Was the Puppet Already Haunted Before Charlie? (2AM Puppet Cope)

This is what happens when I get too much time on my hands at 2AM. I start over-analyzing the Puppet. Well, if there isn't anymore Puppet content, I guess we're going to have to make our own!
Music:
Through the Cracks - Freddy in Space 2
0:00 Fredbear's Flying Animatronics
1:47 When was the Diner, when was Charlie taken?
3:25 Was the Puppet Already Haunted?
4:18 Henry is an Unreliable Narrator
5:46 The Actual Point
6:02 Wait, the Puppet was the Last Murdered!? (Two Puppet Theory)
7:06 Seeing Things That Aren't There

[@polishscribe674]

Explanation: Scott cannot stop himself from making everything sci-fi. He doesn't care about the fact that FNaF takes place in the 80s while trying to give paranormal stuff scientific explanations.

[@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185]

Realistically,if ghosts did exist there would be an explanation

[@RFDN0]

​@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185 the difference between magic and science is understanding.

[@jimUkay]

💯%

[@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185]

@@RFDN0 Exactly

[@vincentmorris8431]

He decided the most reasonable course of action was to use them all at once in their most abysmal state. (Insert Afton going 50/20)

[@KHWrld999]

Idk what’s more disturbing Henry control shocking his own daughter or some random kid that he believes is his daughter

[@charleswolfe8896]

Speaking of terrible fathers Who do you think is a better father William Afton or gendo ikari

[@casualcommenter7152]

Honestly, the puppet was never haunted. It can just transcend dimensional barriers and perform necromancy. Built different 💪

[@speedyjolteonwarrior6662]

So it’s just like bonnie from fnaf 1?

[@victoriavidaud]

I really love the fact that “transcends dimensional barriers”, “performs necromancy”, and “built different” are all in the same thought. Now I want to make a character with that as the basis 😂

[@speedyjolteonwarrior6662]

@@victoriavidaud There already is one. It’s named flumpty from one night at flumpty’s.

[@Phantom-rh7nc]

It can speedblitz, remember!

[@ManicFiction]

Flumpty Vs Bonnie vs Puppet when???

[@MrsDizazter]

"2AM Puppet Cope" sounds series worthy

[@eduardoaguero1220]

2AM Puppet Cope, the last Puppet coping

[@Sayne7]

honestly i thought it said "2am puppet core" and i thought we'd be treated to a sick new genre of music lmao

[@Midnight_Afton645]

an old victim trying to save a new one

[@Joey-vs4fr]

Absolutely beautiful

[@sweethistortea]

Y’know, I never actually noticed the puppet flew like a fairy until you mentioned it.

[@AcidDreamz666]

She was a fairy

[@redpanda6497]

Imagine him with wings.

[@gaminganimators7000]

She's so dainty!

[@victoree6680]

yeah same, I just took it for granted and paid no attention to it, like "yea it's always been floating :v"

[@TristanThatBoi]

Fredbear’s having animatronics that can just straight up fly is both terrifying and cool

[@clwilliams9276]

N cannon to modern FNAF if u take a look at Eclipse in Ruin 😅. The daycare attendant has strings, Eclipse just flies apparently. The second or maybe 3rd playthrough I watched, pointed that out n I was never able to actually spot the string otherwise. So yeah, flying n floating in modern canon. Pretty sure that also happened in Help Wanted 2 but I don't remember.

[@nathanielgarza9198]

I could see why that was shut down I mean imagine a slender man robot just fly at you for no reason

[@doopdoop9258]

2am puppet cope is such an iconic title

[@soundwave6366]

Now we really need a puppet origin story. Because it always seemed so unnatural. How unbelievably skinny it was, never seeing any endoskeleton or wiring exposed, and it floating around. What truly are you? What makes you so special?

[@tympestbooks1727]

Secretly, the Puppet is haunted by Charlie's from other versions of the timeline, all trying to save both the version they find themself in's Charlie as well as the other missing children. The narrative problem here is that, due to the series being what it is, they can't save anyone.

[@bendy514]

Plot twist: the puppet is actually just a very skinny magicans that just happens to experience high blood pressure and collapse near charlie that night

[@tylerlyons1812]

Honestly, basically everything’s possible in this God damn franchise.

