WESTMAN ATELIER I WANT YOU MASCARA | Worth $45?

Hi lovelies,
Today I'm trying this very expensive mascara from Westman Atelier so you don't have to!
**** Ad Info ****
This video is NOT sponsored. Links below to products used/worn in the video are affiliate so if you choose to use them to make a purchase, I will receive a small commission. I purchase all products myself unless they are clearly marked as GIFTED, in which case the brand has sent them to me with no obligation to post.
My Eyelash Growth Serum
rstyle.me/+eNY...
**** Products Mentioned ****
Westman Atelier Eye Want You mascara (Brown)
rstyle.me/+WdW... (UK)
rstyle.me/+JRF... (US)
**** Makeup Worn ****
By Ellie Brow shape
go.shopmy.us/p...
Huda Beauty Brow pencil
go.magik.ly/ml... (UK)
shop-links.co/... (US)
Charlotte Tilbury Beautyverse palette (mattes)
go.magik.ly/ml... (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml... (US)
Charlotte Tilbury Fire Rose palette (shimmers)
go.magik.ly/ml...
Tom Ford Primer
rstyle.me/+P1s... (UK)
rstyle.me/+GnS... (US)
Prada foundation
rstyle.me/+Y6s...
Haus Labs concealer
rstyle.me/+dZW... (UK)
rstyle.me/+tkt... (US)
Pat McGrath Undereye Powder
go.magik.ly/ml... (UK)
go.magik.ly/ml... (US)
Hourglass Jellyfish palette
rstyle.me/+0UC... (UK)
rstyle.me/+PQ9... (US)
YSL Candy Glaze (12)
rstyle.me/+Vcv... (UK)
rstyle.me/+oUq... (US)
**** What I'm Wearing ****
Top: go.magik.ly/ml...
Nails: OPI Bubblebath
go.magik.ly/ml... (UK)
shop-links.co/... (US)
My Brushes:
Rephr:
www.rephr.com/...
Sonia G:
go.magik.ly/ml...
BK Beauty
bit.ly/3FK77YL
**** My Closest Foundation Shades ****
Winter shade | Summer shade
Chanel = BD41 | B50
Cle De Peau = 040 | 060
Dior Backstage = 2WO | 4WO
Estee Lauder = Tawny | Shell Beige
Haus Labs = 190 | 260
Hourglass = 8 | 10.5
Lisa Eldridge = 17 | 19
Nars Natural Radiant Longwear = Santa Fe| Aruba
Pat McGrath = 14 | 18
Shiseido Synchro Skin = Bamboo | Citrine
Tom Ford = Shell Beige | Golden Almond
**** SKIN TYPE ETC. ****
I am 38 and my skin is pretty "normal" with no dryness or particular oily areas. I do have early signs of aging like fine lines/texture, as well as some sun damage and REDNESS!
I don't use fake tan, but I get very tan naturally in the summer as I have an olive undertone so my face is often a LOT lighter than my body, because I keep my face very well protected to keep my melasma under control and signs of aging at bay!
**** Contacts ****
Instagram: charlotte_holdcroft
Twitter: charholdcroft84
Business Enquiries: [e-mail]

[@renatahamdandemattosbayao6284]

Clinique has a tubing mascara in black and brown (lash power). It’s a lengthening mascara with a thin wand. Finish is natural but buildable. It’s worth trying, the brown shade is perfect and the price point also good. And good for sensitive eyes.

[@sovrappensiero1]

I’m low-key jealous of your naturally-curly lashes, Charlotte! Love the brown mascara on you. For me personally it’s too $$ but then again I can’t get into luxury makeup at all. I don’t really care about packaging, only product quality (a rare bird, I know!)

[@ellenkass9410]

Not rare at all🌵👩‍🦳💜

[@homerrules100]

YSL makes my favorite brown mascara, its a true brown.

[@peterlangendorff9846]

I love the look of brown mascara. I use the brown cake mascara from Kryolan with a spoolie.

[@GMW.artist]

Give me Byredo Tears in Rain or MAC MacStack Waterproof any day. I just need brown versions of both too!!... 😎✌🏼💜

[@wendynoake-forshaw3847]

That is the prettiest brown mascara I have ever seen! Really does look beautiful on your sumptuous lashes. Not my ball park price for mascara but if it was …

[@daisyspanhakbon1364]

Very, very pretty, especially the colour, very complimentary with your brows, elegant yet still very much there❤❤❤

[@yasminchen9254]

Hi Charlotte, for your “you don’t need that ” video, can you please do one for advent calendars. I’m so obsessed rn and want to buy everything 😢

[@michelleisabel]

I have this in my basket for the Sephora sale starting next Friday. I know you hate "Too Faced Better than sX" but I actually loved that in the brown, but it did dry out quickly, so I'll give this one a try. I think it looks beautiful.

