We Watched Every Episode of Star Trek TOS (Full Series Discussion)

[@targetaudience]

Watch ALL of our Star Trek Reactions --> kzbin.info/aero/PL5Pso33oqJDh42SaJFX3kdl1ZkBea3gxc

[@RLucas3000]

There IS Star Trek from the 60s you’ve not seen yet, as far as I know, and I believe it’s available on youtube! In the 70s, you used to have to go to conventions to see it! Any guesses yet?? It’s the infamous Blooper Reels! Every season for the cast party at the end, the editors would assemble a blooper reel for the cast and crew to watch and enjoy. Don’t pass up the opportunity to react to these. Your fans will love it I’m sure.

[@Nomorage]

BTW, there is a Mirror Mirror sequel episode in Star Trek Continues entitled "Fairest of Them All." It has a hilarious intro as well.

[@Daniel-Strain]

Oh boy, on what you'd like to see more of - just wait for TNG :)

[@talynstarburst2l2l2l]

I just finished Stat Trek Continues after reading all the recommendations here.. I highly recommend it as it fills the gaps between the show and the movies with an amazing finale.

[@cdfreester]

"It's not what we thought it was. It was more." I don't think any TV show could expect a better compliment than that. It's been so much fun watching you guys come along for the Star Trek ride and watch you seeing this beloved show through fresh eyes. Well done, gentlemen. Keep it up!

[@neillio]

For Political intrigue you'll love DS9, it's got more political intrigue than you can handle. For Courtroom drama you're gonna love TNG. "Lawyer" Picard is a trope that never gets old.

[@GamingTheSystems1]

Thank you for making these videos. I look forward to YEARS of more Star Trek reactions from you two.

[@portland-182]

Just remember this was budget squeezed series, made weekly. They can't stop, or they will miss their delivery dates. The fact that so many of the episodes are so good, speaks to the hard work of all involved. I'm so glad you loved it, all the different series have great episodes, even the animated version. Politics and religion, are the meat and potatoes of DS9

[@Serai3]

People keep saying the budget was tight, and it was, but only because what they wanted to do was so expensive. It was actually one of the highest budgeted shows for its time, sometimes pushing $200K for an episode. This was huge bucks for TV in the 60's. So no, it was not a cheap show at all. It only looks cheap now because we've lost the art of imagination as an audience, and demand that everything look hyper-realistic or it gets rejected as subpar. Back then, it didn't matter that you knew the Gorn was a guy in a suit, because realism wasn't the point - the _story_ was the point. The story was the point in all of science fiction. It was only when FX jumped several levels with the advent of CGI that story began to take a back seat to yaya, and scifi stopped being about challenging the intellect of the reader, and became about entertaining the dwindling attention span of the audience, a completely different proposition and one that need not have anything to do with the intellect. In its way, it has set science fiction back sixty years, back to when it was considered silly fluff for kids or weirdoes, and not a serious way of exploring real world issues.

[@nunyabizness6595]

Good point. The original Outer Limits and Twilight Zone were made on shoestring budgets but still have alot more resonance today, withstanding the test of time. 😮😮😮

[@portland-182]

@@Serai3 I think the money people from the studio budgeted it as a 'normal' TV hour without realizing everything had to be built. They did not have experience with science fiction. The price for the season was set before a frame was shot, and the production team had to get in all the shows made within that contractual sum. That put a budget squeeze on the show right out of the gate. Part of the NBC / Roddenberry conflict was that every time they tried to save money with a 'bottle show' (using just existing sets), the production would get the 'more alien planets' complaint, which were the most expensive shows to make.

[@Serai3]

@@nunyabizness6595 Really? You consider The Zanti Misfits to be more relevant than Star Trek? Wow. Okay, whatever.

[@mikejankowski6321]

Regarding what you would have liked to see more of...TNG, DS9, Voyager, and Enterprise will satisfy you on pretty much all counts. And the movies - we can't forget the movies. I am so looking forward to more content from you!

[@daniel385]

This is why I watch you guys -- I've seen these episodes 100+ times and I never came close to fully appreciating the dramatic reveal of the woman's blindness in that episode. You made me see how special it was. Shatner's reaction is perfection. (FYI -- "Takei" rhymes with "toupee.")

