Queen, Love of My Life - A Classical Musician’s First Listen, Reaction, and Study

This is the first Rock piece that I took the time to listen to. It seems appropriate that it came from the iconic The Queen. It really surprised me - harp, piano, and Freddie Mercury’s stunningly expressive voice - not at all what I had associated with Rock music! The trouble Brian May had to go through in order to play the harp part of the piece, Freddie Mercury’s Classical influence, and the source of inspiration for the piece are some of the things I discovered along the way. Let me know what your thoughts are about this beautiful piece of music!
If this is the first time you’re watching one of my videos and you’re curious about who I am and my fields of expertise, follow this link:
• All about Virgin Rock ...
Join the classical musician Amy Shafer in her first listen of Love of My Life by Queen and watch her follow-up thoughts and discoveries about this piece of music.
_________________________
If you want me to do a First Listen and In-depth Analysis of YOUR song of choice, or if you want an exclusive 1:1 session where I can answer your questions, dig deeper into a topic, or even coach you in your musical experience, such as a music theory, piano, or harp lesson, singing, music reading, etc, follow this link:
ko-fi.com/amyshaferarts/commi...
If you enjoyed this well enough to support my work, here’s a link where you can “buy me a coffee”… or two :)
ko-fi.com/amyshaferarts
_________________________
Amy Shafer, LRSM, FRSM, RYC, is a classical harpist, pianist, and music teacher, Director of Piano Studies and Assistant Director of Harp Studies for The Harp School, Inc., holds multiple degrees in harp and piano performance and teaching, and is active as a solo and collaborative performer. With nearly two decades of teaching experience, she teaches privately, presents masterclasses and coaching sessions, and has performed and taught in Europe and USA.
_________________________
Credits: Music written and performed by Queen
This video may contain copyrighted material whose use has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. VirginRock, as a non-monetized channel, is using this material for educational, critical, research, and commentary purposes in our effort to promote musical literacy and understanding. We believe that this constitutes a “fair use” of the copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, which provides allowance for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond “fair use”, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
If your copyrighted material appears on this channel and you disagree with our assessment that it constitutes “fair use”, please contact us.

[@elliotcohen6652]

Freddie would have just adored his music being discussed in comparison to Mozart, Brahms etc al! Such a great pity he's not still around to hear this beautiful analysis.

[@TheRock-xj7hs]

Your knowledge,insight,depth of enjoyment and love for music is such a gift you share. Grazie! You Rock!

[@barrymitchell6444]

Chopin was his favourite classical composer though.

[@AAnaCCarol]

The joy of a person discovering Queen!!! I was 9... I just can't remember how it felt to me back then

[@susanengland3919]

This is a direct quote from Freddie " “All my lovers asked me why they couldn’t replace Mary, but it’s simply impossible. The only friend I’ve got is Mary, and I don’t want anybody else. To me, she was my common-law wife. To me, it was a marriage…We believe in each other. That’s enough for me. I couldn’t fall in love with a man the same way as I have with Mary.” She was truly the love of his life.

[@leaisstillhere]

I would be interested where this direct quote is from

[@Panda_man..]

@@leaisstillhere i found a portion of the quote featured in this video about the relationship between him and Mary: kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3iWlXiAqbaXi7csi=BpBig5I90bDMYzSn

[@isaacesparza2742]

⁠@@leaisstillhereSame,I'd love to know where Freddie said that quote. I know Freddie said in "the bigger the better" interview that Mary was his only friend though.

[@leaisstillhere]

@@isaacesparza2742 Yes, but he never said that he couldn’t love another man the way he fell in love with Mary…It contradicts so much about what we know from interviews from Mary herself. Especially because Freddie is a gay man. I believe they were best friends but nowhere near romantic.

[@deborahlewis8183]

Yes, Freddie is quoted as saying that in the 2019 book "Freddie Mercury, A Life, In His Own Words"

[@ilionreactor1079]

Brian May is not only a master guitarist, he returned to Imperial College in 2008 and earned his PhD in ASTROPHYSICS.

[@mortennielsen2364]

2007 ;-)

[@johndododoe1411]

I heard he returned to the observatory every year to gather more data for his thesis each time the stars were in the same positions .

[@SamLovesMovies25]

And now he has been knighted and is SIR Brian May haha

[@RichardLaurence]

Queen are basically a genre all by themselves

[@VirginRock]

I have a lot to discover :)

[@michaellueneburg2261]

The Queen catalog is one of my choices for a deserted island playlist.

[@mattah_the_original]

Queen did every genre, really. You will find them so interesting! React to "The Millioaire Waltz" which is also in this "classic" style, but a bit more rock definitely

[@ungainlytitan1460]

@@michaellueneburg2261 Yup that and Led Zeppelin

[@youandwhosearmy6339]

Spot on!

[@nathanduke5323]

Freddie Mercury's death is still one of the greatest losses in the history of all music.

[@alanrickett2537]

Mendelssohn, Mozart, Mercury all taken to soon

[@magnuslofgren2441]

@@alanrickett2537 Don't Forget Elvis Presley, Whitney Houston and some more

[@infodotwtf]

Now I want to see Brian May react to this video.

