WATCH LIVE: Day 23 - Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial: Amber Heard Takes the Stand Again | E! News

A U.S. judge ruled to have the jury hear Amber Heard's $100 million counter claim against Johnny Depp. Depp's legal team calls witnesses to testify.
Depp is suing Heard for $50 million over a 2018 opt-ed she wrote in The Washington Post describing herself as a "public figure representing domestic abuse" and Johnny claims her article defamed him and cost him Pirates 6. Heard is countersuing Depp for $100 million.
Taking the stand today:
Dr. Richard Gilbert, MD
Julian Ackert, Computer Expert
Dr. Dawn Hughes, Clinical Psychologist
Amber Heard
#JohnnyDepp #AmberHeard #Livestream #ENews
Subscribe: bit.ly/enewssub
About E! News:
The E! News team brings you the latest breaking entertainment, fashion and Pop Culture news. Featuring exclusive segments, celebrity highlights, trend reports and more, the E! News channel is the only destination Pop Culture fans need to stay in the know.
Download The E! News App For The Latest Celebrity News and Trending Videos: eonline.onelink.me/yMtl/4ead5017
Your favorite shows, movies and more are here. Stream now on Peacock. bit.ly/PeacockEEnt
Connect with E! News:
Visit the E! News WEBSITE: eonli.ne/enews
Like E! News on FACEBOOK: / enews
Check out E! News on INSTAGRAM: / enews
Follow E! News on TWITTER: / enews
WATCH LIVE: Day 23 - Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial: Amber Heard Takes the Stand Again | E! News
• WATCH LIVE: Day 15 - J...
/ enews

[@xxxxmimi]

I cannot imagine a victim of physical abuse would taunt and laugh at their abuser the way Amber did. It definitely didnt sound like someone whose afraid of their life.

[@freddysnewchannel8885]

There's a positive side to Amber's attack on Johnny, she's shown the whole world his good nature and integrity.

[@sallymascorro7313]

Yes she has

[@kelsiidaviess]

As a victim of severe mental abuse from an ex boyfriend, to the point where I almost took my own life… it is DISGUSTING to see her get up there and lie like that. Not a single tear came out of her eyes. She needs serious help. She is not right in the head.

[@mcpeewee68]

I've never followed her but tonight peeked at her Instagram. Her poor little baby. She's already abusing her with the name she gave to her. (For real). But I fear for this childs emotional and physical well being...15 yrs from now we'll be hearing SOMETHING

[@primalcritters]

I am with you 100% as a victim of gaslighting and severe psychological and physical abuse buy an axe, I am horrified by how she treats him. She is the abuser

[@SuperWendilou]

I feel your pain babe... I felt the same and did exactly the same.. I tried 5 times to take mine. The last time I nearly did get my wish I was so so very close if I didn't get there when I did I wouldn't be here today.. and well done you for being a survivor .. lots of love from the UK x

[@maggie19ful]

abused victims can be very strong ,she didnt need to tear up,so your measure is if they dont shed a tear they are lying?what bu***S

[@polishlass5067]

She's fueled with hate and revenge. Disgusting. She had literally everything.

[@umulisaj]

Did you ALL see Whitneys reactions when Camille said, “no! I didn’t ask you about anything” 😂😂😂 priceless

[@HeyItsLilly974]

Yes Whitney was cringing when Camille was questioning amber I bet Whitney is coppen heaps of backlash but I think she deserves it by what her and ah friends bludged of jd

[@MariaLopez-oy3ox]

I love how camille can get her to show her real self !

[@marleehenson7712]

The fact she claims she has been asking him for years to leave her alone but yet she admitted to writing the op-ed… 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@robhaskins]

It's amazing how she keeps her composure whenever she's anywhere except for on the stand testifying to one of her lawyers; then she goes into facial contortions and struggling to cry without crying. Then she switches immediately to her usual ice queen status again in cross-examination.

[@itseffinsexxitime]

Crazy how she goes from hysterical to totally stoic once she’s done talking. Not to mention the complete lack of tears lol

[@zNanaKomatsu]

Its because when she acts.. she cant cry

[@charanpritedhami1005]

@@zNanaKomatsu she can’t act either.

[@formerly.informal]

I was wondering if anyone was going to notice the lack of tears.. but she wipes the nose.. not even blotting the eye area is what baffles me...I hope the jury can see what ever they need to see to make whatever determination they need to make.. honestly

[@tiffer3478]

Yes. That’s a clear sign of borderline personality disorder.. which she has. They can change different moods within minutes. Even extreme moods.

[@lisane0201ify]

This is tipical for a person with histrionic personality disorder to act like this and the fake crying too 😪

[@prejzemres8148]

johnny didn't ruin your career he in fact gave you a career and you ruined it yourself

[@LM-ed5dv]

Yes!!! I agree Amber ruined Amber thinking she was the $hi÷ and turns out she aint what she thought and thinks she is. She damaged herself all by herself!! Plus she's obviously a terrible terrible actress considering she can't even produce tears when she is supposedly crying!! 🤣

[@user-ne8dj8qc4d]

Absolutely!

[@kamariamystical8667]

Boom ! Absolutely

[@inhisservicegodis3287]

TRUTH THIS GIRL IS TWISTED AS HECK! JUST ILL BREED

[@thenextscent2075]

Facts!!!!!

[@kayaspencer325]

So bottom line is she admitted to writing the op-ed which is the ENTIRE REASON they're in trial. It's done. She's guilty.

[@deemoneyyy7692]

This is what stumps me! She has said more than once she wrote it and this time she admitted to it being about him

[@elliotnicholas420]

Yes but if she manages to convince people what she wrote is true, then she did nothing wrong

[@notawalnut4873]

She wrote an editorial about her experiences. How can he sue her for 50 mil for that? They were arguing that she didn't write the title that was used online. She wasn't guilty for writing an op-ed, he can't just take money of folk for that. For example the sun called him a wife beater, which was substantially true...and she was his wife 😬😬

[@deemoneyyy7692]

@@notawalnut4873 wait, you genuinely believe her? you don’t see through her lies and bad acting?

