Learning a 1000+ year old style of singing (ft. Archana)

Check out Archana: linktr.ee/arch...
PRE-SAVE WILD ONE: distrokid.com/...
SUBSCRIBE and hit that bell: bit.ly/2OgWtuA
SUPPORT my videos on Patreon: bit.ly/MKRsupport
FOLLOW ME ON SPOTIFY: spoti.fi/2ReBgph
MERCH: shopmalinda.com
Follow me on:
Twitter @missmalindakat / missmalindakat
Facebook / malindakathleenreese
Instagram @missmalindakat / missmalindakat
TikTok @malindamusic / malindamusic
Edited by Ethan Treiman
For fan mail:
3430 Connecticut Ave NW PO Box 11855
Washington DC 20008
*EQUIPMENT*
(all links are affiliate links, so if you buy from here you support me too!)
AUDIO
For singing: amzn.to/2wwYXRo
For vlogging: amzn.to/2wyQfSE
A great start mic: amzn.to/2xhkScb
Interface: amzn.to/2fAxFyM
VIDEO
Camera: amzn.to/2hi08JS
Lens: amzn.to/2fABZ14
Vlog camera: amzn.to/2xnN4vT
I use Logic and Final Cut Pro to edit audio and video respectively :)
THANK YOU PATRONS!!
Archivy
Christian Ashby
Ed Banas
Russ Billings
Caleb Bukowsky
Heather BookCat
Zach Brandon
Bree Campbell
Cinnder
Douglas Charles
Will & Sheila Cole
James Copple
Mariah Dierking
Fr. Joe Fessenden
The Fishers
Mariah Fyock-Williams
Mimi Ginsburg
Marlo Delfin Gonzales
Brent Goldberg
Oi Gromit
Pippa Hillebrand
Jonathan Isip
Joseph K.
Dave Jones
Rita K
Kinetic Dreams Studios
Balazs Kis
Sam Knetsch
Raphael Lauterbach
Alex Molloy
Geoffrey Morgan
Eystein Nicolaysen
Barnabas Nelson
Rachel-Maya RC
Jeannene Mironack
Paul Murray
Barnabas Nelson
Derek Ramm
P.S.
Katie Palen
Richard Prout
Jeff Schwarz
Alexis Sullivan
Lisa Stark
Mary Hall Surface
Tom
Theodore Ts'o
Hank van Deventer
Reinier van Grieken
David Vollbracht
Sam Waller
Pete Warchol
Zane

[@0arjun077]

Sadja : Sa : Cry of the peacock Rishabha : Re : Lowing of the bull Gaandhaara : Ga : Bleating of a goat Madhyama : Ma : Call of the heron Panchama : Pa : Call of the cuckoo Dhaivata : Dha : Neighing of the horse Nishaada : Ni : Trumpeting of the elephant Meanings : Sa is derived from Shadja which means 'giving birth to six'. Re is derived from Rishabha which means ‘Great One’ Ga is derived from Gandhar which means ‘sweet fragrance’ Ma derived from Madhyama which means ‘being in the middle’ Pa is derived from Panchama which means ‘the fifth note’ Dha is derived from Dhaivata which means ‘sixth note/divine’ Ni is derived from Nishad which means an ‘seventh note’ also ‘setting at rest’, ‘esoteric doctrine’, ‘secret doctrine’, ‘mysterious or mystical’ Singing the Swaras has a positive effect on the body, mind and the consciousness. The swaras also effect our feelings and emotions. The swaras are also associated with planets and colours ‘sa’ (shadjam) - Mercury - green ‘ri’ (rishabham) - Mars - red ‘ga’ (gandharam) - Sun - golden colour ‘ma’ (madhyam) - Moon - white or yellowish tint ‘pa’ (panchamam) - Saturn - blue or black dha’ (dhaivatam) - Jupiter - yellow ‘ni’ (nishadham) - Venus - multi colour Qualities of the Svara Shadja - Means 'father of the six svaras' and the one which gives birth to the other six svaras. Rishab - Being the nearest to the Grâmni svara (Sa) it is strong as Vrishab (Bull). Gandhâr ­ Is associated with karunâ (sadness, longing). Madyam ­ This svara is in the middle of the saptak. Pancham ­ Is made up of the words panch (five) and mi (to measure). Is that note that is fifth from the Shadaj and is the tool to measure the svara intervals. Dhaivat ­ Is the overtone of the madyam svara and is heard by the Dhivân (sensitive minds). Nishâd ­ Is so called because the notes of the scale come to a close with it. The word is derived from Sanskrit root “ni+shâd” to come to a rest. Nishâd is full of karunâ (longing)

[@JustFiddler]

matur suksma

[@vasanthasrikantha6512]

rishaba means bull

[@averages64]

Thank you 🙏

[@PLad-pr9cl]

Thank you so much🤗 ***🌼🏵🌸🌹🌹🌹🌸🏵🌼*** I've heard the word karuna, defined with a meaning close to love, fraternity (love for all and everything, infinite love): I'm wondering if it is the same word, and if I remember well?

