WARNING - BUYER BEWARE When Buying Seeds From Amazon and Ebay

[@rondat5994]

I am not sure why so many people are up in arms about this video. As he stated in the title “…Buyer Beware.” Was there a better more tactful way he could have worded things, sure, but after watching the video - I can honestly say that I don’t think he meant ALL sellers using Ebay or Amazon. What I saw/heard was a passionate gardener, deeply angered and frustrated by the fact that there are individuals using these reputable vendors to scam gardeners. “I hope I drove this point home; you guys need to be really really careful.” Do your research. Be informed. There is some shady garbage going on. You have to be really careful these days. GO TO A PLACE YOU TRUST. “I just can’t stand the stuff that’s going on, the lack of respect for beginning gardeners….” (His words) Over and over he says go to someone/somewhere/anywhere you trust and be mindful.

[@42nard58]

Thank man for the truth

[@themattj]

Originally, the title read, "Do not buy seeds from Amazon or EBay." It was a great hook, but it upset some folks.

[@rmjames83]

Ronda T WELL SAID! THANKYOU! THANKYOU FOR THE TRUTH LUKE!

[@rondat5994]

Matt, I saw the original title and I agree that it was not ideal - it could have been worded better (as seen by the new title). But if the same people who got so upset and/or 'unsubscribed' watched the video. They would have heard him say: “I just can’t stand the stuff that’s going on, the lack of respect for beginning gardeners….” and go to someone/somewhere/anywhere you trust and be mindful. He was not trying to say all vendors were bad, just be careful. Someone/somewhere/anywhere includes those reputable sellers on ebay, amazon...etc. There is a knee-jerk reaction epidemic in social media today; sadly few seem willing to read/look beyond the initial subject introduction.

[@MIgardener]

We changed the title to be more accurate. Thanks for your support and love.

[@YourDroidDoes]

I love growing rainbow colored roses. I have three plants in full bloom now. They're right next to my tree that grows cash money. They're perfect companion plants.

[@CrazyIvan865]

🤣🤪😝

[@ceciledrummond1668]

Where can I get some seed like sorrel collaloo

[@ashleyburks4639]

Lolz, you passed the vibe check!!

[@Carma.Carisma]

🤣🤣

[@McALLAN1983]

you forgot the most painful thing about this scam... which is that the buyer invest months and effort growing the wrong thing...

[@Goldfishstick]

The Dude wasted valuable space on my small apartment patio garden growing weeds and not buttercrunch lettuce, once. Was so pissed.

[@michele695]

I am one who spent lots of time in soil , fertilizers , pots , watering ,planting etc. I am disabled and don't have money to waste and it was hard for me physically ,and I got nothing. To say the least I was P I S S E D.

[@antoine7559]

Wait 2 months just to find out it to marijuana

[@nvan7891]

@@antoine7559 Those are almost certainly Marijuana seeds. Source: I have grown Marijuana for over a decade.

[@antoine7559]

Nocutitout Yeah I know I just wanted him to plant them I grow myself

[@beckybenally9500]

Everyone should go onto Amazon and report incorrect product information, maybe together we can stop the madness!

[@LH-et7of]

Yes, people should provide a review for their online orders.

[@newoneinblack]

Exactly, and don't expect me to leave feedback until everything has time to grow! Sadly, by that time half or more of these seed sellers will be out of business - and back listing with a new company name.

[@MandaGeminiLioness]

I got banned from making a review for anything I order. But you can talk to customer service if these things pop up. I’ve bought seeds off amazon & dont have any issues. But I also looked up the seller and made sure they were local. I feel bad for the people that don’t look into things before making purchases. (I got banned because a seller from China didn’t like that I wasn’t happy receiving a broken item. When they offered to give me a refund only after I gave them a good review I reported the seller & amazon blocked me from making any reviews) 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@RealResponce]

His point was Amazon Facebook exec ban everyone for their speech(fake news) but don't care if they sell "fake vegetable seed/flowers exec.

[@nabilalbert3661]

I don' think so because they are used to it

[@amcginnis1234]

there are also lots of people trying to pass seeds off as "easy to grow" when what they are selling is difficult if not impossible for the average person to grow. An example is orchid seeds which basically require a lab and sterile agar in a jar in order to germinate

[@thenoicemango1827]

I've been scammed before when buying seeds from Ebay. I've bought many seeds from ebay and I've only been scammed when buying from China. Now I only buy seeds from American sellers or trusted sellers.

[@agustasister5624]

My new FAVORITE SEED SELLER IS OUTSIDE PRIDE..i got a package of 5000k snapdragons that leaked...didnt esnt it replaced just contacted them about one package that leaked pretty bad. Andnsuggested theyndo what they do with other really small.seed...double package. They re sent it!!!! Really they have a lousy contact system....BUT u get get great value...if u grow in bulk...which i do... I buy about 2500k dollars worth of seeds a year...in BULK...so ive tried a lot...JOHNNIES IS PROBABLY THE BEST BECAUSE OF THEIR SUPPORT SYSTEM. Not so keen on that california company that does do GREAT NON GMO WORK...LOVE THEM BECAUSE OF THAT AND SO I TRY TO SUPPORT THEM TOO. But only because of their political stance on gmo. Im qm trying to move to plugs..omg..NO ONE IN AMERICA SELLS PLUGS TO THE PUBLIC...WHATS UP WITH THAT AMERICA????

