Wendy (Red Velvet) Hits Her New Highest Mixed Belt!

red velvet, red velvet wendy, red velvet wendy best vocals, wendy vocal fail, wendy vocal range

[@fuurin5312]

I feel overwhelmed. This girl is a hardworking person ever. She sang 8 songs on her birthday’s party for fans. But I also know she’s tired, she isn’t a robot ofc, even she is very healthy and has quite good stamina, it’s exhausting to prepare practicing her solo comeback and also this event at the same time, but she is very happy to sing and aim to show the best perfs for fans tho. She told us on bubbles that she knew her throat wasn’t in good condition that day and she regretted in some songs so she did send another version of her singings to us. She’s very sincere and honest when it comes to her singing. Her own responsibility towards her goal’s standard is very strong. I admire and respect her so much

[@sumysim3245]

The fact that she sang so many songs and is this stable astounds me, I'm not a pro, but after 2 songs, I'm finished! You can tell with the proper technique and experience, especially now with her voice acting, she has lots of stamina. She isn't a machine, no one's going to sound perfect after hours of singing, not at all. She sounds comfortable in that range, which is truly a feat.

[@Rhaphidophile]

Sge admitted herself this day was awful for her vocally. I wonder if it's because of her new album comeback preparations.

[@marie_nicolas]

her schedule was packed and it didn't helped sm greenlit this bday party just few days before the actual event giving her less time to prepare....she may actually got the two songs she perform on this bday party from the build up competition where she is currently a judge 💀 and yeah her cb too which got lot of layers too but thats for another discussion

[@drewadrianuyangurin1812]

Where did she say this?

[@k.n3809]

I feel like this is just an example of a great singer just having an off day, which is normal.

[@Bluwie._.piixxee]

This type of shit doesn't happen overnight. It needs HARD WORK and that needs pure determination for your craft. If you love what you do, you're willing to practise and improve it. The cake girls are one of the few groups I'll confidently say that love what they do. This is why people who are in the industry for years never improve, because they need the ambition to work for it.

[@mcbill7352]

She literally did not hit the note lmao

[@jennievelvet]

@@mcbill7352 she hits the same notes in literally all of her songs while singing live, mind u.

[@phineasfacingfront7806]

No hate she's a terrific singer but she was off key in the whole clip.

[@natm8368]

Yes

[@indigo_neo]

She wasn’t completely off though, just a little flat.

[@sumysim3245]

The fact that she sang so many songs and is this stable astounds me, I'm not a pro, but after 2 songs, I'm finished! You can tell with the proper technique and experience, especially now with her voice acting, she has lots of stamina. She isn't a machine, no one's going to sound perfect after hours of singing, not at all. She sounds comfortable in that range, which is truly a feat.

[@manogaming6534]

@@sumysim3245 I am also astonished by Jennie. She goes to a lot of fashion shows, reality shows etc and she performs like a monster on stage . I m no pro , but i know how difficult it is to do all those stuff and still perform so powerfully on stage. But people only like when wendy does mistakes. Please praise wendy for doing mistakes but then have Audacity to call Jennie lazy. I don't get why only wendy gets tired after 2-3 songs?? Other idols also get tired but people hate them tremendously. But why are people praising wendy here?? Idk why people have these double standards.

[@lenriquegomez7672]

​@@manogaming6534Jennie is not on Wendy's level, not even close to compare lol

[@sawadeekrunch9436]

HOLY SHIT WENDY

[@seungwannie3624]

Wow I didn't know this was her first time trying to hit that. Props to her for her continuous improvement. She even got dragged on twt cause of this but little did they know its actually an A5 and she's obviously trying new things. Look forward to Wendy's new album "Wish you Hell" out March 12

[@dibadibo3937]

The people in the comment tryna be critical of her in this clip. I get it if it was a C5 but don't y'all realize that it's a FUKKIN A5?? Only FEW can land this note healthily. 95% of kpop can only dream to do as half as decent as Wendy did here lmao. Give the girl a break. It was her fukin birthday. She can goof around after she sang and danced her ass off that day

[@uforc49kie69]

Exactly this is probably the first time ice seen her mess up when she has been singing for over a decade. Her vocal range as a kpop idol is one of the top and she has over 300 songs and song covers to prove it. And I feel like people will compare this with other idols, but other idols aren't even in her range.

