Vocal Coach & Songwriter React to Time To Say Goodbye - Zhou Shen (周深) | Song Reaction and Analysis

☕ Buy Us A Coffee: buymeacoffee.com/throga
🎙 The Vocal Gym (Online Course): throga.com
🐱 Shirley Jones Mug: throga.printify.me
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
DESCRIPTION
Join us for a first-time reaction and analysis of Zhou Shen with Guinness World Record-breaking vocal coach, Richard Fink IV, and Billboard #1 songwriter, Johnny Cummings.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
ORIGINAL VIDEO(S)
▶ • 【ENG SUB】周深Zhou Shen《T...
THIS REACTION ON BILIBILI
▶ www.bilibili.com/video/BV1uC4...
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
JOHNNY CUMMINGS (INTRO/OUTRO)
iTunes - / johnny-cummings
Spotify - open.spotify.com/artist/4VXWc...
#周深 #timetosaygoodbye #zhoushen #reaction #vocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts #songwriting #songanalysis

[@Throga]

Join us this coming Wednesday (April 17) at 8am EST for a 90+ minute LIVE reaction to Zhou at kzbin.infoZRMoSVKqOWk

[@sammyleung4021]

"Mirage" Please🙏🙏🙏

[@user-fm6dx4nc3j]

@@sammyleung4021 Hi Sammy Yes Mirage is amazing. Charlie has soooo many amazing songs. Richard and Johnny will be doing so many marathons for Charlie. Too many good songs. I want them to react to Moonlight and snow spring. The list is endless.🥰🥰🥰

[@sammyleung4021]

@@user-fm6dx4nc3j Totally agree ✨

[@msmshappy1180]

Will be awaiting!👍👏😘🙏🙏

[@dream.wonderfulll9430]

“My heart will go on” please ❤

[@joyceng2403]

Time to say goodbye. It is such a beautiful song covered by Charlie. It is a bit heartbreaking, that’s was the time he was still not popular and tried so hard to win himself a chance just to perform, and it was still the period that “ everyone says I sang great, but when they come to a time to choose, none of them picks me.” Even with such a beautiful performance of “time to say goodbye”, he still fails the game…. We are so glad that Charlie has lived these through and now grows up as a super star.

[@user-cf4mt1rk4x]

喜歡周深唱歌,不油膩 沒機心, 安靜人的心靈

[@wanxianzhou6902]

对，抚慰人心的歌声

[@ooch543]

真的！！！周深唱的超級無敵好👍當初第一次聽把我驚呆了！好美！好美！

[@xuesun9132]

Everyone wants to be friends with him! Thank you for the reaction!😊

[@soho3016]

He’s definitely my favorite singer. But it’s more than just singing, his personality and kindness are also very attractive. Love him❤❤❤

[@user-fm6dx4nc3j]

We all love and support Shen Shen. My one and only singer I listen to.🥰🥰🥰

[@cecilialee7215]

Me 2

[@ft4352]

我喜歡專業老師評周深的歌❤下星期三再見😊

[@ceceliakrieg5824]

The centre judge is a world class baritone and said Zhou Shen has one of the rarest voices in the world, and believed in him all the time. He encouraged him many times to gain confidence and it was him jumping to his feet after The Lonely Goatherd when Charlie really became the performer he knew Charlie could be. There are some fantastic duets and trios with the other singers in this show. They all wanted to sing with Charlie. There is a video Super Vocals 10 Amazing songs. It's worth watching. Remember, some of these singers are still at University learning to sing classiically. It was such a great show.

[@user-lq9mi1xm1h]

又一個想要成為朋友的聲樂老師😂😂😂周深太優秀了❤❤❤❤

[@aya071996]

對呀，周深美好又強大❤❤

[@user-dq2hx5tt4l]

對～😂😂

[@hkho3480]

是的呢 每次聽到另外一位RE主Rosette老師說要跟周深出去玩和成為好朋友就忍不住笑出來 現在Richard又這樣說 😂😂😂

[@luyuan-zh5cb]

He was an unfailingly modest person, we always loved him

[@xueru2910]

现在的我，听歌只听周深。❤❤

[@ft4352]

我都是😊

[@user-bj5hf7hi2u]

+1

[@starling232]

