Vocal Coach/Arranger Reacts to CARPENTERS - “SUPERSTAR” (Analysis of the most classy band ever)

In this video, I react for the first time to Carpenters performing “Superstar”. I analyze Karen Carpenter's amazing performance, explain and demonstrate her vocal techniques and I'll tell you what I think made it so great. The Carpenters are arguably the most classy band ever to grace the earth, spinning musical silk. I am SO happy I got to react and analyse this for you. Daphne loves their music, it makes her relax!
Watch the original video without me banging on: • Carpenters - Superstar
My NEW KZbin Channel! ➡️@MoreFairyVoiceMother
For voice lessons, workshops and video submissions please check out my website www.thefairyvoicemother.com
I'm so excited to be a part of your singing journey, It's one that truly never ends.
Love you forever,
The Fairy Voice Mother x
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Lolli sing: • Lilac Wine - Lolli Wren …
If you liked this video and would like to support me to make more in the future, I would be hella grateful for a small donation via this link www.buymeacoff... (no pressure at all of course- i'll be making videos the best I can anyway)
Become a patron if you like too! / tfvm
ALSO, get yourself some brand new, beautiful MERCH! www.thefairyvo...
www.TheFairyVoiceMother.com
Insta @TheFairyVoiceMother
TikTok @TheFairyVoiceMother
Mail [e-mail]
Intro and Outro graphics by Lucy Chappell
#TheFairyVoiceMother #Carpenters #Superstar #VocalCoach #KarenCarpenter

[@zeuso.1947]

Wow Lolli, take a bow. Hearing Karen's warm voice coming out of your beautiful face was pleasantly shocking and made me a bit teary eyed.

[@kenglasson2920]

Totally agree with that 😍

[@mineau9728]

Totally agreed

[@RonSnow23]

You mean hearing Loki lol sorry autocorrect, lolli sing like Karen, not the her voice coming out of lolli, that would be a completely different skill set that is way above singing and music lol. Not trolling just noticed how you typed it and it made me smile cuz I do that stuff all the time

[@zeuso.1947]

@@RonSnow23 I did it on purpose for rhetorical impact. Not an accident.

[@patbrewer4205]

You really did sound like Karen had to go back and make sure it wasn’t her took my breath away, you could easily cover her

[@kenglasson2920]

Yes i think this is the best reaction to this song EVER. Totally gets the greatness of Karen. Please like if you agree.

[@daveking9393]

Me too!!!!!

[@kenglasson2920]

@@claymiller8171 Interestingly, yesterday was my rather old birthday and me and a few friends sat and played old songs on KZbin and had some quiet beers. Anyway, my friend said (knowing I am a huge Karen fan) you will like this and played a cover of "Close to You" by some girl. They all said wow that is so great and sounds just like her. I said, No. The moment I hear her voice I know if its Karen, and while this is nice, she does not have the range etc. Karen is a one off.

[@victordegrande1628]

@@kenglasson2920 Have you heard Tori Holub? She is the closest I have heard to Karen.

[@jstokes]

Yes, I agree with you!

[@mwflanagan1]

Richard would be delighted so see your perceptive approach, and your whole-body appreciation of some of his arranging nuances. Wouldn’t it be cool if he saw it?

[@iutchube]

Her voice is one of the most beautiful sounds ever produced on this planet.

[@RFazor]

I believe so

[@lsmoulton]

Utter Perfection ! 😯

[@robertfindley921]

Some ridiculous list had her 94th best vocalist of all time. People like Taylor Swift and Billie Eilish were higher. LMAO!!!

[@michaelt3308]

X​@@robertfindley921 F'n RIDICULOUS!!!

[@donnahdunthorn5207]

I agree.

[@douglask.pennington2091]

Your analysis of this song and its arrangement is absolutely outstanding, especially with your voice demonstrations. The Carpenters were an incredible duo, and Karen's voice remains unmatched to this day.

[@victorjohnson7512]

The keyboard player is her brother Richard Carpenter. He also does the music arrangement, and sings backup.

[@davidvanderwood9649]

I was hoping someone would explain Richards role in this song thanks

[@ericsandi6619]

Richard was the brains of the group, with respect to arrangement and songwriting. Karen has the best female voice you've ever heard and was a great drummer also.

[@keithjohnson8330]

My mother's favorite song was "I'm On The Top Of The World. Check it out..please.

[@joshuawiedenbeck6944]

And also has a significant car collection from what I have heard.

