Vocal Coach & Songwriter React to The Night in Ulaanbaatar - Zhou Shen & Anda Union 周深安达组合唱 / 乌兰巴托的夜

☕ Buy Us A Coffee: buymeacoffee.com/throga
🐱 Shirley Jones Mug: throga.printify.me
🎙 FREE Vocal Profile: throga.com/vocalgym
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
DESCRIPTION
Join us for a LIVE first-time reaction and analysis of The Night in Ulaanbaatar and Huan Yan with Guinness World Record-breaking vocal coach, Richard Fink IV, and Billboard #1 songwriter, Johnny Cummings.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
TIMESTAMPS
00:30 ⏰ Good morning and introduction
05:35 🎤 Discussion about a Chinese song involving throat singing and band
12:02 🎶 Yodeling and tone likened to a Zen meditation session that captivates the soul
17:14 🎶 Analysis of unique vocal techniques in a Mandarin song performance
26:07 🎶 Appreciation for traditional immersive experience of exploring different sounds
32:57 🎤 Analysis of singing competition dynamics and potential producer influence
41:18 🎤 Gratitude for support and desire to return
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
ORIGINAL VIDEO
▶ The Night in Ulaanbaatar - • 周深安达组合唱《乌兰巴托的夜》,低沉的呼麦与...
▶ Huan Yan - • The Voice of China - Z...
#周深安达组合唱 #乌兰巴托的夜 #ZhouShen #reaction #vocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts #songwriting #thevocalgym #songanalysis

[@Rosie-vy4nl]

Zhou Shen's musical journey has not been easy. After he appeared on the show in 2014, he signed a 6 year contract with the management agency from the show. His agency insisted on marketing him as a duo with another male singer. They weren't interested in developing him as a singer. After his contract with them ended in 2020, he formed his own company. His career has since gone from strength to strength.

[@Throga]

Wow! Thank you for this info.

[@Rosie-vy4nl]

@@Throga At the beginning of his career (and while growing up) he faced many negative comments because of his voice - people called him a sissy and worse. He was afraid to sing during his teenage years because his voice didn't change much. Even during the beginning of his career you can tell that he tries to make his voice sound deeper when he is speaking. He has acknowledged in interviews that he faces an extra hurdle compared to other singers before he is 'accepted'

[@janque2547]

I say “good riddance” to the management company who does not know how to appreciate talent.

[@user-uc6jz2ch1n]

his first show was on the “China voices” ，if you can react this would benice。

[@rjs722]

I understand that he actually had a channel on Weibo I think where he sang anonymously and had a good following but he feared showing his face. Most followers thought that he was a female. I have seen reference to the handle/name he used but don’t remember it off the top of my head.

[@user-dw3ci9vx9p]

周深，一個真正走向國際的聲音

[@huikimtan5945]

Zhou shen my only is very good

[@lansylee5239]

Zhou Shen is an amazing singer.❤❤❤

[@teresalau86]

Beautifully done by the Mongolian Bend and Zhou Shen ❤❤❤ the second song the director invited him many times while he was studying music in Ukraine. Finally the third time he agreed and that was back in 2014

[@user-xm1xf9ms1j]

I Love Zhou Shen❤

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

+1

[@mlllcjoy]

Zhou Shen, uniquely him. Chance upon him accidentally in 2014 on a work trip to China. He appeared at the singing competition. Totally drawn and awed by him, and I started listening to his songs, and whenever he appeared in TV programs over the years. Despite against all odds in the earlier years, he remains the humble and well-mannered guy as he is today. He is a well deserving singer, and he should be heard beyond the shores.

[@johokeen1]

Same here, I 'stumbled' upon him in 2016 after listening to his anime song 'BigFish'. And since then, I've been a fan. I adore his wonderful talent and his sweet personality. So blessed to be able to enjoy his beautiful vocals thx to YTube.