[@ferrofluidfangz]

third option. he was a 🧚🏼‍♂️ fairy ✨

[@tonysonic456]

A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one. Also, the ideas that there's either someone also possessing the Puppet, there's two Puppet, the Puppet time travels somehow, or Charlie never possessed the Puppet at all are ABSOLUTELY INSANE yet perfectly fit the kind of thing FNAF does on a daily basis. The big reason why I love and hate this franchise so much.

[@Rainbow_dash67.]

Or crying child possessing the puppet

[@sutarikun]

I wouldn't put it past the canon to have a second puppet. Perhaps we really do have both a puppet and a marionette!

[@bearinyourwalls]

Honestly, the idea of the Puppet never having been Charlie is great from a horror aspect when you consider the perspective of the potential other spirit. Imagine it was anyone else (likely a kid considering the series we're talking about but not necessarily). Imagine dying and ending up inside of some Puppet and trying to do what you can for other victims in a situation you wouldn't understand as well without the connection to the people involved only to get trapped and repeatedly shocked because some man believes you're his daughter. But you have no idea who he even is and he gives you a speech that's not actually meant for you as he literally sets you on fire. Honestly, with how insistent Henry was about his daughter existing in the way he wanted (at least in the books) he probably would have been willing to convince himself that any kid who looked similar enough to her actually was her. Kinda like what Eleanor did with that one girl (i think her name was Rochelle or something like that idk).

[@AngelTheory-M]

At this point, there so much events not told I don't know where Shadow Bonnie come from There highly possibility Cassidy was the frist one to died, she died in accident at the Circus before fredbear family dinner She is likely the real daughter of William Afton, and Elizabeth was created to replace her, William is trying to rebuild his daughter since the started Cassidy is positive ghost she was there for everyone, the one after william without a doubt is the crying child All games gameplay are made in based in what the vengeful spirit suffer

[@Ozeglion]

Ranelle was the name, so yeah, close enough

[@Ozeglion]

@@AngelTheory-MIn the most respectful way possible, *WHAT?*

[@AngelTheory-M]

@@Ozeglion Elizabeth didn't go in fnaf 6 to help William, but to cut him into pieces, she is one saying to William, "the one you shouldn't have killed" , she is angry because William killed someone she cared During dialogue between OMC and vengeful spirit you can listen William scream for help in the background, he asked for henry and mike help, but not Elizabeth help,even she go there save him, why? Its because the one tormenting William is the vengeful spirit together with Elizabeth Glitchtrap is a anomaly trying to help William afton escape The endo mimic and vanny they want to eliminated glitchtrap Because this whole thing its a game and glitchtrap is breaking He was able to escape thanks Jeremy help in hw2 Cassie whole route in painted yellow signs point the route to the mimic and draw by Vanny for Cassie

[@Ozeglion]

@@AngelTheory-M …That answers nothing You aren’t even explaining anything, you’re just making these claims without even saying how you came to these conclusions in the first place Also, you seem to be forgetting that Elizabeth quite literally said to William that she’d ”make him proud” at the end of Pizza Sim

[@sorrel_leaf_vespers]

"It's 2AM and I haven't slept" I- GO TO BED

[@andtheniforgotit]

"Especially if he's a jester" The 3D security puppet you buy for the simulator part of Fnaf 6 does have some jester hat-like protrusions coming from it's head, and doesn't resemble either pixel depiction of the puppet. Granted, that could be a redesign of the puppet like the Rockstars are redesigns of original Freddy and Friends. Are Sun and Moon really the spiritual successor of the puppet? The puppet has always been associated with children. Whether guarding them or handing out prizes in the prize corner. Now it's been upgraded from child security to a full-on Daycare Attendant (not that it's doing it's job any better, given he kicks Gregory out and throws him to the wolves (though, also granted that was after Gregory narrowly escaped the leopard). Maybe Sun and Moon aren't as out of left field as we thought.

[@g3mkn1ght60]

The 2 am delusion is amazing

[@ggdynfytugfy6892]

I think the general consensus for theories where the puppet is the last one possessed is just that the other kids were wandering spirits and Charlie bound them to the animatronics (there’s a whole thing here connected to that tales story about how ghosts can’t move on until their bodies are found iirc)

[@firefi1960]

I mean, apparently at this point in the series Afton has his super advanced murder clown robots to suck out soul juice, and canonically Bonnie doesn’t abide by the laws of reality, so a flying puppet doesn't sound that farfetched in a world that created Faz-Goo and mimics

[@Bluejayisback]

2AM cope is the best kind of cope.