[@andretostesmusic4863]

It sounded kinda terrible but that's fine for a first attempt, we all gotta start somewhere! Hope she improves as time goes by

[@aayushgupta1265]

She herself hit above that note before but she was tired that day because of that it happened not because she isn't improved 😂😅

[@morbidmusing]

You’ve never gone sharp or had a voice crack in your entire career? She’s a trained vocalist and has been for 10 years. The human body can’t reproduce sound with 100% accuracy every time, especially not while ill, malnourished or exhausted which kpop idols usually are. “Sounded kinda terrible” is crazy 😬

[@riffgroove]

She's a millionaire who's sold millions of albums, and widely considered the best female vocalist out of the entire 3rd and 4th gen of Kpop. Keep making those KZbin videos in your living room.

[@andretostesmusic4863]

@@riffgroove grow up 🤭

[@riffgroove]

@andretostesmusic4863 "Those who can, do. Those who can't, critique."

[@lilyrose0116]

She has always been an amazing but the FACT that she came back this strong of a vocalist after her career ending injury is a miracle and shows exactly how hard she has worked.

[@riffgroove]

This video proves what I've said all along. Even on a day where sh isn't at her best, she STILL sounds better than 99% of the rest of the 3rd and 4th gen .

[@hola_terry]

Honestly, this is the kind of situations where we should be saying "idols are humans too" not on videos whwre someone is calling out an idol for being racist dor the nth time. Wendy has time and again proven to be great vocalist. We have bad days too.❤

[@skzsmenuiscd3721]

I'm the most excited about her new album. She deserves all the love. And I hope this album a success.

[@AP-fi2di]

She sounded exhausted, thin and flat. She went off tune too. But knowing her, she is one of the top vocalists among 3rd gen is truly astonishing to me. There must be a reason that she couldn't deliver it properly.

[@DeeDeeDeeeee]

Hopefully she can eventually lessen her nasality and whininess, she has the potential to go even farther but her mix has so many issues in comparison to her upper and lower registers.

[@stephenduran6060]

I actually think she's actually sick or something doing this! Because in parts she should be able to do well (the non-belting parts and the notes before A5), she sounds very nasal. That's why she sounds very whiny here. Imagine if she wasn't sick when she did this.

[@DeeDeeDeeeee]

@@stephenduran6060 yeah this was an off day for her but even at her best, her mix is outclassed by vocalists that are below her skill wise (Lily, Yuju, Haewon, etc…) but her head voice and lows boost her up.

[@stephenduran6060]

@@DeeDeeDeeeee I agree. Her belts could be so much better if she just learns how to control her resonance.

[@stephenduran6060]

@@DeeDeeDeeeee I agree. Her belts could be so much better if she just learns how to control her resonance.

[@vianneyphilippe8962]

I don’t know her , maybe she’s on her bad days (that normal even for the greatest vocalist)but I’d say that there’s no need to hit a high notes if you know you don’t have worked on your technique to do so. She hit a A5(unhealthy at all)but at the end she’s struggling with the remaining part of the song. Don’t come at me saying that she’s not struggling, we can clearly hear she’s not supporting those notes.Even the D5 was airy because it wasn’t supported.

[@achmadhuda_11]

She is Wendy from Red Velvet, she is actually one of the best Kpop vocalist in 3gen. Yeah this is her bad day but the op from this video was made a video about main vocalist in 3rd gen and she is rank first, beating Solar, Wheiin, and Jihyo. Maybe she is on same level as Taeyeon but below Ailee

[@DeeDeeDeeeee]

This is definitely more of a bad day for her, she normally can go up to D5 with good placement and support and even Eb5 occasionally. The A5 was out of her range, but it’s also out of most people’s ranges.

