WEREWOLF LIVE: We Accuse Each Other of Wolf-Murder, with Dicebreaker - WHO IS THE WEREWOLF?!

Which of the seemingly innocent villagers is in fact the murderous werewolf? Outside Xbox, Xtra and Dicebreaker are bound to fall out in their quest to discover the culprit.
The Outside Xbox and Outside Xtra Pride shirt is here! Outside Xbox and Outside Xtra are proud to celebrate Pride Month 2020 with our LGBTQIA+ friends. All profits from the shirt will go to the Marsha P Johnson Institute (in the US) and Gendered Intelligence (in the UK and rest of the world): shop.reedpop.c...
Halls of the Undead by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution licence (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
---
Official Merch Store! teespring.com/...
Become a member of Outside Xtra! / @outsidextra
Outside Xtra is a companion channel to Outside Xbox, covering the wider world of gaming with weekly lists, Let's Plays and shows with your hosts Ellen and Luke. Look for regular appearances by OG Outside Xboxers Andy, Jane and Mike, and generally more of the videos you love, about more of the platforms you enjoy, from a team now two people larger overall.
Thanks for watching and be excellent to each other in the comments.
Find us at www.outsidextra...
Subscribe to us at / outsidextra
Like us on Facebook at / outsidextra
Follow us on Twitter at / outsidextra

[@FrankieAdds]

I greatly enjoy the concept that for the first night of the first game, the villagers saw some big dog tracks and nothing else but still immediately burned an innocent woman alive no questions asked

[@tarnim80]

the historical accuracy was truly on point

[@sick0832]

those were the days ...

[@jasonsorin1021]

She's heavier than a duck, what else were we supposed to do?

[@IzEror]

@@jasonsorin1021 I understood that reference!

[@nunyobidniz]

@@IzEror if you hadn't, we'd be expected to send the Spanish Inquisition after you🗡️🗡️😉

[@Drewsiph]

Andy: "Are you ready for the heartbreaking news?" Jane: *laughs maniacally*

[@MinnehahaSybyl]

And I believe her response was "Yeah, sucker."

[@njohn72ilovemusic]

You gotta wonder who's more in control at this point, Jane or Prudence?

[@lisarichards7898]

Clearly Jane is Prudence's puppet there can be no other explanation

[@MySerpentine]

@@njohn72ilovemusic There was never a difference

[@rabbit-exe3606]

it's extremely funny to me that the villagers won the first round mostly because of andy's baseless desire to kill mike at every possible moment

[@kitschlover]

hahahahaha it was amazing, a harmless werewolf... XD

[@eleanorsmith7152]

I seem to remember a similar thing happening when they last played 🤔

[@kitschlover]

@@eleanorsmith7152 hahahahha true

[@bysmth6450]

Baseless? Haven't you seen ghost mode??

[@musicf3b]

No information, yet completely accurate lol

[@mattgardiner744]

Luke: "Hi everyone-" Andy: "I demand to kill Mike immediately!"

[@patience1926]

Saddest moment- when Andy protects Jane and gets mauled by her. Galaxy brain moment- Lolies playing Jane like a fiddle. Most hilarious moment- Mike wearing the werewolf attire and still managing to kill someone before getting caught. Also Andy accusing Mike for the sake of it and Mike actually being the werewolf both times. This session was gold!

[@oxfanblink4115]

Almost choked on my drink when i saw Mike in his webcam with his hat and gloves. Was worth it though 😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂

[@youliahadzhidimova5260]

@Patience This, but with time codes.

[@RepKyle95]

That Lolies moment was POG as hell. She was playing 4-dimensional chess!

[@oxfanblink4115]

Starts at 4:22 😃 Great fun especially with Jane’s werewolf face when she’s chosen 😂😂😂 And Ellen’s giggles 🤗🤗

[@doodlecrazydc]

Bump so people can see this

[@jasonsorin1021]

You couldn't have started slightly earlier? You've done enough QTEs to get one within a minute.

