Why is Carnatic music boring? | VoxGuru ft. Pratibha Sarathy

[@bhavyaurs1955]

Accepted your words ma'am i am learning senior carnatic music sometimes music tested my patience a lot... to come properly. Sometimes I cried / enjoyed/ got angry but still i don't like to give up because Music is my passion..... That connection is not leaving me thanks a lot for your advice Boosted me!! Whenever I feel I am unable to do ..,.. sure i will listen this video to boost myself..... Make some more videos like this and encourage the students who wants to achieve something in life..... 🙏🙏🙏🙏 Hope you will read this message 👏🤝 Ma'am

[@maysunkj]

Never.... Carnatic music is not at all boring..... Its like a heavenly flow of emotions.... Imbibe in it.... You will never ever ....feel... Boring.... Fact is that....... I am not saying it...........

[@xavqnesh420]

Ew just check Western Music, it's the main source of all music, in the bakery vans in my country the put Beethoven's Fur Elise, not this stupid s#1t.

[@manishreal8095]

Carnatic Music is the best music in the world 🌎 I am from Nepal but Carnatic Classical is my favourite Genre though I don't understand ❤

[@Nandakii]

Prathibha ji has left out one very important point according to me. Everything is difficult, boring at first, but with time and constant exposure, we start to love it. That's how I fell in love with Carnatic Music. I think it is Quintessential that students must have constant exposure to concerts, especially live ones. This makes even a person who hates Carnatic music but has an open mind start to love Carnatic Music.

[@bhavyaurs1955]

Really we need mentor like this!!!! Your a goddess Saraswati to all our music students from 1st video to till now your tips are awesome and good teaching ma'am viewers what do you say?

[@harsh3391]

I come from non-carnatic region where hindustani music is practiced traditionally. I think Carnatic music is very divine, sweet and melodious. It's not at all boring. Carnatic is my recent discovery, i got exposed to it during 2020 lockdown. I ardently follow Vidushis Ranjani and gayathri and Kuldeep pai ji. I'm yet to discover more and more excellent Carnatic artistes. I wish I could also learn Carnatic music someday. 🙏♥️

[@maheshjayaraman6856]

Hindustani is more soul touching

[@harsh3391]

@@maheshjayaraman6856 Both are equally soul touching bcoz their source is one. Both are derived from the "Sama veda" hence they have many similarities.

[@maheshjayaraman6856]

@@harsh3391 want to learn hindustani help me...

[@maheshjayaraman6856]

Ketaki julab juhi champak ban foolae..

[@harsh3391]

@@maheshjayaraman6856 I myself an amateur singer...My singing is very naive. Maybe you should approach a tutor, that could definitely help. Happy learning 👍

[@krishnakrrish578]

Being a carnatic music student from 3 4 years, if u feel bored of carnatic raagas or music , its clear that u haven't understood the actual raaga bhava or beauty of Gamakas and its usage even I am working on that to make sure it sounds better 😊

[@deepanagaraj8764]

I am a small time carnatic music teacher who tries to learn more along with teaching students.......Sometimes students are good and ready to learn, but the parents who don't know and are not exposed to Carnatic music field are just impatient and want their wards to show off to their friends or relatives their singing skills and so keep pressurizing teachers to teach songs in short time.....I do not want to bring out caste issue here, but yes they do matter when it comes to respecting this Carnatic music field and how different and divine as compared to the film songs....But when the families watch the music reality shows where children are singing, they just want their children to be on that stage fast as possible....They just don't understand that many of the children who sing on these stage shows and popular playback singers are Carnatically trained and it takes years and loads of patience for them to be there!!

[@shikharverma1661]

Very true sir caste is important as highly specialised arts like music and dances are preserved only by heredity others people are prone to market manipulation. ❤️🙏🏻

[@mohamedthayath9411]

May be boring to hear, but much much soothing to the mind.... that's make's it supernatural.

[@rocky49able]

A true music lover likes every type of music.

[@Anish20778]

From Nepal ! Have closely followed carnatic and hindustani music. Avid admirer of carnatic music.

[@mohanakumarannair7971]

Karnatic music is boring when structure and analysis exeeds aesthetic limits, excess circus and acrobatics kills the ' bhava;' or transcendaendal mood of raagas, but exceptions are there like the rendering by m,d ramanathan etc,

[@umavijay7677]

Thanks for this video. My daughter learning carnatic music and sometime I heard the same from her. This video helps alot.

