VOCAL COACH reacts and breaks down PENTATONIX - AMAZING GRACE (1st time hearing with SUBS)

[@carladewitt1947]

Never in my life could I have imagined that I would watch almost 45 minutes of a reaction video, in subtitles no less, and be completely transfixed throughout the entire analysis. I love your reaction videos. Not having a musical background of any kind, I know when I hear something special, something that moves me, something that touches me deep inside, but with your analysis, I come to understand, even if only a little bit, why I have such a visceral reaction to this music and the true genius that is Pentatonix. Thank you, so very much. I hope and pray you can continue to do these videos.

[@olabergvall3154]

He has so much in depth analyses to share, the videos just can't be short. I too am glued to the screen and hanging on his every word. Thank God for subtitles, otherwise I would have zero access to this brilliant man!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Carla, I never took for granted that anyone could go beyond the first 60 seconds... so every extra second you guys spend watching this video is a GIFT I feel truly grateful for. GRAZIE!!!

[@SilverFlame819]

Right?? On my first reaction video of his, I was like, "SUBTITLES?! What is this shit? I can't possibly be expected to READ a reaction video!" And here I am, several videos in now. Like, "Oh, this one's going to be 7 hours long, and I have to read it? Okay! I'll take two!" LOL! They're soooo good!

[@shirleyujest7786]

I would like to add my voice in agreement. I am also forever grateful for you putting into words the "run up to the cliff and free falling" because that was eloquence that escaped me. Boy did you nail it!

[@bsmith5970]

@@olabergvall3154 Funny how fast you get caught up in his analysis and forget it's not English. I've watched this whole thing 3 times and learn a bit more each time!

[@nadinehaney6590]

I cannot imagine why why this would not be considered fair use: your reaction videos are far more educational and analytical than any other reactors.

[@bchemptyyeetttt]

It's an automatic system, there's not a person behind the fair use law in youtube

[@nadinehaney6590]

@@bchemptyyeetttt all the more reason why it makes no sense: I have watched many other KZbin reactions to this same song, where all they do is play the video and then say something lame like " wow, yeah that was awesome" and they don't get any flack for it. If it's automated then it would be set up with an algorithm that uses some criteria such as how many times the video is paused and for how long to determine if it is being used just to pirate a video that draws traffic to a channel or is it actually being used to educate, and nobody is watching Roberto just to see/hear an artist because it would drive a person nuts as often as he pauses, replays, stops, talks, plays another 10 seconds etc etc. You only watch Roberto's videos if you actually want to learn something. If it is an algorithm I would love to know what the parameters are because I could list half a dozen KZbinrs off the top of my head that are definitely using the "reaction" format for no other reason than to increase traffic to their channel because whatever their original purpose for starting their channel didn't pan out so they suddenly change to a reaction channel and their numbers increase exponentially.

[@bchemptyyeetttt]

@@nadinehaney6590 It makes sense for them to ban the longer videos, probably the algorithm takes in consideration which video is using the copyright content more, and a 40min video where the song that has copyright is played multiple times is more relevant than a 6min video. It sucks.

[@ricobarth]

I think it's because he plays the entire verse/chorus without pausing before going back, and that trips the "fair use" alarm in the algorithm. So there are five chunks that are, in this case, each more than a minute long.

[@bchemptyyeetttt]

@@ricobarth yup

[@lanadavis9535]

His expression when Kevin sings! I live for it!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, Lana!!!

[@summerarmstrong2841]

When you’ve watched a reaction for almost 45 minutes and it feels like 5 minutes... you know it’s good!! I truly appreciate your reactions! You even play the best parts over and over again! And I learned so much! I can see your love for music and how it moves you. I’m forever a fan.

[@elizabethsantersero9597]

I love the way you pull back the curtain and give us a peek at how exactly they manage to create the beautiful arrangements they do - thank you so much for your time and effort!

[@CurtisMontague]

You are by far T-H-E B-E-S-T reactor and educator for Pentatonix. You should see the smile on my face when I get a notification that you have reviewed another Pentatonix song. You truly are just as special as they are. I hope they get to see one of your reactions to their songs. Please continue because there is even more treasure that awaits you with this vocal group. GUARANTEED!

[@ritathomas5167]

Yes, cmonta001 ! I was thinking exactly the same thoughts! I really hope Pentatonix can listen to this! This man is phenomenal!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

...And you should see my smile after reading your comment!!! Thank you, cmonta001!!!

[@violetf.2025]

Hello Roberto 🙋🏻‍♀️. A year has passed and I'm still patiently waiting for you to react to more PTX videos. I've seen hundreds of reactions to PTX songs but you are my favourite reactor. You are extraordinary and a superior league to me. Watching you analyzing music with your heart and soul is outstanding. Beautiful! 🌟 *Pleeeease* consider to continue your channel, you would make me / us so happy. 🌈 If you worry about copyright issues even a reaction without video would be fine as we Pentaholics know the videos with closed eyes. Recommendation "The Prayer". It's hopefully worth their next Grammy. Thank you for reading this and much love from Germany ❤️

[@JoshuaPhair]

I have been watching reactions to this group for close to 4 years now. Your reactions are the first that have hit me with such intense emotions. You have a true gift of being able to catch the quiet, impactful, subtleties that create the magic that is Pentatonix. I truly hope that their content managers stop blocking your reaction as you are now my all-time favorite reactor. Perfetto, Splendido, Bravo, Bravissimo.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Grazie, grazie, grazie Joshua!!!