[@0arjun077]

@@PLad-pr9cl yes its the same Sanskrit word but meaning is slightly different yet the same here, Karuṇā (Sanskrit: करुणा) is generally translated as compassion or mercy and sometimes as self-compassion or spiritual longing. It is a significant spiritual concept in the Indic religions of Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, and Jainism.

[@meerasomasundaram8564]

Being a south Indian who's been forced into carnatic singing just like every other child here. I immedialty had like a blast from the past without even realised i started singing along and went on the next 20 having a whole concert with myself

[@avibcci1297]

I was smiling throughout the video, not from south but my parents too forced me to learn carnatic singing 😂 and I am glad that they did.

[@martisbvk]

How the fuck is Karnatic music based on Sanskrit? Halegannada is fucking Sanskrit now.

[@honestbrahm]

The idea one builds in their head that they were “forced” is what has led to decline of Bharahiya culture unfortunately

[@siamesevodka]

​@@martisbvk Carnatic might have started out as being in Halegannada but people like Purandara Daasa composed in incredibly Sanskritised Kannada.

[@siamesevodka]

@@honestbrahm Preach all you like but enrolling your children in classes without asking them if that's what they want to do is wrong. Even if you are deadset on your children learning, say, Carnatic music, at least give them some choice. I for one despised singing Carnatic... if my parents had at least asked me if I wanted to do something else Carnatic-related I would have told them immediately that I would have preferred to learn the veena or mridanga instead. But no, because immigrant parents foist their expectations upon their children...

[@igormitin1989]

By now I strongly believe that Malinda is getting herself ready for timetravel with these traditional singing styles so she can blend in easily in the past

[@chiyahoskere]

this is still a widely used style of singing in south india and many many who dedicate their lives towards it

[@sushi6368]

There is a huge platform for Carnatic music in India. Chennai, TN, in south india is the hub for it! An entire month is dedicated for the Carnatic music where artists perform in various performing arts centres across the city. This is one of the most interesting and challenging form of art. If you ask someone learning international art forms in music, this will be the top of their list! Just cuz something is not marketed so much doesn’t make it ancient or lessen it’s value. Kinda sad to see such a comment.

[@rairadio7119]

She can use it in future too, as India continues to keep it's clothes and music with full gusto.

[@irishsamurai9008]

I think she is preparing for the future. She will become one of our ambassadors when aliens land

[@shoutg]

some touch of mysticism in the singing

[@everydaypatriot1083]

Anyone who claims "appropriation" is sadly mistaken. To appreciate the art of other cultures is to honor it.

[@ge5493]

preach

[@emma-di5ly]

Exactly. Archana wouldn't have said to try it if she believed it to be appropriation.

[@shrutivashishth541]

Carnatic is traditional Hindu music- performed in the glory of our Gods. Non hindus are not allowed to perform it. It’s not mere appropriation, it is outright abuse of our religious beliefs. Know better.

[@keithhunt5328]

Appropriation is when when white women shout racist slurs at Indian people and then wear swastika earrings and say Namaste to each other while doing yoga

[@stuthijha2994]

@@shrutivashishth541 where does it say that theyre not allowed to perform. you need to do your research before opening your mouth and actually touch grass cause thousands of non indians have immense talent in this filed

[@scylla1772]

Imagine her singing something like Chinese opera. So many wildly different musical traditions to try!!

[@mayochupenjoyer]

now i really want to see that, along with maybe swedish and arab singing!

[@solvated_photon]

A lot of westerners probably won’t take Beijing Opera seriously at first though

[@kukuandkookie]

That was one of my first thoughts too! Chinese opera is such a rich aspect of Chinese culture, it would be really cool to see her try some of the singing techniques! Like besides Beijing opera, there’s also Kunqu and Sichuan opera and so on and so forth. 👀 Of course, it can also be very off-putting for some people who aren’t used to it, but with Yunjin from Genshin Impact and various songs that use Chinese opera techniques, I feel like it’s helped normalize it for some. Speaking of those songs though, since I know just how hard it can be getting into Chinese music when you don’t speak/read Chinese, I’ll leave some of the songs that incorporate Chinese opera into them below!: • kzbin.info/www/bejne/o2fQeouXma9pmaM • kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z2nPqoSlhb2hZrs • kzbin.info/www/bejne/r2mVq35ve5WLfaM • kzbin.info/www/bejne/r5zUm5ikZctlpLs • kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZpzHn4ieeMt2g9k • kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4TCdWNto7plrdE (this one’s actually a song for a cartoon inspired by Beijing opera!) • kzbin.info/www/bejne/mXWahHmdZbCMZtU (this one’s got the instruments yet less of the vocals but it’s from a drama focused on Beijing opera, and the drama itself includes a few scenes of characters singing for the opera!) • kzbin.info/www/bejne/j4aVn6ababSbm5o (and ahhh Zhou Shen’s voice really is angelic… This isn’t even the first time he’s tried Chinese opera, as he’s also sung it here!: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oGWThWarjcl6a7s ) • And of course, I’d be remiss if I didn’t include Yunjin’s song: kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5CpXn5-i6mCedE I’m sure there’s more out there, but these were the ones I grabbed off the top of my head. I’ve gotten a lot more into Chinese media (donghua, manhua , cdramas, music etc) lately, and gufeng (ancient style-inspired Chinese music) is some of my favourite genres to listen to. It’s kind of why I have these songs; I enjoy collecting things into resources and then compiling lists of references/recommendations for newcomers to Chinese media. 😆 So yeah, sorry for the extreme enthusiasm, but I really do think it would be cool if Malinda tried Chinese opera! Otherwise, hey, at least I compiled some really nice music for people to stumble across ahaha. 💕