[@gracewang2145]

Thanks for reacting to Zhou Shen's The Night in Ulaanbaatar. Such touching singing, so beautiful! Zhou Shen's melodious voice seems like a warm breeze blowing from the vast grasslands, affectionate and tranquil, his moving singing directly touches my soul! Also thanks for reacting to Zhou Shen's Smiling Face, this is the song Zhou Shen sang when he officially debuted as a singer on July 25, 2014. Thank you Zhou Shen for choosing music, allowing us to hear the Voice Of Nature. Amazing singer Zhou Shen, love you, proud of you, forever support you❤❤

[@sweejunechai4791]

＋1

[@yisumwong3432]

👍👍👍❤

[@sarahma4998]

His personality is as beautiful as his voice!!! He is always cheerful! Thoughtful! A little sunshine!!

[@user-fm6dx4nc3j]

Well said.🥰🥰🥰

[@rjs722]

I am here for Charlie and anything the Throga guys want to react to. Another great session with Charlie. It would be great if we could do a duet marathon with Charlie that way you can see other great Chinese singers. Charlie does a ton of duets as he is a treasure boy and everyone likes to sing with him. He is on various shows - variety shows like Running Man, as a vocal coach on new singer competitions, and various singing and entertainment shows. He puts out a ton of content so it's hard for reactors to keep up. Also, it would be fun to have a few clips of Charlie's eng sub interviews or from his annual Sing-a-thon on his birthday each year. That way you can see his personality shine. There is a North America Zhou Shen, International Zhou Shen, and a Hong Kong Zhou Shen fan clubs on KZbin that also have eng subs. Happy to see our new translator. I will hunt for him on Bilibili.

[@Throga]

Great suggestion!! Thank you RJS :)

[@user-qj4lc4qs8t]

I like Zhou Shen's duets with Lina Gong and Liang Long; two which are funny. Also Haken Lee and Charlie have quite a few good ones. I can't wait until the next Charlie reaction here.

[@MA_2_]

When Zhou Shen participated in "The Voice of China", he was questioned by the staff behind the scenes: "Does he really know how to sing with this kind of appearance?” After losing the competition, Zhou Shen was still signed by the company, but not much work was arranged for him. The first and only one CD was self-financed by a producer who heard Zhou Shen’s voice…….. Because he senses that Zhou Shen has great talent and potential. If you have time, please consider listening to "末日飞船", I think it's a very interesting song, a song about the universe!

[@sammyleung4021]

Thanks! Richard and Johnny~ Zhou Shen ❤❤❤

[@0922kate]

What an artist ! Zhou shen !Hope someday he stands in international stages.

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

+1

[@susanhughes1800]

I truly believe he will someday soon!!

[@foreverrmoonchild]

My God, I have tears in my eyes. The way Zhou sings is sobeautiful, @throga please, if you can, bring more analysis of Charlie

[@salabaoba0]

Thank you so much for all you do! Love Zhou Shen!!

[@sashaho7197]

Beautiful and stunning as always !! Zhou Shen has one of the most beautiful voices on the earth, soft, warm and soothing, just like coming from heaven. He is one of a kind. He is my one and only.

[@meig3830]

絕對應同,他也是我唯一最愛的歌唱家❤❤❤

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

+1

[@catherinekwok7781]

Zhou Shen's 2nd album is coming soon! Just officially announced! Look forward to it♥♥😍😍😍

[@yhkuo3558]

Every time I listen to "The Night in Ulaanbaatar " I am moved to tears. It makes me feel like my heart is back home & comforted.

[@user-qj4lc4qs8t]

Maybe you enjoy the Hu also, another Mongolian group. LP and the Hu "mother nature" is beautiful.

[@yhkuo3558]

@@user-qj4lc4qs8t Tks! I'll check it!!! Actually, I love "HAYA Band".

[@yhkuo3558]

@@user-qj4lc4qs8t Tks. I'll check it. I also like HAYA BAND.

[@yhkuo3558]

@@user-qj4lc4qs8t Thank you. I'll check it. I've replied twice, but the system failed to deliver my message.