肯定的❤

[@sammyleung4021]

+1

[@Li-np7js]

我也是

[@breath-so4gl]

聲樂老師真敏銳，能從演唱中就感覺周深的個性好、想跟他做朋友。我是看了不少他參加的綜藝節目才知道他是個性好又有趣的人😊

[@weiliu5418]

哦，这歌我听了一千次了，感觉还能再听一千次，真的好好听❤

[@user-zi4pr3gu5h]

謝謝！非常興奮又能再一次讓大家聚在這聆聽周深的天籟之聲

[@yhkuo3558]

Trust me, everyone in this room not only wants to be friends with Charlie, but also wants to hang out with him hopefully.

[@whichhuang2265]

超愛周深的美聲🥰🥰🥰

[@amaramares557]

My reaction when the female judge gave Shen Shen a negative mark for this audition: “dang, you are screwed Shen Shen! If this is not good enough to her, what can you possibly do better to please her? Maybe she just doesn’t like you because you are too good. 😐”. And yes, that show kind of reflected Charlie’s struggles in real life.. He always had to do extra work to prove his talent and worth as an artist.. and in the end on this particular show.. I was left in tears, all he did was still not enough to earn a place in the top. We are lucky that he never gave up no matter how harsh critics were to him. This man really sings with his heart and works incessantly to improve himself ❤

[@xinwang4643]

The show itself was at least 6 years ago. And he has made incredible progress since that!

[@user-cf4mt1rk4x]

Thanks for your reaction to zhou Shen. He sounds like an angel singing at a church, healing our souls.

[@sammyleung4021]

This performance is in 2018.❤

[@rjs722]

I have a feeling you will have done the version with just the song. There are versions with Eng subs with his conversation with the judges before his audition which gives you insight to Zhou Shen. At this stage of his career, he was not confident. You can see it. He is surrounded by all these classically trained singers from internationally known music programs. At the same time, he had achieved some fame as a pop singer especially with his song DaYu which exploded on the scene as part of the movie soundtrack. Everyone had all these expectations. I thought the judges were more harsh with him on the show and you can see throughout the show how he struggled. All the guys loved him and his voice but each time ZS competed, he lost to others and felt he was letting down his team. He was in tears several times but shouldered through it. Thankfully, he smashed it with The Little Goatherd, which is why his fans are especially fond of that performance. It’s also touching to see how many of the more experienced singers took ZS under their wings and worked to build up his confidence. His growth from Super Vocal to Singer 2020 to Treasured Songs where he performs duets of treasured songs with different singers is amazing. His latest show, Circle of Sound was amazing and ZS shined as you have seen with Listen and Inflammable and Explosive. So many good songs/duets both tradition/classics and modern pop songs. His new album has been anticipated for 7years. His pre-released song Mirage is No 1 on the China music charts. He has 4 songs in the top 20 including Spring Snow and two music soundtracks. His album will be stunning I don’t doubt. New music video due on the 16th.

[@Throga]

We did the one with the conversation :) And we are doing Zhou for this coming Reaction Wednesday as well!

[@janque2547]

@@Throgaoh wow,! Couldn’t wait! Many of his fans will be so so so sooooooooo….happy ❤….this one at least 😊😊❤

[@jessicaho9286]

Yes can’t wait for the reaction to mirage and spring snow!

[@Allys777]

@@ThrogaI’m really happy you did the one with the subtitles. I have watched this entire program and the competition was ridiculous. So many amazing singers, Dimash was at their final performance, I can’t remember if he was a judge or just a guest. Also Charlie wasn’t a new singer to them. His first public appearance in China was Huan Yuan on the Voice of China which I think you’ve seen. This competition is from 2019 so about 5 years ago, and I’d like to clarify the teacher in middle’s remarks. Zhou Shen is classically trained as a bell canto tenor (in uni) he was not however trained as a counter tenor. That’s the part he figured out on his own, so not completely from scratch, but amazing nonetheless. He really is one of the sweetest characters ever. He’s grown so much more confident over the years, it’s beautiful to see. If you need any more recommendations, I would suggest his impromptu duet of Lake Baikal with Li Jian( the original singer), as well as his cover of The Orchid Pavillion Preface, by Jay Chou (that’s the gentleman that wrote Nunchucks that you watch Hua Chenyu sing). I sadly can’t join you on morning lives cause I work. But I try to watch all of them in the evening. Thanks as always for your wonderful commentary. I always enjoy it and I missed your intro song 😂, I enjoy that too💞.