[@agustasister5624]

@J .S stay away.from their jewelry AND PEOPLE WHO MAKE JEWELRY AT HOME.AND BIG BOX STORES WHO SELL THE SURPRISE..

[@brigidatersigni5565]

kshiftkometh on

[@zehnass]

BROOO! I JUST BOUGHT PEASHOOTER SEED PACKETS FROM AMAZON, I CANT WAIT TO GROW THEM

[@shellbells339]

Have yall heard about the mystery seeds being mailed from China to people in the US and UK? No orders were ever placed! ??? What is this all about?

[@Gabriel-um9hm]

grifting... the order is made by a scammer in order to post fake reviews on amazon and ebay

[@wolfinthesuit]

Those probably Magic mushroom seeds to get u high bruh would like to receive 🥵🤤

[@ShirinDelsooz]

People need to think very critically when making any purchase on the internet. Look beyond reviews, go the extra step and see who the vendors are, do they have a passion for gardening? Are they knowledgable about gardening? What are their credentials? Do they have social media pages? Are they acknowledged by key players in the industry? Also, you need to see if you can get the seeds for free at a local seed exchange organization/event! I admit, when I first got into gardening, I had no idea where to buy my seeds. I certainly didn't want to buy anything from Monsanto. I had to do a lot of online researching and I also went to the library and looked at the back of gardening books where they list resources to buy seeds, then I talked to other people and now I know where to get my seeds. I bought some from MIGardener too! Now I have an abundance of seeds and I save so many of my own.

[@pinkbigfoot1981]

Chinese gouvernment pays shipping fees internationally, that's why there is free shipping ;-)

[@RobbieAndGaryGardeningEasy]

Yes, you are SO right, that is why all the shipping out of China on the internet is FREE, their government pays the shipping.

[@pinkbigfoot1981]

And then other gouvernments wonder why our economy gets buldozered (is that even an english word) by the azian market....

[@johndifrancisco3642]

I do believe the USA is the world's largest economy, and it would not surprise me if WE were paying for the shipping.

[@anonymousanonymous1314]

John Di Francisco: Are you joking or serious? The United States economy is in the toilet. China's economy is far stronger than ours. They're doing all of our manufacturing. We're doing near to none. Until that changes we'll never have a good economy.

[@Goldfishstick]

Why do we need to manufacture to have a good economy? Sounds like old thinking. Just my two cents.

[@roachmine2008]

Just saw this video in an article posted by Mashable. You're getting famous now...lol. I live in Ohio and watch a lot of your videos for advice since our climates are similar. You only have to look at your garden to see you are very knowledgeable and experienced. Grow on my good man, grow on.

[@RTUG00]

"Budha ginseng hanging... Even though ginseng is a root!" 😂 Come on now. You know that's funny.

[@marysallette5919]

YOU SHOULD REALLY PLANT THOSE BLUE STRABERRY SEED TO SHOW THE PUBLIC EXACTLY WHAT THOSE PEOPLE ARE REALLY SELLING

[@ajdexter4195]

Mary Sallette yes but if they are contaminated or have a foreign disease it could kill all his plants and be really dangerous but yes I am curious to what he got🖒

[@ChrisD4335]

that would be pretty unlikley, they are seeds

[@pinkbigfoot1981]

tossing is contaminating other peoples enviroment....

[@Danny_Boel]

even growing tomatoes indoors can get you a visit from a swat team , there was something in the news about that...

[@killuminatepeacefulness3948]

Mary Sallette its dangerous. It could be a invasive species that can sprwad it seeds and take over in the long run it could be bad. Just look at American bitter sweet and Japanese bitter sweet

[@NorthernThaiGardenGuy]

Luke, plant the seeds in a controlled environment (if you can) and if it turns out to be some sort of Pigweed or evasive species, you could file charges against them through the FDA. It's one of the ways to clean up the sites and sources.

[@peepslostsheep]

A couple people have pointed out that the seeds look like marijuana seeds, and that 'blue strawberry' is a strain of marijuana.

[@NorthernThaiGardenGuy]

I hate to admit it, but I thought that initially when I saw the seeds. That does make sense, and if true - is a truly risky way to sell pot, but I don't doubt that it could be what was going on here. It makes sense, and would explain why all the weird colored fruits (probably doper code for weed).

[@johndifrancisco3642]

THEY ARE NOT POT SEEDS! Pot seeds look small and smooth like BB's. These are rough and larger like whole pepper corns.

[@Spelunkingpunk]

@@johndifrancisco3642 wonder if it was weed or allspice 😂

[@ctrey8395]

Pig weed lol that's the 1st

[@Snowiesphotography]

I have only ever bought seeds from AliExpress...I haven’t really had a problem with them...super cheap seeds that I can’t get here....I’ve only had one person somewhat scam me by giving me hollyhock seeds instead of maple trees...but I’m not upset since I like hollyhocks too...I started buying seeds from AliExpress as a test because I heard a lot of bad things, but so far I have recieved what I purchased (except that one) and now I have some really cool plants and flowers that I wouldn’t be able to get otherwise...I think you just need to be careful when buying and check seller reviews and photos.

[@sterlingtardie]

Maybe you should have the USDA look at what you received to help identify what it was that you were sent, or maybe plant in a quarantined area that won't affect your garden.