[@lindamorris3149]

Besides the five members of the group, you really have to give props to their arranger, Ben Bram. He is a genius.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, Linda, he DEFINITELY deserve it!!!

[@johnscholfield4492]

Ciao Roberto di Australia. I have no musical training, cannot sing, cannot play an instrument yet music touches and moves me intensely. You can express what my skin and feelings are telling me even though I do not have the words to describe my experience. Thank you and molto grazie.

[@ConnieGordon]

Nice expression of what I was wanting to share: both some of the technical information along with the multitudes of words that show the inner passion that the music engenders.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, John!!!

[@kayecastleman6353]

Whoever is disputing your pedagogical, teaching and critical use of Pentatonix videos has clearly never listened to them. You are the most informative and thorough analyst I have found on YT. Unfortunately, many unqualified reactors use PTX videos to increase their subscriptions, since Pentaholics tend to be a passionate and loyal group, and will support anyone who discovers the band. It is a disgrace that legitimate and knowledgeable instructors such as yourself are penalized for using your talents to open our minds to the beauty and skill of musical artists, while opportunists are free to gather support unimpeded. I look forward to viewing many more of your videos of our favourite five. "In bocca al lupo!"

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Kaye, again... THANK YOU!!! ...”Viva il lupo!!!”

[@annettegroenewegen6873]

And the charming tear they try to bring out ...

[@olabergvall3154]

I don't know what any of that means but I support it wholeheartedly

[@dianeaustin2414]

So well said.

[@juliewylde5238]

I’m totally in awe at your ability to analyse the technical aspects of the arrangement, I did not think I could enjoy PTX more than I did, but having this breakdown of the way they produce the sounds adds to the whole experience, thank you so much.

[@justinperry13]

So. I’ve heard a great deal of different reactors. In my opinion, you are not a reactor. The only way I can describe you is a Music Scientist. The way you catch things and teach us.... honestly, you need to be nation-wide conferences or something. You have a hell of a talent man.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Truly grateful for your super kind words, Justin, so encouraging!!! Thank YOU!!!

[@lauriehalverson1680]

Completely agree. I hear so much additional done in the music when he is done and I enjoy the piece so much more than I did originally.

[@InkWellideas]

I'm pleading that you find a way to continue reacting to Pentatonix, even within the restrictions imposed. I know I am not alone in valuing your thorough reviews and interpretations: they mirror the effort made by these musicians to raise a cappella arrangements to a point worthy of your/our attention.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you InkWellideas!!!

[@kayecastleman6353]

Kevin never used to sing, but in the early days of Pentatonix he lived with Avi, their original bass. Avi is a classically-trained "basso profundo", and he helped Kevin to train his naturally beautiful tenor voice. Aren't we lucky! Kevin was already skilled musically, having played twice as a soloist at Carnegie Hall, cello and saxophone. (He also completed pre-med at Yale before joining Pentatonix. AND he speaks fluent Mandarin.) Kevin is no slouch, and many say he is the most talented musician in the group, writing and arranging, as well as performing his foundational beatbox with the group. In some PTX videos he plays cello while beatboxing... a skill he invented that he calls "cello-boxing."

[@tonie48]

I don't think he invented cello-boxing, I think he learned while studying in china.

[@kayecastleman6353]

@@tonie48 I haven't been able to find any Chinese cello-boxers that he learned from. I'm still pretty sure Kevin invented the skill while he was studying in China. Can you direct me your source? Thanks.

[@tonie48]

@@kayecastleman6353 I'm not 100% sure, I just remembered watching a video where he was talking about learning it while there, if I can find it, I'll link it.

[@kayecastleman6353]

@@tonie48 I do believe Kevin learned to play the cello while living in China. He probably also worked on his beatboxing skills there. But all my sources say he put them together on his own (not a lot of beatboxing cellists out there, in China or elsewhere!), and he was the one that coined the term, 'cello-boxing.' it's so easy for the details of these things to get confused among the millions of PTX fans, so I'm happy to be corrected if I've gotten it wrong. Anyone?

[@tonie48]

Kevin already knew how to play the cello since he was little, I think in the that's Christmas to me video, there is a picture of him as a child holding a cello. It is probably possible that he put his skills together.

[@marymichele340]

❤️❤️❤️❤️. On my-amazing reaction. First, not sure why you get blocked. Your reactions are very educational. Secondly, I appreciate your appreciation of Matt (the bass) and Keven (the beatboxer). Your comment at the end regarding the ‘transformation’ shook my soul. So profound. Your observations are insightful. And you love Mitch’s voice as I do. Just an FYI-To demonstrate how much I enjoy your reviews, I spend 43 minutes reading the subtitles as I do not know Italian. Can’t wait for next one!

[@lengould9262]

Me to. Watched several times sequentially, always studying the English subtitles. So knowledgeable!

[@luinrina]

Same here. The imagery he used to describe what he was hearing was very moving. I loved every second of these 43 minutes and can now enjoy this amazing PTX song even more thanks to Roberto's very insightful analysis. I really hope he can continue with these analyses. I'd love to see him do Run To You, Mad World, Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairies, Mary Did You Know? and God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Mary!!!