[@KamdynDoty-Balch]

3 words. What. The. Fuck. On a serious note, this is possible.

[@j.a.m.m]

Another possibility for the "already haunted" part could be that it could still be Charlie, right after dying. We assume that Charlie dies right when the Puppet gets next to her, but maybe the timeline of events could be this: - Charlie is locked outside, the Puppet is not possessed yet, just doing what it's programmed to do - Afton kills Charlie in that dumpster thingy, her spirit moving over to the Puppet - The Puppet is now possessed, and move towards Charlie's corpse (why? I dunno, she just died, cut her some slack) - And finally the Puppet slumps over on Charlie's already dead body. Doesn't really explain the floating part outside tho, but hey, haunted robots and stuff

[@profsrlojohn635]

Classic FNAF, picking apart the smallest details and spiriling it into the massive implications, while also destroying existing beliefs for no apparent purpose! Count the toes! Where’s the strings? Etc. On the two spirits idea, imagine if sammy is canon to the games and they both died and were put in the puppet. Wild. Also, on the death arrangement thing, you might like looking into dual process theory, it’s an interesting video.

[@nepi7847]

there has been a trend of technology in freddy's becoming more rudimentary with time (up until pizza sim), starting off in the 80's if not sooner with springlocks, the funtimes and potentially flying pupets, to then basic endos with facial recognition linked to police databases, to just basic endos with basic suits, and in the end battery powered animatronics

[@kalkuttadrop6371]

6:50 Or the Puppet was the first to actually haunt the animatronics, the others were simply dead til Charlie showed up and remnanted them. That also fits the Candy Cadet thing, Charlie could have focused her power on one kid and fully brought them back to life Eleanor style, but instead she split it amongst the 5 and they haunted the animatronics

[@GFred1983]

0:04 It’s not. The Nightmare animatronics being illusions video was the shortest.

[@That_one_void]

Caption moron has a plan is like 2min long

[@salt_factory7566]

“It would come a little out of left field” talking about Lefty.

[@LiaMakesContent]

this title is insane but I've actually wondered this before a while back but I didn't really have a reason to believe it so I stopped thinking about it

[@jdw1483]

Yes yes yes yes yes yes this has been my head Cannon ever since the retcon got revealed in FNAF 6. Sammy was the first soul in the puppet and then he went and got his sister so either there's two souls in one animatronic or there's a second puppet somewhere that Sammy put his sister soul into. I'm glad I'm finally not alone. When you are controlling the puppet and the minigame, the fact that you're controlling him implies that he's already sentient, which means he's possessed.

[@Lightman0359]

I was gonna say something similar, and Maybe Puppet is so powerful because of having 2 spirits [like good old Fredbear]. Following this rabbit hole, some claim Shadow Freddy is CC manifesting the Springlock Fredbear Suit [or it is his agony] and Golden Freddy is Cassidy in charge [like a Vegeto/Gogeta thing, I have also heard this used to explain purple hat v black hat for Fredbear]. Taken together, Nightmarrionne, Green/FNaF 6 Puppet and blue FNaF 2/3 Puppet could be Agony, Charlie dominant and Sammy dominant.

[@jdw1483]

@@Lightman0359 I like this theory. :)

[@stephaniegagne3376]

Literally commented this before I found this comment

[@jdw1483]

@stephaniegagne3376 Wow! So I'm not the only one who thought of this? Awesome!!

[@andresmorales4045]

It's so funny to think about the fact that the security for a popular restaurant in 1983 was just a flying puppet that was advanced enough to go outside in the rain but not strong enough to pull up some boxes or make any alert or sound for help xd

[@Sirhc_B8207]

I mean... it didn't exactly thrive in the rain either

[@ghost_knight23]

Wait so for 30 years there was just a 6.8ft puppet either walking like a baby giraffe or just straight up flying that’s terrifying

[@Neku628]

Maybe the puppet didn't look like how it was in the 1980s. Maybe it was like a toy plane made to look like the puppet. I am probably reaching. RC airplanes were a thing in the 1980s.

[@thescorpion1012]

i love you theories! and honestly this one could fix the timeline issue of Charlie being the last to die, maybe the puppet got possessed by someone who died at Fall Fest, and that could maybe be the reason behind "a wound first enflicted on me, and one that i let bleed out" possibly Henry's wife, which is why the puppet went to protect his daughter in the alley, and why she helped the other MCI victims, she's a mother trying to protect children, maybe William killed her when she discovered something at Fall Fest.