[@Serai3]

_(FYI -- "Takei" rhymes with "toupee.")_ ISWYDT

[@pauld6967]

I hear you Alex & Josh with your list of "I'd like to see...." and being spoiler-free all I can do is smile & say keep watching the shows, TAS, TNG, DS9, etc. & movies. I think your persistence will be rewarded. :-)

[@eddos8303]

I am very excited for you to go into TNG, because there is another TNG Review Show on KZbin, but they rip almost every Episode to pieces, so i hope to see more of your positivity with TNG! (If you like it that is)

[@Sarbury12]

With just the original cast, you get to look forward to 3 films that are masterpieces, 2 that are very very good, and 1 that is such a train wreck that it’s insanely rewatchable.

[@LaBlueStateGirl]

There was a fan made MST-3000 style VHS that was circulating around in the 90s that was a parody of The Undiscovered Country and it was up there with the best episodes of the real show. It was so funny that it made repeat watching a lot of fun. I wish I knew how to get ahold of it again because I have such good memories of watching with friends. Even the "usual places" on line have had no results.

[@komradewirelesscaller6716]

The remastered episodes had some real highlights.

[@jasonthedave6140]

This is a great way to describe the 6 og Trek films.

[@montylc2001]

Which one is the trainwreck? I think i know, but I'm curious as to which one.

[@jasonthedave6140]

@@montylc2001 I assume he's referring to ST5, which I agree with.

[@davidradich9342]

You guys need to watch the fan series "Star Trek Continues".

[@Vulcanerd]

The hole/gape you feel after finishing TOS, I get, but it's also another series that's so easy to just pop on in the background as your work, clean, do chores, etc. Trek is never too far!

[@reichensperger1847]

For those who've been with you for the past 79 episodes, this discussion was a genuine delight. It was fascinating to hear your comments about wishing there had been an Uhura-centered episode, or a Sulu-centered one. The sad thing is that they diminished as the "Big Three" came to dominate over the run of the series. We gradually lost those little scenes where we got to see them away from their posts on the bridge, like Uhura hanging out with Sulu in the botany lab ("Man Trap"), Uhura playfully teasing Spock in the rec room ("Charlie X"), or Yeoman Rand trying to fix Charlie X up with a date in the same episode, I think as you revisit the first season you'll be pleasantly surprised to see the greater depth that the crew got (including guest helmsmen like Bailey, Stiles, Riley, etc.) With gratitude for a year of great insight, wit and charm.

[@brandonflorida1092]

"Let's get the hell out of here" was very risque for TV of the time.

[@jamesalexander5623]

Star Trek TOS started when I was in Junior High and then High School. I was there from night one. And from what you say you liked most about TOS and what you will like to see in TNG .... You are going to Blown Away X's 1000. Politics, Romulans, Klingons and their Cultures in Depth. Star Fleet, The Borg ... And of course Q and Data! You're going to have so much to explore and discuss. TNG actually enhanced my Life!

[@uclagymnastx-ing]

When you mention about never again having the feel of 60's era Trek and about a sequel episode and how you'd like to have seen more of the "Mirror, Mirror" episode and its characters......You two really should jump ahead to Star Trek Continues. It really is well-done, respectful, and true to the spirit and feel of the original series, down to special effects and camera angles as well as storylines. Once you get past the jarring effect of seeing other actors in the iconic roles, it truly does feel like you are watching lost episodes from the 60s, completing the Enterprise's 5 yr mission, with the last episode leading us into the Motion Picture.

[@tomyoung9049]

Grew up loving this series. Even watching these thru the 70s it many times seemed so much better then other sci-fi of the time.

[@ScarlettM]

17:45 - "The Vulcan Academy Murders" and "The IDIC Epidemic" - two wonderful Star Trek stories and they have a lot of Spock's parents and Vulcan.

[@anthonybernacchi2732]

Just to clarify, those are both Star Trek novels by the author Jean Lorrah. "The Vulcan Academy Murders" was published in 1984 and "The IDIC Epidemic" in 1988, but they both take place during the TOS/TAS era, so you could read them in the near future if they catch your interest. I never read either of them; IIRC, my late mother enjoyed "The Vulcan Academy Murders."

