WATCH: Nirmala Sitharaman bluntly counters Rahul Gandhi Over 'Halwa Ceremony' remark

[@vanamala4751]

Nirmala madam, thanks for description of Halva tradition. Youngsters whoever they may be should give respect to that traditional process & elders. Thank you madam.🙏

[@samuelpou1041]

Wasted all her time on Halwa. Now who will say something on the budget? Modi??

[@bimalkumardeb2435]

I am an north indians but I must say South Indians are far more disciplined, honest and responsible.

[@rituraj_1276]

Don't generalise. 🇮🇳

[@tokenno7553]

I am from south part of bharath but first of all I request you to please stop this north india, south india things

[@Hindustani_jaago]

Please don't have North-South divide. We are all Bharatiya Sanatanis

[@bimalkumardeb2435]

@@tokenno7553 your cm is dividing not me and I am just saying North Indians are more open minded.

[@tokenno7553]

@@bimalkumardeb2435 you gave reply to a wrong person my friend

[@rimakumari6299]

What a speech really awesome.last punch line is just mind blowing charity begins at home.😂

[@appukuttan3263]

Nirmala sitharaman is very honest and truthful finance minister which i have ever seen.

[@swaditi1]

Fantastic commentary by Nirmalaji I am too emotional hearing this.

[@JyotiSharma-yp9gj]

Well said Mam 🙏🇮🇳😊

[@appukuttan3263]

She is a great finance minister in the history of India. I respect her, irrespective of political party.

[@RahulGandhiEra]

Kaha se atey hai ye log

[@pradeepkumar-dn6qg]

Arrogance, attitude, shameless

[@SaugataBanerjee-ck9yz]

The " Halwa" comment by Rahul Gandhi is senseless.

[@gurupadappakabbur6648]

Pappu is trying to search stones in pure curd . for each and every thing he comments negatively.

[@Hindustani_jaago]

He is taking opposition duties seriously. Oppose everything - oppose progress in Bharat, oppose Sanatan Dharma, oppose Bharatiya culture and traditions, oppose sense and sensibility.....

[@maryvarghese5718]

Sanghis here

[@pram9132]

Empty vessels make the most sound. !!

[@appukuttan3263]

Good explanation

[@hsejar69]

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 Superb Nirmala Ji

[@jayeshkanhangad4237]

she nailed it😂😂😂😂

[@suryanarayanachennai9415]

Nailed halwa.

[@RahulGandhiEra]

When where lol 😂 I don’t know how you guys are blindly supporting this Budget 2024 ?

[@jayeshkanhangad4237]

Lop is LoL😂😂​@@RahulGandhiEra

[@gurupadappakabbur6648]

Pappu will get clean bould for reverse swing bowling.he is under impression that what ever he omit from his mouth has to be accepted by everyone.gone were the days.now it will not work out.

[@sanaatanviswa]

BHARAT MAATA KI JAI 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@abdulrahamanameen]

😂

[@missionpehlapageair1holypdf]

​@@abdulrahamanameenWhat's up?

[@Hindustani_jaago]

​​@missionpehlapageair1holypdf Jiha__dis will not respect Bharat mata. They will live in other countries and disrespect the culture, religion, and people of that land.

[@sobhanarajendran7065]

Nirmala great lady

[@AITechTalk-hz2tx]

Throw congress out of India who ruled us 60 years but don’t know budget halwa making ceremony process shame on such foolish party

[@parthasarathir2990]

Stupid congress party Rahul Gandhi Stupid talk useless person

[@manotoshdey3020]

I think the matter has been made clear to Mr. Rahul Gandhi, MP

[@hariharanv6684]

Super smt nirmalaji

[@rameshvs5342]

All are shouting .if one speaks no one should not speak? Why disciplines are followed? In parliament?

[@supriyagentes6042]

Ma' am we all know who is corrupt and who is not , it need not be taken personally to say it pains because the wrong doers have no shame. YOU TACKLED THESE WRONG DOERS VERY NICELY

[@pallavibhole4337]

Shameless congies.... Respect for Nirmala ji 🙏

[@ManojKumar-sf7cb]

Very befitting reply to Drama actor Rahul. He knows nothing and very eager to display his ignorance.

[@gurupadappakabbur6648]

He himself has accepted that he is Pappu and inspite of support from his chelas he can not be able to improve his maturity level and dignity.

[@rajs8836]

Halwa ceremony will go on even if congress comes to power and the budget will be even more worst.

[@sreedharanummapilly7019]

Very nice and meaning full answer

[@silkachandane1261]

She is a finance minister not an halwai n don't know how poor n middle class people managing their houses.