[@Imtrying_girl]

Damn I’m about this head cannon for sure

[@thescorpion1012]

@Imtrying_girl honestly I love theorising about Fall Fest and the characters from that part of the timeline

[@Imtrying_girl]

@@thescorpion1012 me too! I want more wife lore!!

[@thescorpion1012]

@Imtrying_girl imagine if a Fall Fest game comes out. We finally meet Henry and Williams wives and it gives us so much lore and background on these characters, like maybe William was already tampering with animatronics for some nefarious reason, his wife was blind to it but unknowing to her she was helping him by running the festival, and then Henry's wife caught William up to no good maybe trying to ruin Henry's career, but he tries to stop her from telling people and then he kills her, a fire starts and all the evidence is lost

[@Imtrying_girl]

@@thescorpion1012 Yesss for sure, I think the fire killed Henry’s wife and that’s the wound first inflicted on him. And perhaps they put her in the puppet?

[@chaoticneutral7976]

I remember someone pointed out that Lefty might have eaten the wrong Puppet. Could be a design oversight (kinda like how Mangle is missing their Endo teeth in UCN) but it could be a neat idea to explore. Might even tie into why the Puppet masks no longer has any tear streaks on the Tangle (unless we're supposed to believe that the tear marks vanish once Charlotte was set free). On a different note, I now wonder how Jim Henson is gonna show the Puppet moving in FNAF 2 since it's too skinny for a suit performer. Whether they show them using a string/track mechanism or walking like in Help Wanted, I'll be interested either way

[@bananashoplifter3440]

...Huh. That's a good point. _Now my brain itches_

[@LiperioHK]

How is the Puppet the last, but also the one to gift "life" to the MCI children? I might have an answer to that but there's not a lot of evidence, just some sort of outside the box thinking What I think is misrepresented the most in this debate is that death = immediate possession. We've seen in some Fazbear Fright stories (can't remember which one exactly) that ghosts can linger around as long as their bodies aren't found. What I'm thinking is that maybe Susie was the first victim indeed, but she and the other MCI kids just remained around as ghosts until Charlotte died, at which point she possessed the Puppet first, and then brought the other kids to the animatronics? Idrk to be honest it's also 2am thinking here

[@Blueberrypie62]

usually henry is portrayed as a fucking genius with robotics, but, DAMN, FLYING ANIMATRONICS??? Well, now we know why william was jealous/j

[@user-wt1fn5gb1v]

I do think that there are two puppets, because I think in Security Breach you specifically buy "Security puppet" which is A: differently named then actual puppet. And B: Makes possible sense because the two have different designs.

[@SombraCheeks]

I mean it does seem very emotional... crawling in the rain to be with a dying child. Does not seem that is base programming so probably already haunted yes hehe

[@Imtrying_girl]

I mean, it had green glowing eyes already. Damnit man now I’m rethinking everything

[@jackbrassington3489]

I get the impression Scott knew the puppet was going to play a big role in the core narrative he just didn’t know how. I actually really liked the big twist in fnaf 6 I didn’t see it coming and it was tragic.

[@Quaxophone]

Since I first saw it, The Puppet has always been one of the most fascinating characters in the game to me, and I really hope to see more of them (Him? Her? I've lost track lol) in future installations of this beloved series especially since a large piece of the story seems to fall upon its shoulders!

[@alymatronicdeeare8265]

The name of my band: 2AM Puppet Cope.

[@waggieentertainment9387]

Imagine if in the minigame the puppet had obvious strings and when he gets outside, you have to rip yourself off the strings (by pressing the right and left buttons repeatedly) to flop down to get to charlie in the alley. Or have it where he gets on all fours before slowly having to pull itself with his arms. Helps feed into the whole sad rogue ai thing

[@benjaminstewart8088]

Something I just noticed in the 8-bit mini games. Prier to the child's death, the puppet had rosie cheeks. After their death, the puppet had crying eyes. Does the crying eyes of the puppet means it's possessed?

[@Sirhc_B8207]

That's what I've assumed. Another interesting thing is that the puppet mask on the blob isn't crying

[@DCMarvel2009]

Oh dang, this came as much of a surprise as the big box in the corner of my room. Wait…

[@Sparklingsand]

The puppet is great! I totally understand why you love him, I love him now. I never had a definitive favorite of the fnaf catalog of characters but I know now that he is my favorite. I hope to see him return someday soon.