[@bradclifton5248]

A Richard continued to write for well known singers all the way to the early 2000s

[@MiaMidol]

I have waited 50 years for your analysis and I just hope those that criticised the Carpenters back then watch and realise just how little they know. This was a feast of educational commentary performed in such a humble manner. I have never heard anyone do what they did since and sadly we lost their partnership far too early which denied us a plethora of emotive entertainment. Thank you so much for enlightening us, you truly are a star.

[@CoreyWickramasekera]

Can't deny KAREN CARPENTER as one of the BEST FEMALE VOICES,....Everrrrrr

[@guypainter]

And also a world class drummer.

[@jessieball6195]

Not ONE OF, Karen was the GOAT of singers-male or female.

[@starsearch1952]

@@jessieball6195no you can’t speak for everyone. There’s Whitney Houston..

[@A-whiter-shade-of-pale]

This song was mastered in 1971 with their band providing the instruments BUT Richard took this master and 19 others to England in 2018. He rerecorded with Karens voice and released "Carpenters with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra" December 7, 2018 35 years after Karen died. Richard Carpenter served as the album's producer, arranger and conductor.

[@mr.puckerie4800]

Seriously, never been more wow'd with Lolli's vocal prowess than in this video. The way she takes on Karen Carpenter so nonchalantly... color me way impressed

[@iancremmins4727]

i agree,

[@bradclifton5248]

She deserves any opportunity that comes her way.

[@phoebus]

True she is talented, but it's easier to copy then it is to invent.

[@bradclifton5248]

@@phoebus talent, unfortunately, does not beget fame these days. Many in music industry are talentless or has been and still garner attention unjustifiable. Taylor Swift is a perfect example

[@iancremmins4727]

@@phoebus name a band that has never done a cover, i am sure she will find her own way soon

[@michaelhwenig]

Amazingly Karen sang this song in one take. Karen sang way beyond her young 21 year old age. Hauntingly beautiful, etheric. and timeless! ❤

[@designstudio8013]

huhuhh

[@Carrinthe]

I'm a metalhead but I've always enjoyed the Carpenters. Karen has such an incredible voice and when I hear her I always get a little sad realising what an enormous talented and beautiful person we lost in 1983. Anorexia is such a terrible desease. Btw, you did an amazing Karen Carpenter impression, impressive!

[@whitepouch0904]

Anorexia was just a symptom of a more deeper serious problems. She had a cptsd caused by her narcissistic abusive mother. She was a scapegoat and her brother was the golden child. She longed for a mother’s love but never received a single “I love you” from her that she really needed.

[@ChuckHackney]

Hip hop, rap, metal head, hard rocker, whatever your genre, there is no way your ears can deny absolute greatness, the wonder of Karen Carpenter.

[@Carrinthe]

@@ChuckHackney I totally agree, why limit yourself to a genre while you can enjoy everything. I'm perfectly happy listening to some Abba after hearing some Megadeth while ordering the blu-ray of the Ayreon concert I visited last year with my stepson.

[@snakeeater47]

Im a metal guy also but its good to have balance in our lives.

[@gdreynolds9989]

You are now my very fave YT vocal coach. You explain how and why vocal things can happen and in different ways. All the other talked about why how they were dressed and why he/she wore yellow and I'm thinking... shouldn't vocal coaches talk about voices, not about wardrobe choices? Can't wait to watch the rest of your vids.

[@nederlanditism1154]

Nobody's mentioned that she was a great drummer, a great singing drummer

[@mitchfleming274]

In 1975 She was voted the best drummer of the year over John Bonham...

[@kilmister82]

🙋🏻‍♂️ and sing at the same time 👍

[@trevorwhiteman8056]

By the readers of Penthouse I believe..!@@mitchfleming274

[@kburke4618]

She was a fantastic drummer who was, in a way, cursed with the best voice in pop music

[@nederlanditism1154]

​@@kburke4618 With the curse which was: great voice - a lot of success - pressure - anorexia nervosa; that's the idea, isn't it?

[@garylagstrom3864]

Karen Carpenter was an Angel 😇 sent from Heaven and left us way too soon! One of the most beautiful voices ever heard! The compositions are the direct result of her brother Richard Carpenter who really played to Karen’s strengths as a singer! I LOVE ❤️ the music of The Carpenters! RIP Karen!

[@auralfixxation6702]

Her voice is one of the best, natural voices in music history. Just stunning.