[@tiramisusweet]

Wendy is actually well aware it wasn't her best performance but to put her down for a bad night over her 10 years of amazing singing career? Some people are just waiting for her to make a mistake to hate on her. If there's one thing I know, Wendy will only get better. Already one of kpop's top vocalists but still take vocal lessons. Can't say the same for others.

[@jessicamiranda2580]

@@DeeDeeDeeeeeyou know her range?

[@uforc49kie69]

She can sing the notes, she was just tired after those other songs. Most of the songs she performed she has already covered them before and sounds perfectly fine. It's literally just this day was her worse. She had been singing over a decade and this is my first time hearing her sound off key.

[@uforc49kie69]

Yall realize this d-day is probably 1st time she has messed up in her years of singing for over a decade, she has proved over 200 songs that she can sing, her notes and the songs she cover are hard to sing. So please stop comparing her to people like lesserafim when lesserafim have easy noted songs and majority of the time their just standing there and its the first song they sing and they cant even get the pitch right at all even though songs like easy are literally easy, and other 4th gen girl groups too their running 2 miles with breaks, she is running 8 with only 1 second to walk, This is why people defend her, when you have a strong period of doing something.. people will acknowledge your flaw as a mistake and still support you.

[@marie_nicolas]

there's actually people on Twitter who posted this video saying she sound bad 😭 they're unhinge I hope the creator of this video create a content out of that fiasco edit: okay maybe she didnt hit that note in a good way but imo her whole performance on her bday just shows she wants to challenge herself and thats the start of growth I love that for her

[@monika_888]

RIGHT?!? I’ll admit she doesn’t sound the best here but that doesn’t mean stan twt’s strainy favs are better vocalists than wendy

[@msadent1825]

They don't really fear anything😂

[@marie_nicolas]

@@msadent1825 they also drag taeyang from big bang 😂 years of kpop noise really damage their ears

[@msadent1825]

@@marie_nicolas taeyang?! At first they lost their hearing sense, but at this point they have lost all their senses!

[@msadent1825]

@@marie_nicolas just came from listening to daesung new song. A standard 4 minute song and a bless for the ears

[@Nameless_mixes]

Wendy covering “Sorry Not Sorry” when? 🙏💙

[@Chuu_Vault]

This got me more excited for Wendy new mini 👀

[@Nameless_mixes]

Same, bestie 💙

[@namiko282]

I like Wendy’s singing but this seemed like an off day for her. Every clip I’ve seen from this concert sounds and looks like she’s struggling. I’m not hating, it wasn’t horrible but definitely far from her best. Maybe she’s sick idk

[@tiramisusweet]

This is not a concert. It's a birthday event. She rehearsed for like 2 days. Sang 5-6 difficult songs before this. She was aware that this is not her best performance and promised to come back better. She was also in the middle of preparing for a solo comeback. I hope her throat is better now since her cb is next week.

[@christiancastelo4729]

People will criticize Wendy for having aa bad day yet they will defend their faves saying they're trying even when they are just bad in the first place LOL

[@Be.my.chill.kill.127]

her range is insane, considering she was singing LIVE 8 songs one after one and all of them very challenging...truly insane! 💪✨️

[@tiramisusweet]

I always appreciate LIVE (no backtrack) singing. It will not always be perfect and i think thats part of the charm. Some kpop stans cant even tell lip syncing and using of loud backtrack from real live singing. I'm not bothered by people mocking Wendy over this coz im pretty sure Wendy outsings their faves in her worst. This is one off day vs 10 years of impeccable reputation as an outstanding vocalist.

[@shshshshdf]

sounds so unhealthy... can't say I'm excited for what's to come if she keep going

[@Rubeer-qe2me]

that's an A5 for sake

[@sawadeekrunch9436]

BABES LITERALLY NO ONE HAS EVER SUPPORTED AN A5 EXCEPT FOR QUEEN SOHYANG

[@ttteea]

She sounds a little off pitch too after hitting A5. It seems Wendy has been singing very difficult songs like Love on Top to challenge herself and expand her tessitura.

