Was Pokemon on the DS Really That Good?

[@GohTheGreat]

Gens 3, 4 and 5 are fan favorites, and the DS can play all of those. So I think it’s unambiguously the best point for pokemon.

[@StrawHatMidas]

The ds was a masterpiece

[@cremapastelera00]

not only are they fan favorites but they're also peak pokemon, so the conclusion is that the DS era is truly the best

[@joemomma6317]

5 is overrated

[@GohTheGreat]

@@cremapastelera00 “Peak Pokémon” is a subjective statement. There’s no objectively best game, that’s why I said fan favorites instead.

[@eclipses3131]

@@joemomma6317y’all hear sum? Oh did they say gen 7 is overrated?? I totally agree 😂

[@Squid0798]

Idk about anyone else but I am honestly so grateful to have been a child and adolescent during the times these games came out, what a time to be a kid. Pokemon was so mesmerizing back then

[@StrawHatMidas]

Right! it was a great time to be a fan of pokemon and the series was truly great :D

[@kaz7690]

As a kid I was always envious of the Xbox/PS/PC folks because I only had a DS, 3DS and a shitty laptop that could barely run KZbin. Looking back, I definitely do not regret owning those consoles. They gave me so many precious memories that I would never trade away.

[@auro-toxicyt2177]

right!!! soul silver is still my favorite pokemon game ive played every game except the lets go games there just not for me. I still have the copy of platinum i got for christmas from my grandpa when i was 12

[@thunderboargames8369]

The Ds era will forever be one the greatest achievements in Nintendo's history

[@3dsfan2002]

3ds was better

[@johnnyrocketfingaz]

Not better than the DSIXL ​@edwardsaldana2534

[@ANVILD3VIL]

​@@3dsfan20023ds had the worst pokemkn games ever

[@3dsfan2002]

@@ANVILD3VIL 3ds has the best Mario and Kirby games, gen 7 is goat

[@ANVILD3VIL]

@@3dsfan2002 we're talking pokemon wise here...pokemon g7 is one of the worst ever(only 8 and 9 are worse)

[@CarlosColon-m7i]

It’s better than the switch era games

[@TheDeathmail]

To be fair, that era has nostalgia backing it. Back when they came out, there was a lot of controversy and hate for a few years..... And starting in Gen 3, EVERY GENERATION got hated for a few years.... and then, after a few generations, nostalgia pours in and the kids who grew up with those games become adults and bam, the games got love....

[@auroraragazzoni4533]

I mean, the switch era games are pretty bad in general (except for let’s go and legends) so yeah

[@toooydoeur]

@@auroraragazzoni4533 s/v is better than lets go but yeah legends is the best

[@MultiDarkII]

thats not hard lmao

[@mohamedaminekhadhraoui6417]

The shit I took this morning is better than the switch Pokemon games and the one I took yesterday.

[@parzivallampruge2549]

90s Chicago bulls level run.

[@StrawHatMidas]

They COULD NOT MISS! :)

[@OnlyRetroHere]

I remember being 14-19 (i was born 1993) during the Gen 4-Gen 5 era and even though i really like Gen 3, the DS era was where are my Pokemon obsession truly began. I played so many Wi-Fi battles, trading, completing the Pokedex and post game in this era. Sure this era wasn't perfect like every other era, (mainly because of diamond and pearl) but, i'll never forget the amazing experience i had with the DS Pokemon games.

[@alexconstas9634]

Yeah this was back when a new game in a franchise actually added content and made improvements. Such a novel idea

[@nate186]

im wanting to play ds games again but I barely played as a kid. Do you have any recommendations for an almost newcomer for which pokemon game for ds I should play first??

[@ryandemboski6313]

@@nate186 i'd start with platinum or black/white 1

[@nate186]

@@ryandemboski6313 you are epic, thank you

[@OnlyRetroHere]

@@nate186 Play Platinum(don't play Diamond and Pearl), Then, Black and white 1, then HeartGold SoulSilver and finally Black and White 2.