[@allanrose3661]

Can't wait for you guys to get back to more Star Trek reactions. Great stuff from you as always.

[@MatthewCaunsfield]

This was such a super fun series, I really enjoyed experienced TOS afresh through your eyes.

[@nicholasbartonlaw341]

Of course, the great thing is because the original series had so many classic episodes, it is immensely re-watchable. You can revisit a TOS episode in the future and it will be just as thrilling, but now it will seem more like meeting up with an old friend for some fun reminiscing, rather than meeting a new and mysterious acquaintance. I can honestly say having watched some episodes more than I can count, my favorites never get old.

[@scgreek1114]

It's funny how as you addressed your favorite aspects of the show, such as more political intrigue and star fleet's inner workings, I would immediately think of specific TNG episodes. That's gonna be a wild ride!

[@Bjy001]

Aye aye Captains! REPORT: VELOCITY STATUS UPDATE: As per my calculations at Warp 2 (2ep/wk) it will take nearly 2 years to travel through TAS, TNG and the TOS movies alone. An additional 4.28 years for destinations DS9, VOY and ENT. Not accounting for the occasional shore leave of course. I dinnae wish to rush the Captains but the orphans on Planet Super Nova urgently need those medical supplies ever since some buffoon talked their computer into blowing itself up. Trek well Captains Lt. Bjy OOD

[@momokomiyafuji396]

It occurred to me that you may not have realized…if you continue to watch in actual release order there will come a point where you are watching TNG and DS9 at the same time. DS9 first aired in January of 93 and TNG ended in May of 94. And again an overlap with Voyager first airing in January of 95 and DS9 ending in June of 99. I double dog dare you guys to watch both each week like we did in the real world 😁

[@mikejankowski6321]

I recently got the DVDs and binged them in that airdate order. Wow, satisfying!

[@fakecubed]

Airdate order is the best way to watch Star Trek, at least in the TNG->ENT era. I think TOS can be watched sort of at any time.

[@gregoryfloriolli9031]

“We’ll never compare a feature series to TOS.” Fast forward to the future where you guys ask the question every Trekkie asks, “Kirk or Picard?”

[@mikejankowski6321]

I have a tee shirt of 10 reasons why Kirk is better than Picard. It starts with Hair!

[@fakecubed]

I'm really looking forward to "Kirk or Picard or Sisko?"

[@blacbraun]

A lot of people say the 2nd season was the best but I think the later part of the 1st season is the peak. Episodes like "City of the Edge of Forever" and others show the series hitting it's stride.

[@rustyshackleford4609]

I can't wait for you guys to see TNG & DS9

[@Drakoni23]

Without saying too much: You talking about all the things you want to see more of, you're in for a treat. Funny thing for me is, I started to binge TNG only a few weeks ago. And I kept thinking of what your reaction to some of what is happening might be :D Looking forward to see if I got some things right that you'll like/dislike.

[@sergioaccioly5219]

There's this old saying (among mathematicians, I believe) that if you fire an infinite number of bullets at an infinite number of targets, eventually you'll hit Beethoven. Most of the things you'd like to see again show up will show up... eventually. You might have to wait some five hundred episodes, but you'll get there. It was a good run, I wonder if you'll be able to go through all those Episodes (777 and counting - plus TOS, 11 movies and Short treks ).

[@komradewirelesscaller6716]

Batman and Star Trek. My two favorite shows from the 1960's!

[@kschneyer]

Something important to remember about the fuzzy-looking planets-from-space that we see in the original FX in TOS. It wasn't that the technology didn't exist to make the planets more detailed; they could have done that if they'd wanted to. This is how planets *actually* *looked* in photos of telescopic views. (By this time we'd had some orbiters around Mars, but they'd only ever sent B&W photos.) The Voyager missions of 1977-1986 were our first look at how planets really appeared close-up, and they changed SF TV views forever.

[@robphillips1797]

You guys are awesome!

[@ldifalco2010]

Completely agree with your take on the original effects. I have long said that adding new effects took away from the show in that we do not get to see just what those hard working special effects crew were able to do with no computers or high definition cameras. With just a shoestring budget, they had to build models from scratch, using opticals, lighting, and a whole bunch of tricks that have long been forgotten. When you consider that this was done before the ground breaking effects of 2001: A Space Odyssey, a movie with a huge budget, it just makes those original TOS effects so much more special.

