Are They Live? BABYMONSTER - ‘Stuck In The Middle’ SPECIAL STAGE Reaction.

[@natasyaayu910]

Maybe not many people notice Ramii's harmonies in the music video, but on this special stage the vocals and harmonies really look really beautiful ❤

[@Poppiizschkrz]

I think there are many people cuz adlibs she it's very clear. 😊

[@Ceritahalu-v4m]

I think so 🤍🤍🤍

[@IanChav]

She is doing amazing live, so good, amazing job Rami!!!

[@elthonbujung7006]

Rami is the best. Her vocality and artistic side. She always did it perfectly.

[@cutine08]

Rami is the best . Her vocality and artistic side she's always did it perfectly that's why i love her 😍😍😍😍😍😍

[@VIIX1991]

I pray that they use Rami's version of ad-lib at the end when they do the re-recording. It's so good I have to watch that part again and again lol.

[@WatchingSundays]

Right? 💯👏👏

[@LalisaAlisya]

Truee

[@hani-rg7sb]

Rami is just insane

[@ArkAngelBP]

Men, rami's vocal and harmony... She is becoming my bias wrecker with chiquita... Im obssesed with her vocals!!!!

[@ArkAngelBP]

My bias is ASA cause she is amazing in everything, for me, she is the real ace of the group, because she is main rapper, lead dancer and for a lot of people her tone and timber is so amazing that can be a vocal perfectly, can compose for herself, and for me, the number one visual with Rora... Ahyeon is good at everything too but for me, she is not the best in anything singing (for me Rami is better) Rapping (ASA and Ruka r better) Dancing (Ruka is better and for me ASA too) and visually everyone has theire preference, but I see a lot of reaction and everyone say ASA and rora and chuquita looks the best visually... Don't get me wrong, I think ahyeon is amazing too and she is going to bring a lot of vocal belt and talent to the group, but she is not the ace for me ...

[@Monsters_off_the-world]

I'm so happy someone finally noticed Rami' talent

[@ณัฐธยาณ์เครือพาน]

Pharita uses very good singing techniques.❤❤

[@joycedduk]

Rami doing adlibs is life itself hahaha

[@astrid4911]

Rami is just spectacular

[@feradacate]

Yes they live that can clearly notice when Chiquita used the mic and rami adlibs at the end. They have a unique vocal.

[@SOOYASKIMJ]

RAMI'S VOCAL ARE INSANE🤯

[@jannellepaculan3480]

Update: Babymonster just posted a behind the scene for this one. I think you're still in doubt if this was indeed live but you'll see that it is live by checking the short behind the scene for this.😅

[@africawai3555]

Thank you for reacting BM for us. My favorite vocal is Pharita, but particular in SITM, i have to admit, Rami and Chiquita both touched my heart.

[@xxprettylittlethings]

Most of Rami’s adlibs are in the studio version too, they’re just buried in the mix. If you listen really carefully you can pick them out

[@pomsiriluck8396]

Pharita's high notes ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@koalakyutie7469]

I love the reactions of different reactors...Rami's adlibs indeed gave new flavor to the song❤

[@princessdream9338]

Pharita is my bias but I love them all❤

[@stacyaldon2833]

Ramiiii bias and stan here ❤❤❤

[@PharitaBabymonster-n4q]

Yes! I think Pharita is perfect👍

[@prinellarob2003]

It's their live vocal , you can hear ad-lib, vocal runs and even harmonizing here which is not audible in studio version. They are really amazing with their vocal power. FYI , YG is the company that let do their artists show their potential if you follow their other artist's live stage you will know it even from Babymonster's predebut evaluation performance.

[@jayee90]

You can also hear harmonizing even though none of the girls has a mic to their face. It may be “live” but it is definitely mixed and mastered and probably had a bunch of takes until it was perfect. However, the girls still sound amazing and not taking away anything from their talent. Just wanted to clarify that it is not truly live raw vocals.

[@ArkAngelBP]

​@@jayee90ovbiusly is not all live, even the best singer in the world do mix live and prerecorded...

[@enemynumber-zm3ug]

i hope they did also its live

[@cristelgracemercado7400]

@@ArkAngelBPit’s live

[@shantanugadakh1131]

​​@@jayee90sorry buddy I have to disagree here.... Having "backtrack" doesn't mean you have to "retake" until it's perfect, you are looking down on girls who have sung much much harder songs in their last evaluation, and as they have to be evaluated back then, it was definitely one take and live. I do agree that it is "mixed and post prod" to a certain degree but that tell us that it was "multi-take" and not "single take". You even put "Maybe" before saying this is live so are you even questioning that this is live performance? Do you think they are like ____ idol (I won't take name cos everyone knows by now) who does lip-syncing and not live?