[@MaanelSitaBlueLily]

sterlingtardie I am sure the usda will be really forthcoming, Not.

[@richardcrane784]

I appreciate your view on this subject Luke. I absolutely cannot stand false advertising or showcase marketing for that matter. my daughter and I have really enjoyed your videos on here.

[@sandradee3477]

I bought desert rose seeds from amazon - shipped from china - and they looked just like that. I planted them and got dianthus flowers. Got my $ back!!

[@lissethmontenegro7421]

Exactly that’s what I like from Amazon if you report they send you the ron item they give you your money back.

[@jeanskilling708]

Bad seed suppliers sell more places than the internet. The seed store I bought from this year sent me so old of seed most did not work. when I e-mailed them they did not answer back .I gave up after the forth time.

[@SardiPax]

I've had some issues with Amazon UK. I purchased a propagator and on opening it (I'm an engineer) despite ordering a 25W heater, it was 15W. I asked for a replacement. When that came, the same. And the cable was marked 25W. I asked for a third one and again the same. I demanded a partial refund and kept the last one. Recently, I ordered Snow Banana seeds. Got something, 100% germination but pretty sure they aren't Banana's. Out of interest, this is illegal in the UK (if done intentionally) under our Trades Descriptions Act.

[@YouCantEatTheGrass]

Buying high quality seeds is very important. But the issue is who you buy them from, not where. I always buy from Westcoast Seeds, and they sell on Amazon. The difference between $1 and $3 is so small, why risk all your gardening time and space on growing a plant that will have bad production or bad germination.

[@kritakareem8643]

They don't care what you paid. They make their money selling your email address to advertisers.

[@CrazyIvan865]

😲

[@harmonizingjourney]

I couldn't find a good place for a testimonial for MI gardener seeds. So putting it here. I am very impressed. I just recently purchased seeds for the fall. Within days of sowing they sprouted. Now for my end they didn't get enough sun because I didn't expect them to germinate so fast so darn a bit leggy. I got them in more direct sun now. Thank you MI Gardener for all of what you do with seeds and your videos are very helpful 🥰

[@bugander9802]

I bought 'Heritage seeds' for large beef tomatoes and they grew to about 5ft, wonderful foliage - not a SINGLE flower. Heritage my arse.

[@anneelizabethrobinson8450]

Bought some of your seeds recently, you have a lot of unique product and they're awesome! I just moved to TN and people here have known about you for years. I'm a big fan.

[@matthewcutler4440]

I love your passion for this issue. And you are right to be angry. There are about 5 companies I buy seed from online. Yours is certainly one of them. Keep up the good fight.

[@nitinjain8837]

But solid one color roses are real, aren't they? Like red, green, black, etc.

[@wrightyrightrite]

I'd be less concerned about getting bad seeds and more concerned about bad people potentially having your credit card numbers.

[@Cabsterman]

If you buy from eBay and Amazon you don't share that with them

[@GardeningwithLadyCheryl]

Your credit card transaction is completed via PayPal. If you are unhappy with your purchase you can file a claim. PayPal will refund your money back into your account. Purchases from eBay and Amazon are safe.

[@iainwalker8615]

It’s sad that these fake seed scams are only getting more prevalent like the fake AI generated cat face flowers for example

[@kingofalldabblers]

It's disconcerting seeing you angry. You are the most wholesome person ever. You are the embodiment of the whole "Midwest nice" thing.

[@GregSheehan733]

Etsy too! I got burned on some live plants. Live and learn.

[@Lemurai]

False seeds? You mean Monsanto?

[@JohnDoe_88]

I had predecided to only buy seeds from your store before yesterday's video. You're a trustable source of viable seeds so be proud of your quality. You're honest and fair people so speak out as you please without worries.

[@sandynystrom5344]

I know what your talking about I paid for cucamelon seeds from amazon from china I got watermelon seeds I let them know I didn't get what I paid for, they said they where sorry they will resend them as of today which has been a year I haven't got the new ones so lesson learned on me so I went thru a nursery store and got my seeds I wanted which where cucamelon seeds; it make me upsets they do that

[@thenoicemango1827]

I got scammed from an Ebay seller when I tried buying venus fly trap seeds from china. I just normally buy from American sellers or Trusted sellers.

[@kikilicious99]

Sandy Nystrom I also bought what I thought were lemon cucumber seeds and another variety, a typical looking cucumber, grew. I really wanted the lemon cucumbers and was really disappointed.

[@MaanelSitaBlueLily]

LISA BEISHLINE Totally agree

[@MaanelSitaBlueLily]

LISA BEISHLINE Actually I stick to seeds from home her in the uk, mostly I gather my own and do not buy. People become lazy...

[@JTTeProductions]

Sandy Nystrom : By your seeds from Luke. They are safe & what you see is what you get! I buy my seeds from Luke & I'm very happy with the services. ❤

[@ymehair]

So glad I watched this. I didn't realize that you had a web site that I can order seeds! Can't wait!! Hope you are enjoying your garden!

[@gailgreenberg6953]

I live in France and usually get my seeds-mainly heirloom-from a great organically grown seed co. called Kokopelli. They also share seeds across the planet! By the way, I had deep blue/black tomatoes last year: cherry tomatoes that were delicious.

[@lucarnetrange]

Yes Kokopelli is a serious association and sells rare seeds (old variétés).