[@saul-goodman]

It’s ironic that gen 3-6 is when the fanbase “grew up” and stopped playing Pokémon until they reached adulthood and recaptured their love for the franchise. This is unequivocally the best time in Pokémon history

[@DracoMeteor91]

No its not, gen 3 sucks

[@saul-goodman]

@@DracoMeteor91 No, gen 1 is unplayable, gen 2 is only slightly better, gen 3 is the first one that isn’t perpetually stuck in alpha/beta

[@DracoMeteor91]

@@saul-goodman well first of all, remakes arnt considerd new gens. so technically you can call FRLG gen 1 as well and those games are some of the best in the franchise. regardless, gen 1 is not unplayable at all. its very playable and fun despite the glitches. but generation is more then just the game, its the designs as well, and gen 3 has the worst pokemon designs in existence + those are really tedious annoying games who force you to surf annoyingly amount of water and is constatntly forcing new objectives on you, which gen 2 dident do. all the lore and greatness of gen 2 was thrown out the windows in gen 3. those games are dumpster fire. you just wear nostalgia googles.

[@DC-YTC]

​@@saul-goodmanGen 1 & 2 were fantastic in the 90s but I do not see why anyone would play them now. It's like people who tell current gamers to play the SNES, people need to realise that there is an element of nostalgia with most of the games

[@a.x.x8184]

@@DracoMeteor91 I agree Gen 3 isn’t that great and there’s a whale 🐳 as a mascot legendary, basically no rival (Wally even exist?), Mid dex, boring music and the start of humanoid starters 😢

[@thefonzpart]

Gens 3, 4, and 5 all felt interconnected and had every region available It was like one big journey. Now Pokémon takes that away from us and gives us very controlled and contained experiences by removing content and Pokémon and selling it back to us as DLC Pokémon is a pseudo live service game now

[@fastest_mia]

I'm so glad I never sold my old pokemon games, still have my copies of gen 3, gen 4, gen 5, gen 6 and gen 7

[@StrawHatMidas]

Save them and never sell them

[@dionysus5284]

What were your teams in each gen?

[@CreepyJournals]

The new games are great but I still bust out my DS and play Gen 4 and 5 now and again. They just haven’t captured the charm and quality in the newer switch games 😢

[@StrawHatMidas]

I think the art style and nostalgia are there best on DS for me

[@TheDeathmail]

Personally.... I don't like Gen 4... it feels so sloshy to me... I actually prefer BDSP because they felt easier to play....

[@OnlyRetroHere]

​@@TheDeathmail That's fine. I prefer Platinum over BDSP.

[@cuck1ngfunt]

@@TheDeathmail Have you played Platinum, or just Diamond/Pearl?

[@paoloh885]

This. Last few years I've been taking my DS with me whenever I'm on vacation. Especially the gen 5 games are still really fun to play and a great way to kill time when not driving.

[@applechrisp]

I think the ds era was the best for pokemon and games in general because playing 3ds games and generations of consoles after will eventually loose game features over time when companies shut their servers down. So you won't be able to play the game at its full potential. Its pretty bad when you can play a gamecube game in the year 2024 but you can't play a wii u game because of servers.

[@Cam22.]

BW2 is forever peak pokemon the best Pokémon experience possible

[@StrawHatMidas]

Extremely great games, some of the best of all time

[@nayabperwaiz952]

​@@StrawHatMidasTHE BEST OF ALL TIME!!

[@MentaAzul]

Ikr? Also the pkmn world tournament feels like the culmination of the saga.

[@ditz3nfitness]

Remakes!!

[@anthonyt425]

Agreed, HG/SS was my favorite but mostly because of extreme nostalgia. BW2 was the absolute peak for me.

[@aira4739]

The best streak of Pokemon game is undoubtedly PMD EoS, HGSS, BW, and B2W2

[@sylphidstriker6909]

having these come out during my childhood was awesome. i still play them from time to time and i'm almost 30 now

[@LetsTalk.42]

Game boy advance, and DS generation for Pokemon was PEAK!!