[@moviesciencereview7071]

Regarding Uhura. There was supposedly a Uhura heavy episode that never got filmed but was proposed and scripted. It was called, "Portrait in Black and White". But pushback from the network due to it's subject matter meant it couldn't get filmed.

[@ScarlettM]

I greatly enjoyed your Star Trek reactions! You gave me hope that younger and younger generations will still be able to fully appreciate the genius of Star Trek.

[@UncleUncleRj]

Great job guys. As far as the JJ Abrams films, I hated them at first until I watched the first one again and realized it was one of the best written Star Trek stories out there, giving us an alternate timeline without messing up the canon we all love. This also means potentially more content with the new timeline.

[@jamesbarrington6244]

I would like to see your reaction to a British show from the sixties, The Prisoner. If nothing else check out the first episode, it gives you the basic premise. For the era it gives an interesting comment on society and the role of the government. The show is about a spy “forced” into retirement.

[@dirus3142]

Good to hear what you want to see more of in Star Trek. The Next Generation, and Deep Space 9 series does exactly what you want. You learn more about the Federation, Star Fleet, and other races. Two of the best episodes of TNG are court room style stories. The Klingons get fleshed out a lot in later TNG, and DS9 episodes because of the character Worf. While DS9 explore the Ferengi, Cardasian, and Bajorin people. TNG, and DS9 also over lap with there seasons. The 90s were a golden age of Star Trek.

[@CeeJaey31]

I’d also add that DS9 has an episode titled “inter arma enim silent leges” (In time of war the law falls silent) That’s a morally/political story that hits me every time

[@MisterGoblin65]

That 26 minutes just flew by.....could have easily listened to you guys for an hour 😂...Thank you both for revisting this classic!

[@exhistoriascientia]

Nichelle Nichols spoke about her frustration with scenes getting cut and her character being ignored and placed the blame on the network who feared her character wouldn't/wasn't well-received in a certain market, ie. the South. NBC even refused to offer her a full contract and tried to buy out her contract in order to keep her off the air. When her agent called her one day in that first season to tell her, she asked what it meant and her agent simply told her, "Gene [Roddenberry] says don't worry." "What does that mean?" she replied and the agent just reiterated, "Gene says he'll take care of it; don't worry and just show up to work like normal." She did just that and found nothing had changed. What she didn't know at the time is that Roddenberry hired her as a guest start instead, the salary of which was higher than her recurring supporting contract. Plus, because Matt Jeffries had designed the Communications station to be right behind the Captain's chair (logical since the Captain needed to have that station in close proximity in a crisis), it meant that Uhura was always in almost every shot of Kirk in the command chair. As a guest star, she was paid for every moment on screen even if it was just her elbow visible behind Shatner. In this manner, Nichelle made more money than she had been and Roddenberry bled the executives for far, far more money than they'd have had to pay out if they'd just let her earlier contract stand. Not only did he keep her on the show, Roddenberry made them pay for their cowardly attempt to keep her off-screen. By the end of the season, she was given a regular supporting role contract like Doohan or Takei.

[@eddos8303]

Wow! I hated Roddenberry before reading this, it was eye opening!

[@christopherb501]

@@eddos8303 Like Stan Lee, Roddenberry was a perverted, complicated figure who ultimately did more good than bad. Still iffy in places.

[@jjs2351]

Thanks, guys. I really enjoyed your reactions, opinions, and thoughts about each show, even when they didn't jive with mine. Seeing each episode come up on patreon was a real treat. When you do Next Gen, understand that it took the series awhile to get going. The same goes for DS9.

[@minispy9770]

TNG did get remastered effects but it only really enhanced the quality of the existing shots. This was a hard thing to do and extremely expensive which is why DS9 and Voyager didn't get remastered in this way I think.

[@t.p.s.musicacademy9301]

The reason DS9 and Voyager haven’t been remastered is because they used early cgi (not the style of ILM Quad Printing like TNG), which I believe has a quality of only 420ip. The cgi elements can’t be upscaled to 4K resolution - or atleast several years ago could not. With Ai now, who knows 🤷‍♂️

[@samsonau8205]

At some point, I'd like to see you guys review some of the fan-made TOS films. ST Continues and ST: New Voyages are the two most prominent ones. ST: Exeter was surprisingly different and good too. These are very much like the 4th season we never got.