[@Cabsterman]

I've never bought seeds claiming to be a "rare variety", but I have bought seeds packaged from a brand I trust. Recently I bought on eBay 25 packs of Botanical Interest seeds for 50 cents a pack, sealed (packaged for last year though). Always make sure you are comfortable with the expiration date. If the seller doesn't share all the details, don't risk it.

[@kidgloves2]

Thumbs up! I spread the love among a few reputable sellers each year. I hope they all stay in business. My favorites are MIgardener, Baker Creek, SSE, and a couple tomato specialists. Luke would you consider doing a new Q&A video?

[@teresamcbrayer2549]

I wish I would have seen this before I ordered my Mouse melon cucamelon seeds. On amazon. It says this is only available through a 3rd party seller. And it said that the seller provides no tracking number. $15.99 free shipping. The add says 100mg. Not even sure what that means.

[@killuminatepeacefulness3948]

I get seeds on Amazon. And u go gotta watch what u r getting... But everything i got soo far was what i was looking for..

[@KillowPillow]

I saw Purple and Bright red Venus flytrap seeds and they just photoshoped a picture of a Venus flytrap and then just colored it

[@laurabrowning924]

Take them to your county extension office and have them test them...

[@SmirkJerk]

Haha I got an ad for those crazy seeds right under your video.

[@FuriousPsyOp]

I buy Live coffee trees and cacao trees on Ebay. Its not garbage, but YES China sells the fake colored strawberries. I sell live trees on Ebay. Do it all the time.

[@andrefernandes2975]

Do the cacao seeds germinate?

[@cindyskillman544]

I got seeds from China in 2019 but the box was labeled "sweet pea earrings". I hadn't ordered anything. 😳🤷‍♀️😳 We boxed them back up and threw them in the trash. I thought later we should have baked them to kill them, but I doubt they could sprout. They were in a little cardboard jewelry box-pretty thick. Something invasive, I'll bet.

[@Happilymarrieddad]

@midgardener Hey man, you should plant those in a pot. I'm really curious to see if they even sprout?

[@zairemonae7506]

I love your videos. I just started a small garden and I find myself binging on your videos to educate myself on a successful garden.

[@evievilla8897]

I am SOOOOO HAPPY I watched this video!!! I Literally just filled a cart with $248 worth of seeds from USA Garden center (or something like that) for next years garden, with rainbow colored everything’s and well let’s just say there went 2 hours of my life I will never get back. Ughhhh How dumb am I that I honestly almost fell for that scam!?!? I guess like he said I just wanted to have the most beautiful garden filled with all sorts of New and Interesting plants. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU MIgardener for The reality slap!

[@DistopiaKosaki]

Yeah that happened to me

[@rmjames83]

The other risk that is often overlooked, is the risk of introducing devastating diseases into your country from seeds bought from (some) foreign sellers on EBay/Etsy/Amazon, etc. Such diseases can not only have the potential to wipe out entire groups of varieties, or "genera" in our home vegetable gardens, it can put our entire food security at risk if these diseases infect large scale farming. These unscrupulous sellers often don't care about the consequences of their unsanitary growing practices, and prioritise mass quantity over quality-something I know Luke does not do! Luke cares about the quality of his product, as well as the security of our food! The results are clear to see in Luke's product-100% germination (or close to), as well as perfectly healthy and vibrant plants! I encourage anyone and everyone to give his seeds a go-you will be so happy with the results!

[@EileenJoyHappy]

I have seen some of these ads that MIgardener is talking about! I am so glad that you showed this!

[@dechinta]

I ordered some purple pampas grass for $9.99 which took forever to arrive and they were from China. The ad didn't say that. I planted them and I have a green thumb and....nothing. However, I ordered some crowder peas from Ebay from Two Willies Nursery and I planted some and they were about 1-2 inches high in two days and are doing wonderfully if I can keep my dog from trampling them. I am very impressed with them. I have started saving seeds from veggies that I get that are awesomely good and it's so exciting to think about starting them next Spring. I love your videos! I am disabled so cannot plant to the extent that I would like, but it's in my blood. Something I have always thought was amazing is that my Daddy could take a dead stick and put it in the ground and it would grow into something beautiful. He had the greenest thumb I've ever seen! Me.....nope....couldn't get a cactus to grow. Then, when Daddy got into his 90's and could no longer garden, everything I touched turned to beautiful plants. It was like he finally passed on the green thumb to me. After he died, at 95, and we were cleaning out all my parents' things, (my parents were married for 71 years and died very close together,) I found a little jewelry box in his storage room and there were 4 kernels of corn in it. My sister turned up her nose and said, "What on earth! Throw that away!" but no. It is in my china cabinet now because, I knew, he must've had a really good crop that year and wanted to save some seeds. My sister had no interest in gardening. One time she was over at my house and I was washing up a mess of turnip greens and asked her if she wanted a turnip that I had accidentally pulled up. I remembered she used to love raw turnips when we were kids. She did not want it and I said something about I hated to waste it, but I didn't really like turnips, only turnip greens. She looked at me like I was the stupidest person on the planet....as only a sibling can look....and said, "Well, if you like turnip greens, but not turnips, why don't you just plant the greens?" OMGosh, that was so funny. We haven't spoken in over two years, but I remember that day with mirth every time I think of it. Thank you for letting me share.