[@leahfromcrimia8424]

After 5 years of AH's abuse, JD may have lost it a time or two which is understandable. He painted over her artwork for one, If the jury finds even one act of violence -physical or mental- then she wins.

[@darlenedonoghue-anekwe]

As a retired registered nurse, I understand the language used by Dr Gilbert. He was able to put in layman's terms what the actual injury was, and, most importantly, how it happened. JD's testimony was spot on.

[@rebeccaswift7588]

I'm a DV survivor with PTSD. I can tell she doesn't have PTSD..She doesn't show even the most basic symptoms of it. The audios show she had no fear of Johnny. She taunted him, belittled him, hit him and admitted it although she turned the meaning of those audios around putting herself as the victim..she is so brazen to think those of us who listened to the audios believe she was the one being abused when it was clear she was the abuser..mind boggling.. I did everything I could to not say or do anything to agitate my ex..I waited for him to fall asleep before I'd allow myself to sleep..yet Amber said she took sleeping pills and fell asleep after she was alledgedly brutally beaten, dragged through glass, raped with a bottle, choked and flung across a room landing on a games table with him ontop of her.. after i took a beating I curled up into the fetal position in the corner of my room shaking and crying. I was too afraid to fall asleep..

[@chrissiescovell]

Lol she just wants to leave her alone but she pursues him into the ground. He won't look at her but she can't take her eyes off of him. What piece of work.

[@soniamaria1089]

its been weeks and she’s still as exhausting as the first day ffs she makes me so mad

[@vaijayanti_prememalcolm8160]

That’s what narcs do, run you into the ground

[@stacyyoust]

Um. This is Depp's second lawsuit he'll probably lose. He's not letting go. But, you make excuses for him. Endlessly.

[@ellenmorrison4435]

Exactly but she’s so traumatized she can’t even shed a tear .. what about johnnys kids she wasn’t worried about them and what they had to live with they’re innocent

[@elisa5441]

She's a hypocrite

[@LoveDandD]

She cried to the jury but when Camille interviews her demeanor changes suddenly; she does not cry and gets very snarky. A huge performance just like we heard on those recordings. So sad. Bad actress. I hope the jury is intelligent enough to see through this BS.

[@BR-tl8en]

Because she wasn't prepared for it. She didn't expected the judge will allow Camille Vasques to question her about the things she did. 😏

[@docnasty74]

Don’t talk about my Amber like that. Jk. Team Johnny all the way.

[@melaniekathleen4098]

Exactly. It takes everything in her to keep her temper at bay. Hence why she's screwed herself with admitting that was why she wrote the op-ed. In this cross examination she admitted it was about JD. Did anyone else catch that? IF she was such a "victim" she'd be crying hysterically at even the idea that someone would think she was lying. She wouldn't be sarcastic and have the attitude she has. She's such a joke. I hope this all blows up in her face, she loses and owes JD 50 mil, and her career also goes up in flames. Get back to Texas psycho!!!

[@kno330]

Because Camille dishonour her. Look at Camille's face she is looking at Ambar like she is teasing Ambar.

[@rosejia9303]

She didn’t cry to the jury, she couldn’t shed a tear, just distorting her face to what she thought looked like painful expressions

[@SandyG1966]

It is gobsmacking to watch her avoid admitting when she is incorrect, when questioned about the wine spilled on the floor photo - she just cannot admit when she is incorrect, it really is disturbing to watch, the frustration that goes with conversing with a person like this is intense, I have dealt with people like her in the past and it is nothing short of traumatising because in the end you start feeling like you are an idiot or just plain insane and the self-doubt that grips you is noncompare.........of which none of what she is saying is true, this is a real example of a person who is a professional gas lighter.

[@SisShea]

3:01:21 Right after Amber nails her own coffin by admitting to writing the OpEd about Johnny, her sister Whitney's face says it all. Camille is a brilliant attorney. This was THE moment of the cross exam yesterday.

[@Samantha_b1]

“I’m obviously wearing makeup” *zooms in to show she’s clearly not wearing makeup* “I’m wearing makeup as per usual” *except for the day she went to get the TRO surrounded by papz.* The bruise didn’t even look like a bruise, looked like smudged eyeshadow

[@darktwisty6728]

Someone said that mark p paparazzi took was a nasty zit. 😂

[@bethmaldonado9241]

Smudged around a Damm zit! Lol

[@SuperSexymami1234]

🤣👌

[@jasonhaberski6843]

The pic with her and Rocky? It’s obvious she was NOT wearing make up.

[@Samantha_b1]

@@jasonhaberski6843 yeah exactly

[@LM-ed5dv]

I cant count the times she smirked laughed and smiled throughout this case ! Especially when she was proud of her abuse. Amber is sickening talking and even more to look at.

[@emily6225]

Omg why is everyone saying this. He’s been doing it the entire trial.

[@Alaaxx93]

And how many times has poor little boy Johnny and his team of mean girls had smirked and smiled throughout this case?

[@lululemkowski5468]

@@emily6225 because she is liar and testimony is insane..her white woman tears are disgusting

[@bahamutkod]

@@emily6225 because this is absurd and Heard is the one claiming it's Johnny alone doing it and that she never did -- which is a lie.

[@BR-tl8en]

@@emily6225 The difference is, Emily, JD wasn't there on the stand claiming - not even once - that he never did that. AH, however, was claiming that even though she was smirking and staring at him *the whole time* he testified. You surely do understand the difference, right?

[@acp7489]

Did you all see how Depp’s team stood up when he walked in the courtroom? I mean talk about respect. He respects others And the same respect is received.

[@TIGRESSA73]

He's had celebrity status for such a long time, yet remains humble. AH isn't even close to his status and she acts like her 💩 don't stink! Arrogance up the wazoo! Thats why nobody can stand her. My blood boils and I cringe every time I see her. I wish I could get 5 minutes in the street with her!