[@mattbuszko]

@@kukuandkookie It's refreshing to read your enthusiasm and passion for Chinese performing arts. As a westerner, I had a similar experience with Vietnamese (and to a lesser extent Chinese) music. It's "other-ness" was a big barrier to entry initially. Now, it moves me deeply, especially the older, more traditional stuff. Music is amazing

[@Amaiguri]

@@solvated_photon Fair but it's so beautiful, everyone ought to try it at least twice

[@pissupehelwan]

For Westerners and non-Indians: both Carnatic and Hindustani (the 2 different forms of Indian Classical music) are very much contemporary. They have ancient origins but both are taught, learnt and performed in the current day and age. There are plenty of concerts both in India and abroad where Indian Classical music lovers can and do go and enjoy just like you have concerts for Western Classical music.

[@aryaleelamisra4407]

i have grown up learning hindustani classical music which is the other form of traditional indian singing and it makes me very happy for my culture being shown on ur channel!

[@miayana2539]

I'm Indian and the title made me super emotional. I've been following Melinda since her Google translate sings days and the Irish singing video was one of my favourites. So to see her explore my culture's traditional style of singing makes me so happy :)

[@briansgamesandanime]

It's so amazing to hear traditional carnatic music integrated with Western pop. It's just more proof how music is a universal language. I thoroughly enjoyed learning about this style. 🥰

[@marilouhuille4578]

You might like Susheela Raman ! She does that with such talent 💖

[@briansgamesandanime]

@@marilouhuille4578 thanks🥰

[@AlexXPandian]

@@briansgamesandanime Someone called Ilaiayaraaja has been doing this for decades, and in a genre defining way. Probably 500+ songs to choose from but here is one : kzbin.info/www/bejne/faivnWt9nK6jeJo

[@luna6975]

You should listen to Shuba! She does this in her songs

[@briansgamesandanime]

@@luna6975 thanks I will☺️

[@lauren3173]

I was apprehensive of watching this video for so long. I am adopted from India. I was adopted into a white family in midwestern America. I have spent my whole life trying to connect with my culture and figure out how I fit into it. Learning about something so deep and meaningful to my culture has always been intimidating and somewhat isolating. But I want to do it so badly. This video means so much to me because it’s like having a friend here to support me. Someone familiar to learn along with me. Thank you Malinda! ❤

[@artarmour7914]

Hey

[@Amuzic]

6:58 that Sun coming out was so apt. Because the Raga Archana is singing here is equivalent to Raga Bhairabhi in North Indian Hindustani classic. The name literally meaning something to be sung at Bhor(Dawn or morning). Yeah, Archana left out the most beautiful aspect of Indian Ragas. They are closely related to time of the day and the environment and the mood.

[@TheCosmicNote]

Very true. Raag Bhairavi is such a beautiful rag, so Komal and it’s perfect for mornings.

[@supriyamallaya8452]

It’s not Bhairavi. It’s Raaga Mayamalavagowla which is equal to Raag Bhairav not Bhairavi in Hindustani

[@blueberrymuffin4921]

@@supriyamallaya8452 yea the first ragam learned is mayamalavagoula

[@Amuzic]

@@supriyamallaya8452 i didn't say it is. As I am not aware of Carnatic Ragas. But, it did sound similar to Bhairavi in Hindustani. Thanks for illuminating.

[@yamiyugi3871]

I am not Indian, however I really find Carnatic singing kind of hypnotic and super interesting! It’s so irresistible to listen to!

[@siamesevodka]

This is very cool. I too was 'forced' to learn Carnatic music as a young immigrant boy, I appreciate it now a lot more than I did then! Really looking forward to the next one in this series, Malinda, I loved the Sean Nos video a few months back too. Edit: something not mentioned by Archana in the video is that there aren't just different kinds of raagas but different varieties of talas (the beat they played with their hands). This one is the Adi tala, the first tala any student learns.

[@KainYusanagi]

She did mention that it's the first form that is taught specifically that she's doing here, though.

[@siamesevodka]

@@KainYusanagi Oh I don't think I was paying attention, I thought she was referring to the raaga she sang in being the first one you learn... oops.

[@spdcrzy]

The thing is, after a while growing up, pop gets boring. And I went back to Indian classical LOL.

[@HybridCalisthenics]

Saw this video pop up on my feed. Sounding great as usual, Malinda!

[@ativerc]

Hey man, nice to see you here. Your videos help out everyday. Have a nice day.

[@lornilula4213]

aye Hampton!

[@scientia.veritas]

Weird seeing you here. Worlds colliding!

[@preet2692]

Wow, Hampton, didn't imagine I'd see you here! 😊

[@meret99]

Archana’s speaking and singing voices are so different....she just transforms magically when she sings!💖

[@elitzapetrova3768]

And also confirm as another comment says (about Slavic music), in Bulgaria, which is where I originally come from, there exists a traditional singing rich of extra long female voice sounds that produce a mystic effect on the human mind. One song particularly, "Izlel e Delio haidutin", has been included in the Voyager Golden record launched in the space in 1977.