[@Scandoboy1000]

You must plant those seeds and see what they are. Every first grader knows that when an equally skeptical boy named jack carelessly tossed the bean seeds he traded for, they grew to enormous heights and resulted in him acquiring a goose that lays golden eggs. Your curiosity should get the better of you, but regardless you do not know by experiment that those seeds do not produce some weird plant that has blue strawberry like fruit. You have to close that loop before you can render your final verdict, even if by experience you know your not going to get blue strawberries. You said it yourself, you do not know what those seeds are. So plant them and show us the result. It might be an interesting plant, and those seeds at the very least share the honors of natural selection that might have taken 3 billion years. Besides, you paid for them. If you were not going to continue the experiment why take that first step? To be on total solid ground, you have to grow them, otherwise we just have your judgement call and tortured seeds that went half way around the world only to be disrespected. The seeds are not responsible for the sins of the seller, they are seeds and should get a chance to grow.

[@nicoleblaylock4929]

Right on . thats exactly my feelings. And the jack and the beanstalk .....priceless. Love ur comment

[@PenneyNile]

Luke, I find your passion about this kind of crap very inspiring. I have just started gardening, and I am SO fascinated by the multicolored plants I have seen... I may have been one of the idiots that would buy the rainbow roses, except for the fact that I design graphics with Paint Shop Pro, and I know how to alter colors on items like this. I am disappointed that the roses aren't real, but glad that I saw this video and confirmed my suspicions about the plant. Thanks for posting it because I know that it will save some of you fans and followers some disappointment in not getting what they were expecting! LOVE this channel --so many helpful tips and great information. Keep up the good work!

[@Ladydragon1776]

thank u for the information Luke!! i just bought some "rare" seeds and realized now they are from china i will be requesting a refund

[@gardenlady58]

I totally agree with this. I have seen posts on facebook from gardeners who have grown things from seeds bought this way and they were not what they were supposed to be. If you are and experienced gardener and are willing to take a chance, go ahead. however he is just saying to use caution. if you are not experienced and may fall for the multicolored rose seed, for example, you are better off buying from a reliable company, or from an established youtube person like MI gardener. what he is saying is just to beware what you are buying and let your experience guide you. common sense advice.

[@zombiesRus_1]

I have bought seeds from Amazon with no problems I always look at reviews before ordering

[@chasewildermuth4069]

Got some leek seeds off of amazon and couldn't get them to germinate, then I found you guys!! Yours growing like a champ

[@XxScArEcRoWxX1]

I get my seeds in person. . Grass roots face to face

[@GinchyGirlCreatesAndGardens]

I bought seeds from a couple sellers in eBay and well , I had great germ. But for example, my zucchinis , I had two different types from one seed pack!! Lesson learned !

[@hoganFE]

do you sell seed? I have had good experiences on ebay and etsy - I go by the feedback.

[@efrenchen293]

hoganfehandbags Yes he does. Good, cheap seeds.

[@efrenchen293]

migardener.com/store/ This is his seed store.

[@MIgardener]

Yes we do, reliable, 100% heirloom seed. None of that craziness.

[@CodyFlock]

MIgardener | Simple Organic Gardening & Sustainable Living I've been curious, where do you source the seeds you sale? Not looking for specifics, just in general. BTW, used Trifecta+ this year - loving it!

[@MIgardener]

We source our seed from a broker who deals only with small family owned organic seed farms. They are from all over the united states, but most of all they are reputable.

[@kikilicious99]

I've purchased seeds from eBay and have had good luck, most times. One time I purchased pepper seeds and grew 2 plants from the pack. Neither plant was the one advertised and those two weren't even the same. I was very disappointed but it was months later so there was nothing I could do about it. I did by 4 packs of seeds from MIgardener and sowed 3 of them this year with great success. Thanks! You have quality products. I recommend them.

[@anonymousanonymous1314]

Well since you didn't plant it I'm forced to assume that you're wrong and it is definitely a blue strawberry.

[@rmjames83]

I agree it's best to avoid in most cases as it's hard to sort good from bad, until you have already bought! Feedback scores are unreliable, since many will give feedback before they have germinated the seed. Many sellers encourage you to leave feedback on receipt, not after germinating their seed!

[@moeal-ansi3548]

Thanks for talking about this Luke. Ive been ripped off before where Ive bought seeds or plants on ebay or amazon. I always paid next to nothing but what i got was just crap. Its dishonest and unethical. I totally agree with what you said about trust and good reviews when choosing a seed or plant supplier. Watching your videos is like having a chat with one of my best buddies, I trust in what you say because I see your passion and honesty. At times being honest is better than being politically correct and Im sure the vast majority of people watching agree with me. You wont loose and genuine subscribers, keep up the good work.

[@joshsimpson10]

I feel your frustration as a small business owner. I like the fire brotha! You will be big dawg some day soon with your business, keep grinding!

[@TheBoricuaso777]

Quit bickering and plant the dam seeds so we can see what it is! That would have been more interesting.

[@ashleyburks4639]

Literally just placed my order for A lot of seeds of diff varieties, of course!! Thanks a ton ton for caring so passionately for the wonderful craft & for other people!!