[@fokthewef]

Me too 😂😂

[@jusDau]

Side Note: On all Queen Albums in the 70's there is a liner note saying " No Synthesizers used " this was so that people knew all the different sounds were made using the traditional instruments, mostly Brian's guitar, he could make any sound with that thing.

[@Funster00]

You are going to love discovering Queen. One of the greatest, creative, genre defying groups. 4 musicians who all contributed to the songwriting. An iconic lead singer and showman, a fantastic rhythm section and a legendary lead guitarist (who built his own guitar from scratch).

[@VirginRock]

I’m looking forward to it! Thank you!

[@bonya4585]

Brian May, the lead guitar, is also an astrophysicist!

[@Ranadkins]

In addition to the 4 contributing, they’re the only band where all 4 members wrote a number 1 hit for them. Another One Bites the Dust” written by John Deacon “Crazy Little Thing Called Love” written by Freddie Mercury ‘Fat Bottomed Girls” written by Brian May “Radio Ga Ga” written by Roger Taylor

[@JohnLeePettimoreIII]

Stephen, i absolutely agree.

[@lethiapage4767]

What kind of voice is that anyway? Well. Amy we stopped trying to figure it out and we just love him. That's is Freddie Mercury. And he was a vocal master. 😔

[@chrome235]

This is quality content. Most reaction channels just listen and call it a day, but the depth of your research, analysis, and demonstration is excellent.

[@profeh3346]

I’m thinking that Freddie is listening to this from Heaven and is loving it! Someone who can help us appreciate the depth of his talent! ❤❤❤ Thank you!

[@bettybaby63]

“Is this really rock?” Queen can’t be put into a box. They experimented with everything. Live this song was transformed. Stripped down to just Brian & his 12 string, Freddie’s voice and then the audience comes in. Great reaction.

[@imweakfordeaky]

That “nasally cello” was indeed Brian May’s homemade, hand built guitar - fed through a little made-from-scraps amp built by bassist John Deacon. Oddly enough, these two inexpensive pieces of equipment are hugely responsible for the unique “Queen sound” on many of their songs. Brian dubbed his guitar The Red Special - he built it alongside his father Harold when when Brian was a teenager, because the family couldn’t afford to by a manufactured electric guitar. - the neck came from a 100 year old fireplace mantel slated for scrap, the body from an old oak table. Brian sometimes fondly calls his guitar “The Fireplace” or “The Old Lady.” John Deacon , as a young electronics student, saw some wires sticking out of a builder’s skip (dumpster) - he investigated and found the wires attached to some odd-looking circuit board. He decided to take it back to his flat and tinker around with it to make a little practice amp. He mounted his creation inside a cheap little bookshelf speaker case. John took it along with him to rehearsal … Brian heard a quality to it he wanted to experiment with, so he plugged his guitar in … - and discovered that this guitar and amp combination (both homemade) allowed him to mimic orchestral instruments-because their utterly unique qualities were seemingly *made* to work together ! Wikipedia article about Brian’s The Red Special : en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Special Hackaday blog article about John’s The Deacy Amp: hackaday.com/2017/05/08/a-queen-mystery-the-legend-of-the-deacy-amp/

[@VirginRock]

Thank you for this information! It is really amazing and these stories speak volumes about their musical genius.

[@roverwaters3875]

just for your education: Brian didn't give any name to his guitar. All the names were given by others.

[@JohnLeePettimoreIII]

@@VirginRock if you think "classical" instruments can't rock, then check out Jethro Tull playing *_"Locomotive Breath"_* . Ian Anderson's flute solo is *_EPIC_*

[@JohnLeePettimoreIII]

@@VirginRock not simply musical genius, but all were university educated in their various fields. for example, the drummer (Roger Taylor) was pursuing Dentistry, and the lead guitarist (Dr Brian May) has a PhD in Astrophysics.

[@thomasfortner9112]

I’m Weak for Deacy: I copy/pasted your post to a friend of mine. I really appreciate your input regarding Deacy and Brian, and I really, REALLY appreciate the way you value and understand John Deacon’s underlying contributions to the group as a whole, aside from his obvious (and painfully overlooked) bass mastery. Awesome stuff.

[@ariskopoulos8486]

I love your reaction to this. I am a huge Queen fan since 1975 and thru high school years often criticized for being a Queen fan, Their talent was beyond rock n roll and was more unique than any other band ever.

[@PedroLopez-db1ku]

Yes,you are right, I am big fan too

[@LucSchots]

Same here. Fell in love with A Night at the Opera, went back to Queen & Queen II, and followed on the whole carreer. And yes, they weren't appreciated in my high school at all

[@MicahBell_1860]

Never been a Queen fan, although in the last decade I have found an appreciation for their music & their talent. Never heard this song, but for you. I thought it was beautiful

[@elemar8209]

Queen is their own style. There is no box to put them in. Freddie was a true genius along with all the rest of the band members. So talented all of them.

[@markhoward408]

Welcome to the Rabbit hole that is 'trying to figure out Freddie's voice' Lovely reaction. We still miss you Fred x

[@evilblumonkee959]

THE musician's band!!!! As a musician, Queen will blow your mind. I'll say no more. Long live Freddie!