[@cheungh4064]

Love Zhou Shen❤❤

[@xyzmai]

Zhou Shen is amazing. He can sings in more than 10 languages/dialect. I wish Johnny and Richard knew the Chinese lyrics, as if they do, they can appreciate Zhou Shen's songs even more, 'cos it's the emotion, the stir that Zhou Shen can create in people's heart whenever he sings. Just beautiful

[@leannefranson1198]

Oh, more treasures from you! Thank you so much for reacting to Zhou Shen again, and these two fantastic pieces. How can you not fall in love with someone with not only such talent, but such range, and such a story... I just want to hug him at the start... "It's ok, don't be afraid, people will love you"... he turned down the producer for two years, to come onto The Voice of China. He was just singing online, unseen, as KaBu, and I think was super afraid he'd be mocked and laughed at, with his high voice on tv in public. You can visibly see him relax when he gets some audience cheering. He didn't get far... turns out that they had already someone picked for the group, so he didn't "fit" with the group they had built up of "winners" to tour later. But the audience there and online LOVED him, and demanded more of him. I think for a long time he was still booked as an oddity. A "oh, look! Under his outfit disguise, it's a MAN!" I think really it was the OST from Big Fish that gave him a wider audience and credibility. Don't you just want to hug him, in that video of his first performance? It is interesting how he came out in an outfit that looks like what we changed into after school as kids... patch jeans and a tshirt. I think maybe he was steeling himself for failure, and was like "'I'm not going to dress up as a special occasion. I'm going to pretend that it doesn't matter". Such a treasure. Thank goodness he failed getting into Chinese university, and then again at studying dentistry in Ukrainian. If he had succeeded, he'd be humming under his breath while he drilled teeth. The Ulaanbataar song is wonderful. I just love how Zhou Shen explores different music and different sounds in different languages. The singers and musicians in Anda Union are incredible as well. It isn't an old folk song. Here's some info: "Ulaanbaatar at Night is a cover of a Chinese song originally from 1985, lyrics by Mongolian poet P. Sanduyjav, music by G. Pürevdorj, and original singing by Mongolian Smile Band. "

[@madarinawong4488]

I q

[@hz9042]

Love Zhou Shen's voice💓

[@lisawinston1548]

I know zhoushen thought the super vocal show and singers show from China, then just keeping discovering about this little man and felt sad to knew zhoushen in the voice show only 2 performances 😢, he such a treasure from the God ❤

[@graceliang2227]

He is very popular now,every channel and TV show want him to join,he is super busy and no rest now 😄

[@nikky9344]

In the voice, there are 3, the audition - huanyan, the second round - the lake of baikal, the third, you can search 'a beautiful mistake'.

[@banbanchong5955]

With 'the call from the ancients', the vocal teacher left his tears. He may not know it, the lyrics then sang: the one who sings, please do not cry. Despite the language barrier, the emotions conveyed by music break through language limits.

[@user-um5jq9mx5o]

Thank you for your reaction to Zhou Shen🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@teresateo5088]

Hi Guys ❤Glad you are back for Zhou Shen 😊

[@Throga]

Thank you so much for your support!!

[@behappyhealthy1147]

Zhou Shen, the young singing artist who well deserves our appreciation, treasure and love. The more we know about/hear him, the more we love him. That's why we name him Treasure Boy, Angel, Walking CD, Baby❤❤❤

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

My favorite musician ! He is one of a kind ! ❤ Zhou Shen ❤

[@stingray4988]

The second Zhou Shen song you reviewed is called Huan Yen (歡顏, meaning smiling face), written by Li Tai Xiang (李泰祥), an avant garde music composer in Taiwan in the 1970's. The song recorded in 1979 was his first ever attemp crossing over into pop music by collaborating with a new female singer called Qi Yu (齊豫) who just emerged from Taiwan's college singing contest. The first judge that turned his seat around is called Qi Qin (齊秦), who is Qi Yu's younger brother. Both singers are extremely popular in Taiwan as well as in mainland China and Hong Kong in the 1980's and 1990's. Zhou Shen is the most popular singer in China today. This song Huan Yen is Zhou Shen's first ever TV appearance in China.