[@melsmith511]

I have had excellent experiences buying seeds and plants from eBay and Etsy. I have a two-acre field of Aronia berry plants (Nero) that I started from seed purchased from eBay. Started in 2015, they are producing berries this third year when all the information I read said it would take from 5 to 8 years to bear fruit when started from seed. I ordered more seed from the same seller and have another 1600 plants started in my greenhouse now. I've purchased Comfrey and Sweat potato plants off from Etsy, they are growing well. Now, I wouldn't buy colored roses that look totally photo shopped but you have to pay attention to what appears real and to reviews and feedback. ...and don't buy a Ford truck. Had one once, it quit working! Don't ever buy a Ford....Ha!

[@Cabsterman]

Nice Melvin keep it up!

[@PinkiPinkiest]

Can I ask who you purchase your seed from ?

[@charlessloop1552]

I clicked for the title I am not into the gardening hobby but into planter aquariums but I subscribed because I seen the passion u have for your hobby

[@GurtGobain]

Shoulda planted them, I'd be really curious to see what they actually were. Probably just weeds. Btw on Facebook ads, eBay or Amazon you can report any listings and get their accounts banned.

[@thatjiujitsumom]

I buy your seeds and I really appreciate what you do and your videos. My garden wouldn't be the way it is without you!

[@anniegaddis5240]

LOVE the warning. I bought some Passion Fruit seeds on Amazon. It turned out the seeds were actually Morning Glories. Sigh. Scumbag is right!

[@lissethmontenegro7421]

but if you report to amazon you get your money back.

[@toptierfish9335]

What happens when u buy rose seeds on eBay from China and u get a empty package saying usda intercepted and took seeds ...

[@on3cashmuney]

I have ordered off of Amazon and so far so good I go off of the reviews, I also email the seller.

[@anniegaddis5240]

Some ARE good, but not most from China. I got perfect seeds from "Rare Seeds" on Amazon, and later found out they are from Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Company. LOVE them!

[@acoatofgold5627]

Rare Seeds and Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Company are the same company. Baker Creek's website is "rareseeds.com" but most companies are not like that. - jacob

[@mandabroadway460]

I have bought many seeds off amazon, and never had a problem.

[@GardeningwithLadyCheryl]

I've had the same thing happen to me. BTW: I've been very pleased with seeds and other merchandise I purchased from eBay and Amazon.

[@GardeningwithLadyCheryl]

I've had great experiences from my purchases on eBay and Amazon. I've purchased seeds from merchants from China, but mostly from the US. I've received extra seeds, plants, cuttings and even whole fruit. I will continue to support small merchants, especially on eBay and Amazon, I don't care what Luke said.

[@rmjames83]

I will be sharing this-PLEASE share too! While people keep buying, they will keep selling!-if we all help to get the word out, eventually the market for scam seeds will dry up, and people that don't know better will stop being scammed! (Hopefully!!!!)

[@birdsberriesbrews6191]

Best episode ever! Had an argument few month's back about blue strawberries... Ugh. Can't convince sheeple.

[@dandahermitseals5582]

I appreciate your video for it's content and your intent. I'm in my 70s and I grew up in an erra where everyone including and especially merchants had to be honest in their advertising claims. I just became aware if you from someone I trust who grouped you with Baker Seed as the go to real deal. Dan at Arms Family. I will be shopping at your store as well as Baker's very soon. There is no accountability for merchants today in any category and the Chinese are masters at false claims and rippoffs. I've been stung so oftenbi can't count. I bought three drones from one merchant who promptly took my money ( transaction is matter of record in my PayPal account) and never shipped. After nearly 6 months they simply dissmissed my claim and had my comments "removed" from the internet!!???!! Ni such thing as safe shopping out of the USA or on ebay from chinese merchants. I miss America. I will be pursueing your catelog ( or list?) in the next few days. Keep the faith n stay your path. Sincerely Dandahermit

[@emmitstewart1921]

I've seen those ads. They are cleverly labeled so that they come up when you are searching for something else. I've come to recognize that any kind of odd seeds being sold from some place in China are probably bogus. Your "strawberry seeds" look a lot like hemp seeds. I'm not sure, but once I worked in a pet supply/ garden center store where we sold sterilized hemp seed as bird food and they were about that size and shape. For a laugh, search for "monkey face flower". The picture is of a Dracula orchid. (Yes, there is a real genus of orchids named for Dracula.) The trouble is that to grow that genus from seeds needs laboratory like conditions for germination, greenhouse atmosphere and temperatures, and about six years for the plant to reach flowering size. Caveat Emptor.

[@asecondisahiccup]

Happened to me when I started gardening. Saw an ad for some really cool carrots. Sent off money, got back just about what you got. A small envelope labeled machine part from China. Did they kind of look like pepper corns, without the smell? But they got 6.99 off of me. This is a very informative video. Thanks

[@vngudes]

Yep I bought those same ones when I first started but it was the rainbow chrysanthemum! Smh! I know better now!

[@susankoch1319]

Thank you so much , very informative! My husband tried gardening and fell for a lot of this junk on line. I continue to garden and have always loved seed catalogs full of good products and information.

[@nationalbaseball]

why would you not plant them? might as well check...

[@MIgardener]

Because i am not an idiot... strawbery seeds are small, pointed, and less than 3mm across. These are massive balls that almost look like peppercorns.

[@OutOfNamesToChoose]

Alex Marley Interestingly, after watching the video, I did a bit of Googling. It turns out that "blue strawberry" is also a strain of the erm....devil's lettuce. I guess they were trying to sneakily sell seeds which might be illegal to sell.

[@ChrisD4335]

they do look like weed seeds hmm...