[@michaelpennington9327]

Queen is a class in and of themselves. There is no one like them. In sound, composition, musicality, instrumentation and performance they are unique. Yes, they do have much harder rock songs. But they also have many songs that don’t really fit into any genre

[@stevensprunger3422]

Hurry up and finish doing this weekend

[@stevensprunger3422]

Send it in Shenzhen

[@PedroLopez-db1ku]

Love your commentary it's perfectly right

[@ThibautKurt23]

With Queen you will discover they mix every kind of music : classical, rock, hard rock, jazz, metal, music hall etc... without being boring. And every musician has his contribution.

[@starratsbiting8066]

"Is that what they call an electric guitar?" Love it!

[@jacobsmith4284]

Wow. Just wow. Your ability to break down and communicate this song with such depth and musical passion and knowledge is like a found treasure. Bless you and your hard work!

[@open_water2411]

I was lucky enough to see Queen in 1979. I found this quite emotional and I agree with your conclusion here. I also think when you’ve analysed him some more you’ll conclude he was a genius. ‘Barcelona’ will confirm it.

[@davidwichner510]

Having listened to Queen since i was young, some 40 years ago, watching your exploration of this song is such a pleasure. I got so much pleasure seeing you connect the beauty of this music with the extensive classical body of work you have clearly studied in detail. Thank you for sharing your journey.

[@pamelatriffon4408]

Enjoyed your reaction! That's the beauty of Freddie Mercury and Queen. They didn't limit themselves to one genre of music. They delved into many different genres. Including classical, jazz, gospel, R&B, disco, funk and rock.

[@VirginRock]

That's what I hear over and over again! I will definitely come back to them and review more of their work.

[@jonasrmb01]

Also Metal!(Mainly because of Brian May's Influence) They basically invented Speed Metal with Stone Cold Crazy in 1973!

[@konradtomala3580]

@@jonasrmb01 Actually Stone Cold Crazy was played as early as by Freddie's previous band Wreckage. Freddie also wrote first really metal-ish sounding Queen song - Ogre Battle. Let's also not forget about fantastic prog-metal like songs from 1st LP - Liar, Great King Rat.

[@LMTino]

Freddie Mercury brought a theatricality to Queen, tapping into and expanding upon his love of theatre, opera, music hall, vaudeville, ballet & more. Queen was an enigma among the rock world and perfectionists in the studio. But with four very distinct styles btwn bandmates, they supported each other which created their own varied sound. LIVE, their songs are revisited with their audience & entertainment in mind. You will have a field day within their song catalogue!

[@VirginRock]

Yes, this is what I hear over and over again about this band and Freddie Mercury in particular. I am eager to explore more of their work!

[@thomasfortner9112]

Virgin Rock: Please do! I thoroughly enjoyed your analysis of this song all the way till the very end of the video. I shared this video with my good friend and fellow musicophile and told him that he would enjoy it immensely. I’m sorry that I keep gushing, but I find your reactions to be unique amongst reactors.

[@SuperMoofie]

@@VirginRock Freddie love Opera, and sang with Montserrat Caballé on several occasions. They became the very best of friends.

[@briangeorge286]

It was great to see the joy on your face as you discover the music of Queen. They're a band that cover all genres of music.

[@rustisamust9079]

Queen from 1974 - 1978 is untouchable genius. No-one will ever produce rock music like that again.

[@staceyfoley2556]

I enjoyed every minute of your review of this song. I have listened to this song hundreds of times and your unusual perspective and expertise has allowed me to listen to it with fresh ears. I appreciate the time that you took to research and demonstrate on both the piano and harp. Thank you.

[@VirginRock]

Thank you!

[@ruipereira2180]

Stacey, I second your thoughts.

[@juanbecerra7138]

And a third from me

[@michaellueneburg2261]

And a fourth from me! I must admit, some of the "reaction channel" videos I watch are so I can vicariously experience those songs the first time again. But her perception and depth of analysis has opened up songs I have listened to and loved for decades in a new way. The next time I listen to them in their entirety it will literally be the first time again, because of a new understanding and new ears!

[@joeterp5615]

Late to party - as I just discovered this channel - but I agree! This woman is so knowledgable and completely delightful!

[@aukebakker887]

loved your reaction. You will love 'you take my breath away', 'Nevermore', 'My Melancholy Blues', 'Lily of the Valley' and Jealousy'

[@VirginRock]

Thank you for the suggestions - I’ll put them on my list!

[@dianecourtney2724]

To mention only a few 😄

[@VirginRock]

@Bill Blackman Thank you! All of them except for the last one are already on my list!

[@wilandy409]

And what about "Lap of the gods" ? And the "revisited" of course 😉😎

[@wilandy409]

@Bill Blackman The March... and The Fairy...👍👍👍👍 Good to see someone who appreciate the early albums 🤝😉😎

[@nickdryad]

One of the most frustrating things about the Freddy Mercury story is how little is said about his musical training. It’s seems he had no formal music training yet his pianistic style is mature. His chord changes are very Romantic and the voice leading in the chord changes is highly sophisticated.

[@Blackadder75]

he certainly had piano lessons as a boy, I think when he went to boarding school in Zanzibar?

[@treetopjones737]

@@Blackadder75 Boarding school in India. Piano lessons and he joined the choir. So he had some vocal guidance at least for that.

