We're the APT. & Number one girl stages actually live?

[@Ayushi_789]

Her no.1 girl's performance had me crying so hard

[@ROSIELY-KPOP]

Omg me too!! And the fact that she was probably holding back her tears as well. Ate the studio version fr 🥺

[@Ch14n9]

i also heard she had a bit sore thoart it made my day

[@turbomunch]

Unstable

[@ADITHA8055]

Me also

[@JML_OFFICIAL_]

Rosé sings so well that people doesn't know if it's actually live or lip sync 😮

[@aisha227]

She's Rosè...nothing to prove really

[@himaririku9254]

STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,

[@Jenxworldx]

I didn't ask?​@@himaririku9254

[@Suso-xs5yy]

@@himaririku9254dude stop she’s talking bout something else , I mean I LOVEE them too but don’t put something in something else

[@Matcha_.me-luv]

@@Suso-xs5yythey’re just a bit

[@illegurlmoon730]

To all those jobless haters.... here's our golden vocalist Roseanne Park ✨💜

[@MrLove-666]

Some people hate being jobless? Or was that your limited thinking way of trying to be a white knight and felt the need to avenge Rosé that'll never see this Short? You sure have some spare time to waste at your job

[@himaririku9254]

STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,,

[@Renaichell]

@@MrLove-666YOU ATE THAT UP (love to rosé

[@aminazenha9378]

Her vocals are no Joke she sings very effortlessly Its for the people who said in mama she didn't sing live Her angelic golden voice is very beautiful she sings along with her feelings 💓

[@himaririku9254]

STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,,,

[@aminazenha9378]

@@himaririku9254 didn't ask

[@BushraKhan-w9b5o]

And the giggles when she was going on the stage 😂 Rosé gave a tight slap to haters without saying anything 🤣😌

[@someone2992]

The "girl in your eyeeeeseeeeeeeseeeeee" part live was heaven😭😭😭😭😭

[@himaririku9254]

STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,

[@Blinky_pink444]

No no no @himaririku9254

[@evaunger5785]

She is sooo amazing n awesome n her live vocals r so heartwarming that it makes me lose tears everytime 🩷love you Rosé 🌹

[@ethnikistar]

Proud to stan her nonstop since day one ❤🎉❤🎉 Fansés, it's our time 🎉

[@TahirMehmood-m4s]

Her vocals are not a joke ,now its proved that the even sound good with just a piano

[@ærina.æ]

✨ GOLDEN VOICE. ✨

[@bella-isacbella-isac6914]

Her voice and vocal is good enough to getting better day by day ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Kittkide]

Rosè again and again slaps haters but still they gonna hate how shameless 😂😂😂

[@deadinside-i3h]

Bro someone literally said that it's pre recorded 😂lmao our Rosie sang so good some haters can't believe in their ears. 😂

[@coquetteflop]

@@deadinside-i3h Girl haters have nothing else to do, jobless fr.

[@소공자-i8y]

로제 멋짐~

[@Kingchristopher-96]

I am so proud of her, my tears down when looking this video 😭

[@Savageblink_girly]

She is awesome 🩷🩷

[@Bareh843]

She is talented.

[@eunxkpop]

she also giggled when she got up ❤

[@Gaeul147]

There is nothing to prove. Rosé sings live, not like others

[@Di.neshaa]

Not like others?

[@sumsumiho]

​@@Di.neshaawell yes

[@frankminlal8983]

​@@Di.neshaaYES

[@Di.neshaa]

@@Gaeul147 what do you mean?

[@chan.____]

Lol everyone sings live in BLACKPINK except that lisa

[@sakurateppei]

I'm just a casual listener..but her number 1 girl here got me hooked. the raw emotions projected through the screen and I felt it!..It is live for sure

[@Ayushi_789]

Rosé and youngji's voice complement each other so well💖

[@imagine_3026]

We love Rosé❤

[@wangy8939]

You release good music and you have the vocal chops and gift of singing to deliver your own songs...thank you for pushing out something that is heartfelt and convincing...not a waste of time

[@anvivarakhedkar1305]

Wowwwww❤❤❤❤❤

[@Iheartkpop_4ever]

Her performances were just🤭✨👌🏻❤️

[@rvlixsiaaaaa]

I can't believe that people still have the audacity to even think that this girl would not sing live?? I mean bruh that's ROSÉ , what do you take her for!