[@ChrisD4335]

but MJ veraritys have to be grown from cuttings to be true to type, seeds generally results in poor quality ditch weed

[@TheMurlocKeeper]

Great laker - no, they're not coated. If a tiny strawberry seed was coated this much, the seed would never be able to sprout! It's staggering to me how so many people could be so ignorant and uninformed about this. Strawberries are usually sold as runner cutoffs, not seeds. It should be a living plant. It's extremely rare for anyone reputable to be selling strawberry seds. You just don't do it. Any heirloom plants or seeds, I get from The Diggers Club in Australia. Highly reputable, and for the most part, grow all their own seeds and bulbs and plants that they sell. They don't send overseas though. Only in Australia....as well they should. Source seeds, bulbs and plants from your own country only.

[@tanyasawyer41]

I work in a nursery in Australia and a customer of ours brought some of the multicoloured rose seeds into us. I did plant them, one did actually germinate! It is indeed a seedling rose plant. More like the wild variety in growth habit.It is over a year old but very weak, should it ever flower I will let you know. Germination rate at 1%, not too good but it is a rose.

[@lincolnklee]

don't throw away, contact MSU and let them test or grow, maybe they can contact right people to change this issue

[@MIgardener]

to late.... No way was I keeping those around for longer than they had to.

[@jroc2813]

Those look like peppercorns to me. Thank you for using your passion about gardening and planting to warn the public of a real issue! I personally wouldn't buy seeds off Amazon or Ebay. I'm in the US, and seeds are sold at most retail department stores and gardening specialty stores. With that said, many people obviously do look to those sites, and I'm sorry to learn about the scammer situation. I consider those sites to be a Wild West of sorts. If you haven't already made one, maybe you could make a science-style video teaching folks about what sorts of plants actually exist in nature and why something like a rainbow rose or different-colored tomatoes growing off the same vine is impossible. I think if the general public / new & eager gardeners were more educated about plants and our food, these types of scams wouldn't be nearly as successful.

[@kimberlyguimond4186]

Buyer beware! Buy from Luke!

[@comesitunderthetrees]

I LOVED THIS!!! I LOVED THE PASSION! THE SINCERITY!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR SHARIG THIS!!! I immediately knew it was a sham!!! I'm now a new subscriber. I really enjoy an appreciate your content. Wishing you prosperity in all you do. Be well!

[@thetobaccoguy1751]

BS! I actively sell heirloom tobacco seeds on Ebay. I work very hard and give 100% ensuring quality seeds and happy customers. Firstly, don't buy outside the US. That removes 90% of the problems. Then, look at feedback, and don't buy seeds that cost $.75.

[@jumpoffa5011]

When purchasing seeds I consider the source from where they come from. I have found that if they come from China you are more likely than not will not get what you paid for. First seeds must go through customs and be declared. It they don't they will be confiscated. If by chance they do make it to your home they may not grow, be the right seeds or plant or you will find that they were not shipped at all. Purchase your seeds from a dependable source or take your chances. I look at the plant or vegetable that I am interested in. I research it on the internet then look at KZbin to see if anyone else has grown the plant that I am interested in. Then I will look and see what the seeds or plant will cost me to have it ship to my address. This is where I really get mad. When shopping on E-bay I find that suppliers do a bait and switch number. They charge $1.00 for the seeds then charge $3.95 or more to ship the seeds. E-bay allows this to occur. I find e-Bay suppliers usually charge you a lot for the small amount of seeds they send you.They provide you with a small baggie of seeds with no instructions that can fit in a number 10 envelope and a fifty cent stamp. Do you know how frustrating that is? To have seeds that are not marked with no instructions? I have to ask myself why put myself through this. I usually walk away. I rather purchase seeds from HomeDepot than pay for something so outrageous. That is why I say consider the source. I purchased close to $40.00 worth of seeds from migardener.com. I got seeds that cost only $0.99 and free shipping. That's right this is Migarderner's seed company. Check it out it is well worth it. However, I also purchase seeds from these two other suppliers: www.seedbankbox.com, because Jake Mace lives in my growing zone 10a, and www.seedsavers.org, where people get together and share their seeds with others. What I find is that if I can't find what I need at one supplier then one of the other two will have what I am looking for. Don't get taken to the cleaners by a foreign country supplier. If you need to take a chance, then shop in your own country and only from those that you know and trust.

[@JPAnor]

wow soo early that the thumbnail didn t even load

[@codyminecrack248]

Nice sona btw.

[@mrstn123]

I have had great experiences buying seeds from EBay and Amazon. It's a super way that people share their biodiversity and make a little. I always check the side filter box on EBay to exclude everything except North American sellers. As for weird plants and scams- even when I was a kid, we would get seed catalogues with bogus pictures of giant 10 for pumpkins, or miniature pineapples growing like cherries on a small tree. Everyone had to go to the circus and see the carnival when they are children. No sensible gardener would fall for silly plant scams.

[@lapriest1]

I was in a seed swap group that had shady people…send wrong seeds or bad seeds or nothing at all.

[@TheMurlocKeeper]

lapriest1 - then it obviously wasn't a good group, lol! A seed swap group should actually meet up an be able to talk to one another...and anyone found selling bullshit should be chucked out in shame. Gardeners, REAL gardeners are usually good, honest, decent people....but there are always wolves that prey on these types of groups, and I think this is what happened here.