[@wonderingstar1483]

I’ve worn brown mascara for 25 years as black was always too harsh on my complexion. Thanks for your review! Always on the lookout for new ones to try! Love your channel. ❤❤❤❤

[@lelannazalee2730]

Thank you for trying this! Especially in brown. I wanted to buy it during the Sephora sale and now I know it’ll be worth it for me as someone who struggles with mascara transfer.

[@lesliespencer7942]

Interesting shade of brown! How does it compare to the YSL brown and/or my default Dior Brown (neither of which are easy to find - or budget-friendly, but they are BROWN!) Thanks for the review. Now off to find it here in the UK...

[@redouteshabby2024]

The little bit of fallout on your lid is the reason I stopped using their first mascara. It really transferred terribly. So I am a little bit worried about that. Otherwise it looks divine! Loved the effect you used at around 12:36! That was so cool!

[@alltheketoladies209]

My favorite brown mascara is the (yikes) Sisley So Volume so $45 seems almost like a bargain. 🙂

[@barbraluce5706]

For me, Sisley lasts longer. WA mascara dries out within a month. The color looks lovely on you, Charlotte

[@lesliehatch-herman9325]

😂

[@lyndawithay3135]

What I want is the return of black-brown mascara from the 80s. That was my jam. I was 13. Lol. 💕🐾💕🍁

[@dianebraden629]

I would love to try the brown mascara and I am willing to pay the high price. I thought it looked beautiful on your lashes.

[@catherineekchristensen4668]

LOVE that you ran to the post, took off your mascara - I would totally have done the same! Just ordered the Les Etoiles... something about this line feels so luxe, it's the experience of it all! x

[@alya27092]

I don’t like brown mascara for me and I don’t like to use oil cleanser. I have tried Hermes mascara (black but they have brown) in store and I love it. Also I removed Hermes mascara only with lukewarm water, so their claim is true. It is very expensive but beautiful and very good, so Hermes mascara will be my next one to buy. And their new eyeshadows are gorgeous. I bought 06 and I’m in love.😍 From WA I just like the packaging . In my opinion it’s a very expensive brand for the quality they offer. This mascara looks good on you but you already have very nice lashes due to the good genes and the lash serum you use. Thanks for sharing!

[@dkladiann]

For that price, I expect a make up artist come over and apply my mascara every day

[@MsBNoodle]

I mean..it will be easy to find in a hurry in the bottom of my bag 😂

[@daisyspanhakbon1364]

😂😂😂❤

[@kfryett1339]

It looks great, but am reluctant to buy after the WA complexion drops went off really quickly. Please let us know how this goes for you. For the price I would like to use this daily for 3 months. Thank you x

[@Littlen80]

For me the best brown mascara is the Green People one! Not very expensive but it gives a very beautiful natural effect ❤ I love the luxurious feel of Westman Atelier cosmetics so I might have try this one ❤

[@africke744]

Thank you Charlotte for another entertaining video. Did you choose your lipstick to match the mascara tube, or is it sheer serendipity? 😄 Best wishes all round, Anne

[@kirstenolson776]

I think that color of mascara looks really pretty on you. It compliments your eyebrow color nicely. I wasn't planning to pick up this mascara, but after your review I think I'll give it a try. If you had reviewed it in black, I wouldn't be as interested.

[@megdvs21]

I think it’s lovely on you especially your lower lashes actually 🙂☺

[@kirstenolson776]

I'm really impressed with your natural nails. I always assumed you had press-ons or something, but here is proof that you got these glorious nails the old fashioned way.

[@elysiumfieldsbeauty6502]

I don’t usually buy mascaras but, I will check this one out during the VIB sale ❤

[@mlralston]

I love this content. Fantastic job, my lady. I am informed and get a bit of a chuckle.

[@richapraja]

I really really like this mascara on you but unfortunately for me, I don't think brown mascaras work because I'm brown with black lashes - so brown looks weird on me. My version of brown mascara (or more natural looking or toned down) is Victoria Beckham's Future Lash mascara. I really really really like the look it creates with fanned out and lengthy eyeslashes, it comes off easily (it is a tubing mascara) and the bottle is just luxurious to look at and hold. If you've not tried it, I highly recommend it

[@celinag9968]

She certainly has my attention. But I need to hear it’s still going well, 3 weeks from now, like you mentioned. I don’t wear mascara daily, and I’d be upset if it dried out from one use to the next.