[@maheshjayaraman6856]

Hindustani is more difficult than carnatic

[@aswanth2789]

I really interested in carnatic music because it is listening very beautiful.Sometimes this taking to another beautiful world 💕❣️

[@natarajaniyer6748]

Thanks ma'am for encouraging video. It keeps me boosting. The MUSIC is my passion. As you said correctly, i enjoy my journey.

[@AK-be9gn]

Carnatic is the most beautiful thing that i have ever seen ❤

[@jyothivaradarajan3962]

Currently I am learning music online from a teacher in our neighborhood.He teaches the nuances patiently.So now I am enjoying the learning.

[@preeeethvi]

I find Hindustani boring lmao

[@nishavasudevan]

Yes that happened with me and i switched to hindustani music and never got bored again. I think each person has their own preferences. Many people don't like hindustani music but karnatic they love

[@monishwaran5206]

❤

[@SA-op2uz]

Hey prathiba.. I learnt carnatic music for almost 7 years during my 7th to 12th std.. But i took that as lightly.. Classes were for 2 days.. And that was a mere extra curricular for me.. I did sing in skl choir.. But its been 8 yrs now.. I'm completely out of practise.. I think I need to refresh everything I learnt and also I didn't learn about these swaras and ragas, singing ragas much during my classes.. I could hardly identify swaras Or ragas and i need to improve on gamakas .. I'm in between, not a raw beginner and not an expert.. Which bundle of course should I try to get on line again

[@VoxGuru]

Great to know you wanna get back to practice! You could explore either the voice culture combo or the beginners bundle. It would be a good brush up before you take more advanced lessons.

[@bhalajisubramanian2282]

mam what is mean by gamakas?

[@narayanans2636]

I love both Carnatic and Hindustani music. the problem however is that the general expectation is that you need to know the nuances to enjoy the music. Without any knowledge of nuaances, one can enjoy, film music, a movie, or a Tv show. However, it gets a little bit difficult to watch carnatic music is that you seem lesser off, if you do not match beat for beat with the musicians. That seems an implicit expectation in a Sabha audience. Second problem is relatability, for common audience. This I am saying as a regular visitor to many concerts both carnatic and hidustani

[@malaradhakrishnani8822]

During my school days I cursed the shopwala adjacent to my house for his free broadcast of A I R Nilaya Vidvangal performance during noons [only alapana - endless ]. I was a big zero. It took years for me to know that a nice song will follow those 'thadharinna's - when I had an opportunity to attend a stage performance. That was a old story now. Thanks to Social media.

[@jyothivaradarajan3962]

Wow! You read my mind exactly. As a child ,some 55 years ago,my parents insisted on my learning carnatic music.I used to resist it saying , “ it is always sasa riri gaga”.Instead I used to enjoy Bollywood movie songs. Of course the current day facilities for learning music ( Carnatic or Bollywood songs) were not available then. Now I am 64 years old and I have the interest as well as the time to learn music. I find your channel immensely useful and interesting. I am sure there are many more like me.Thank you

[@Radhakrishnan-yz9sp]

Very useful

[@faridnassiry7935]

Goodfor us.

[@revaansh108]

The only music that is left with some genuine Bhartiyata is Carnatic Music of Southern India. I just love it 🙏😇

[@sridharpatrachari4163]

Sorry Carnatic Music is not boring. People either have not heard or understood it. It's a divine music. It's rather very sad that you term it as boring.

[@deepanagaraj8764]

This is known as clickbait!!! To get more views, put that kind of title....

[@musicworship4520]

who says it's boring? People who say this are the most boring people, in my experience.

[@castafioreomg]

Karnatic music is sounding boring or over the top or even comical sometimes because the of the artists.There are pritams and then Rahman's in the music world.Over emphasis on technique kills the art.And conveyed the right energy or emotion in a song is important.A bhakti song should not be sung like an aggressive way as if depicting a war scene.

[@vigneshsubramanian2511]

Lol I see where you are coming from but no one sings bhakti songs aggresively.

[@ganeshsadasivam1317]

Namaskaram madam, I want to express my views on Carnatic Music. It is not boring at all. It is not necessary yo understand Carnatic Music, but we can definitely enjoy it provided the musicians render it with Jeevan.

[@satyareddy248]

How can I identify my vocal scale,i am a lot of confuse about it ma'am, please suggest me how can I identify.