[@drentsnoorden8325]

I remember playing daimond on the airport flying to family for christmas and meeting other kids with a nintendo with pokemon too and we could play together for some time. Was a good time

[@StrawHatMidas]

I have great memories of playing these with friends :D

[@mountchoco8174]

I remember playing hg late at night when I was around 9 years old with my cousin (we were only children and more like brothers) on his pearl profile. I fell asleep at around 2am (never stayed up that late before at that age) next to him while he kept playing and would wake up throughout the night to see him at a different point in the game. I ended up moving away and losing touch after all those years passed- I miss those times 🥲

[@SagaciousSilence]

People need to stop spreading the false narrative that Black and White was controversial because people wanted to play their old favorites. That is absolutely not what happened. I was there when the games were released. Everyone hated the new designs and thought that the new Pokémon sucked and that it was hard to create a party of Pokémon you actually liked. There were definitely a handful of overpowered Pokémon that people latched onto, but that didn’t help the fact that the starters and early route Pokémon were so bad.

[@orangesoda8832]

Yup

[@StrawHatMidas]

I was also there for its release and it was extremely controversial. In hindsight I like the change and think that it was nice but i definitely agree with the early routes being lacking

[@michaelballack3051]

What do we consider early routes?

[@Detective_L]

Black and White 2 fixed all the issues everyone, including me had with the first one. The world tournament was the best addition to the franchise that no one asked for and we sadly never saw it again

[@jwiguy6547]

You are absolutely right. I hated Gen 5 and I still do. They got a lot of things right. But a whole bunch wrong.

[@zayndot7288]

fond memories of opening my DS in the morning to listen to soundtracks while I got ready for school.

[@Gloryboyquan]

psp better

[@ethanknifsend9775]

I remember buying a used copy of platinum at GameStop for $47 because I never got to experience sinnoh when it came out and thinking “damn this is really expensive”

[@PenguinWithaCrown]

Honestly I thought you had 50k+ subs, this video was so well made!

[@StrawHatMidas]

Wow thank you! I do my best on every video and hope to get there someday!

[@Thug_Nose]

I’m going through all the DS pokemon games on an emulator and having a blast. Love having fast forward as an option, using my PS5 controller on my laptop and seeing gen 5 on a big screen is so satisfying. It being all free is the cherry on top, the fact that these games cost $150+ is insane, you’ll never see me buy that for a decade old game. Emulation all the way!

[@kodyb5869]

I would gladly pay money if they rereleased a definitive version of all these games on the switch or another Nintendo console

[@jaykelley103]

People pay that much for old games because modern ones are trash. Not just pokemon

[@Thug_Nose]

@@jaykelley103 True. Can’t think of any games worth mentioning past 2018

[@IIDoMiN4ToRII]

Nothing beats the original. You wanna play some free fake shit then do it. Not everyone is poor and would rather the real things in life

[@Thug_Nose]

@@IIDoMiN4ToRII lmao ok 🐑

[@godlyskitz2141]

I’ve recently gotten back into card collecting but I also decided to do a rerun of White 2, man the game is just as amazing as i remember it from when I was younger.

[@basketball3825]

The music was so ambient, and this was the perfect time for me given my age at the time. Being 8-11 I was at the height of my love for pokemon. I have these games etched into my memory

[@naumnation3112]

Had the blessing of starting with gen 1-2 despite being born in 97, Sapphire is my favorite game for nostalgia but BW2 are the best games I've ever played for a pokemon game. Gen 5 is just unmatched

[@StrawHatMidas]

i was born in 98 so i am right there with you. GEN 5 video is coming soon!