[@CiaraDanes]

Sculpted by Aimee in brown or black is great ❤

[@DM-eg6ow]

I currently have a brown Too Faced mascara that I like. And I heard Tower28 is coming out with a brown version of their mascara as well.

[@tracymcarlson]

It looks so beautiful on you, but you have those glorious lashes already! I have short, stubby, straight lashes, so a wet mascara ends up being smeared all over my eyes. 😂 Thank you so much for the honest review as always! ❤

[@kikisellsteamsellinghomesi5104]

YSL has a great brown mascara

[@meganryan9945]

Just beautiful Charlotte❤️

[@zozel77]

Brown mascaras are the best for day wear, eye lashes look defined but more natural. I love any of the Lancôme ones and also Talika Liposils Mascara. Thank you for trying this one for us 😊

[@lesliehatch-herman9325]

I love a good brown mascara-I’m fair-skinned, and black mascara as an everyday look is too much for me. This price makes me want to cry, though. I’d be more willing to try it if I knew the component was refillable; that way if it turns into a holy grail for me, the refills would be less expensive. I do love how the tube looks, and that shade of brown is awesome, too! Thanks for showing this to us!

[@shelleyeatz]

The fire rose shimmers on your kids 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@marthadiazsantella3709]

Have you tried the brown one from YSL? I love it!

[@peterlangendorff9846]

I absolutely prefer brown over black mascara. But Charlotte has exceptional lashes to begin with.

[@ashleyharris4174]

I’m not sure if you’ve already tried it but I would really recommend the sculpted by Aimee brown mascara. I use the brown and black mascaras that she does and they are my go to mascaras. Definitely my favourite mascaras. Lovely volume and length. The brown is a lovely colour. 😊

[@gladysgarrity5721]

Wow the mascara looks beautiful I just love mascaras ❤

[@sunshinestate4001]

Im usualy a black mascara girl,but this preticular shade is very pretty.Its given you a doll like look,what I really like.Ty Charlotte.(I might get it...ouch)

[@Mama-de-Tia]

Too pricey for me but it looks gloriously chic on you!

[@Mommaslew]

Love my brown tubing mascara from Thrive. I can’t stand the effort required to remove waterproof mascara….and I do not enjoy raccoon eyes…so THRIVE IT IS!❤❤❤😊

[@zipperdidoodah5411]

I once read that out of all makeup, mascara was the one thing you don't need to spend a fortune on; and that drugstore versions are pretty good. In my experience I would agree with that, although it's never stopped me trying luxury brands too :D At the moment I'm just finishing off my Jones Road black mascara which I really like, but once I finish that I have just bought the black-brown Clinique mascara in a swishty green metallic tube! The tester in store swatched pretty brown to my eye, so I'm looking forward to trying it out. Cost around £19.

[@susannehorn8075]

This is the most beautiful mascara look you’ve ever worn. It’s a the stunning , super - flattering color on you with perfect length and no “chunk”❤ in my opinion, don’t go back to black

[@kellyckennedy1143]

I love this mascara, I’ve had no flaking like the other WA mascara. Just the right amount of product comes out on applicator. I’ve been using for several weeks and haven’t seen any difference in application since I first started using it. I can use on my bottom lashes which I can’t do with black mascara.

[@Megan-nk2hk]

Thanks for mentioning the smell. It is sadly too much for me and I cannot wear it. The packaging is so cute though lol. I liked her other mascara, which had no smell.

[@rhondavosberg551]

The mascara looks beautiful on you. I would not purchase it, though. It is too expensive, and I am already torn between three different mascaras.

[@SchlichteToven]

I'm also in search of a good brown mascara since they discontinued Clinique's Naturally Glossy. I use Clinique's brown High Impact, but I'm after the more natural look that Naturally Glossy had, which looks like you just dyed your lashes. I'm really only using mascara for colour, as my eyelashes are white-blonde. I've tried some brown Korean mascaras, which don't add bulk, but their browns always have so much red in them, I feel like it almost makes me look like my eyes are bleeding. Maybe it doesn't do that to people who already have dark lashes. I'm hoping to try the Lancome Definicils in brown soon, and the 19/99 lash tint mascara. I might have to add the Westman Atelier to the list if I can get a sale - it's $60 CAD! That's ridiculous.

[@SolElarien]

it looks great!

[@moryooseo7752]

This is one I really want to try, Thanks for the review!