[@devangel007]

yh i dont think carnatic music is boring. not every carnatic song i would say is for me but i rly do like carnatic in general. i think this goes for all genres of music. ppl dont like hard rock but there is definitely one song they will like. this is basic understanding. i do have a genre i prefer most but i listen to every genre. it's what i think is pleasing to my ears. to each their own tho.

[@Abhinavgaming203]

Mam can you do video on how total carnatic are long means from beginnings end like a flow chart I hope u will answer to my comment .Thank you mam for this video ,help me a lot from this video

[@sivaguru1133]

I'm a carnatic vocal teacher in Malaysia. You're tips are very useful to me. Thanks

[@vaniviswanathan379]

Very nice encouraging tips. I liked it how you said - Challenging!!! Challenge accepted 👍

[@funkynie]

🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@ramachandranbalasubramania4826]

Carnatic might be boring because you are reluctant to learn the nuances of it

[@lisabon1343]

Is beautiful, what they are talking about.

[@vasudevannair7598]

Learn film songs based on classical ragas

[@BadassBikerOwns]

I strongly feel that there needs to be an intermediary between professional Carnatic singers and common people. Otherwise people don't get exposed and have no interest in ragas, talas, etc. In my case, singing bhajans in religious centers gave me the interest in classical Indian music.

[@SanthoshNarayanan007]

Carnatic music is my passion❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@navniitpanwanr1732]

Krnatak music is sweet lu listen and saregama to

[@CharukesiArunraj]

Wonderful mam 😊🙏❤

[@punarvasu1000]

Very useful tips indeed!

[@thasmaikv1787]

Thank you so much ma'am

[@sivaguru1133]

👍🙏

[@somnathmaharana3171]

Pranam

[@thasmaikv1787]

Hi ma'am

[@kanikagautam8545]

Hello ma'am..I've been following your channel for long.. I am a student of hindustani music..but very interested in caranatic music also .. I've a query ..I want to know about THAYAM style .. I've heard this word in a video raag kalyani thillana of Shri Balmurlikrishna Ji . Infact thayam was the style of his singing in that thillana I guess.. Can any caranatic learner tell me about THAYAM..??🙏🏻

[@Nandakii]

You mean Thanam?

[@kanikagautam8545]

@@Nandakii Sir Thayam was written in the description of video ...but may be you are correct ..may be they had made a mistake .. But yes it was some style of Shri Balmurlikrishna where the raag is kalyani but it sounds different raga at some specific place.. It will be highly great if you can tell me about this 🙏🏻

[@Nandakii]

@@kanikagautam8545 because I don't think there is something called Thayam. Thanam is a part of Mano dharma sangitam, (improvisational music) It's quite close to Drupad in Hindustani music. It's usually of the syllables Tha, Nam, Nom. Thus the name. It's usually sung after a long Alapana called Ragam, and is followed by a Pallavi (usually a one line composition) together known as Ragam Thanam Pallavi (rtp). Hope that helps.

[@Nandakii]

Or perhaps you mean Thaya Ragamalika, the form unique to BMK. That is when the Raga remains the same, but some minute phrases from different Ragas are included in the rendering.

[@kanikagautam8545]

@@Nandakii thanks a ton sir ..means a lot I want to know what is that thing due to which one raga sounds like different ragas..you must have heard the thillan of raga kalyani by Shri Balmurlikrishna ..can you help me with that 🙏🏻

[@bigyaniparajuli6357]

❤️

[@siddhantpaswan1158]

Hindi me learn kraiye ma'am Hamko English nahi aati hai Please ma'am🙏🙏🙏

[@navniitpanwanr1732]

Unko hindii nhi aati

[@tanmaygusain1316]

South Indian audience zyada hogi..

[@deepanagaraj8764]

You learn English

[@manivelsahayam9871]

i found you people pronouncing re(ray) as ree weird-with all due respect as i am a south indian living in Australia i find hindi film songs more melodious than carnatic music-also there is such a variety of music in hindustani music. Also i have noticed that you Pratibha do not respond to either my or others comments.

[@Nandakii]

Music is music, sir. Carnatic and Hindustani are unique and beautiful in their own ways. Some may like CM, some may like HM. Depends on the person. If you do not like Carnatic music, you may very well stop watching and commenting irrelevant and unnecessary comments on Carnatic music sir, with all due respect.

[@karanliya7056]

It makes more sense to pronounce it as 'ree' because the name of the note is 'rishabh'