[@thomaspappalardo7589]

Actually he had several years of piano lessons as a child. Actually, he and Brian May were at the same course level.

[@blipstat]

Where has this channel been all my life. This is like an advanced species coming down and casually talking about our great achievements.

[@AliT0555]

Not only did Brian May “learn” to play the harp for Love of My Life he also learned to play the Japanese Koto for The Prophet’s Song. (I would recommend you give that a listen Freddie’s canon in the middle of the piece is quite interesting.). Also, John Deacon learned to play the double bass for Who Wants To Live Forever. I think that shows their dedication to their music.

[@VirginRock]

Indeed, great musicians!

[@robynmurray7421]

​@@VirginRock Dr Brian May is also an astrophysicist.

[@johngraham5996]

and also deac's learned to play the fender rose on you're my best friend, he took one home and practiced until he got it! 👑✊🇬🇧

[@lms203]

@@robynmurray7421 so true, we tend to forget that

[@konradtomala3580]

@@VirginRock Not exactly right, John Deacon played double bass as early as on two tracks from A Night At The Opera Album: "Death On Two Legs" and "'39"

[@the_Futurist]

Oh my, you are amazing You have just wowed yourself a new subscriber!! 😮

[@VirginRock]

Why, thank you!

[@carlohenley4044]

This is one of the most delightful videos I've ever watched. Incredible song, lovely naive reaction. Love it :)

[@billtwolabbs3959]

The greatest feeling when you listen to Freddie's songs are you don't want them to stop. He always leaves you wanting more.

[@mikedytham9996]

It's a beautiful love letter, soft, gentle, sweet and full of emotion. Not every Rock song needs crunching power chords. You can't eat burgers all your life, some melon or strawberries are required too.

[@chrisstone2567]

Oh boy - wait till you hear the song "Bohemian Rhapsody" by Queen. You will be here for hours. Superb video - really so interesting to hear your breakdown.

[@hgodden269]

The most wonderful thing in the music world is that Freddie Mercury was given to us. The most tragic thing is that he was taken from us so soon.

[@stevenlovett643]

What a great review of my favourite 'rock' band of all time - been a fan since 1974 and especially of the great Freddie. There is nothing Freddie wouldn't try in terms of music, a unique and very complex character and an unmatched stage presence.

[@aaronsensei7637]

Queen is rock that works at the scale of opera and classical. Masterpiece performances. Artistic expression. That is why they are so unique

[@cuthalin4976]

I recommend you to watch the video of them doing this Live at Wembley. You will get to see Brian play this on a 12 string acoustic guitar, Freddie sing live and use his favourite instrument...the audience. Also helps that I was in that audience :)

[@andresbarriga5305]

You lucky you.

[@treetopjones737]

No-one was sitting by the last song in their concerts. #FreddiesMagic

[@cuthalin4976]

@Lisa Vivera Actually while it was a great gig, we did the Knebworth show which totally out did Wembley. however that may be because the line up had 3 of my favourite bands, Big Country, Status Quo and Queen as a perfect Rock day :) Ah the memories of those great rock years :)

[@Canucklehead557]

Wow! I love music, love Queen's music. Love your understanding.

[@fosterern]

I have watched your other videos. You are such a joy. I hope you never lose your enthusiasm of discovery. BTW: I have been a Queen fan for 50 years and you have provided me with a new look at the band. Thank you.

[@hollowslayed4979]

I think you would appreciate “you take my breath away” studio and live version.

[@VirginRock]

Thank you for the suggestion - I’ll put it on my list!

[@jeremykothe2847]

@@VirginRock 100% that should be your next step.

[@papercup2517]

@@VirginRock The two versions are very different, as are the recorded/studio version of Love of My Life' and the arrangement of it they usually do live, which is much simpler, with all the instruments in the recording replaced by acoustic 12-string guitar (played, incidentally, by an astrophysicist - fun fact!). You might enjoy the elaborate harmonies of the studio version of You Take My Breath Away, but my favourite by far has always been the live version, with just Freddie at the piano, singing to a rowdy crowd in the park... by the time it's over (only c2 1/2 minutes later) you could hear a pin drop. Absolutely riveting stuff. You can find it on YT under YTMBA, Live at Hyde Park. Since the song is so short, you might like to compare the two versions. Oh, yes, other gems from the Queen repertoire I think you might find interesting: White Queen - Live at Hammersmith (featuring an extraordinary rock piano/electric guitar duet) Bohemian Rhapsody - The official studio version, with video, is recommended, to get the full, crazy, visionary rock-opera effect. These are all early to mid- Queen songs, my favourite period. Some of their most popular and famous songs though are from the later period and are often played/ sung at sports matches, and it's possible you may even have heard them without knowing who or what they were: We Will Rock You (usually followed in live performances by:) We Are the Champions (complete with audience participation) Freddie loved opera and did delve into writing operatic/ classical style pieces later, performing his composition 'Barcelona' with his friend and idol, the opera singer Monserrat Caballe at the opening of the Barcelona Olympics in Spain. A pretty bold move and personally it's not to my taste and I'm not sure how successful it really was. Freddie had an incredible voice, but self-taught and wholly untrained for opera. It gets a lot of attention for the novelty of it, I guess, with the two world-famous stars from quite different musical spheres. Thoroughly enjoyed your review of LOML, the effort put into research, and your classical perspective - thank you. :-)

[@karenj3611]

Yes, definitely

[@samsowden]

I suggest listening to albums rather than individual tracks, though of course that's less practical for content creation.