[@raynxxiaqoh2833]

It is so clean that even if you can see that they are singing live, you still doubt it. That's the exact definition of "unbelievable"

[@taurustar8692]

so trueee afff they are really good!!!!!❤❤❤

[@AshleyRomulo]

Yes esp Pharita she got that studio smooth voice it sounds unreal as live

[@applegracebacquiano2718]

Their voices sent me to ☁️ especially Rami’s way of harmonizing 🥹🤍

[@getgreatstuff88getgreatstu8]

Wow, this is for sure live. I prefer this special stage live version. The girls are exceptional. Tears to my eyes.

[@waewwow_shinewaew6427]

I really like Chiquita and Pharita vocal

[@RamiYa961]

My #Rami I'm so proud😊😊

[@BriggsYoda]

Like some others I’m original Ahyeon bias. But love all the girls they’re so good! I love Rora’s voice. But Rami I’m like OMG I’m dead whatever she wants 😂 And you guys really crack me up 🤣

[@TinaB5]

Rami Harmoni very perfect ❤❤❤❤

[@geggesabsev5206]

If you saw their pre-debut evaluation stages there is no doubt they can sing live well. Here you can clearly hear their breathing, Rami's harmonization is clearer but there were some parts the back up vocals comes from the recorded music but their vocals are live.

[@kittituchpanyaparu9]

RAMI RAMI !!!!

[@ถ.วัวลายตําบลหายยา]

BABYMONSTER...THIS IS MAGICAL.RUKA looks like mulan in the first scene MY GOSH!!!.CHIQUITA Looks like Cinderella and ASA looks like snowwhite.But I'm love soprano voice.PHARITA vocals was immaculate.RAMI's voice really beautiful(Hidden Vocals).RORA's anglic voice melted my heart and she's so super cute ❤❤❤

[@kwanchannelgamer1115]

I love pharita voice❤

[@jcp164]

You are right last part its different than MV, you are the second reactors who notice this. Rami was the mvp on this stage, she did the adlibs at the back. She was the only one who hold the mic around her waist for readiness, and several time she lifted her mic to sing when the other do their part.

[@shantanugadakh1131]

The last part may be "different" but rami was the one who did the adlibs in the M/V as well... Many didn't notice it because of Pharita's high note but if you listen carefully then you can clearly hear Rami in the background

[@Shivan451]

Asa is my bias of BM, i love her vocal tone and her rapping skill are amazing too.

[@LifeByKpop]

Wow, they're killin' it. 😭😭😭 🔥🔥 BABYMONSTER 🔥🔥 Yup, it was VERY live!

[@onehelluvahector]

Rami for sure

[@smithcorbilla7575]

Babymonster can sing live even from the start YG artist are the best when it comes to live performances❤

[@a3_keyal-fatih930]

True

[@Karmahandle]

There is a soft backtrack but it's also live vocals.

[@maypham83]

Everyone did so well with their vocals and hearing them singing live sounds even better than the MV coz you hear their vocals more than the studio version. Rami's vocals on this one really stood out on this stage performance than the MV studio version. They all did an amazing job! Cant wait for Ahyeon though!

[@IanChav]

Honestly sounds even better than the M/V, how are they better live? They are amazing!!!

[@magsss1293]

The backtrack might be loud on some parts, but just watch their behind the scene of this special stage released today, you can hear little difference from their voices in the rehearsal vs studio/recorded version. If you've been following or watching YG artists, they can really show their audience they got talent & skills onstage. It's only the agency that's holding them down.

[@alaizahsamporna9343]

they can do more of that ,they have the talent so why trow a hate with them

[@fel1237]

It’s obviously LIVE!

[@lancecooletamador5629]

Yes absolutely live bro

[@ukiss4ever7]

Guys, do not ever underestimate YG Entertainment. They are VERY, VERY confident in their artists' LIVE Vocals. Don't underestimate them EVER. Their artists ALWAYS sings live. I mean, ALWAYS, unless they have a member with problems with their throats or they're sick, then yes, they have to lipsync to protect their artists' health. But all the time, their artists sing live whether they dance and sing or not.