[@oxfanblink4115]

Jason Sorin They were having technical difficulties starting worse than poor Ellen because of it being unusually hot over here in the uk 🇬🇧 especially in the London area where they’re based for the past couple of days

[@JachAnen]

Thanks my dude

[@oxfanblink4115]

Jan Christoffersen No problem dude

[@NathanWeeks]

Well, obviously Johnny is the wolf. Worst human disguise ever.

[@VonDiesel3768]

You avatar perfectly matches your comment.

[@Malkontent1003]

@@jennifernewby3774 Do you?

[@patience1926]

Lolies pulling that genius manoeuver there was amazing. Because Jane got really lucky with killing the healer 1st round and then killing the seer, when seer revealed their identity not knowing no one could protect them. She had the best chance at winning if she hadn’t been impatient.

[@Fureimes]

OH GOD THE ANDY PROTECTING JANE WHILE SHE KILLS HIM WAS THE ABSOLUTE BEST... I CRIED

[@liamwillis860]

I found it very ironic

[@yoholup19]

She has always said that corazon wouldn't leave her shed kill him first

[@NacnudPinky]

That moment when you hug your friend to protect them from a sniper and they stab you before giving the sniper a thumbs up

[@mattfenner9457]

Love how everyone took their own prejudices in to the game. The OXbox crew just wanted to kill each other. Jonny and Alex just wanted to kill each other. Everyone wanted to kill Andy.

[@JaronActual]

This is standard fare for any group of friends when playing Werewolves.

[@premiumheadpats4150]

@@JaronActual I must agree.

[@armandonicolas2651]

I know Im asking the wrong place but does anyone know a way to get back into an instagram account?? I somehow forgot my account password. I would love any assistance you can give me.

[@kodyrowen1131]

@Armando Nicolas instablaster =)

[@armandonicolas2651]

@Kody Rowen I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site thru google and I'm in the hacking process now. Takes a while so I will reply here later when my account password hopefully is recovered.

[@Mankoi1701]

I think other people have mentioned, but I'd recommend playing with the hidden ally. One player who knows who the werewolf is and their goal is to help the werewolf survive and they win if the werewolf wins, even if they were killed along the way. The werewolf does not know who their ally is. Lots of potential complications added by this, but the most relevant one is that it adds an element of doubt when someone says "I'm the Seer, and I know the werewolf is [x]." Without a hidden ally, when someone does this, it's almost certainly the truth, as the only person with reason to lie about it is the werewolf, and the werewolf would be found out immediately when their information turns out to be bad. Having a non-werewolf whose job is to provide bad information and has no regard for their own life can add an element of doubt. Also adds a bunch of interesting potential strategies for everyone, but especially the werewolf and the ally.

[@BogaDragon]

I also think this would be a good thing to try - it's a fun thing to add to help the werewolf out and still give people a role to play ^^

[@MorinehtarTheBlue]

It's certainly a way to nerf the seer role which seems a little too potent in a group this size. Though I worry that such an ally in a six person game amounts to at least 1.5 werewolves. Kind of swings the balance in the other direction. I'm more inclined to say they should play it vanilla with no roles. Mostly I want to see them do the actual deduction part of the game.

[@premiumheadpats4150]

@@MorinehtarTheBlue Or at least no seer.

[@premiumheadpats4150]

When my friends and I played this,.... well, the girl in charge really liked to mess with people. So there were many variables. She would put anywhere from 0-4 werewolves in the game regardless of the group size(That 0 werewolf game got really heated lol). There were a few times when she left out the seer and just pretended there was one. We didn't always play with a healer. However, when we did have one, the werewolf was even allowed to go a night without killing anyone just to see if they could trip people up. Make the healer think they protected a victim. Maybe with that "victim" even being the werewolf or one of the werewolves. Shit got pretty ridiculous sometimes, but I remember it fondly. Also, just personally, I like chaos in my games. So even when I was just a villager I'd sometimes claim to be the seer to confuse things. I remember one game three people claimed to be the seer. And when I was a seer lucky enough to sniff out the werewolf, I'd occasionally just hold onto the information to see what happens.