[@amylee6585]

Oh god I've wanted to learn Carnatic and Hindustani for the longest time! Glad to see that someone trained mainly in the Western style (like me!) try it

[@chiyahoskere]

i’d suggest that you don’t try both because your voice would need to be properly conditioned for both styles and they’re both very distinct. having learnt carnatic my whole life i cannot bring life to a hindustani based song because of the way my voice was shaped strictly to carnatic styles.

[@BodybuilderKingViky]

Try Hindustani (Northern) classical music first because our scales are much easier and quite equivalent to Western scales and we don't engage in microtonal or quartertone music immediately. The south Indian music style is a little more complex and tougher to learn straight away.

[@benjaminbennington213]

"Mongolian Throat Singing" This would be really cool to hear you try out

[@djordjepejic864]

Yes! I came here just to say this 😁😁😁

[@tomcline5631]

It's almost like the notes go flat slightly,almost into a minor. Fascinating scale! Our band director tried to explain this to us but I never got it! This was in the mid 80s in Missouri,so not a lot of resources available. So cool!

[@leo_ryda-81]

It is sort of a "minor scale"; if we put the basic carnatic scale that she sang into western notation, it would be C C# E F G G# B C (if C were the key)

[@sahanaashvin1573]

The scale always changes based on the raagam! Youd be surprised.

[@alcurtis93]

It has a Phrygian/ Phrygian dominant feel

[@Cardsmaster]

This is so beautiful. How art brings two people together. The willingness to learn. Every culture has treasures to be learned.

[@StephanieV04]

Can you do an episode on Slavic traditional folk singing and Scandinavian folk singing? I know there are probably better terms but I mean the music from Slavic and Scandinavian countries like Poland, Belarus, Bulgaria, Sweden, the faroe islands, Iceland etc. Also an episode on native people's traditional music would be very interesting as well.

[@thedanishcatgirl3205]

Yes that would be so cool. Maybe old Norse singing. I have always loved my Viking heritage and I know that there are people who not only know how to speak old Norse but also sing it.

[@thedanishcatgirl3205]

Or maybe Kulning which is an ancient Swedish type of herdingcall. I remember watching a video with it and it sounded very magical

[@weronikamusia1113]

Yes! I also wanted to write a comment and suggest the Slavic technique of the 'white voice'! I'm learning to sing it myself and would love to see Malinda's view on it

[@ventisupremacist6965]

as a slav , I would literally love that so much

[@joermnyc]

Bulgarian would be cool, I’m pretty sure it’s one everyone knows because it was used for the choir vocals in Xena: Warrior Princess.

[@ASentientBlockofSwissCheese]

Omg as a student of Carnatic music I’m so glad you appreciated and explored it. It’s a beautiful tradition and a part of my heart. Thank you so much for this, Melinda.

[@phantaphil]

If I could communicate with trees If I could tame the seven seas If I could conduct each storm and breeze I would compose an earthwide song For all living beings to humm along All birds, all whales together singing Just one simple melody, harmony bringing Soothing mankind's ignorance and rage Allowing the planet to enter a new age This age of euphony will heal the world As I said, if I could I would write what I heard

[@yasco.]

that’s so beautiful 😍 where’s it from? did you write it yourself?

[@phantaphil]

@@yasco. Yes, I wrote this myself. Thank you so much!

[@Amaranthine56]

This is very beautiful!!Keep it up 💓

[@phantaphil]

@@Amaranthine56 Thank you so much 💜 I will 😊

[@mikaelafox6106]

I know people who can communicate with trees.

[@thewierd_thewonderful996]

She says it's all nasal. But being a South indian myself who was trained in carnatic, i think we are discouraged from using the nose a lot while singing. It's a mix of both, we use the nose but we don't solely use the nose.

[@sathyak7814]

Actually, my teacher forbade to use nose but instead to let the sound originate from the abdomen.

[@ninnusridhar]

I grew up learning the mridhangan(the traditional percussion accompaniment for a carnatic song), so this theory hit so close to my own experiences. Great job Mel

[@sinimeg]

This is such a cool idea for a series, this is the kind of thing that I would have liked to be taught in high school in the music class. This first video was so cool and interesting, loved it

[@keerthanas4144]

As an Indian, I'm so glad that one of my fav singers from the US does a Collab with an Indian artist.. I'm sure all the other Indians are feeling the same 😭

[@rutvikrs]

Nope. Some of us are not happy with bringing Carnatic to the west. The West has had a brutal history of digesting music and then denigrating the culture. Jazz, Blues, even Hindustani in the 70's and today Latino thrived when it's progenitors were relegated and the source culture was denigrated. They will do the same to Carnatic. I am not a traditionalist by any stretch of imagination, but this is one of the cases where it needs to be retained in temples.