[@UnBroken11100]

I loved your reaction/breakdown! Your analogy of someone running off a cliff and then taking flight was beautiful. The image it gave, as I listened to the song, moved me. I truly hope they don't remove this video.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Gretchen!!!

[@frederickgramcko5758]

Where have you been? You're top notch. I just got here and you haven't posted in a year? Hope to see more of your reactions real soon. You really are one of, if not, the most articulate musical reactors I've ever listened to. And I've listened to so many reactions. Stay safe👍🙏✌🇺🇸🇩🇰🏴‍☠️

[@joebarnhart4460]

The "background drone" sound is also a reminder of how the arrangement sounds when performed on the bagpipes, which is a common way to perform this hymn. Example: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oqG9moOQrNyLnq8

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you Joe!!!

[@Karenlowry1]

I just read through the comments to find one about this, and would have added it to my own comment if someone else hadn't mentioned it. I was in matching band as a teen and had the privilege to hear this performed by 2 college bands that had real bagpipe playing members. Edinboro University of Pennsylvania and Indiana University of Pennsylvania. They both were phenomenal to hear in person and I so loved that Pentatonix gave this nod to the tradition of bagpipes playing Amazing Grace. It would sound something like this, but back in the late 80's people had clunky video recorders so you won't find either band doing it with bagpipes on youtube kzbin.info/www/bejne/eZe2fn2mfZ6mjs0

[@gelelied]

Glad to find this comment, I recognize the bagpipe drone for several reasons... brother-in-law plays the bagpipes, also, most police funerals in Chicago and likely other large US cities feature bagpipe bands playing this exact piece (without My Chains are Gone) for years.

[@kcrain81]

Roberto, thank you again for another amazing reaction! I've grown up singing this song myself, and being a big fan of Pentatonix brings me joy listening to it. But your talented dissection, explanation, and education only magnifies my appreciation of their talent. I especially love the realization you present of the person running away from the broken chains they've left behind, jumping and flying off the cliff in an explosion of freedom. The cinematic visual that presents marries so well with the melodic and vocal environment of the performance. I'm blown away by your talent to listen and notice such amazing detail. I hope PTX continue to allow you to react to more videos, as I believe it only enhances their performances and my appreciation of them, and you!

[@jessiemassey8588]

There is very little I can add that hasn't already been said by everyone else, but I'll add to the chorus anyway! Your analysis is a masterclass! I've been recommending you to everyone. The best part about your analyses is that, I Know that I like these songs, I Know I love the Pentatonix, but you are explaining to me (and everyone else) WHY I love them and their arrangements. I also greatly appreciate the way you analysed Mitch's part. Too often, if Mitch isn't singing in his higher range he doesn't get the notice, but you've put it out there for all to see and learn just why he is still an outstanding singer and still worth our attention and praise even when he's not blasting us from the rafters I couldn't appreciate you and your content enough!!! P.s. I also second the recommendation to analyse Daft Punk

[@talyn5304]

Great reaction! I've watched this video hundreds of times, I've watched other reactor's watch this video hundreds more...but I have never seen ANYONE point out the many intricacies of this group, the way that you do. This was truly a Master Class in reacting...thank you! =)

[@Kelcoe99]

One of their original compositions is called Run to You. Kevin sings there as well, it has beautiful harmonies and one of my favorite moments of dissonance. Enjoy your reactions and the education! Thank you!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, Kelcoe99!!!

[@pauldunn5955]

Kevin Olusola(beat boxer)--just for your own sake-check out his solo youtube channel. He has some really beautiful work(and you get to hear some of his cello work too)

[@myramegill7293]

WOW! Technical analysis, and emotional, spiritual, ephemeral, tactile, and metaphorical interpretation as well- all in under 45 minutes!! Bravo, Maestro! Bravo! I am undone, emotionally spent. Amazing. Thank you!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you for your beautiful and generous words, Myra!!!

[@myramegill7293]

@@LezioniDiCantoOnline 😊💜

[@ShinyElfriend]

I've just watched your three reactions and analyses of Pentatonix @PTXOfficial. I do hope the band has seen these, it would be a tremendous shame if not. I think they might appreciate someone taking such pure pleasure from their mastery, while demonstrating your profound understanding and interpretation of their intricate choices. I doubted I could appreciate them more than I already do, but I had a big, stupid, grin on my face through all three videos while you picked at the stitches of their amazing tapestries and found every single golden thread. Lovely. Such a shame there are no more. They just switched management, and are looking for a new label, perhaps the new Powers-That-Be will understand that what you're doing is good for everyone, and you can return to these absolutely riveting commentaries. Bellissimo.

[@bettyhayes8178]

I wish you were reacting to PENTATONIX this year because then perhaps you would have chosen to react to The Prayer. It is a beautiful cover and whenever I hear it I always think what would Roberto say about this cover. Even if I can't enjoy your insights into this beautiful song I hope that you get the chance to enjoy it for yourself.

[@timcaldwell5241]

I can’t begin to recall the number of times that I have listened to Pentatonix’s version of Amazing Grace...It always moves me as it is so beautifully done. I just went back and listened to the “Official video”, and it was as if I had never heard/seen it before...Your breakdown and explanation of that incredible video (plus your obvious emotion) achieved, what I thought was impossible...it made like it even more!!! THANK YOU!!!