[@algoja83]

My dear Fairy Godmother, your passion is so contagious it makes 'nerding' about music a moment I've come to look forward to week after week!

[@quigleyd]

Lolli, you never cease to amaze me with your ability to duplicate the sound of the people you review. You did an almost perfect impression of Karen. Your joy always blesses me.

[@mykevenable8180]

So love your analysis !!! As a five or six year old, I would play the 45 vinyl copy of this song over and over again, not really knowing anything, but that it sounded wonderful. It's lovely to see someone hearing it for the first time and witnessing that instant joy from this musical masterpiece.

[@Mrvictorfernandes]

I'm so happy that you are reacting to and checking out the Carpenters. Karen Carpenter is a divine piece of inspiration and heartbreaking cautionary story to anyone whose lives have been touched by hers and brother Richard's art... Rest easy, little drummer girl. Love you forever... ❤️🌹🥁

[@FavoriteMovieDate]

Richard is only lately getting the attention he deserved as a genius arranger, backup singer (the harmonies with Karen), and musician that supported his sister’s incomparable voice and really made their sound. Karen was a miracle but so was Richard. So nice you recognized it immediately.

[@2kanchoo]

This is why lolli is my favorite reactor/coach. Not only can she deconstruct and explain all the techniques, but actually execute and sing. Lolli are you secretly a lyrebird or something? How can you sing like literally any singer. Not close, exactly! Exact same vibrato and everything. It's uncanny.

[@simonkoorn]

It was pretty close to Karen’s voice exactly. Not many woman can get that low with the same feeling in it.

[@jessieball6195]

@@simonkoorn honestly, not really close to Carpenter's, who is? But she is pretty good.

[@BenjWarrant]

@@jessieball6195 honestly, yes, really close to Karen's. Do you not hear good?

[@DavidClark-es1ww]

No kiddin',.....!❤😂🎉😮😊

[@rmcdaniel423]

The way you personally demonstrate the vocals, and dissect with such delicate reverence = you are supreme at the music challenge of echoing a true icon of the past. Please . . . keep posting your wonderful content!!

[@reedhaley15]

Damn Lolli, you recreate the voice nuances of one of the greatest pop singer in history like it is no big deal. You could do a masterful cover of this. Nobody else would dare.

[@BB-gb3lj]

I agree, I’d love to hear her sing!!!

[@stephenfisher2595]

Oh, they would dare. And have. Check out Ksenia Buzina with Leonid and Friends. She does a masterful cover of this song. She doesn't have quite the depth and richness of Karen's lower register (no one ever will), but she is close. And the band that Leonid has put together is top tier pro level. Oboe, french horns, strings, harp and acoustic guitar accompany a horn section and a rhythm section as good as the best in the world.

[@TheSeeking2know]

@@stephenfisher2595Worry of musical tributes.

[@mentak2593]

My mom sounds exactly like her, wish my mother didn’t have terrible stage fright and never sang in public

[@jbs256]

@@stephenfisher2595 she can and has many times. This may be her best and it dropped to honor Kacie’s birthday in heaven. kzbin.info/www/bejne/gGqYnZmAptRsjLssi=zM5RkvU-H4pe4q62 .

[@michaelhwenig]

Karen Carpenter never had any formal vocal lessons. Truly a God given talent. Her brother was a masterful pianist, lyricist and composer. He specifically structured songs to fit Karen's angelic pitch perfect voice.

[@need100k]

That was my thought as well. She didn't need to go through some sort of voice lessons, but was born with this voice and the ability to control it to perfection.

[@HariSeldon.]

Listening to interviews with them, they were adamant that their name was “Carpenters”, not The Carpenters. I’m not sure why.

[@Andrew-xn6lt]

So glad you have chosen the Carpenters. She has a beautiful voice. Such a tragedy 😢

[@xCelticSamura1x]

You are by far my favorite Vocal coach and reaction channel on social media, your love and passion for music is nothing short of inspirational Your videos make me want to learn how to sing, which i have wanted to try for a while anyway, but you explanations accompanied by demonstrations and knowledge bombs that explain not only how to do the technical aspects, but also how it works and what is happening while it works is amazing. It is like you are teaching the science and biology of the voice, and i absolutely love it, Thank you for coming into my youtube algorithm and in turn, my life. You amazing human/genius

[@markk.4941]

Her brother Richard is a musical genius. Pair that with Karen's voice and you have one of the best groups ever. Check out "Rainy Days and Mondays".