[@lesliethompson8552]

How much respect he actually is showing for Amber (miss Heard) her non-respect (Johnny not Mr Depp)

[@clairedionne559]

@@lesliethompson8552 Ownership! Her Johnny... he belongs to her! Always will in her mind...

[@Joohee4]

Myself, and many other true survivors and those of us who truly suffer with PTSD everyday, are deeply hurt by her lies- especially regarding her claims (which have been debunked) of having been an SA and DA survivor. She is the worst type of woman in the world.

[@yordowtahslipenwidmahasban5744]

khloe kardashian's dining table is so cute 😍🤎

[@emily6225]

I’m not hurt.. she most definitely is a survivor of some sort of abuse.

[@emily6225]

Hell the whole world is abusing her. Victims of abuse are literally becoming the abusers by psychologically abusing her. It’s sick and twisted. The whole thing.

[@vickimingus9281]

me too

[@samanchaudhry4958]

the problem with women is they want to win in there miseries too compete with other women bring them down....whatever her injuries are its still abuse, glorifying jhonny depp after all evidence is weird so is her cyber bullying specially in this time when words like emotional and psychological abuse exsist.

[@kittycat10100]

I had an abusive boyfriend years ago. When he wasn't being charming he was arrogant, condescending, stubborn, flippant, moody, dismissive & a liar. One of the parties in this case behaves just like him and it isn't Johnny.

[@kaylalee3577]

So true!! I couldn’t have said it better.

[@ajyoung4530]

Yea its amber heard... Shes awful. Im sorry you were a victim. I was aswell.

[@mistystrickland32]

So true 100% I'm a survivor of abuse and I believe Johnny did not abuser her.

[@cococharney1170]

Man Camille’s tactic to get under ambers skin and show her true colors is phenomenal. What an exquisite attorney.

[@hille422]

I didn't see that at all, Camille seemed snarky and bitchy to me and it seemed Amber got under her skin.

[@TIGRESSA73]

I agree!! I was waiting for AH to lose it! 😆😆😆😆 I love Camille!

[@yanithsaherrera7533]

@@hille422 nope

[@melissajsp]

@@chaenahgleeson60 are you serious? She seemed “jealous” to you? That is really reaching for straws

[@bahamutkod]

@@chaenahgleeson60 wow, you really see and hear only what you want to see and hear it seems...

[@ThaoNguyen-zg7kd]

It's impossible to talk so comfortably about a traumatizing time of your life with such self-righteous aggression and defensiveness and confidence if you truly suffer from PTSD. I fought against depression for years and have coped with it much better now, yet the minute I talk about it, tears come out and block my words. What AH is presenting is a mockery of people who are still struggling out there

[@whiteninja5546]

I am sorry it happened to you and you are right she is making herself victim after all viewers saw her smirking during trial. She really showed us who she is.

[@ronniemat8437]

Yes, they'd have to take me off the stand because words would fail me as can't cry and speak at the same time.

[@ThaoNguyen-zg7kd]

@@ronniemat8437 Yes! it's uncomfortable, unsettling, unease, emotional like hell and even torturing to talk about these things. It's not only the lack of confidence but more of a calm state of mind that stops victims talk about these horrible events AND SHE CAN'T EVEN SHED A DROP OF TEAR then she said she's trying to teach us to freaking speak up.

[@mel3687]

If she suffers from histrionic personality disorder, this can explain the emotional distance/absence. But in terms of discussing traumatizing events--if you relate them enough, you do develop a degree of desensitization--especially if you have undergone significant therapy (which she has a history of doing). And speaking from personal experience, while I can become quite emotional when my (narcissistic) abuser denies culpability, it inspires angry and impatient outbursts with their lack of remorse and honesty rather than a tearful or frightened emotional response. So we can't discount individual personality and any underlying mental health or pharmaceutical influencers (like anxiety or antidepressant medications).

[@ThaoNguyen-zg7kd]

​@@mel3687 I agree with what you said and that is precisely why it doesn't make sense. Had she developed desensitization due to therapy, healing time, meds, she wouldn't have flinched with a poor face upon hearing JD yelling in the recording evidence - which she sure went through multiple times before the trial. Or another time when she jumped at the sight of JD walking towards the stand but in the meantime constantly looking at him and smirking. I also had outbursts of anger towards my abuser, but manipulation, redirection, and clarification are out of the equation during those times. In her testimony, she only got angry when she tried to stand on her ground but then still tried to lead the question more favorably. She faked crying when she said she wanted to be left alone but several minutes later became the fierce warrior who had already gotten over trauma. These reactions are just not consistent

[@sonalikandalkar1534]

amazing to see someone cry so much and not shed a single drop of tear ...LOL

[@Complicated179]

Probably another psychological condition that she'll claim Johnny caused 🙄

[@LM-ed5dv]

Yes !!!

[@lauraalletto1673]

I said the same thing lol

[@ellenmorrison4435]

She’s delusional

[@user-ql4ve5wf8q]

Her acting coach mentioned that AH has always had a hard time crying when she's acting. 🤣😂

[@mylesastinnette6208]

The way she turns on and off her emotions in a nanosecond is crazy.

[@jennicadelgado220]

Johnny doesn’t have millions of people campaigning against her! She has millions of people against her because of HER OWN ACTIONS! She is not a victim. She has obviously been reading tabloids and social media and is now referencing it in her testimony. What a joke

[@carolinacastro2027]

Yeap, I make nasty comments about her ON MY OWN !!! Johnny has nothing to do with it 😉

[@jackrussell3084]

You are exactly a puppet dancing by the pull of strings, watch you dance to the Depp media campaign.

[@jonnanthonymartinez4455]

It's funny how she stops crying when she stops speaking. But when she opens her mouth again instantly goes back to crying

[@MsKayKay1980]

I was thinking the sane thing. She also picks back up where she left off, often repeating "her lines" over. Bizarre...

[@catinheels88]

Excuse me? Did Amber really say that Kate Moss came out the woodwork to support Depp? Wow... It's Kate Moss for goodness sake. What woodwork did she need to come out?

[@RodneyKimbangu]

Talks to the jury and fake-cries, talks to Camille, and fights! Make it make sense!