[@timeformyself4782]

Roberto, thanks for sharing your knowledge and feelings with us. Thanks for the English subtitles, as well. (English is second language for me so I can't even imagine how much work goes behind translating and adding subtitles for a 43 minutes long video). You should deserve 1 ESPRESSO for each minute of this memorable analysis! Please, ENJOY it!☕

[@bettyjeanandrianoff5695]

Roberto is amazing. Just watching his video has taught me how to listen to music in a totally different way; now I listen to the singers and their subtle changes. Betty Jean Andrianoff

[@dishmurphy6539]

You’re still my favorite. It’s been a year since your last reaction/analysis. I hope you & your family are well. Pentatonix is famous for copyright restrictions. Many reactors have success by adding a filter on top of the video. It’s not ideal and I wish it was unnecessary but it does work. Earlier this year Pentatonix released a cover of The Prayer. Scott, the soulful baritone sing part of the song in Italian. He often apologizes for his Italian but I think it’s beautiful. It would be lovely to watch your reaction & analysis. ✌️💚 🎶

[@nancymahaffey7636]

What a true privilege to have the opportunity to listen to Pentatonic and a complete Master such as yourself. All of your listeners are so fortunate to learn from you. I am humbled to see you spend your time with us and teach us through your love and appreciation of music. Thank you.

[@paulinejane9742]

Honestly your reviews are in a different class to any others I’ve watched. So interesting & you share such great knowledge with us. I could listen all day. All members of Pentatonix are exceptionally talented but Mitch stands out for me. One of the most memorable evenings of my life was a classical music/opera evening in beautiful Italy, can’t wait to visit again if ever the world returns to normality, but for now I’ll look forward to your fantastic reviews. Thank you ☺️

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Miss Polly! So good to know you have great memories of the time you spent in my country!

[@bettydiorio8551]

Not only are you an amazing teacher, I'm enjoying your Italian... love Pentatonix. Thank you.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank YOU, Betty!!!

[@lvw7668]

Hand to god this is the best reaction but more importantly analysis of this song I’ve seen. You always show the intricacy of the arrangement and all the little ways with movement, vocal texture, timing, etc... they create these masterpieces.

[@deejay136]

You have become one of my favourite reactors. Absolutely love how you can take a song and really breakdown the feeling and the notes all at the same time. You're awesome 👌 Please react to their cover of Aha! Live at the Star Vista Singapore. It's a fan made video so hopefully will not get blocked. I think you'll be blown away!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Dee Jay!!!

[@kenyattamaasai]

If I could like this ten times, I would. Moving, insightful, inspiring, educational. What more could one ask for to accompany such sublime music? The piece is a classic for a reason, the rendition elevates it so far above the standard, and your commentary enriches it yet further, and to a degree I could not have anticipated. Bravo e grazie!

[@JemUzumik]

Hello! The singers who maintain that "hmm" at the beginning are the girl "Kirstin" and the beatboxer "kevin".

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, JEM!!!

[@JemUzumik]

@@LezioniDiCantoOnline 🤗 Maestro, admiro mucho la forma en la que expresa y analiza las piezas musicales, exitos en su vida, Que Dios lo bendiga 🙏🏻. 🤗Maestro! I really admire the way you express and analyze musical pieces, successes in your life, God bless you🙏🏻.

[@PJoFriel]

Such a wonderful video! I always get really emotional during Kirstin's solo and it wasn't until I watched your video that I truly understood the reason behind my response. It's Kevin's beat boxing "bomb drop" followed by that group crescendo that creates this feeling of transcendence that completely overwhelms me. It's magical...and so Pentatonix. Thank you so much for helping me understand. Your videos are intelligent and technical, but also very emotional. It's obvious that you love what you do and enjoy sharing it with others. I look forward to viewing more.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, PJ Friel!!!

[@Chivalryisalive7]

Roberto, the way you are poetic with the musicianship and technicality, the dynamics that are often mathematical and separates the emotion from the music is a breath of fresh air. Suddenly brought back and the gap bridged once again to the marriage between the emotion and the math of music. I treasure your knowledge of music theory that you breathe life into. I have trained in music theory and always got bogged down in the "classroom" setting, caught in trying to figure out the math of it all. It surely figures an Italian of all people would seamlessly bring the two together for me. The way you present the theory and the emotion identifies everything my ear hears and tells me "is right" and makes sense. I pray you are able to continue dissecting a group I love so much to add even more depth to songs I have listened to dozens of times over. From an ocean away, keep doing what you do Sir. Thank you.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Ben, your kind words are super appreciated!!! Thank you VERY much! Roberto

[@pauldunn5955]

Tara Simons Studio does lots of Pentatonix songs as well as a few others--May I recommend doing a quick youtube search and find a few other coaches--ask them what they do that gets them past the copyright_misers. It would be a shame to miss out on future reviews!!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you for the tip, Paul!