[@kumgokiri]

puppet my beloved

[@NoahFence736]

Love your content!!!

[@notrealnamenotatall2476]

Thank you! 8D

[@orinwilliams-kh2bz]

Actually, Bonnie is seen levitating in the poster and trailer. Bonnie does not abide the laws of physics

[@iexist_thatsit]

The fact that the Puppet can somehow FLY has bothered me for a while and I'm happy to see I'm not the only one that's being haunted by this detail. Also if Henry really did just delude himself into believing it was Charlie and the twist is executed well then Henry might just go from being my least favorite character to one of my favorites.

[@maahentertainment6307]

Hey yall! Ik this has NOTHING to do with the vidio, but can you guys help me? A few days ago I decided to play fnaf 1 again, and so, I did. But there was an issue, I died to foxy, ON NIGHT ONE. As far as I'm concerned, he comes on night 2 or 3, and then before I died, the "ITS ME" text popped up, but no golden freddy. But the rest was normal. Was my game bugged or am I just dumb? (Nah, this comment got pinned, and got 45 likes? Thank you sm! Also thanks for the responses too❤!)

[@legionbeast]

Foxy NORMALLY doesn't show up on night one UNLESS you NEVER use the camera. There is a hidden timer and if you never use the camera for the night, he bypasses all requirements and attacks.

[@maahentertainment6307]

Thanks! But, I was on cameras and also forgot to mentio, he started on the outside position, so, I guess I'm not stupid 😅

[@simplyhoodie]

@@maahentertainment6307 You just got incredibly unlucky. Foxy has a VERY low chance to move later on in night 1, as for the "it's me" it isn't tied to Golden Freddy, that is just something that has a random chance to happen for the spooks. I'm almost certain I've gotten the it's me during the phone call.

[@maahentertainment6307]

​​@@simplyhoodie 𝕥𝕙𝕒𝕟𝕜 𝕪𝕠𝕦 𝕤𝕞! 𝕀 𝕘𝕦𝕖𝕤𝕤 𝕚𝕞 𝕛𝕦𝕤𝕥 𝕦𝕟- 𝕝𝕦𝕔𝕜𝕪 𝕥𝕙𝕖𝕟 (:

[@acatwithahatt7999]

@@simplyhoodie I'd like to add to this. The "it's me" text and flashing images of Freddy and Bonnie are surprisingly frequent for me, happens up to 5 times each playthrough sometimes multiple times at night. But that's just a small aside, I'd like to mention that Foxy is "disabled" technically up until like 3- or 4 am, I don't really remember which, where his AI value gets increased by 2 or something, meaning that foxy, if the cameras are used sparingly CAN move on night 1, and that happens almost every time I play cause I rarely ever use the camera on night 1. If you don't use the cameras at all on night one Foxy would usually kill you during the ladder half of 4am or early 5am, or not at all if you're really lucky, but as long as the cameras are used sparingly he shouldn't move more than maybe 1 stage. There are many many videos on the AI of fnaf 1 and it's really interesting, so if anyone reads this absolute paragraph of a reply and they haven't checked out the world of "technical fnaf" I'd highly recommend it :D

[@garyzeng2899]

I really like the idea of there being two puppets, especially since they both look distinct, and it's a difference that's long been overlooked

[@akaLiiL]

"Sometimes a story is just a story. You try to read into every little thing and find meaning in everything anyone says, you’ll just drive yourself crazy. Had a friend do it once - wasn’t pretty."

[@Unknown_Geek]

On the "Puppet died last" part; I like Dual Processes' idea that the missing kids didn't fully possess the suits until after Charlie died. She died next to the metal she possessed so once she woke up she would have seen her dead body and understand what's happening. After finding the other spirits, she chooses to stay and help them

[@captainet2457]

This is the most unexpected video to come out at this time!

[@A.B.-ub9un]

CC being the Puppet could still work considering Garrett in the movie.