[@TIGRESSA73]

She's crazy 🤪

[@MsClaudia2013]

That's defense

[@RodneyKimbangu]

@@MsClaudia2013 great. Her defense aged like bread.

[@mistystrickland32]

I am a victim of domestic violence from a past relationship. It makes me wanna vomit when she says she is the voice for domestic violence victims. She is not a victim of abuse she is nothing but a liar. I stand by Johnny 100% I don't need someone like Amber to be a voice for me of domestic violence. She used Johnny and all she wanted was fame from all her lies. I hope she goes down.

[@m42037]

She should've went to jail for perjury

[@AJonez]

How can Amber say that it is "so humiliating" when she has gone out of her way to post pictures and videos of Johnny being passed out with ice cream all over himself, yelling and smashing things, groaning on an airplane etc? She has done everything she can to try to humiliate HIM.

[@selfrespectingfemale6811]

She was determined to get one last chance to abuse him. She really is a psychopath. Johnny got out before he was killed, because I'm sure she would have done so. Scary that she has a child now.

[@jamierodriguez8218]

Dr Hughes sounds so defensive. Dr. Curry was offering professional rebuttal but Dr Hughes, just like her last testimony, with so much emotion as of she was in the room, as if she is defending her daughter. It seems so bogus. All of ambers witnesses were a joke. They all seemed shady, unprofessional, rude, condescending.

[@LM-ed5dv]

Agreed 100% Dr Hughes is very unprofessional about it all. She tries to hard to sound so right and professional but you can't lie when the writing is in black and white right in front of your face. She falsely tested Amber and everyone knows it.

[@CTGirl1500]

Yeah this Dr. Hughes just has a bitchy face. Excuse my language. And she sounds so combative, unprofessional, and angry.

[@MW-mj7li]

Since her case disintegrates in the hands of anyone with a shred of competence, I imagine they have to fish around until someone is finally incompetent enough to defend her. 😏

[@hauhauyeh]

Totally I feel the same way

[@jennicadelgado220]

I said the same thing! Dr Hughes obviously tailored the tests to fit AH narrative and when she was called out for it she became extremely defensive. All of AH witnesses ruined their careers for siding with a liar .

[@slatsnathan2792]

Respect is earned. Make the donations that was withheld for 13 months.

[@denisechavis4820]

That Judge is a spectacular one always had control of her court room and was fair to both sides!!!❤️❤️❤️

[@Scheerzaaah]

As someone who suffers real PTSD and a woman, I find offensive what Heard is doing. And she's making it harder for real victims to be trusted. Shame on you, AH, and hope JD wins!

[@cuarajhyrojayju4397]

Don’t worry depp will win because he has more testimonials evidence he has money he can pay more money talk

[@cuarajhyrojayju4397]

I can’t even remember what I did yesterday and Camille spect Amber to remember in detail what happened 5 years ago

[@OGKENNYD3UCE]

@@cuarajhyrojayju4397 whale I tink she spect her to re member wen she members tings dat sport her clames butt not anyting else at all

[@TheKrazyKrow]

This circus is just horrific to watch. I really thought her acting couldn't get any more cringeworthy. She's brazenly proven me wrong today. Holy ****.

[@margiethomas8]

I really think they should have had Tori Spelling play this part...

[@alexuscapps1854]

If she really wanted to make a tear appear , All she’d have to do is think about how bad of a loss she is fixing to take.

[@lindsayblackmon8129]

How is is EVERYONE except her is lying... I'm so glad his lawyer keeps pointing that out lol

[@Alaaxx93]

Who’s “everyone “ ? you mean Johnny’s employees, almost everyone who witnessed for him were his employees at some point or benefited from him, these are the same yes men who knew of his drug addiction and did nothing to stop it

[@anett2803]

i agree!!! her witnesses couldn’t even keep a straight answer either!!

[@panduhkitteh186]

@@Alaaxx93 she was even calling her own witnesses liars. Lol 😂 HER witnesses and HIS.

[@kayaspencer325]

@@Alaaxx93 Everyone who testified and said different from her testimony are liars, is basically what she keeps saying lol

[@burnsmycookies]

Everything she is "suffering publicly" now is all her own doing. That's what happens when you lie trying to ruin another humans life also know as karma. To even say that "Johnny has solicited millions of people to do on his behalf" to torture her is the biggest crock of crap. Give us some credit, we do have our own minds and can listen and see that she is just a plain liar. She just didn't realize that all her bs and lies would come back to bite her in her butt.

[@mylesastinnette6208]

Good thing they had long weekends. I am sure you saw her rubbing around her eyes a lot and one cheek implant was inflamed during this Trial. Did you see her hands. She’s beating something or someone.

[@BunnyLang]

Where's the girl who was threatened to have her wrist broken? Where is her testimony?

[@KingAlmafi]

I swear her acting is getting worse and worse everytime she goes up 😂

[@LM-ed5dv]

Funny those tears and pity party went away real quick when it wasnt her turn to play victim anymore

[@PMB-if5ls]

I didn’t know I was watching the movie split. When Camille started talking Patricia came out and Penny left 🤣

[@RofuGhost]

😂🤣😂

[@pcyndiap9018]

🤣🤣

[@kayleesykes2739]

The only true emotions she’s shown are when she’s wallowing in self pity. Misery loves company. Her comments belittling Johnny for experiencing joy in the court room is extremely telling of her character.

[@danishkhan-gp9mm]

Exactly what i notice how evil she is

[@taramay8174]

She can't even shed a genuine tear

[@jalandonijom273]

Amber Heard talking about advocating for others by sharing alleged abuse experiences seriously makes my skin crawl. Amber Heard asking Johnny over and over to leave her alone does not really make any sense as she was the one being sued for continually harassing Johnny with her lies, i.e, publishing the oped, etc. Amber Heard blaming Johnny for people turning on her because they (we) see through her malevolence and wickedness is not Johnny’s fault but hers and hers alone. Even now, Ms Heard continues to gaslight and twist the truth to serve her own purposes. What she doesn’t understand is people are not stupid. Underneath the carefully made up facade lurks an evil, calculating excuse for a human that is now being exposed for what she really is.