[@guypainter]

Good shout there mate... I'd love to hear Lolli's analysis of Rainy Days... kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpupoISun8yVqNU

[@whitepouch0904]

I’d say Karen was more of a genius if she had studied piano I’m sure she could be at her brother’s level if not more but her mother wouldn’t let her shine where her brother shined because she’s the scapegoat child and he was the golden child. Not just she’s a perfect pitch singer she’s a great drummer too and played guitar as well. The record label initially just wanted her to be a soloist but their narcissist mother didn’t approve of it as she was just a minor at that time. She only approved if her son would be given a deal too. She was the caused why she developed anorexia. That’s the only thing she had a control in her life and she got carried away. Agnes thought her son was more or was loved by the people like Karen but no. When Karen died Richard career also died.

[@waydetheblade]

Many people have great voices, and many are featured on youtube. Was very impressed to hear yours, and singing to one of the best singers in recorded history. You're much more than a voice coach.

[@admseraph]

This is why the Carpenters were so immensely popular for so long. Richard's songwriting and arranging along with his sister's amazing voice and style were unique and unforgettable. They gave us so much beautiful and timeless music, that can take us back to the same memories and feelings as when we first heard them. RIP Karen.😪

[@tastyfishsauce4410]

I'm nowhere on the same universe as technical as you but I enjoyed your take/reaction to the Carpenters. They were before my time but did hear them through my aunts playing their song when I was young. I can describe her voice as calming, warm, made me feel safe and loved like a mother to a child (I think) if that makes sense. Thank you.

[@evanhorton2520]

You are stunning, both visually and vocally...and your sense of humor is "spot on".

[@designstudio8013]

stop

[@Emrio3]

Wow! I am so impressed with your analysis and reaction. The way you capture the essence of the emotion in the song in your reaction. I fell in love with you before the ennddd. 😘

[@p5gBand]

Dang Lolli, I've always been impressed by the way you are able to demonstrate techniques used by the artists you are analysing but your (extended) singing of this song is more than impressive, it is beautiful (I love the Carpenter and especially this song)

[@dalefriday5496]

The credit for all the nuances of the instruments as well as backing vocals goes to Richard Carpenter. He did almost all of their arrangements and was, in my opinion, a genius arranger and writer.

[@lifelover515]

Excellent analysis, I learned a lot. As you probably know, Richard was a superb keyboardist as well as an equally superb arranger, and was very fond of the oboe. Bravo FVM. There are few who can demonstrate vocal technique by example the way you do. Astonishingly, AFAIK, Karen never had a voice lesson in her entire, tragically short life. It was all instinctive. Your delight exploring the Carpenters is palpable. More please..

[@mattblatchley2061]

It's gutwrenching to think about her decline...she was so wonderful, she should still be singing

[@helokopter924]

Good reaction and voice breakdown. Herb Alpert heard Karen's voice on a demo in 1969 and signed her brother, Richard, and her to A&M records. Karen received 3 or 4 Grammys in the 70s and sold over 80 million records by 1982. She was 1975 rock drummer of the year according to Playboy. Perhaps THE best female vocalist-ever, because she commands you to listen as she sings in perfect pitch TO you, not at you, with emotion and enunciation. No auto-tune or gimmicks. No professional voice or drum instruction. She was known by the studios as 'one take'. She rarely, if ever, recorded more than one take of any song. She was also the ONLY female harmony/background voice in all her songs. She was truly born with an incredible singing talent. Documentaries point out the accolades to her voice, such as, Paul McCartney said she had the most angelic voice after hearing her sing 'Ticket To Ride'. John Lennon ran into her at an LA restaurant and told her "you have a fabulous voice, luv". Supposedly Frank Sinatra stated that Karen was the only singer he'd pay to hear. I recommend songs such as, Yesterday Once More, Solitaire, This Masquerade, Need To Be In Love, Hurting Each Other, Only Yesterday, Close To You, I Can Dream Cant I (beautiful rendition to the 'big band sound'), Crescent Noon, Ordinary Fool, Rainy Days And Mondays, A Song For You, etc. KC never knew true love. One of her few friends included Dionne Warwick. 5'3" KC really lost weight, due to anorexia, in earnest beginning in 1975. She died in Feb 1983 at age 32 due to heart complications from anorexia

[@mattblatchley2061]

oh, my goodness...you must do a Carpenters Cover on one of your channels...your ability to capture that sound is unbelievable.