[@anduinelungoldagnir7766]

I binge-watched your Star Trek reactions over the past couple of weeks, and I am delighted to hear you're going to continue on to the films and other series. You guys are, quite simply, fun to hang out with and I'm looking forward to seeing how the first few seasons of TNG stack up against TOS in your estimation.

[@eddstarr2185]

That final scene in, "The Squire of Gothos", where Trelane is arguing with his parents. Mom and dad want Trelane to come inside and Trelane wants to continue to play with his pets. I recall the father saying, "humans are superior to us - they have feelings". If I remember this correctly then it's the first time I've ever heard an alien recognize, and respect, a unique quality in humanity.

[@chrisboerger465]

Around the time of Next Gen, DS9, Voyager, I remember reading that George Takei was rallying for a Sulu-centered series where he was the captain of his own ship. I would have loved this, but the producers blackballed it...maybe because Takei was such an outspoken critic of Shatner, etc ? Just a guess. At any rate, a lost opportunity.

[@jamessatter7418]

The animated series gives Uhura a spotlight episode, which you might like!

[@KeplersDream]

Based on certain comments you made, now I'm looking forward even more to your reactions to Star Trek 2 and 3.

[@GeraldWalls]

23:20 Scotty gets his Extra Episode (and a damn good one) in TNG. Relics (S6E4). The classic line is revisted: "It is green." (The lack of contraction is intentional and you'll understand when you get there.)

[@ChrisS-no3ft]

You guys should definitely watch Star Trek Continues, a fan-made show of unbelievable quality with great fan actors portraying the original roles, with James Doohan’s own son, Chris, playing the role of scotty. They duplicated the sets, the lighting, AND the quality storytelling that made it great. It’s supposed to “finish” the rest of the 5-year mission, and actually gives the series a proper finale that flows perfectly right into Star Trek:The Motion Picture. You’ll be impressed. There are some actual guest stars you will recognize!

[@joepolymath2308]

I wholeheartedly second this suggestion.

[@ChrisS-no3ft]

@@joepolymath2308 Thanks! They did a great job. Its literally like it was made in 1960’s.

[@MrDeathpilot]

12:15 "I would love to see more of the political drama...." 16:15 "I would love to see another "Mirror Mirror" type episode..." You're going to love DS-9.

[@kurtl8425]

Enterprise has a great take on the mirror universe too.

[@richelliott9320]

Yes the glowing face groaning did scare the crap out of me in 1967 I was 7 also the Beloc puppet too I ran and turned off the tv before he showed up at the end of the credits when I could. No remotes in those days lol

[@larry6360]

It was a lot of fun guys. There's still some great stories in the other shows. TOS definitely is like lightning in a bottle due to the era it was made in. The other shows are cool in their own right. DS9 is a personal favorite of mine, hope you can get to it at some point. It has some great writing and a much more interconnected and arc driven episodes, plus many great characters. ✌️

[@commandosolo1266]

"I would like to see more of the political drama." "I'd like to see more of Starfleet, how it operates." Laying in a course for Deep Space Nine.

[@Welsh_Dragon756]

If there is one thing that I think is great about modern streaming shows is that an episode can be as long or as short as it needs to be to tell the story. No more having to fit it into an exact time. Not all shows take advantage of this though.

[@rymerster]

You’ll get most of what you are wishing for in TAS, the TOS movies and TNG. The TOS movies expand the universe a lot, and this is built on by TNG.

[@arthurward2067]

Definitely watch the 60s Batman series, it's every bit as fun and funny as the film

[@capnpooter]

(AKA CapnPooter) Thank you for taking the time to do this. That was a great breakdown. Love the 'what do we want to see more of' and thinking of all the upcoming episodes you are going to love. DS9 was made for Josh, that's going to be a ride. HSide note-ave you seen the newer AI video editors out there yet like Wisecut AI Video Editor or Autopod that automatically do all your cuts for you? Amazing tools out there and I can't keep up! They will free up your editing to do more watching. This might be a good time for you to watch The Shatner Roast..