[@maddyseeks7206]

she called it charity work lol

[@BunnyLang]

A scary woman, indeed. Infuriating, audacious, bully.

[@gollymissholly8791]

It’s called litigation abuse tactics and that’s what Johnny Depp is doing. Look it up.

[@BunnyLang]

@@gollymissholly8791 Wonder why the court took the case...

[@gollymissholly8791]

@@BunnyLang Why did Johnny's legal team choose to make court filings in a state that neither JD nor AH ever resided in- neither during nor after their relationship? Think about it. JD chose this state based on its lax anti-SLAPP laws because most other states don't allow vexatious suits.

[@shilohross3044]

She said she hasn’t been laughing and joking in the court room but she was doing just that hours before her act.

[@katiekonyi896]

Honeslty i think amber lied about 99 percent of everything she tryed to protest About this is sad i hope she gets the help she needs i truly do this is sad

[@Astral_Blaize]

Narcissists love to project and blame

[@jakylaaa_2010]

i guess she forgot there are cameras in the courtroom 😂

[@tonicalilivin5837]

shes sitting with a mountain of evidence but doesnt have picture of all the "cuts" from the glass but only has the pictures of the mirrors

[@LM-ed5dv]

Righhhtttt !!!

[@kayleesykes2739]

“I’m not snickering and laughing this is painful.” Wow how does a big ole heaping spoonful of your own medicine feel! Imagine how torturous it was for JD watching her giggle roll her eyes and obnoxiously chew in the 2016 trial.

[@mel3687]

She was referencing Johnny... who was _supposed_ to be the "misunderstood victim," but instead was evidently enjoying himself immeasurably with his legal team--like a group of mean girls at their cafeteria table, scoffing, sniggering, eye-rolling, head-shaking, laughing, paling-around and the general lack of professionalism displayed by a couple of his attorneys who communicated nonverbally to the jury repeatedly. It seems to me that she _meant_ she was taking this trial seriously (unlike Depp). She was in earnest. She wasn't unconscious of the publicity and general prejudice against her, she knew how she would be projected and perceived. People are stupid--they're fed a narrative and seduced by celebrity worship, and/or project their *own* experiences onto the situation with great bias and close-mindedness. They aren't objective. They're looking for reasons to pull out the torches and pitchforks. I feel bad for her, because she's right.

[@mel3687]

By the way, did you watch her last cross examination (where Camille behaved like an ogre), and her redirect? She was incredibly composed and humble and polite. (she rolled her eyes in exasperation a few times when Camille hurled unfounded accusations but that's it). It was the most genuine display of emotions I've ever seen from her (which is saying a lot, considering how disingenuous her grief comes across. She's angry, not sad. She shouldn't try to misrepresent her emotions). Did you see Johnny's cross examination? Mumbling rudely under his breath, arguing, smirking, scoffing, sniggering, staring fixedly, and laughing after his misogynistic text (calling Amber a cum guzzler, among other things) was read in court? And you're attacking *her*? It boggles the mind. That poor woman has been badly mistreated and misrepresented to the world. Oh, and there was no 2016 trial. The UK trial you seem to be referencing was *Johnnys* libel case against a UK tabloid. Amber was subpoenaed to testify as a witness. So I don't pity him at all. He instigated it

[@kayleesykes2739]

@@mel3687 based on the way you’ve incessantly defended Amber on countless comments I KNOW you’re an abuser. You have a perpetual victim complex and you condone Ambers behavior because you ARE like Amber. To those of us who don’t throw adult temper tantrums and beat up our spouses for not doing what we want you look like a fool.

[@krisskross8524]

@@mel3687 Kaylee Sykes was also referencing the 2016 trial where Amber Heard was snickering, laughing, eating and chewing just like she is referencing johnny depp doing in this trial. So the commenter meant that she's getting a taste of her own medicine and yes it's painful. With regards to your comment of whether JD is taking thisb seriously, we can't clearly say but JD may simply be more at ease in this trial as compared to the 2016 trial because his legal team now are more prepared and clearly it shows in evidences and on how they upheld themselves and JD's testimony during cross examinations and rebuttals.

[@mel3687]

@@krisskross8524 You mean the video deposition she gave? Honestly, after seeing the mountain of evidence including the incriminating admissions in Depp's text messages, I suppose I couldn't fault her. I'd be angry, impatient and dismissive too. She did address her deposition at one point, I remember, and said she wasn't rolling her eyes at the situation but at the attorneys questioning her who, like Camille, apparently expressed ridicule and disbelief and sarcasm. It's really sad. I mean, I went into this slightly biased against her because I heard brief clips of the leaked audio tapes that seemed to showcase her abrasive personality, and I watched short extracts from their deposition for the UK trial b/c they were linked in some article. But then I actually listened to them in their entirety, and followed the trial proceedings. I read the incriminating texts and realized Depp's public persona was a blatant lie. I pretty much experienced the trial exactly as Heard's attorney's presented it in closing statements. And I was sad, because I had liked Depp. I thought he was another Keanu Reeves. But that's obviously not the case.

[@penelopebailey2846]

one moment she is smirking then she's sobbing and begging. This woman is crazy.

[@wandahoward-holmes4825]

Yes, that part! Smh

[@codreaming9304]

Anyone else look forward to hearing the reggae music Johnny is jamming out to every morning?!

[@lululemkowski5468]

What,?? Lol when

[@codreaming9304]

@@lululemkowski5468 When he pulls up to the courthouse in the black SUV every morning. The guy in the front row passenger seat always jumps out before it even comes to a complete stop 😂 and then opens the door for Johnny. You can hear the reggae music blasting. It’s awesome ♥️.

[@goofoffgames8398]

Why why why won't Depp's attorneys point out the sharp edge on his bar countertop? It would answer all their questions..The bar looks like marble and is definitely a 90 degree polish edge...they are sharp..A thrown bottle impacting with the distal joint would cause a crushing injury from the top. The bottle's force would silutanously cause a finger to smash into the sharp countertop edging, which would slice the finger from the underside, all the while preserving the nail. No glass in the wound, no bruising on the top.. Exactly how Depp said it occurred.