[@JohnZ117]

@@premiumheadpats4150 A salute to that moderator.

[@sammywhatammy]

i adore Jane. you can tell when she's just admiring herself in her own webcam feed and it's both hilarious and endearing

[@skiddadleskidoodle4094]

That’s the level of self love we’re all trying to archive lol

[@Worm.soup666]

And she really dresses up for these I think that says alot about her as a person and that shes happy how she dresses

[@skiddadleskidoodle4094]

@@Worm.soup666 I mean her style is just * chef‘s kiss *

[@brokegeek2]

Alex: "I just wanted to see who would vote" f%*king SAVAGE!

[@Brittanysplittany]

Yeah, that wasn't cool!

[@billyward9440]

who's Alex ?

[@NoOne-zd6zb]

For the last round, I was hoping Luke would secretly be the werewolf and slowly take them out one by one while they're accusing each other

[@SpectreRyder]

Idk if the GM can be the werewolf. That would be op af

[@amandap7733]

@@SpectreRyder I think that's kind of the point though, like it's the last game so why not just sit back and watch the chaos.

[@MorinehtarTheBlue]

That's just game breaking. Making their actions pointless makes it a waste of participants time. I mean they could do that for the sake of a show but then it really isn't a game anymore.

[@Worm.soup666]

@@MorinehtarTheBlue it could just be really funny seeing them not being able to figure it out

[@StirrCrazy90]

I mean, Luke is well known for saying "Chaos is a ladder," so that would check out.

Mike sounds guilty even when he's innocent

[@hafezali860]

I'm very similar to Mike in that regard, I always get nervous when accused even if I'm not the werewolf, making me very bad at this game. Still love playing tho.

@@hafezali860 me too! I'm incapable of lying in this game so I'm terrible, still love to play! And to watch them play 😊

[@danieldundon6]

He does sound guilty, even when he's not

[@Legendary_Detective-Wobbuffet]

"That's where your wrong Captain. I'm never guilty."

[@Robbie32]

1:03:12 Jane: "You will live to regret this." Johnny: "I hope so."

[@jmccmj234]

As a camp counselor, I used to call this the Bear game. We had wild bears, a park ranger to investigate, a nurse to heal and a heck of a lot of infighting.

[@dolfuny]

My church played this game but it was called mafia. I won once all by myself because my partner got killed in the beginning against like 30 people and I was so proud of myself

[@sbcd7808]

I love how the werewolf literally didn’t kill anyone in the first round and the villages just burned two people at the stake

[@Tickerbee]

I like that the deaths slowly change from executions to Mortal Kombat finishers :P

[@pyrrhy]

Mike's 'tell' is that he's a lot more vocal when he's trying to hide something 😆

[@alexharrison2743]

I absolutely love them asking the French ghost "is there life after death?" and getting a flat "no."

[@Kradd]

Awwww, when Jane kills Andy and he tries to protect her, beautiful counter to the previous round. Such a sweet friendship 😊 Edit: next round: oh

[@Thrythlind]

I almost feel like in this game, when the seer investigates a person that is going to die, you should tell them "Corpse" rather than "werewolf" or "not a werewolf"

[@caseybaker7935]

That could actually work pretty interestingly with the Hunter. If the Hunter is moved to declaring a target at the start of the night phase, that means there could potentially even be more than one corpse when the Seer comes up

[@thomasgodridge5945]

This was a joy to watch. I'd love to see more of this in the future. Also Luke made a superb GM.

[@JediSentinal]

nice profile pic 😄

[@wuwupyon]

I love his stories in the choose your own adventures from past SOTWEs so I’m glad to see him with the same flair here

[@otterblau5253]

Luke's choose your own adventures with Ellen has prepared him well.