[@targetaudience]

I’ve looked into the AI editing stuff but I’m just unfortunately not very experienced and don’t have a lot of time to dedicate to learning, but I’m trying

[@Serai3]

Fun fact: The phrase that Roddenberry used to sell the show to the network was "Wagon Train to the stars". Wagon Train was a famous Western TV series about, well, about a wagon train heading West. They never arrived at their destination because that would've ended the show, and there were always problems and crises to deal with.

[@torquaymouse2236]

Great episode.

[@gallendugall8913]

Oh yeah, the TNG remaster is great. You can see the drywall screws holding the super science stuff together.

[@Lumibear.]

And so many little black paper squares…

[@Vulcanerd]

A friend of mine and I will occasionally, when appropriate, yell "I'M Captain Kirk!!" to each other.

[@VulcanDeathGrip44]

You guys are going to love Next Gen. Especially starting in season 3.

[@openfor45]

Thanks for posting this! Hopefully you both find some time to POST a 2nd {Full Series Discussion} answering more Patreon questions; love the insight & discussions you bring!

[@targetaudience]

Not answering more questions but the 2nd part of the video is coming soon where we reveal our Top 15 episodes as well as our Patrons!

[@GrandManor]

You discussed how the cast bought into the premise of the show. No one was more committed to fan perception than James Dothan (Scotty). A director was once setting up a shot, and instructed Doohan to push a certain button. Doohan refused, declaring that if he pushed that particular button it would “blow up the ship”. After some back and forth and lots of tension, the director gave in. I believe this story was in one of David Gerrold’s books about the making of Star Trek (he wrote The Trouble with Tribbles episode).

[@johnmackendrick5173]

I'm mixed on the effects. Some episodes, such as Errand of Mercy and Tomorrow is Yesterday, were completely absent in the original showing. There were no Klingon ships present in the first season and when the Enterprise went around the sun, all we saw was the model in space just shaking. Digitally adding to these kinds of stories definitely added to the experience. Other episodes didn't need them at all. The original Amoeba in The Immunity Syndrome completely blew away the new digital effects. Sometimes, I agree with Alex and Josh. Jumping back and forth between computerized effects and old style effects can take you out of the story.

[@devmag52]

TOS is amazing. Even the camp is rewatchable

[@chrismacphail7041]

loved your journey

[@donkfail1]

And when you get on a bit and TNG kicks off and goes towards making their own movies, but TOS seems to never stop. The interweaving continues as the "modern" series starts overlapping. Living in Europe back in the days when the different series was bought in by different channels, so the timelines wasn't always how you wanted. And the movies was a lottery, sometimes the movies was out far before compared to the TV shows. One reason why I have all the series and movies before Enterprise on disc. And I've stacked them up in the right order and plowed through it a couple of times.

[@teenystudioflicks1635]

Those episodes you would like to see more of are revisited in future series. Mirror, Mirror type is used again in DS9, and Kahn was used in one of the TOS movies as well as the second reboot Star Trek film. Villians in TNG (Q) return in both DS9 and Voyager. Nurse Chapel (aka Majel Barrett aka Mrs. Roddenberry) plays Number One (TOS pilot), Lwaxana Troi (DS9&TNG), and the voice of most onboard computer interfaces throughout the series from 1966 to 2023. A younger character version is also in the 2022 series Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. Many things carry over in following series/movies (inc the Gorn).

[@williamblakehall5566]

Thank you for everything, and if I may be so bold, if you ever want to revisit the Sixties, and even want to try a show which was DELIBERATELY, for artistic reasons, all black and white, I can not recommend enough the original Outer Limits. Too often mixed up with memories of The Twilight Zone, unfairly dismissed as "that monster of the week" show, OL was a gutsy show, a weird mix of scientific optimism and eerie horror, that was, much like ST: TOS, a very mixed bag, with some episodes tedious or exasperating, but others that were undying classics. Trek had a huge impact on me, but not before OL gave me a sense of wonder.

[@cashflowhustles]

I would also add Alfred Hitchcock as well as far as 60s TV.

[@mark-s]

Can't wait for you to see the animated series which gives a uhura spotlight episode which could have been in the live show

[@SchlockstarJoe]

14:11 That’s Measure Of A Man. Season 2 episode 9 Next Gen.