[@lululemkowski5468]

And the chip that broke off the bar

[@ilonnaShay]

That's a really good observation

[@anthonyperryman8284]

It was addressed however momentarily

[@roxdarmurray6634]

Agonizing, painful, humiliation that SHE CAUSED!!

[@dealin21s]

When Camille is questioning her, Amber gets upset and all aggressive. When Rottenface gets on the stand she flips the switch in .02 seconds and starts getting emotional. We all know no tears are gonna waste their time coming out of her eyes so I don’t know why she keeps trying to cry. 😂

[@Alaaxx93]

Amber was calm and collected, the only one that looked triggered and upset was the tiktok “lawyer “Camillie, she was unprofessional and had this “mean girl” attitude the whole time.

[@dealin21s]

@@Alaaxx93 Ohhhh, and again, just like in the live chat, you come to Amber’s defense. Camille was no different than what Rottenface was to Johnny yesterday. Who was the aggressor yesterday? Rottenface. Who was the aggressor today? Ms. Turd. Trolling doesn’t trigger me because that’s what trollers want - a reaction. You have a good day and I’m sure we’ll all see you bright and early for the closing arguments.

[@ellenmorrison4435]

Queen Camille exposing Amber again

[@IvoaBettencourt]

@@Alaaxx93 Calm and collected ?! a freak show coming from one person alone you mean …from victim to an arrogant narcissist in a split of a second. when triggered she does it better then Jekyll and Hyde . Her lawyers have been nothing but rude and down right aggressive, belittling JD witnesses the entire trial.

[@GameOver-hs4qs]

Amber is a very troubled woman both emotionally and mentally. She simply needs help. After this case is over, I hope she can get the help she needs.

[@hille422]

Johnny is a very troubled man and has been for a few decades. He simply needs a deep dive into some soul searching help. And when this is over I hope he gets that help he needs as well.

[@carolynmitchell7330]

I worry about the health of her adopted child.

[@taramay8174]

If she admits she has a problem. Then that's the only way she can ever get help

[@LM085]

She’s too narcissistic to think she needs help. She only plays the victim when it suits her.

[@Astral_Blaize]

@@hille422 Johnny has been receiving help and has owned up to his troubles and his "monsters". Also hard to get help and get sober when you lived with someone who won't support you being sober.

[@katburrows7316]

Funny how she stops crying when they object and then she goes back to crying again

[@marizabosquez7926]

AMBER TURD : WELL U ASKED ME ABOUT IT... CAMILLE : NO I DIDNT ASK U ABOUT ANYTHING🤣🤣🤣🤣!

[@paolazamora5405]

Camille is a beast! She’s not letting Amber get away with NADA! Calling her out in ALL her LIES!! I don’t feel not one bit bad for AH she brought this onto herself !!!! Hope she goes down !

[@marizabosquez7926]

@@paolazamora5405 I AGREE 100 % WITH U!

[@sylviajh14]

She admits SHE captured the video of Johnny smashing the cabinets, but claims she has NO idea how TMZ was able to not only obtain a copy, but also acquire the copyright for it? Did someone steal her phone, send the video to TMZ and she knew nothing about it? Give me a break.

[@twiggmister1]

I find it very interesting that she's stating that she has so so so many rules for herself and *everyone* around her on what to say and not to say, what to do and not to do around her To make sure she doesn't have crazy panic attacks and such.. But not one during the trial, where all of her trauma was put out and "lies" about it (that she l claims) and to excruciating details.. And she hasn't had a single panic attack or anything close or resembling it. Just a simple thing I noticed now listening to her testimony. There are others as well.

[@KatrinaMaslow]

I personally am not a victim of SA or DA, so I cannot speak on that standpoint but what I can speak on is Emotional Abuse (EA). I was EA by my father until his passing. I still can't talk about the things he said to me to this day without crying. With it being hard to talk about EA for me I couldn't even begin to comprehend how survivors of SA and DA feel. I hope that this case can help both men and women in these situations to seek out help and use their voice. Amber Heard is a disgrace to the real survivors in the world.

[@pcyndiap9018]

Ten years later and i still can’t talk about my abuse. I was a victim of Sa and Da. It upsets me watching her on the stand.

[@BunnyLang]

I know I hate her for what she's done. I feel like she completely ridiculed me personally as someone who was severely abused and has CPTSD.

[@Lupus_Fighter]

A.H’s attorney is mad hatin’ on Dr. Curry

[@Teaally1913]

She hopes to reclaim… money and power after this is over. Never seen such a waste of taxpayers time!

[@MrSmartyPantsNow]

Camille is on her game today, as always! I love watching this and I can't wait for closing statements!

[@andrenawright8037]

But she broke the restraining order, not him.

[@whitefawn01]

Jonny's injury was more serious than Amber's team wants you to believe. When you look at the x-ray, it's pretty bad and had to be so painful, so how did Jonny hold Amber and beat her!? There's no way he could have even used that hand. Just another of the mountain of lies Amber wants you to believe!!

[@An-xj7tq]

Is it just me or she is much more cocky/arrogant this time than the last time she was on the stand? In my opinion she thinks that she is winning, hence the change in attitude

[@dawnsrayz]

I don't think she thinks she is winning. I think she's being exposed as a fraud and a vindictive, scheming, aggressive person. So, true to form, she's flipped that story and put it on Johnny and the WHOLE WORLD that he/we are all frauds, all vindictive, scheming, aggressive people and she is the victim of all of us and has to defend herself. And that's why she's more arrogant. Remember her personality disorder: she can't take any blame for anything she does that's wrong.

[@ilonnaShay]

Yeah I think she knows she's losing and the anger is her becoming defensive. Coincidentally, she scored very high on defensiveness on the psychological test by Dr Curry. Everything about her is being exposed, it's insanely fascinating to watch lol

[@LS-us1jm]

I think it’s the opposite. She thinks she’s losing so she’s almost being defensive

[@Complicated179]

She obviously got word on her smug and smirkiness cause she got that in check real quick for today... or maybe that was just her getting into her best character.