[@GrimSidius]

I had the same thoughts, I was immediately transported to a previous show of the weekend with a classic Luke adventure.

[@Tatokat]

I really hope they're going to play this again sometime.

[@leoseydoux3831]

There's gonna be a part 2 over on dicebreaker

[@ceilingfanenthusiast6041]

I liked your comment before even watching, I just know that this will be hilarious

[@daniellarson8291]

Have to get Ellen a better connection first though 😂

[@TheNerdyOrganist]

A role crated by a very annoyed moderator: The defiler. The defiler can curse somebody with an unhealable pain in the throat. If the cursed player tries to speak, the pain is so strong, that he immediatly dies. The cursed player can still make gestures as he likes. You can make this condition last forever or just for one cycle, but that has to be decided before the game starts (Though it is more entertaining if it lasts forever). The defiler can do that in every night. Originally created this role to punish players that just never shut their mouth and annoy EVERYBODY!

[@Worm.soup666]

Who are you implying

[@TheNerdyOrganist]

@@Worm.soup666 I wasn't talking about anyone of Team OX or Team Dicebreaker. I meant people from my own little group of Werewolve fans, who don't seem to be able to be quiet. Though I have to admit: Silencing Andy could be very entertaining, even though he doesn't annoy me.

[@PatrickLongblkwhtrbbt]

Man Chessmaster Lolies played Jane like a fiddle omg lmao

[@wolfybat3335]

Rules were muddled there,.. one accusation per day

[@patience1926]

Well that happened more than once, so it doesn’t matter. Besides Luke should’ve stated that rule. He didn’t, so it’s not a rule in this session. And you have got to admit Lolies pulling that genius manoeuver there was amazing. Because Jane got really lucky with killing the healer 1st round and then killing the seer, when seer revealed their identity not knowing no one could protect them. She had the best chance at winning if she hadn’t been impatient.

[@orsolyafekete7485]

@@wolfybat3335 While true, she was already exposed, they would have just burned her the next day

[@oxfanblink4115]

Couldn’t believe it either 🤯 Felt sorry for Jane when she got found out despite being smart with how she killed unlike Andy and when he was successful with killing Mike. Mike was close to being successful with me too when he disappeared briefly and popped back up with his wolf thing on him lmfao 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂

[@ottersintuxedos4981]

I would love to see Luke do a DnD one-shot sometime with Johnny as a player

[@BattyButtercup]

It could be an in-universe barding session of Dob's! Or a doby swap scenario...

[@the.seagull.35]

Yes please!

[@jasonsorin1021]

Dob is an inspiration to us all

[@nunyobidniz]

Yaaaaassss!!!!! Just yes. This needs to happen! Edit: Also, "doby swap"👍 love it!

[@nunyobidniz]

And I just 'liked' my own comment. I am not ashamed. 🖐️Self-five!👏

[@tycol322]

Everyone always asks "Werewolf?" But no one ever asks "Why, Wolf?" "How, wolf?"

[@Legendary_Detective-Wobbuffet]

What wolf?

[@lydiamourningstar2028]

Wolfeo, Wolfeo, a werewolf art thou, Wolfeo.

[@Numbsquall1989]

And this is the difference between a werewolf and aware wolf.

[@SmilinSinner]

When, wolf?

[@StirrCrazy90]

There, wolf. There, castle.

[@neolexiousneolexian6079]

Isolationist autarkist playing this game: "I am the healer. I'm not afraid to reveal myself because I've been healing myself and I'm just going to keep healing myself. Good luck!"

[@SpectreRyder]

Well then the werewolf kills everyone else and leaves the Healer for last so it's a guaranteed win

[@wulfricr7635]

This is why most versions have the healer either not be able to heal themselves or not able to heal the same person night after night.

[@thecommonman9524]

@@wulfricr7635 or just heal themselves once.

[@crouchingmarker]

'We're in the original time period, but you're all different people, but with the same names.' Ah. The reboot.

