work to prevent them, i wonder in such world can we able to build a more just and humane world. please share and say no for Israel terrorists .

[@RogerLewis-ey2tt]

That's such a beautiful thought. There are decent Israelis, too, who only want to end apartheid and live together in peace.

[@alanhat5252]

​@@RogerLewis-ey2ttthen they are not z1onists & not welcome within the z1onist project that is 1srael!

[@iracemagoncalves3475]

❤LFREE PALESTINE❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@ayshaalbusmait9935]

💔💔💔

[@kurukafadeser4910]

Daha çok protesto edilmeli

[@idoofir238]

Let me get this straight... you are holding hostages, and you are questioning the ethics of the people who are coming to rescue them from you? for the type of car they use?

[@lindanurdreamz]

They had NO PROBLEM GETTING THAT AID TRUCK IN !Tell me again why it’s the only aid truck in weeks allowed to enter? The Most Moral Army in the world,

[@user-bh4tl6ob4v]

hope the driver is ok

[@bdinaz]

What does this video supposedly depict? All i see is a commercial vehicle that has somehow been inserted in between two IFV. Happened to me in Germany all the time.

[@MalcomAli]

They can use an aid truck to release the hostages and can’t use similar tactics to spare innocent lives?

[@mosminakhatun248]

Ya Allah apne bando pe rehm kar ya arrhmarrahemin rehm kar ya rabbul alamin madad kar sabr ata kar hifazat farma hasbunallah wa nimal wakeel

[@staycool3133]

#FreePalestine🇵🇸🤝🇮🇷🤝🇱🇧🤝🇾🇪🤝🇸🇾🤝🇮🇶

[@clipazia3330]

Freedom for Palestine 🇵🇸☘️ Prosperity for Palestine 🇵🇸☘️ Long live Palestine 🇵🇸☘️

[@shajeea3522]

What an inhumane act

[@craigbrown8180]

Just by chance, all the hostages were being held in homes of innocent gazans.

[@maryfarrell9439]

It’s against international law to use an aid truck in a military operation.

[@jacksonrazorback5626]

Common sense 101: Losing a war that the ummahs started doesnt make them victims.

[@thedave3704]

Hostage release or the rescue operation that got the four hostages? Like, when was this?

[@user-ln2cj1ig5h]

Most evil people in the world.

[@louisjeandin1970]

Just commenting for the algorithm...

[@user-ch7my1iy1m]

اهما بلا أخلاق بكل شي سبحان الله الغدر والخيانة بدمهم الله ينتقم منهم يارب العالمين

[@User_3584]

ONLY FOUR ????😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂COME ON...WHAT A SHAME

[@cinders392]

Such abhorrent evil

[@husnabeghum2738]

This is a crime

[@Mariyasheikh7868]

Free free Palestine astaghfirullah astaghfirullah astaghfirullah astaghfirullah😢😢😢

[@Justin-jc3el]

Anything is justified to rescue hostages that shouldn't have been taken in the first place

[@usairalthaf7740]

Cowards😂😂😂

[@sophiap2617]

Just when you think they can't stoop any lower they somehow find a way to prove you wrong!

[@shahinamukadam2233]

Deceit, cruelty and genocide. .. LEARN from the only democracy in ME

[@iw12]

You all have lost your minds, they were rescuing hostages. Do you even hear yourselves?

[@SaMa-sq3mu]

War criminals

[@Antrunu]

Only cowards would camouflage themselves in an aid truck and then commit a massacre...The IOF will not cease to surprise us with their despicable tactics

[@janeking9540]

Really disgusting. Morally bankrupt action knowing that people would move towards an aid truck.

[@Rihi-yl8sy]

Very evil

[@Farooqmurtaza117]

Shame on all Muslim Rulers, Curse on them, not helping the Palestinians 😢

[@netseyyahi]

Free Palestine 🇵🇸🍉

[@user-gs2kz6mg2n]

Lets takea moral moment and remember who started war? Who got drunk on the blood of the innocent ? Who thought it was a great joke? Who laughed and rejoiced? Who had their moment?

[@paulmcgrath3835]

The war was started many years ago when the Palestinians land was occupied by the terrorist aggressors Zionist Israel.

[@oanapopescu6176]

Yes. Very good question. This started before 1948 when isrealis killed and massacred the palestiniens and stole their land. And expelled over 750000 palestiniens to create illegal settlement. So isreal started this war.

[@Theresa-ts2ls]

That's been happening to Palestinians for 75yrs didnt start in oct just not reported much in main stream media

[@samueldeoliveira261]

do you want examples of what's immoral? check what hamas does

[@nochumfaerman6076]

It was a rescue, not a release the I. D f lost a soldier doing that. Level gaza.....

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎Calling for release of one group of Hostages ▪︎Not Calling for release of another group of Hostages ▪︎Equality or Supremacist?

[@RIKOXOLO]

They used the humanitarian aid truck as human sheild.

[@najwasakinah2335]

Yahudi Laknatullah Yahudi Laknatullah Yahudi Laknatullah Aamin Ya Allah

[@sunnykissar360]

#free Palestine

[@0miy0]

Over 9000 detained in west bank right now

[@jjmeiring2320]

Where is the truck. Where is the idf

[@wilhelmbeck8498]

They laugh at concepts, such as "ethics"

[@nurulfauziaevitaramdhana9380]

Laknatullah

[@medreda2491]

❤️🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@user-cr6eu4io6s]

Вы зачем запустили их на свою землю надо было бороться всеми силами и выгнать этих чертей, много лет тому назад,, вот теперь плоды доброты поспели.

[@Taxistheft.]

Hypocrite army

[@khalifazarulizwan5196]

The "aid" truck was from the pier. The US involved in this ops.

[@RBplacementor]

War crime

[@bombsingaza]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@VictoriaRege]

Oh! The Most (UN)Ethical ”Army” In The World COMMUTS AN NEW Crime!/V from Sweden

[@rufaimohamed895]

I don't think a ceasefire will bring the war to an end The war will end by the Israelites returning the Palestinians land And the leaders facing death penalties

[@antoniuselva]

THE WILD WILD WEST OUTLAWS 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱

[@hdhddfhfufu4676]

هاذي حقيقت الجيش الصهيوني الإرهابي