[@busybeestudios582]

I had an AU where Charlie's mom was an employee that unfortunately suffered a fatal springlock accident that led to her possibly haunting the animatronic that was(possibly) her daughter's favorite, i.e. the puppet in this scenario. Is it accurate? Nah, idk anything about the lore anymore 🙃 But at least it makes a little more sense to me😅

[@JeffTalksALot]

Seeing someone else for the first time question HOW the Puppet can just fly after years of wondering was refreshing

[@zippyzippad]

EVERYONE WAKE UP!!! NOTREALNAME POSTED 🙌🙌 (fr though, i think im addicted to your videos 😭 ive been watching them nonstop all week)

[@b.beanie9580]

I'm glad 2AM Puppet Cope is a common emotion🥲

[@Sayne7]

I thought it said "2am puppet core" and I thought we'd be treated to a sick new genre of music lmao

[@stephaniegagne3376]

Theory: Sammy exists in the game universe as well. He was the first to possess the Puppet. It was him who made it float out to Charlotte’s body

[@Hazamabro]

You can join us Roxy fans hoping she'll just be back good as new and we can all just huddle around and cope together.

[@TRquiet]

The darker tone of this one has me picturing you as a grizzled paranormal detective in the 1930s. It’s raining outside and the ghosts are mad.

[@ccsfstudios2321]

0:11 I find it so adorable how you refer to the puppet as “my baby”.

[@viviennemorgan7217]

puppet is like one of the friendly spirits who came in to give life to every animatronic and decides to split.

[@viviennemorgan7217]

they can even give life to electronics.

[@kalkuttadrop6371]

Phone Guy said it 'could go anywhere' in FNAF 2, and he doesn't know about haunted animatronics until the FNAF 1 era. 1:58 We really don't know that given that the sprite in the mini-game is brown. It's possible it could be, or maybe it's Freddy Fazbears Pizzeria. Maybe it's even like a proto-Freddy location from the early 80s. FreddyBear's Family Pizzeria or something.

[@flamefangstar]

You know, i appreciate your rare use of jump scares. It makes the videos super relaxing

[@your_mate_era7067]

4:38-4:47 has to be one of my favourite snippets from this channel of all time. It was such a casual delivery for a hilarious line I love it

[@BotBartek]

I think i like this 2AM cope already. I would love to have more of those silly talks about brainworming inconsistent stuff

[@chaoraiser2338]

Omg you have no idea how much i've been thinking about this, specifically how is the puppet hovering, and how high can it go, and did it get more air mobility after Charlie possessed it. Can it fly? Will it fly? It's the true mystery of FNAF. Also congrats on being verified, i didn't even notice that.

[@00lizard]

Wow, those are some pretty cool observations! Now I've got a bunch of "what ifs" in my head. Also, I liked when you went off-script. Had me chuckling for a bit!

[@captainhydrodus4616]

I love catching your vids keep it up!

[@Thor-Orion]

The puppet not being Charlotte would be an amazing twist

[@DoggoJacco]

You're one of my favourite channels! So entertaining, "varied" (as far as FNAF goes lol) and it just scratches that theorist itch in my head. Thank you so much for making content!!!!!

[@thefrogthatknows5251]

First thing, that's Freddy's. Cakebear isn't Fredbear, it's Freddy. We know that because the model is always referred to as Freddy and the murders, of which we now know for certain Charlie was the last of, was at a Freddy's, seeing as we know it happened in 1985, with Fredbears closing in 1983 the same year that Freddy's opened. That's Freddy. This is Freddy's. Second, there is an unspoken aspect to the lore that I have been shouting into the void since people started misquoting the books to justify nonsensical theories. In other words, since the books came out. Agony isn't just red flavored remnant. Remnant isn't just soul juice. Agony does not require a soul, or death, or anything. Agony is exactly what it sounds like. It's pain, not human pain, but the pain that an object feels. It's provenance. It's trauma. Pain is an animating force, witnessing something traumatic offers some maligned form of life to the objects that witness it. It's why Spring Bonnie was so intent on killing even before William was sealed inside it. It's why the Funtimes, without being infused with remnant, are so volatile and angry. It's why in that very same minigame Freddy slows to a stop as he watches Charlie die. It's why the puppet continues to drag itself towards her body even though her soul hasn't entered it. There are two steps to hauntings, two very different forms and two very different sides to the animatronics. In one part it is the soul that continues to animate the body. In the other part it is the body itself who, buy some traumatic mechanism, has seen too much, and become aware.

[@The_StripeDH]

What if the second puppet was the security puppet. If it was bought it would be burned with the others and Henry just got which puppet wrong

[@El.fish.the.chocolate]

I have a theory: Fnaf takes place in the same universe as tf2. Think about it, in both universes robots with ai exist even back in the 60s, ghost exist, magic exist, souls exist, hell and heaven exist, there is a way to collect souls, both take place in america and, the most important, scout is the victim of the bite of 87 as god told him. Perfect and we can even say if you want that it is merasmus that is maintaining the souls on earth for his own amusement.