[@LeahGrahamCracker]

Thanks so much for loving Matt's voice and giving credit where credit is due. When Avi left the group, there were many who didn't take the change well. Matt is an incredible talent and a perfect addition to Pentatonix. This is one of my favorite reactions. The flying metaphor you described was perfect! Another amazing reaction/lesson. Thank you so much! 😊

[@kayecastleman6353]

I see others have commented on the "pedal note" you mentioned, which was intended to evoke the sound of bagpipes, which commonly accompany this song, especially at funerals. Of course, you picked up immediately on the dissonance, which is a legendary feature of that instrument. I enjoyed every minute of your reaction, especially the soft appreciation on your face as Kevin began to sing. Sometimes words are not needed. IMPORTANT: Is there anything we can do to support your issues with copyright??

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, Kaye!!! I appreciate very much your kind offer to be of help!!!

[@dorothythompson3302]

Being a huge Pentatonix fan, I must say I find your reactions the very best as they give such insight into how this beautiful sound is created. Thank you!

[@SonjaWitbooi-f4t]

❤thank you once again. I love how you love them. They really are amazing. You give us insight on their unique way of singing❤

[@carolscott1686]

I appreciate the way you explain what is happening in the song in such an expressive way. It is apparent that the music touches you profoundly. Pentatonix are masters of their craft. When Kevin sings at the end his beautiful, clear voice brings me to tears every time. Thank you for the insightful breakdown of this song. I hope that you will do songs from their new album The Lucky Ones soon.

[@debschwer2236]

I just wanted to say that after watching your breakdown of Pentatonix hallelujah that I’ve never seen a more detailed and professional review. The one thing that truly strikes me is how much your love of music shows through in the review. I never realized that other people besides me would stop and listen to a portion of a song over and over to understand it and to relish it. Thank you so much.

[@dishmurphy5754]

I’m so happy you selected Amazing Grace. I think it’s one of their best, a masterpiece. This performance brings tears to my eyes every time. There are so many elements of this group, their arrangements & performances to appreciate but for now, I love how secure they are in their own talents that they freely support each other when it’s not their turn in the spotlight. Whether it’s adding to the rhythm or enhancing a lead, they take the supporting role. Some songs are balanced with each having their own parts. Some have a primary lead. It never matters. They are there for each other & always deliver their best. I rewatch their official video often but I’ll also watch this reaction again as well. (And not just to hear you speak Italian) Once again you put words to the emotions I feel when I listen to Pentatonix. I love your analogy to jumping off the cliff. We all have chains that bind us to some degree. This arrangement gives you the ultimate freedom to break free, open chest, soaring. I’ll think of you every time I hear that part again. Grazie

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Ahhh, I am honored, Dish Murphy!!! Thank you for your beautiful comment!

[@nadinehaney6590]

Something that is inherent in us as human beings is that we have this desire, almost a need really, to share things with others that have brought us joy, because joy is something that the more we give the more we have. When I see how listening to this group brings such a joy and a shine to your eyes and a brightness to your spirit, it brings back the wonder I felt the first time I heard this. The beauty of this performance in particular is almost overwhelming, in the best way possible!

[@annengvall9003]

So happy to see another Pentatonix video from you! Thank you!! You are by far my favorite “reactor”. You help me to understand why I love their music so very much. They have so many amazing songs to choose from. My favorite might be their cover of Mad World.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank YOU, Ann!!!

[@oldguydoesstuff120]

I have played in a worship band for many years, and know this basic arrangement pretty well. When you talked about Kevin (the beatboxer) dropping out and the vocalists flying - that's when our band (and plenty of others as well) tend to drop out the instrumental backup and sing acapella. With a group that is already acapella, they did a brilliant job of imitating that effect. The singers are all singing words rather than oohs or aahs or rhythmic sounds. They are more like a choir than instrumental backup. Still, after having done this for years, I now know why it works so well because of your explanation.Thank you.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

No, THANK YOU for your beautiful comments, Old Guy Does Stuff!!!

[@cindymcvay9579]

I have enjoyed Pentatonix for many years but your breakdown helps me to understand musically why I have loved them. Thank you so much for the beautiful way you describe the music. It makes me want to learn Italian.

[@callalily9842]

I'm loving your Pentatonix reactions. They are incredibly insightful and informative. Please don't stop doing them. I would love to see your reaction to their cover of Elton John's "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" from The Lion King. It's brilliant.

[@isabelmarti9486]

Yes me too!

[@sharynmapenzi1321]

Yes... it's awesome

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Calla Lily!!!

[@sallypursell1284]

Signor, Roberto if I may, I truly enjoy your Pertatonix videos. It would be a shame if you were to stop doing them. Thank you for your most enjoyable and educational work.

[@carmenmercer7916]

In my humble opinion your analysis of Pentatonix is amazing! I will watch and learn from all of their music you are able to review. Thank you.

[@UnmarkedSurveillanceVan]

I said it in your last video and I’ll say it again, you are easily the one of the best if not the best vocal coaches I’ve seen on yt. I could watch your reactions all day long. Cheers!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

That is VERY kind of you, thanks unmarkedsurveillancevan!!!

[@mariaage8568]

So glad that you were able to react to another Pentatonix song! THOROUGHLY enjoyed this!! The images that you paint as you listen to them are beautiful. I absolutely agree that with this song....you can feel it on your skin. Literally get chills every time MItch and Kirstie sing "like a flood" and I have listened to this 100 times! Please continue, I get so involved I forget I'm reading the subs!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Maria!!!