[@kodthananat]

Rami adlib kill me 100times ❤❤❤

[@armyindonesia8542]

Kau begitu sangat menyukai rami😂

[@archisung6783]

One and only Babymonster ❤❤❤

[@kyleensing4411]

It's livesync 😂😂😂

[@nhie_xx3152]

RUKA ❤ ASA that my love my love my love ~ #SITM #BABYMONSTER

[@IanChav]

I did not notice the "My Love" back and forth between Ruka and Asa in the M/V.

[@everydaybetter5885]

they changed a bit of the note so it sounds different from the studio version.

[@iagreewithyou3478]

There's definitely post prod adjustments here and there, but there's no doubt it's them really singing. I just hope we can hear them acapella or get a behind the scenes clip of them practicing.

[@Alexia-BM7]

🤣

[@katariaxx]

You can definitely see nuances int heir actions that show you they are singing live. Facial and neck muscles moving, breathing, hand movements, the way the shoulders move up and down, the little body movements. All those if you pay enough attention.

[@jimbo3207]

I don't think it was one take performance given the movement of the girls during the video. I split the vocals off the audio track and ran it through a vocal analyzer, it was definitely pitch corrected and some effects added, its not overdone though. Apparently they're releasing a live stage version on the 15th, can't wait for that one.(I think this could be another X hoax as I can't find any reference to the live stage on YG's websites)

[@iagreewithyou3478]

@@jimbo3207 There's a poster in their community posts here in KZbin. Looking forward to the 15th 😍

[@jimbo3207]

awesome@@iagreewithyou3478

[@irawatitrianaable]

they livee i believe it

[@MMDSeoJinYT]

If you want to confirm if it's live or not, react to their behind the scenes of that stage

[@JamesKaneshiroDesignSamurai]

For the ending of the MV, the mix was different and to me at the key change with Pharita's belt had too much processing/filtering on it. If you go back you will hear the same runs and harmonies but because of the mix, Rami's parts didn't shine like it did in this version. The level of the mics were more evened out and so you could hear everyone's voice a lot better. Pharita's belt wasn't overly processed and with that more natural sound made it sound so much better. Now if they got RORA to play the piano for the song or at least a part of the song that would be even more amazing. We know that she can play because you can find clips of her playing at competitions/recitals.

[@ananghermanyhahanang3305]

Rami ❤

[@baemoon401]

Yes of course they doing live !! YG things! singing Live!😱😭

[@mtbwithtfb]

Guys, I just can't pick one. They all have unique vocal flavor that, individually, stands out with me and this live version just sealed it for me. It would be like picking my favorite child. I can't do it. That said, Rami, for her age, has incredible vocal agility and control that I enjoy very much.

[@yanzkie2781]

They have a very good voice that people is getting confused if its live or not. The one part you know is live is ruka pronunciation is not that clear.

[@mtbwithtfb]

100% live. Ad-libs are mostly live. Same as video but music was louder so harder to hear it.

[@KindredSpiritttt]

Ramis wasn't branded for Mariah Rami (Mariah Carey) for nothing hahaha

[@Undmw]

When the teacher asked Who is the vocalist of the group and all the Babymonster members said Me!!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@jetaimesooshi]

I also always question if they're singing live

[@hafeeznazmi9347]

It live vocal bro 🔥

[@hajrahismaidi4082]

Please watch their introduction member in predebut

[@Chisahimada]

Its live, at first you can hear chiquita's voice is deep compared to the original version

[@yourkawaii88]

it's all live 100%

[@ConKhi-gy6wg]

EVERYONE!!!! 🤣

[@WatchingSundays]

Doh‼️

[@Aleanaa25]

라미는 실력파 연습생이에요 맘에 들어요 주목해주세요

[@Alexia-BM7]

Of course it's live, what a stupid question...🤦‍♀ They are BabyMonster, they are not New Jeans, Ive, Aespa or Le Sserafim.....

[@dummypk4753]

🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@Dzai2]

If its yg then its real live..also ygartist don't know how to lipsync,like you can tell from the get go if its not live,guess its cause they are not trained to lipsync that they don't know how to match their lips 😂...

[@mbahmusalto6654]

Ad libs is same with music video, you can check again.

[@taurustar8692]

ruka weak pronounciation, and rami vocal range in the last video proves that they live.. and their breath is not like they do it fake😂

[@Blink_boy2000]

I hate us😒

[@TinaB5]

Rami Harmoni very perfect ❤❤❤❤