[@tonicalilivin5837]

thats what i said aswell smh someone told her she was smirking and stuff

[@emily6225]

Dude. He’s been doing that the entire trial.

[@shannaperry4974]

I thought they aren’t supposed to watch anything about the trial? So wouldn’t that be a violation if she is?

[@Complicated179]

@@emily6225 Not while being accused of his vile actions towards her - not like this woman. That hit waaay different whether you admit it or not. She was beyond exaggerated in her demeanor yesterday. There's a time and place for everything and her timing was placed differently from Johnny's. Not the same.

[@Saiyan1229]

@@Complicated179 i couldnt have said it better.

[@Graciefrohst]

Why does it look like she is doing a monologue audition? How did she know that her smirks are captured on camera? Are they allowed to see how they were presented online? It seems she is more concerned how people perceived her more than her own reflections and speak only about it. It is very obvious. I feel bad for those who were really victims of injustice.

[@tonicalilivin5837]

im a make up artist and i have been doing it for 20 years...worked with and in all kinds of lighting...amber testified that in the bathroom it was two different lights on thats why they looked different...we all know those are both the same photos. but what my eye catches is that the reflection of the lights are in the same spot on her nose and forehead...so there is no way that one is the bathroom light and the other is made from the bulbs that goes around the mirror.

[@danielatouch7498]

Also, I noticed that the amount of color was the same in the background as well as the foreground. That photo was definitely altered with saturation. She lied when she said they were two different photos. She should be done, I hope.

[@lindsayblackmon8129]

Which shows at the very least, it was ran thru a filter, which can change all kinds of stuff

[@marthaayalew2505]

I caught that lie too. She photo shopped it.

[@deborahbrown1916]

If I remember right, she said the brighter light was the next day or hours later. Did she just stand there for hours in the same position? How could one replicate the exact angle, position, and exact hair placement with 2 different outcomes....you clearly see the lighting on the right top of her forehead at the exact position in each photo!

[@roxylopez2639]

She said she had makeup on in that photo must be a very great perfect foundation match applied real smoothly she has no eye makeup

[@rickjamesb.]

I loved the interruptions from Camille Vasquez. Every time Turd tried so hard to this time REALLY get crying, she cut off her act 🤣😂

[@hille422]

That showed me that she's not that great of a lawyer, when you ask a question and then don't let them speak, it looks like deceitful. If I was a juror, I'd see right through that crap and have doubts about your client.

[@akee7299]

Camille is rude and expects Amber not to do the same

[@Saiyan1229]

I have a super strong feeling whitney isnt on ambers side but she was forced to testify for her. Ambers got something on her.

[@Astral_Blaize]

Yeah she's also Ambers punching bag

[@anaperez4062]

She said that she wanted Johny to leave her alone but yet she was the one begging him not to leave her wow!!!!!!

[@itsme.dajaaa896]

But when Johnny was describing her attacks on her own sister she was smirking & smiling & giving him the DEATH STARE . girl come tf ooooon! Btw u still aint crying.

[@deemoneyyy7692]

“I’m not snickering and laughing or making jokes” we saw you. It’s recorded lol also platform??? I didn’t even know who she was until this trial 💀

[@laojuelos]

1000000000% agree 😂 i didnt know who she was 😂😂😂

[@laurelflint1866]

Same

[@mistystrickland32]

Yes all she did yesterday was smirk and laugh

[@thebathing8pe300]

There is literally a bruise kit in the bottom left corner of the screen in the photo of Johnny with spilt ice cream on him😂

[@peat_dont_repeat]

What I went through is triple this. I want justice for me

[@tiffanybreazeale7065]

I can't even listen to her anymore. She went from saying the Op-Ed wasn't about him, to she has the right to tell her story. She further stated it was about him and makes a reference to his power. Wow!!! Amber, not only do you appear not credible with ALL of your lies exposed, but you signed a NDA!!!! In my personal opinion, which I know means nothing, I feel like she will be held liable for some of the alleged damages expressed by JD.

[@bubby1flapjack]

I know the main argument she can make is that she wrote the Op-Ed and its true buuuut she's been caught in so many lies that it makes her side seem unreliable.

[@loriw2332]

As Amber is on the stand talking, or crying about how she want her life or her voice back and wants Johnny to leave her alone, my question is: Why don't i see any tears? If that was me talking about someone who have done such miserable things and i was so distraught, i would be crying my eyes out, red face, tears and all. Where are hers?

[@whobitmyname]

It's called acting, and she's terrible at it.

[@edmond4556]

At this point she would call her own mother or child a liar if it goes against her story!! There’s a reason why the whole world don’t believe u amber and it ain’t because where all jd fans !!

[@prejzemres8148]

so she says she brought her publicist to the court parking lot just in case there were paparazzi but she didn't mind to cover up her bruises? and then in the other picture were you can see she has no bruises she says that she covered them up because she was outside? ummmmm doesn't make no sense to me

[@MegaPotp]

Performance of her life!👏

[@ellenmorrison4435]

What a performance and still no tears

[@deborahfollowscornell9007]

How does she know what color suit JD is wearing, to have the same jacket color as Johnny? Seems stocker-ish.

[@lucygooseyy]

That’s what I keep saying .. I’m baffled each time lol

[@qKfairytale]

I hope my ex is following this trial well because he was exactly like AH, and I was made a fool in front of my family, friends, and police. I’m still recovering from PTSD from DV, yet he’s living so freely and “innocently”.

[@hauhauyeh]

Sending love and hugs to you . Plz be safe and healthy and best wishes for you.