[@kusnovakusnova3819]

Shen Shen has said before, many complimented his voice & praised his singing skill but in the end, less chose him. We, Shengmi felt his loss and we didn't even understand when we got attacked by other fans that they support their idols but somehow put the blame on Shen Shen? Shen Shen is hardworking and keeps maintaining his solid foundation thru discipline. His efforts pay off now. Shengmi knows how many songs he sang last year. When we thought it's already a lot in the previous year, he set another record. He is always down-to-earth and sings like his last moment so that's why he can always deliver 💯

[@cherryee7088]

Once you are a fan of Charlie, you will be his fan forever! Not only he has an angelic voice but also an angel like personality!

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

+1

[@jackye212]

＋1

[@leeyinyee3507]

+1

[@user-zm2kq2ek4i]

+1

[@behappyhealthy1147]

＋1

[@joyceng2403]

Charlie is super adorable

[@sammyleung4021]

We all love Zhou Shen🥰🥰🥰

[@gauping]

我因為愛周深所以也訂閱了這個頻道,感謝兩位專業老師慧眼識英雄

[@chuchenyang429]

+1

[@whitecloudblackshadow]

+1

[@longhuang6732]

This is a song performed by Zhou Shen on a TV program he participated in in 2018.

[@teresalau86]

Here to support Zhou Shen 🌟🌟🌟

[@lep6856]

He sang so beautifully and sadly, the loneliness in his tone makes me cry

[@longhuang6732]

I am waiting. I'm glad you've done another program about Zhou Shen's music.

[@amychou0917]

有周深必看❤

[@tsai2217]

聽不夠～期待2024/4/17直播❤

[@behappyhealthy1147]

Zhou Shen's Time to say good bye version is my favourite one ❤ He deserves our appreciation, treasure and love ❤ I remember that his ex agent had arranged other jobs for him & crashed with that tv show period. And that might hv explained why he's not been chosen to be the final six. Anyhow, thank God we can enjoy many different genre of music by Zhou Shen now and he's now one of the top China singers! Ofc Zhou Shen is the best & the most amazing artist in my opinion! ❤❤❤

[@keylamoraes3559]

my eyes... I'm crying. It's impossible not to be moved by an angelic voice like that, oh my God

[@yisumwong3432]

很愛周深❤❤❤

[@chaulingchik8139]

周深每翻唱一首歌都會變成最經典的翻唱❤️❤️👍👍👏👏

[@user-zd1tv2hh3i]

雖然2014年就認識深深，但真正入坑是從此曲開始，而且是一開囗瞬間跌入再也爬不出來了！

[@hsiuchuchen4857]

相信你再也爬不出這個坑了，因為認識了他，你是幸福的！😊

[@hkho3480]

Zhou Shen’s Time to Say Goodbye is amazing. 😀👍🏻Can’t wait !!! But … only one song ? One song is not enough… 😢

[@Throga]

We agree!! That's why we have Zhou Shen (Pt. 2) setup for next Wednesday for another 90+ minutes of reaction!!

[@hkho3480]

@@Throga 90 mins !!! 🙀😺🫶🏻❤️🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@user-ji9vc1dw2v]

Thanks a lot!! This time, i won’t forget to write down my name when buy a coffee to you guys! 😂😂

[@loolaihong202]

@@Throga Wow, so good to hear this!! Super excited, and hope I would be able to catch up with you guys!! See you on Wednesday!!😍

[@queenie3865]

@@ThrogaGreat, I’m looking forward to it!. Please react Zhou Shen’s new song “Mirage”.❤

[@user-ej6yq7io4c]

狠狠期待 真的很愛兩位老師的reaction 專業 有趣

[@hpe3203]

ShenShen has been invited by UN to sing at today (18th) for the Chinese Language Day event! He is in NY right now!