[@naumnation3112]

@@StrawHatMidas hell yeah can't wait! Gen 5 gave us the most substantial content imo always love going back and playing

[@anthonyt425]

Born in 92 and started with gen 2. Spent sooo many hours on Pokemon then. I played gen 5 years ago but only just beat it a few years back (beginning of COVID). Excellent story, great rival, animation was solid, music was great, and selection of Pokemon was large while still being manageable.

[@PlayStationatorTV]

DS era is the peak of Pokemon. Hasn’t hit the same level since and maybe never will

[@LuigiTheMetal64]

Generations 3, 4, and 5 are the best. The anime graphics made the world and characters look great, and allowed plenty of fun content.

[@isaacmedina2957]

I still have my Pokemon Diamond save file from April 22❤ loved these older times

[@RomasKalash]

Absolutely it was the best on the DS, and it peaked in the 5th gen. The care and attention to detail peaked, as did the artistic direction. Beautiful. Gen 2 and 3 have the most nostalgic connection to me and were with me throughout the largest part of my childhood, so I don't consider B&W reaching the zenith as being a result of the rose-coloured-nostalgia-go-goggles.

[@robertlupa8273]

+1 for honesty 👍

[@a.x.x8184]

A Gen 5 remake I hope it has new evolutions for the needed Unova dex. Pre evolutions for Audino, Heatmor, and Druddigon. Final evolutions for Swoobat, Alomamola, and the elemental monkeys

[@theniteowl7777]

while many kids started their journey in Kanto, i started my journey as a young adult in Sinnoh, mainly because i had a DS lite (a console i seriously loved at the time) and Diamond would be a game that i would play because, not that i cared for the Pokemon franchise, but because it seemed like a solid DS game with great graphics. and it was that. on a side note i would never be a Yugioh TCG player unless i had first played the DS games. anyway, the DS lite really changed how i experienced video games, and i still play classic DS titles on Drastic.

[@tamerkoh]

I'd argue the DS era was the last era of good region design for Pokemon as well, with it starting its decline in Gen 5. Unova still had some of the metroidvania-esque exploration that HMs offered when it came to reaching optional areas or dungeons later, to find unique pokemon, items or trainers you couldn't elsewhere. However, it didn't have nearly as much in the puzzle realm, like the Strength or Ice sliding puzzles in Gen 4. Black and White 2 are still good games anyway and still offer a lot to do, it was just the start of things getting really linear with the route design, and some of the depth being stripped out mechanically. Once Pokemon went fully 3D and stripped out the HMs, it was a permanent hit to the level design, and it hasn't ever recovered. Every area being a bland and simple hallway that you have no reason to return to after the first time is what the level design looks like now, with no optional dungeons and puzzles.

[@3dsfan2002]

3ds was last good era, because the games were the best looking in the series, throw at me

[@alulim4968]

@@3dsfan2002 nah they look like shit

[@Rihcterwilker]

Very true. The metroidvania aspect and ocasional Environmental puzzle made exploring so fun. i'm a sucker for puzzles in adventure games, and the 3d games from the 3DS forward have none of that.

[@anthonyt425]

I got so turned off from the 3D sprites and the ease of play in newer games. I'm so grateful for ROM hacks so I can still play with newer Pokemon and still enjoy the regions I grew up with. (Seaglass Emerald comes to mind).

[@ChrismonYTF]

Your upload schedule is crazy! Love the videos, keep up the great work

[@StrawHatMidas]

It may tone down a bit when I start my new job but I have been LOVING making the content and hope that someday I’ll be able to do this full time :)

[@zmo_oo]

just found my old 3ds from when I was little, thought I lost it. The time was still set to 2011.

[@mewcraftcrowned8009]

Not to mention cynthia was the first ever female champion and she is the strongest one of all

[@user-cw7ym6oo1x]

Good quality video, thought a much bigger creator made this until I checked 😂 keep it up bro

[@StrawHatMidas]

Wow thanks! Maybe someday ill be a big creator, you never know :D

[@GoveXL]

Playing all thee games as a kid was wonderful, Everytime I hear the soundtrack I get extremely nostalgic, good times

[@MaleWingDiver]

Crystal, Emerald, and Platinum are my holy trinity for the series. I still have my copies and play them to this day.