[@keerthanas4144]

@@rutvikrs .... Dude it's Malinda we're talking about. I'm really glad that Indian style of music is being recognised by the world! What happened in the past has already happened and the world changed a lot since the 70s. If you read the comments in this video you'll see how much some of the foreigners liked this style and how curious they are to learn about the culture. And yes I wouldn't want that to happen to Carnatic especially since I've learnt it in my younger days. But I Believe the world has changed a lot since the 70s and that history would never repeat again

[@rutvikrs]

@@keerthanas4144 1. My comment does not have to do with the content creator, but the audience and the way the artforms have been used, absorbed and discarded by the west. To say that this stopped in the 70's is not true. It's happening with Latino culture right now. A contemporary Indian example is the way Yoga is being twisted that even I feel uncomfortable(a philosophy of self reliance on bodily level now is a commercialized product with India, the source of the knowledge making zero money and zero authority over its own tradition). All this while being disabused of our concerns. Meanwhile there is a silent attack on "Indianness" of yoga both on the academic and cultural spheres. 2. Indians particularly seem to have this penchant that a bunch of people enjoying the artform equates to elevation of the artform internationally. We substitute this "foreign acceptance" for our lack of confidence in our own culture. The art form due to its nature will never be for the masses, it will be for institutions to make this American and then trash it. 3. I am not saying people should not practice the artform or even that it's Indian in perpetuity, all I am asking for is the source to have credit and authority over its evolution just the way it happens with western artforms, food and culture. Otherwise the day is not far when Indians have to learn Carnatic at Berklee, just the way "Indology" died and became "South Asian studies" with its locus at Yale.

[@rohinikayal4440]

agreed

[@Ermude10]

@@rutvikrs Hm, I personally don't like that way of thinking. Might be that I don't fully understand the cultural significance of this type of singing, but I think there's something sad about hindering traditional artforms from evolving with the passage of time. It's not like Jazz, Blues, western classical music, latin music and other genres evolved from nothing. They also evolved by building upon previous traditions. And they're still practiced in the same or similar way to the old traditions, albeit not in the mainstream and by most musicians. EDIT: Aha, just read your second post. > I am not saying people should not practice the artform or even that it's Indian in perpetuity, all I am asking for is the source to have credit and authority over its evolution I can sympathise with that a bit more. To be honest, I think any artform will sooner or later be adopted outside of its traditional settings. The only way for "its source" to influence its evolution is then to actually be the main driver of teaching and spreading the artform so that "outsiders" don't misappropriate it, but that rather let the traditional practitioners adopt outside influence to evolve the art.

[@arjun_ragafanatic]

I really appreciate this take on a music very close to my heart. Unfortunately it's the case that we only have so much time to talk much about it. So I thought I'd take some time to add a few things that may interest people here. 1. Carnatic music is not a "1000 years old". It is not an ossified system that has been "preserved" since antiquity. It is a living breathing, and continuously evolving incarnation of the musical ideas that have risen in the vast land of India over millenia. With the exception of passages taken out of Hindu scripture, all the greatest compositions today date back to the 17th to 18th century. There are older compositions which we have unfortunately lost the melodies of. This music is still very much evolving incorporating the diversity of styles from across India. 2. Archana has described a raga very beautifully. It is a feeling. If you take a set of melodic phrases that "feel right" together and convey some emotional idea, you have a raga. Make no mistake, this is not a concept unique to Indian music. Arabic music has it, even western music. We simply have a dedicated system to study this 3. I have to disagree with the voice thing. Like with any music there are a variety of voices. It is completely incorrect to claim that all singers sing in a frontal manner. I personally like to switch it up when I sing. The human voice is really flexible and can create stunning sounds when explored. Carnatic music makes use of Chest, throat, and head resonances and a lot more. no falsetto is used however. 4. Regarding quarter tones.... I understand that there's a lot of academic interest in this as it is unfamiliar to wester audiences. However IMHO the best way of looking at this is through the lens of emotion. Quarter tones are used ALL THE TIME in western music, they're just not called so. I've heard them consistently in blues and country music. All of those vocal flourishes that convey that extra punch of feeling typically involve a microtone. Western Classical violinists use microtones to add more "feeling" quite often. So in summary, quarter notes are not the "basis" for the music, emotion is. When I learn a scale, there is no guide other than what my teacher sings and what it makes me feel. If you want to learn the music, it's easier if you feel it out than if you think about the microtones. 5. Ornamentations define the music. They are not "optional". The very identity of many ragas is borne out in the way the notes are ornamented. In-fact the word Ornamentation is a bit of a misnomer. In Carnatic music, the word "swara" (closest concept to a note) refers to a moving body of sound and not a specific frequency. E.g. Sa being flat and Re being an oscillation around Sa in the raga gowla. Again, the best way to internalize these things is to listen, feel, and practice.

[@MysticHeather]

Your comment is super enlightening thank you for sharing!! As someone w a cultural and lived history w bluegrass music I can totally see what you mean about the quarter notes

[@harihp7]

I've learned carnatic music for about 10 years and it was fun watching u learn it^^ Archana has a very beautiful voice and she couldn't have explained it any better... thanku for the lovely video❤️

[@purpleworm4725]

I really like the part where you tried to learn carnatic way of singing, because when Archana just showed some examples I really couldn't wrap my brain around how it is done. Like normally when I hear a brief melody I can repeat it. But here my brain was just stuck and my mind was blown :)

[@edwardspencer9397]

For how difficult it truly is.. try these 2 videos. This is Kaushiki Chakraborty when she was a little girl trained by her father kzbin.info/www/bejne/bGfSqqOvoJZ5ftU. This is when Kaushiki is an adult and is a legend herself kzbin.info/www/bejne/q3bUiq2ar5iNrMk The notes you are hearing are usually sa re ga ma pa and permutations and combinations of these. pa ma ga re ma, pa re ga ma dha.. and so on.