[@jow6510]

He took a video while he was in Time Square!!! Dude, my Charlie boy, when are you coming to the Big Apple for your concert!!! BTW this is from a fantastic show/competition with amazing performances (mostly opera or musical style) and super talented (the show mixed the already-famous ones with the music academy ones and created amazing chemistry!) singers; even though I am a Charlie fan, he was just one of the stars there.

[@zerrinsigirci638]

Time to say hello not goodbye to Zhou Shen maginificent 👏👏🌷

[@emkoh2746]

Oh My Goodness! That’s it! Magical 🤩💘

[@user-it9zb8wu9s]

Love your reactions to Zhou Shen, he is a such treasure boy (Angel voice !😊

[@gracewang2145]

Thank you for your response to Zhou Shen. You are very professional, humorous, sincere, and authentic. I like what you said:"He wasn't just born magically with the skillset. I mean, he has, I'm sure some genetic, but this is, he put work into this!", that's really well said. Hard work is his greatest talent, Indeed, professional teachers are better able to understand the tremendous effort behind the success of those geniuses. Zhou Shen didn't undergo falsetto training, but rather trained in tenor. In university, he studied professional and systematic bel canto techniques, allowing him to effortlessly sing in the range of female voices or even higher. Zhou Shen's tenor is extraordinary, not only beautiful but also powerful, possessing the distinctive characteristics of clarity, brightness, strength, richness, and grandeur unique to male voices. In Zhou Shen's voice, there's a soul representing warmth and love, very charming. Zhou Shen is my favorite singer.On March 31, 2024, Zhou Shen released the debut lead single "Mirage" from his New Album "RefleSHEN Pronoun". It's an electronic music piece, with Zhou Shen's vocals being particularly penetrating and captivating. I highly recommend it to you. "The Mirage"music video will premiere online at 10:00 AM Beijing time on April 16th! Only 3 hours left until then. starring Zhou Shen himself. I'm super excited! ❤❤

[@catherinekwok7781]

Thanks for reacting to Zhou Shen! He covered many songs and elevated the songs to another level, he always bring new surprises and new tastes for covered songs. Look forward to Wed reaction. The official MV of Mirage , from his new album, will be released on 16 Apr 0:00am. Please react to it too ❤😊❤❤😊😊

[@darbygoosie784]

"Mirage" is stunning

[@user-qe3ge7go3r]

很期待明天直播，回來看大家的初遇❤

[@teresalume7887]

he has a great voice

[@gabrielhung1647]

This was the song I heard then I addict to all his performances...😂

[@user-mw2bv7fk1v]

This is not his first appearance, his first appearance was in a competition show 'The Voice China' singing the song 'Huan Yan'. He was quite different from now but his singing was already beautiful then. Thanks for liking Charlie.

[@user-nq9fy6lo3c]

This performance is from 2018. Super Vocal season 1.

[@foreverrmoonchild]

OmG, I dreamed about this last night. I love your reacts guys. I learn a lot ❤ Love from Brazil 🇧🇷 Saranghae 💜

[@prachawit6012]

🎉 จาก ประเทศไทย 🎉 ♥️ Charlie Zhou Shen♥️ 泰国 🇹🇭 ♥️ 🇨🇳 中国 Southeast Asia 🇲🇲 🇹🇭 🇱🇦 🇻🇳 🇰🇭 🇲🇾 🇸🇬 🇮🇩 🇵🇭 🇧🇳 🇹🇱

[@tntn9581]

Yes, it's a WOW when I first heard this..... one word- Amazing!

[@z_a_r_a_oxowowsb7511]

Incredible voice….my words

[@christinatse2536]

Zhou Shen studied music at Lviv National Musical Academy.

[@user-gv6ij7re9i]

Because there was Chinese opera in the song, he went to a teacher to learn how to sing Chinese opera. Among the recommended songs are opera songs such as Brightness, Seeking Bosom Friend in Jiang-hu and Orchid Pavilion Preface.

[@user-fm6dx4nc3j]

Thanks for your reaction to our treasure boy Charlie. He's amazing. So many good songs of his. Hope you can react to Mirage, Moonlight, Listen to the rain and If I miss you,i will miss you. The list is endless. See you this Wed. Can't wait.🥰🥰🥰

[@zoeyngo6347]

So excited for the Wednesday Reaction!