[@zhuoli6367]

Zhoushen was a Uni student when he sang Huanyan, also that was his first public stage. Before that, he only sang songs and uploaded them to social media in China, and his angelic voice had attracted some followers prior he’s getting famous. I can tell his singing skills are improving constantly these years, while his first stage was already amazing❤

[@littleYuan27]

They have done an excellent job translating your video. It is very accurate and elegant❤

[@chuyuanhuang-bf3lc]

I agree. They're sooooo hard working. Amazing fans Charlie has. 😊❤️

[@user-kp9jh6nh7v]

The blue microphone is a gift from fans on his 26th birthday; he has been using it since then

[@susanhughes1800]

I love that I do believe he truly is so grateful for his fans. Truly is a talent and I’m so glad that I found his incredibly beautiful voice!

[@ft4352]

我愛周深❤亦愛他的歌❤

[@vhbb5560]

metoo😂

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

+1

[@joyceoewify]

Me too! Absolutely love his songs and adore his personality! Such a beautiful soul!❤❤❤

[@msmshappy1180]

Thank you so much for this 💖 💗 💓 ❤️ 💕

[@lawwaifun3437]

We are proud of Charlie Zhou Shen. Thank you for your reaction of Zhou Shen again. ❤❤❤

[@LittleFish_1507]

Zhou Shen is an ARTIST❤❤❤Thank you

[@minchen3162]

周深❤❤❤

[@canada9405]

Love Zhou shen❤❤❤ Thank you

[@ammylo9003]

周深唱歌可以觸動靈魂深處，總讓人無意識地流淚

[@susanhughes1800]

Yes you should go! Love this song it is in Mongolian and Zhou Shen sings in that languages in the song.

[@Lu_HelloAll]

Love Zhou Shen❤

[@wendy-ex5yz]

the last sentence of the first song is "the singer shall not cry." the turth is that the listener cried.

[@laiyingnguyen9990]

👏👏👏👍👍👍🫶💪🥰 love your real professional reaction videos , I learned a lot of knowledge of music from you guys , Thank you so much ❤️Zhou Shen ❤

[@qkjack5065]

I am Charlie’s fan in Hong Kong. Support 👍

[@myinni7089]

Some singers when they sing, you enjoy it because it feels like they're telling their story through music. When Zhou Shen sings, your soul is moved/touched because it feels like he's singing your stories back to you - it's feels "personal".. I've a suggestion - we give you multiple translated song lyrics and you choose which song/s you would like to react to. That way you get to enjoy his vocals both from the music arrangements AND his interpretations of the lyrics using his voice.

[@tvc3mye]

This is a brilliant idea! I second this idea..

[@cynthiaong102]

Thank you guys for reacting to Zhou Shen's songs. He is really amazing. 🥰🥰👍👍

[@msmshappy1180]

Àwesome Zhou Shen ❤❤❤❤❤❤Amazing as always ❤️ 👏 ♥️ 💖 😍 💕 ❤️ 👏 ♥️ 💖

[@user-cy7ej4yr6w]

"No fear in my heart", "Rubia", "Sanctuary" from Zhou Shen. :)

[@ZhouShenFans70s]

Can’t agree with you more that Charlie’s voice can teleport us to wherever he wants to show us! We’re a group of fans for Charlie who were all born in the 70’s. No doubt that listening to Charlie’s songs will be our lifetime journey!❤

[@leannefranson1198]

I was born 1963 and am in Canada! :D

[@user-fm6dx4nc3j]

Shen Shen has fans from young to old. Yes his voice puts me in a zone and teleports us to another plane. Yes lifetime journey🥰🥰🥰

[@FionnaLiang]

我和孩子都喜欢听周深唱歌，从未遇到有人如周深这般，唱歌深深地打动着我的心。听他的歌真的是我往后余生的快乐。

[@tsai2217]