[@purpleworm4725]

@@edwardspencer9397 3:06 in the second video - OMG how?!?!?! :O

[@diverseindia6397]

@@purpleworm4725 she belongs from a very famous family in music. She is grand daughter of an Indian legend. They are purely in classical music. If you want to listen a bollywood singer whose back ground is classical music but they sing other styles too then I'm dropping two links ( first one is consist of a high note C#6 which is not a head voice ) Second one is semi classical, checkout both and then give your opinion I'll be glad to read your review. kzbin.info/www/bejne/n5eum4FuoJ2rnMk - female singer kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZzafZ1oodOge80 - male singer

[@AshNight1214]

I would LOVE to hear how the traditional Kagoshima/Okinawan style of Japanese singing is created. I love the sound but can’t figure out how to make it happen

[@isabellamelendez4424]

I feel the same way!

[@boardmsr]

When Archana starts singing just the basic Sa Re Ga Ma, it seems so magical..

[@TheOne-ix6qc]

As a person who is learning North Indian classical singing, I'm fascinated by the Carnatic music. Just so amazing!

[@aananya6106]

Singers are truly something different... I took absolutely ages to learn how much Malinda learnt in the span of this video, and their singing legit gave me chills and goosebumps. So good.

[@howHumam]

I don't usually enjoy hardcore traditional Indian singing, but this really helped me understand what's going on. I am grateful to learn, and can't wait to see where this series goes.

[@psychadelicpotato8580]

Once you understand the minute nuances, science and it's principals, you'll start appreciating it even more. I used to not enjoy it much in the past, but since I began training I began viewing it with much more respect and awe.

[@842king9]

This concept is an absolutely great idea! I'm loving learning how artists are celebrating their traditional music and carrying it forward! So important! I love seeing it! Be still my heart! 🤍

[@pendragon2012]

Malinda you are a national (and international) treasure! I love how you're highlighting all the different cultures and traditions! Beauty will save the world!

[@vaamikasharma]

I'm so glad this is going to be a series because music really does transcends cultures and languages. Also Archana seems like such a great teacher!

[@sm_artx]

I love both Hindustani and Carnatic styles of music. However, the quarter tones are the ones that give me goosebumps every time I hear Carnatic music.

[@chillsahoy2640]

Being part Spanish, I'd be very curious to see you dissect and expertiment with traditional Spanish music, especially considering any Arabic influences it may have incorporated! I wonder how it differs from other Mediterranean musical styles from countries that did not spend 800 years under Arab control, whether that had any effect on the instrumentation or chords that are used.

[@mar1na1993]

I am half spanish, too, and would love to learn more about the flamenco style of singing - what makes it unique, etc.

[@gadeaiglesiassordo716]

I'm Spanish and I was actually thinking not about flamenco but about the singing techniques involved in singing jotas (traditional music from northern Spain)

[@LucaAnamaria]

This would be awesome. I am not Spanish, but my soul is at least partly so. 😜

[@lll2282]

Indian music got no arab influences but arabs do have indian influences

[@luzyfuerza101]

You know, the he gitanos originally derived from India, do you notice any similarity in this singing and their singing? :-)

[@aalaworks]

As an Indian really feels proud to see video abt carnatic music. Thanks... And you Archana you really talented.thanks.. And all your songs are good

[@jude.niranjan]

This is a good Indian and a true Hindu I suppose. Good vibe and good character are so much more important than puritanism and bigotry.

[@MyRx777z]

It's really interesting....listening to India's ancient singing has that humming and nasally type of gesture, reaction, or emotion involved in it. In Asia, Vietnamese and Chinese's ancient singing has that same vocal emotion too.

[@azainkadri9556]

It's not this nasal or humming traditionally. It's the way she specifically sings.

[@MyRx777z]

@@azainkadri9556 , did you see her expression with her hands? She pointed the sound, vocal, or focus gathered in one spot and that is around her nasal area

[@Cinnder]

That wasn't the sun; it was the light of knowledge. :-) Love these videos, and always fascinated how you're willing to push yourself outside your normal boundaries. Also, good timing what with similar fusion music being used in the Ms Marvel series now playing.

[@bhanushreeprasad]

You have a very calm, curious, and innocent demeanor. It was a pleasure to learn from your learnings.

[@Marcusnoredpond]

How wonderful is this channel and this episode! As a child my mother saw the goodness of Carnatic music, I quit just before reaching mastery to play sports 😊 Now I want to learn again embracing my southern Indian culture. More power to you both

[@Proud_Pagan]

Belonging to north of India I was introduced to Carnatic music quite late in my life but the moment I started listening to Carnatic music I fell in love with this style . ❤️❤️

[@Melissa_939]

Beautiful interview Malinda and you introduced us to a gorgeous artist! I'd really love to see you learning about and attempting to joik. It's a traditional style of singing practiced by the Sami

[@MysticHeather]

Thank you for bringing this to us, I’ve always loved Indian styles of singing and now I know that they actually have names and aren’t just ornamentations!