[@samueldominguez5318]

Don’t forget this is the generation of the trilogy Pokemon Ranger and where the Pokemon Mistery Dungeon saga peaks.

[@Habeteel2]

Great video, nostalgia is big here

[@StrawHatMidas]

I am 99.999% nostalgia

[@leahx4552]

Im so happy that the DS pokeom era was my childhood. I got Pokemon Platinum and the DS to my first day of school. I loved everything about this game. It also feels like gen 4, 5, and partialy gen 6, where the last gens that the pkm company actively cared about the games. They added so much quality of life changes and really good pokemon. After x and y all that just vanished and the goal was to be as child friendly as possible. I hope that when black and white become a remake they actually care this time!

[@ecdabbin]

Man this might be my favorite video on KZbin, thank you

[@StrawHatMidas]

Wow, thanks! That is a big complement, I appreciate it so much :)

[@cloudtg462]

Awesome vid bro. I also agreee DS generation was peak, Diamond and Pearl to Black and White were crazy hyped days

[@princemannic]

i got reccomended a video right below this called "is pokemon emerald still peak in 2024" lets see who is more convincing

[@StrawHatMidas]

Hopefully it was me lol maybe I can find their video and we could collab :)

[@theguycanfly98]

@@StrawHatMidas kzbin.info/www/bejne/hWXWiKtpZcl3abc&ab_channel=GramKraken

[@theguycanfly98]

@@StrawHatMidas Your videos were both fire in their own right. Would love to see a collab

[@lxe36]

Im playing my beloved Generation at the moment (5)

[@gramgramsausages189]

What is the song 0:52

[@josephshim2442]

Twin leaf town’s soundtrack

[@gramgramsausages189]

@@josephshim2442 thank you so much

[@alisar6378]

HGSS was my favourite. GSC being my very first Pokémon games made me feel at home ❤️ playing the remakes

[@StrawHatMidas]

HGSS is such a good game, i have a video on it and i am playing through it now lol

[@Adimas0]

The DS era outdid its predecessor whereas the switch could not so any DS game especially HGSS, Platinum and B2W2 were just above and beyond to me

[@jakeekaj2623]

Most people I’ve talked to HATE gen 5 so much but to me they’re probably my second favorite generation. Gen 3 will always have a special place in my heart because fire red is my all time favorite (even though if I play gen 1 it’s usually the originals since it’s way faster)

[@vincenzonavarra3380]

Why you stopped putting the date of realese in europe and australia?

[@Edward_Ardy4671]

The reason is simple, it was the peak of innovation for Pokemon games

[@kuka1337]

i give you like beacuse you are the first youtuber to ever greet my family at the end of the video

[@StrawHatMidas]

I hope that everyone who watches and their families have good days :) I want to spread positivity when I can :D

[@razorback10]

Short answer: Yes. (As a bonus you could even use the DS and DS Lites GBA ports to play Gen 3, and use Gen 3 games to have interactive Pokemon catching in Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum)

[@DrakoNotDraco]

Gen 5 had the best graphics

[@TheKrimsonKhaos]

i agree. it’s funny how there was a time when everyone thought gen five graphics was dated especially the pokemon sprites.

[@michaelballack3051]

One word: Absolutely.

[@imrafiki966]

Not even just the games, Pokemon in general hit its PRIME with the DS era. Toys, games, and the TCG were all absolutely phenomenal. The TCG is still really solid, but the toys and games pale in comparison to the DS era. XY and ORAS was alright, mostly carried by megas and I actually loved the story in XY. But SM/USUM is when it started really trending downhill

[@FollowYourTrueDreams]

I have diamond, soul silver and black, I’ve only played SS so far but all three seem like they’ll be fun!

[@jnunnery94]

Able to bring pokemon from previous generations ✔️ Able to Trade/Battle/talk over wifi with no subscription ✔️ Able to send them to pkm console games ✔️ Gen 4 was by far the best generation we had for pokemon games.