[@teenystudioflicks1635]

You really need to watch the Star Trek bloopers that are out there! They are a hoot!

[@Jessica_Roth]

No, Roger C. Carmel was never supposed to play Cyrano Jones. According to David Gerrold's book, "The Trouble with Tribbles" (which includes earlier versions of the script), Cyrano was always named Cyrano; he was not Harry Mudd. Indeed, Gerrold got a script note about whether Cyrano was too similar to Harry, but they decided to just roll with it. Also, "I, Mudd" was only 5 episodes before "Tribbles", so a return might have been difficult to work into the latter episode. Ironically, Gerrold actually did a bit of script-doctor work on "I, Mudd", although he says the only bit of his work that survived was the idea of 500 identical robots. But yes, more Harry Mudd would have been cool.

[@JamieEvansBooks]

In the 'What do we want to see more of?' everything you said and asked for is in TNG .... :)and In the 'Which supporting actor deserved more?' a must read novel is Uhura's Song that came out in 1985...

[@cageygutman7027]

ha ha - you guys are gonna love TNG

[@katheryns1219]

One thing to keep in mind is that color TV was pretty new and few of us had one. No one in my neighborhood did, so I didn't see the series in color until I was an adult and watching the reruns.

[@GeraldWalls]

Future video: "which is better TNG or TOS?" The correct answer: "They are different beasts from different times. They each have their own strengths and weaknesses." kzbin.info/www/bejne/hGrUinlveb-Dmtk

[@CMWaters]

Political drama? Oh, you'll love a lot of DS9 then.

[@dylanbottom4669]

Ds9 is the best one.

[@neillio]

DS9 is so good

[@athos1974]

DS9 ❤ Best Star Trek series ever.

[@auntienancy7787]

I came here to say this EXACT thing... lol

[@eternalhalloween1]

For me, it's easier to go best episode by main character. McCoy "The Man Trap" Janice Rand "Charlie X" Kirk 🏮 "Arena" 🏮 Sulu "Mirror, Mirror" Spock "Journey to Babel" Scotty "Wolf In the Fold" Uhura "Trouble With Tribbles" Chekov "The Way to Eden"

[@Panzer4F2]

Believe it or not, there is a Clint Eastwood movie that you need to see. The Dirty Harry movie introduced a character actor named Andy Robinson. He played his character so well that it influenced his later job offerings, but it also laid a solid foundation for his work on Deep Space Nine. You should consider checking it out, as I think it helped with his Star Trek character's credibility as a docile tailor.

[@Analog_Mind47]

The CGI vs Original effects have always been a Mixed Bag for me. The Ultimate example being "Doomsday Machine" in which the original model of the Cone Ship looked better, but the CGI was able to do the choreography of the Space Battle much better. Also Next Generation & Deep Space 9 have great episodes where they explore the politics & cultures of aliens or Explore the Interworkings of Star Fleet, and a tone of great character work

[@justinp4996]

It has been great following you through the first series, looking forward to more and seeing the perspective of new fans on old content for me.

[@geengeklooi]

Blessed video, looking forward to the next : - )

[@cashflowhustles]

Harry Mudd was a great 60s comedic character.

[@davidge5856]

At the risk of sounding like I'm bullying you, you're NOT done with the 60's yet, OR that unique, 60's Trek TV look. Why? Because Desilu studios ALSO produced a little series called MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE , and used many of the same innovative lighting and camera techniques as well as many of the same cast and crew (in fact, when Trek was finally cancelled, Leonard Nimoy's pals at Desilu gave him the first shot at replacing Martin Landau when he left the M: I series, taking on the role of Paris, man of a thousand faces for a couple of seasons). So while it's NOT Star Trek, and it IS a different kind of show, there are a TON of overlaps with the (then) experimental camera work and lighting, with cameos from Shatner, Takei, and dozens of the same bit players doing excellent work as guest stars. The early Mission: Impossible series can seem VERY dated after the high-octane conversion into the Tom Cruise, non-stop-sprinting, blockbuster territory, but there's still so much to love. If you want another dip into that "groovy", quasi-psycheadelic era, look no further than Mission: Impossible, The Original Series. Hope you find the time and enthusiasm someday, and thanks for the investment of time and all the great reactions/ reviews!!!