[@deadinside-i3h]

Fr girl i saw people on Instagram saying it is pre recorded 😂next level delulu people

[@Ayushi_789]

​@@deadinside-i3h like literally bro They think that the laugh in apt is also pre recorded😂

[@josnaakhter1717]

@@Ayushi_789 WTH! BRO I SWEAR THEY ARE TAKING DELUSIONAL TO NEXT LEVEL

[@Iamadiva--ot7]

Bruh she's Rosè! Lipsyncing is not in her blood ❤

[@Zenith-27x]

I thought today this channel would claim they had fans singing in the studio & that she exhaled in the studio. Even chuckling during apt in studio.💀

[@misjam8309]

Her live vocal is Awesome 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@OKOJIEEJIOSEYE]

Because it was pre-recorded (In MAMA) doesn't mean she lipsync I don't get people reason for hate cause it is beginning to sound like they just hate for nothing So happy she proved them wrong now

[@H__K-f9e]

All she need is a mic and she slayss💕

[@akilahuwacu523]

Golden voice of Korea for a reasonnnn❤❤❤

[@k-popclouds]

Rosé sing live only ❤

[@netishamondal8019]

She now looks healthy er than before ❤

[@hxrry.diaries]

She's ROSÉ. Like a rose. Perfect ♡

[@김은정-k3m]

로제 목소리 깡패 느무 좋아

[@cherrycheese.]

The golden voice girl of Korea🥺

[@blcxie]

Our rosie proved she the main vocal! 😭🎀

[@Kpop_loveies]

@rosiely you missed one thing When she went to lee youngji she was seen laughing and it was heard in the microphone

[@deadinside-i3h]

Yes, i was going to say that.

[@Astile03]

Guys I am going to Seoul this December since I passed my audition round wish me luck … meet u guys soon as an idol ❤ just wanted to share the happy news

[@loveyakubu5862]

Congratulations 🎉👏❤ Wish you all the best 😊

[@Beauty_black_.X]

Ohhh!! Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations Congratulations B Congratulations Im your 1st fan if u become idol plz don't forget me❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@_Gojosaturo_JjK]

Go for ittt girllllllllll>>>>>

[@mittalpatel2496]

Good Luck, 😊 Which company did you audition for?

[@pushpalatha3496]

Good luck girl , don't forget us when you become famous okay ? ✨️

[@g-nicttn4477]

She had throat pain this day. She’s fantastic and her voice is so good ❤

[@anjanapisharodyr-1247]

Rosè the 10 has 100% live vocal no doubt😂❤

[@AaradhyahVashishtha]

My no. 1 girl is the best! Love you rosieee 🌷✨

[@Zeliazzzz]

She could sing directly into their ears and they would still think it's not live.

[@boicecarat]

fyi, this show is totally live as always, so its only the real singer who can attend 🥰

[@gamergirl8786]

I never knew a song will make me feel like this i mean from the day it has released nd when i first heard it 😔 i cried bc uk i also wanted someone to love like i am his one nd only 😢 it hurts 😭🤕

[@TI7MEENA]

Her voice is gonna make me cry😭 🥺

[@k--pop9518]

Replying to haters who said she can't sing great Ex after mama2024 😊😊😊😊😊

[@homeofjuliebee]

Best Girl Rosé🫶🏼

[@yourfuture5307]

Even her mama performance is also live, but in private stage. Idk why haters spread rumors that they're lipsync lol.

[@Defendsonly5111]

That "hater" is this channel owner only She's the only one on while yt saying so

[@yourfuture5307]

@@Defendsonly5111 oh really? Lol I thought this channel's owner is different 😂 Idk why many people and creator didn't thinking before saying

[@ΔημήτρηςΒλατάς-β5ε]

YG when I see you. Dude has the golden voice of Korea hidden away for Manu years. She could be in IU or Taeyeon level if only she was given the right offers.

[@cherrycheese.]

One thing is Blackpink members are expert in proving the haters wrong 🤭

[@cyuan-ig6do]

👏👏👏👏👏😍💯

[@skiblu8268]

her live singing makes me fall in love with number one girl song! fall in love at the first sight ❤ more than the music video 😂

[@SalmaJann-z3w]

I Love you rose ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤APT song ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@K4teHERE]

Rosé cmon dont be sad just for those haters Here's a compliment for u ❤*You are beautiful the way you are*❤ *There are many haters in the world ,. ignore them* Pretty people loves u Ugly people hates u *Dont make ur life sad just fir some Stupids in your life* Problems are the part of life so chill Keep in mind 20% hates u BUT 200% loves you!! Hope you like it!!❤ We all are here to support🤞🤞 you!!

[@tanawat5197]

you literally hear her jumping and singing and laughing and shi this girl is like a singing prodigy, see can sing better live than many artists

[@Eiko00-x5h]

ROSE I LOVE YOU 🥰 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@VnextKim]

She can sing unlike other Members, for sure.

[@ch-ti9cy]

There's no need to question it, unless she used backtrack. But she didn't use any here. So it's easier to tell that she's 100% live. Only idiots say no

[@thankunext3378]

I feel like Rosé saw the critics about her last performance being pre-recorded and was like: "I will show them" LMAO Her vocals are amazing❤

[@hangannguyen1009]

Live 100%

[@keisehellen6727]

Rosé is my uted, girl you're my number one forever like forever❤❤❤❤ in my eyes is only you

[@bryancruz710]

i think in showbiz there are different level of "live" , maybe depends in the budget of show organizers for talent fees and miscellaneous element, i think this is live and very raw, very simple venue , and showband. this performance is actually a different FIRE on its own.