[@joychowdhury9270]

That period between 2008-2012. HGSS, Platinum, BW & B2W2, PMD: Explorers of Sky. The franchise couldn't miss

[@manojgabriel6128]

I played Ruby when I was young and helped my sister to play Sapphire. Then I finished Emerald... Those were the best time! Now I'm 30 and I started with Soul Silver and I love it a lot cause of the nostalgia. I ll be going with Platinum and BW2 next... Cant bring myself playing the newer games

[@NicholasPangaribuan]

Used to play with R4 with all the pokemon games back when I was a teenager, and now I kinda want to relive it again by buying a dsi with the original cartridges. But man oh man, in my country, an original copy of platinum is around 300 to 600 usd. Slowly turning into collectors item...

[@baschtey]

Not to forget all the great Spin-Offs we got on the DS to assist the main Games. Mystery Dungeon Explorers of T/D/S, Ranger 1-3 etc. We still had a 3D Battle Simulator in Battle Revolution… Great times. :) Nothing from this time is left.. I would pay a shit ton of money for a remake or a HD Switch Port of Colloseum or XD. :D

[@adrenaliner91]

And here the picture is zoomed in too, what the hell man xD

[@StrawHatMidas]

I have only been doing this for a few months but I am working on the process :D sorry :c

[@MrLoLFaQ]

Gen 4 was my last gen and I still stick with it today. Black and White might still be good games but I think they were getting out of ideas for new Pokémon by that time already. I was born in 1997 and still started with gen 1 and went chronologically through them. Was the best experience I had and I'd say gen 2 or the remake even is the best Pokémon I've ever played. It was just great that you could go back to Kanto region and get 16 badges. I played Platinum in 2007 but Heartgold just a few days ago. Great games. I also played them on original hardware but due to the speed I could never do that nowadays. I just can't imagine how I didn't even mind when I was a kid.

[@EarflapKing]

Pokémon Diamond Pokémon black/white Pokémon x and y Pokémon soul silver and heart gold were so fun on the DS. Golden era

[@mackmag00]

Great video 💯🔥

[@FaIIenSkater91]

i wonder what % of the fan base would say the top 3 pokemon games are Platinum Emerald and HGSS in whatever order

[@DoctorAlright]

I’m almost done paying off my sealed copy of Pokémon heart gold, pray for me 🙏🙏

[@joelx10001]

I remember going to GameStop and getting my mystery gifts those days hit different

[@StrawHatMidas]

It was a great time

[@jaretco6423]

In my opinion, Black 2 & White 2 is an near perfect Pokemon game. Everything from it's QOL improvements from the previous games, to the well crafted worlds, characters and other gameplay, an great roster dex, the postgame at it's best, the music, etc. The story isn't on the same level as the first Black & White game. But it's not an big deal for me since I prefer gameplay over story anyway and I think the plot is fine enough. Even to this day, no games comes close of being as perfect as B2&W2 were.

[@helly9015]

3ds is peak pokemon not ds, you can play gen 1,2,4,5,6,7, gen 3 remakes etc on 3ds.

[@HunterAnsorge-ok9jk]

And that’s why I remember my time in Sinnoh 10x better than my time in Kalos, right?

[@3dsfan2002]

@@HunterAnsorge-ok9jk dp sucked

[@fabiolopes8615]

Sorry, Platinum, HgSs and the unova games are simply unrivaled and not one entry ever since even comes close

[@shak1155]

​@@3dsfan2002dp sucks but then platinum came and became one of the best game of the series

[@nickmanning6240]

Quantity does not equal quality. It’s a nice hot take, but I think you will find you are in the minority. I will say mega evolving is sick though

[@Hynotama]