[@SamBorgman]

I want this.

[@jurgenradics155]

Holy moly Lolli, what a reaction. Your amazing excitement for music and vocal skill made this reaction a unique adventure.

[@mikeglo168]

What a wonderful reaction/review. It was nice that you gave so much attention to the music and arrangement which are usually overlooked. You did Karen proud when you mimicked her.

[@gliebzeit]

Thank you for this incredible reaction video to The Carpenters 'Superstar' performance! Oh my!!! Lolli, you have such an amazing voice and highlight the nuances of singer's vocals that even a noob like myself can understand. I have only been subscribed for a little while ... but, have almost listened to every one of your personal singing videos. Keep on sharing your 'gorgeous' talent with us!

[@rockfordrocker8971]

Crazy how well you do KC! Well done! I am so impressed with your knowledge and skill, and of course your very musical spirit makes these reactions among the best.

[@waldorfstatler3129]

That is one of the best reaction/analysis of this song I have heard.

[@wgandy9541]

Your enthusiasm and "nerdy" exuberance is contagious!!! I thoroughly enjoyed your reaction to one of my favorite singers. I have always loved Karen's voice and the songs the Carpenter produced and now you are explaining to me why I have loved them so much. There were so many little details that you picked up on that, even though I'd listened to this song "a million times", I did not realize that was what she (they) were doing.

[@mariagrover1781]

Loving this reaction. Karen Carpenter had such an enveloping voice, a hero to all altos! And loved hearing you singing more for us and demonstrating how & why the approches she uses were so magical !

[@mariagrover1781]

And also loving the commentary on all the instruments!!

[@carolhesterberg7526]

Goosebumps from the first measure. The sign of a great song! Richard's arrangement and keyboards are stunning, as are Karen's beautiful singing and masterful drumming. True familial genius! Karen truly knew how to vocally deliver a song!

[@raymondlong3024]

1 thing I'll say, of all the voice reactors, and there are many I've watched, you know your shit and I was captivated by it. I will definitely be watching more, good job.

[@RockinLocks4u]

Yes, Richard's arrangements are a work of art all on their own...then add Karen...sublime

[@bobbygrace7520]

Supposedly a terrible task master that demaded perfection and assuredly added to Karens self doubts!

[@whitepouch0904]

@@bobbygrace7520 yup sadly the dynamic of a golden child and a scapegoat child 😢

[@catticusfeline4623]

Fairy Voice Mother, thank you for your intricate, articulate analysis of the miraculous Karen Carpenter and the Carpenters. Their artistry is extraordinary. It's wonderful when professional vocal coaches and arrangers share their knowledge and insights with us.

[@marshallhirashima3633]

What a wonderful review of this wonderful Carpenter's song! Lolli, your voice is also truly amazing! Your analysis of songs are amazing, knowledgeable and informative! Thank you and keep up the great videos ... truly amazing!!

[@rogerwhitacre8247]

Wow!! Lolli, I watch a lot of reaction/analysis videos. The best are made by real musicians who break it down instrumentally, vocally, and the composition. This may be my all time favorite analysis of all time! I watch a lot of Elizabeth Zharoff (The Charismatic Voice) who is outstanding. You rank right up at the top with her. I'm loving exploring your videos. Thank you for sharing!

[@steverakes6182]

The greatest female voice to ever grace the planet. Her voice healed millions of hearts and souls before she was called back to heaven.

[@starsearch1952]

It’s subjective. Many ppl say Whitney is THE VOICE for years..

[@steverakes6182]

@@starsearch1952 Whitney who?

[@OldCanadianguy953]

One doesn’t try to explain Karen Carpenter’s gorgeous voice. One just realizes they’re in the presence of someone who comes to visit us mere mortals once in a millennium.

[@claudiacorvi2286]

Well said❤

[@starsearch1952]

I feel the same about Whitney..

[@trailrunner919]

Always enjoy your reaction videos and this one in particular was one of my favorites, with an added bonus of you actually be able to recreate Karen's amazing tone and vocal ability...thank you!!!

[@miamivicefanatic9736]

I've learned so much from hearing your analysis of this classic song. You bring up so many things that others skip over. Thank you for sharing your insights.

[@sefander74]

Fairy does Carpenters. This day just turned around nicely. Always, always loved Karen’s voice and their arrangements. Gives me goosebumps and tears and vibes for days.

