We Should Not Use Ash'ari's Argument To Prove Islam! Shamsi Raihan & Visitors Speakers Corner SamDa

[@shakibhussain6931]

I know this Brother Raihan Personally and He is one of the most Kindest and Smart people I have ever met. I am truly thankful to Allah for having a friend like Raihan and anyone who knows him should feel honoured too. May Allah bless and Preserve Raihan.

[@OHA2468]

Mashallah, I recently stumbled upon him while watching this channel; the way he speaks presents his claims and proves his points is wonderful, mashallah.

[@neomatrix4965]

Alhamdulillah that this brothers can see how much brother shamsi is very knowledgeable in islam and actually humble and always speaks Quran said the prophet said and sunna machallah might Allah award you and protect you brother and more brothers follow you for sake of Allah

[@abdullahassaffah]

He is a deviant madkhali who blindly justifies Abu khadeejah spub crime including money fraud and women grooming

[@h.h.4699]

So Happy to hear this from Raihan ma sha allah

[@udaramalam7348]

Shaikhul Islaam Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullaah) said at the end of his life: ”I regret losing most of my time in other than studying the meanings (or explanations) of the Qur’aan.” Edit : ilm kalam is dangerous no doubt about it, the point of this comment was even ibn taymiyah regrets wasting his time, study quran is more beneficial than refuting them

[@mamadouba4876]

i think you made a mistake it wasn't IBN Taymiyah but it was KHAZALLI who was regretting to have spend the entire of his life learning ILM ALKALAM and also ABOU AL MAANIN AL DJOUWAYNI and others but not IBN TAYMIYTAA

[@aburaffa9922]

I think it's imam al ghazali regret not ibn taymiyyah.

[@udaramalam7348]

both were regrets (rahimahummallah)

[@mamadouba4876]

@@udaramalam7348 yes but IBN TAYMIYATTA wasn't among them as i explained in my first comment but anyway they repented afer like ALHASSAN ALASHARII

[@udaramalam7348]

@@mamadouba4876 agree

[@abdullahmahmud1298]

Alhumdullillah..... I am Salafi.....follow the Quran and sunnah according to the understand of the Salaf - e - salaheen I am from Bangladesh

[@sharulshah1979]

You follow wahabi understand

[@wardboxer6895]

@@sharulshah1979 aren't you tired already. Switch up to sth else

[@udaramalam7348]

​​@@wardboxer6895 bārakallahu fīkum, brother let him show his character

[@abdullahmahmud1298]

@@sharulshah1979 the sign of misguided sect (ahlul bidah) is to slander Ahlus sunnah by calling them wahabi, madkhali

[@Fvrside]

Alhamdulilah Akhi, a lot of Biddah in Bd. Glad to hear the followers are in BD.

[@AbdulMalik-oy6wv]

I'm happy these brothers talk Allahouma bareek lahoum

[@irfanlokhandwala4823]

This was such a nice video to watch This should happen more dialogue between our Muslim brothers at the park and might help to clear out a lot things

[@hermithmza]

16:45 The true etymology of the word Philosophy

[@HussainFahmy]

*_Hyde Park visitors can learn more from Sheikh Shamsi_*

[@MustafaE-g8f]

Love from Turks inshallah

[@user-ew1xu4wq4k]

The brother in the 2nd part of the video sounds very scorned… a lot of men don’t want to be a man at all once they get married. The fact that he can’t admit that shows he’s in denial. He sounds like a full on red pill guy. Blaming woman 24/7…

[@hamzanocap]

So-called daees, aiming to follow in the footsteps of Allah's Prophets, are uncertain in Allah's existence. Embarrassing, further humiliation for the ahlul kalaam.

[@ummerfarooq5383]

17:00 had no one Egypt realised that the word Philosophy comes from the name yusuf

[@ummerfarooq5383]

Philosophy has been taken over by polytheists. In Philosophy time is three but according to hadith qudsi no.4 Allah is time. And Allah is one.

[@ummerfarooq5383]

11:30 - I translate philosophy as فعل yusuf.

[@thundafundamentalist]

The only person better than Shamsi on speakers corner against Atheists is Anwar Ghanbouri DUS dawah!

[@sharkyh7327]

He was the very good, very articulate. He knew their arguments and used the Qur’aan and sunnah to prove the the existence of the Allah Azzawajal

[@ummerfarooq5383]

9:50 - Allah says be and it is Allah is not your being.