[@judymimi8865]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍Charlie Zhou Shen is my beloved singer. Also, I am looking forward to your reaction to Charlie Zhou Shen's new song, the "Mirage"😊

[@breath-so4gl]

終於等到了！請多聽幾首歌吧🙏

[@hkho3480]

老師們說下周三會有90分鐘！ 太棒了！😺🎉

[@joyceng2403]

Take a seat here so that I can enjoy your reaction on time. I always like your reactions on Charlie.

[@user-qj4lc4qs8t]

I like many of his duets also.

[@anniewu6239]

This TV Show is in 2018, so it is Zhou Shen six years ago.

[@AkemiCollins]

It was a classical singer competition that created a crossover group. Big Fish is and always will be ShenShen signature song.

[@AistPrint]

Чутно, що навчався в Україні💙💛 Наша школа співунеперевершена. Браво 👏👏👏 Дуже ніжно і чутливо🙏 Cлава Україні!💙💛

[@amywongamy2865]

🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@longhuang6732]

Although there is only one song, thank you for your program.

[@yuwei929]

周深寶寶我來啦

[@LadyBettySun]

Zhoushen is classically trained. He graduated from Lviv National Musical Academy of Ukraine, majored in Bel Canto.

[@user-xp3bw7fx6g]

Zhou Shen is a genius in singing with his soul ❤fabulous ❤❤❤❤

[@akaneyuki3743]

Shen shen, singer favorite ku yang bersuara seperti malaikat ❤

[@rjs722]

Looking forward to Wednesday!

[@msmshappy1180]

🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍👏👏👏😘😘😘 Thank you so much for reacting to Awesome Zhou Shen!❤❤❤ Happy Happy!!!..that there's more of Awesome Zhou Shen next Wednesday 17/4/24..thanks lots!❤

[@MirraYin]

it's very hard not to fall in love with Charlie after listening to him, and it's too hard not to love Charlie after watching his reality shows, talking, etc. He is a very funny and smart and hard-working and humble and sweet guy. BTW, I love "Concerto Pour Une Voix" so much, it must be angel singing! Hope it can get to your reaction list next time.

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

+1

[@sarataz07]

Just stunning! First time listening to this singer. Just wow! 🌹🌹🌹

[@Zoe-vt8po]

You two are so cute, so professional and humble.

[@vinatan4884]

I like your reaction and looking forward to the coming wednesday reaction of Charlie Zhou Shen songs, thank you!

[@May-ii2nm]

Zhou Shen sings very good, especially can move people's hearts.

[@kimemerson5732]

He really is quite amazing, and a very sweet man as well, I just want to hug him! I have found many fabulous singers on these Chinese talent shows, all the people shown are terrific singers!

[@aya071996]

周深さんが大好きので、ありがとうございます❤

[@ejentabi]

Zhou Shen is like a person who skipped pupurty. He is also a language genious (he can pick up a new language real fast). He is a perfect fit for songs like "Arrival of the Fairy Queen" or "when a child met an Angel" type of songs.

[@lisahsu2190]

Thank you for reacting Charlie Zhou Shen. His voice is so stunning!

[@xyzmai]

great reaction. Charlie Zhou Shen is amazing!

[@gardeniagardenia9981]

So glad you've finally scheduled this review, can't wait.....

[@MariaFrancisca-sv1tg]

ShenShen❤

[@MLA-ml1sj]

Zhou Shen a une signature vocale incroyable, je suis émerveillée par sa voix et sa puissance vocale.

[@sammyleung4021]

When Zhou Shen performs songs, he can always do it just right and arouse the listener's emotions, so listening to him singing will give you the feeling of being there.💕

[@travellingstonesSS]

I love zhoushen so much!❤

[@user-eh3ik2li5b]

Thanks! I'm so happy, I hope Wednesday comes quickly!🎉🎉🎉

[@Amoy-CN]

周深是中国乐坛一股清流，他的声线特别容易让人共情。我最喜欢他的歌曲《大鱼》《等着我》

[@user-gv6ij7re9i]

Zhou Shen is very gifted with languages. It is recommended to listen to him singing "Let it go" in nine languages.

[@Throga]

That's on our list for next week - another Reaction Wednesday coming up with Charlie!