[@tpez777]

I've seen many reaction videos for this song, but you hear and analyze things that nobody else does. You can even sing like her! Great job!!!

[@atinker7575]

Lolly this is perfect, the best vocal reactor reacting to the best singer. love your reactions.

[@starsearch1952]

The best singer is Whitney Houston So many amazing talents out there..

[@theedge9174]

Richard Carpenter was the MASTER of arrangement and composition. He and Karen fed off of each other so well. There will NEVER be another duo like them. One of a kind.

[@Aussiecris214]

Rip Karen Carpenter was an angel just like Lolli ❤❤

[@SRMscott]

Nobody on KZbin can match this level of musical analysis…absolutely marvelous

[@Wrangler-fp4ei]

Love the reaction and understanding of the music you bring. I loved how you sang to your cute little pooch (dog).

[@ronaldriis1023]

I am very impressed with your analysis of the arrangements and the backing musicians. And your voice is incredible! R.I.P. Karen, the voice of an angel.

[@lesgrice4419]

Wonderful! Karen does some amazing vocal gymnastics on 'Goodbye to Love' too, such long melody lines and such a beautifully sad song.....and wonderful fuzzy guitar....

[@paulineson6731]

Totally agree. I was intendING to suggest the same. The guitar solos are so atypical and almost jarring for the Carpenters but bloody awesome. My fav song by them.

[@OHsopositive]

The birth of the power ballad!

[@garyclegg3722]

Thank you for this wonderful critique of this song, Lolli. I have watched it more than twice! Haha Again, very well done.

[@bbwng54]

One of gteh better/best anaylsis of Karen's voice that I have heard.

[@TheRealSkeletor]

I just want to say, I love your analysis of both the vocals and instrumental compositions in these songs you cover, but it's the editing of these videos which is really the cherry on top in making each one quality entertainment. Keep up the good work! :)

[@elukuu9632]

An angel reacting to an angel..

[@roba7737]

Karens voice is so soothing. Miss her talent. ❤

[@ryansmallwood1178]

Such nice vocal timbres in this one, thanks so much for breaking them down and all the other musical details!

[@chrisjeanotte4059]

You have a beautiful voice my dear. I would love to hear you sing one of the Carpenters songs.

[@waltgula3308]

The Carpenters, officially known as Carpenters,[a] were an American vocal and instrumental duo consisting of siblings Karen (1950-1983) and Richard Carpenter (born 1946). They produced a distinctive soft musical style, combining Karen's contralto vocals with Richard's harmonizing, arranging, and composition skills. During their 14-year career, the Carpenters recorded 10 albums along with many singles and several television specials.

[@TheBartman14]

You have a lovely voice as well :-) Karen has always been one of my favorite artists. 🙂

[@chaoticwonder3278]

I always melt at the sound of Karen's voice. Such a shame we can only imagine how much further she could have gone.

[@humboldtharry1289]

I wish she would have done a duet with Linda Ronstadt

[@davidfredericks4626]

Check out Tori Holub. She'll impress you and reincarnate Karen for you

[@starsearch1952]

@@humboldtharry1289or THE Whitney Houston..

[@davetoms63]

We lost two great people when she passed.... glad to see someone giving Richard his due

[@TheSuefriend]

The amazing thing about her voice is that she can just fill your soul, and completely break your heart at the same time. A master of her craft.

[@jeffkemper7920]

213,000 subscribers cannot be wrong, and they aren't. You have become one of my favorite people on KZbin. I am so happy that I found your channel. You are wonderful and very gifted, in more ways than just singing. Keep on doing what I know that you love to do. Thanks for brightening my week!

[@chrisegbertky]

Holy crepe! You just enriched my appreciation and enjoyment a song from my youth. You are immensely talented and engaging! 😮 W O W ! Btw Karen is listed on DrummerWorld's list of the Top 500 Drummers of all time. Yes she really was that good.

[@olafurw]

If you're into haunting singing then Rïcïnn - Doris has an absolutely chilling ending.

[@rogerdsmith]

Richard Carpenter went on to have a notable career has a producer, arranger and composer. In fact over the years, Richard Carpenter has composed many theme songs for TV series.

[@rfleming7883]

This has got to be the best analysis of a hit song I have ever heard. Karen and Richard Carpenter (I am sure) would be delighted at your words as they penetrate the beauty of the music and singing and reveal what it takes to produce such a magnificent recording. A colossal work of art. Plus, as a bonus, you have a wonderful voice and come very close to giving us the brilliance of Karen Carpenter. Gosh, I am now a subscriber!