[@barbarahicks2927]

Thank you, thank you, thank you Roberto... I was one of those who requested this one. I have sung many versions of this song over my 66 years (Chris Tomlin version and the original), and nothing has ever given me the "chills" like their version. As usual, their harmonies bring new life to an old classic. My favourite part is Matt's bass during Kirsten's solo... goose bumps! Frankly, I would love to see the members of Pentatonix "react" to one of your reactions.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank YOU, Barbara!!!

[@joannekearney5329]

I know nothing about music... but you helped to explain why I feel emotional with many of their performances...

[@ambeauty2001]

I really really hope Pentatonix watches this and all your reactions vids cuz they're just bellissimo!

[@milo_thatch_incarnate]

The list of videos on the internet that I would watch for a solid 40+ minutes is extremely short. Your videos, dear Roberto, will ALWAYS be on that list. Well worth every minute. Ecselsior!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

THANK YOU, Mel V!!!

[@milo_thatch_incarnate]

@@LezioniDiCantoOnline The bit where you described the absence of the beatboxing at the climax being like, running and jumping off a cliff, and that moment suspended in the air... it is exactly right. Actually, it was such an accurate description that I saw a vision of it in my mind, and almost teared up. And I also realized that when Kevin (the beatboxer) hits his high notes in the end, it's like he's the last to join the group in flight =D and that made me smile so much.

[@bettyhayes8178]

I really miss watching your reactions and hope you can do some more one day. I still listen to the reactions you did. There are so many songs that I hear now and wonder what you would say about them. You will probably never see this but I just wanted to let you know that I very much enjoyed your reactions because they made the music live. Thank you so much.

[@sandyleewhite]

💖💖💖***********HOW DO I COMMENT ON PERFECTION********** 💖💖💖(Thank You Roberto Delli Carri, I really love your reactions & commentary) 😊

[@Catlinel]

Not a single second too long, it was so interesting from beginning to end ! I really appreciate that you take the time to clearly explain all those details and technicalities. And it was funny to watch you trying not to get too entranced by their singing while analysing it; we can all relate to that I think^^.

[@davidwiles1987]

Thank you for your informed and enlightened reaction, finally someone who knows music, with actual explanations of what is actually happening in the performance. I truly appreciate you!

[@bjeffrie22]

Enjoying this tremendously so far. You are one of the few people who bring out how much the 'not lead at the moment' are filling in the sound and how intricate the arrangements are. Be back for the rest later.

[@bjeffrie22]

Great reaction / analysis. Some may complain but I like that you replay sections and explain what you find. Temple Music Academy is also heavy on the analysis side pointing out -- as you did -- aspects such as Kirstin & Mitch throwing out a clear tone and adding vibrato toward the end. (They can actually do this together and match vibrato.) kzbin.infovideos

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Brian!!!

[@topturretgunner]

Roberto. I do say Grazi thank you very much for reviewing this rendition of a timeless hymn by PTX. I do so enjoy acapella and good well done harmonies. Your critiques are revealing and informative. They get beneath the surface and bring to light the hidden gems of technique, control, pitch, breathing. Things that many others are not familiar with. Thank you again and God bless you.

[@jayholland2632]

I really love the way you break down and help your viewers appreciate the smallest intricacies of PTX arrangements. Even after hearing a song by them many times, you never fail to point out and highlight something I have missed. For that I am grateful. I hope you can get the copyright issues straightened out, it would be a shame to lose your insights into my favorite group. Perhaps you should try some live performances, they seem to get blocked less. One in particular I would recommend is their 2016 Popspring performance ( kzbin.info/www/bejne/bXiweaSPrdWhsM0 ) recorded by for MTV. The audio and video are top notch. It would also give you a chance to analyze some original compositions. 'Cracked' has Scott's bluesy soul lead, 'Can't Sleep Love' is just a fun pop song oh yeah and Mitch raps, and last 'Water' is written and led by Kirstin. It also has a fun medley in the 'Evolution of Michael Jackson'. Given your style it would be advisable to break them up to avoid a 2 hour+ video, LOL.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much for your comment, Jay!!!

[@Alcagaur1]

This is, as advertised, a thorough, detailed and discursive analysis, not simply highlighting a few of the stunning heights of the piece, but a comprehensive commentary from a deconstructive standpoint of what is achieved and how. As a non-native speaker, you bring a greater capacity to stand back from the avalanche of expression and home in on the causes, great and small, for the crescendo of feeling here made manifest.

[@Lupin788]

What an amazing and joyous reaction and breakdown! From your mouth to the ears of the Grammy nomination committee. After listening to your detailed analysis, I'm convinced Pentatonix deserves nominations for arrangement and for vocal performance.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, Lupin788!!!

[@mlroeder]

That tension of the dissonance followed by the release of the resolution is everything to me. I get a physical and emotional response every time. It makes my heart smile. 🥰 Your explanations of how their choices effect us help me see it in other places and in other songs. Your willingness to share just how strongly it makes you feel makes it easier to allow myself to do the same. Thank you! 🥰🥲

[@ritathomas5167]

Please do not stop attempting to do Pentatonix reactions! There are many, many people with KZbin channels who react to them, and some are better than others. However, you are absolutely the BEST! I am a music person, and still learn so much from you!!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Rita!!!