Love Charlie Zhou Shen ❤❤❤❤❤

[@user-zi4pr3gu5h]

如果你懂中文的話，那麼請帶上耳機聽周深唱的歌，會是一個美好的心靈享宴。😊

[@HC-sr3wz]

他們一直都在用耳筒聽呀

[@user-cj7hp9dl5b]

@@HC-sr3wz 這個好笑

[@Chen-gv6lx]

❤ ur reactions!Looking forwards to more Zhou Shen!😊

[@terraprime]

It brings me so much joy to see two people touched by music in a language they cannot understand. Thank you for your reactions and your comments. They are beautiful. One extra comment: Charlie and the female vocalist (I don't know her name but she appears to be part of the group called Anda Union) were both singing in two languages - Chinese Mandarin and Mongolian. That'd be like someone singing in English and also in Swedish in the same song, where the two languages have different consonants and vows.

[@abbiewan337]

Please go on reacting more songs of Zhou Shen

[@user-un3zu1ou1o]

thanks💙💙💙💙

[@sallychau5128]

Zhou Shen is a gift to this world. Please spare more time for reacting to his stages/works. Everyone deserves a chance to hear him.

[@tian37299]

周深🎉

[@anggleang1190]

Support zhou shen, good man.❤❤❤

[@karpinglin7144]

I really like the way you two work together to host and showcase your professional analytical skills. Marvelous !

[@RRrr7373]

Thank you Richard and Johnny for reacting Zhou Shen' songs, love it and always enjoy it. Zhou Shen is an amazing singer!

[@user-ju9jc1yb4x]

+ 1 love Zhou Shen ❤his voice able to touch the soul of ppl

[@cheungh4064]

Come again for Zhou Shen❤❤

[@user-it9zb8wu9s]

Love your reactions to Zhou Shen, he is a such treasure boy

[@zhuoli6367]

FYI, at the beginning of the song, the backing singers sounded like yodeling is called Humai（呼麦），which is an ancient way of singing from Inner Mongolia in China. This song was performed by Zhoushen and the female singer, Anda, both in Mandarin and Mongolian language. Absolutely epic❤

[@kuilai4988]

@ Richard & Johny, Zhou Sheng's audition song at The Voice - China, HuanYan - is the movie track OST of a 1979 taiwanese movie. The first teacher who turned around during the audition clip - his sister is the original singer of that sound track.

[@nikky9344]

Zhou Shen (w/o 'g')

[@psicologia.em.dialogo]

Thank you, guys! Please try Zhou Shen and Tan Wei wei duet ('Listen')🙏 It's sublime! 🥰 The story behind the song is so special! 🥰

[@user-cl8iy8wc6d]

Zhou Shen's chanting (Mongolian long chant ) is Intangible Cultural Heritage (UNESCO). This song is very well interpreted and performed by Zhou Shen and Mongolian artists. I love Zhou Shen's crystal voice and graceful performance.

[@user-ky1jz9pm3i]

❤Zhou Shen❤

[@jenniferbergendal1290]

Wow!!! Charlie is Amezing!!!

[@JT-cm9di]

In a way you're right, The Voice is pure business, Charlie has chance to win at all not because he wasn't good enough back then, simply because he's not from rich family.

[@thou168]

他的導師那英曾說她沒有選擇周深是因為他的外表不具冠軍相，未來也沒有發展的跡象！結果周深卻被另一位音樂製作人賞識自掏腰包幫他製作了他的第一張專輯！這十年周深憑著自己的努力為自己爭取了很多得來不易的舞台！重點是每一場表演都讓人充滿期待且不讓人失望！

[@user-qj4lc4qs8t]

I've watched Charlie sing with many others in duets with singers who are only OK, but with Charlie singling along side, the piece becomes really special. He's done quite a few with Haken Lee.