[@dancartlidge5202]

I am a classically trained singer, and I've searched the internet all over to find someone who can actually interpret Karen Carpenter's vocal production. So, if you're ever in the states, hit me up, and I'll buy you coffee and we'll chat about successful pop vocalists!!!

[@davotiac]

Thank you for the reaction and expert commentary for such an unusual and otherwise perfect song. The combinations and their, her delivery make continued listening and now with your description a pleasure.

[@papajon62]

Karen Carpenter’s voice, as angelic as it is, could have a bit of melancholy and sadness to it that always moved me to tears in a good way….

[@VictorHernandezVH1]

Lolli, thank you. From the bottom of my heart. You've become one of my best musician friends. Sharing the joy we find in music. And schooling me on tidbits I was unaware of.

[@guanyin19]

So many more songs from the Carpenters for you to explore. I sincerely hope you do. There is a reason why so many in the music industry agree that Karen had the best voice of all time. She was a once in a generation (maybe several generations) talent. And gone far too soon. Her voice is like a warm hug that embraces the soul. May I suggest listening to their song Sing? Such a fun, lyrically uplifting song, not to mention the glorious instrumental accompaniment.

[@bonester50]

Karen is as you describe. Once in a creation I say. There’s something so powerful and simultaneously so soothing about Karen Carpenter’s voice. What a gift.

[@raymondallo9947]

I can't get over your analysis. It is so good, so detailed and the fact you analysed Karen Carpenter, who is classified as the gold standard by many sound engineers, makes my heart sing. I love how you not only analyse the voice, but instruments and production. Love it.

[@cmdrsliman]

You're a positive joy to listen to. Someone must indeed love us very much to give us trees. . tea . . this music, and your very talented self.

[@sheepherder3737]

And marshmallows!

[@ChicagoAstronomer]

You made me cry....thank you.

[@damanfromtn]

My goal is to find a place in more conversations to use the "Bloody hell" phrase. Although I don't think it would be as endearing as when you use it 🤗 That was an incredible breakdown. Super job.

[@paintwithpa8694]

This is the best video you’ve done in my opinion because I got to hear you sing. I’d love to hear more of your voice.

[@patrickbernardy3100]

You are not just the Fairy Voice Mother, you are the Lady of the Lake, the High Priestess of Avalon. You perfectly mimicked Karen Carpenter. Magical!

[@starsearch1952]

Yah and they said ppl couldn’t mimic Karen..

[@hubrisnaut]

Geesh, I recently got you in my suggesteds and subbed for your spot on analysis of Mr. Blue Sky. I am impressed again. Your analysis and replication of Karen's voice with it's backing is excellent. Well done.

[@quigleyd]

Richard Carpenter is an amazing arranger. This is most obvious in their Christmas album. Karen's voice is so rich and mellow. She died much too soon.

[@OHsopositive]

Christmas Portraits is, hands down, the best Christmas album ever!!

[@craigbigbee6395]

Lolli, I can only say how impressed I am with your voice! Everyone else sounds like dirt after hearing Karin, you match up so well!

[@drieuxkoeppel8152]

I CANNOT listen to Karen without crying. SHE DID NOT NEED TO DIE…but her death at age 32, provoked a long-overdue public talk about Anorexia Nervosa…I hope she’s seeing how much she actually changed people’s perceptions of anorexia. Her recovery was punctuated by her death at 32. She died of the constant starvation damage to her heart. RIP Karen 1950-1927,4

[@alpohlenz]

Wow! Thank you Lolli. This was the best and thorough analysis of a Carpenters song I’ve ever heard. I love and enjoyed the nuances and musicianship you highlighted!

[@alexharbison4411]

Nice reaction, it's nice to see someone acknowledge Richard Carpenter's genius as a musician and producer. His arrangements, instrument choices and pairings were had a lot to do with Karen's success.

[@nickvasiliades4537]

Great analysis Lolli! And your voice is amazing too. Karen's just taking us on a glorious vocal joyride and her brother's masterful arrangement is pure delight....and you pretty much don't want it to ever end.

[@troybee7815]

"Not breathe is generally bad advice.'' You make me so happy. Thanks for that.

[@benf1111]

I'm a musician and love this song but you've helped me hear things in it I've never noticed before.