[@CtrlAltWut]

Andy: "killing me won't bring back your precious apples" *my fkn sides!!!!*

[@sneakydeekie5472]

Whenever I play in small groups like here, I find that it’s much better to get rid of the seer role because it ends the round so very fast not giving the werewolf a chance to win..

[@JaronActual]

A Fortune Teller alone isn't a problem with 6 players, but the Fortune Teller AND Defender together against a single werewolf is pretty tough.

[@heleneandersson7649]

I was hoping he would set one game in a nordic town so everyone could fail doing scandi accents. 😆 it's fun when other people struggle to talk like me rather than the other way around. This was a fun time, thank you. ❤

[@lespaulpanhead025]

Andy: “How do these differ from regular wolf tracks?” Because you know WERE they are!

[@nunyobidniz]

Noice 👍 But also, Boooo! (sry, I don't make the rules)

[@lespaulpanhead025]

Nunyo Bidniz fair enough

[@johnsharplin]

32:16 Luke, I can't BELIEVE you didn't use this golden opportunity to utilize the phrase "fled incontinently."

[@gabeschugardt5710]

Mike keeps getting found out because he just can't resist killing Andy.

[@Legendary_Detective-Wobbuffet]

And vice-versa.

[@wulfricr7635]

And Jane apparently just wants to kill them both and have control of oxbox 😂

[@cealvan8941]

1) hunter: as they die, they shoot someone 2) suicidal: wins by getting themselves burned at the stake 3) mayor: gets an extra vote (may be werewolf as well)

[@973daydreamer]

You can also have - minions who win if werewolves win, know who the werewolves are but werewolves don't know who minions are. - lovers who know who each other are and if one dies the other dies from heartbreak

[@jasonsorin1021]

We have uneven democracies, bad mental health, and crazy people with guns. 'MURICA!

[@orsolyafekete7485]

When we played basically this with over 20 people, we had some weird roles, my favourites were: Baker: if killed, everyone starves to death three days later Prostitute: protects someone from getting killed but also turns off their ability for that night (hilariously, works if used on themselves) Jesus: if killed, comes back to life three days later

[@freyavalon]

No one mentioning the Witch? Out of the 9 times I've played, I somehow got that card 6 times.

[@kaniamia]

Sarah Schute This game sorely needed a minion.

[@Storm0483]

I haven't laughed this hard in 2020, thank you so much for making me cry laughing Andy and Jane's faces and expressions when Andy is werewolf and Jane finds was amazing But the best part undoubtedly was Alex's trap for Jane which worked perfectly

[@CorwinAlexander]

I have doubts: Lolies expression when she found out it was Mike that killed her was priceless.

[@bezerkoid]

The whole Andy angrily writing to kill Jane in revenge first night was legitimately the hardest I've laughed for weeks

[@87dtrip]

Mad props to whomever made the call for the atmospheric music at the start and end. That was beautiful. *Bonus comment no one will read* I've had moderate success with a cloth/towel wrapped cold compress or bag of ice to keep a melting laptop operating. *If someone does read this* Fear the condensation wrap it in a tea towel or rag or something, anything!

[@sick0832]

"Good Times At The Grief Harvest" sounds so much like a mid-2000s emo band! XD

[@eddiemoon6522]

I love your group dynamic so much. I'm not doing the best but I've been laughing ever since I found all of yalls content because its so cheerful and lovely

[@rimurutempest4945]

I love how they crafted a village with its own sort of lore, with grief harvests and import/export of bone fragments. With complex relationships and prejudices.

[@Randesie101]

I’m glad Luke couldn’t be a werewolf. Sculpting with a hairdryer would be an absolute nightmare😉.

[@aspirationsDelineation]

The Original Village being on the moon makes sense as to why Werewolves can transform at any time.

[@vict4451]

Even though Ellen's feed is jacked, you can tell she's laughing her ass off.