[@dianecourtney2724]

Queen and Freddie in particular are not a “ typical “ rock band ✌🏼💕

[@VirginRock]

Since I have zero experience with Rock Music, I guess I will have to compare. But it seems like you're not the only one saying that!

[@davidellinsworth22]

@@VirginRock they're definitely not a typical rock band. Bohemian Rhapsody will best showcase this to you.

[@treetopjones737]

At the time, no rock band had done something like "Mustapha."

[@kentnottingham9635]

I am so glad I stayed till the end of your show! To hear and watch you breakdown and compare the way this song was constructed was simply amazing! Thank you, even though you’re “Classical”, YOU ROCK!!! 🤟😎🤟

[@dmitrivassiliev15]

Your reaction is so amazingly beautiful and entertaining! I wish your channel and ideas lots of success!

[@richlisola1]

Queen is most definitely a rock band, and all four members wrote hit songs. It might be the only rock band in which all members wrote songs and compositions. Their style is unbelievably varied, so not all their songs sound like rock. But overall, mostly yes. Enjoy the journey!

[@VirginRock]

Thank you!

[@roverwaters3875]

Queen is a rock band

[@damonhines8187]

The Beatles all contributed songs, even Ringo, eventually. 'Don't Pass Me By', 'Octopus's Garden.' Sure there's others.

[@cutthr0atjake]

Not the only band. 10CC also had all 4 members as songwriters.

[@sloganreadet1151]

Around 40% of their output is hard rock/regular rock, 30% are pop songs, and the rest are a wonderful mix of vaudeville, waltz, prog rock, even songs that defy genre classification like Fairy Feller’s Masterstroke.

[@lisaargyrou1488]

Wow 🥰 our beloved Freddie is magical 🤩 best vocalist, charismatic pianist and a beautiful person ❤️ Freddie Mercury ❤️ liked subscribed 😁

[@VirginRock]

I could clearly see only from this one piece of music that Freddie was indeed a great musician. Too bad that he left us so early!

[@WayneKitching]

This is the most detailed reaction video I've ever seen. I also enjoy The Daily Doug, with Doug Helvering, a classical composer. The difference is that he isn't a rock virgin, although he is learning about many new artists he never knew before. I love the fact that you went and did some research on the music.

[@kentnottingham9635]

Your reaction brings a smile to my face, Brian May is responsible for all the string and wind instruments, all played on his Guitar. In a song”Good Company” from this album, Brian does a full Jazz band on his guitar that is phenomenal! Queen can rock your face off and be gentle as this song. Thank you SO MUCH for reacting to such a beautiful Queen song!!!

[@jchow5966]

Freddie mercury was way more than rock n roll. Yet he was very rock n roll.

[@errolfellows409]

Excellent! Most enjoyable. This is the 2nd of your videos that I've watched. My 1st was your 2nd, She's Leaving Home., by The Beatles. I think that this is a grand concept. Your naivete as regards rock is delightful. Your musicianship and talent are obvious. Your remarks and explanations are succinct and to the point. I think that your title, VIRGIN ROCK, is perfect! I'm 74, a hippy and a reprobate, and have played electric bass in rock, pop and blues bands for bloody years!! Still do, but gigs are in short supply! I look forward to more of these.

[@thomaspotschka5387]

I really like, how curious you consume and analyse this complete meal! And the smile at your face shows, you enjoy this surprising supper! Thank you, I love your way!

[@JT40_]

This song always fills my heart with joy and your analysis just adds even more to it.

[@stevesilk334]

Thank you, wonderful video, took me by surprise and very pleased to have heard your analysis of one of the most beautiful songs ever written, Look forward to viewing more of your content, Stephen

[@DrTomoculus]

The KZbinrs so incensed at your reaction to The Beatles "She's Leaving Home", should come to this one. There's so many things to respond to in this song. Freddie's voice, and how you can feel each note he sings. How the music echoes, supports, and responds to that voice. The care put into making everything fit together. For me, Mike Leander's string arrangement in She's Leaving Home is the only thing providing emotion, dramatics, suspense, sadness, confusion. Because the singing carries none of this. And if I were to hear both songs for the first time, for voice alone, Freddie would win by a landslide. He sings with so much emotion. Yet retains every part of the melody that's important. This is Art.

[@janetd8198]

Queen never tried to replicate this song in a live performance, but what they achieved live is amazing in its own right. I recommend Love of My Life live at Wembley 1986 to see what they decided on for live. Very different but still awesome! You will really be amazed at Freddie and Montserrat Caballe performing Barcelona. Would love to see your reaction.

[@VirginRock]

It's on my list!

[@jiwa88]

I thought live in Montreal was more visceral and truly moving

[@spercepolnes21]

Live in Rio is powerful.

[@stevenborman9110]

What I feel that comes through from your reaction here is your joy as you experience a "rock" song for the first time and you then explain what you feel and think so nicely and in a way thatis thoughtful. Then your latter part on the harp and piano is such a unique factor, combing "classical" instruments with rock to my ear and mind shows the skills that rick musicians have. Thank you.