[@JT-cm9di]

​@@thou168最讽刺的好声音本来就不看外貌选人的😂

[@hkho3480]

Can’t wait for the Charliethon !!! 😀❤

[@yaoandersson7811]

天使的声音 ❤👍👍👍🇨🇳🌹🌹🌹

[@gretchenfraley3898]

It amazes me how Johnny turns around and plays the same tune immediately.

[@user-fm6dx4nc3j]

Yes it’s amazing how Johnny does that. Good ear for music. Talented

[@jilllee3800]

No doubt！ You should go. I will always be here if Charles here.

[@yuanyuanzi5834]

Thank you for your Charlie ZhouShen reactions, love them.

[@viovivi809]

Thank you for such an enthusiastic reaction! Always love hearing professionals analyse Zhou Shen's singing (as I have completely no idea about music other than understanding when someone sounds amazing). A trivia: the last line of the first song, after Richard says "that's the part that gets me teary-eyed", actually translates to "The Night in Ulaanbaatar is so quiet (could also be translated as calm/silent/peaceful) // The person/people singing should not drop a tear"

[@littlesparrowwitch]

There is something incredibly moving about that first performance - Mongolian traditional pieces tend towards the highly emotional! I'd suggest listening to Ayanga's performance of Grassland on Super Vocal! That first audition! You can see how nervous he was but how his confidence grew when instead of being mocked everyone loved his voice (at this point his voice was known but not what he looked like). We outside of China came very close to never hearing this beautiful voice and appreciating a wonderful young man! Love how much you love him!

[@eugeniayau]

I still get goosebumps listening to 欢顏 (Huan Yen)~10 years after I fell into Shen Shen's musical pit and not wanting to get out 🤣🤣🤣❤️❤️❤️

[@janetli3789]

I love your reactions! I hope you will react to "Monsters" and "Just like fire" cover by Zhou Shen! He did amazing jobs again ❤️

[@aarynsaleh1259]

Zhou Shen💞💞

[@user-gz2yt5zd9d]

❤️周深 無敵👍👏🥰

[@Ven-_-L0033]

Besides their awesome singing, I just ❤ how Zhou Shen, the introvert, started doing the Mongolian dance in the middle of the clip 😂. 深深太可爱啦❤❤ Love your comments, guys! ❤

[@chuyuanhuang-bf3lc]

Love your reaction to Charlie ZS. You guys are very professional. One of my favorite songs of Charlie is Heart of Peace. The 1st electric music style song of him. It's an English song originally written by Chinese songwriter Zhangye. It's about anti-war theme and calls for Peace ＆ Love. The song is absolutely a perfect masterpiece. It deserves a reaction. 🤩👍🏼

[@chuyuanhuang-bf3lc]

Sorry for putting it wrong. It's electronic music I mean. 😂

[@yuanyuanzi5834]

I like 《Heart of Peace》, specially, Mr. Zheng Ye studied in Russia, and Charlie Zhou Shen studied in Ukraine. They made this song at early Ukraine war. This is not the first Electronic Music for Charlie, Charlie and Panta Q 有《對不起》《話語》very good EM songs.

[@user-xm1qo3ow2m]

其實周深跟郭曲的對不起及話語是更早的電子音樂，也很好聽的

[@sharonz221668]

❤❤Zhou Shen so much

[@gabrielhung1647]

Thank you to reacting Zhou Shen's songs...❤❤❤

[@janettang2076]

I came from Bilibili and just subscribed the channel! Looking forward to more reactions to dear Charlie. He deserved to be heard and known by more people and this is also his momentum all the time.

[@Throga]

Awesome! Thank you!

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

👍

[@guyguy2937]

I didn't know this song.... fabulous

[@annadeng6736]

Love your reactions to ZhouShen, he is a such treasure boy❤

[@eugeniayau]

Just wanted to add a thought whilst watching your show (sorry if someone has commented on the thread already...didn't have a chance to read all the comments) ~ great show by the way😊~ Zhou Shen NEVER overpowers whenever he duets with another singer...he'd only harmonize with him/her and they'd tweak the arrangement that'd bring the song to a whole different beautiful level! 👍👍👍 Zhou Shen lives for music~with his ShenMis (that's us...his diehard fans) coming in close second!!! 😊😊😊 ❤❤❤❤Shen Shen!!! Look forward to your next Zhou Shen react...