[@claretravels783]

Andy Mike & Jane are so much the '3 people with guns all pointed at each other' meme, and I love it

[@cthulhufhtagn2483]

I literally cried laughing during this. I love how any time the Oxbox gang plays Werewolf, Andy immediately accuses Mike, even before the game begins. Would love to see a Codenames playthrough in this same style!

[@jasonsorin1021]

Paranoia. Mike would accuse Andy of being a communist before they even made their characters.

[@IzEror]

Well knowing the rules to Paranoia is treasonous.....

[@odysseus_kopis]

There is one, on Dicebreaker, from EGX 2019

[@JustAbidTooMuch]

Mike's costume was priceless 😂

[@numuhukumakiakiaialunamor5174]

I will say, it's weird to me that that Johnny keeps revealing his role in the first round. When I played Werewolf (Mafia) with my friends we never said that we are a Healer or the Seer, because it's against the rules. The Seer may know who the Werewolf is, but convincing others was part of the game

[@AK_allday_907]

Yeah same, and love your username btw, just finished oathbringer, started The Way of Kings in April and really loved the series. Starting Mistborn soon

[@numuhukumakiakiaialunamor5174]

@@AK_allday_907 Thanks! I love The Stormlight Archive, and Mistborn is fantastic as well. The first three books might be the best written trilogy I have ever read. I hope you will enjoy it. Life before death!

[@973daydreamer]

Jane could have confirmed Lolies was not a merewolf but let the mob harpoon her! Cold.

[@CorwinAlexander]

She knew it was too early to reveal her identity at that point. She none-the-less tried to convince them not to kill Lolies without revealing her identity.

[@00pugsly48]

I love Luke’s scene setting in this. Bravo good sir

[@colinspeirs]

Loads of respect to Andy Farrant for working in a "The Wicker Man" reference

[@TheRemiCay]

My favourite part was Jane's "Can we only burn 1 person per day?"

[@daviestj]

I watched your second werewolf episode before this one. During one game, to pull a prank, you should have all roles EXCEPT the werewolf, just to see the cast self destruct.

[@alexharrison2743]

Oh wow this would have been amazing

[@totz_the_plaid9625]

​@@alexharrison2743@daviestj In "Blood on the Clocktower," a similar sort of game, one possible decision a storyteller can make is to have an 'atheist' game with no evil team and require the players to "execute" the storyteller to win. (Possibly an oversimplified explanation, but that's the general idea at least.)

[@alexharrison2743]

@@totz_the_plaid9625 that sounds great, that would be such a Westaway move

[@samsavc123]

The great part about how Luke is setting up each subsequent round is that, theoretically, they would eventually work themselves into modern times which I think would be an amazing premise

[@KFPSchnitzelkochTschango]

They shouldbt have trusted that traveling merchant, M Channeil, who hid the magic brew with the werewolf curse

[@ethanderrick8486]

I love how Ellen relied on her notepad to conceal her emotions when dead

[@oxfanblink4115]

Was almost as cute as her giggles throughout 🤗

[@wyattfish7259]

Can we all admire Ellen’s quick thinking at 34:24? I would NOT have thought up such a plausible defense so fast! And Andy’s sly Wicker Man reference at his death

[@MrMBinder]

Ellen's laptop knows what the real struggle is like.

[@thajocoth]

No "lycan subscribe"? This version is very unbalanced in the villager's favor. When I've played this game before, it would be 2 Werewolves, 1 Seer, and 3 Villagers. That was more balanced.

[@chrismanuel9768]

One Night Werewolf on the other hand, I've only once seen anyone correctly kill the wolf once all the crazy cards are in play. Especially the Tanner trying to get himself killed by purposely "failing" to hide that he's actually the werewolf

[@TheNerdyOrganist]

Problem is, that more than one Werewolf is hard to do in a Zoom call. They somehow need to decide together on one victim without talking. Writing it down on paper would take to long and wouldn't be great to watch if they have different opinions. I would replace Healer or Seer with another charakter, as together they are way to strong with just 6 players in total. Replacing with Witch or Hunter would be more balanced.