[@jaisivaramsivaram258]

if you Want Sonia Made Italy Pizza.😮

[@53randomchannel]

Who started halwa ? That halwai Raul Gandi. Who raised a point of sc,st in halwa ceremony?

[@marvar8497]

@@jaisivaramsivaram258 no pizza, mrs. Modi made dokla.

[@jaisivaramsivaram258]

@@marvar8497 INDIANS OK. With dokla. Halwa. because of Indian Foods. But We Don't want Italian Foods..😄

[@amarnathsharma2908]

Want to live life king.. do not wait for freebies. Work hard

[@bkgi5]

Great information madam 🙏

[@ulhassujayan1316]

FM has given a nice explanation on the halwa making ceremony and given Rahul a befitting reply.

[@sanjay89992]

This lady is very clever. She is so sentimental ..where was this sentiment when you were taxing the poors nd middle class??.. senior citizen ke mediclaim par v tax??!.. madam..you are very clever!!!

[@pradeepnabar]

I am myself a senior citizen. Halva and taxes are two totally different matters. I agree with you that insurance is a tax matter and Rahul, as an LOP, should have argued vehemently on this matter. But that it requires study of budget document. But does he have that ability to do so ? Absolutely not. So, it is easy to pick up such unrelated Halva issue. And here too he comes without preparation not knowing that he himself going to put sand on his empty head. There are many intelligent MPs in Congress who should have been in their own right the LOP. But that will never happen . Because Congress is a Pvt Limited Party

[@sunnybhai6161]

​@@pradeepnabar Are you happy with the current budget first put your house in order then comment about LOP and other matters like Halva , Vada Pav and Papad 😅

[@pram9132]

That is part of the India finance not her personal budget.

[@honestlyspeaking6630]

​@@sunnybhai6161actually LOP should raise these issues of the common people but he is incompetent and any other congress MP should have been LOP. It shouldn't be a family party.

[@shylajavijayan9835]

Excellent presentation Ma'am ❤

[@kanduri-]

Great Mother of Indians NIRMALA Sitharaman ji ,👍🙏🏼. We ❤️ LOVED you all .Jai Bhartha mathaki ,Hara hara MAHADEV 😂

[@sreevidyahariharan1331]

Can Rahul understand budget? No tutor can help him.Dear opposition, select another leader. We respect opposition.

[@Usersd-n5o]

Rahul understand. But FM stick on halwa which is important to her😂

[@RahulGandhiEra]

Do you Lol ?

[@nanjarajshivaiah8985]

modiji know everything, he knows how to avoid radar detection, etc etc, his intelligence list goes on and on...

[@abrahampc9433]

Go ahead mam.

[@yogeshkumar.v.d9954]

But for sure the Govt has to answer ..why do they charge 28%tax on the purchase of Two wheeler and 5%on the purchase of Helicopter...Two wheeler is a very important mode of transportation of our 80% population

[@greenpeace1474]

because helicopter sales are few and two wheelers are in millions , government needs money for development

[@subungsaboro95]

MPs are wasting parliament session time , money by simply making personal attacks on each other!

[@pravatrmishra3001]

Yes you r r8. Those who talks without their turn should be invalid and suspended from session. There should be such rule. How this msg we will sent to hon Modi ji and Hon president, Can any body tell me.

[@satyamvittal8513]

Superb mam. La jawab. It's a good lesson to a bad student.

[@tkjoy7212]

Exllent

[@subhambanerjee1138]

When you provoke Finance Minister

[@balasubramaniann3632]

What a great message, a fitting reply to LOP of RG.. These people don't have rights to talk.. 🙏👍

[@cinia.s7138]

Why Rahul Gandhi wasting the presious time of parliament by raising blunders. He should learn about our Indian culture.

[@balasubramaniann3632]

Charity starts at Home.. A best reply by FM Nirmalaji.. Deserves the fitting reply. 🎉

[@apchengalath4078]

The opposition should be ashamed of their behaviour and conduct in the parliament.

[@sapnajain3121]

I am not even listening to her...busy admiring Anuraag Thakur ji...he is the cutest❤❤❤❤

[@kailashtrivedi6217]

Pain is never taken but to give others

[@lakshmiprasanna5426]

RG doesn’t know our Indian culture. He knows only Italian. He doesn’t deserve Lok Sabha.

[@realageyoga6461]

Pappu the comedian.. very good entertainment item

[@thomasutube1]

If it goes this way orginal Pappu will be withdrawn by A1, A2 and BJP before he reaches 75.

[@nandakumarnair6505]

Hands of Nirmala madam for talking boldly in the midst of these hooligans.