[@loonylovegood2.073]

Omgggg that's so cool!!! ❤️❤️❤️ Happy belated Birthday btw.. Hope you had the happiest of birthdays Malinda 🎂🥳

[@leo_ryda-81]

This is such a wholesome video! I'm so glad to see that you are providing a platform for us all to learn about the different cultures through music! Music truly does bring all of us together! The only thing that I would like to modify about what Archana said about carnatic singing is that it is not a "nasal" technique; instead you are encouraged to sing from the diaphragm (why students are required to sit criss cross on the floor); different notes resonate in different parts of the body at different pitches, but it is not primarily nasal

[@nordicson2835]

Thank you this was an awesome post. My sister in law is from India , she has an amazing voice , she has been coaching our daughter, ( her God daughter), and she has really improved, thank you for giving her the credit she really deserves. Could you post a link for voice coaches in this style for parents looking for coaches in this style

[@emilsoberbro36]

I know nothing about singing but I really enjoyed this. I can appreciate different cultures and their music.

[@heteranthera3473]

That was very interesting. I relly like this kind of singing and her voice is awesome! Also, very well done Malinda, that seemed really difficult.

[@geetanjalichatterjee3140]

Carnatic notes are so much more difficult than Hindustani classical notes, although both the modes are equally beautiful and intricate

[@Ethrianor]

Fantastic. Love music from all around the world. Watched some from a couple of years back of Pratibha Sarathy. Also different styles of throat singing, and just too many others to list.

[@remyatempest6700]

I really enjoyed this! Looove the how she broke it down! I found myself singing along.

[@arunnambirajan5157]

Learned Carnatic Music when I was young. Full support on the future of this series

[@physicist-physician5555]

This style is very difficult to learn but yet very beautiful.

[@Guiylan]

There’s such a wonderful diversity in the worldwide history of singing and music in general… Thank your for letting us discover that with you! ❤

[@OKBettsy]

This makes me want to learn Carnatic music, it's so so beautiful. Archana is an incredible artist, definitely checking her music out

[@savesoil3133]

Beautiful indeed! 🌸 #SaveSoil #ConsciousPlanet

[@Serenity_Dee]

The discussion of resonance reminds me of how I was taught to manage it when I was taking lessons on feminizing my voice; we were taught to gradually move it out of our chest and into our throat before bringing it all the way forward. (There were other things we were taught alongside resonance, of course, which are much more socially learned behaviors rather than the result of testosterone poisoning.)

[@gyanaprakashbaral4248]

our classical culture is dying slowly it's really heartbreaking. ❤🙏from India

[@froseed]

OMG Malinda!! Yess!!!! This is soooo good! It's a marvelous idea! I love this so much. I like the translation stuff too (still can't get over gradually watermelon) but this project feels like something much much more important

[@tharii314]

I'm grown with sinhalese music which is inspired by Indian classicals, Most prominently it's Hindustani-ish but sometimes Carnatic vibes also gets into play. Archana's voice tho, It drives me back to my school days where I were studying Eastern Music!

[@shubhasv9803]

Lovely video! You honor us by learning about our music and singing it ❤

[@coolomya2253]

OMG i can keep listening to Archana singing classical. sooooo soothing and awesome

[@glassdragonmedia]

Omg that's so cool. Absolutely beautiful, I just love the way this sounds. I love the sound of music from all the different ancient cultures. You can just picture yourself in the native environment. It's like a mood. Omg I can't wait to hear more, Malinda! Personally, I've been learning a lot of Viking music. It's ancestral for me. It's very beaty, gets my blood boiling and makes me battle ready or solemn depending on the song. I recommend groups like SKÁLD, Heilung, Danheim, and others.

[@rameshbabun]

It's "Karnataka Shastriya Sangeetha". Great Saint Purandara dasaru is called Karnata Sangeetha pithamaha. Has contributed to Streamline the Raga, thala, bhava, and many dimensions to Music.

[@Astrology_Witch_DJ_Lifestyle]

😍❤️ THANKYOU SO MUCH FOR APPRECIATING OTHER CULTURES MUSICAL STYLES ON YOUR CHANNEL! 😍❤️ so relatable to everyone, even if people aren't from that culture, they can learn something beautiful 😍❤️ from someone Beautiful 😍❤️🎶

[@murg27]

Archana has a beautiful voice and her classical singing is perfect. It shows the amount of practice she would have put in over many years. We should appreciate her parents who put her to learning it 👏

[@annmariebartholomew2591]

That ‘shake’ itches my brain, it’s so beautiful

[@alitherebelinstigator.7106]

This was magnificent! You approached this with such respect and obvious joy, it's all anyone from another culture could ask for. You did great stepping outside of that comfort zone and learning something new, that's always humbling, haha! Thanks for the intro to Archana, she's epic (listening now on Spotify). Bless, dear Lady.