[@linda8609]

I have listened to this entire reaction video three times to date - there will be more - because each time Roberto delli Carri teaches me to hear something new, increases my appreciation and introduces my ears to subtleties I would otherwise miss. I am most grateful!

[@cherylhowe1541]

Roberto, the best reaction/insight of Pentatonix that you've done. Especially loved the way you critiqued Mitch's part. Most people don't catch that key change to B for his beautiful voice. My favorite word to use when describing Mitch's voice is that it's smooth. It flows beautifully from register to register. It's seamless in this song. Kirsten's performance may just be the best she's done so far. And Kevin at the end - I loved your reaction and statement about him flying after the transfiguration. When he first came to PTX he said he couldn't really sing. Avi, the former bass, told him he could and took it upon himself to teach him. I look forward to your next reaction to this under appreciated group. Ciao!

[@WatcherOfMeatball]

Your analyze is just mesmerizing! I need 2836385726251667474 more videos! I could watch and listen to you forever ❤️

[@michaelcooper5677]

Your comments are, as always, superb. It is wonderful that you pick up on the fact that their singing is reflective of the words and that they use their vocal artistry to reinforce the meaning of the words . That you conceptualize things into visualizations that you see and share with us is quite remarkable. It is also very special the manner in which we learn from you, not only what they are doing but also how they are doing it and gain insight into why they are doing it a certain way. They have great mastery of their art form especially as they are quite young ( at least to me, I am 75 ) but then I would say the same of you. I would echo the comments of Mr. Barnhart (below) about how the "drone" tone in the beginning is I think a way they honor the sound of the bagpipe version of the song which is widely played and heard not just in England and Scotland but in the U.S. as well. You are a source of joy as well as knowledge and emotional insight and it is clear that you love music and you love what you do. I hope that the passion that you express so wonderfully in your voice , your facial expressions and body language may some day become the pandemic that the world experiences rather than the one we having now. I paraphrase Shakespeare but I feel " You have unclasped the book even of your secret soul" with your videos and it is a very great gift. Thank You.

[@Kristina_Rose]

I love your reactions and analysis. It is like sitting down at the end of the day with a good bottle of wine. Those of us who love PTX know there is something very special in what they do but wouldn't be able to say what it was. Your analysis only increases my love and respect for them. I hope and pray that you can make these videos work, that the record company understands the value in what you are doing. The band loves reactions to their music and are in a constant battle to keep them from blocking everything. Please keep it up - I would love to hear your thoughts on more of their music - particularly any of their Evolution videos, Havana, or Imagine.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you VERY much, Kristina, for your kind comment!!!

[@nicklenights]

Sir: If you could, Pentatonix did a 4 song Mini concert as part of a Japanese program called Pop Spring. The year was 2016. The Japanese were/are putting this on every year and introducing new emerging artists to the public. So far as I know, there are no copyright issues that would prevent you from teaching us ( your public) more about their songs. Three are original songs with one a mixture of clips of Michael Jackson songs. Each song can be reacted to as single songs and your commentary would be of great interest . Hopefully you will check out the video and see the possibilities of using your knowledge to teach us. It is a live performance and they were a bit younger but the genius is there and their last song “Water” is fantastic. Kirstie is the singer and Avi Kaplan is the bass. Caio!

[@amandamcallister5560]

I never comment on videos. I watch a lot, but I don't think I've ever commented before. I feel compelled to say that you make me see/hear these songs in a different way. While I know how they make me feel, I now can understand WHY they make me feel. I have no music background aside from piano lessons as a child. I speak only English and I just love listening to your beautiful language. I could listen to you speak Italian all day! Your knowledge and passion make it possible for me to watch 43 minutes of reaction. Sometimes I can barely stand to watch 5 minutes of others' reactions because they say what I would say, i.e. "Wow that was amazing!" You bring a different side to these and I hope you never stop doing them :) You have yet another fan in America!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Amanda, thank you SOO much for your comment!!! I am truly glad that you found this video of some help.

[@curdanet]

Hello, my name is Carlos Urdaneta, a Venezuelan living in Chile due to the crisis we are experiencing in our country. I am a great admirer of your accurate and excelent comments in the musical analyzes that you do. In this case, I wanted to tell you that I use headphones with an excellent response to low frequencies. Sony XB550AP with a frequency range from 5 Hz to 22,000 Hz. At minute 31:38 you talk about the void left by the beatboxer so that the prominence of the climax moment is taken by the voices. In fact with these headphones you can hear that the beatboxer gives a note that decreases it to the fadeout that serves as a bridge to that silence, that beatboxer is even more "amazing" .. than good performance. Thanks for your analysis and I will be waiting for your next video. You are excellent. All the best.

[@Curiousmindnowwhat]

God.... you are musical surgent... I love how you dissemble music and make it understood and so easy to follow.... I think I could watch your reactions for hours

[@scarlett0464]

I am loving your breakdowns! Can't believe I'm watching long videos that I have to read 😂 Thank you for your insight.

[@resolved37]

The' mmh' sound is supposed to remind you of bagpipes, which are often used at Irish wakes.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, resolved37!

[@artheis1342]

I have never experienced a reaction video so intense and enlightening. Thank you.