[@esthercheng8614]

Thanks for your reaction to Zhou Shen, he is such a lovely and wonderful singer not only in China. Personally i think he is one of the most best singers in the world. I will introduce the following songs for next reaction. 'She is a bleak star, This is me, Time to say goodbye, Kepler, baby до свидания, 算你狠，The lights of China.... So grateful for your video and let more people to know Zhou Shen

[@user-cz1lh7pc2r]

👍👍👍

[@Rosie-vy4nl]

A comment that Zhou Shen frequently encountered was - 'Zhou Shen sounds good and has great singing skills, but if he was a woman then he would be nothing special'. He has spent his life overcoming these difficulties. Now he tries to share positivity and strength in overcoming life's challenges through his music. He says that his fans provided him the light and strength for him to continue on. He wants to do the same for his fans, so as long as we need him, he will be here to sing for us!

[@tim0chen]

Well said! Thank you!

[@user-qj4lc4qs8t]

Besides having a beautiful voice, he's also a great performer. His humility makes him even more loveable.

[@dream.wonderfulll9430]

Zhou Shen’s voice is not just like woman’s. He has woman voice’s beauty, plus man voice’s strength underneath. That’s why his high note is so beautiful and comfortable , not piercing at all. That’s why you can enjoy his music all day long, they soothes your soul. He is such an angel❤❤

[@alexxgalaxy]

Going by that, all women or men with beautiful voices and good singing skills mean nothing at all and they are just ordinary 😅

[@user-xb2kl1gj4z]

你說的只是唱商喔！​還要情商，歌曲注入靈魂更重要捏！

[@rjs722]

If this song resonates with Johnny and Richard, wait until they listen to Listen with Tan Wei Wei, Heaven/Da Yu with Tengri, or his other traditional songs Painted Silk or What Love is from the Classic Songs Program. When Charlie sings What Love Is and also the Russian song - Cranes on the same program, I just want to cry.

[@user-jh8db7ei3i]

美到聽歌的人掉眼淚！

[@tntn9581]

The night of Ulaanbaatar is so quiet and peaceful ~ The song is so beautiful ~

[@mrsb3083]

Someone uploaded ZhouShen's baby baby video a few days ago on BiliBili. He sang a cover song in two timbre when he was 16 at high school. All his school mates(fans) were cheering off the stage. One of ZhouShen's fans has forwarded the video to her YT channel.

[@leannefranson1198]

what is it called? Which YT channel? Thanks!

[@mrsb3083]

白雲蒼狗此深為你For Charlie@@leannefranson1198

[@YINGTANG-li5tp]

I would like also to propose for Zhou Shen's "Moonlight", his voice is pure and beautiful as always, he did a lot of changes and show his other potential of his voice.

[@anggleang1190]

Beautiful voice, he is nice guy, l with love❤❤❤

[@Dorie0401]

Love Zhou Shen ❤

[@emilydunbar7005]

The charisma of you two is so pleasant and inspiring, and I really enjoy this reaction very much. Your reaction brings the depth of the song. I can understand the Mongolian throat singing and ancient Easten tone so much better now. Without your pointing out the different layers of the singing, I would not appreciate the arrangement of this performance. Richard and Jonny, your talks were never too much! 💕👍

[@leannefranson1198]

I agree. I don't understand people who come to reaction videos by those who have expert knowledge, and then expect them not to stop the video to react, and not to talk. The whole point of me watching Throga videos is to hear what they have to say, to see how they react to the songs, his singing, teach us new things about what we are hearing. We can already listen to the original with no interruptions or talking as many times as we want. Why come to a reaction and then complain it's a reaction? Richard and Johnny, your talks are never too much!! Love your insights!

[@youngwound2507]

love zhoushen