[@jackrussell3084]

I think your Ex is more like Depp actually 😂😂😂

[@unataladriana3833]

Wow you need to read your own comment; your ex sounds A LOT like JD

[@m42037]

In what ways, tell us maybe it could help us like me

[@chrissiescovell]

Not sure why the therapist is back to argue for PTSD, when it is not her clinical job diagnose, but an actual psychiatrist DID find a diagnosis... Two!! And an overly exaggerated feigning of PTSD which supports the diagnosis given, and proves she doesn't have PTSD. There's a humongous freaking difference between a board certified psychologist and a licensed psychiatrist* The difference is a nurse able to see someone is sick and an epidemiologist having just completed a thorough exam and investigation

[@Joohee4]

That is such a good point and clarification. I wish Johnnies lawyers would’ve caught on to that…

[@bethmaldonado9241]

Facts! This woman is also defensive as hell which I find extremely unprofessional especially for a board certified psychologist!

[@TIGRESSA73]

Yes and also we've seen how AH is a lying manipulator, she's very capable of manipulating tests and people!! I hope no one hires her so she can deal with her recovery from "abuse", "PTSD" and her "embarrassment " 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄 she's such a lying sack of 🦬💩💩💩💩💩💩

[@gardenroom65]

The judge is the ⭐️

[@breannamcdonald]

So strange that you have damage from what you’ve lived through? But are so eagerly ready to recount every detail without real fear or genuine tears and terror

[@TellTheTruth07041]

I feel like Amber did to little to late with her acting! I don't believe a word that comes out if Amber's mouth, she is a proven liar and the world now knows it. She is suffering bc of her doing, nothing to do with Johnny.

[@kiwasamuels463]

I think she just can’t bare the fact she will have to live in lower class for the rest of her life onwards

[@soniamaria1089]

@@kiwasamuels463 ^💯💯💯💯

[@TellTheTruth07041]

@kiwia Samuels Exactly! That is why she asking for double the amt he is!

[@pimversteegh]

I want her to go free and skip jail time, because I think it would be so much worse for her to be out and have to face the world after this.

[@Magdasvid11]

How quick her crocodile tears subsided and her arrogance kicked in when Camille began questioning her😂

[@thisoneperson8400]

My mother is a domestic abuse surviver. My oldest sister was killed by her abusive husband. My other older sister jumps from one abusive relationship to the next without hesitation. And i hate that for them. I hate that my sister is dead because she wouldnt leave. I hate that my mother had to survive her abuse and become cold and hard as stone because of it. I hate that my other sister cant figure out that there is another way to be loved. All that being said i stand with any woman in an abusive relationship trying to escape. However i believe Amber Heard is simply pretending. And if she is may God have mercy on her soul for what she has done.

[@nolimitkk2715]

Sorry for your lost 🙏🏾🕊

[@brooke3312]

She’s just mad that she was found out. And doesn’t think it’s fair that she can’t get away with it.

[@ellenmorrison4435]

Exactly everyone lies except Ms perfect Amber

[@girlfriday4508]

Omg i know I’m late but clearly she has been on social media…. Yes Amber you absolutely were smirking

[@patw7945]

Camille is so intense as a cross examiner. No hiding from her.

[@akee7299]

She’s rude and unprofessional, she interrupts while Amber is talking yet she expects Amber to do the same

[@codreaming9304]

2:21:10 - she dramatically grabs a tissue for the camera (and the jury/courtroom) to see…..yet doesn’t USE it! 🤔 Can’t wipe away tears that don’t exist, I guess.

[@dbello1542]

I love. The fact she actually says to read the directions but later the attorney goes into the directions and how the test is invalid I it's not done by the standard of the test and Dr Hughes left huge blanks Dr. Curry filled it out correctly it's hilarious how Hughes gets ripped apart for doing everything wrong and the. Only thing they bring up countless times is she interviewed at JD house and tried saying she told her husband about amber and didn't happen muffin gate lmao

[@roxdarmurray6634]

On her TV interview one week after the verdict, she said she was “TERRIFIED” during this cross with Camille.🙄 Does she look terrified..? Or does she look like she’s enjoying this fight… Argumentative, arrogant & abrasive!! LIAR!

[@chrissiescovell]

Lol.... Secret.... She called TMZ to the courthouse so she could pose for the camera, the reporter said it himself, she was to pause and look toward the camera so they could get a picture of the right side of her face

[@cheryl69preston]

No tears. She's an actress and that's just what she is doing, acting!

[@davednz1264]

Badly, even

[@yaxinli6251]

And yet she’s not even good at it

[@giannabiondo3815]

she can remember everything when johnny supposedly “hit” her but when she gets confronted about something SHE did all of a sudden she CANT remember

[@jasonhaberski6843]

Right? I can’t recall 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@AnneettaLife]

1:03:21 are people dumb or just playing dumb? The fact that they had to actually pull up the time and date and name of file that both photos were taken is incredibly funny to me. People defending her are really going to pretend that those two photos are different? I really hope the jury notice the ridiculousness of it all.

[@Montague182]

They dont have to act dumb because they are really dumb. Jury's eating pop-corn, let them be, see how far these group of clown can go. Jury's already had the results before the trial even started. 🤣

[@Samantha_b1]

And the photo of the spilled wine saying it’s from an incident in December AND may? It was the same photo !! Camille is burying her i love it

[@smileyjoewiley8319]

Why is she calling him Johnny, like they are still close, in her story he is abuser. He doesn’t call her by her name but respectfully by the last name because she is past and he is glad she is, he doesn’t want to have any close relationship and you can feel that distance that is normal when you get away from person that you have not good experience or memories with. She is still keeping kind of bone with him like she still has rights to …. I don’t know but it is weird. I would never call abuser the way she call him, in best scenario he would be Mr. Depp.

[@DB.1224]

I totally agree with you.

[@TIGRESSA73]

Trying to play the part like she loves him still and only divorced him due to his abuse 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡 give me a break!!!!

[@sheritadavis9228]

Because she is delusional and clearly can't let go which is strangely weird in my opinion

[@skinnyb111]

How is she going to say she was wearing makeup but it is very clear in that picture she was not wearing makeup? She is ridiculous.

[@raybass1938]

well in the last recorded conversation Johnny warned her this would happen and gave her an out to tell the truth and she refused.