[@superbored4576]

i mean she doesn't really go up that high that much (correct me if im wrong)so idk, I'd say she sounded fine to me

[@goldyd144]

All the clips I've seen of her singing in this dress have been... interesting.😬 OK, to be honest, this one's fine though. 😅 Probably a combination of an off day + her challenging herself with more complicated material to improve her technique and expand her range. Nonetheless, I'm interested to see how she improves over time now that she's exploring more with expanding her range! This is a hard note. Whew 😮‍💨

[@user-dw8gc4rz7d]

HARD WORKER WENDY !! I LOVE YOU !!

[@ryeppo]

Best singer.. Best main vocal.. Best girl..

[@DarielAndre]

go girl give us everything😍

[@Yujin_the_ace]

Oh god I got goosebumps 😮

[@jjuaassol]

Wendy's been grinding hard in her downtime, no doubt. Already a vocal powerhouse, but her constant hustle? That's straight-up fire.

[@tiramisusweet]

She hasn't taken a vacation for over a year! 🥺

[@thatrandomperson5828]

it's so refreshing to hear a kpop idol without backtrack

[@ReapingWillow]

It's a cover... at a fanmeeting type gig... so this is her own time, and therefore, i would be SHOCKED if she DID have a backingtrack. AS that would be a first for me to see done! Lol, I have NEVER seen any backtrack to a cover at a fan event. Ever. The only times i see anyone, including her, have backtrack is when they are performing on a stage that isn't their own. In other words... multiple groups, multiple performances, and the reputation of their show on the line. Such as awards and comeback music shows... shit like that. So, either you haven't seen anyone else perform outside of those venues other than her... or there's a bunch of groups out there I dont know anything about, whilst you know about ONLY them.

[@thatrandomperson5828]

@@ReapingWillow Why are you annoyed? I didn't know this was a fanmeeting, for all i know it could be a concert of some kind (where covers usually have backtrack). Also idk what you mean saying backtrack only occurs on comeback and award stages, the majority of kpop group use backtrack in their concerts?? I don't watch a lot of fanmeets and I assumed it was a concert, idk why your so upset by this??

[@fajar4741]

WENDY CALM DOWN!!

[@ayeshaazmat230]

this was not a good day for her all of her performances were off key, she's usually great tho

[@andreadewisekarningsih5029]

Yeahh❤

[@jaescuore7049]

Was there any problem in her ear piece, because she's off by at least half a note, throughout the clip....

[@paulinangelina7037]

Yes ...she said her in ear was not working ever since the smtown tokyo

[@tiramisusweet]

Her own in-ear is actually broken and won't be fixed until around this time. I hope it gets fixed before her comeback next week though. She knows it wasn't her best performance and actually send a better version to her fans. 😅 She always worries but I hope it doesn't affect her confidence. She's been doing so well esp after her stint in musical theatre.

[@bromoboy]

she sounds off key, that belt is unnecessary 😂😂😂😂😂

[@nuzulhaziq]

She delivered

[@user-ru6li1oz5w]

🎉

[@PS12342]

She sounded flat unlike her usual singing but even being flat she makes it sound good . I am not defending her but just imagine if she was able to hit the note without any problem it would be an end of Kpop vocals

[@banamilkaholic]

Just because she was off key while singing one song doesn't make her a bad singer... everyone has bad days. Nobody can sing with perfect pitch every time they perform. She's human too

[@autumn399]

Love that Mamamoo has a catergory for themselves in where to look for real live vocals!❤

[@5XKXNXA]

It sounded unpleasant af😅

[@gyeomibear]

she's the best 3rd gen vocalist along with solar. there must be an underlying reason

[@thatname4451]

Her voice broke, right? In the "shut your mOuth" Still surprising ;)

[@igotbit9454]

I know she can sing but this was not it. (And I’m a Wendy fan)

[@s3ungwann]

Wendy seemed so overworked in this birthday party... i mean did you see how she moved and looked after hitting the note i dont know the word for it but like she was about to fall out of dizziness or something. she prepared so much and did so much for it even tho she wasn't well. I sometimes worry about her. She even apologized for her singning :( wendy is a great Vocalist. I think with her comeback this was just too much for her. I hope she rests her vocal chords I'm scared she'll overdo herself and something might happen. Take care Wendy.