[@johndifrancisco3642]

lapriest1, That sounds SO perverse, and I LIKE shady people! =P

[@ronsellew5696]

You have to follow the old adage of " Caveat emptor " [ Let the Buyer Beware ]! especially when buying things that do not sound logical.

[@StreetMachine18]

Looks like cilantro or coriander

[@StreetMachine18]

bo ter berg I know hemp is a very useful plant in other parts of the world. is it rather easy to grow?

[@StreetMachine18]

bo ter berg Putting a seed in the ground and watching it grow is pretty easy but controlling the temperature and making cuts takes a bit of a skill. I suggest ec-1118 wine yeast instead of beer/ale yeast. Makes the final product a bit more light and fruity.

[@Sheepy007]

No they don't really. And I know, I have both

[@sazji]

There are so many seed scams online; I report many to Amazon frequently. Blue Begonias, “Purple Venus Flytrap Carnivorous Bonsai”. 😅 Good that you discouraged that purchase!

[@njhw4990]

I Purchased the Japanese Trifel tomato seeds form Amazon after watching your video about this tomato and I like to try different ones every year and I grown 3 plants from this seeds and I got some red plum looking tomato with no taste at all, nothing like the purple pear shape tomato that you showed on your video... do you sell the seeds or where do you recommend to get them? and thanks for this video!

[@MIgardener]

we will be carrying that tomato this year in the store. :)

[@gomezaddams6470]

Claudio NJHW yes he does it says so above it says So Below I sound like dr. Seuss there's a little arrow underneath the video pull it down with your finger or tap it depending on if you're on a computer or telephone and it'll pull down a list of sellers it'll say seeds it'll have the supplements all sorts of things with the ordering details coded right on there. I hope that helps and he just said they're $0.99 most heirloom seeds are anywhere from low-ball $4.99 high $7.99 crazy! we need to share so that diversity stays here for everyone!

[@jjankowskirecoverme1]

MIgardener | Simple Organic Gardening & Sustainable Living Luke, thank you once again for airing your helpful warning on internet scams. I know you do this to help educate your audience. I have purchased your seeds, 911, and Trifecta because of your personal and professional ethics towards your viewers and customers with amazing results. I appreciated your bonus video and as usual your passion for your craft and your superb ethical standards always make a leadership influence in our online gardening community 🌴 Julia from Florida

[@josiegagne9829]

I fully agree with Luke's feeling on these websites for buying seeds. He is NOT telling people to not buy from Amazon or eBay. He is telling people to be careful when you buy seeds. I am a huge Amazon and eBay client. Absolutely! I am also a new gardener who wouldn't know much about seeds. However, having said that, I completely agree that certain things just don't make sense. Blue strawberries??!! Has anyone ever seen those anywhere? And let's say we did see some, would you not wonder how they got them that way? Those multicoloured roses....I've actually spoken to a florist friend of mine who told me that food colouring and dies are used to change their colouring. But not to the extent shown in the picture. People get offended with everything nowadays. Not once did this video feel like he was insulting anyone. In fact, it's truly refreshing to see someone that dedicated, that caring about his craft, and people to inform them of scammers just out to make a buck (by the way, eBay and Amazon sells these but they usually come from another company). And the worst website for all those products shown in his video?: Wish! Common sense, and Google go a long long way to help you be better informed. And people like Luke, who are genuinely looking out for ppl. This was my first time seeing this video and I was so happy he made it. Thank you Luke!

[@dontforgetthesunflowers8088]

A few years ago I thought purple carrots and potatoes were fake. Then I started seeing them in the store so I assumed they were genetically altered. Then I learned the truth! 😂. This coming year I'm starting my first garden and wanted good seeds. I did my research and found out about you. While doing my research I found out why getting good seeds is so important. Thank you for this video!

[@TheMurlocKeeper]

Natasha Coleman - you can also get purple sweet potatoes as well. It looks wild when you mash them and serve it up, lol! Oh and if you boil up the potatoes/sweet potatoes with green peas, it makes them look...greener? Dunno why, it just does, lol! Would probably work with beans as well. Just something I remembered from my childhood.

[@mochacream3923]

Thank You

[@magadociourex]

I have purple beans and purple pea pods in my garden right now! they're organic/non gmo seeds. The peas and beans turn green though when cooked.

[@janinesechler467]

Natasha Phelps, what are the purple carrots, and potatoes made from? How are they getting purple?

[@rebeccajosteelman563]

Wow, now I know where to buy funny flower seed, lol 😜 Thank you for your very informative and helpful videos, Luke. At this point, trying to use small space while living in an apt in California. I will be looking in your website to see what seeds I can get to try out. Am learning and I thoroughly trust you, and many more KZbin organic garden growers providing reliable knowledge and creative ideas to help inspire - please keep up the good work.

[@Jim-the-Engineer]

They look like peppercorns!

[@olive4naito]

😂

[@rmjames83]

I'm not sure what people are upset about-Luke just is trying to encourage a "buyer beware" mentality in all of us-it's especially important for beginners, because it can be so hard to sort fact from fiction. There is so much on the internet that can result in you being scammed-not just with seeds, and he wasn't ever "attacking" anyone-he was just calling for some accountability and buyer protections on behalf of all of us-(admirable if you ask me!) from a company/companies that rake in millions each year allowing this sort of thing to happen!