[@Kashroy_]

Kiya mila apko Rahul ji, gajab beijjati 😂

[@geethajoel7132]

Nirmala prepared halwa to be given to the poor and needy through her budget. So she prepared halwa with the affluent and privileged , she being one who didn't contest an election, to hold the post of FM.

[@sapnajain3121]

Anurag Thakurji is so cute❤

[@pallavibhole4337]

Look at the way Rahul is sitting... I am ashamed of, and disappointed with this fellow... I used to think he is at least pure at heart... but he has come out as cunning as a jackal.... wants to divide the country based on caste...

[@Rika_0112]

Why is she concentrating on halwa not on other objections 😢

[@dev_peace_soul]

Why Rahul brought halwa then

[@Rika_0112]

@@dev_peace_soul 😀😀

[@vicentemascarenhas6142]

To make her boss happy

[@RajuYadav-um4hr]

@Rika_0112Because Pappu Sir wants to relate Halwa with Corruption.

[@gurupadappakabbur6648]

Your joker Pappu has raised the issue with out knowing the head and tail of halwa history. He is violating all the norms and values being practiced.

[@annamalairadhakrishnan9063]

Like Subramanian Swamy said Rahul will talk anything without any sense. Dynastic prince craving for power

[@sobhanarajendran7065]

Shame on you Mr Rahul shame shame

[@lissajoe5623]

I thought Nirmalji is a little bit more educated but disappointed from her circastic speech

[@venkatanarayanavuppu9720]

All her speeches, right from the beginning, sarcastic only. Very Poor IQ.

[@sadasiva1282]

It means Rahul a bit less educated.

[@RamReddyRaghu]

Teach lesson to Pappu khan first before lecture others 😢😂😅

[@thomasutube1]

​@@RamReddyRaghu If it goes this way orginal Pappu will be withdrawn by A1, A2 and BJP before he reaches 75.

[@hmrd8555]

Nirmalaji replied perfectly to ideotic joker baffoon Rahul 99

[@golubholu7872]

It's Shame that Rahul is Leader of Opposition

[@gurupadappakabbur6648]

Voter's who have sent their feku leaders are repenting for their blunder mistake commited. Can't help.

[@knsassociates]

Who wants a tradition. We want a good budget.

[@yogeshkumar.v.d9954]

Lady who is FM of our country... Has so much time to talk abt HALWA ...This shows that both the parties has so much time to spend ..this time they wud spend on betterment of the country

[@RajeshK-qg8sy]

During Congis rule mayb Kharges family members might hv prepared halwa... Congress Rahul Gandhi are shameless creeps

[@dharakaranwal6083]

Well done ma’am..👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@suchithrashetty172]

Till date Rahul Gandhi doesn't know why this halwa ceremony doing..he thought it is for everyone..so he is crying mujhe halwa nahi mila nahi mila😂😂

[@lalanray3323]

RaGa = doom dikha ke Bhaga 🐕️

[@nagarajababu9504]

Why don't we make once Rahul Gandhi once Finance Minister of any state... He will know the feeling of making budget

[@MAHENDRA.V]

Mother EARTH❤

[@leelamohanan6513]

Chota Bacharach is asking for halwa , give a little to Bacha with a chota kapada 😂

[@georgekuttyjohn9039]

10 years there was no opposition leader

[@parthasarathidas7241]

Those who are shouting " Honourable" members? My foot.

[@geethakaranth4035]

Very informative regarding halwa being done during budget

[@amarnathsharma2908]

Good finance minister

[@manabtalukdar2098]

What is the response of the LOP and his deputy Gaurav Gogoi to Nirmalasitaraman statement in Parliament .Just being eloquent English speaking protege of 11:22 Macauleys does not further the cause of new Bharat.

[@balachandraks5989]

Rahul should have been to know about the traditionals .has not been trained with your friends of your party workers. Being a Italian you should know 😡😡😡

[@vallabhbhaishah3970]

It is surprising that speaker does not stop members shouting when FM is replying the questions of opposition leader It s insult of Fm

[@deepaksd5157]

Great 👍

[@sumagowda4016]

U r correct mam

[@saneeshkumar999]

Super replay Nirmalaji ❤❤❤❤❤

[@RahulGandhiEra]

This FM is explaining about the process of making Halwa lol She couldn’t even understand the sarcasm behind Halwa Pathetic FM Rahul is not talking Halka he is talking about the most important #Budget understanding. Rahul rightly mentioned that “FM could even understand the basic principles”

[@esnehayadav4978]

Seriously!!! Brother please once again go through Mr. Rahul’s speech. But I must tell you, YOU ARE wAY MORE INTELLIGENT than Mr. Rahul Nehru… “Mr. Rahul is not capable of such analogies”