[@mariopanczel8581]

Aw man! This makes me want to learn more folk music from where I'm from. (Specifically Hungary but all eastern European styles of music are absolutely gorgeous to me)

[@saividhyakannan]

Archana's a wonderful teacher! She took me back to my childhood.

[@anna-maymoon1001]

I love this series so much! It's so cool to learn along with you and from people who are passionate about the music they're singing ❤🙌 (Also you ask excellent questions!) I remember listening to carnatic whilst doing GCSE music and my teacher just couldn't get it across to us. It's nice that the syllabus has such a wide range of music included but it would have been even better if we could have listened to the music performed live and taught the nuances by the artists themselves. Its a bit like studying Shakespeare without seeing the play - yes you can read and watch a performance, but it's not the same as being in the room and getting goosebumps.

[@pteddygovender6584]

Thamil radio hd listen to the radio

[@itsmetorque]

Its good to watch we learn and try each other❣️❣️❣️

[@ItsMido84]

Her color is stunning

[@carlinc.christensen3478]

This is amazing!! Thank you for sharing your curiosity and discoveries with us! you make the world a better place!!!!

[@justgogo2370]

That sunlight... looks like you are enlighten!!!

[@crystalolson9594]

This is so amazing ❣️ I love what you're doing & sharing 🙂 thank you 🌌

[@Ray.5446.]

I've always wanted to learn carnatic violin since I was three and first saw the queen of the damned. My favorite carnatic violinists are Karthik Subramany and L. Shankar. Now I really want to learn how to sing carnatic music.

[@PavanMS87]

Holy smokes! Fell in love with you both 🤯🤯incredible stuff 🫶🏻

[@indomannn]

Wow you have started with the most difficult singing style ma'am...i appreciate it

[@rebeccaboudreau7589]

Love this, but so sad she didn’t end with singing a traditional song. Sitting for a few hours in an ashram years ago just to listen to a devotee singing this type of song was beyond transformational. Please do a follow up of her! Her voice is beautiful 🙏

[@alicejacobs760]

Thank you for sharing Malinda. I have found another favorite artist. Big Thanks for your series. I plan to see all of them 🤍💜

[@EDuGoIHuvvet]

I would LOVE if you did the Nordic indigenous Jojk. It's so beautiful, and can really touch your soul.

[@davidmoffitt9257]

OMG! This blew my mind! Thank you so much. I had a lot of fun watching this and singing along.

[@oliviaknight1123]

I don't know how I ended up here but this is beautiful! You beautiful women with those tones, you gave me goosebumps....🥰

[@juliacornejo7802]

Even though I didn't know the actual name, I've heard Carnatic singing and I find it so glorious and expressive I love this series you decided to do, I love learning about different singing styles and specially when you are behind the content, because I also love the time and passion you put into your videos and projects. I can't wait to see what's coming next.

[@thelocalplatypus2711]

This is so awesome! I appreciate your music Malinda, thank you!

[@venkag]

Archana's voice is coarse when she speaks, her voice become melodious when she sings. She is a gifted child

[@mermaidopulence8539]

I'm Nigerian and Native American so I have a mixture of different types of music and it's amazing.

[@MaySmithereen]

So curious about your human experience

[@mermaidopulence8539]

@@MaySmithereen that doesn't even make sense

[@MaySmithereen]

@@mermaidopulence8539 How so?

[@mermaidopulence8539]

@@MaySmithereen like what do you mean by "human experience"

[@MaySmithereen]

@@mermaidopulence8539 As a bicultural individual - of both Nigerian and Native American heritage as you put it - it would be quite interesting to know how you have experienced the world, especially if you live in America.

[@Tizzavizza]

She's such a good teacher!! Very calming

[@whitecrow1949]

Fascinating! I'm an old Deafish man. I got in touch with the Indigenous part of my ancestry about 13 years ago by becoming involved in a Native American Circle. Because we had a diverse set of Indigenous nations being represented we came together over Lakota ways. I refer to myself as Deafish because I am not completely deaf. I use my residual hearing. My brothers were awesome in helping me to learn to pray, sing, and drum in these ways. I'm talking about this because in Indigenous cultures all over the world we seek to honor our histories, ancestors, and the Earth Mother. On the drum the beat was four. It felt like our own hearts beating in concert with the Earth,

[@starhill6792]

Archana is so talented!!!

[@LucaAnamaria]

Thank you so much for starting this series! I'm a musician / singer who is into world music and this is right up my alley! Love it. You should check out Croatian klapa singing!

[@ElineVera]

Ohh I looove this video! Please make more for different singing style. You girls are awesome!

[@ardavalilable]

I love her voice and the style, recently made some friends from south India (from Tamiland), I must say they're the must generous and kindest people in the whole world. I am really grateful to hear their singing style from this awesome and talented young lady! Thank you Malinda, looking forward to see an episode of yours singing songs from my country!

[@psychadelicpotato8580]

Tamil Nadu or Tamizhnad

[@ardavalilable]

@@psychadelicpotato8580 the one with the oldest language, and heritage across southern Asia!

[@alainadacosta1222]

What a beautiful style of singing! I loved how it connects her to her culture

[@anweenawin]

This series is going to be so interesting!!! I'm so excited :D can't wait for the next one An idea: flamenco