Was Netaji a Hindu nationalist? I SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE I INDIAN HISTORY

[@wasimkhan580]

Thanks!

[@kartikeymishra2608]

We are proud of our first PM Subhash Chandra Bose 🙏🙏

[@himanshukahtrivito]

All had lucrative legal practices. He left ICS. A spymaster, a military general and a patriot of highest order that could be.

[@slansari8157]

ऐसे टापिक पे बात आज जरूरी है 🙏🙋‍♂️🇮🇳 दोगले ही दूगले रास्ते पर चलेंगे

[@Yajna007]

Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose had already predicted in the early 1940s that the ugly brand of politics practised by the _Hindu Maha-sabha_ organization is gonna entail devastating consequences.

[@ArvindKadu-gw5xo]

@@Yajna007 भारत हिंदुस्तान शे पहचाना जाता है हिंदू की बात तो नही है गलत है कैसे बात

[@Yajna007]

@@ArvindKadu-gw5xo ढ़ाई साल अथवा तीन साल पहले मेरा ideogy *sickular* था एवं (तथा) उन दिनों मैंने ऐसा कमेन्ट {यह वाला comment} लिखा था। मार्च 2022 एवं अप्रैल 2022 से लेकर मेरी ideology बदल चुकी है एवं मैं पहले के जैसा एक बार फ़िर pro Hindū बन गया हूँ एक बार फ़िर लिख रहा हूँ because my ideology was indeed *pro Hindu* from 2001 till 2018 and then it underwent a transition next few years और फ़िर उसके पश्चात् I became sickular from 2021 onwards. I remained sickular for less than a year {only ten months indeed} and then once again switched back (reverted back) to my previous ideology. तो फलस्वरूप इस पर्टिकुलर वीडियो पे किए गए मेरे comments को *इस बात को (इस सच्चाई को) ध्यान में {मद्देनज़र} रखकर पढ़ियेगा* कि उन चन्द कुछ महीनों के लिए मैं uncharacteristically _Sickular वादी_ बना हुआ घूम रहा था (जो कि अब आजकल मैं नहीं हूँ). पिछले सवा दो वर्षों या ढाई वर्षों में मैं *well and truly* Pro Hindū ही रह हूँ और आगे भी रहूँगा (भविष्य की यदि बात की जाए तो).

[@Yajna007]

Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and his supporters were arch enemies of Shyama Prasad Mookerjee's Hindu Mahasabha. The _Forward Block_ was a bitter rival of the Hindu Maha-sabha.

[@himanshukahtrivito]

Totally secular he was.

[@manjushaganguly9659]

Kyaa bat hai bahut bahut dhanyvad 🙏🙏

[@RajendraPrasad-nq1iv]

डा पुनयानी का व्याख्यान देश को रास्ता दिखाता है

[@subhashhedau9308]

सत्यमेव जयते 💖✌️

[@rakeshbadera4720]

मुकेश जी नमस्कार

[@sadiqhussain2563]

गांधी इतने भारी हैं आरएसएस और हिंदू महासभा में कभी कोई बाहुबली पैदा ही नहीं हो सकता जो उन्हें उठा सके। कभी सरदार पटेल की कभी नेताजी सुभाष की मूर्ति इनकी हीन भावना ही दर्शाती है।

[@FITNES6269]

Produ to be subhashchandra boss 🚩🚩

[@sarojininautiyal9696]

यह सच है कि कांग्रेस ने नेताजी बोस के साथ आपराधिक अन्याय किया है

[@thatswhy8601]

*नेताजी की धार्मीक विचारधार बिलकुल वैसी ही है जैसी राजेंद्र प्रसाद,सरदार पटेल,अटल बिहारी वाजपाई.....और यह स्वत: उनकी बेटी ने Interview में साफ साफ बताया है......क्रपया गलत फहमीयॉं नां पालें......*

[@sauravsaha4799]

Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose was a socialist secular leader not a Hindu nationalist. But he was thousand times larger than Neheru in terms of leadership and involvement in India's freedom struggle.

[@himanshukahtrivito]

He was a disciple of CR Das another great leader few talk about.

[@himanshukahtrivito]

Satya Hindi should get Anuj Dhar on a debate.

[@bittoochatterjee2661]

How very true. Yes I agree on each and every word of yours Prof. Mukesh Kumar ji and that of yours's Prof. Ram Puniyani ji Keep up the good work. Both of you are so right My respect to you 👍👍👏👏✌✌💕💕❤❤💖💖😊😊

[@SKumar-mj6gf]

Netaji would never allowed India to divide and Pakistan created.

[@manjushaganguly9659]

Puniyani ji ko sunana har bar bahut bhata hai ! !!

[@WaseemAhmad-et2jx]

🙏

[@sayedqayamuddin3348]

B jpaajadi ka dusman hai

[@ramnoberoi9661]

Good 👍

[@ManojKumar-gh8sf]

बीजेपी के पास हिंदू मुस्लिम और मंदिर मस्जिद के अलावा कोई और एजेंडा नहीं है

[@sandeepsipu943]

Spiritual Pahele nahi To sare Agenda hi Khatam Ho Jayega Aur Agar BJP ke pas koi Aur Agenda Nahi Hota to Aaj Desh 🙏🇮🇳Nahi Chalta

[@vitthalpednekar6788]

Some people argue that subhash chandra bos got people due to sawarkar " help British military "

[@ExSaAd]

Professor ne Jo book ka Naam Liya kahin kahin per nahin mil raha hai kripya aapke pass ho to link dijiye

[@mkcon5838]

General Shahnawaz Khan, capt Habiburrahman, and other moslem officers of INA need to be mention.

[@ratankumaryadav3801]

For any subject ,read authentic literature available on the subject, general tv audio ,video are time pass, people are saying.