[@wilhelmberend116]

Classical composed arrangements by Brian may and Freddie Mercury . Amazing musicians. Bach, Mozart and Beethoven layered instruments and chromatic runs . Just amazing

[@bigredtlc1828]

Such a beautiful voice, and no autotune. Freddy was the best. Classic rock was may more experimental than I seemed to remember or maybe just took for granted. Compared to today's over-produced songs, these classic songs are just amazing. Thank you for your video. Great analysis on a wonderful song and band.

[@Mravenrocks]

It's such a pleasure seeing an expert of your level take your time to really analize and explain your ideas about what basically is a new genre of music for you. Your explanations where everything and more of what I would expect from a great professor, the scoring was more than fair. Probably the beginning of an incredibly journey, an amazing video.

[@TheFireMonkey]

I relate to your reaction to Queen as "rock" - personally I'd call their music simply "queen" - now they DO have some pieces that are definitely rock, some very hard rock - but then, Queen was always an unusual band - interesting side note - one of the band members [Brian May] is an astrophysicist [well known in the field] at the same time as being a band member. I suspect that you would find Bohemian Rhapsody - now that one IS rock, but it also is a real rhapsody.

[@VirginRock]

It's on my list and it will come soon!

[@richlisola1]

I might also recommend some live Queen performances because they can differ greatly from the studio recordings. For example, my fav live Queen performance is the song “White Queen,” live at the Hammersmith Odeon in 1975-Freddie’s vocals and emoting are at their top, and his piano playing, it’s as if he was possessed. The back and forth between the piano and Brian May’s guitar, top notch guitar orchestrations. Brian’s guitar is like a voice. And of course subtle but noteworthy is John and Roger’s backing instrumentals. The live is vastly different from the studio. Much better in my opinion.

[@VirginRock]

Of course, every live performance is very different from the studio version and there are multiple reasons for that! Thank you for your suggestion! I will write it on my list!

[@loveym8879]

Thank you for your analysis and demonstrations. Enjoyed it so much. I love Freddie Mercury and Queen. Please do more analysis of Freddie and Queen songs and also Freddie and Montsy.

[@VirginRock]

Thank you!

[@clintonsmith5163]

@@VirginRock "Montsy" means Monserrat Caballe, who recorded an album with Freddie. That album is called "Barcelona."

[@VirginRock]

@@clintonsmith5163 Yes; I am aware of that now.

[@sgt.blkdog3840]

I wonder if her head will explode upon hearing Bohemian Rhapsody 🧐

[@betseyclark2832]

Looking forward to your remarks after viewing Freddie and Montserrat Caballe. This is the first ever collaboration between an opera diva and a rock star. I thouroughly enjoyed your treatment of Love of My Life. I think you would like My Fairy King; my favorite track from their debut album.

[@VirginRock]

They are on my list!

[@konradtomala3580]

@@VirginRock I would highly recommend the piece "The Fallen Priest" from Freddie and Montserrat Caballe album "Barcelona". I think this is the best composition on the album, their voices wonderfully harmonize with each other. You will be amazed.

[@bpmc9935]

Well done Amy... even though I've known this song for decades, I've never paid much attention to it. You're fascinating analysis, however, has given me a whole new appreciation. Love your channel!

[@jeffreyoslin8148]

It’s Queens style, it’s what set them apart. Intertwining classical, opera, and rock music. Freddie’s exquisite voice always tying it all together. Brian May is an astrophysicist and an outstanding musician. IMHO A night at the opera is their masterpiece, Bohemian Rhapsody their greatest song.

[@hackapump]

Queen was so eclectic, arguably the most eclectic of them all. Especially Freddie let all sorts of genres influence his songwriting. So you could certainly argue that individual songs have very little to do with rock. But taken as a whole, Queen was a rock band with a typical rock band lineup: Guitar, bass, drums and piano - and three of the four members supplying vocals.

[@BarleyC]

Thank you so much for posting this wonderful, informative, and engrossing reaction and exploration of this song. I've loved this song ever since I first heard it when I bought Queen's album "A Night at The Opera" in 1975. I felt in later years, this beautiful studio version was overshadowed by the voice-and-acoustic-guitar live version. I am delighted to see the original recording receive the attention it deserves! Subscribed!

[@ErnestoCore]

Quality, quality content. This is a master class in itself.

[@dianecourtney2724]

Hello Virgin Rock. Speaking of structure and ‘ turn of phrase’ You might find Killer Queen interesting… a song Freddie wrote when he was in his early 20’s which I have always found remarkable . Brian May said in an interview that Freddie wrote a perfect song and it was genius.

[@bluebell3720]

Killer Queen is used as part of the UK GCSE music exams!

[@VirginRock]

It is already on my list!

[@craenor]

Killer Queen is the song that really launched them internationally, especially in America.

[@jackiepage6120]

This is a great channel! It’s obvious why you’re getting so many followers so quickly.

[@pteifert]

Lol “what kind of voice is that anyway “ oh man lady, the voice of an angel

[@darrelldog5]

You really did your homework on the piece and the band. I am really impressed.

[@hollowslayed4979]

Totally loved your analysis. Cannot wait for your next one!