No. Sorry, not sorry. I’ll take the “n64 trees” of Pokemon on switch, over the cramped form factor and the HMs of the DS titles. Oh and despite the people’s complaints, Pokemon Let’s Go was a legitimately good title, with interesting catch mechanics that broke up the extremely monotonous gameplay of the Kanto region. I will agree that some newer evolutions of Kanto pokemon should have been in the game, as well abilities and breeding. But I’m fine with it, given that it’s meant to be “babies’ first pokemon”. It was the first game where I actually completed the dex. Pokémon Sw/Sh was also very good, if lacking in the story area, especially with the addition of the Crown Tundra. Scarlet/Violet had very good story, but was severely lacking in the technical department, including graphics. Ironically I think Pokemon Legends Arceus is really boring and bad and I hate that the next appearance of Mega Evolution is going to be in a freaking Legends game.

[@adfa1994]

I don’t care what anyone says, gen 5 games were the true first 3D Pokemon games

[@swathedpyhton5296]

A cynthia fight is also in gen 5

[@swagchadd6925]

I think I speak for everyone when I say that gen 5 needs at least one more remaster, if not a port onto the switch

[@oddishu]

Yeah definitley. And I should say, I'm not one of those people that hates gen 8 or gen 9. I actually do like gen 8 and LOVE gen 9 despite its problems. But when you ask the question, was the DS the best era of Pokémon then absolutely. Sinnoh, Johto, Kanto and Unova! The sprite and pixel graphics really were peak during the here. Yeah, DS era was the best hands down. I also really like 7th gen Sun/Moon/UltraSun/UltraMoon but was never super crazy on gen 6 as a whole.

[@hanes2]

it was a good run, especially since you could play the GBA games on the DS Lite too.

[@manethisthabesticouldthink1289]

I could replay bw2 a very numerous amount of times and have just as much fun each time. Hard to say the same for the switch era.

[@nathanlamont9920]

A lot of people say 3rd gen was the peak, and I agree with that. Especially, we had solid side games such as Colosseum/XD people are still talking about today. Kids who started with gen 4 + 5 are going back playing Colosseum/XD and enjoying them. FR/LG is still the definitive way to play the Gen 1 and Emerald is the definitive Hoenn region game. Yes over ORAS!!! Plus, competitively, it was somewhat balanced due to the lower power level. Kids who started with 4+5 gen is the last group of people who got into Pokémon who likely still play today. And a lot of the big PokeTubers are around the age/started playing on gen 4. Wolfe being the oldest, or at least look around my age. I started back on gen 1, and even I admit that RYB is only playable if you're feeling nostalgic. Gen 1 aged like milk. The only flaw with Gen 3 is the physical/special split which came with Gen 4.

[@Iestynity]

People will always be biased towards what they grew up playing. My first console was the GBA and I grew up playing LG & Sapphire & later Emerald (Gen 1 & 3), so I totally agree with you that Gen 3 was peak Pokemon. Because of that I don't like Gen 2 as much, because even though I had Crystal, the graphics of the GBA games just looked a lot better. IMO I wasn't a fan of the direction Gen 4 took the graphics and started making everything look 3d, and that everything had to have an idle animation.

[@jaykelley103]

FRLG are gen 3 asset flips

[@HighKage97]

Gen 5 is my personal favorite. Bring back the PWT 🗿🍷

[@StrawHatMidas]

I love gen 5 so much :D

[@stephcurran1724]

I’m so privileged to tell people that SoulSilver was my very first Pokémon game I owned 😊😊😊

[@StrawHatMidas]

That is a major flex :D

[@JoeMama-yb8oc]

No love for the spin offs? Mystery dungeon is goated 🥺

[@damianrogowski5519]

Iam sad i have some old pokemon games lying around , but the friends from back in the day i played with dissapeared. Whats the point of still playing without rivals.

[@wmv8996]

I stopped playing pokemon after Sapphire. I'll have to try these out.

[@adamrochester1]

So which is the ultimate game ?