[@abdullahanselin8474]

Asalamualaikum would the advice be to address these questions from athesits to be quote quran to them? Does anyone have any common verses to quote addressing common arguments. JazakAllah khair

[@hamzanocap]

Surah Zumar has many verses suited to addreseing the doubts of the atheists. Surah Furqan is another chapter with many thought provoking verses that are suited for mankind in general. If the person is sincere then there is no harm in quoting verses directly but it is best to start off with utilising the arguments Allah uses in paraphrase.

[@abdullahanselin8474]

@@hamzanocap JazakAllah khair

[@saudasiri6019]

That guy talking about feminine men coming to hajj he trying to blame saudi as if the country can prevent them

[@humzdon4life]

So what I got from this video is we cannot use philosophy to an atheist? How do we prove god to an atheist then cuz they don't believe in a scripture like the Qur'an genuine question?

[@NoNames824]

Call them to Allah still my brother. Nothing wrong with using analogies as long as they fall in line with the Quran and the Sunnah. You don’t have to stoop to their way of argumentation because it leads to confusion. Calling to Tawheed is the first thing that you must do.

[@norazly6845]

We don t follow ibnu Taimiyah and Muhammad bin Abd Wahab brooo

[@Mustaza5]

Who is ibnu taimiyah. Only salafis knew him. Is like no other scholars better than him....😂😂

[@ummerfarooq5383]

23:20 Allah's curse be on women who put on makeup aswell

[@twatik]

Dont curse the living, especially not women who wear makeup ... Ask Allah to guide them, many Muslim women wear makeup, ask Allah to guide them and us all barakAllah feek

[@Mustaza5]

Ilm kalam is like others branch of knowledge. To reject it 100% is crazy as it is part of our life. If salafi reject it ok but to call maturity and ashaari misguided is a big claim.

[@ihtishammahmood197]

I don’t think you guys have enough knowledge to debate the Asharis

[@opposingbaatil]

yes because the Asharis have too much knowledge ,that's why they rejected some of the Attributes of Allah. Make sense right.

[@ihtishammahmood197]

@@opposingbaatil wat attributes of Allah have they rejected

[@opposingbaatil]

@@ihtishammahmood197 you are asking me this question and you are talking about knowledge? Please , what is this?

[@ihtishammahmood197]

@@opposingbaatil bro prove your claim I have not cme across such things 🤦🏻

[@MustafaE-g8f]

1 God +1 God +1 God = 3 Gods, Maths

[@twatik]

"B-bu-but math is man made!"☠️ Logic is man made according to man worshippers

[@ashifhassan1148]

Asharis has more giant scholars than Atharis. I don't think contingency argument goes against Quran. Everything depends on Allah. And ie the conclusion contingency argument gives us.

[@denohart4929]

Brother the prophet (pbuh) didn’t come with a contingency argument, Islam isn’t here to prove there is a Creator, everyone already knows their is a Creator deep within, Islam came to negate ALL false deities brother.

[@AK_UK_]

​@@denohart4929 and what if someone doesn't beleive in Allah? You can't simply state that it's natural for him to do so, when he believes otherwise.

[@ashifhassan1148]

@@denohart4929 In order to do that we must use different types of knowledge as the current modern world is super advanced. I am only suggesting to use contingency argument to arrive at a necessary being. I am not saying to define the attributes of Allah using contingency argument.

[@mohammadhoujeiry]

​@@ashifhassan1148 and how can you explain this necessarily being is allah and how can you explain that his attributes are eternal, this nonsense has nothing to do with knowledge allah say in the quran in surah mulk about the people of Hell fire, they say if we use our knowledge and hearing we wouldn't be of the people of hell (و قالوا لو كنا نيمع او نعقل ما كنا من أصحاب السعير) and that is clear prove that they don't use sound reasoning and knowledge, brother some people are arrogant and joining these arguments will only entertain them allah say were they created out of nothing or were they their own creators, allah asks us to look in our creation he give examples about sun and moon and their movement allah give example about us about animals and clearly their is wisdom and laws and rules in this world, islam came with the perfect way of living there is alot of Prophecies in islam that is happening u can use all of that these are the quran and sunnah arguments if someone dont want to accept them leave them, sorry for my bad English i hope u understand me

[@ashifhassan1148]

@@mohammadhoujeiry You don't get my point. After it has been established that there must be a necessary being then we will explain that necessary being is Allah according to Quran and Sunnah. We only define his names and attributes of Allah according to what he has revealed.