[@babujinarayanapillai3167]

Pappu is still a Halwa Baby. He is spoiling his name

[@jhumaghatak969]

6:48 Hats off to our finance minister

[@m.karunakarreddy9126]

It's clearly DIVIDED AND RULE POLICY

[@knowledgeispower5007]

Superb lady ❤

[@RajeshKapoor-n8u]

सरकारें कभी-कभी ऐसे कार्यक्रम पेश करती हैं जो नागरिकों को पहले से अघोषित संपत्ति या आय की घोषणा करने की अनुमति देते हैं, अक्सर कम दंड के साथ। इनका उद्देश्य आम तौर पर कर अनुपालन बढ़ाना है। एक बार जब अमीरों को सरकार से चेक वापस मिल जाएगा तो इंडेक्सेशन वापस ले लिया जाएगा, जो उन्होंने नकद में अर्जित किया है, जिससे सफेद लॉन्डरिंग हो जाएगी, उदाहरण के लिए हरियाणा आदि से खरीदी गई एकड़ जमीन। दो साल पहले 1 करोड़ के चेक के लिए किसानों को 99 करोड़ नकद दिए गए थे, अब 100 करोड़ के चेक के लिए इसे अमल में लाया जाएगा। अगले बजट तक केवल 12.5% ​​प्रकार की माफी योजना का भुगतान करके सभी मालिक बनें। फिर मध्यम वर्ग और अधिक खुश! यह एक संभावना है???

[@AnandaLaxmiYoga]

Fantastic speech. You should remove all type of reservation. All st, sc, obc, minority people operate and run flights of congress people who looted India with British and moghale. What is rahul, Priyanka, Sonia cast and are they coming under minority? How come all temple under govt as cash cow? Why not madrasa and missionary

[@ourcreations8644]

Last matter is not halwa, onion

[@siddudodamani3311]

Apriciate madam ji 🎉

[@random3430]

Rahul jee did not complain about halwa ceremony. He is complaining about who were present at the halwa ceremony. Halwa or not middle class ka toh kar dee dhulie nirma jee

[@parameswaryt6660]

💐

[@VEENAPINTO-pz5ue]

Please talk for the future 😊

[@Krishnaexperiences]

ఈ వీడియోను వీక్షించిన తరువాత కూడా ఇంకా కాంగ్రెస్ పార్టీని సమర్ధించే వారు ఆలోచించండి.

[@subhashch.barman5967]

This budget is like a post dated cheque on a crushing bank.

[@kuldeepyadav-gx1bx]

Please madam Talk about what you have done , we have voted you to power not congress , stop blaming them .

[@yamahacalicut6790]

She won't need anyone's comment to understand the need of poor and middle class of India, as she herself is having a life of common man at her house in Chennai. Rahul can only imagine these life in his dreams. Nirmalaji i bow down before your simplicity...

[@malatisaha9238]

Why halwa & not samosa . Again personalised preferences. Just like the budget .It's so sugary, also has dairy ghee. so many con factors,unhealthy - like -diabeties,dairy - suffering of nonhuman animals. To sum up the halwa tradition -jitna gud daloge uthna mitha hoga - that's budget ( is it customised or personalized , or generalized - ?)

[@swapankumarbose3514]

Why didn't FM give a plate of halwa to Rahul?

[@elizabethjohn5087]

Husband will talk nicely.😂😂

[@hmrd8555]

Perfectly replied....

[@kprajendran-oz9bc]

Amul baby wants halva now.. He is crying.

[@samirbanerjee9146]

Why the MP & MLA are not paying tax? You are not paying tax but taking tax from common people bah... very nice. What astonishing system of our country.Opponents also silent in this regard because they are also enjoying the benefits. They are shouting in the parliament to show the people.

[@bmmr]

even those who voted for Modi ji also are shocked with this budget thing, especially honest tax payers

[@SantCvs]

❤

[@vkap123]

( Budget for 2024 ) The Finance minister is completely destroyed the middle class peoples in India . It's a useless Budget. Shame on you.

[@Srisribaburao]

Middle class till your life ends. Want all development but not ready to shell out a single rupee out of your pocket. Let the looter shell out money as well

[@ak18101]

Every one want a piece of halva

[@ZakirHussain-jr2wf]

What a Great Invention by Nirmala Seetharaman. "In Italy Halwa is not made " Doesn't She ashamed to say this Nonsense ? A Well Educated Good Brained Human would not say such Nonsense.

[@charumathisanthanam6783]

Ur Raghul khan talking sense is it?

[@dushyantch]

Worst FM. Worst budget.