[@lin9802]

⁠@@Throga waaaaaa, I can’t wait!🎉🎉 Thanks for reaction on Charlie. He is such a goooood person and has great great great voice👍

[@rjs722]

Can’t wait. You have to react to some of his pop songs and definitely some duets from Treasured Songs and from Circle of Sound. You will love You’re too Cruel.

[@user-cf4mt1rk4x]

​@@Throgaalso please check out Zoobi Doobi that is covered by zhou Shen. It's interesting too.

[@user-fm6dx4nc3j]

@@rjs722 so many good songs to react to. That’s why Richard and Johny will have to have many Charlie marathons.😅😅🥰🥰🥰

[@zaffaz]

Obrigado por partilhar conosco suas impressões sobre Charlie Zhou Shen, esse admirável artista chinês. Saudações e bênçãos.

[@lillywang7219]

Thanks for another video about Charlie. He sang this song in 2018 on the TV show Super Vocal.

[@mandanal2232]

Loved this reaction!!! Always so interesting ❤ I'm glad you guys are getting an idea of his personality now too ! He's just so adorable and down to earth

[@cddoudou]

This is the competition back in 2018. The English subtitle version was added 2 years ago.

[@emkoh2746]

Hello Richard & Johnny ! I’ve just stumbled upon your channel, this reaction video! Gosh! Am I delighted at your response 🤩😍! It brought back memories of the first time I heard Zhou Shen/Charlie sang. I spent the whole night till the wee hours of dawn searching for information about this incredible singing creature. 😅😆. Love your reactions! Please do more! Needless to say I hit the subscribe button straight away! 😉. Waiting for tomorrow’s video 🤩. Thanks lots!🙏

[@user-gz2yt5zd9d]

❤️Zhou Shen👍👍👍🥰🥰🥰

[@chuyuanhuang-bf3lc]

Thank you for your lovely reaction!!!🥰 I'm looking forward to the live next Wednesday. Just can't wait ha ha ha. 👻The fact is that Charlie graduated from Lviv National Musical Academy in Ukraine in 2016 with full A grades. He had studied Bel canto there classiclly and formally for years. He was trained professionally by a very famous and authoritative Ukrainian tenor singer for a long period. So It's not like his success only depends on great talent(or genetic things) and great effort, just singing and practicing at home alone. What they really meant was that Charlie had never studied the specific falsetto tenor. He had explored and developed this tone perfectly all by himself, since his college major was more about traditional male tenor.

[@user-qj4lc4qs8t]

This confused me when he said he wasn't professionally trained. This performance may have been when he went back to China during break and was still in dental school.

[@chuyuanhuang-bf3lc]

No, this performance was recorded in 2018 or 2019. He had graduated from the musical academy in 2016. He only studied dentistry earlier for just one year.

[@sc8739]

@user-qj4lc4qs8t Listen carefully, he said he was not professionally trained as a “falsetto” tenor.

[@loo6942]

@@sc8739 Do you speak Chinese? Is "falsetto tenor" a broken translation of the word "countertenor" or is that what they were actually saying?

[@cherrywong8581]

Thanks for reacting Zhou Shen ! I enjoyed the reaction so much ! Looking forward to the next Shen Shen reaction😊

[@juathimlim4236]

Thanks for reacting to Zhoushen songs. This “Super Vocal” variety show was held in November 2018 when Zhoushen was 26. There were 36 competitors and personally I classified Zhoushen The Most Spectacular Amazing and Soul Moving singer among all. He did most solo items eg “Time To Say Goodbye” “ Memory” “The Lonely Goatherd” Best duet “The Crescent Moon” Trio “Hawthorn Tree” “Over The Rainbow”. Zhoushen is a professional trained Bel Canto tenor from the famous Lviv Conservatory Ukraine under the late famous opera tenor. Zhoushen singing skill is far beyond than any of the 35 competitors even better than the lady judge and the young male judge. I discovered Zhoushen accidentally by chance listening to his “ Huan Yan” meaning “Happy Countenance”. I was totally shocked by his professional singing skill! Like a CD! Zhoushen is a humble yet ever learning singer Pray he is blessed all through……………..

[@laiyingnguyen9990]

I became his fans since this super vocal show five years ago, during this five years,I love him more and more by his talents and personality, he is a very sweet, smart , humble, kindness and funny person too.