[@kmq1053]

I like the look of this but I’m also waiting to see if you review the Hermes one at £56!!! Talking of reviews - are you still waiting on delivery of the PM Bijoux mothership palette?? I managed to get mine quite quickly and I live in the UK. It’s so variable where PM shipping is concerned! X

[@bevyoung2009]

Hello beautiful Charlotte 😍

[@taigahilliard619]

How pretty

[@whoathatsanicememe3093]

Im not "low key jealous" I'm FULLY jealous of people with beautiful lashes. My husband has the most beautiful lashes and my youngest daughter inherited them... lucky duck.

[@prophetessoftroy]

I know it’s kind of the opposite of a luxury brand, but I’m told that Tower 28 just released a brown mascara. I think I saw in a different video that you weren’t a fan of the components (they really do look kind of like play makeup, don’t they?), but the product is supposed to be incredible. I’m a pretty dedicated Lancôme mascara girl, but I have been thinking about trying it.

[@ashleycottey4043]

Have you done a review on the YSL brown mascara? If not, I would love to see one thinking about purchasing because I just ran out of my thrive brown mascara, and was looking for a splurge item.

[@twoleftfeet9626]

Westman Atelier are sooooo overpriced for the quality of their items

[@celinag9968]

AND THEN, they turn before I can ever finish them (maybe not all preservatives are bad)! And they don’t actually make refills for anything, and then what do I do with all this weighty garbage?

[@periwinklestar9100]

I disagree. I ❤ W.A.! For the performance, ingredients, and packaging, they can't be beat.

[@juliedubberley1192]

​@celinag9968 that's the trouble with "clean beauty" they don't use preservatives so products go off quickly.

[@periwinklestar9100]

@juliedubberly, I have had some W.A. products since they launched (2 years ago?), and NOTHING has altered with her products. Nothing.

[@juliedubberley1192]

@@periwinklestar9100 that's good to know.

[@petra1995]

You won't catch me paying more than, like, £8 for a mascara, I just like listening to you talk, Charlotte

[@melindagenitempo2359]

Doesn't YSL lash clash have a brown ? I love the black one so much. But no I won't pay 45 for this. However the scult stick in truffle is to die for.

[@kategibb5245]

You have such incredible lashes that most mascaras look great.For us lash mortals,I think this is massively overpriced as are most of WA products.

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Tower 28 is releasing a brown mascara.

[@SueGreene-st7qc]

Love this whole eye look on you!! Mascara looks pretty and u are so lucky to have long lower lashes!! I think it doesn't look too long. What shadow do you have on? Thanks

[@janinepannell]

It’s nice but nah imma not paying that. You look great tho!

[@joanburleigh3061]

Hermes to compare, please??? Adore you ✝️🇺🇸💄❤️

[@anadanaya1867]

Did you try the Ysl LashClash in brown? How does it compare?

[@verakristinarobinson7013]

I did find a brown/black at N'7 at Boots. Think they still make it.

[@francescadanzo9786]

Hi Charlotte!Do you ever tried the brown version of the YSL lash clash mascara?thank you..

[@dawnwebster8395]

Hi, it looks beautiful but no way can I justify that on a mascara, because of how often you need to replace it.

[@lisalovesphotography]

Interesting that the handle part of the wand is so short. I’m not sure I’d do well applying mascara with it-too much like a mini-size. 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@lesliehatch-herman9325]

I wondered about that, too. It might be a bit of a learning curve in holding it just right. Maybe the weightiness of it makes it feel less awkward?

[@angelaxilouris5775]

Thank you Charlotte for this review. I will NOT be buying a $45 mascara that needs to be replaced every 3 months. You were blessed with great lashes with GREAT curl. For people with straight lashes, this is money thrown in the trash. And the marketing term of "CLEAN" cosmetics I'm not buying plus they don't last long. Love your videos!!

[@jennawoodard8386]

💕💄

[@evelynrosado9711]

I’m not picking up that expensive mascara.

[@jennifermorrison229]

Beautiful mascara but definitely overpriced.

[@peterlangendorff9846]

GW, the person, seems so blah to me. There’s just nothing about her that makes me want to use her products when I can get something like Hourglass for the same price, or Tom Ford for a little more.

[@VickyRyan2018]

Westman Atelier is very very overrated and very very expensive for no reason

[@Sl1ck_Lunat1c]

Very lack luster mascara IMO 🫤

[@ellenkass9410]

From across the pond again. I love brown, and it's hard to find. But $45? I will stick to Clinique for now. 👩‍🦳🏜🤎