[@not_in_the_mood]

not to be rude or anything but every recent performance clip i’ve seen of her with this outfit on has been terrible. this is definitely not the iconic Wendy that’s known for being a vocal powerhouse in the industry. hopefully she was just having an off day or something.

[@estebanrodriguezlagos6858]

Hay una chica en la 4ta gen que mixea mejor en esas notas..

[@emiraseav9293]

That day was truly not her day.

[@joshua2764]

Now sir u know she sounded flat as hell

[@AnandaDaradiba]

Erm, I don't know if this is coincindent, but I just watched her Wish You Hell live perfomance on music show, and I feel like her singing is regressing, compared to before. She's not as stable as before, or maybe because of the choreo. But idk, I just like she's much stronger before.

[@il6886]

Unhealthy, unsupport. Just stop, it's not your range!

[@tiwtiwlee4248]

?? Eb5 supports and F5 no Strained

[@tiwtiwlee4248]

ez F5 A5 and better than Someone or many idol 😊

[@user-pj6fp4jj6h]

She is great but wtf happened in this clip

[@giselle1831]

Its her worst perf but she can teach this gen how to sing with this messy performance

[@rick.8589]

she's trippin

[@Irys1997]

I love her voice so much! I'm worried about her frantic plastic surgery addiction but I have to find a way to let that go, because my worrying isn't going to even slow it down a little

[@marie_nicolas]

pls tell us where in her schedule could she sneak having multiple plastic surgery? for you to say that you should be following her activities

[@Irys1997]

@@marie_nicolas do a little research of your own, it is not controversial that she has had *dozens* of procedures done on every single element of her face from her hairline to her throat, like literally 30-50 changes. You have no reason not to doubt me but the fact of the matter is that I am using the term “frantic plastic surgery addiction” for good reason. I don’t know of anyone else so young who has had as many procedures done. I don’t say “worry” lightly. She has been on a path that is pathological, and I hope that someday she can find peace with herself and her own face

[@marie_nicolas]

@@Irys1997 you just pulled that out of your ass lmfao I say you're the one who should be doing a research and should base your accusations on facts, unless you're the one who did the procedures on her you have no evidence that the surgeries you're talking about is true. You didn't even answer my question cause you know you're just spewing nonsense based on your limited information 😂

[@marie_nicolas]

@@Irys1997 you didn't even answer my question what makes you think I'll take you seriously 😂

[@Irys1997]

@@marie_nicolas I didn't take your question seriously, because how am I to know what she does with her free time. I've just seen discussions from plastic surgeons that detail every single procedure she's had done month after month since roughly 2014, and the list is unimaginable, it can barely fit on two pages. Just look at her face over time! Look at her in the Bad Boy era, and look at her today. It isn't the same face at all. And by 2016 she had already had more work done than most celebrities have in their lifetimes. THEN she doubled and tripled down on it.

[@ungegreier1802]

Is SM still starving their idols?

[@manogaming6534]

I m so sorry, i love wendy and she is my bias in rv but if any other idol had done this u people would br like“kpop has lost interest in vocals " and “they are popular for no reason "“they should take vocal classes" and would bash them endlessly. U guys are praising wendy now but if this was done by another idol, it would be last day of their life because of trolling by u people. Don't get me wrong i know wendy is best vocalist of gen 3 and one of the best in whole industry but in this specific clip she isn't showing it. I m not saying to hate her, but u guys should also not hate other idol if they sing a little less proficiently one or two times . Bye.