[@bchemptyyeetttt]

Ugh I hate that youtube keeps deleting Pentatonix content even though the members said they enjoy reviews of their songs and reactions

[@TransparentEclipse]

It’s pentatonix record label. They crack down super hard on most of their covers and somewhat on their original work. Pretty much the only thing that is usually safe from blocks are their evolutions and medleys, but even they get blocked occasionally.

[@azuresinger]

How informative you are! 👏 You are unlike any other reactor I've watched. Granted, it's a little maddening to have to read, but that's my fault for not knowing your beautiful language. Thank you over & over again! ❤️

[@pglover64]

Roberto, where have you been! Miss you brother, hurry back!

[@pglover64]

Robert, need to ask you a question? Why do you not sing in your lower register? There is nothing wrong with your mixed voice but I think you probably have an incredible baritone voice that you don’t have confidence in and therefore don’t use. Tell me if I am wrong but being around the industry for over 40 years I can spot someone with a great voice that could be even better. Please don’t think I am criticizing you in any way, I am not. I just feel you are holding back on yourself for some reason.

[@betabyte5620]

You have given me a whole new appreciation for their music, pointing out details I would have never noticed. I can't imagine the process they go through to come up with these arrangements and loved your theories behind the beatboxing intensifying before entering the void. It would be fun if they came across your reaction and provided their thoughts. I'm sorry you are having issues with warnings. I hear that from a lot of people reacting to their music and appreciate that you continued to try.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, BetaByte for your words!!! Roberto

[@bindak]

Thank you for these wonderful analyses! I’m not a singer (nor do I speak Italian), and I find your PTX breakdowns to be my absolute favorite. I’m sorry you are having fair use issues; I hope you will be able to resolve them soon so we can benefit from your knowledge! Ciao 😘😘

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank YOU, Belinda K!!!

[@charlescoomer6080]

Your analysis of their music makes me appreciate them even more.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Happy to hear that, Charles!!!

[@pughead2]

I absolutely adore the detailed breakdown of the key changes, transitions, and emotion this brings out in you. I see and hear things I never would have on my own. I know other reactors change the perspective of the video, using software, from, "wide screen" to a more square, shorter rectangle, to ,so called, trick the algorithm from identifying the video origin. Maybe that would help prevent the copyright blocks. KZbin's "fair use" system is broken and hurts both the viewers and the artists.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you very much, pughead2!!!

[@sharonstrain9831]

I was riveted during the entire video. It was mesmerizing and so full of information. You are able to verbalize technically and emotionally what so many of us hear and feel when we watch Pentatonix. Bellissimo!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you SO much, Sharon!!!

[@AudioVile]

I don't know if you will see this comment, but WOW!!! You have an incredible ear! With all that happens during this song, you picked the details out and broke some of those harmonies and changes down in such an understandable way! You are the first reactor (I've heard at least 20 on this song) that mentioned the arms crossing and opening on "my chains are gone..." Your analysis when you rewind each section is amazing. I LOVED how you reacted to the "void" (as you called it) when Kevin suddenly stops as they go to the pure a cappella passage. The whole reaction was an enjoyable learning experience for me. You are REALLY good! Outstanding!! This one reaction (the best I have heard) MADE me subscribe! In a single word... BRAVO!!

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Scott, I TRULY appreciate your generous and encouraging words! Thank you!!!

[@sharonrimsza7960]

I always love their music but you point out additional beauty in their voices. Thank you

[@myramegill7293]

Dear Robert, I miss your reactions and analysis! Where have you gone? 😔

[@JA-mt3lm]

I agree with Carla DeWitt. I Subscribed because I watched/ subtitled Read. For first time transfixed. Why? Roberta, even with subtitles you have a very special talent. Your the first professional who Clearly explained both the Technique an artist used to fully Creat/convey/present with stunning accuracy the Full Emotional reaction that a song will give the listener. I’m not a musician, I don’t sing, I cannot read one cord in a lullaby, I enjoy ‘reaction videos’ on occasion, many different kinds. Because of you took the time to complete a video, explain clearly what you see, hear, feel, I Now hear music with greater appreciation. Thank you for this exquisite, precious gift you gave me without even knowing it. On Christmas no less. God bless you and all your friends and family this Holiday season. 💕💕

[@teofilaguillermo6448]

Ciao Roberto. I am from the Dominican Republic (Spanish) I truly hope you find a way to continue reacting to Pentatonix. Your knowledge and teaching style has helped me become aware of the nuances in songs adding extra layers to my hearing experience.

[@dianeparker4695]

When you have the time, please review "The Prayer". I think you will enjoy the part that Mitch sings. It's like listening to an angel soaring.

[@susansouthard]

I love watching you take so much joy in this music!

[@joshlinds]

Your knowledge, appreciation, and passion has only served to heighten my already immense appreciation of Pentatonix, and I hope the "higher powers" in KZbin reactions understand that! It fully envelopes my senses to read your expertise...I FEEL it that much more. Truly with knowledge comes power and understanding!! Someone like you creates a needed communal element of enjoyment that is lost in 6-minute clips of someone only recognizing the "Wow" factor. I wish I had your take on everything I hear! Thank you!!!

[@susanpeterson9947]

Thank you for an incredibly insightful reaction! I hope that SME will leave you alone.

[@LezioniDiCantoOnline]

Thank you, Susan!!!