[@VirginRock]

Thank you! Me too! Actually the next one is ready, but KZbin flagged me for copyright violations, so I'm working through the Fair Use defense.

[@bigmallly7863]

@@VirginRock Good luck with your defence. I have my own channel & although I receive copyright claims, I have never had a strike against any Queen songs I've played.

[@VirginRock]

@@bigmallly7863 Not for Queen, but for The Beatles!

[@bigmallly7863]

@@VirginRock Ah! I don't go that far back, I play mainly 70's & 80's. I've had a few worldwide blocks which I just delete.

[@VirginRock]

@@bigmallly7863 I see. Well, maybe you want to take a look at “She’s Leaving Home”. I did and what I found is really interesting: kzbin.info/www/bejne/h2TYgXiQprljnbM

[@rootstothebone2939]

I think you really have to listen to the entire album, A Night At The Opera to get the context of Love of My Life. It sits comfortably alongside all the other songs which include 1920s English music hall, folk, operatic rock. And its sister LP, A Day At The Races (both are named after Marx Brothers films) is also very varied with waltzes sitting alongside glam-metal belters like Tie Your Mother Down. That's what makes Queen so intriguing... they were hugely experimental and were willing to try anything...

[@squidkid2]

I grew up with rock which is my first love but did a deep dive into classical music of all kinds later in life. And Schubert Lieder came to mind immediately when I heard this piece. I also developed a love for opera and Freddy Mercury's voice here is like a female coloratura. The more I listen to music in all its forms I've come to realize how interconnected all forms of music are. I'm sure if Schubert were alive today he would love and admire this little gem! I love your insight on the little harp parts. I don't know if you are aware of the harp's use in jazz but my first real exposure to the instrument was through the playing of Dorothy Ashby. Great video.

[@michaelmueller8772]

Really, really enjoyed this. I love watching someone learn about and experience music that I love, only for them to teach me things about that same music as well. Subscribed! Fantastic!

[@anacristinaribeiro9592]

This song belongs to an album named "A night at the opera",released in 1975. They wanted to prove they could join classic music and rock. From the same album you should here Bohemian rapsody. I liked a lot your video!

[@VirginRock]

I learned that and it seems that so many are recommending Bohemian Rhapsody. It is definitely on my list!

[@sharonroyal1410]

Please..."Barcelona" a spectacular duet with Monserrat Caballe , the glorious beloved operatic soloist.You'll be astounded!

[@VirginRock]

@@sharonroyal1410 It's already on my list!

[@errorgorilla]

Most of the internet is a mistake: at best innervating, often frustrating, largely rage-inducing and generally utterly awful. This is not such a thing. Rarely I have enjoyed half an hour more than this fascinating video. Bravo!

[@marykidd4004]

Thanks so much for your analysis. Freddie and Brian would love it!

[@maisondesophia4359]

Ah, yes. Queen. Wonderful introduction to the world of rock music. Queen was a very lyric rock band. I'm a sort-of retired wagnerian soprano, and I totally love Freddie and his band of merry musicians! It appeals to my sense of drama and everyone involved is a virtuoso, just like in opera! Enjoy listening to "A night at the opera" and "Jazz". And yes, it definitely has Lieder undertones, assorted with vocal harmonies. I enjoyed your discovery very much! :)

[@maisondesophia4359]

As a suggestion, Metropolis by Dream Theater. All of Dream Theater, in fact. All albums of Yes. Gentle Giant, early Genesis... So many to discover! Enjoy! :)

[@BobbyWallisch]

I really love and admire open minded people! Wish you many great discoveries!

[@johnpublicprofile6261]

QUEEN is a Rock Opera band, a term pretty much created to describe. They play various musical styles from fairly heavy Rock to Pop etc. But they were often influenced by Opera and Classical music. You should listen to "Barcelona" (operatic) and "Bohemian Rhapsody"(Rock Opera).

[@thomasfortner9112]

I absolutely am dumbfounded at your reaction/analysis to this song! You have a unique input and insight in your reactions. I’ve been listening to this song for decades and loving it, but you’ve helped me develop a new understanding and appreciation for the subtleties inherent in this composition. I’m glad I discovered you this evening. Liked and subscribed!

[@Freak_a_zoid]

Wonderful reaction. Enjoyable to learn from, listen to you, and think with you. Great smile, warm laugh, and inviting aura. Thank you for this video. I hope you have more. I’m new harm sound, only heard in Aurora’s live concert of Walking in the Air. Harp has grown on me so much.

[@VirginRock]

I am definitely planning to dig deep into Rock Music, so stay tuned in!

[@kasperkjrsgaard1447]

I have to admit, that even being a lifelong Deep Purple fan, Queen are on another level. To be honest, I’ve been following Queen since 75-76, so they’re most certainly not unknown to me. 😅 But, as being a hard core Deep Purple fan, I feel obliged to bring your awareness to the group. The former, late, keyboard player Jon Lord was classical trained as well as their former guitar player Ritchie Blackmore, while their drummer Ian Paice was swing/big band trained. A mixed bunch most certainly. In the song “Pictures of Home” from their masterpiece of an album “Machine Head” really show a lot of classical inspiration. To be reccomended. Another relic from the 70’s is Ian Andersons “Jethro Tull” where he plays the flute standing on one leg (😳🤨🤷🏼‍♂️). A song reccomended is “Locomotive breath”. I look forward to be following you.