[@Morithcat]

When I've played it, what usually happens is that you know that there is a chance of for anyone to be in play (and werewolf is a certain). But you don't know the proportions. So it could be just one werewolf one time, the next the werewolf, healer and Hunter. One time might have two werewolves. No one might be ordinary villagers.

[@thajocoth]

@@TheNerdyOrganist That's a good point!

[@thajocoth]

@@Morithcat That sounds really cool! I will suggest that next time I play

[@andyfarrell2877]

coming back a couple days later to just once again remark on how absolutely GOD TIER that one move from Lolies was. brilliant.

[@brentage5000]

Of course, the real werewolves were the friends we ate along the way

[@marhawkman303]

If werewolf movies have taught me anything at all it's that man is the real monster. :p

[@nunyobidniz]

@@marhawkman303 the werewolf was inside us all along 😉

[@marhawkman303]

@@nunyobidniz that is true actually :D

[@JabRok86]

32:12 The urine jokes continue, I think Andy just got werewolves and jellyfish stings mixed up

[@michaelpirrone]

Because someone mentioned it in the live chat but I can't respond to that (obvs), I just wanted to point out to whoever else watches this, that the word dice can be singular and is the more common choice over die in England.

[@TheOverArchiver]

I love this game. I’m most familiar with it as “Mafia”, but whatever form it’s in is great.

[@tusharchandra4276]

Mike's definitely the funniest member of this group. He's just too goddamn hilarious. I keep coming back to this video for him

[@IAmKenkira]

With this and Bloodbourne I don’t believe ive heard the word “horrible” said so many times by a young British lad.

[@Legendary_Detective-Wobbuffet]

Try reading Turn of the Screw. It's nothing but that.

[@patwilson9186]

I wish he kept in the other roles to not make it nearly impossible for the wolf to win

[@maureen_83]

The villagers won most of the time in this game session. I think to have the Wolf a fighting chance to win, they need to put the Tanner role in the game. Where the role of the Tanner is to get himself/herself killed to win the game and the villagers lose. It would make it more interesting session. Or give the Wolf a Minion to keep the accusations off the Wolf. And the Wolf team can win together. I love watching this stream. Everyone did great!!👍👍👍

[@carriefrazier1809]

Used to play a version of this at camp called “Mafia” (upon reflection that’s pretty messed up...) Luke did such an amazing job providing colorful narration - should he consider DM-ing at some point I would love to watch his campaigns

[@liamross340]

I’d love it if they did a critical role type thing and every so often the players of the D&D game they all play would rotate around DMing a different one shot

[@wuwupyon]

This was fun! Enjoyed it when Mike, Luke, and Ellen played it with Dicebreaker in the past and it can only be more chaotic (thus more fun) with even more people. It also satisfies my craving to see people’s handwriting styles

[@Blaine_St_Cloud]

Maybe play without a seer next time. Seems to make it almost impossible for werewolf to win.

[@AK_allday_907]

I always played it that the healers and seers couldn't say their roles,

[@Singeferno]

You all should do Town of Salem. The minimum player requirement is 7.

[@dindapriska]

How do you play the game?

[@Singeferno]

@@dindapriska it's almost the same game, but different "factions." There's a board game or they can get it through steam. But this way they could all play and I'm sure, given the options for classes, it would be chaotic.

[@albimoya3461]

Town of Salem was quite fun; though I don't have a proper laptop or PC to get on and I've been a bit iffy after they got hacked; but as far as I can tell the hackers didn't get any valuable info and I assume measures have been taking; all the crazy roles make it enjoyable but I definitely feel it's a lot better with all your friends and stuff; I felt a lot of the games with ransoms had a good bit of just hanging to hang and shooting to shot instead of actually trying to investigate but definitely had a few good rounds

[@LordPiddlington1912]

59:28 for future reference, the Lolies Gambit, first deployed against Jane. Absolute class.