[@averyatwell95]

Hmm.. considering Wendy has shown her abilities multiple times & this was her first attempt at A5 (?not sure) & her voice is tired from her comeback practices (I saw in the comments) & this concert was a last minute plan (again I read in comments), I'd say she deserves a pass. Compare it to say some other idols whose regular performances are worse than this off day of Wendy. It's not the same.

[@manogaming6534]

@@averyatwell95 why can't other idols also get tired of promotions?? Are other idols robots and only wendy is human?? U guys are so weird. 😂

[@songkang3xsrvx]

​@@manogaming6534this is concert . She performed 5-6 songs and danced before covering love on top. I don't see other idols who get hate hitting such high note on their own song that too at encore

[@averyatwell95]

@@manogaming6534 did I say that? If someone consistently performs off key, straining, screaming, scared on stage, etc. even in easy songs their whole careers then it means they are bad singers. Wendy's is once in 10 years. What's so hard to understand?

[@manogaming6534]

@@averyatwell95 can u name someone who consistently sings off key?? Sorry u r over exaggerating things and if you search enough u will get many other examples of bad vocals by wendy so it is not only this clip.

[@m.a2345]

On the day of the video, Wendy woke up with the mission of being bad at everything she could. She was terrible at singing Love On Top, she was terrible at dancing Water and she managed to be mediocre when trying to achieve that A5... disappointing!

[@yahyasbai3958]

Wtf is that shit

[@aayushgupta1265]

Just a singer having a bad day😅

[@everysongends]

she sounds aweful here ngl!!!! what's wrong with her voice here???

[@wiggly95078]

growing? this is pitchy strainy mess lol

[@trisha179]

The high note was great but her vocal was not that good.

[@manogaming6534]

People are saying in twt “don't judge her by just one clip" I m sorry but u guys are the one call jennie, jisoo, jimin, wonyoung, lia snd other idol horrible names like lazy, pick me, stiff, uninterested, untalented etc.

[@MeghanAir-pb6tz]

You are comparing these mediocre singers with Wendy. None of them can sing like Wendy. Maybe they are talented in other aspects but not singing. Wendy even on her off day can beat them.

[@manogaming6534]

@@MeghanAir-pb6tz sorry but i am talking specifically about this clip. I m not comparing wendy with others. I m saying that when it comes to this clip people r saying don't judge her by just one clip. But these same people call horrible names to idols just by seeing one clip. Btw in ur opinion these maybe mediocre but in others opinion they maybe great so insulting someone according to ur opinions is not good sorry.

[@MeghanAir-pb6tz]

@@manogaming6534 naah, idols who are criticized for their vocals deserve it. Vocal skills are not opinions but facts. None of the idols you mentioned have even average vocals. Its just their fans hyping them up. And its not one clip. They continuously sing off key, scream high notes, strain those vocals and fan start calling them Mariah Carey. I won't talk about Wonyoung since she is a sub vocalist. Others are main/lead yet their talents are nowhere so. Singing is part of their job and if they can't do that then they deserve criticism. Wendy is one of the best vocalists out there. She has hundreds of clips to prove she is great. Comparing her to the these idols is like comparing Whitney Huston on a bad day to Selena Gomez. Utterly stupid.

[@averyatwell95]

​@@manogaming6534 oh so those are your favs? All non vocalists whose best performances are worse than Wendy's worst.. I see why you're so bitter making multiple comments to get Wendy dragged.

[@manogaming6534]

@@averyatwell95 sorry but these are not my favs I am rv stan and a wendy bias.when did I drag wendy down?? Make it make sense please. I m just saying treat idols equally. If u hate wendy, hate others too. I u are not hating wendy don't hate wendy too. That's all I want to say. Please be mature just because I type smthng about some one that doesn't make me stanner Or hatter of someone. Bye

[@Julaly0728]

Sorry but its awful.. 😅