[@ofeliawotsits6080]

It’s a 10 from me! Funny, I was listening to the song “Killer Queen” on the radio the other day, and I just said to myself “Why don’t they write songs like that any more?”. It has long seemed to me that great songs have become rarer and rarer over the last 50 years.

[@richlisola1]

At least in the mainstream music scene.

[@ulfingvar1]

Most mainstream music today suck donkey balls. Sadly.

[@swapticsounds]

The typical pop/rock-formula is ABABCB, verse, chorus, verse, chorus, bridge, chorus, often extended by an intro, solo, and/or outro. In this sense, Love Of My Life is pretty formulaic, but it works out. Further extensions of this formula can be a pre-chorus, (which might not lead to the chorus at first but second time) or an extended bridge or c-part consisting of several subdivisions (Queen: Innuendo).

[@ellesee7079]

To see more of classical influences on Freddie Mercury's writing, you may want to listen to 'It's a Hard Life', as the opening phrase is based on an aria called "Vesti La Giubba" from the opera Pagliacci by Italian opera composer Ruggero Leoncavallo.

[@VirginRock]

That sounds so interesting! I will put it on my list right away!

[@LaserRockShow]

@@VirginRock maybe it was already mentioned but for sure you have to listen to the millionaire waltz :)

[@jozsefnemedi8472]

And a movement of a Grieg chamber piece starts with the same melody but I can't remember which one

[@clintonsmith5163]

Fascinating video. You did a great job with it. It is both entertaining and informative, which is something very rare in the "field" of music reaction videos. Two Queen songs that I would love for you to react to are My Fairy King and Nevermore.

[@VirginRock]

Okay; they are on my list!

[@lcbcreative]

I enjoyed your perspective and would be very interested in your opinion of Freddie's more complex compositions like Bohemian Rhapsody or Somebody to Love (should you decide to do more Queen). The Fairy Fellers Master-Stroke is a mind boggler if you're interested in going back to the early seventies. The songwriting side of Freddie Mercury has always intrigued me. Freddie and Queen expanded the musical tastes of young listeners for decades - they crossed so many genres of music. And then there was Freddie's collaboration with Montserrat Caballe. Your journey into rock may not keep you reacting to Queen very long, but their catalogue is immense and diverse. Good luck with the channel! I just remembered - Who Wants to Live Forever, the official video, features an orchestra. John Deacon, Queen's bass player, taught himself the double bass and that's him playing it in the video😀. He also taught himself the electric piano when Freddie refused to play anything other than a grand. All four guys are amazing.

[@VirginRock]

Thank you for your lovely comment - and I’ll put those pieces on my list!

[@TheScottSlater]

I would definitely second (and third and fourth) Bohemian Rhapsody. It caught the world by surprise back in ... '74, I believe? It defies categorization.

[@sloganreadet1151]

@@TheScottSlater 1975 actually but it is a great song

[@yinoveryang4246]

Yes this is all true. For me it sometimes seems as if Queen "dumbed down" musically. The early music, to me has more atmosphere, and and is also more interesting musically (harmonic structure and and composition), it is more ambitious. When you get to the 80's, the idealism of "we can do anything" had disappeared when Punk happened and rock journalism started to accuse them of pretentiousness. So they needed to change to fit with the fashions. And they did. But unlike many others, they succeeded!

[@sloganreadet1151]

@@yinoveryang4246 I agree! By the time of The Miracle, Freddie had gotten word of his AIDS and seemed to want to return to the 70s which resulted in songs like The Miracle and Was It All Worth It harkening back to the high production, intricate sounds of the 70s. A lot of Innuendo seems to sound like a weird mix of the 80s synths coupled with the old “Just do whatever we want” attitude.

[@getexis8685]

The band Queen is fabulous. It proves to us that there are also free soft rocks in Nature. From what I see, I think playing the harp must be one of the most difficult instruments to play, apart from pedals, so you deserve my respect for your dedication and joy in showing us, as an audience, the beautiful sound of the harp.

[@wobtabak1660]

10:37 "who was this again?" So lovely

[@aarond23]

Only one solution here we need to get you an interview with Brian May about playing the harp :)

[@Milewskige]

06:18 Brian May is such a great guitar player that he could even make his guitar sound like an entire Dixieland band. Listen to the end of "Good Company"

[@obiwanbenobi4943]

They had several songs which to me just sounded like them romping through previous eras of music. Good Company, '39, Lazing on a Sunday Afternoon, Millionaire Waltz and probably others I'm not remembering now. All were fun and very interesting to me even at a young age.

[@happydays3678]

Thank you so much. I've been a Queen fan since the 1970s, I found your analysis very interesting and enjoyed seeing your reactions and hearing of your experiences. So beautiful seeing you play your harp. What a wonderful sound. I've also loved Mozart all my life too. Who could live without music?

[@GrantSchinto]

Too early to tell, but this just may end up being one of my favorite KZbin channels of all time. Love this analysis and the infectious enthusiasm for discovering new things and the insights your background helps you provide. I definitely plan on watching all of your Queen analysis videos for sure.