[@silikon2]

If you want more 60s episodes, definitely check out Star Trek Continues. They did an unbelievable job of replicating the look, feel, story, everything. The first one is a sequel to Who Mourns for Adonais, featuring the same actor who played Apollo. Sure some of the acting isn't great because it's a fan production, but most of it's fine and there are numerous guest appearances of real actors such as John de Lancie, Lou Ferrigno. If TAS was the fourth year, Continues is the fifth year and explains the background of The Motion Picture.

[@riccardogemme]

Oh man, hearing a particular part of this video, there's a particular moment in the films that I can't wait for you to see. And yes, i'm not gonna say anything more until then.

[@mikejankowski6321]

"A" particular moment?!?!? I can think of several outstanding ones. And several funny ones. And several deep ones. The list goes on...

[@MrDeadstu]

I love Star Trek TOS, always have. I also love watching you two take in the show for the first time, I could watch you guys discuss ST:TOS all day. (ahem vids are too short...lol) I will most definitely be signing up for Patreon for the movie reactions, ST 2:WoK being my favorite. ST:TNG was pretty good, better effects for sure. I eagerly await your evaluations of future ST shows. (yes you will compare them to TOS, it's inevitable) --> one question, How do you feel about the constant upgrading of the original Star Wars movies(4,5,6), seeing you didn't really like the upgrading of the original Star Trek?

[@targetaudience]

I think remastering/upgrading movies is inherently different from TV, but only to make the visuals look better not to add a bunch of new junk like the Star Wars special editions. This is because typically you can remaster a movie in its entirety so it all fits as to where TV the old footage will always look old for the most part so the updated visual effects become jarring

[@MrDeadstu]

@@targetaudience I am lucky and have a copy of the SW original movies w/o all the crap updates. Thanks for the reply. Keep up the great Star Trek reactions and discussions.

[@anthonybernacchi2732]

@@targetaudience Guys, does this mean that you might watch the Director's Edition of the first Star Trek movie rather than the theatrical version? I haven't seen the most recent version of the Director's Edition due to cash flow issues, but I've seen clips from it, and it's clearly far superior to the original (and doesn't have any "new junk"). As everyone will undoubtedly tell you at length when you get to it, the first movie was originally released unfinished due to time constraints (they had an immovable release date). I think you might enjoy the movie much more if you see the most recent version first.

[@targetaudience]

@@anthonybernacchi2732 yes we are watching all the movies in 4K, directors cut for the first one

[@anthonybernacchi2732]

@@targetaudience Good to know. Thanks, guys.

[@WanderingCactus]

The Mudd Episode you wanted a sequel got one, but only in short story form. James Blish who did the novelizations of all the TV episodes wanted to do a book featuring all three Mudd stories, but he couldn't get the rights to the animated episode. Rather than scrap the book or only have two stories, he wrote a sequel to Mudd's Women, an while it's been 15+ years since I read it, I still remember it as just as hilarious as the real episodes.

[@FunkyRive]

You guys are not aware yet about how much you are going to enjoy the future 🙂

[@trektubeofficial]

Loved watching your reactions guys, so interesting to get fresh and honest takes. Can't wait to see you watch TNG, you'll love it - the writing is next level! (Though it takes a couple of seasons to hit its stride.)

[@larky368]

It would have been cool to see the return of Bailey who went off with Balok in "The Corbomite Maneuver."

[@Warped9]

TNG was remastered, but it’s not as easy to tell the difference.

[@garanceadrosehn9691]

You might enjoy "Star Trek Continues", which was an attempt to really capture the look and feel of the original series.

[@davewilliams1157]

Yes! And it has good followups to at least three TOS story lines!

[@linphillips8331]

The Lights of Zetar episode did freak me out when I was very little.

[@richierich398]

Are you guys sure you haven’t watched TNG? Those that know, know😂. I have to admit, I was not a fan originally of your format and content. I believe I had commented at one point that it reminded me of.MST3K. But now I really do appreciate your thoughts, insight, commentary, and analysis of the show. Looking forward to the animated series!

[@THICKETDWELLERR]

So, the to main things that you did not see coming, had to be blindness, irony much? 10:41