[@quaggy1632]

I genuinely have an obsession with your videos I love them so much, I always somehow check KZbin right after you post it’s like I’ve developed a 6th sense

[@buzalt]

yeah im possessing the puppet

[@HollowNaruto63]

That would be baller if the puppet is just a random person and bro did this under the assumption of doing "good for his daughter "

[@CameronBaxter-bq6oh]

I’d be more than happy to have a second puppet.

[@user-wt1fn5gb1v]

Hey there!!! I love your videos so much!! And your voice is so relaxing!!! Just wanted to say that! :)

[@user-wt1fn5gb1v]

I'd say a specific thing I love to do while watching your vids, but tbh, I love watching your vids anytime!

[@ironicallyedgy7234]

I imagine that, since Henry made the Puppet specially to protect Charlie, that it violently ripped from its strings to get to her, and starting crawling once it left the building. It going from “flying” to “crawling” in the minigame could just be a visual representation of how much the rain screwed it up, as it would be difficult to convey otherwise with such a limiting art style.

[@daryljones9367]

Thanks for the extra video ❤

[@sanek-puppet-463]

My GAAAAAAME theory: What if The Bite of 83 actually happened before Charlie's death, and after Chris(Yeah, I call CC as Chris, cuz this name is cool and very fits to him+CC, Crying Child, Bite Victim & etc are sound stupid and lame, PROBLEMO?😠) died, he actually at first possessed the Puppet himself. He saw how his dad(possibly going crazy due to losing his son. Yeah, I'M STILL wanna believe that Will isn't so jerk, who killed his friend's daughter......just for some stupid remnant) tried to kill Charlie, so he decided to save her, but it was to late. After that, he left the body due to it was broken, and Charlie just possessed instead. Thats how they met each other in afterlife, and become frendz😊

[@user-nn7et5kx9n]

You know i feel like having it be someone else would be cool if henry was more present in the ganes. I dont read the books so if this poped up without the context of the original books, in the games id go... "So they were a nobody?!" I don't think it would be a good idea. I do miss the puppet though. I didn't realize how much I had until it was gone... Rip Charlie... or Evan... or whoever you are.

[@Afton-ph9uw]

I’m probably wrong because idk much about what it says in the books, but it could be Sammy in the puppet before Charlie

[@edslushie570]

I hadn't thought about the floating thing. I suppose if it took place in modern day they could just say it was dangling from a drone.

[@raphyline_2422]

yippeee !!!! i love you so much nottie and more puppet copium is what i needed to keep me alive

[@reject1877623]

You open up with , " my baby" I would say something but ( let me go evil mastermind here for a second.) ( twirling my exaggerated mustache) I read your fanfiction so I know how you feel about the puppet. MUHAHAHAHAHAHAHAhaha haha haha ha ha....... Or at least have a good idea of how you feel about Mari.

[@EnigmaticStationary-gc3of]

Quantum puppet! Quantum puppet! I love these vids that are kind of just talking out ideas. Quality content. Hope you got some sleep afterwards!

[@kiiroiakuma839]

Segway may be? Just imagine full-size Segway with puppet's hands on the handle. Oh, now we have to do something with invisibility technology...

[@cawareyoudoin7379]

I'm all for new ideas, anything to make the theorizing in this franchise interesting and fresh again. And that is a good point, though probably an oversight - by both Scott and the fandom at the time.

[@Crow-uh6mj]

Imagine if one of the spirits was what made Nightmarione, where Henry might had found a way to get his daughter to pass on but had no clue about the other one.

[@scribblpad]

There’s always the possibility that the MCI kids were left rotting in a backroom until Charlie was murdered and subsequently put them in the suits. Or maybe the sprites are symbolic of their souls? William put their bodies in the suits, but it was Charlie who put their remnant into the animatronics. Of course, depending on how you interpret it, that contradicts Henry’s “A wound that was first inflicted onto me.” which in itself contradicts Susie’s “I was the first. I have seen everything.” which- yeah. This franchise is a beautiful, beautiful mess.

[@chaoticsilver8442]

Matpat should make a multi-hour-long reaction to this.

[@tub_so]

I personally really like the time traveling puppet thing tbh, i want that to be canon cause then the puppet could show up in the games without totally retconning the fire