[@elizabethwright9463]

The music is good suspense type music while we wait.

[@alanbeardsley8346]

49:35 Best round of the game! So many good twists and turns in this one! Surprise ending!

[@scooterjss]

When you guys play on Dicebreaker you should play it as Mafia.

[@snoozewarlock4378]

*intense anime music plays* Jane: I vote that Johnny is the werewolf. Alex: Ha, you've activated my trap card. Jane: Nani?

[@adrianoverbury4949]

🎵If it hadn't been for Cockerel Joe I'da been sleeping a long time ago Where did you come from Why do you crow Where did you come from Cockerel Joe🎵

[@thecommonman9524]

Booo! Boo.

[@timphillips4302]

I liked Andy's Werewolf play of not killing the Seer but killing the revealed villager, getting rid of a potential vote. When the Werewolf gets found on the first round and is accused they should use Mike's tactic of "I'm the Seer and known Blank isn't a Werewolf" they can pick anyone and be right. This might let them talk their way out of being killed. Played a version of this 20 plus years ago. It was Mafia and not Werewolf which did allow for a lot more creative kills, especially if you know the players and can reference cars, homes, allergies, phobias, etc.

[@ryadinstormblessed8308]

42:38 Jane looks so peaceful! It's almost like a sweet and innocent look... but of course we've learned better than to believe that! 😂

[@hiatusinc]

This is a vision of Luke being drunk on power

[@the.seagull.35]

The seer really breaks the game with this few people.

[@kaniamia]

Danny Dolan Yup. If they choose correct within the first two nights, the werewolf is screwed. Because either they’re immediately killed by the townspeople, or they successful convince everyone that THEY’RE the seer, at which point the townspeople kill the real seer, find out it was an innocent, and kill the werewolf the following day.

[@jeffreywells1832]

Fixable a bit if you disallow people outright spilling their roles, which would have helped here IMO.

[@fatzmcgee]

Or drop the Seer entirely for this few.

[@alyonahomy]

Can't wait for the second part, this was great!

[@Tuftdog]

More DM-Luke stuff! Love watching Luke run the show with Johnny as a player (and Lolies over here too). Hope you guys do more stuff like this :>

[@lukasgamemaster4528]

I'd buy a shirt with everyone looking like smiling werewolves and the line from Andy, "Good Times at the Grief Harvest!"

[@TheNerdyOrganist]

Your village was clearly to overpowered as they always won against the werewolves. Healer and Seer together are way too strong together in a setting of only 6 players. Better remove one of them and replace it with the witch or the hunter.

[@nitroglitch45]

52:15 I love how you can hear Jane's chair squeak while she's shaking her Andy sign. That's how excited she was to kill him.

[@brentage5000]

(After Ellen's Sia/Seer joke) Luke at the start: "Poker faces on, people." Ellen: "That's not a Sia song." Can't believe it took me this long to notice that Gaga joke lol

[@jamiemcnally3222]

This makes me want to see them play Mafia or Town of Salem

[@nunyobidniz]

I've seen nothing of this kind before. I've no idea what to lycan it to...

[@iwantsalmon]

1:01:50 that is some next level gameplay

[@Featherbow]

Oh man I usually go camping with friends every year and we usually end up playing this. Didn't get to go this year because of the pandemic, so seeing you guys play it is awesome.

[@andy4037]

Johnny is far, far too good at this game. Another point in the "nonhuman" column

[@matwetton]

JOhnny half cut with a shillelagh is the mood I didnt know I needed

[@Crimson_Rogue97]

I got introduced to Werewolf by a uni friend a few years ago and ever since I've loved it. Can't wait to see you guys do more of this 😂😂

[@ryadinstormblessed8308]

Would love to see this return!

[@FioreTheDragon]

OMG! this was hilarious! I can't wait for next week!!