[@arundey4029]

Congress ka Govt. Ne Netaji ko kabhi V prapya Sanman Nehi diya O baat Satya hai .Netaji ke bare mai sabse accha se Anuj Dharjee bata sakte hai.unko kiu nehi bulate.

[@himanshukahtrivito]

Thanks to the controversy at least now SatyaHindi talked about Netaji else no video in History Segment on him. He was indeed the tallest amongst all leaders except Gandhi Ji. Forgotten Hero and someone who makes the Gandhians ignore him and Right wingers can’t appropriate him due to ideological opposite. Bipin Chandra aptly writes INA agitations and trials were an “opportunity “ to be captured and to capture that electoral opportunity Nehru wore his lawyer coat after many years.

[@souravbiswas2510]

This is another hidden secret of Congress like Kashmir...they didn't tell u the truth about him. Richard Atlee and Ambedkar had said that he is the one who ahd freed India

[@krishnkr.tripathi8092]

Is it that much simple?kya wo rash bihari bose dwara guided nahi the jo ki japanese far right aur underworld ke qaafi kareebi the aur sath hi hindu mahasabha ki japanese branch aur azadvhind fauj ke founder bhi. Aur agar aap thode documents juta paye to payenge ki subhash babu khud kam se kam japanese far right ke qaafi kareeb the. Kyunki context azadi ka tha isliye hum unki vichardhara ko nahi samajh sakte. Mere khayal se wo national wale socialist the jaise ki hitler ki socialist party. Aur hum right wing ko hindu muslim framework me kyun samajhte hai. Kya Savarkar before his invention of hindutva was a leftist. Kya hindu nationalism bas rss ki creation hai ya ek natural dominant ideology rahi hai modern India ke shuruaat se hi. Aap Arya samaj dwara inspired sashastra independent movement jo ki ghadar movement me culminate hua aur aurbindo ghosh jaise logo ko ideologically kaha pate hai. Kya ye sab log hindu nationalist nahi the. Jab wo anti muslim bayan denge tabhi hindu nationalist ya extreme right kehlaye jayenge. Ye ek gair congressi independence krantikari movement raha hai par ideologically hindu nationalist. Bhagat singh bhi isi confused hindu anarchist nationalist parampara ke socialist the. Is samay koi bhi rajnaitik padha likha vyakti socialism se kisi na kisi tarah prabhavit raha hai. Par ye sab log anti congress ho gaye kisi na kisi samay pe. Bhagat Singh bhi gore bhoore ki bat congress ke liye hi ishara kiya hai. Congress satta hastanantaran ke paksh me thi aur pragmatic tareeke se soch rahi thi. Wo qatai anti British nahi thi. Subhash chandra bose ek natural hero hai hindu right wing fascism ke. aur ye fark batane ka kasht kare ki hindu rashtravaad aur fascism me kya antar hai. Aapko hindu rashtravad se dikkat hai ya fascism se. Ya sabkuch chalega bas anti muslim nahi hona chahiye. Bal Gangadhar Tilak jaise fascist sabko pasand the, par wo allah ko jald hi pyare ho gaye, bechare azadi ki ladayi lad nahi paye.

[@IndianPsalmist]

Mukesh ji aap ne Netaji ko sirf Subhash karke sambodhit kiya ye baat acchi nahi lagi, ya to Subhashchandra Bose ji ya Netaji bolte.

[@deepakchaudhuri4348]

Read more about Netaji who was never a communal or religion based politics.Read Taruner Swapna . Third class attempt .to hyzac Netaji Bose

[@FITNES6269]

Tumhe kuch nhi pta yaar tum hova Histhaskaar ho jisen bhart ki real histihaas chupaya gya 🚩🚩🚩

[@shailendra1323]

ye kya subject hai

[@bittoochatterjee2661]

Had the sacrifice of Subhash Chandra Bose forgotten by us or atleast by by Grand father, then How could he become a HERO of mine at the age of 6 or 7 in the year of 1974. Neither the common people Nor did the Historians of this Country forget the supreme sacrifice that he gave for achieving the freedom of our Country. How can I forget my Hero who gave up his today for my / our tomorrow. No way and I will ensure this keeps on going even tomorrow by sharing the stories that I learnt from my grandfather to my daughter and she also carries forward this legacy of his further more. I feel blessed take pride in getting born and am proud of being a true Hindu from India due to people like them. 😊😊💖💖❤❤💕💕✌✌👏👏👍👍🌹🌹 and AND NOT DUE TO People like Savarkar, RSS, VHP, Bajrang Dal, Modi, Yogi Shah, Mohan Bhagwat n either did the historians of this country , 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔😒😒🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂🤦‍♂

[@121mahipalsingh6]

Ye joodh ka samana hai.

[@modernworld6144]

Puniya ji ki jai ho Pakistan ki jai ho

[@bhawnayadav7498]

क्यों आरफाजी का नाम बदनाम कर रहे हो

[@brajkishorebalendu2010]

@@bhawnayadav7498 ये मानसिक बिमार विदेशी यूरेशिया वाले पोंगा पंडित गोबर भक्त ही है

[@kakulid7286]

दो रुपाया कि गुलाम अंगरेजो कि औलाद परिचय देना जरूरी था किया . बाप दादा कि इतिहास सुनके कस्ट हो रहा होगा 😂 बाप दादा कि गद्दारी सूनके पेरिसान मत हो . गुलामि छोड़ सच्चे देश भक्त बन . कबतक छुपते फिरेगा संघीओं . इतिहास तुमे चेन से रहने नही देगा .

[@modernworld6144]

@@kakulid7286 o apne abba jinnah se puchana

[@udaysarma9513]

Your discussions are all motivated and biased.