[@Pegela_Bhutia]

Really rose and lipsyncing c'mon she is the golden voice 💗🌠

[@Jay-kv9xc]

She must be the only KPop idol who don’t lip sync? 😂

[@조범기-d8o]

❤

[@stevennewton3469]

Rosé ❤

[@Rorablink]

Of course it is LIVE

[@NeonKue]

Pretty obvious it’s live as you can hear how she switches up the flow and cadence.

[@rxx.Samira]

She also giggled in apt which you could hear

[@sf5838]

Lmao. The fact that u even have to do a video like this to prove it was live is insane. You gotta leave those idiots alone who will criticize any little thing she does because they dont have anything good going on in their lives

[@Jack-hm1hu]

Yes, they were live. And even if it wasn’t she proved it in many other live performances how good her voice is. Nothing to prove tbh.

[@ZoriNikolova]

It's a fact that Rose can sing beautiful but Lisa doesn't that's why she gets criticism

[@fernandaserna-n4o]

I do thing that in th two performances there was some type of filter in her voice it could be add in post production or even in the mic. Bp often uses mics with filters in their concerts

[@marksmith1226]

Rosé killing the game and haters hate to see her succeed. lol

[@Selene_kinda]

Trust me guys! She's Rosé...

[@toanduongngoc7160]

You could hear her laugh in APT. performance so end of story LOL

[@AnnaBrown99]

She was overshadowed by lisa and jennie in bp. But now she can shine perfectly

[@noorhidayahabdulsukor1139]

she's definitely singging live. Rose had a sore throat that day, and you can hear her voice sounding raspy but beautiful.

[@Tanisha-n8q]

rose is the best singer in the whole kpop industry

[@shawnbrent1165]

Everyone knows Rosie can sing live really well

[@Joohyuniex]

If its pre recorded then the audience member did really well lip syncing 🤡 (sarcasm by the way)😂 Its so obvious its live😂

[@jungsu_]

You have to be deaf to think she isn't singing live. Is anyone really thinking that?

[@deshna91011]

I can see her real voice out a little bit.. ❤

[@yourfuture5307]

A little bit? Wdym?

[@deshna91011]

​@@yourfuture5307if you had seen rosé's and gd collaboration, there her voice is different from present, a bit deeper and when you see here, at some places her voice gets deeper like earlier..

[@yourfuture5307]

@@deshna91011 both are her natural voice, it's just about how she opened her mouth, like wider or smaller. Her voice gets deep when she sings a low note, and thinner when she sings high/mid note. I'm so tired seeing people who said she used real/fake voice. She can use any of voice whatever she wants, whatever technique she wants, whatever she needs as long as her voice's type still the same

[@deshna91011]

@@yourfuture5307 I'm not telling about real and fake, ik both are real, but I'm just comparing it with earlier

[@yourfuture5307]

@deshna91011 okai cool 👍🏻

[@zxcvbnmzxcvbnm9254]

SORRY WHATTTTT SORYY WHATT

[@MyAngelRose-h5j]

We don’t need evidence, she ate all sing in every where

[@BTSInUrArea_XG_ATEEZ]

I literally got into a whole argument with a hater on the Number One Girl performance because they said she wasn't singing live 😒🙄 all the stuff said in this video is basically what I told them because they had some lame excuse going to everybody's comment and wording it differently, haters are so blinded by hate it's truly embarrassing 😂

[@S.W.H-x6x]

I can’t believe that some people still think she’s lip syncing😂 it’s so obviously live

[@belle_aame]

Idk if the haters are dumb or the idols who messed up lipsync that they cant differentiate a live performance from the recorded one🙆‍♀️

[@biank1816]

Number one*

[@The4pinksforlife]

She finally got rid of the nasal singing, bring rosie deep voice back!!!

[@Dina-zb2cv]

But haters still said she's lipsync in this show along with youngji lmao 🤣

[@sakshi1148]

Sing so good that people think u are lip syncing 😂

[@Janiah1320]

Also when people sing their stomach will show it

[@lilionlyy]

No need for proof. We just need ears!

[@buephom7430]

Ur will always be no one girl😢❤

[@stvrlighttrikii]

Mother is afraid of lipsync

[@yvonnemaryinasua9093]

What’s your point??? Whether it was LIVE or not but at least Rosie can sing what about u!

[@PratibhaBinni]

People need to understand rose is golden vocalist ofcourse she is. Queen of vocal but as human we need to thing about Lisa she is rapper not a vocalist but atlist she trying to sing for Lilies ....and she is not just singing she always doing something extra for Lilies ...she showing dancing skills even she can sing and Rap perfect way sometime she is stop because she need breath ... And Hatters calld she lypsisces without any reson they just want to hate her Even Lisa always trying to help so many people she donating everytime she donating palestine people .she is pure soul gyus pllss dont hate spread love about Lisa .....

[@cmoageneralmerchandisecmoa8084]

bruno mars be better tho 😂😂😂