[@StrawHatMidas]

I have a video coming out tomorrow that will answer that :)

[@adamrochester1]

@@StrawHatMidas I haven’t played since I was 11. I’m 32 now lol. Latest one was 2002 for me ruby and sapphire :/. Was going to get emerald or white 2 or platinum or hgss

[@adamrochester1]

@@StrawHatMidas keen to see it

[@StrawHatMidas]

@@adamrochester1 I would start with either HGSS or Black and White 1 personally. Black and white have a weird quirk where they only use pokemon from that region so it would be like starting with red and blue but on more modern hardware. HGSS are also good and have you consistently doing things throughout the game with little to no break. Emerald is really fun but it’s also a bit dated but it’s my personal favorite. I would start with either of the two though and build from there.

[@adamrochester1]

@@StrawHatMidas cool thanks g

[@jimr7065]

Is nobody going to comment how distracting these games' overworld graphics were when running on a Nintendo handheld?

[@swathedpyhton5296]

Black and white 2 is the only pokemon with a challeng mode

[@ashleeramey]

"Now iam broke"😂

[@StrawHatMidas]

i bought pokemon black and now i am homeless (please help)

[@retsel3141]

GB,GBC,GBA & DS game Pokémon is the only Pokémon games that doesn't lag on my mobile phone emulator.

[@ondeado6013]

I bought one of those cartridges with 500 games for Ds and it has all 9 of the games.

[@StrawHatMidas]

I often forget they sell those lol that’s a good deal :D

[@ondeado6013]

@@StrawHatMidas yah dude 😁

[@richardkinier]

for me it was always gen 1-3 cuz i player my first pkmn game when i was 5 (2000) on colour then i got emerald when i was 10 and it was game changer for me.

[@Attackplaya]

I remember watching japanese youtube videos bcz the game always launched there first

[@StrawHatMidas]

You were not alone lol, i did that with black and white 2 a lot lol

[@moritzkoch4766]

I loved every second of Pokemon on ds, especially platinum and its music!

[@Pokéric1986]

Objectively gens 4 and 5 are the best. However, nostalgia can’t be underestimated. Gens 1-3 just hit different

[@ZaysWorlld]

Pokemon could genuinely easily be the biggest game ever again right now if they made an open world survival game similar to pal world game style. with fornite pov. Make all regions. Add all pokémon. And release it on all platforms as in Playstation, Xbox, Pc, Nintendo. Game would be #1 game for as long as gta if done correctly. they could add new pokemon through updates etc and run the online like a gta server . where u can battle friends and go on journeys, compete in tournaments, all in 1 through an open world. 99% that would never happen but potential 🌍

[@Jay89700]

I came back to download white on delta

[@elpuma25]

Started playing Pokemon games and I was able to play the first 5 generation and I can say that B2/W2 was the game I had the most fun, second would be Emerald then Platinum . HGSS was such a dissapointment though considering how good its reputation is.

[@ditz3nfitness]

BLACK AND WHITE HAD THE BEEEEST MUSIC! 🔥🎶

[@MojaveKnight17]

Good times

[@StrawHatMidas]

Right it was an incredible time to be a gamer

[@MrMonkey2475]

3 - 5 was peak pokemon. If your fav pokemon game is either 3, 4 or 5 then you are a true fan. All 3 are s tier gens

[@coughfee1416]

I would like to say that all the Pokemon games from Gen's 1 - 4 would have been meh games without the enhanced versions. This is especially true for Diamond and Pearl as without Platinum, the horribly mismanaged dex is atrocious to play with. Also, almost all of Pokemon X and Y's problems would have been solved with Pokemon Z being released, and I would compare this to Diamond and Pearl. Heart Gold and Soul Silver also forgot to fix the weird level curve (this was the second chance as Crystal exists). Which kinda confuses me as I would not see a reason to not fix it.

[@chinesekangaroo]

Pokemon taught me to dream big, i wouldn't be living in a 7 million dollar apartment in LA if it wasn't for pokemon on the DS.

[@chickenandksivideoreviewer9739]

Shut up